A second Admonition to Mr. Edward Bagshaw written in some hope of curing his IMPENITENCE; or at least of saving some of those in London, Northamptonshire, and other Counties, whom he hath laboured to pervert, by FALSE DOCTRINE and FALSE-REPORTS; which tend to destroy, 1. The Soundness of their Judgements by dangerous Error, 2. Their Christian Love, and Unity, by Love-killing Principles and Divisions: 3. And their Christian Practice, by sinful Censures of, and Separations from the far greatest part of the Universal Visible Church of Christ, and Communion of Saints, and the public Worship of God; and consequently to the destruction of their own souls, and of the Churches.A second Admonition to Mr. Edward Bagshaw written in some hope of curing his IMPENITENCE; or at least of saving some of those in London, Northamptonshire, and other Counties, whom he hath laboured to pervert, by FALSE DOCTRINE and FALSE-REPORTS; which tend to destroy, 1. The Soundness of their Judgements by dangerous Error, 2. Their Christian Love, and Unity, by Love-killing Principles and Divisions: 3. And their Christian Practice, by sinful Censures of, and Separations from the far greatest part of the Vniversal Visible Church of Christ, and Communion of Saints, and the publick Worship of God; and consequently to the destruction of their own souls, and of the Churches.
pp. 23–188411 passagespart 3 of 11
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2. But so strange is your forgetfulness or your self-contradicting faculty, that you need none to tell your Readers that you write untruths, but your self. Do you take no notice, that all that is my words is, that such a Holy and Righteous Government is desirable, and may justly be sought as all Christians agree: But your profession is that [most of your converse is with those that do in faith expect it. And could you see no difference between seeking it, and in faith expecting it? I desire the conversion and salvation of all the men I know, and I seek it of God in prayer, and of as many of them, as I have fit opportunity, (or ought so to do at least;) I desire the Conversion of all the Kingdoms, and people of the world; but whether I may in faith expect it, I am so ignorant that I cannot tell. I desire and seek by prayer of God, that all the world may have holy and just Governors: but I cannot boast of so much faith or hope in this, as those that you converse with. As proud as I am, I freely confess my Ignorance to you. But certainly they that take it for an Article of their faith, do carry the Notion further than I can do, who profess that I am ignorant of it, whether it be a promised thing, or not?
2. But so strange is your forgetfulness or your self-contradicting faculty, that you need none to tell your Readers that you write untruths, but your self. Do you take no notice, that all that is my words is, that such a Holy and Righteous Government is desirable, and may justly be sought as all Christians agree: But your profession is that [most of your converse is with those that do in faith expect it. And could you see no difference between seeking it, and in faith expecting it? I desire the conversion and salvation of all the men I know, and I seek it of God in prayer, and of as many of them, as I have fit opportunity, (or ought so to do at least;) I desire the Conversion of all the Kingdoms, and people of the world; but whether I may in faith expect it, I am so ignorant that I cannot tell. I desire and seek by prayer of God, that all the world may have holy and just Governours: but I cannot boast of so much faith or hope in this, as those that you converse with. As proud as I am, I freely confess my Ignorance to you. But certainly they that take it for an Article of their faith, do carry the Notion further than I can do, who profess that I am ignorant of it, whether it be a promised thing, or not?
Sect. 24. E. B. p. 7.—[Because you dare not own any hazardous and persecuted truth;1 and you find it far easier in your Notional Divinity to recant all that formerly you were convinced of, than to bring your heart to a willingness for Martyrdom.]
R. B. 1. You spake of danger before; you now add Persecution and Martyrdom, intimating that this is such a persecuted point; which as far as ever I heard (who live in the same Land, and have as hard thoughts of persecution as many others have) there is not any thing true in your intimation. Name the Law that is against the Opinion of the desirableness of a holy Government of all the world? Name the person that ever suffered for that Opinion? Though those that will resist or pull down Governors, because they take them (justly or unjustly) to be ungodly, may suffer for it. Again therefore to imply danger of Martyrdom, for that which no man (that ever I heard of) suffered for, and to feign the avoiding of that danger, to be the Chief Cause of my recanting or changing my mind or words, which I never recanted or changed, is a monstrous course of fiction and temerity.
R. B. 1. You spake of danger before; you now add Persecution and Martyrdom, intimating that this is such a persecuted point; which as far as ever I heard (who live in the same Land, and have as hard thoughts of persecution as many others have) there is not any thing true in your intimation. Name the Law that is against the Opinion of the desirableness of a holy Government of all the world? Name the person that ever suffered for that Opinion? Though those that will resist or pull down Governours, because they take them (justly or unjustly) to be ungodly, may suffer for it. Again therefore to imply danger of Martyrdom, for that which no man (that ever I heard of) suffered for, and to feign the avoiding of that danger, to be the Chief Cause of my recanting or changing my mind or words, which I never recanted or changed, is a monstrous course of fiction and temerity.
2. Your talk of Recanting all that formerly I was convinced of] implieth more temerity and falsehood. Any man of humane modesty would have thought [All] too big a word, when the instances produced by him prove nothing. If you refer to ⟨p. 63⟩the Revocation of my Book, you should have opened your eyes, and seen that I profess not to Recant all the doctrine of it, though I revoke all the Book, and wish men to take it as non-scriptum: And sure that passage had no peculiar recantation.
2. Your talk of Recanting all that formerly I was convinced of] implyeth more temerity and falshood. Any man of humane modesty would have thought [All] too bigg a word, when the instances produced by him prove nothing. If you refer to ⟨p. 63⟩the Revocation of my Book, you should have opened your eyes, and seen that I profess not to Recant all the doctrine of it, though I revoke all the Book, and wish men to take it as non-scriptum: And sure that passage had no peculiar recantation.
3. But if Recantation be so easy to me, remember that I pretend not to Infallibility, nor am altogether unwilling to Repent. As for Martyrdom, I take it to be every Christians duty, yea, necessary to salvation, to prepare for it; that is, to deny his life, and to forsake all in true resolution, for the sake of Christ, and hopes of Heaven: But how far my heart is brought to a willingness of it, though I am sure you know not, and therefore venture to speak what you know not: yet I have no reason to boast, nor to be self-confident, nor to be high-minded, but to fear.
3. But if Recantation be so easie to me, remember that I pretend not to Infallibility, nor am altogether unwilling to Repent. As for Martyrdom, I take it to be every Christians duty, yea, necessary to salvation, to prepare for it; that is, to deny his life, and to forsake all in true resolution, for the sake of Christ, and hopes of Heaven: But how far my heart is brought to a willingness of it, though I am sure you know not, and therefore venture to speak what you know not: yet I have no reason to boast, nor to be self-consident, nor to be high-minded, but to fear.
