Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Moreover, Basil gtells us, The Confession of Faith is conformable to the delivery of Baptism, and the Doxology conformable to the Confession of Faith; That they are all three much alike. That they Baptized as they had received, and believed accordingly as they Baptized, and gave glory just as they believed; that there was a necessary and inviolable coherence betwixt these, and that an innovation in any of these, would destroy the whole, [Greek or Hebrew]; lib. de Sp. Sanct. cap. 27. p. 274. But he does not think the change of Phrase and Words therein is such an innovation, if it remain the same in sense, [Greek or Hebrew], for he himself used the Doxology very variously, and would not be bound up to one Form, in the expressing of but four or five Words. And by what liberty he took in this, shows, what might be taken in the rest. Two days before the writing of this Book, in Prayer with the People, [Greek or Hebrew], he used the Doxology two ways (both differing from that which is usual) as he tells us cap. 1. [Greek or Hebrew], Glory to God and the Father (adding) sometimes with the Son, together with the Holy Ghost; sometimes by the Son, in the Holy Ghost; but this is but a taste of his variety. He that will observe how it is used in this Book, and in the end of his Homilies, may find it diversified ⟨p. 105⟩near forty several ways, and run almost into so many Changes, as so few words are capable of. One may think they are put to hard shifts for proof of the prescribed Forms in question, who are glad to make the ancient Use of the Doxology one of their Arguments. We see it would not serve their turn, if it could be proved, that they were as much limited to Forms of Prayer in Baptism, as they thought themselves confined to the words of Christ, delivering the Form of Baptizing. Those that thought a [Greek or Hebrew], a conformity in sense sufficient, where Christ gives the direction, might with much reason judge this enough, or too much, when men only prescribe; and in cases too, where a greater Latitude is safer. Their practice, in the severals premised, show, they knew no such prescriptions, nor would have honoured them with any more observance, or so much.
Moreover, Basil gtells us, The Confession of Faith is conformable to the delivery of Baptism, and the Doxology conformable to the Confession of Faith; That they are all three much alike. That they Baptized as they had received, and believed accordingly as they Baptized, and gave glory just as they believed; that there was a necessary and inviolable coherence betwixt these, and that an innovation in any of these, would destroy the whole, ; lib. de Sp. Sanct. cap. 27. p. 274. But he does not think the change of Phrase and Words therein is such an innovation, if it remain the same in sense, , for he himself used the Doxology very variously, and would not be bound up to one Form, in the expressing of but four or five Words. And by what liberty he took in this, shews, what might be taken in the rest. Two days before the writing of this Book, in Prayer with the People, , he used the Doxology two ways (both differing from that which is usual) as he tells us cap. 1. , Glory to God and the Father (adding) sometimes with the Son, together with the Holy Ghost; sometimes by the Son, in the Holy Ghost; but this is but a taste of his variety. He that will observe how it is used in this Book, and in the end of his Homilies, may find it diversified
〈non-Latin alphabet〉
〈non-Latin alphabet〉
〈non-Latin alphabet〉
〈non-Latin alphabet〉
⟨p. 105⟩
near forty several ways, and run almost into so many Changes, as so few words are capable of. One may think they are put to hard shifts for proof of the prescribed Forms in question, who are glad to make the antient Use of the Doxology one of their Arguments. We see it would not serve their turn, if it could be proved, that they were as much limited to Forms of Prayer in Baptism, as they thought themselves confined to the words of Christ, delivering the Form of Baptizing. Those that thought a 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, a conformity in sense sufficient, where Christ gives the direction, might with much reason judge this enough, or too much, when men only prescribe; and in cases too, where a greater Latitude is safer. Their practice, in the severals premised, shew, they knew no such prescriptions, nor would have honoured them with any more observance, or so much.
g[Greek or Hebrew], de Spir. Sanct. c. 27. p. 274.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, de Spir. Sanct. c. 27. p. 274.
To proceed, There was a mode of Renunciation generally used in Baptism, and a general agreement to use the same in sense; and yet, as to Words and Syllables, a strange variety: When as here, if any where, a common rule enjoining uniformity in Words might have been expected, and in such a Case, if in any, would have been observed. I have taken notice of more than twenty hvariations of this so short a sentence; and find no two of the many Ancients who used it, to represent the usage of it to us, agreeing therein as to Words and ⟨p. 106⟩⟨p. 107⟩Syllables; nor yet have I met with two instances, where the difference is not more than Syllabical: It may be others may meet with more; yet if ⟨p. 108⟩more than two, amongst so many intending to express the same thing, had used exactly the same Words, (and where other things besides a Rule might have rendered their expressions Uniform) it would have been no proof, that the Words had been prescribed; it would rather be strange, if in such circumstances, they should not casually fall into such an agreement without the conduct of any prescription. But since they are so far from observing the punctilios of a prescribed Uniformity, and vary herein so much, as one may wonder how so few Words could be contrived into such variety; it proves sufficiently, that they were not under any Orders, obliging them, to use precisely the same Words.
To proceed, There was a mode of Renunciation generally used in Baptism, and a general agreement to use the same in sense; and yet, as to Words and Syllables, a strange variety: When as here, if any where, a common rule injoining uniformity in Words might have been expected, and in such a Case, if in any, would have been observed. I have taken notice of more than twenty hvariations of this so short a sentence; and find no two of the many Antients who used it, to represent the usage of it to us, agreeing therein as to Words and ⟨p. 106⟩⟨p. 107⟩Syllables; nor yet have I met with two instances, where the difference is not more than Syllabical: It may be others may meet with more; yet if ⟨p. 108⟩more than two, amongst so many intending to express the same thing, had used exactly the same Words, (and where other things besides a Rule might have rendered their expressions Uniform) it would have been no proof, that the Words had been prescribed; it would rather be strange, if in such circumstances, they should not casually fall into such an agreement without the conduct of any prescription. But since they are so far from observing the punctilios of a prescribed Uniformity, and vary herein so much, as one may wonder how so few Words could be contrived into such variety; it proves sufficiently, that they were not under any Orders, obliging them, to use precisely the same Words.
hOrigenes, Quid denunciaverit diabolo, non se usurum pompis ejus, & voluptatibus pariturum, in ep. ad Rom. Universis denique aliis Diis & Dominis, Homil. 8. in Exod. Constantius, de se, Renuncians Satanae Pompis & operibus ejus & universis idolis manu factis, credere me in Deum professus sum, in Edict. ad Sylvest. Cyril, Hierosolym. Catech. 1. Mister. [Greek or Hebrew], p. 228, 229. Ephrem. Syrus, Abrenuncio tibi Satan, & cunctis operibus tuis, l. de poenit. c. 5. Basil, [Greek or Hebrew], de Spir. Sanc. cap. 27. no prescription for it. Cyril Alexandrin. Ibi deposuerimus tenebras a meant nostra, & doemoniorum turbis valedixerimus, omnemque ipsorum pompam, & cultum prudentissime respuerimus, consitemur fidem in Patrem, lib. 7. contra Julian. Salvian Massiliens. Abrenuncio, inquis, Diabolo, Pompis, spectaculis & operibus ejus, de provid. lib. 6. p. 197. Quae est enim in baptismo salutary Christianorum prima confessio, nisi ut renunciare se Diabolo, ac pompis ejus, atque spectaculis, & operibus, protestentur? p. 198. Dionysius Areop. [Greek or Hebrew], Eccles. Hierarch. The repeating of it singular. Clemens Constit. [Greek or Hebrew], l. 7. c. 41. Justinian. [Greek or Hebrew], c.... l. 33. §. 1. de Episcop. Audient. Tertullian, Sed & aliquanto prius in Ecclesia sub Antistitis manu, contestamur nos renunciare Diabolo, & Pompae, & Angelis ejus, de Coron. Milit. c. 3. Optatus Milevit. Contra nos peccatores (ut vultis) interrogemus alterum Gentilem, an renunciet Diabolo, & credat Deo, &c. & dicat Renuncio & credo, Cohtr. Parmenianum, l. 5. p. 59. Cyprian, Seculo renunciavimus cum Baptizati sumus, Epist. 5. l. 1. Stare illic potuit Dei servus, & loqui, & renunciare Christo, qui jam Diabolo renunciaret & seculo, Serm. de Laps. p. 151. Cujus (mundi) pompis & deliciis jam tunc renunciavimus, cum meliori transgressu ad Dominum venimus, de habit Virgin. p 107. See carnis concupiscentiis & vitiis renunciasse profitetur, id ibid. Augustin, Quisquis huic aedificio conjungi desiderat, renunciet Diabolo, Pompis & Angelis ejus, de symbol. ad Catechum. l. 3. c. 1. Omissa enim certissima cautione, qua vos abrenunciare omnibus Pompis Diaboli, & omnibus operibus ejus, & omni fornicationi diabolicae, spospondistis, Homil. 3. ad neophytos. Pro ipsis enim respondent, quod abrenuncient Diabolo, Pompis & Operibus ejus, & ideo pactum, quod, cum Christo in Baptismi Sacramento, conscribunt, custodire contendant, nec unquam aliquid de Diaboli pompis, vel mundi istius luxuriosis oblect ationibus concupiscant, de Temp. Serm. 116. Ambrose, Dicens, abrenuncio tibi, Diabole, & Angelis tuis, & operibus tuis & imperiis tuis, Hexam. l. 1. c. 4. Quando te interrogavit Sacerdos; abrenuncias Diabolo, & Operibus suis? quid respondisti? Abrenuncio. Abrenuncias seculo & voluptatibus ejus? quid respondisti? Abrenuncio, de Sacrament. l. 1. c. 2. Quid interrogatus es, recognosce, quid responderis, renunciasti Diabolo & operibus ejus, mundo & luxuriae ejus, lib. de iis qui Myster. initiant. c. 2. Chrysostom, [Greek or Hebrew], Homil. 21. ad pop. Antioch. p. 609. Savil. edit. [Greek or Hebrew], in
And thus we find not only those of the Greek and Latin Churches differing, or such as lived at a greater distance, and in the parts of the Empire, remotest one from another, but those of the same Country and the same Church, where, if any where, Uniformity is to be looked for: We may observe it in Tertullian, Cyprian, Optatus, and Augustin.
And thus we find not only those of the Greek and Latin Churches differing, or such as lived at a greater distance, and in the parts of the Empire, remotest one from another, but those of the same Country and the same Church, where, if any where, Uniformity is to be lookt for: We may observe it in Tertullian, Cyprian, Optatus, and Augustin.
Nor do several Persons only differ herein amongst themselves, but we may see in divers instances, one and the same Person express this usage variously; whenas, he that is not circumscribed by others, nor will be imposed on by the imperious, is constant to himself, many times, and varies not in the use of as many, or more Words, than this Form consisted of; and so it is represented by Cyprian, Chrysostom, Jerome, Augustin, Ambrose, Origen.
Nor do several Persons only differ herein amongst themselves, but we may see in divers instances, one and the same Person express this usage variously; whenas, he that is not circumscribed by others, nor will be imposed on by the imperious, is constant to himself, many times, and varies not in the use of as many, or more Words, than this Form consisted of; and so it is represented by Cyprian, Chrysostom, Jerom, Augustin, Ambrose, Origen.
Now, if in so short a sentence as this, and that universally used in some terms or other, with a general harmony as to the sense, and wherein also there is nothing of Prayer, and so none of that ⟨p. 109⟩reason which there is for freedom in Praying, they were not limited, nor did tie themselves to a Set of Words: Who can believe they were, or would have suffered themselves to be confined to an unvariable Form of words, in Praying at Baptism?
