The first Book. Of the Jewish Church-government.The first Booke. Of the Jewish Church-government.
pp. 1–152271 passagespart 2 of 7
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The eleventh place, which seemeth to hold forth unto us an Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin, is Ezech. 13. 9. where its said of the Prophets that did see vanity, and Divine lies: they shall not be in the assembly of my people, neither shall they be written in the writing of the house of Israel, neither shall they inter into the Land of Israel. Where (as Diodati and Grotius observe,) the speech riseth by degrees. 1. they shall not any more be admitted into the assembly or council to have any voice there, as Prophets in those ⟨p. 26⟩days had saith Diodati citing Jer. 26. 7. Secondly, they shall not so much as come into the computation or numbering of the people as members of the Church of Israel. 3. Nay they shall not be permitted to dwell in the holy Land, or to return thither from their captivity; they shall not have so much favour as strangers had, who might come into the holy Land and sojourn there.
The eleventh place, which seemeth to hold forth unto us an Ecclesiasticall Sanhedrin, is Ezech. 13. 9. where its said of the Prophets that did see vanity, and Divine lies: they shall not be in the assembly of my people, neither shall they be written in the writing of the house of Israel, neither shall they inter into the Land of Israel. Where (as Diodati and Grotius observe,) the speech riseth by degrees. 1. they shall not any more be admitted into the assembly or councell to have any voice there, as Prophets in those ⟨p. 26⟩daies had saith Diodati citing Ier. 26. 7. Secondly, they shall not so much as come into the computation or numbring of the people as members of the Church of Israel. 3. Nay they shall not be permitted to dwell in the holy Land, or to returne thither from their captivity; they shall not have so much favour as strangers had, who might come into the holy Land and sojourne there.
A debate with Master Prynne, concerning the exclusion of profane scandalous persons from the passover.A debate with Master Prynne, concerning the exclusion of prophane scandalous persons from the passeover.
In the first branch, the word translated assembly is [Greek or Hebrew] sod which properly signifieth a secret, and is used for counsel (because counsel ought to be secret) or for the place of counsel, or assembly of Counsellors. Pagnin in his Thesaurus p. 1761. readeth this place with Hierome, in consilio, or otherwise saith he, in concilio. Vatablus: in concilio populi mei non erunt. The Septuagints read [Greek or Hebrew]: that is, those Prophets shall have no hand in the Discipline of my people. The same word they render in other places by [Greek or Hebrew], and [Greek or Hebrew], yea by both these put together, Prov. 20. 19. where for the Hebrew sod, the Septuagints have [Greek or Hebrew]. He that revealeth the secret counsels in the Sanhedrin; and it cohereth well with the preceding Verse, where they mention [Greek or Hebrew], Governments. Sometime they expound the word by an Episcopal (I mean not Prelatical) inspection Job 29. 4. [Greek or Hebrew]. God was an overseer of my house. So that, so far as the Septuagints authority can weigh, that place Ezek. 13. 9. must be understood of the secluding of those Prophets from the Sanhedrin, not from the Civill (in which the Prophets were not members) but from the Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin.
In the first branch, the word translated assembly is 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 sod which properly signifieth a secret, and is used for counsell (because counsell ought to be secret) or for the place of counsell, or assembly of Counsellers. Pagnin in his Thesaurus p. 1761. readeth this place with Hierome, in consilio, or otherwise saith he, in concilio. Vatablus: in concilio populi mei non erunt. The Septuagints read 〈non-Latin alphabet〉: that is, those Prophets shall have no hand in the Discipline of my people. The same word they render in other places by 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, yea by both these put together, Prov. 20. 19. where for the Hebrew sod, the Septuagints have 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. He that revealeth the secret counsels in the Sanhedrin; and it cohereth well with the preceding Verse, where they mention 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Governments. Sometime they expound the word by an Episcopall (I mean not Prelaticall) inspection Iob 29. 4. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. God was an overseer of my house. So that, so far as the Septuagints authority can weigh, that place Ezek. 13. 9. must be understood of the secluding of those Prophets from the Sanhedrin, not from the Civill (in which the Prophets were not members) but from the Ecclesiasticall Sanhedrin.
