Whether Judas received the Sacrament of the Lords Supper.
pp. 436–46046 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
By this time it appeareth that Mr Prynne hath no such consent of writers of his opinion, or against mine, as he pretendeth.
As for those Ancients cited by Mr Prynne, some of them (as Origen and Cyril) did go upon this great mistake that the sop which Christ gave to Judas, was the Sacrament; which error of theirs is observed by Interpreters upon the place. No marvel that they who thought so, were also of opinion that Judas received the Sacrament of the Lords Supper; for how could they choose to think otherwise, upon that supposition? But now the later Interpreters, yea Mr Prynne himself having taken away that which was the ground of their opinion, their Testimonies will weigh the less in this particular. Chrysostom thinks indeed that Judas received the Sacrament, but he takes it to be no warrant at all for the admission of scandalous persons: for in one and the same Homily, Hom. 83. in Matth. he both tells us of Judas his receiving of the Sacrament, and discourseth at large against the admission of scandalous persons. As for Bernard Mr Prynne doth not cite his words nor quote the place. Oecumenius (in the passage cited by Mr Prynne) saith that the other Apostles and Judas did eat together communi mensa, at a common Table; But he saith not at the Sacrament of the Lords Supper. That which Oecumenius in that place argueth against, is the contempt of the poor in the Church of Corinth, and the secluding of them from the love feasts of the richer sort. Now, saith he, if Christ himself admitted Judas to eat at one and the same Table, with his other Disciples, ought not we much more admit the poor to eat at our Tables? Mr Prynne tells us also that Nazianzen in his Christus patiens agreeth that Judas did receive the Lords Supper together with the other Apostles. I answer, first I find no such thing in that place. Next, those verses so entitled, are thought to be done by some late author, and not by Nazianzen, as Jo. NeW enklaius in his Censure upon them noteth, and giveth reason for it. Cyprians Sermon de ablutione pedum, as it is doubted of whether it be Cyprian's, so the words cited by Mr Prynne do not prove the point in controversy. The other Testimony cited out of Cyprians Sermon de caena Domini, as it is not transcribed ⟨p. 457⟩according to the original, so if Mr Prynne had read all which Cyprian saith in that Sermon against unworthy receivers, peradventure he had not made […] of that testimony.