Now, if in so short a sentence as this, and that universally used in some terms or other, with a general harmony as to the sense, and wherein also there is nothing of Prayer, and so none of that ⟨p. 109⟩reason which there is for freedom in Praying, they were not limited, nor did tie themselves to a Sett of Words: Who can believe they were, or would have suffered themselves to be confined to an unvariable Form of words, in Praying at Baptism?
And that there were none limited to any Forms of Prayer, is made evident, more directly by that of Basil, lib. de Spir. Sanc. cap. 27. where, mentioning the several Prayers used in Baptizing, he declares there were none of them to be found in writing, [Greek or Hebrew], p. 271. We bless the Water in Baptism, and the Oil used in Unction, and the Party also Baptized; but out of what Writings? They had no Prayers for these severals, in or before his times, written; none found, none set down in writing; and how there could be prescribed Forms of Prayer, and yet no Prayers in writing, is not intelligible. There were no writings enjoining them, That Prayers should be used for these purposes; much less therefore, what Prayers should be made use of, or in what Form of Words. For where the existence of a thing is not supposed, there's no giving rules for the mode of it, amongst those who are regulated by reason. They had then no Rules nor Prescriptions in Scripture, or Councils, or Fathers, or any Church Liturgies, for the use of such Prayers (much less for the Words of them) [Greek or Hebrew] reaches all. There was nothing for them in his time, but [Greek or Hebrew], silent and secret Tradition, in opposition to ([Greek or Hebrew]) what is iWritten; ⟨p. 110⟩which is utterly exclusive of, and inconsistent with any such Rules or Prescriptions, and so quite clears the Church for all such prescribed Forms in Baptism, in all Ages till that day. And clear of them it was long after; for,
And that there were none limited to any Forms of Prayer, is made evident, more directly by that of Basil, lib. de Spir. Sanc. cap. 27. where, mentioning the several Prayers used in Baptizing, he declares there were none of them to be found in writing, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, p. 271. We bless the Water in Baptism, and the Oyl used in Ʋnction, and the Party also Baptized; but out of what Writings? They had no Prayers for these severals, in or before his times, written; none found, none set down in writing; and how there could be prescribed Forms of Prayer, and yet no Prayers in writing, is not intelligible. There were no writings injoyning them, That Prayers should be used for these purposes; much less therefore, what Prayers should be made use of, or in what Form of Words. For where the existence of a thing is not supposed, there's no giving rules for the mode of it, amongst those who are regulated by reason. They had then no Rules nor Prescriptions in Scripture, or Councils, or Fathers, or any Church Liturgies, for the use of such Prayers (much less for the Words of them) 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 reaches all. There was nothing for them in his time, but 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, silent and secret Tradition, in opposition to (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) what is iWritten; ⟨p. 110⟩which is utterly exclusive of, and inconsistent with any such Rules or Prescriptions, and so quite clears the Church for all such prescribed Forms in Baptism, in all Ages till that day. And clear of them it was long after; for,
iDuobus modis dici posse observationem aliquam esse scriptam: id enim scriptum cum ab aliquo vel scripta lege suisse praescriptum (qui proprius est & usitatus horum verborum sensus) vel tantum in scripto libro commemoratum, Dall. de pseudep. p. 334. He takes Basil in the former sense, ibid. Ob. But by Writings Basil may understand the Scriptures only. Ans. His words plainly deny it of all Writings, and not of the Scripture only, vid. Dall. p. 334. He alleges many expressions of Basil in the same place, concluding, Ex quibus vel caecus videt, qua ista accepta erant, Traditionem, Basilium non quibusdam, sed quibusvis; non canonicis, sed omnibus omnino libris opponere, ibid.Duobus modis dici posse observationem aliquam esse scriptam: id enim scriptum cum ab aliquo vel scripta lege suisse praescriptum (qui proprius est & usitatus horum verborum sensus) vel tantum in scripto libro commemoratum, Dall. de pseudep. p. 334. He takes Basil in the former sense, ibid. Ob. But by Writings Basil may understand the Scriptures only. Ans. His words plainly deny it of all Writings, and not of the Scripture only, vid. Dall. p. 334. He alledges many expressions of Basil in the same place, concluding, Ex quibus vel caecus videt, qua ista accepta erant, Traditionem, Basilium non quibusdam, sed quibusvis; non canonicis, sed omnibus omnino libris opponere, ibid.
The Impostor, kwho forged these Constitutions, under the name of Clemens, many Hundred years after the Apostles, and one Age at least after Basil, tho' he set down Prayers for the Baptismal ⟨p. 111⟩Office, yet he ties none to those Forms (no not when he pretends they were of the Apostles composing) nor to any other; but leaves all at liberty to Pray as they saw good, only to the same effect he would have them Pray. He requires not, that they should use those Prayers (of his) but such Prayers with a [Greek or Hebrew], his words are, l. 7. c. 45. [Greek or Hebrew]. For if some such Prayer be not made by the Godly Minister at each of these, he that is to be Baptized, goes into the Water only as the Jews, and parts with only the Impurity of the Body, not the Impurity of the Soul.
The Impostor, kwho forged these Constitutions, under the name of Clemens, many Hundred years after the Apostles, and one Age atleast after Basil, tho' he set down Prayers for the Baptismal ⟨p. 111⟩Office, yet he ties none to those Forms (no not when he pretends they were of the Apostles composing) nor to any other; but leaves all at liberty to Pray as they saw good, only to the same effect he would have them Pray. He requires not, that they should use those Prayers (of his) but such Prayers with a 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, his words are, l. 7. c. 45. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. For if some such Prayer be not made by the Godly Minister at each of these, he that is to be Baptized, goes into the Water only as the Jews, and parts with only the Impurity of the Body, not the Impurity of the Soul.
kOb. Cook, p. 123. And others deny the latter part of this Book to be Basil's. Ans. The generality of Protestant writers do not question it, Chamier, Casaubon, Dalleus. Mr. Cook thinks it was writ by one living after Meletius, who survived Basil, and so after Basil's time. The later he lived, the less Ancient will prescribed Forms appear to be by his Testimony, which in this cannot be suspected; who will think him so impudent to affirm, what every one knew to be false? B. Usher inclines to think, the interpolations of the six Ancient Epistles ascribed to Ignatius, with the six latter, and also Clemens Constitutions did ex eadem officina prodire, and yet the former not extant before the sixth Age; and therefore the Constitutions are elder, in Dallaeus, de supposit. Ign. l. 2. c. 2. p. 237. cum 232, 233. After the Prayers in Baptism, in reference to the Oil and Water, and Chrism, c. 43, 44, 45. l. 7. having said, c. 43. [Greek or Hebrew], he adds, c. 45. [Greek or Hebrew], haec atque alia his consentanea dicat, [Greek or Hebrew], &c. For the Catechumens, [Greek or Hebrew], some such, hujusmodi benediction, l. 8. c. 16. med. For the penitents, [Greek or Hebrew], in some such manner, in hunc modum, cap. 8. fin. In the blessing of Water and Oil, [Greek or Hebrew], c. 29. l. 8. [Greek or Hebrew], l. 7. c. 26. pro primitiis collatis, [Greek or Hebrew], l. 8. c. 39. pro mortuis [Greek or Hebrew], l. 8. c. 41. post sumptionem Eucharistiae, [Greek or Hebrew], l. 7. c. 27. [Greek or Hebrew], l. 7. c. 28. [Greek or Hebrew], pro Eucharistia quidem in hunc modum, l. 7. c. 26. And by these instances, when he calls for Prayer or Praise, with [Greek or Hebrew], or [Greek or Hebrew], or [Greek or Hebrew], or the like; we have warrant to understand [Greek or Hebrew], or [Greek or Hebrew], or [Greek or Hebrew], and that such liberty is allowed.Ob. Cook, p. 123. And others deny the latter part of this Book to be Basil's. Ans. The generality of Protestant writers do not question it, Chamier, Casaubon, Dalleus. Mr. Cook thinks it was writ by one living after Meletius, who survived Basil, and so after Basil's time. The later he lived, the less Antient will prescribed Forms appear to be by his Testimony, which in this cannot be suspected; who will think him so impudent to affirm, what every one knew to be false? B. Usher inclines to think, the interpolations of the six Antient Epistles ascribed to Ignatius, with the six latter, and also Clemens Constitutions did ex eadem officina prodire, and yet the former not extant before the sixth Age; and therefore the Constitutions are elder, in Dallaeus, de supposit. Ign. l. 2. c. 2. p. 237. cum 232, 233. After the Prayers in Baptism, in reference to the Oyl and Water, and Chrism, c. 43, 44, 45. l. 7. having said, c. 43. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, he adds, c. 45. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, haec atque alia his consentanea dicat, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, &c. For the Catechumens, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, some such, hujusmodi benedictione, l. 8. c. 16. med. For the penitents, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, in some such manner, in hunc modum, cap. 8. fin. In the blessing of Water and Oyl, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, c. 29. l. 8. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, l. 7. c. 26. pro primitiis collatis, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, l. 8. c. 39. pro mortuis 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, l. 8. c. 41. post sumptionem Eucharistiae, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, l. 7. c. 27. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, l. 7. c. 28. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, pro Eucharistia quidem in hunc modum, l. 7. c. 26. And by these instances, when he calls for Prayer or Praise, with 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, or 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, or the like; we have warrant to understand 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, or , or , and that such liberty is allowed.
By which we may discern, what was the freedom, as to Prayer at Baptism (and consequently elsewhere) in those times when he writ (probably about the latter end of the fifth, or the beginning of the sixth Age) when Forms through necessity were growing more common. Prayers to the same effect ⟨p. 112⟩would then serve the turn, as they now serve the Reformed Churches. He that appeared to the World about that time, in the visor of Apostolical lAuthority, would not by virtue thereof presume to tie any, in administering Baptism, strictly to one Form, any one Form of Words; No, not to those Words, which he would have them believe, were formed by the Apostles themselves. The Apostles, as he personates them, gave liberty to wave their own supposed Forms, and think it well enough, if Prayers to the same purpose be used instead thereof. In all probability, if this Actor had laid his Scene in places and times, where more restraint had been tolerable, he would have represented it otherwise.
By which we may discern, what was the freedom, as to Prayer at Baptism (and consequently elsewhere) in those times when he writ (probably about the latter end of the fifth, or the beginning of the sixth Age) when Forms through necessity were growing more common. Prayers to the same effect ⟨p. 112⟩would then serve the turn, as they now serve the Reformed Churches. He that appeared to the World about that time, in the vizard of Apostolical lAuthority, would not by vertue thereof presume to tie any, in administring Baptism, strictly to one Form, any one Form of Words; No, not to those Words, which he would have them believe, were formed by the Apostles themselves. The Apostles, as he personates them, gave liberty to wave their own supposed Forms, and think it well enough, if Prayers to the same purpose be used instead thereof. In all probability, if this Actor had laid his Scene in places and times, where more restraint had been tolerable, he would have represented it otherwise.
lWhere he presumes to say, [Greek or Hebrew], l. 8. c. 15.Where he presumes to say, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, l. 8. c. 15.
But there needs no other evidence, for this liberty in Baptismal Prayers, to any who are willing to see, than that in Augustin, de Bapt. contra Donat. l. 6. c. 25. where, examining the Allegations of the several Bishops in the Council under Cyprian, to Sedatus of Tuburbis, who pleads thus for the Rebaptizing of those Baptized by Heretics; in quantum aqua, sacerdotis prece, in ecclesia sanctificata abluit peccata, in tantum Haeretico sermone, velut cancere infecta, cumulat peccata: As the Water, by the Prayer of the Priest, in the Church is Sanctified to the washing away of sin; so by an Heretical Prayer, as by a Cancer, it is infected, to the increasing of sin.