In the twelfth and last place, the new Testament holds out to us an Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin: Whether the civill Sanhedrin was wholly taken away by Herod, and another civill Sanhedrin not substitute in the place of that which he took away, but the Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin only remaining, as some hold; or whether both did then continue though not so clearly distinct, as others hold: This we find that there was an Ecclesiastical government in the hands of Church-officers; for 1. there was a council of the Priests and Elders and Scribes Matth. 2. 4. & 16. 21. & 21. 23. & 26. 57, 59. & 27. 1. 12. Mark 14. 43. Luke 22. 66. Acts 4. 5. mThe Centurists say that those ⟨p. 27⟩Elders were joined with the Priests in the government of the Church, with Ecclesiastical persons in Ecclesiastical affairs. Which hath been rightly taken for a president of our ruling Elders. 2. That Council is called [Greek or Hebrew] Luke 22. 66. Acts 22. 5. the Presbytery or Eldership: the very name which Paul gives to that assembly of Church-officers, who ordained Timothy, 1 Tim. 4. 14. is it credible that the Apostle would transfer the name of a civill Court to signify an Assembly, which was merely Ecclesiastical and not Civill? The very use of the word in this sense by the Apostle, tells us that in his age the word [Greek or Hebrew] was taken in an Ecclesiastical notion only. 3. This Council did examine Jesus concerning his Disciples and his doctrine, and received witnesses against him, and pronounced him guilty of blasphemy, Matth. 27. 57. Mark 14. 53, 55. Joh. 18. 19. Hence Protestant writers draw an argument against Papists, to overthrow their infallibility of Councils: unto which argument Bellarmine deviseth four answers. But it came not once into his thoughts, to reply that this council was civill, not Ecclesiastical, which had been his best answer, if any probability for it. It hath been supposed, both by Protestant, and Popish Writers, that it was an Ecclesiastical Council, such as the controversy is about: otherwise our Argument had been as impertinent, as their answer was insufficient. 4. Our opposites have no evasion here, but that which Bilson, Saravia, and others of the Prelatical party did answer in opposition to ruling Elders; namely, that the Jewish Elders were Judges or Magistrates; But the reply which served then, will serve now:
In the twelfth and last place, the new Testament holds out to us an Ecclesiasticall Sanhedrin: Whether the civill Sanhedrin was wholy taken away by Herod, and another civill Sanhedrin not substitute in the place of that which he took away, but the Ecclesiasticall Sanhedrin onely remaining, as some hold; or whether both did then continue though not so clearely distinct, as others hold: This we finde that there was an Ecclesiasticall government in the hands of Church-officers; for 1. there was a councell of the Priests and Elders and Scribes Matth. 2. 4. & 16. 21. & 21. 23. & 26. 57, 59. & 27. 1. 12. Marke 14. 43. Luke 22. 66. Acts 4. 5. mThe Centurists say that those ⟨p. 27⟩Elders were joyned with the Priests in the government of the Church, with Ecclesiasticall persons in Ecclesiasticall affaires. Which hath been rightly taken for a president of our ruling Elders. 2. That Councell is called 〈non-Latin alphabet〉Luke 22. 66. Acts 22. 5. the Presbytery or Eldership: the very name which Paul gives to that assembly of Church-officers, who ordained Timothy, 1 Tim. 4. 14. is it credible that the Apostle would transfer the name of a civill Court to signifie an Assembly, which was meerely Ecclesiasticall and not Civill? The very use of the word in this sence by the Apostle, tels us that in his age the word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 was taken in an Ecclesiasticall notion onely. 3. This Councell did examine Iesus concerning his Disciples and his doctrine, and received witnesses against him, and pronounced him guilty of blasphemy,
mMagdeb Gent. […]. lib. 1. cap 6. Seniors populi videntu• fuisse […] è populo lecti viri, aetate, d ctrina, & vitae p•obitate spectati, gui simul cum Ecclesiasticis […], Templi, […] & […] rerum […] […] Ecclesiae […] […], […] habuerunt.Magdeb Gent. 〈…〉. lib. 1. cap 6. Seniores populi videntu• fuisse 〈…〉 è populo lecti viri, aetate, d ctrina, & vitae p•obitate spectati, gui simul cum Ecclesiasticis 〈…〉, Templi, 〈…〉 & 〈…〉 rerum 〈…〉〈…〉 Ecclesiae 〈…〉〈…〉, 〈…〉 habuerunt.