Sect. 25. E. B. And this alone,1 I take to be the true cause, why so weakly, and so unlike a Minister of the Gospel you inveigh against sufferings. For you have never yet experienced either the comfort or the cleansing of them, and therefore venture rashly to speak evil of what you know not; and which I fear you have neither courage nor affection to venture the trial of: I speak it to your shame.
Sect. 25. E. B. And this alone,1 I take to be the true cause, why so weakly, and so unlike a Minister of the Gospel you inveigh against sufferings. For you have never yet experienced either the comfort or the cleansing of them, and therefore venture rashly to speak evil of what you know not; and which I fear you have neither courage nor affection to venture the tyral of: I speak it to your shame.
R. B. 1. Thus sin useth like a River to run on, the longer the greater! Wonderful! that you can believe the people that fear God to be so sottishly credulous of all the falsehoods ⟨p. 64⟩that you shall tell them, as not so much as to open the Book which you accuse, and to see that you deceive them. If you will prove that true which you say, it must be by this argumentation: He that telleth men that sufferings have their temptations as well as prosperity, and warneth men to fear and avoid those temptations, doth weakly and unlike a Minister of the Gospel inveigh against sufferings: But so doth R. B. Ergo—
R. B. 1. Thus sin useth like a River to run on, the longer the greater! Wonderful! that you can believe the people that fear God to be so sottishly credulous of all the falshoods ⟨p. 64⟩that you shall tell them, as not so much as to open the Book which you accuse, and to see that you deceive them. If you will prove that true which you say, it must be by this argumentation: He that telleth men that sufferings have their temptations as well as prosperity, and warneth men to fear and avoid those temptations, doth weakly and unlike a Minister of the Gospel inveigh against sufferings: But so doth R. B. Ergo—
But the Major is false, and therefore insufficient to support your false Conclusion. Let the Reader but peruse my words, and if he find one syllable of inveighing against sufferings, let him believe you the next time, and take you for a man that hath not quite forfeited his credit.
2. And what friendship to sin,1 and continued enmity to vigilancy and repentance do you express, when you were told an unquestionable truth, and but warned of an unquestionable danger and duty, to reject all so senslesly, and that with such false retortions. Tell your followers, 1. Is it false or true, that sufferings have their temptations as well as Prosperity; and in particular to drive us into uncharitableness and extremes from them that we suffer by? 2. Are not you and others that suffer in danger of such temptations, and sin in sufferings? 3. Should not such temptation and sin be carefully watched against? Is there any falsehood in all this? 4. And is he fit to glory in the cleansing fruit ⟨p. 65⟩of sufferings, that shall falsely say, that such a necessary warning is an inveighing against sufferings? &c. 5. Do you believe that they that turned Quakers in Prison are gainers by their sufferings? or they that lose more of their Love, than of their Liberties?
2. And what friendship to sin,1 and continued enmity to vigilancy and repentance do you express, when you were told an unquestionable truth, and but warned of an unquestionable danger and duty, to reject all so senslesly, and that with such false retortions. Tell your followers, 1. Is it false or true, that sufferings have their temptations as well as Prosperity; and in particular to drive us into uncharitableness and extreams from them that we suffer by? 2. Are not you and others that suffer in danger of such temptations, and sin in sufferings? 3. Should not such temptation and sin be carefully watcht against? Is there any falshood in all this? 4. And is he fit to glory in the cleansing fruit ⟨p. 65⟩of sufferings, that shall falsly say, that such a necessary warning is an inveighing against sufferings? &c. 5. Do you believe that they that turned Quakers in Prison are gainers by their sufferings? or they that lose more of their Love, than of their Liberties?
19th Crime, rejecting and slandering readful warning.
3. If I never experienced the comfort or cleansing of sufferings, I have cause of great lamentation, as having suffered very much in vain. I will not with Paul here glory in my infirmities, but I shall confess, that they greatly aggravate my sin, if your words be true: For I have born the yoke from my youth: since fourteen years of age I have not been a year free from suffering, and since twenty two but few days, and since 1646. (which is about twenty five years, I have had but few hours free from pain, (though through Gods mercy, not intolerable.) I have had sufferings in Peace, and sufferings four years in War: The first year I preached the Gospel, my life was sought by malice for my Ministerial work, and dissent from others: The next place I came to (where I was after more blest, and spent my labours) the first year I was hooted at in the Streets, but for preaching the Original sin and misery of mankind (which this man feigneth me to extenuate, if not deny.) The next year my life was sought by an armed Tumult, and strangely preserved, while others were knocked down in the Streets, but for looking after my safety. The same year my life was sought more publicly, and I ⟨p. 66⟩was forced into a Garrison from my habitation, through the fury that still sought my life. And since then, O what wholesome and constant sufferings have been measured out unto me, almost continually night and day. I will say no more, but that above all the external disposals of my most wise and gracious God, I humbly, and heartily, and daily thank him for my sufferings. But surely this man is not […] or permitted to write this in vain. Alas, my God, it calleth my sin, my unfruitfulness to my remembrance! My cleansing, nor my comfort have not been answerable to the sharp but gracious helps and warnings which thou hast so long vouchsafed me: It is true, too true, that I have sinned so much under sufferings, and been so unfruitful after sufferings, that I have little cause to boast of cleansing, and less experience of comfort, than otherwise I might have had. But yet I have so much experience as obligeth me to thankfulness, and assuredly to number this saying with his Untruths that he utters;1 even the twenty sixth in number; And I think the Crime of usurping the prerogative of God, of knowing the heart, should be repented of.
3. If I never experienced the comfort or cleansing of sufferings, I have cause of great lamentation, as having suffered very much in vain. I will not with Paul here glory in my infirmities, but I shall confess, that they greatly aggravate my sin, if your words be true: For I have born the yoke from my youth: since fourteen years of age I have not been a year free from suffering, and since twenty two but few dayes, and since 1646. (which is about twenty five years, I have had but few hours free from pain, (though through Gods mercy, not intolerable.) I have had sufferings in Peace, and sufferings four years in War: The first year I preached the Gospel, my life was sought by malice for my Ministerial work, and dissent from others: The next place I came to (where I was after more blest, and spent my labours) the first year I was hooted at in the Streets, but for preaching the Original sin and misery of mankind (which this man feigneth me to extenuate, if not deny.) The next year my life was sought by an armed Tumult, and strangely preserved, while others were knockt down in the Streets, but for looking after my safety. The same year my life was sought more publickly, and I
Can any of your followers themselves believe, that you that never saw me till of late years, and never thrice spake with me (that I know of) and that lived at so great a distance from me, and that were unborn when my sufferings began, and were a Child when I was in the greatest of my sufferings many years, I ⟨p. 67⟩say that you, should be able peremptorily, without any exception to conclude, that [I never yet have experienced either the comfort or the cleansing of them] When you know how much cleansing Peter acknowledgeth the very Apostates sometimes had, and even they that are most terribly cautioned, Heb. 6. had tasted of the powers of the world to come. Some cleansing and comfort even a miserable man may have.