But there needs no other evidence, for this liberty in Baptismal Prayers, to any who are willing to see, than that in Augustin, de Bapt. contra Donat. l. 6. c. 25. where, examining the Allegations of the several Bishops in the Council under Cyprian, to Sedatus of Tuburbis, who pleads thus for the Rebaptizing of those Baptized by Hereticks; in quantum aqua, sacerdotis prece, in ecclesia sanctificata abluit peccata, in tantum Haeretico sermone, velut cancere infecta, cumulat peccata: As the Water, by the Prayer of the Priest, in the Church is Sanctified to the washing away of sin; so by an Heretical Prayer, as by a Cancer, it is infected, to the increasing of sin.
Augustin Answers, Si non sanctificatur aqua, cum aliqua erroris verba per imperitiam precator effundit, multi non solum mali, set etiam boni fratres in ecclesia ⟨p. 113⟩non sanctificant aquam. If the Water be not Sanctified when he that Prays, through unskilfulness, utters some erroneous words; then, not only many evil, but good Brethren, in the Church do not sanctify the Water. Multorum enim preces emendantur quotidie, si doctioribus fuerint recitatae, & multa in iis reperiuntur contra Catholicam fidem. For the Prayers of many are daily amended, if they be recited to the more Learned, and many things are found in them contrary to the Catholic Faith; (they were vitiosae preces, & in quibus aliquid perversum, as he afterwards.) Now such prayers cannot be supposed to have been any common Forms, commanded, or used, much less prescribed by the Church. The course taken to redress this, was not a total prohibition of the Prayers they had chosen; nor the tying of such Ministers to the use of any common Form; no nor the commending of any such to their use: But (what divers Synods (of which before) had decreed) the Prayers, which such indiscreet persons made choice of, being recited to the more learned, were by them amended, and the errors being left out, they are left to use them still, (for the amending of them cannot be otherwise interpreted, than in order to future use:) And this course, as it is inconsistent with the imposition of any set Forms, so it argues forcibly, the Churches then had not in the administration of Baptism, so much as any common Form in free use; otherwise, instead of daily trouble to others and themselves, about correcting their very faulty Prayers; Why are not persons so intolerably indiscreet (who could not discern when a Prayer was Heretical) so much as advised to make use of the common Form? And finally, under what restraint ⟨p. 114⟩can any fancy the more discreet and learned to have been in Baptizing; when the weakest and most imprudent had so much liberty therein? Nothing needs be more manifest, than that neither the prudent nor indiscreet, were then confined to prescribed Forms in the Ministration of Baptism.
Augustin Answers, Si non sanctificatur aqua, cum aliqua erroris verba per imperitiam precator effundit, multi non solum mali, set etiam boni fratres in ecclesia ⟨p. 113⟩non sanctificant aquam. If the Water be not Sanctified when he that Prayes, through unskilfullness, utters some erroneous words; then, not only many evil, but good Brethren, in the Church do not sanctifie the Water. Multorum enim preces emendantur quotidie, si doctioribus fuerint recitatae, & multa in iis reperiuntur contra Catholicam fidem. For the Prayers of many are daily amended, if they be recited to the more Learned, and many things are found in them contrary to the Catholick Faith; (they were vitiosae preces, & in quibus aliquid perversum, as he afterwards.) Now such prayers cannot be supposed to have been any common Forms, commanded, or used, much less prescribed by the Church. The course taken to redress this, was not a total prohibition of the Prayers they had chosen; nor the tying of such Ministers to the use of any common Form; no nor the commending of any such to their use: But (what divers Synods (of which before) had decreed) the Prayers, which such indiscreet persons made choice of, being recited to the more learned, were by them amended, and the errors being left out, they are left to use them still, (for the amending of them cannot be otherwise interpreted, than in order to future use:) And this course, as it is inconsistent with the imposition of any set Forms, so it argues forcibly, the Churches then had not in the administration of Baptism, so much as any common Form in free use; otherwise, instead of daily trouble to others and themselves, about correcting their very faulty Prayers; Why are not persons so intolerably indiscreet (who could not discern when a Prayer was Heretical) so much as advised to make use of the common Form? And finally, under what restraint ⟨p. 114⟩can any fancy the more discreet and learned to have been in Baptizing; when the weakest and most imprudent had so much liberty therein? Nothing needs be more manifest, than that neither the prudent nor indiscreet, were then confined to prescribed Forms in the Ministration of Baptism.
And thus we have made it sufficiently evident, that in the Ancient Church, the order for Administering the Sacraments (the Prayers especially used in their Consecration) were not prescribed; nor the Administrators thereof under any such restraint, as later and worse times thought fit for them. I might endeavour to give the like satisfaction concerning other parts of Worship, which were Administered by Prayers; and might do it now with more ease than this already done. But it is not needful, since those, who show the greatest passion for the Forms in question, affirm, that in the Sacraments they were and are most necessary, and were first there used; and so must acknowledge, that when they were not in use there, they were no where used, nor any where counted needful: And besides, this Discourse grows long, (and so may be tedious) beyond what I expected or designed. I will therefore only add some few testimonies, which give evidence against such Forms in general, and will reach the particulars, as therein involved; easing my self and others thereby of a tedious and superfluous labour.
And thus we have made it sufficiently evident, that in the Antient Church, the order for Administring the Sacraments (the Prayers especially used in their Consecration) were not prescribed; nor the Administrators thereof under any such restraint, as later and worse times thought fit for them. I might indeavour to give the like satisfaction concerning other parts of Worship, which were Administred by Prayers; and might do it now with more ease than this already done. But it is not needful, since those, who shew the greatest passion for the Forms in question, affirm, that in the Sacraments they were and are most necessary, and were first there used; and so must acknowledge, that when they were not in use there, they were no where used, nor any where counted needful: And besides, this Discourse grows long, (and so may be tedious) beyond what I expected or designed. I will therefore only add some few testimonies, which give evidence against such Forms in general, and will reach the particulars, as therein involved; easing my self and others thereby of a tedious and superfluous labour.
Begin we with Justin Martyr, one of the first Writers left us of unquestioned credit, after the Apostles times: Who, Apol. 2. p. 139. hath these words, [Greek or Hebrew] ⟨p. 115⟩[Greek or Hebrew]. We are not Atheists since we worship the Maker of all things, affirming, as we are taught, that he hath no need of Blood, Drink-offerings, or Incense; in all our Oblations, with Prayer and Thanksgiving, according to our ability praising him. In his time, they Prayed and gave Thanks according to their ability. Now certainly, the1 abilities of the Pastors, at least, of those times, reached further without stretching, than the reading or reciting of some Prayers, composed for them by others. They were persons ordinarily of greatest abilities amongst the Christians. When ordinary Christians were superior to the Pastors of after times, they wanted not the knowledge of Divine things, nor the sense of their Spiritual condition, or their Peoples, nor a faculty to express tolerably what they knew and felt. They were not besotted by intemperance, nor had lost the use of their faculties for want of exercise, nor were their gifts shrivelled up by a curse, because they did not employ them: They had ability to frame their own Prayers, as well as to make their own Sermons; and if they confined themselves to Prayers made by others, they did not give Thanks and Pray, as the Holy Martyr says they did, [Greek or Hebrew], according to their ability, or as they were able. The phrase hath been sufficiently vindicated before; but because it here occurs again, let this be added for further satisfaction. It is said, that it denotes not the exercise of abilities for Prayer, but earnestness in Praying, neither less nor more: But this is only said, without any proof, without any instance where it is so taken, either in Justin Martyr, or any other. ⟨p. 116⟩The best way to discern the import of it, will be to observe, how this and other of the same signification are used commonly in this or other Authors. Now Five hundred instances might be produced, wherein this expression, and others of the same import, do clearly denote the exercise of abilities for the work, to which they are applied. I will but give a taste hereof in a like case, preaching or writing, pastoral works, as Prayer is.
Begin we with Justin Martyr, one of the first Writers left us of unquestioned credit, after the Apostles times: Who, Apol. 2. p. 139. hath these words, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉⟨p. 115⟩〈non-Latin alphabet〉. We are not Atheists since we worship the Maker of all things, affirming, as we are taught, that he hath no need of Blood, Drink-offerings, or Incense; in all our Oblations, with Prayer and Thanksgiving, according to our ability praising him. In his time, they Prayed and gave Thanks according to their ability. Now certainly, the1 abilities of the Pastors, at least, of those times, reached further without stretching, than the reading or reciting of some Prayers, composed for them by others. They were persons ordinarily of greatest abilities amongst the Christians. When ordinary Christians were superiour to the Pastors of after times, they wanted not the knowledge of Divine things, nor the sense of their Spiritual condition, or their Peoples, nor a faculty to express tolerably what they knew and felt. They were not besotted by intemperance, nor had lost the use of their faculties for want of exercise, nor were their gifts shrivled up by a curse, because they did not imploy them: They had ability to frame their own Prayers, as well as to make their own Sermons; and if they confined themselves to Prayers made by others, they did not give Thanks and Pray, as the Holy Martyr says they did, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, according to their ability, or as they were able. The phrase hath been sufficiently vindicated before; but because it here occurs again, let this be added for further satisfaction. It is said, that it denotes not the exercise of abilities for Prayer, but earnestness in Praying, neither less nor more: But this is only said, without any proof, without any instance where it is so taken, either in Justin Martyr, or any other. ⟨p. 116⟩The best way to discern the import of it, will be to observe, how this and other of the same signification are used commonly in this or other Authors. Now Five hundred instances might be produced, wherein this expression, and others of the same import, do clearly denote the exercise of abilities for the work, to which they are applied. I will but give a taste hereof in a like case, preaching or writing, pastoral works, as Prayer is.
In Justin Martyr, where he says, they did mexhort the Brethren [Greek or Hebrew], and when he tells Trypho he would make a collection of all the places of Scripture which concerned the millennium, he would make a ncollection [Greek or Hebrew]. In Origen, when he says, the Christians instructed omany [Greek or Hebrew], and what Celsus alleged he would examine [Greek or Hebrew]. So in pEusebius, when he tells us, the Bishops made panegyrical Orations [Greek or Hebrew], & de vit. Const. l. 4. c. 29. Likewise in Basil, when he speaks of Praising Gordius [Greek or Hebrew], forgetting his own qweakness, ⟨p. 117⟩and says, he will explain rthe words of the Apostle [Greek or Hebrew], and that the impiety (he is mentioning) was elsewhere refuted [Greek or Hebrew], and that he had preached the day before [Greek or Hebrew]. Also in sChrysostom, when he says it was necessary he should [Greek or Hebrew], discourse of Prayer; and frequently telsewhere.
