The Question between M. Prynne & me concerning Judas, much like unto that between Papists and Protestants concerning Peter. Two things premised. 1. That Matthew and Mark mentioning Christs discourse at Table, concerning the Traitor, before the Institution and distribution of the Lords Supper, place it in its proper order, and that Luke placeth it after the Sacrament by an [Greek or Hebrew] or recapitulation: which is proved by •ive reasons. 2. That the story John. 13. concerning Judas and the sop, was neither acted in Bethany two days before the Passover, nor yet after the Institution of the Lords Supper. The first Argument to prove that Judas received not the Lords Supper from Joh. 13. 30. he went out immediately after the sop. Mr Prynnes four answers confuted. His opinion that Christ gave the Sacrament before the common supper, is against both Scripture and Antiquity. Of the word immediately. The second Argument from Christs words at the Sacrament. That which M. Prynne holds, viz. that at that time (when Christ infallibly knew Judas to be lost) he meant conditionally that his body was broken and his blood shed for Judas; confuted by three reasons. The third Argument from the different expressions of Love to the Apostles, with an exception, while Judas was present; without an exception at the Sacrament. M. Prynnes Arguments from Scripture to prove that Judas did receive the Sacrament, ⟨image 26⟩answered. That Judas received the Sacrament, is no indubitable verity as Mr. Prynne calls it, but hath been much controverted both among Fathers, Papists and Protestants. That the Lutherans who are much of M. Prynnes opinion in the point of Judas his receiving of the Lords Supper, that they may the better uphold their Doctrine of the wicked their eating of the true body of Christ, yet are much against his opinion in the point of admitting scandalous persons not Excommunicated to the Sacrament. M. Prynnes bold assertion that all the Ancients except Hilary only, do unanimously accord that Judas received the Lords Supper, without one dissenting voice; disproved as most false, and confuted by the testimonies of Clemens, Dionysius Areopagita, Maximus, Pachymeres, Ammonius Alexandrinus, Tacianus, Innocentius 3. Rupertus Tuitiensis, yea by those very passages of Theophylact, and Victor Antiochenus, cited by himself.
THe Question between M. Prynne & me concerning Iudas, much like unto that between Papists and Protestants concerning Peter. Two things premised. 1. That Matthew and Marke mentioning Christs discourse at Table, concerning the Traytor, before the Institution and distribution of the Lords Supper, place it in its proper order, and that Luke placeth it after the Sacrament by an 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 or recapitulation: which is proved by •ive reasons. 2. That the story Iohn. 13. concerning Iudas and the sop, was neither acted in Bethany two daies before the Passeover, nor yet after the Institution of the Lords Supper. The first Argument to prove that Iudas received not the Lords Supper from Ioh. 13. 30. he went out immediately after the sop. Mr Prynnes foure answers confuted. His opinion that Christ gave the Sacrament before the common supper, is against both Scripture and Antiquity. Of the word immediately. The second Argument from Christs words at the Sacrament. That which M. Prynne holds, viz. that at that time (when Christ infallibly knew Iudas to be lost) he meant conditionally that his body was broken and his blood shed for Iudas; confuted by three reasons. The third Argument from the different expressions of Love to the Apostles, with an exception, while Iudas was present; without an exception at the Sacrament. M. Prynnes Arguments from Scripture to prove that Iudas did receive the Sacrament, ⟨image 26⟩answered. That Iudas received the Sacrament, is no indubitable verity as Mr. Prynne cals it, but hath been much controverted both among Fathers, Papists and Protestants. That the Lutherans who are much of M. Prynnes opinion in the point of Iudas his receiving of the Lords Supper, that they may the better uphold their Doctrine of the wicked their eating of the true body of Christ, yet are much against his opinion in the point of admitting scandalous persons not Excommunicated to the Sacrament. M. Prynnes bold assertion that all the Ancients except Hilary onely, doe unanimously accord that Iudas received the Lords Supper, without one dissenting voyce; disproved as most false, and confuted by the testimonies of Clemens, Dionysius Areopagita, Maximus, Pachymeres, Ammonius Alexandrinus, Tacianus, Innocentius 3. Rupertus Tuitiensis, yea by those very passages of Theophylact, and Victor Antiochenus, cited by himselfe.