4. As for your fear that I have not courage or integrity enough to venture the trial, I thank you for your warning, and shall beg integrity and courage of God; But to add that you speak it to my shame, is but to show that you could hardly speak with any caution many sentences together: For your fear doth but speak your uncertainty: (and to have pretended to a certainty were to pretend to be a God.) And why should you think that I must be ashamed of that which you are uncertain of? I doubt you speak it more to your own shame.
4. As for your fear that I have not courage or integrity enough to venture the tryal, I thank you for your warning, and shall beg integrity and courage of God; But to add that you speak it to my shame, is but to shew that you could hardly speak with any caution many sentences together: For your fear doth but speak your uncertainty: (and to have pretended to a certainty were to pretend to be a God.) And why should you think that I must be ashamed of that which you are uncertain of? I doubt you speak it more to your own shame.
Sect. 26. E. B. p. 8. You should have spared the dead,1 and not disturbed the dust of my fellow prisoner Mr. Powell, by reproaching his memory with so abusive and disgraceful a mention of him, as if he were a false Prophet, and acted by a deluding Spirit: For you lay to his charge, that many years ago, he prophesied of some things which we do not yet see fulfilled.
Sect. 26. E. B. p. 8. You should have spared the dead,1 and not disturbed the dust of my fellow prisoner Mr. Powel, by reproaching his memory with so abusive and disgraceful a mention of him, as if he were a false Prophet, and acted by a deluding Spirit: For you lay to his charge, that many years ago, he prophesied of some things which we do not yet see fulfilled.
111th Crime Excusing false prophesying to the dishonour of Gods Spirit.11th Crime Excusing false prophecying to the dishonour of Gods Spirit.
R. B. 1. Though it was printed since his death, it was written before ever I heard ⟨p. 68⟩of his death, and I think many Weeks before he dyed. 2. You made it in a manner necessary to me to convince you by some instance that was near enough for your observation; and do you blame me when you have done? 3. I named not Mr. Vavasor Powell; but only your Companion and fellow Prisoner; and its like you had more than one, and few could know that it was he: But you have disgraced him by naming him. 4. I called him not a false Prophet; but warned you not thus to abuse Gods people, and bring reproach upon Religion, by fathering rashnesses and deceits on the Spirit of God? And have you so little sense of the honour of God and Religion, as to be angry at that! Alas Sir, what would you have said if I had told you how common this was in the Army? To set up and pull down, do and undo, own and disown, as by the Spirit of God? If I should have told you of the sad Instances of Mr. Erbury, Mr. Saltmarsh, Mr. Dell, Mr. William Sedgwick, (who as from God wrote one Week to the Army against their putting the King to death, and the next or same Week wrote to them quite on the other side; and that set London by a Prophecy or Vision on looking for the day of judgement on a set day,) to say nothing of abundance such; besides Mrs. Hutchinson in New England, and the Ranters and Quakers in our days. Can you have any love to souls, and any zeal for God and for Religion, and not be grieved to think that Gods ⟨p. 69⟩Spirit should be thus reproached, and Infidels hardened in a contempt of the Spirit, as if it were but a fancy! O woe to the world because of offences!
R. B. 1. Though it was printed since his death, it was written before ever I heard ⟨p. 68⟩of his death, and I think many Weeks before he dyed. 2. You made it in a manner necessary to me to convince you by some instance that was near enough for your observation; and do you blame me when you have done? 3. I named not Mr. Vavasor Powell; but only your Companion and fellow Prisoner; and its like you had more than one, and few could know that it was he: But you have disgraced him by naming him. 4. I called him not a false Prophet; but warned you not thus to abuse Gods people, and bring reproach upon Religion, by fathering rashnesses and deceits on the Spirit of God? And have you so little sense of the honour of God and Religion, as to be angry at that! Alas Sir, what would you have said if I had told you how common this was in the Army? To set up and pull down, do and undo, own and disown, as by the Spirit of God? If I should have told you of the sad Instances of Mr. Erbury, Mr. Saltmarsh, Mr. Dell, Mr. William Sedgwick, (who as from God wrote one Week to the Army against their putting the King to death, and the next or same Week wrote to them quite on the other side; and that set London by a Prophecy or Vision on looking for the day of judgement on a set day,) to say nothing of abundance such; besides Mrs. Hutchinson in New England, and the Ranters and Quakers in our dayes. Can you have any love to souls, and any zeal for God and for Religion, and not be grieved to think that Gods
5. You show more of the relicts of modesty here, than in most that I have yet met with, in that you do not deny the truth of what I said of him. But yet your intimations are deceitful, as if his Prophecies had not been absolute, but conditional, or else not for the present, but the future. But the case was this, as learned and understanding hearers will yet testify; that at Clifton upon Teme in Worcestershire, quickly after Worcester Fight, in his Sermon he said, that He would tell them these things as from God, that they should have no more King, nor pay any more Taxes, nor pay any more Tithes, and laying his hand upon his Bible, he added [And this I have otherwise than from hence] which showed that the Scripture was not his Rule, for all you accuse others of making it an imperfect Rule.
5. You shew more of the relicts of modesty here, than in most that I have yet met with, in that you do not deny the truth of what I said of him. But yet your intimations are deceitful, as if his Prophecies had not been absolute, but conditional, or else not for the present, but the future. But the case was this, as learned and understanding hearers will yet testifie; that at Clifton upon Thame in Worcestershire, quickly after Worcester Fight, in his Sermon he said, that He would tell them these things as from God, that they should have no more King, nor pay any more Taxes, nor pay any more Tythes, and laying his hand upon his Bible, he added [And this I have otherwise than from hence] which shewed that the Scripture was not his Rule, for all you accuse others of making it an imperfect Rule.
6. And do you not yet perceive your partiality and respect of persons? It seemeth your duty to open the faults of the Prelates and Conformists, and to calumniate us Non-conformists that dissent from you, and to feign that which you think will serve you for reproach. But if your companions public false prophesying be but mentioned upon your own instigation, you cry out of abuse and disgrace to his memory. Sir, Was it true or false? If it be true, that thus he ⟨p. 68⟩[…] ⟨p. 69⟩[…] ⟨p. 70⟩did (which is mentioned as no rarity) should you not rather take part with God than him? And if an Aaron will make the people naked to their shame, will not God record it to his shame? Is not the honour of the Spirit of God more tenderly to be preserved than his, or yours, or mine, or any mans? O do not injure God, for Man.