In Justin Martyr, where he says, they did mexhort the Brethren 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and when he tells Trypho he would make a collection of all the places of Scripture which concerned the millennium, he would make a ncollection 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. In Origen, when he says, the Christians instructed omany 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and what Celsus alledged he would examine 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. So in pEusebius, when he tells us, the Bishops made panegyrical Orations 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, & de vit. Const. l. 4. c. 29. Likewise in Basil, when he speaks of Praising Gordius 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, forgetting his own qweakness, ⟨p. 117⟩and says, he will explain rthe words of the Apostle 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and that the impiety (he is mentioning) was elsewhere refuted 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and that he had preached the day before 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Also in sChrysostom, when he says it was necessary he should 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, discourse of Prayer; and frequently telsewhere.
m[Greek or Hebrew], &c. Apol. 2. p. 157.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, &c. Apol. 2. p. 157.
n[Greek or Hebrew], Dialog. cum Tryphon. p. 88. edit. Rob. Steph. Lutet. an. 1551.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Dialog. cum Tryphon. p. 88. edit. Rob. Steph. Lutet. an. 1551.
o[Greek or Hebrew], contra Cels. l. 8. p. 428. [Greek or Hebrew], id. ibid. p. 395. vid. p. 409, 410, 411. edit. Cantabr. an. 1656.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, contra Cels. l. 8. p. 428. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, id. ibid. p. 395. vid. p. 409, 410, 411. edit. Cantabr. an. 1656.
p[Greek or Hebrew], Hist. l. 8. c. 3. vid. vit. Const. l. 4. c. 29. infra.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Hist. l. 8. c. 3. vid. vit. Const. l. 4. c. 29. infra.
q[Greek or Hebrew], Homil. in Gord. p. 204. edit. Basil. an. 1551.〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Homil. in Gord. p. 204. edit. Basil. an. 1551.
r[Greek or Hebrew]. p. 142. [Greek or Hebrew], lib. de Sp. Sancto, c. 17. p. 264. Preached [Greek or Hebrew], Hexaem. hom. 3. initio.〈non-Latin alphabet〉. p. 142. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, lib. de Sp. Sancto, c. 17. p. 264. Preached 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Hexaem. hom. 3. initio.
s[Greek or Hebrew], Tom. 6. p. 756. edit. Savil. & in Philip. Hom. 6. p. 34. in 2 Tim. p. 346. & Tom. 1. in Gen. p. 165. Hom. 17. initio. fin. Hom. 17. Hom. 25. Hom. 32. Hom. 48. Hom. 49, 117, 183, 254, 306, 452, 459, &c. [Greek or Hebrew], 306. Hom. 38.
It is evident, that in these passages, the phrases signify, they used their own abilities, judgment, invention, expressions; in preaching, expounding, disputing, &c. And it would not be imagined, but that they denote the same when applied to Prayer, in Justin Martyr and others, had not custom settled another mode of Praying than was used in those times, when abilities to Pray were counted a qualification as requisite for a Pastor, as ability to Preach; and more thought necessary to accomplish a Minister for public Prayer (so great a part of his work) than a Child is capable of.
It is evident, that in these passages, the phrases signifie, they used their own abilities, judgment, invention, expressions; in preaching, expounding, disputing, &c. And it would not be imagined, but that they denote the same when applyed to Prayer, in Justin Martyr and others, had not custom setled another mode of Praying than was used in those times, when abilities to Pray were counted a qualification as requisite for a Pastor, as ability to Preach; and more thought necessary to accomplish a Minister for publick Prayer (so great a part of his work) than a Child is capable of.
Who ever imagined, that by writing [Greek or Hebrew], or pro viribus, they meant no more, than the transcribing another man's Discourse; or by expounding or preaching [Greek or Hebrew], &c. no more was to be understood, than their reading or reciting another mans Sermon, &c. with what earnestness soever? This would be no better, than to offer plain violence to their Words, and unpardonable injury to the Authors. And why is it not as intolerable, when they speak of Praying [Greek or Hebrew], to say they meant no more, than their reading or rehearsing another mans Prayers with all earnestness; let those who are not [Greek or Hebrew], judge.
Who ever imagined, that by writing 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, or pro viribus, they meant no more, than the transcribing another man's Discourse; or by expounding or preaching 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, &c. no more was to be understood, than their reading or reciting another mans Sermon, &c. with what earnestness soever? This would be no better, than to offer plain violence to their Words, and unpardonable injury to the Authors. And why is it not as intolerable, when they speak of Praying 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, to say they meant no more, than their reading or rehearsing another mans Prayers with all earnestness; let those who are not 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, judge.
Nay, it cannot be denied, but these phrases do sometimes denote, when applied to Prayer or Thanksgiving, the Exercise of personal abilities for Prayer; as when Chrysostom tells us, in Gen. Hom. 26. that Noah gave Thanks [Greek or Hebrew], (sure it was in no Form composed ⟨p. 119⟩for him by another) and then exhorts to imitate him; and in the application shows how, viz. taking account every day and hour, not only of Mercies common to others, but particular and personal; yea and those which we observe not, [Greek or Hebrew]. (for all this could not be done in a stated Form) [Greek or Hebrew] p. 202. he adds, God made us rational, [Greek or Hebrew], therefore he gave us faculties, Souls and Tongues, [Greek or Hebrew], that he might be sensible of his favours, and [Greek or Hebrew], p. 203. And in the next Homily 27. we should endeavour [Greek or Hebrew], having always his benefits in our minds ([Greek or Hebrew] that our memory may be helpful to us therein) tho' they be more than we can recount, [Greek or Hebrew], &c. For who can ([Greek or Hebrew];) reckon up those which we have, those which are promised, and [Greek or Hebrew], those which we meet with every day, (so every day there's new matter of Thanksgiving) then enumerating abundance of particulars, p. 204, 205. and adding still [Greek or Hebrew], they can never be numbered. [Greek or Hebrew]; how can any Tongue of Man express them? [Greek or Hebrew], they transcend all human apprehension; yet will have us notwithstanding, remember, conceive, reckon them up, and express them as we are able, and would have us employ mind, memory, tongue, all faculties, therein, as much as we can: for he adds again after all, we must [Greek or Hebrew], such Thanksgivings are according to the abilities of him who offers them. [Greek or Hebrew] (which I proved before to be the ⟨p. 120⟩same with [Greek or Hebrew]) signifies that which is inconsistent with any confinement to a set Form, by our selves or others.
Nay, it cannot be denied, but these phrases do sometimes denote, when applyed to Prayer or Thanksgiving, the Exercise of personal abilities for Prayer; as when Chrysostom tells us, in Gen. Hom. 26. that Noah gave Thanks 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, (sure it was in no Form composed ⟨p. 119⟩for him by another) and then exhorts to imitate him; and in the application shews how, viz. taking account every day and hour, not only of Mercies common to others, but particular and personal; yea and those which we observe not, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. (for all this could not be done in a stated Form) 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 p. 202. he adds, God made us rational, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, therefore he gave us faculties, Souls and Tongues, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that he might be sensible of his favours, and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, p. 203. And in the next Homily 27. we should endeavour 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, having always his benefits in our minds (〈non-Latin alphabet〉 that our memory may be helpful to us therein) tho' they be more than we can recount, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, &c. For who can (〈non-Latin alphabet〉;) reckon up those which we have, those which are promised, and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, those which we meet with every day, (so every day there's new matter of Thanksgiving) then enumerating abundance of particulars, p. 204, 205. and adding still 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, they can never be numbred. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉; how can any Tongue of Man express them? 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, they transcend all human apprehension; yet will have us notwithstanding, remember, conceive, reckon them up, and express them as we are able, and would have us imploy mind, memory, tongue, all faculties, therein, as much as we can: for he adds again after all, we must 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, such Thanksgivings are according to the abilities of him who offers them. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 (which I proved before to be the ⟨p. 120⟩same with 〈non-Latin alphabet〉) signifies that which is inconsistent with any confinement to a set Form, by our selves or others.
Basil also, giving directions how1 to Pray, premises, That there are two sorts or parts of Prayer, Thanksgiving or Praise of God with self abasement, and petition; then he adviseth to begin with the former, and therein to make choice of Scripture-expressions ([Greek or Hebrew], which it seems was Basil's Formulary) after he has given something by way of Example, he adds [Greek or Hebrew], when thou hast Praised him (with expressions selected) out of the Scriptures, as thou art able (or according to thy ability) the same phrase with [Greek or Hebrew], and [Greek or Hebrew], then begin with self abasement; in which, after thou hast been large ([Greek or Hebrew], p. 555.) then proceed to Petition. There he would have him beware of Praying for the severals he mentions, but to seek that which is prescribed or enjoined; not in any Liturgy (for if there had been such, these directions had been needless, and if they should, and might use no other, ridiculous (yet some Mens fancies are so strong, as to stretch these, even to private Devotions;) but in the Scripture, and the Words of Christ (seek first the Kingdom of God, &c.) [Greek or Hebrew], and will have him careful in any wise, that his whole mind be uintent upon ⟨p. 121⟩God, and him alone, and no where else ([Greek or Hebrew]) which will be very hard for him, who, Praying in public or private, hath his Book to mind.
Basil also, giving directions how1 to Pray, premises, That there are two sorts or parts of Prayer, Thanksgiving or Praise of God with self abasement, and petition; then he adviseth to begin with the former, and therein to make choice of Scripture-expressions (〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which it seems was Basil's Formulary) after he has given something by way of Example, he adds 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, when thou hast Praised him (with expressions selected) out of the Scriptures, as thou art able (or according to thy ability) the same phrase with 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, then begin with self abasement; in which, after thou hast been large (〈non-Latin alphabet〉, p. 555.) then proceed to Petition. There he would have him beware of Praying for the severals he mentions, but to seek that which is prescribed or enjoyned; not in any Liturgy (for if there had been such, these directions had been needless, and if they should, and might use no other, ridiculous (yet some Mens fancies are so strong, as to stretch these, even to private Devotions;) but in the Scripture, and the Words of Christ (seek first the Kingdom of God, &c.) 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and will have him careful in any wise, that his whole mind be uintent upon ⟨p. 121⟩God, and him alone, and no where else (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) which will be very hard for him, who, Praying in publick or private, hath his Book to mind.
1[Greek or Hebrew] cap. 1. p. 554.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 cap. 1. p. 554.
uUt collectis & congregatis intra see sensibus, oret Deum, non •vagetur m•nte & cogitationibus evolet, ut ipsis Dei conspectibus, atque ineffabili illi lumini see intelligat assistemem, ibique orations, & obsecrationes, postulationesque, & gratiarum actions suas profundat, nullius extrinsecus Phantasiae solicitatus imagine, Origen. vid. Dall. de objecto cult. p. 396.Ut collectis & congregatis intra se sensibus, oret Deum, non •vagetur m•nte & cogitationibus evolet, ut ipsis Dei conspectibus, atque ineffabili illi lumini se intelligat assistemem, ibique orationes, & obsecrationes, postulationesque, & gratiarum actiones suas profundat, nullius extrinsecus Phantasiae solicitatus imagine, Origen. vid. Dall. de objecto cult. p. 396.
By this we may also judge, what it is to Pray [Greek or Hebrew], or which is all one [Greek or Hebrew]. And to add no more, it cannot be supposed, that there was any prescribed Form of Prayer, for the Case which Augustin mentions, viz. wA House possessed by the Devil; for the relief of which, he tells us, one of the Presbyters of Hippo Prayed, quantum potuit, a phrase equivalent to [Greek or Hebrew], and therefore it may be presumed, he Prayed there according to his ability. And why [Greek or Hebrew], in Justin Martyr, should not signify the same, as in these forementioned instances, and be rendered according to their abilities, so as their Prayers should be understood to be the product of them; I can discern no reason at all, but because they who deny it, are loth it should be so.
By this we may also judge, what it is to Pray 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, or which is all one 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. And to add no more, it cannot be supposed, that there was any prescribed Form of Prayer, for the Case which Augustin mentions, viz. wA House possessed by the Devil; for the relief of which, he tells us, one of the Presbyters of Hippo Prayed, quantum potuit, a phrase equivalent to 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and therefore it may be presumed, he Prayed there according to his ability. And why 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, in Justin Martyr, should not signifie the same, as in these forementioned instances, and be rendred according to their abilities, so as their Prayers should be understood to be the product of them; I can discern no reason at all, but because they who deny it, are loth it should be so.
wVir Tribunitius Hesperius, qui apud nos est, in territorio Tussalensi, fundum Zabedi appellatum, ubi cum aflictione animalium & servorum suorum, domum suam Spirituum malignorum vim noxiam perpeti comperisset, rogavit nostros, me absente, Presbyteros, ut aliquis eorum illo pergeret, cujus orationibus cederent. Perrexit unus, obtulit ibi sacrificium corporis Christi, orans quantum potuit, ut cessaret illa vexatio, &c. August. de civit. Dei, l. 22. c. 8. p. 686. edit. Lugdun.
Let us proceed; That of Tertullian, Apol. 1. c. 30. sine monitore, quia de pectore oramus, hath ⟨p. 122⟩been pleaded by others, and not without reason. Bishop Hall in Answering it, when he was concerned to be most reserved and cautious, so as to yield nothing, but what the words would extort, grants, The mode of Praying was not then under any superior injunction, and so not prescribed. Bishop Bilson concluded from this passage (before it came into debate by the differing parties) that extemporary Praying was used in Tertullian's time, Christian Subject. Part 4. p. 617. rendering it without any xPrompter, as coming from the free motion of our own Hearts, and ascribing it to the extraordinary gift of Prayer then continued. (How reasonably may be considered elsewhere;) and this shows, it is not for want of evidence in the expression, that this sense of it is since rejected by his followers, but from something else. I doubt not, but if it would have been serviceable another way, there would be no question, but this was Septimius's meaning, the Christians did Pray without any such Prompter, as the Heathen, because their hearts were their Prompters: or, as Bishop Bilson, because they Pray as their hearts move them. Prayers suggested to the Heathen by their Monitors, were suggested to the Christians by their own hearts; they had not their Petitions out of a writing, but out of their own Breasts.
Let us proceed; That of Tertullian, Apol. 1. c. 30. sine monitore, quia de pectore oramus, hath ⟨p. 122⟩been pleaded by others, and not without reason. Bishop Hall in Answering it, when he was concern'd to be most reserved and cautious, so as to yield nothing, but what the words would extort, grants, The mode of Praying was not then under any superiour injunction, and so not prescribed. Bishop Bilson concluded from this passage (before it came into debate by the differing parties) that extemporary Praying was used in Tertullian's time, Christian Subject. Part 4. p. 617. rendering it without any xPrompter, as coming from the free motion of our own Hearts, and ascribing it to the extraordinary gift of Prayer then continued. (How reasonably may be considered elsewhere;) and this shews, it is not for want of evidence in the expression, that this sense of it is since rejected by his followers, but from something else. I doubt not, but if it would have been serviceable another way, there would be no question, but this was Septimius's meaning, the Christians did Pray without any such Prompter, as the Heathen, because their hearts were their Prompters: or, as Bishop Bilson, because they Pray as their hearts move them. Prayers suggested to the Heathen by their Monitors, were suggested to the Christians by their own hearts; they had not their Petitions out of a writing, but out of their own Breasts.
xSine monitor, not being urged by any superior injunction.Sine monitore, not being urged by any superiour injunction.
The Gentiles Monitor, as Rigaltius on the place observes, did praeire preces de scripto. Amongst the Greeks, their Prayers were read out of a Book, as appears by Apuleius, describing a great solemnity ⟨p. 123⟩amongst them, where their Monitor, whom they called yGrammatea, from a high Pulpit, de libro fausta vota precatus, Prayed out of a Book.
yTunc ex his unus, quem cuncti Gramma•ea dicebant, pro foribus assistens, coetu Pastophorum (quod sacrosancti collegii nomen est) velut in concionem vocato, indidem de sublimi suggestu, de libro, de literis fausta vota, praesatus Apuleius metamorph. l. 11. p. 204.
Amongst the Persians, Pausanias representing the rites of their Pyretheia, as they were used in Hierocaesarea and Hypaepae, brings in the [Greek or Hebrew] z(who was a Priest, a Sacred person amongst them) thus Praying: aHe coming into a place in the Temple, and having laid Wood on the Altar, first puts on his Sacred Habit, and then Prays to some God; and this Prayer he says [Greek or Hebrew], out of a Book.
Amongst the Persians, Pausanias representing the rites of their Pyretheia, as they were used in Hierocaesarea and Hypaepae, brings in the 〈non-Latin alphabet〉z(who was a Priest, a Sacred person amongst them) thus Praying: aHe coming into a place in the Temple, and having laid Wood on the Altar, first puts on his Sacred Habit, and then Prays to some God; and this Prayer he says 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, out of a Book.
z[Greek or Hebrew] in Hesychius, [Greek or Hebrew], Phavorinus.〈non-Latin alphabet〉 in Hesychius, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Phavorinus.
a[Greek or Hebrew], Pausan. lib. 1. Eliacor. Ammianus Marcellinus, Hist. l. 23. c. 8. The Magus by a set Form of Prayer—〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Pausan. lib. 1. Eliacor. Ammianus Marcellinus, Hist. l. 23. c. 8. The Magus by a set Form of Prayer—
For the Romans, Livy tells us, Numa gave them in writing, all that belonged to their Worship; eique (viz. to Marcus the Chief Priest) omnia sacra exscripta exsignataque attribuit, Dec. 1. l. 1. p. 16. Upon special occasions, the Decemviri transcribed their Prayers out of the Sibyls Books, (their extraordinary Ritual) Dec. 5. l. 1. p. 15. Pacem Deorum peti precationibus, quae editae ex fatalibus libris essent. When they were distressed by Hannibal ⟨p. 124⟩sending Fabius's Picture to bDelphos, Apollo Pythius prescribed them a Liturgy in Writing; which he returning, recited out of that Writing; in which was contained, what Gods they should supplicate, and in what mode; and the Senate enjoined an accurate observance of it. When Scipio Aemilianus was cCensor, the Scribe (their Prompter) at a Lustration, reads the usual Prayer, Ex publicis tabulis; Scipio misliking an expression therein, alters it, and orders the alteration to be made in the public Writing, out of which it was to be read; and so reforms their Common Prayer Book.
For the Romans, Livy tells us, Numa gave them in writing, all that belonged to their Worship; eique (viz. to Marcus the Chief Priest) omnia sacra exscripta exsignataque attribuit, Dec. 1. l. 1. p. 16. Upon special occasions, the Decemviri transcribed their Prayers out of the Sibyls Books, (their extraordinary Ritual) Dec. 5. l. 1. p. 15. Pacem Deorum peti precationibus, quae editae ex fatalibus libris essent. When they were distressed by Hannibal ⟨p. 124⟩sending Fabius's Picture to bDelphos, Apollo Pythius prescribed them a Liturgy in Writing; which he returning, recited out of that Writing; in which was contained, what Gods they should supplicate, and in what mode; and the Senate injoyned an accurate observance of it. When Scipio Aemilianus was cCensor, the Scribe (their Prompter) at a Lustration, reads the usual Prayer, Ex publicis tabulis; Scipio misliking an expression therein, alters it, and orders the alteration to be made in the publick Writing, out of which it was to be read; and so reforms their Common Prayer Book.
bQ. Fabius Pictor, Legatus a Delphis Romam rediit, responsumque ex scripto recitavit; Divi quoque in eo erant, quibus, quoque modo supplicaretur. Dec. 3. l. 3. p. 64.
cQui Censor, cum lustrum auderet, inque solito fieri sacrificio, scriba ex publicis tabulis solemn ei precationis carmen praeiret, quo Dii immortales, ut populi Romani res meliores amplioresque facerent, rogabantur: satis inquit bonae ac magnae sunt; itaque precor ut eas perpetuo incolumes fervent. Ac protinus in publicis tabulis, ad hunc modum carmen emendari jussit. Valer. Max. lib. 4. c. 1. p. 191.Qui Censor, cum lustrum auderet, inque solito fieri sacrificio, scriba ex publicis tabulis solenne ei precationis carmen praeiret, quo Dii immortales, ut populi Romani res meliores amplioresque facerent, rogabantur: satis inquit bonae ac magnae sunt; itaque precor ut eas perpetuo incolumes servent. Ac protinus in publicis tabulis, ad hunc modum carmen emendari jussit. Valer. Max. lib. 4. c. 1. p. 191.
Thus were the Devotions of the Heathen regulated; but the Christians, says Tertullian, (describing them in opposition to the Gentiles) had no such Monitor, did need no such Prompter; their Prayers are not de Scripto, but de Pectore. In Answer to this, thus much is granted, That the Christians in those times prayed without Book; and so it is acknowledged, that those who read their public Prayers out of a Book, are therein nothing like the Ancient Christians, but more resemble the Pagans in that mode of Praying, for which Tertullian ⟨p. 125⟩here derides them. This cannot be denied, it seems; yet, which is the only shift left them, de Pectore, they will have to be no more than saying their Prayers by heart.
Thus were the Devotions of the Heathen regulated; but the Christians, says Tertullian, (describing them in opposition to the Gentiles) had no such Monitor, did need no such Prompter; their Prayers are not de Scripto, but de Pectore. In Answer to this, thus much is granted, That the Christians in those times prayed without Book; and so it is acknowledged, that those who read their publick Prayers out of a Book, are therein nothing like the Antient Christians, but more resemble the Pagans in that mode of Praying, for which Tertullian ⟨p. 125⟩here derides them. This cannot be denied, it seems; yet, which is the only shift left them, de Pectore, they will have to be no more than saying their Prayers by heart.
And this supposes, that in those times they had written Liturgies, and were wont to get their Prayers by heart; for which they should produce some expression, or intimation, or show of proof, from some credible Author of that Age, before they take it for granted. I have yet seen no proof of it, and I am confident never shall.
And this supposes, that in those times they had written Liturgies, and were wont to get their Prayers by heart; for which they should produce some expression, or intimation, or shew of proof, from some credible Author of that Age, before they take it for granted. I have yet seen no proof of it, and I am confident never shall.
Certainly, it was a hard task (and required so good a memory, as all cannot be supposed to have had, who were employed therein) to get all the Prayers they then used by heart. Since the Christians then continued, and principally in Prayer, sometimes Nine hours (and this twice every Week) in their dStations; sometimes Twelve ⟨p. 126⟩hours, as at their Fasts, besides what were usual at their Vigils, Festivals, and Lords-days Assemblies, at their Baptizings, Ordinations, reconciling Penitents, and other occasions; all requiring variety of Prayers.
Certainly, it was a hard task (and required so good a memory, as all cannot be supposed to have had, who were imployed therein) to get all the Prayers they then used by heart. Since the Christians then continued, and principally in Prayer, sometimes Nine hours (and this twice every Week) in their dStations; sometimes Twelve ⟨p. 126⟩hours, as at their Fasts, besides what were usual at their Vigils, Festivals, and Lords-days Assemblies, at their Baptizings, Ordinations, reconciling Penitents, and other occasions; all requiring variety of Prayers.
dJam horum conventuum proprius ac praecipuus finis erat oratio, atque deprecatio, unde factum, ut stationes dicerentur, quod [Greek or Hebrew] statio Hebraeis sit oratio. Dall. de jejuniis, l. 4. cap. 5. ex J. Capell. They began at Sun-rising, Statim ab exortu solis. Rigalt. obs. ad Tertull. id. orat. p. 43. Their Stations were continued till 3 Afternoon, [Greek or Hebrew], Epiph. expos. fid. p. 110. others longer, arguunt nos, quod stationes plerumque in vesperam producamus, Tertull. de jejun. c. 14. Their Fasts till 6 Afternoon, [Greek or Hebrew], Basil. de jejun. [Greek or Hebrew]. p. 133. Diebus atque noctibus jugiter & instanter oramus, propitiantes Deum, Cypr. insistamus per totam diem precibus, & oremus. Idem.Jam horum conventuum proprius ac praecipuus finis erat oratio, atque deprecatio, unde factum, ut stationes dicerentur, quod 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 statio Hebraeis sit oratio. Dall. de jejuniis, l. 4. cap. 5. ex J. Capell. They began at Sun-rising, Statim ab exortu solis. Rigalt. obs. ad Tertull. id. orat. p. 43. Their Stations were continued till 3 Afternoon, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Epiph. expos. fid. p. 110. others longer, arguunt nos, quod stationes plerumque in vesperam producamus, Tertull. de jejun. c. 14. Their Fasts till 6 Afternoon, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Basil. de jejun. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. p. 133. Diebus atque noctibus jugiter & instanter oramus, propitiantes Deum, Cypr. insistamus per totam diem precibus, & oremus. Idem.