6. And do you not yet perceive your partiality and respect of persons? It seemeth your duty to open the faults of the Prelats and Conformists, and to calumniate us Non-conformists that dissent from you, and to feign that which you think will serve you for reproach. But if your companions publick false prophecying be but mentioned upon your own instigation, you cry out of abuse and disgrace to his memory. Sir, Was it true or false? If it be true, that thus he ⟨p. 68⟩〈…〉⟨p. 69⟩〈…〉⟨p. 70⟩did (which is mentioned as no rarity) should you not rather take part with God than him? And if an Aaron will make the people naked to their shame, will not God record it to his shame? Is not the honour of the Spirit of God more tenderly to be preserved than his, or yours, or mine, or any mans? O do not injure God, for Man.
Sect. 27. E. B. p. 8. But 1. May not a good man,1 yea, a true Prophet, be sometime mistaken? Was not Samuel so, when he took Eliab to be the Lords anointed? Was not Nathan deceived, when he encouraged David to build the Temple?—
112th Crime Paralleling false Prophecies with the Prophets words in Scripture.
R. B. 1. Yes, they may be deceived when they speak in their own names, and judge by their own Spirit or reason: But do you think they may be deceived when they prophesy as from God. If so, then what certainty can we have of the truth of any of their Prophecies, if they may speak falsely to us in the name of God? 2. Will not your followers think you yet see your partiality, who in one Page reproach others as denying Scripture to be a perfect Rule, and in another can thus seek to parallel Gods Prophets, with one that rashly in the Pulpit prophesieth three falsehoods together in the name of God? Is it not Gods direction to us, to take him for a false Prophet who prophesieth that which cometh not to pass? Every one that foretelleth that which doth ⟨p. 71⟩come to pass is not a true Prophet, Deut. 13. 23. But every one that absolutely prophesieth that which doth not come to pass, is a false Prophet, Deut. 18. 20, 21, 22. But the Prophet which shall presume to speak a word in my name, which I have not commanded him to speak—even that Prophet shall dye. (Mark whether God do judge as you do.) And if thou say in thy heart, how shall we know the word which the Lord hath spoken, when a Prophet speaketh in the name of the Lord, if the thing follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing which the Lord hath not spoken, but the Prophet hath spoken it presumptuously: thou shalt not be afraid of him.
R. B. 1. Yes, they may be deceived when they speak in their own names, and judge by their own Spirit or reason: But do you think they may be deceived when they prophesie as from God. If so, then what certainty can we have of the truth of any of their Prophecies, if they may speak falsly to us in the name of God? 2. Will not your followers think you yet see your partiality, who in one Page reproach others as denying Scripture to be a perfect Rule, and in another can thus seek to parallel Gods Prophets, with one that rashly in the Pulpit prophesieth three falshoods together in the name of God? Is it not Gods direction to us, to take him for a false Prophet who prophesieth that which cometh not to pass? Every one that foretelleth that which doth ⟨p. 71⟩come to pass is not a true Prophet, Deut. 13. 23. But every one that absolutely prophesieth that which doth not come to pass, is a false Prophet,
Sect. 28. E. B. 2. May not many Prophets truly foretell things to come,1 and yet those things be a long time suspended and delayed because of the sins of the people? Is not this condition to be understood in most Scripture Prophecies, expressed, Zach. 6. 15. And this shall come to pass, if you will diligently obey, &c.
R. B. 1. A Conditional promise or prediction may be not only delayed, but never fulfilled (so as that the thing shall not come to pass) if the condition never come to pass, 2. Promises are oftener to be expounded as Conditional, than peremptory Prophecies, when no condition is expressed. But what words can more exclude both Conditions and Delays, ⟨p. 72⟩than [I tell you from God, that you shall never more, &c. When 1. They never ceased paying Tithes from that day to this: 2. And their Taxes were then upon them, and I think they believe not that they never paid more. 3. And that we have a King his Subjects all acknowledge. Indeed the Jews say that the promise of the Messiah is delayed because of their sins; and by such pretences what true Prophecy may not be perverted, and false excused?
R. B. 1. A Conditional promise or prediction may be not only delayed, but never fulfilled (so as that the thing shall not come to pass) if the condition never come to pass, 2. Promises are oftner to be expounded as Conditional, than peremptory Prophecies, when no condition is expressed. But what words can more exclude both Conditions and Delayes, ⟨p. 72⟩than [I tell you from God, that you shall never more, &c. When 1. They never ceased paying Tythes from that day to this: 2. And their Taxes were then upon them, and I think they believe not that they never paid more. 3. And that we have a King his Subjects all acknowledge. Indeed the Jews say that the promise of the Messiah is delayed because of their sins; and by such pretences what true Prophecy may not be perverted, and false excused?
As for what you say of Mr. Powel's Religiousness, diligence, and worthiness, I never said a word against it: And I desire to promote, and not to cloud the true honour of his name: And your calling that an unchristian calumny which you cannot deny to be a proved truth, is but an unmanly calumny of your own. And for your Prophecy of my memory dying before me, I am not solicitous of the matter; let God do with my memory what he please: nor am I regardful of your Prophecy, who defend false prophesying, being commanded not to fear such, Deut. 18. 22.
As for what you say of Mr. Powels Religiousness, diligence, and worthiness, I never said a word against it: And I desire to promote, and not to cloud the true honour of his name: And your calling that an unchristian calumny which you cannot deny to be a proved truth, is but an unmanly calumny of your own. And for your Prophecy of my memory dying before me, I am not solicitous of the matter; let God do with my memory what he please: nor am I regardful of your Prophecy, who defend false prophecying, being commanded not to fear such, Deut. 18. 22.
Sect. 29. E. B. The pride of your heart,1 discovered by your writings is so apparent, that it cannot but be known and read of all men: to go no further for instances than your last Books, what needed you have told the world in print, that you chase once on Easter day to communicate in a very populous Church, purposely that it might be the further known. Is not ⟨p. 73⟩this like the Hypocrites to blow a Trumpet before, and to do your actions that they may be seen of men? What other end could you have in doing that so publicly then, or in declaring it now, but a vain glorious hope, that doubting and unsatisfied Christians might look upon your example, as their Pole-star, and accordingly direct their course?