And who can believe, their Pastors were then limited to written Forms in Praying, when the ordinary sort of Christians were not tied to any Forms at all in Singing? There seems more reason for a restraint in Hymns, than in supplications; and those who are earnest for liberty in the latter, are well enough content to be confined to Scripture-Forms in the former. It's evident by Tertullian, that in his time, Christians had the liberty in their Church-Assemblies, to choose either such Hymns as they collected out of the Scripture, or such as were of their own conception. So he1 tells us, describing their Love-Feasts; at which we are told, the Eucharist was Celebrated, Post aquam manualem, & lumina, ut quisque de Scriptura, vel de proprio ingenio potest, provocatur in medium Deo canere, Apol. cap. 39. 9. And these, if we believe Grotius, extemporary eHymns, and such used by others, both before, and after those times.
1Thornd. Serv. p. 293.
eNon solebant pro re nata extempore hymnos quos [Greek or Hebrew] vocant, effundere Hebraei—nec dubito quin & hoc canendi genus vel praecipue commendat Paulus, Eph. 5. 9. Col. 3. 16. Mansit divis mos in ecclesia vetere, Tertullianus meminit, & Plinius, &c.Non solebant pro re nata extempore hymnos quos 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 vocant, effundere Hebraei—nec dubito quin & hoc canendi genus vel praecipue commendat Paulus, Eph. 5. 9. Col. 3. 16. Mansit diuis mos in ecclesia vetere, Tertullianus meminit, & Plinius, &c.
It is excepted, that Tertullian, in the place we have insisted on, speaks of private Devotions: But if they will have it of private only, any that considers ⟨p. 127⟩the words, will see it evidently mistaken, Illuc suspicientes Christiani, manibus expansis, quia innocuis; capite nudo, quia non erubescimus. He shows Christians were unlike the Pagans, in their mode of Praying, for such reasons, as would not admit them to be alike any where, either in private or public; since they thought themselves concerned to signify, they were more innocent, and less conscious of what was shameful, than the Heathen, as well in public as in private.
It is excepted, that Tertullian, in the place we have insisted on, speaks of private Devotions: But if they will have it of private only, any that considers ⟨p. 127⟩the words, will see it evidently mistaken, Illuc suspicientes Christiani, manibus expansis, quia innocuis; capite nudo, quia non erubescimus. He shews Christians were unlike the Pagans, in their mode of Praying, for such reasons, as would not admit them to be alike any where, either in private or publick; since they thought themselves concerned to signifie, they were more innocent, and less conscious of what was shameful, than the Heathen, as well in publick as in private.
This manner of Praying was continued in the following Age, as is evident in Origen, who declares it both of the Greek and Latin Churches, which divided betwixt them the1 whole Christian World. They Prayed in his time, not only in their own Language, but also according to their ability, [Greek or Hebrew]. The Grecians in Greek, the Romans in Latin; and so every one in his own dialect, Prays to God, and Praises him, as he is able. Precantur Deum, & celebrant pro viribus. The2 most learned and judicious, that have appeared in this Question for prescribed Liturgies, do yield, that if [Greek or Hebrew] in J. Martyr were duly rendered according to his ability, and be of the same import with [Greek or Hebrew], then the Prayers there mentioned were such as we say, viz. the issue of the Administrators abilities, not formed for him, nor imposed on him by others. Now [Greek or Hebrew], in Origen, is exactly correspondent to, and of the very same signification with, [Greek or Hebrew]: nor can it be better rendered than by, according to his ability, or which is all one, as he is able; and therefore, ⟨p. 128⟩that those Prayers mentioned in Origen were such, may be taken for granted; and those also which we find in the same Book, p. 386. where the expression is of the same sense, but comes nearer to the Form and sound of the other, which they yield is for us, [Greek or Hebrew], that one God, and his only Son both in Word and Image, we worship with Prayers, according to our ability, and honours, offering Prayers unto the God of the Universe, by his only Begotten. It is acknowledged, by the most zealous Friends of these Liturgies, that in the Apostolical times, there was a [Greek or Hebrew], an ability or gift of Prayer, enabling those who had it, to conceive their Prayers themselves; and the exercise of this gift or ability, in the New Testament,3 is [Greek or Hebrew], Jude, v. 20. and [Greek or Hebrew], Eph. 6. 18. But this, so expressed, they will have to have been an extraordinary and miraculous gift, as those of healing, prophesying, tongues, &c. Now the former (that there was a gift of Prayer) we acknowledge with them; but the latter (that it was extraordinary and miraculous) should not be granted without proof, being also inconsistent with other principles equally acknowledged, and with those Scriptures too now alleged.
This manner of Praying was continued in the following Age, as is evident in Origen, who declares it both of the Greek and Latin Churches, which divided betwixt them the1 whole Christian World. They Prayed in his time, not only in their own Language, but also according to their ability, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. The Grecians in Greek, the Romans in Latin; and so every one in his own dialect, Prays to God, and Praises him, as he is able. Precantur Deum, & celebrant pro viribus. The2 most learned and judicious, that have appeared in this Question for prescribed Liturgies, do yield, that if 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 in J. Martyr were duly rendred according to his ability, and be of the same import with 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, then the Prayers there mentioned were such as we say, viz. the issue of the Administrators abilities, not formed for him, nor imposed on him by others. Now 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, in Origen, is exactly correspondent to, and of the very same signification with, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: nor can it be better rendered than by, according to his ability, or which is all one, as he is able; and therefore, ⟨p. 128⟩that those Prayers mentioned in Origen were such, may be taken for granted; and those also which we find in the same Book, p. 386. where the expression is of the same sense, but comes nearer to the Form and sound of the other, which they yield is for us, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, that one God, and his only Son both in Word and Image, we worship with Prayers, according to our ability, and honours, offering Prayers unto the God of the Universe, by his only Begotten. It is acknowledged, by the most zealous Friends of these Liturgies, that in the Apostolical times, there was a 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, an ability or gift of Prayer, inabling those who had it, to conceive their Prayers themselves; and the exercise of this gift or ability, in the New Testament,3 is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉,
Not to take notice, that the gift of Prayer is not reckoned amongst those that were miraculous, where we have a particular account of them, Mark ult. 1 Cor. 12. 8, 9, 10. 1 Cor. 14. It is granted by them, that, as all extraordinary1 gifts were not conferred upon any one Person, except the Apostles; so ⟨p. 129⟩no one gift was conferred upon all; this is plain in the Apostle, 1 Cor. 12. 8, 9, 10, 11. particularly this gift of Prayer, is asserted to have been bestowed upon some one of the multitude, [Greek or Hebrew]. So2 Chrysost. (whom alone, amongst the Ancients, they have to allege for it, as an extraordinary grace:) But all the believing Hebrews (all that are sanctified, to whom Jude writ, ver. 1.) are required to exercise this gift: ([Greek or Hebrew]) and all the converted Gentiles at Ephesus to whom Paul writ, are exhorted by him, to exercise it, Eph. 6. 18. (and all other Christians in them, if those Epistles be of general concernment.) Now it could not be their Duty to exercise it, if they had it not; and if they all had it, it was an ordinary gift, and continued to the Church in all Ages. And so Origen, in reference to this gift or ability, might well say, every one Prayed, [Greek or Hebrew], and [Greek or Hebrew], according to his ability: However, he that was able to conceive a Prayer himself, yet made use of Prayers formed by others, did not Pray as he was able.
Not to take notice, that the gift of Prayer is not reckoned amongst those that were miraculous, where we have a particular account of them, Mark ult. 1 Cor. 12. 8, 9, 10. 1 Cor. 14. It is granted by them, that, as all extraordinary1 gifts were not conferred upon any one Person, except the Apostles; so ⟨p. 129⟩no one gift was conferred upon all; this is plain in the Apostle, 1 Cor. 12. 8, 9, 10, 11. particularly this gift of Prayer, is asserted to have been bestowed upon some one of the multitude, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. So2 Chrysost. (whom alone, amongst the Antients, they have to alledge for it, as an extraordinary grace:) But all the believing Hebrews (all that are sanctified, to whom Jude writ, ver. 1.) are required to exercise this gift: (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) and all the converted Gentiles at Ephesus to whom Paul writ, are exhorted by him, to exercise it, Eph. 6. 18. (and all other Christians in them, if those Epistles be of general concernment.) Now it could not be their Duty to exercise it, if they had it not; and if they all had it, it was an ordinary gift, and continued to the Church in all Ages. And so Origen, in reference to this gift or ability, might well say, every one Prayed, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, according to his ability: However, he that was able to conceive a Prayer himself, yet made use of Prayers formed by others, did not Pray as he was able.
Proceed we to the times ffollowing: Basil ⟨p. 130⟩in the beginning of his Tract de Spiritu Sancto, tells Amphilochius, that he lately Praying with the People, and concluding his Prayers2 with a Doxology, used variety of expressions therein; (sometimes to the Father with the Son, together with the Holy Ghost; sometimes by the Son, in the Holy Ghost) and that offence was taken at one mode of his, expressing it, [Greek or Hebrew], cap. 1. p. 248. Hence it appears, Basil was not, would not be limited to the same words, in any the least part of public Prayers, not in one clause, so short a clause, not in the conclusion ⟨p. 131⟩of a Prayer, where those, who vary in other parts, many times agree; not in a Doxology, where, those that are for more liberty elsewhere, can be content with less. He varies in this once and again, in several Prayers, and none of his variations fall in with the usual mode, (to the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Ghost); nor did the fear of offence restrain him from using this liberty.
Proceed we to the times ffollowing: Basil ⟨p. 130⟩in the beginning of his Tract de Spiritu Sancto, tells Amphilochius, that he lately Praying with the People, and concluding his Prayers2 with a Doxology, used variety of expressions therein; (sometimes to the Father with the Son, together with the Holy Ghost; sometimes by the Son, in the Holy Ghost) and that offence was taken at one mode of his, expressing it, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, cap. 1. p. 248. Hence it appears, Basil was not, would not be limited to the same words, in any the least part of publick Prayers, not in one clause, so short a clause, not in the conclusion ⟨p. 131⟩of a Prayer, where those, who vary in other parts, many times agree; not in a Doxology, where, those that are for more liberty elsewhere, can be content with less. He varies in this once and again, in several Prayers, and none of his variations fall in with the usual mode, (to the Father, and the Son, aend the Holy Ghost); nor did the fear of offence restrain him from using this liberty.
fAthanasius was exercised with more conflicts than others: Theodoret calls him elegantly, [Greek or Hebrew]. After many before, he meets with a new incou• ter in Julian's time; of which that Historian gives this account, [Greek or Hebrew], lib. 3. cap. 8. The Devils not able to endure the power of Athanasius's Preaching and Praying; so that they could less bear his Prayer and Preaching, than that of others, and therefore they raised him more troubles than others met with. Now, if his Preaching had been but the Reading of the same Homilies which others Read, who could give a reason from thence, why Satan should not endure it in him, as well as in others? So, if his Praying had but been the Reading of the same Prayers that others did Read, no account can be given, why the Devils should be more troubled at his Praying, than of the rest. The ordinary Deacons or Readers at Alexandria, and elsewhere, could read a Prayer as well as he. Certainly his power in Preaching, was something else, than his reading another Mans Sermons; and was his power in Praying, no more than his reading another Mans Prayers? One would think it could denote no less, than that he had a more powerful (way or) faculty in Preaching and Praying. And if it be said, that this lay only in his more devout or earnest reading, &c. Ans. If the disinterested can be satisfied, that his powerful faculty, in Preaching, was but his fervency in reading other mens Sermons; I shall not contend, but that his powerful faculty in Praying, might be no more, than his devout reading of other mens Prayers. Athanasius himself shows us, that Prayers were not then had from Prayer-Books, and prescribed Forms, when he tells us, mens orationis fons est.Athanasius was exercised with more conflicts than others: Theodoret calls him elegantly, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. After many before, he meets with a new incou• ter in Julian's time; of which that Historian gives this account, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, lib. 3. cap. 8. The Devils not able to indure the power of Athanasius's Preaching and Praying; so that they could less bear his Prayer and Preaching, than that of others, and therefore they raised him more troubles than others met with. Now, if his Preaching had been but the Reading of the same Homilies which others Read, who could give a reason from thence, why Satan should not indure it in him, as well as in others? So, if his Praying had but been the Reading of the same Prayers that others did Read, no account can be given, why the Devils should be more troubled at his Praying, than of the rest. The ordinary Deacons or Readers at Alexandria, and elsewhere, could read a Prayer as well as he. Certainly his power in Preaching, was something else, than his reading another Mans Sermons; and was his power in Praying, no more than his reading another Mans Prayers? One would think it could denote no less, than that he had a more powerful (way or) faculty in Preaching and Praying. And if it be said, that this lay only in his more devout or earnest reading, &c. Ans. If the disinteressed can be satisfied, that his powerful faculty, in Preaching, was but his fervency in reading other mens Sermons; I shall not contend, but that his powerful faculty in Praying, might be no more, than his devout reading of other mens Prayers. Athanasius himself shews us, that Prayers were not then had from Prayer-Books, and prescribed Forms, when he tells us, mens orationis fons est.
Now, if in such circumstances he would not be confined, in the part of a Prayer, to the invariable use of so short a clause, as the half of the Doxology now used; would he be confined ghimself, or confine others to the invariable use of whole Prayers? No, it is hereby evident, his times knew no such bonds; he used expressions, as to his Auditory seemed strange and unusual, which the words of a Common-Prayer Book could not have been.
gQui loquendi arte caeteris hominibus excellere videntur, but not to be reckoned inter illos doctissimos, quorum mens magnarum rerum est exercitata quaestionibus. Discant non contemnere, quos cognoverint morum vitia, quam verborum, amplius devitare, id. ibid. p. 329. His enim maxime utile est nosse, ita esse praeponendas verbis sententias, ut praeponitur animus corpori, id. p. 330. Basil, In Praying publicly, used [Greek or Hebrew], strange or unusual expressions, which could not be the words of a Common-Prayer Book, of ordinary, tho' free use, much less of one prescribed and enjoined to be constantly, and unvariably used. If there had been any such, you will not think, but Basil would have been confined to them; but he is far from it, he would not be limited to the same words.Qui loquendi arte caeteris hominibus excellere videntur, but not to be reckoned inter illos doctissimos, quorum mens magnarum rerum est exercitata quaestionibus. Discant non contemnere, quos cognoverint morum vitia, quam verborum, amplius devitare, id. ibid. p. 329. His enim maxime utile est nosse, ita esse praeponendas verbis sententias, ut praeponitur animus corpori, id. p. 330. Basil, In Praying publickly, used 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, strange or unusual expressions, which could not be the words of a Common-Prayer Book, of ordinary, tho' free use, much less of one prescribed and injoyned to be constantly, and unvariably used. If there had been any such, you will not think, but Basil would have been confined to them; but he is far from it, he would not be limited to the same words.
Augustin, giving directions, how the Catechumens are to be instructed, adviseth the Catechists (Deo gratias particularly) to accommodate themselves to their several capacities; and when they are to ⟨p. 132⟩deal with those of some learning and eloquence, to let them understand, that God minds not so much the expressions, as the inward affection; ita enim non irridebunt, si aliquos Antistites & ministros ecclesiae forte animadverterint, vel cum barbarismis & soloecismis Deum invocare, de Catechiz. rudib. cap. 9. p. 330. Tom. 4. pars poster. So they will not jeer, if perhaps they take notice, that some Bishops and Ministers of the Church, do invocate God with Barbarisms and Solecisms. Prayers, wherein there were Barbarisms and Solecisms, none will imagine them to have been prescribed by the Church; yet such were the Prayers both of Bishops and Ministers, in Austin's time.
Augustin, giving directions, how the Catechumens are to be instructed, adviseth the Catechists (Deo gratias particularly) to accomodate themselves to their several capacities; and when they are to ⟨p. 132⟩deal with those of some learning and eloquence, to let them understand, that God minds not so much the expressions, as the inward affection; ita enim non irridebunt, si aliquos Antistites & ministros ecclesiae forte animadverterint, vel cum barbarismis & soloecismis Deum invocare, de Catechiz. rudib. cap. 9. p. 330. Tom. 4. pars poster. So they will not jeer, if perhaps they take notice, that some Bishops and Ministers of the Church, do invocate God with Barbarisms and Solecisms. Prayers, wherein there were Barbarisms and Solecisms, none will imagin them to have been prescribed by the Church; yet such were the Prayers both of Bishops and Ministers, in Austin's time.
Socrates, who lived in the middle of the Fifth Century, hand whose History reaches an. 439. gives us an account of the variety then used in Prayers, altogether inconsistent with any common ⟨p. 133⟩prescribed Liturgy, l. 5. c. 21. p. 698. [Greek or Hebrew]. Generally, in any place whatsoever, and amongst all (the sorts of) Worshippers, there cannot two be sound agreeing to use the same Prayers. Now where there was diversity of Prayers every where, How could there be the use of one common Liturgy? where there was no [Greek or Hebrew], no agreement or concurrence, in using the same Prayers in any place; How could there be one prescribed model? when there could not be found two, any where, using the same Prayers; Where were they to be found, that used the same Service-Book?
Socrates, who lived in the middle of the Fifth Century, hand whose History reaches an. 439. gives us an account of the variety then used in Prayers, altogether inconsistent with any common ⟨p. 133⟩prescribed Liturgy, l. 5. c. 21. p. 698. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Generally, in any place whatsoever, and amongst all (the sorts of) Worshippers, there cannot two be sound agreeing to use the same Prayers. Now where there was diversity of Prayers every where, How could there be the use of one common Liturgy? where there was no 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, no agreement or concurrence, in using the same Prayers in any place; How could there be one prescribed model? when there could not be found two, any where, using the same Prayers; Where were they to be found, that used the same Service-Book?
hAntonius of Valentia, a Dominican (in the Council of Trent) said that it was plain, by all History, that anciently every Church had her particular Ritual of the Mass, brought in by use, and upon occasion, rather than by deliberation and decree; and that the small Church did follow the Metropolitan, and the greater, which were near. The Roman rite hath been, to gratify the Pope, received in many Provinces, tho' the Rites of many Churches are still most different from it, &c. And that of Rome also hath had great alterations, and the true Roman rite, not that which is now observed by the Priests in that City, &c. Hist. of the Counc. of Trent, l. 6. p. 548, 549. Prayers in end of Ancient Councils not premeditated, but as the Spirit did excite some Bishops. In Trent, not giving way to the extemporary Spirit of any, but repeating it out of a paper, ibid. p. 813. Fid. Augustini retractat. l. 2. c. 20. of varieties in Sacraments, ••c tamen commemorari omnia potuerunt.Ant•nius of Valentia, a Dominican (in the Council of Trent) said that it was plain, by all History, that antiently every Church had her particular Ritual of the Mass, brought in by use, and upon occasion, rather than by deliberation and decree; and that the small Church did follow the Metropolitan, and the greater, which were near. The Roman rite hath been, to gratifie the Pope, received in many Provinces, tho' the Rites of many Churches are still most different from it, &c. And that of Rome also hath had great alterations, and the true Roman rite, not that which is now observed by the Priests in that City, &c. Hist. of the Counc. of Trent, l. 6. p. 548, 549. Prayers in end of Antient Councils not premeditated, but as the Spirit did excite some Bishops. In Trent, not giving way to the extemporary Spirit of any, but repeating it out of a paper, ibid. p. 813. Fid. Augustini retractat. l. 2. c. 20. of varieties in Sacraments, ••c tamen commemorari omnia potuerunt.
For the West, we may understand by Innocent's Epistle to Decentius formerly alleged, how far they were in the same Age, from being confined to one Form of Church-Service; when he tells us, every one celebrated, as pleased him.
For the West, we may understand by Innocent's Epistle to Decentius formerly alledged, how far they were in the same Age, from being confined to one Form of Church-Service; when he tells us, every one celebrated, as pleased him.
And long after this, something of the Ancient liberty is discernible, in the several Countries, which was retained in some of them, even after the imposing Spirit was roused and active. And by the remaining ruins, we may guess what it was, when it stood entire. At the time, when the Fourth Council of Toledo was held, an. 633. the Spanish Churches were not subject (tho' forwarder for such subjection than others) to imposed orders, for one Form of Worship; no not in the Sacraments. Even these in the said Churches, were celebrated1 in various modes, and in some of them unduly; as is expressed in the Preface to that Synod, In sacramentis divinis, quae diverso atque illicito modo in Hispaniarum Ecclesiis celebrantur.
And long after this, something of the Antient liberty is discernable, in the several Countries, which was retained in some of them, even after the imposing Spirit was rouzed and active. And by the remaining ruins, we may guess what it was, when it stood intire. At the time, when the Fourth Council of Toledo was held, an. 633. the Spanish Churches were not subject (tho' forwarder for such subjection than others) to imposed orders, for one Form of Worship; no not in the Sacraments. Even these in the said Churches, were celebrated1 in various modes, and in some of them unduely; as is expressed in the Preface to that Synod, In sacramentis divinis, quae diverso atque illicito modo in Hispaniarum Ecclesiis celebrantur.
In France ithey had Books for public Service, in the Eighth Century; yet were they used at the discretion of those that officiated, who added or left out, what they thought fit; till Charlemagne, in the beginning of the Ninth Age, would have them reformed after the Roman guise; unusquisque pro arbitrio suo vitiaverat, vel addens vel minuens.
In France ithey had Books for publick Service, in the Eighth Century; yet were they used at the discretion of those that officiated, who added or left out, what they thought fit; till Charlemaine, in the beginning of the Ninth Age, would have them reformed after the Roman guise; unusquisque pro arbitrio suo vitiaverat, vel addens vel minuens.
iPercipiens de omnibus civitatibus Franciae Magistros Scholae, antiphonarios eis ad corrigendum tradere, & ab iis discere cantare: correcti sunt ergo Antiphonarii Francorum, quos unusquisque pro arbitrio sua vitiaverat, vel addens vel minuens, & omnes Franciae cantores didicerunt formam Ro•anam, Chron. Engolismense in Morn. de miss. l. 1. c. 8. p. 224.
And in Germany, long after Boniface had been stickling to reduce it to the Roman uniformity, the whole Country was so far from submitting to any one prescribed order of Service, that in one kDiocese there were various modes of administering, particularly in that of Colen. And lBruno, Bishop there in the middle of the Tenth Age, was endeavouring to reform this, as Church matters, in those days, were wont to be reformed; diversitatem sacra peragendi in sua provincia corrigens, ac ut eadem ubique esset ratio constituens.