Sect. 29. E. B. The pride of your heart,1 discovered by your writings is so apparent, that it cannot but be known and read of all men: to go no further for instances than your last Books, what needed you have told the world in print, that you chase once on Easter day to communicate in a very populous Church, purposely that it might be the further known. Is not ⟨p. 73⟩this like the Hypocrites to blow a Trumpet before, and to do your actions that they may be seen of men? What other end could you have in doing that so publickly then, or in declaring it now, but a vain glorious hope, that doubting and unsatisfied Christians might look upon your example, as their Pole-star, and accordingly direct their course?
114 Crime, Duty reproached, and scandal made a duty.
R. B. 1. As to the Pride of my heart,1 I shall first say this in general; that I am past doubt I have too much of it: As no man is wholly cured of that odious vice, so I am one that have no cause to say that I am perfect. But these things I can confidently say, 1. That so far as I am proud, I sin as much against my own judgement, I imagine, as most men alive do; there being sew that ever I was acquainted with, that have said and written more against it than I have done: I have had these thirty years and more, more odious conceptions of that sin, and a deeper sense of its commonness and prevalency in the world, and the woeful ruins which it makes in the Church and State and souls; and how frequently it showeth it self even in men of great piety and worth, than of almost any other sin. I have had so many thousand thoughts and words against it, as make me much more culpable, if I be proud. 2. And I shall sin as much against my Conscience in being proud as most men in the world. As my Judgement is so much against the sin, so my Conscience commandeth me a very Low and ⟨p. 74⟩Constant self-abasement: It telleth me, that whether I look to a corruptible painful flesh, or to an Ignorant understanding, or to a sinful will, or to a sinful and unprofitable life, I have so little to be proud of, as will render my pride exceeding odious. 3. I do evidently see the odiousness of this sin in others: Were it not for seeming to retort your charge, I should say, that though I cannot as you do conclude of the heart, yet the usual Ensigns of Pride (with Temerity and Injudiciousness, Boldness and Blindness) do appear to me so monstrous in your Writings, above the size that ordinary sinners ever fall to, as maketh me the more apprehend, how dreadful it is to give way to pride in the beginnings; And methinks I see as written on the front of your Writings, Be not high-minded, but fear. Therefore I am still the more culpable, if I abound with that which is so terrible a warning to me, in your self, and other such as you. 4. And as I every day watch and pray against it (and if ever I knew any thing of my self in the world, I am certain that I live in an habituate and ordinary apprehension of my baseness and unworthiness, and of the utter vanity of humane applause) so I find my self partly glad that you tell me of my Pride, that (whatever you mean) I may have one more check to keep it under;
and if it be a messenger of Satan to buffet me, I hope it will not be in vain. 5. And I can assure you, that these Writings which so exasperate ⟨p. 75⟩you, had never come from me, if I had not first so far conquered the esteem of man, and love of reputation, as to be willing to cast my self upon reproach, and to be much indifferent as to the opinion of man? For I was not so ignorant as not to foresee that such as you would take the detection and reproof of their errors for a heinous injury, and be angry at him that called them to repent, and would furiously scatter the fetid excrements of their gall, in revilings of such as contradict them. Methinks then you should see, that I laid by some Pride, when I cared so little for your good word, and exposed my self so readily to your Calumnies.
and if it be a messenger of Satan to buffet me, I hope it will not be in vain. 5. And I can assure you, that these Writings which so exasperate ⟨p. 75⟩you, had never come from me, if I had not first so far conquered the esteem of man, and love of reputation, as to be willing to cast my self upon reproach, and to be much indifferent as to the opinion of man? For I was not so ignorant as not to foresee that such as you would take the detection and reproof of their errors for a heinous injury, and be angry at him that called them to repent, and would furiously scatter the fetide excrements of their gall, in revilings of such as contradict them. Methinks then you should see, that I laid by some Pride, when I cared so little for your good word, and exposed my self so readily to your Calumnies.
2. And I must tell you that though you do as much to cure my pride, as almost any mortal man that ever I had to do with, by the way of open demonstration of the Ensigns of it by your self (as the sight of a Leprosy would cure one that were in love with it;) yet you are too blame for Tempting me so much to pride as you do on the other side, while you decry it: For what is it else but an inviting and tempting a man to be proud, to tell the world, that you have nothing to charge him with to prove it, but such silly Calumnies as these of yours?
2. And I must tell you that though you do as much to cure my pride, as almost any mortal man that ever I had to do with, by the way of open demonstration of the Ensigns of it by your self (as the sight of a Leprosie would cure one that were in love with it;) yet you are too blame for Tempting me so much to pride as you do on the other side, while you decry it: For what is it else but an inviting and tempting a man to be proud, to tell the world, that you have nothing to charge him with to prove it, but such silly Calumnies as these of yours?
3. And yet I will say, that I see now that a mans enemies may be more useful to him than his friends: For I can hear that of my Pride from you, which never friend by ⟨p. 76⟩Word or Letter to my remembrance told me in my life. The more too blame they, if you be not mistaken.
2. But next let us see your evidence or proof:1 Your first is, [What need I have told the world, &c.] would you have an answer to your question or not? If not, why do you ask it? If you would, why did you not take an answer when I gave it you; nor so much as mention it, as if you read it not, when you call for another? Is it because that you remembered, that many that read your Papers, will never read mine, and so will not know what I have said, nor how deceivingly you use them? It may be so: But will that do your work, and hold at last? If I repeat my answer, I shall offend my Readers, for writing the same thing twice, because you take no notice of the first. But this much I will return you now: 1. My avoiding public communion for fear of bringing more suffering on those that scrupled it, (and that so many years together,) was a scandal and temptation to others, and tended to make them think, that I held it to be unlawful; as Peters Separation was a scandal to Barnabas and others: And do you think every man that avoideth scandalizing, is therefore proud: Are not humble men bound to avoid scandal as well as others? If a man by many years forbearing all public Prayer or Sacrament, should tempt others to think that he is against them, or accounts them needless, how ⟨p. 77⟩should he cure that scandal, but by doing that openly, and open pleading for it, which he is supposed to be against? Doth Paul make scandal to be the destroying of another's soul, and a thing to be avoided on such hard terms as he mentioneth, and do you think that the open avoiding it, is to be charged with Pride? How directly do you set your self against the way of the Spirit of God?
2. But next let us see your evidence or proof:1 Your first is, [What need I have told the world, &c.] would you have an answer to your question or not? If not, why do you ask it? If you would, why did you not take an answer when I gave it you; nor so much as mention it, as if you read it not, when you call for another? Is it because that you remembred, that many that read your Papers, will never read mine, and so will not know what I have said, nor how deceivingly you use them? It may be so: But will that do your work, and hold at last? If I repeat my answer, I shall offend my Readers, for writing the same thing twice, because you take no notice of the first. But this much I will return you now: 1. My avoiding publick communion for fear of bringing more suffering on those that scrupled it, (and that so many years together,) was a scandal and temptation to others, and tended to make them think, that I held it to be unlawful; as Peters Separation was a scandal to Barnabas and others: And do you think every man that avoideth scandalizing, is therefore proud: Are not humble men bound to avoid scandal as well as others? If a man by many years forbearing all publick Prayer or Sacrament, should tempt others to think that he is against them, or accounts them needless, how
2. I had for the same reason become a scandal also to our Governors, and to many sober Conformable men, who were tempted by my omission, to think the Non-conformists to be peevish Dividers, who follow Parties and Passion, more than their own Consciences? And would any thing cure this scandal also, that had not been notified? Or is the scandal of so many such persons no evil to be avoided; nor their mis-judging of the Non-conformists to be cured by such as did occasion it?
2. I had for the same reason become a scandal also to our Governours, and to many sober Conformable men, who were tempted by my omission, to think the Non-conformists to be pievish Dividers, who follow Parties and Passion, more than their own Consciences? And would any thing cure this scandal also, that had not been notified? Or is the scandal of so many such persons no evil to be avoided; nor their mis-judging of the Non-conformists to be cured by such as did occasion it?
3. Is not every Minister of Christ a public person? Should they not be the Lights of the world, that cannot and should not be hid? Is every man Proud, that is not Mad? Whether my Actions be noted, is a matter of fact? The question is not, whether I be so regardable, as to be worthy notice? but whether de facto any do note what I do? And do you doubt of it? Why then do you write two invectives to cure their esteem of me? Do you not perceive here how your work contradicts your self? ⟨p. 78⟩And must I needs as my duty, be so mad, as not to know that any observe me, or regard what I do, for fear of being proud? You might as well make it a duty to go naked in the Streets, lest I be proud if I think that any one will observe me. 4. And are not Ministers bound to teach the people by Example, as well as by Doctrine? You dare not deny it. And is that example, which is unknown? Will you teach men to say against Gods command, I must not be so Proud as to think that my example will be observed or regarded? God saith, 1 Tim. 4. 12. Be thou an example of the believers in word, in conversation, in charity, in Spirit, in faith, in purity: Must none that think meanly of themselves obey this? O but, you will reply, Is not this like Hypocrites, to do your actions to be seen of men? Christ will have us all to let our light so shine before men (not with the Hypocrite to get their applause to our selves, but for their own good and Gods glory) that they may see our good works, and glorify our Father which is in Heaven. O but saith Mr. Bagshaw, What other end can you have in doing this, but a vain-glorious hope, that doubting Christians may look on your example as their Pole-star, &c And indeed will such a scorn of E. B. disoblige all Christs Ministers from obeying their Lord, and allow them to live in open scandal, for fear of thinking it lawful to be Exemplary?
3. Is not every Minister of Christ a publick person? Should they not be the Lights of the world, that cannot and should not be hid? Is every man Proud, that is not Mad? Whether my Actions be noted, is a matter of fact? The question is not, whether I be so regardable, as to be worthy notice? but whether de facto any do note what I do? And do you doubt of it? Why then do you write two invectives to cure their esteem of me? Do you not perceive here how your work contradicts your self? ⟨p. 78⟩
5. Do you think indeed that you are not ⟨p. 79⟩noted your self? Do you neither in Life nor in your sufferings, intend to be publicly exemplary? Do you not forbear the public Assemblies, the rather that your example may move others? Thus still a perverse Spirit condemneth it self.
5. Do you think indeed that you are not ⟨p. 79⟩noted your self? Do you neither in Life nor in your sufferings, intend to be publickly exemplary? Do you not forbear the publick Assemblies, the rather that your example may move others? Thus still a perverse Spirit condemneth it self.
6. If Doctrine and Example be the two means commanded, by which Ministers must edify the Church, is it not Pride as well to expect that our words should be heeded, as our Examples? And could an Atheist deal more impudently and profanely, than to tell all Ministers, you are notoriously proud in expecting that all the Congregation should take heed of what you say? Do you not preach or talk to your own auditors, and expect observation? What if another E. B. were among them and should say, How proud are you to expect that we should all regard your words, as if you were our Polestar? These are not meet Lessons for a sufferer to teach the people.
6. If Doctrine and Example be the two means commanded, by which Ministers must edifie the Church, is it not Pride as well to expect that our words should be heeded, as our Examples? And could an Atheist deal more impudently and prophanely, than to tell all Ministers, you are notoriously proud in expecting that all the Congregation should take heed of what you say? Do you not preach or talk to your own auditors, and expect observation? What if another E. B. were among them and should say, How proud are you to expect that we should all regard your words, as if you were our Polestar? These are not meet Lessons for a sufferer to teach the people.
Sect. 30. E. B. I look upon it also as a strange piece of boasting,1 when you tell us, that men of all judgements have written against you:—Is it indeed true that you offend all, and please none, and can you glory that you are accounted the Ishmael of the age?
R. B. Alas, poor man! Is this Conscience scrupulous of Communion with us Publicans and sinners? Here are no less than three more visible Untruths thrust together. 1. That I say, [That men of all judgements have written ⟨p. 80⟩against me] when my words are these [Whereas our differences in Doctrine, Worship and Discipline have engaged men of several minds in such Writings against me.] Where did I say, that men of the judgement of Peter or Paul, of Augustine or Prosper, wrote against me? Are those Infidels, Quakers, with the &c. [All]? 2. That I glory that I am accounted the Ishmael of the age (which is intimated in the question) or boast of mens contradiction? Which is so notorious a falsehood, that I mention it only as other mens contradiction of each other (who blame me for contrary things) and as my own trouble. I only told you, how impossible it is for me to please all men, while men expect so many contrary things of me: The Anabaptists are quite displeased with me for writing for Infants Baptism: The Conformists are angry, because I will not subscribe that [It is certain by Gods Word, that Children which are baptized, dying before they commit actual sin, are undoubtedly saved] without excepting those that are wrongfully baptized, Turks, Heathens, &c. The Antinomians are offended with me for opposing their subversion of the Gospel under pretence of extolling free grace: And others are angry that I come so near them, as to the cessation of Moses Law. And so it is with all the rest. How vain therefore is it to turn a Man-pleaser, when the task is as impossible as unprofitable. But O, saith E. B. what a strange boast is this, to tell us that ⟨p. 81⟩men of all judgements have written against you! That which I recite as my trial and trouble, he falsely tells the world, I boast of.