And in Germany, long after Boniface had been stickling to reduce it to the Roman uniformity, the whole Country was so far from submitting to any one prescribed order of Service, that in one kDiocess there were various modes of administring, particularly in that of Colen. And lBruno, Bishop there in the middle of the Tenth Age, was indeavouring to reform this, as Churchmatters, in those days, were wont to be reformed; diversitatem sacra peragendi in sua provincia corrigens, ac ut eadem ubique esset ratio constituens.
kDecret. Greg. (3. q.) tit. 31. de offic. jud. ord. cap. 14. Quoniam in plerisque partibus intra eandem Civitatem atque Dioecesim, permixti sunt populi diversarum linguarum, habentes sub una fide varios ritus & mores: districte praecipimus, ut Pontifices hujusmodi civitatum five Dioecesium provideant viros idoneos, qui secundum diversitatem rituum & linguarum, divina illis officia ce•ebrent, & ecclesiastica sacramenta ministrent.
lRotger. vit. Brunonis, apud Surium. Oct. 11. obiit an. 965.
And in Ireland, (with which the Britons and Scots symbolized) we showed before, out of the ⟨p. 135⟩great Usher, That till the Twelfth Century, no one general Form of Service was retained; but divers rites and manners of Celebration were observed, till the Roman use was brought in, by the Popes Legates.
And in Ireland, (with which the Britans and Scots symbolized) we shewed before, out of the ⟨p. 135⟩great Ʋsher, That till the Twelfth Century, no one general Form of Service was retained; but divers rites and manners of Celebration were observed, till the Roman use was brought in, by the Popes Legates.
So that all along it is manifest, the uniformity aimed at, in the common prescribed Liturgies, was only the issue and darling of late, dark and degenerate times; an innovation upon the Churches usages, in better times, and an invading of her Ancient Liberty; for which the Bishops of Rome were the greatest Zealots, designing therein the subjection of all other Churches to that of Rome; and gaining thereby, both an acknowledgement of the Papal Authority, from those who submitted to this Yoke, and an advantage of diffusing the Poison of her Superstitions, through the body of the Western Empire, where uniformity in Liturgy and Rituals, became a chief part of the uniform Apostasy of the latter times.
So that all along it is manifest, the uniformity aimed at, in the common prescribed Liturgies, was only the issue and darling of late, dark and degenerate times; an innovation upon the Churches usages, in better times, and an invading of her Antient Liberty; for which the Bishops of Rome were the greatest Zealots, designing therein the subjection of all other Churches to that of Rome; and gaining thereby, both an acknowledgment of the Papal Authority, from those who submitted to this Yoke, and an advantage of diffusing the Poyson of her Superstitions, through the body of the Western Empire, where uniformity in Liturgy and Rituals, became a chief part of the uniform Apostasie of the latter times.
. Hom. 5. p. 122. [Greek or Hebrew], in Joh. Hom. 1. p. 558. Hieronym. Quidam coactius disserunt in Baptismate singulos pactum inire cum Diabolo & dicere, Renuncio tibi, Diabole, & pompae tuae & vitiis tuis, & mundo tuo, qui inmaligno positus est, in
. Tom. 8. p. 270. Secundo post Baptismum gradu, inisti pactum cum adversario tuo, dicens ei, Renuncio tibi Diabole, & seculo tuo, & pompae tuae, & operibus (all. opibus) tuis, Epist. 7. ad Demetriad. p. 63. Abrenunciationem qua praeputiis denudamur, ante oculos collocemus—sic namque dicimus, abrenunciare nos mundo & pompis ejus, Epist. ad Therasiam, de vera Circumcis. Tom. 9. No Writings mentioned the use of any Words whatsoever, any Prayer at all on those occasions, no•e enjoined any set Form of Prayer: But any Words were so far from being enjoined, that there were none so much as set down or mentioned in any Writing.
Origenes, Quid denunciaverit diabolo, non se usurum pompis ejus, & voluptatibus pariturum, in ep. ad Rom. Universis denique aliis Diis & Dominis, Homil. 8. in Exod. Constantius, de se, Renuncians Satanae Pompis & operibus ejus & universis idolis manu factis, credere me in Deum professus sum, in Edict. ad Sylvest. Cyril, Hierosolym. Catech. 1. Myster. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, p. 228, 229. Ephrem. Syrus, Abrenuncio tibi Satan, & cunctis operibus tuis, l. de poenit. c. 5. Basil, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, de Spir. Sanc. cap. 27. no prescription for it. Cyril Alexandrin. Ibi deposuerimus tenebras a mente nostra, & doemoniorum turbis valedixerimus, omnemque ipsorum pompam, & cultum prudentissime respuerimus, consitemur fidem in Patrem, lib. 7. contra Julian. Salvian Massiliens. Abrenuncio, inquis, Diabolo, Pompis, spectaculis & operibus ejus, de provid. lib. 6. p. 197. Quae est enim in baptismo salutari Christianorum prima confessio, nisi ut renunciare se Diabolo, ac pompis ejus, atque spectaculis, & operibus, protestentur? p. 198. Dionysius Areop. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Eccles. Hierarch. The repeating of it singular. Clemens Constit. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, l. 7. c. 41. Justinian. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, c.... l. 33. §. 1. de Episcop. Audient. Tertullian, Sed & aliquanto prius in Ecclesia sub Antistitis manu, contestamur nos renunciare Diabolo, & Pompae, & Angelis ejus, de Coron. Milit. c. 3. Optatus Milevit. Contra nos peccatores (ut vultis) interrogemus alterum Gentilem, an renunciet Diabolo, & credat Deo, &c. & dicat Renuncio & credo, Cohtr. Parmenianum, l. 5. p. 59. Cyprian, Seculo renunciavimus cum Baptizati sumus, Epist. 5. l. 1. Stare illic potuit Dei servus, & loqui, & renunciare Christo, qui jam Diabolo renunciaret & seculo, Serm. de Laps. p. 151. Cujus (mundi) pompis & deliciis jam tunc renunciavimus, cum meliori transgressu ad Dominum venimus, de habit Virgin. p 107. Se carnis concupiscentiis & vitiis renunciasse profitetur, id ibid. Augustin, Quisquis huic aedificio conjungi desiderat, renunciet Diabolo, Pompis & Angelis ejus, de symbol. ad Catechum. l. 3. c. 1. Omissa enim certissima cautione, qua vos abrenunciare omnibus Pompis Diaboli, & omnibus operibus ejus, & omni fornicationi diabolicae, spospondistis, Homil. 3. ad neophytos. Pro ipsis enim respondent, quod abrenuncient Diabolo, Pompis & Operibus ejus, & ideo pactum, quod, cum Christo in Baptismi Sacramento, conscribunt, custodire contendant, nec unquam aliquid de Diaboli pompis, vel mundi istius luxuriosis oblect ationibus concupiscant, de Temp. Serm. 116. Ambrose, Dicens, abrenuncio tibi, Diabole, & Angelis tuis, & operibus tuis & imperiis tuis, Hexam. l. 1. c. 4. Quando te interrogavit Sacerdos; abrenuncias Diabolo, & Operibus suis? quid respondisti? Abrenuncio. Abrenuncias seculo & voluptatibus ejus? quid respondisti? Abrenuncio, de Sacrament. l. 1. c. 2. Quid interrogatus es, recognosce, quid responderis, renunciasti Diabolo & operibus ejus, mundo & luxuriae ejus, lib. de iis qui Myster. initiant. c. 2. Chrysostom, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Homil. 21. ad pop. Antioch. p. 609. Savil. edit. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, in Coloss. 2. Hom. 5. p. 122. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, in Joh. Hom. 1. p. 558. Hieronym. Quidam coactius disserunt in Baptismate singulos pactum inire cum Diabolo & dicere, Renuncio tibi, Diabole, & pompae tuae & vitiis tuis, & mundo tuo, qui inmaligno positus est, in Matth. 5. Tom. 6. p. 6. Confessus es bonam confessionem in Baptismo, renunciando seculo & pompis ejus, in 1 Tim. 6. Tom. 8. p. 270. Secundo post Baptismum gradu, inisti pactum cum adversario tuo, dicens ei, Renuncio tibi Diabole, & seculo tuo, & pompae tuae, & operibus (al. opibus) tuis, Epist. 7. ad Demetriad. p. 63. Abrenunciationem qua praeputiis denudamur, ante oculos collocemus—sic namque dicimus, abrenunciare nos mundo & pompis ejus, Epist. ad Therasiam, de vera Circumcis. Tom. 9. No Writings mentioned the use of any Words whatsoever, any Prayer at all on those occasions, no•e injoyned any set Form of Prayer: But any Words were so far from being injoyned, that there were none so much as set down or mentioned in any Writing.
〈non-Latin alphabet〉
〈non-Latin alphabet〉
〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Tom. 6. p. 756. edit. Savil. & in Philip. Hom. 6. p. 34. in 2 Tim. p. 346. & Tom. 1. in Gen. p. 165. Hom. 17. initio. fin. Hom. 17. Hom. 25. Hom. 32. Hom. 48. Hom. 49, 117, 183, 254, 306, 452, 459, &c. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, 306. Hom. 38.
tAdd that in Cyprian, Propter hoc etiam libellum hunc de bono patientiae quantum valuit nostra mediocritas, permittente & inspirante Domino, conscripsimus, Epist. ad Jubaian. and often, pro nostra mediocritate. And Augustin, De quibus in aliis opusculis, in quantum Domino adjuvante potuimus, satis nos disseruisse meminimus, de peccat. orig. l. 2. c. 34. Et hoc pro viribus ago, contra Cresc. l. 1. c. 9. Si autem ministri assint pro viribus quas eis Dominus subministrat, omnibus subvenitur: alii baptizantur, alii reconciliantur, nulli dominici corporis communione fraudantur, omnes consolantur, aedificantur, exhortantur, ut Deum rogent qui potens est omnia quae timentur averlere, &c. Epist. 180. Honorato, p. 928. edit. Lugduni an. 1561. And that Constantine exhorted his Subjects, [Greek or Hebrew], to lead a pious Life, [Greek or Hebrew]. Athanasius, about to give an account of Man's degeneracy, [Greek or Hebrew], contr. Onules. p. 3. And reciting too some passages of Scripture, [Greek or Hebrew], de natura human. suscept. Tom. 1. p. 465. init. Maximus in Athanas. Tom. 2. says he had confuted Heretics, [Greek or Hebrew], p. 255. Augustin, retract. l. 2. c. 1. in second. libro tractantur caeterae questions, & pro nostra quantulacunque facultate solvuntur, p. 58.Add that in Cyprian, Propter hoc etiam libellum hunc de bono patientiae quantum valuit nostra mediocritas, permittente & inspirante Domino, conscripsimus, Epist. ad Jubaian. and often, pro nostra mediocritate. And Augustin, De quibus in aliis opusculis, in quantum Domino adjuvante potuimus, satis nos disseruisse meminimus, de peccat. orig. l. 2. c. 34. Et hoc pro viribus ago, contra Cresc. l. 1. c. 9. Si autem ministri assint pro viribus quas eis Dominus subministrat, omnibus subvenitur: alii baptizantur, alii reconciliantur, nulli dominici corporis communione fraudantur, omnes consolantur, aedificantur, exhortantur, ut Deum rogent qui potens est omnia quae timentur averlere, &c. Epist. 180. Honorato, p. 928. edit. Lugduni an. 1561. And that Constantine exhorted his Subjects, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, to lead a pious Life, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. Athanasius, about to give an account of Man's degeneracy, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, contr. Onules. p. 3. And reciting too some passages of Scripture, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, de natura human. suscept. Tom. 1. p. 465. init. Maximus in Athanas. Tom. 2. says he had confuted Hereticks, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, p. 255. Augustin, retract. l. 2. c. 1. in secund. libro tractantur caeterae quaestiones, & pro nostra quantulacunque facultate solvuntur, p. 58.
. But this, so expressed, they will have to have been an extraordinary and miraculous gift, as those of healing, prophesying, tongues, &c. Now the former (that there was a gift of Prayer) we acknowledge with them; but the latter (that it was extraordinary and miraculous) should not be granted without proof, being also inconsistent with other principles equally acknowledged, and with those Scriptures too now alledged.