R. B. Alas, poor man! Is this Conscience scrupulous of Communion with us Publicans and sinners? Here are no less than three more visible Vntruths thrast together. 1. That I say, [That men of all judgements have written ⟨p. 80⟩against me] when my words are these [Whereas our differences in Doctrine, Worship and Discipline have engaged men of several minds in such Writings against me.] Where did I say, that men of the judgement of Peter or Paul, of Augustine or Prosper, wrote against me? Are those Infidels, Quakers, with the &c. [All]? 2. That I glory that I am accounted the Ishmael of the age (which is intimated in the question) or boast of mens contradiction? Which is so notorious a falshood, that I mention it only as other mens contradiction of each other (who blame me for contrary things) and as my own trouble. I only told you, how impossible it is for me to please all men, while men expect so many contrary things of me: The Anabaptists are quite displeased with me for writing for Infants Baptism: The Conformists are angry, because I will not subscribe that [It is certain by Gods Word, that Children which are baptized, dying before they commit actuall sin, are undoubtedly saved] without excepting those that are wrongfully baptized, Turks, Heathens, &c. The Antinomians are offended with me for opposing their subversion of the Gospel under pretence of extolling free grace: And others are angry that I come so near them, as to the cessation of Moses Law. And so it is with all the rest. How vain therefore is it to turn a Man-pleaser, when the task is as impossible as unprofitable. But O, saith E. B. what a strange boast is this, to tell us that
3. The third known falsehood is (intimated) that [I offend all and please none.] As if he did believe that those whom I mentioned (even with an &c.) were [all] and there were no others in the world?
3. The third known falshood is (intimated) that [I offend all and please none.] As if he did believe that those whom I mentioned (even with an &c.) were [all] and there were no others in the world?
2. But besides these falsehoods, he again condemneth himself for his accusation. For 1. If it be a matter of Pride to declare that I am written against, why will this man write himself against me, and tempt me to be more proud, when he accuseth me of pride? Is not his Writing published by himself? Why then will he publish that which himself supposeth to be my glorying? and so advance my reputation? (which few adversaries ever did more effectually) 2. And if I offend all and please none, what need he be at all this labour to save men from being pleased by me? But it is fatal or natural to men of his vice, to have bad memories.
2. But besides these falshoods, he again condemneth himself for his accusation. For 1. If it be a matter of Pride to declare that I am written against, why will this man write himself against me, and tempt me to be more proud, when he accuseth me of pride? Is not his Writing published by himself? Why then will he publish that which himself supposeth to be my glorying? and so advance my reputation? (which few adversaries ever did more effectually) 2. And if I offend all and please none, what need he be at all this labour to save men from being pleased by me? But it is fatal or natural to men of his vice, to have bad memories.
The former untruth he again implieth, [You would be grieved for grieving them, and not put it in among your triumphs, that you had provoked so many able worthy men.] He that hath once ventured upon an untruth, may do it boldlier the second time, and may come at last to believe himself.
The former untruth he again implyeth, [You would be grieved for grieving them, and not put it in among your triumphs, that you had provoked so many able worthy men.] He that hath once ventured upon an untruth, may do it boldlier the second time, and may come at last to believe himself.
As for the worthy Opponents whom he nameth, 1. I can honour and love them as much as he, without thinking them infallible: And I can. differ from them without ⟨p. 82⟩disaffection. 2. Which of them is it that the man would have me grieve for grieving? Doubtless those that are in the points controverted of his mind! So kind is he to them or himself. It cannot be all, unless he would have me, either say nothing of the matter, or write contrary things to please contrary parties. 3. And doth he not differ from most whom he nameth himself, by his Separation? And yet he sticketh not thus to grieve many more than them.
Sect. 31. E. B. p. 9. [When I said in one of my exceptions,1 that I feared you were not sound in the doctrine of Justification by faith alone without works, instead of answering directly, and satisfying my scruple (which you might have done in few words) you refer me to five or more Treatises, which you say you have written on that subject.—
R. B. 1. Did you believe when you wrote this, that this reference was a proof of my Pride? 12. Why would you no more regard your reputation, than to recite such a passage as this? Will your Reader doubt whether you should repent of such things as words of Impudency unbeseeming a man of understanding?
For 1. Was it modesty in you to divulge such an accusation as this [I am afraid you are not sound in the doctrine of Justification] without reciting one word of mine which you accuse, or telling the Reader or me any ⟨p. 83⟩reason of your fears? 2. And could you expect that he that had written so many Books to declare his judgement in that point, must write part of another, to tell you what he holds, and consequently write as many, or as oft as men shall so by their Fears invite him? 3. And do you not at that very time prove me proud for writing so many Books, when by this and other passages you call for an answer, that is, for more? 4. Could you think that [a few words] would open a mans mind so plainly, as many Books can do? 5. Could humane ingenuity expect more from one thus slightly questioned, than to be referred to those Books, which were purposely written both to stand as a full Confession of my faith in that point after other mens suspicions, and also to give the reasons of it, and to defend it against all that's said against it? And could I expect, that he that will disdain to read these Books, will read another that repeateth the same things? And shall I write more to remove his Fears, who will rather blindly vent them by calumny, than read for his satisfaction what I have said? If you have read them, why would you say you Fear, which signifieth uncertainty? When you might have come to a certain knowledge? If you read them not, why would you not use a visible means to discuss your fears, before you divulged them? And if this way be right in the eyes of others, what made Dr. Owen, and other Congregational ⟨p. 84⟩Brethren, admonish your Brother Mr. Powell for preaching openly (almost as soon as he came out of Prison) particularly against me and another (then thought to have been Mr. Nigh, but he said he meant Mr. Tombs) by description; and the description of me was [He that is not sound in the Doctrine of Justification] or to that sense. And what made them threaten to disown him if he would not cease such ways? Did ever sober men go about with such general accusations, and expect that men answer to they know not what? 6. But what are the few words that would satisfy you? A yea, or a nay? What if I say, Sir I think I am sound in the doctrine of Justification, and I think you speak evil of the things you know not] Would that have satisfied you?
For 1. Was it modesty in you to divulge such an accusation as this [I am afraid you are not sound in the doctrine of Justification] without reciting one word of mine which you accuse, or telling the Reader or me any
⟨p. 66⟩
was forced into a Garrison from my habitation, through the fury that still sought my life. And since then, O what wholsome and constant sufferings have been measured out unto me, almost continually night and day. I will say no more, but that above all the external disposals of my most wise and gracious God, I humbly, and heartily, and daily thank him for my sufferings. But surely this man is not 〈…〉 or permitted to write this in vain. Alas, my God, it calleth my sin, my unfruitfulness to my remembrance! My cleansing, nor my comfort have not been answerable to the sharp but gracious helps and warnings which thou hast so long vouchsafed me: It is true, too true, that I have sinned so much under sufferings, and been so unfruitful after sufferings, that I have little cause to boast of cleansing, and less experience of comfort, than otherwise I might have had. But yet I have so much experience as obligeth me to thankfulness, and assuredly to number this saying with his Vntruths that he utters;
even the twenty sixth in number; And I think the Crime of usurping the prerogative of God, of knowing the heart, should be repented of.
110th Crime Self-denying.
⟨p. 69⟩
Spirit should be thus reproached, and Infidels hardned in a contempt of the Spirit, as if it were but a fancy! O wo to the world because of offences!
Deut. 18. 20, 21, 22
. But the Prophet which shall presume to speak a word in my name, which I have not commanded him to speak—even that Prophet shall dye. (Mark whether God do judge as you do.) And if thou say in thy heart, how shall we know the word which the Lord hath spoken, when a Prophet speaketh in the name of the Lord, if the thing follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing which the Lord hath not spoken, but the Prophet hath spoken it presumptuously: thou shalt not be afraid of him.
I shall first say this in general; that I am past doubt I have too much of it: As no man is wholly cured of that odious vice, so I am one that have no cause to say that I am perfect. But these things I can confidently say, 1. That so far as I am proud, I sin as much against my own judgement, I imagine, as most men alive do; there being sew that ever I was acquainted with, that have said and written more against it than I have done: I have had these thirty years and more, more odious conceptions of that sin, and a deeper sense of its commonness and prevalency in the world, and the wofull ruines which it makes in the Church and State and souls; and how frequently it sheweth it self even in men of great piety and worth, than of almost any other sin. I have had so many thousand thoughts and words against it, as make me much more culpable, if I be proud. 2. And I shall sin as much against my Conscience in being proud as most men in the world. As my Judgement is so much against the sin, so my Conscience commandeth me a very Low and
⟨p. 74⟩
Constant self-abasement: It telleth me, that whether I look to a corruptible painfull flesh, or to an Ignorant understanding, or to a sinful will, or to a sinful and unprofitable life, I have so little to be proud of, as will render my pride exceeding odious. 3. I do evidently see the odiousness of this sin in others: Were it not for seeming to retort your charge, I should say, that though I cannot as you do conclude of the heart, yet the usual Ensigns of Pride (with Temerity and Injudiciousness, Boldness and Blindness) do appear to me so monstrous in your Writings, above the size that ordinary sinners ever fall to, as maketh me the more apprehend, how dreadful it is to give way to pride in the beginnings; And methinks I see as written on the front of your Writings, Be not high-minded, but fear. Therefore I am still the more culpable, if I abound with that which is so terrible a warning to me, in your self, and other such as you. 4. And as I every day watch and pray against it (and if ever I knew any thing of my self in the world, I am certain that I live in an habituate and ordinary apprehension of my baseness and unworthiness, and of the utter vanity of humane applause) so I find my self partly glad that you tell me of my Pride, that (whatever you mean) I may have one more check to keep it under;
1Of Pride.
⟨p. 77⟩
should he cure that scandal, but by doing that openly, and open pleading for it, which he is supposed to be against? Doth Paul make scandal to be the destroying of anothers soul, and a thing to be avoided on such hard terms as he mentioneth, and do you think that the open avoiding it, is to be charged with Pride? How directly do you set your self against the way of the Spirit of God?
1The Reasons of my public Communicating.The Reasons of my publick Communicating.
And must I needs as my duty, be so mad, as not to know that any observe me, or regard what I do, for fear of being proud? You might as well make it a duty to go naked in the Streets, lest I be proud if I think that any one will observe me. 4. And are not Ministers bound to teach the people by Example, as well as by Doctrine? You dare not deny it. And is that example, which is unknown? Will you teach men to say against Gods command, I must not be so Proud as to think that my example will be observed or regarded? God saith,
. Be thou an example of the believers in word, in conversation, in charity, in Spirit, in faith, in purity: Must none that think meanly of themselves obey this? O but, you will reply, Is not this like Hypocrites, to do your actions to be seen of men? Christ will have us all to let our light so shine before men (not with the Hypocrite to get their applause to our selves, but for their own good and Gods glory) that they may see our good works, and glorifie our Father which is in Heaven. O but saith Mr. Bagshaw, What other end can you have in doing this, but a vain-glorious hope, that doubting Christians may look on your example as their Pole-star, &c And indeed will such a scorn of E. B. disoblige all Christs Ministers from obeying their Lord, and allow them to live in open scandal, for fear of thinking it lawful to be Exemplary?
⟨p. 81⟩
men of all judgements have written against you! That which I recite as my tryal and trouble, he falsly tells the world, I boast of.
⟨p. 83⟩
reason of your fears? 2. And could you expect that he that had written so many Books to declare his judgement in that point, must write part of another, to tell you what he holds, and consequently write as many, or as oft as men shall so by their Fears invite him? 3. And do you not at that very time prove me proud for writing so many Books, when by this and other passages you call for an answer, that is, for more? 4. Could you think that [a few words] would open a mans mind so plainly, as many Books can do? 5. Could humane ingenuity expect more from one thus slightly questioned, than to be referred to those Books, which were purposely written both to stand as a full Confession of my faith in that point after other mens suspicions, and also to give the reasons of it, and to defend it against all thats said against it? And could I expect, that he that will disdain to read these Books, will read another that repeateth the same things? And shall I write more to remove his Fears, who will rather blindly vent them by calumny, than read for his satisfaction what I have said? If you have read them, why would you say you Fear, which signifieth uncertainty? When you might have come to a certain knowledge? If you read them not, why would you not use a visible means to discuss your fears, before you divulged them? And if this way be right in the eyes of others, what made Dr. Owen, and other Congregational
⟨p. 84⟩
Brethren, admonish your Brother Mr. Powell for preaching openly (almost as soon as he came out of Prison) particularly against me and another (then thought to have been Mr. Nie, but he said he meant Mr. Tombs) by description; and the description of me was [He that is not sound in the Doctrine of Justification] or to that sense. And what made them threaten to disown him if he would not cease such wayes? Did ever sober men go about with such general accusations, and expect that men answer to they know not what? 6. But what are the few words that would satisfie you? A yea, or a nay? What if I say, Sir I think I am sound in the doctrine of Justification, and I think you speak evil of the things you know not] Would that have satisfied you?