the Elders are plainly distinguished from Judges, Rulers, and Princes, Jos. 8. 33. & 23. 2. Deut. 5. 23. Jud. 8. 14. 2 Kings 10. 1, 5. Ezra 10. 14. Acts 4. 5. T•status on Deut. 21. 2. & 22. 15, 16. observeth the same distinction of Judges and Elders. Pelargus on Deu•. 21. 2, 3, 4. observeth the like. That which I say concerning the distinction of Judges and Elders may be confirmed by Halichoth Olam Tract. 1. cap 3. The Judges of Soura, M. Houna, and D. Isaac. The Judges of Phoumbeditha M. Papa the son of Samuel, &c. The Elders of Soura M. Houna and M. Hisda. The Elders of Phoumbeditha Ena and Abimi the son of Rahba. And thus we are taught how to ⟨p. 28⟩under and th•se Gemarick phrases, of the Judges of such a place, and the Elders of such a place, that we may not mistake them as if they were one. 5. Some have also drawn a pattern for the constitution of Synods, from that Council, Acts 4. 5, 6. where we find assembled together Rulers, […], Elders, Scribes, according to which pattern we have in our Synods, 1. the civill […] to preside in the order of proceedings, for preventing tumults, injuries, disorders, and to assist and protect the Synod. 2. Pastors of Churches. 3. Doctors from universities, answering to the Scribes or Doctors of the Law. 4. Ruling Elders who assist in the Government of the Church. 6. After that Judea was redacted into a Province, and the Romans having kept in their own hands, not only the power of life and death John 18. 31. but all judgement in whatsoever civill, or criminal offences, falling out among the Jews, meant by matters of wrong or wicked lewdness, Acts 18. 14. And having left to the Jews no government, nor any power of judgement, except in things pertaining to their religion only Ib. verse 15. These six things considered, it is very unprobable (if not unpossible) that the Council of the Priests, Elders, and Scribes, mentioned so often in the New Testament, should be no Ecclesiastical Court, but a temporal and civill Magistracy. The Centurists Cent. 1. lib. 1. cap. 10. reckon that Council for an Ecclesiastical Court, distinct from civill Magistracy: and they propose these two to be distinctly treated of, Acta coram Pontificibus seu Magistratu Ecclesiastico, (and here they bring in the council of the Priests, Elders, and Scribes,) And Actio coram Pilato seu magistratu politico.
the Elders are plainly distinguished from Judges, Rulers, and Princes, Ios. 8. 33. & 23. 2. Deut. 5. 23. Iud. 8. 14. 2 Kings 10. 1, 5. Ezra 10. 14. Acts 4. 5. T•status on Deut. 21. 2. & 22. 15, 16. observeth the same distinction of Judges and Elders. Pelargus on Deu•. 21. 2, 3, 4. observeth the like. That which I say concerning the distinction of Judges and Elders may be confirmed by Halichoth Olam Tract. 1. cap 3. The Judges of Soura, M. Houna, and D. Isaac. The Iudges of Phoumbeditha M. Papa the sonne of Samuel, &c. The Elders of Soura M. Houna and M. Hisda. The Elders of Phoumbeditha Ena and Abimi the sonne of Rahba. And thus we are taught how to ⟨p. 28⟩under and th•se Gemarick phrases, of the Judges of such a place, and the Eld•rs of such a place, that we may not mistake them as if they were one. 5. Some have also drawne a patterne for the constitution of Synods, from that Councell, Acts 4. 5, 6. where we finde assembled together Rulers, 〈…〉, Elders, Scri•es, according to which patterne we have in our Synods, 1. the civill 〈…〉 to preside in the order of proceedings, for preventing tumults, injuries, disorders, and to assist and protect the Synod. 2. Pastors of Churches. 3. Doctors from universities, answering to the Scribes or Doctors of the Law. 4. Ruling Elders who assist in the Government of the Church. 6. After that Iudaea was redacted into a Province, and the Romans having keptin their owne hands, not only the power of life and death Iohn 18. 31
I know Erastus lib. 3. cap. 2. and lib. 4. cap. 4. though he confess plainly that the Jewish Sanhedrin mentioned in the Gospel, and in the Acts of the Apostles, had only power of judging causes belonging to Religion, and that the Romans did leave them no power to judge of civill injuries; yet he holdeth, that in these causes of Religion, the Sanhedrin had power not only of imprisoning, and scourging, but even of death it self. And so endeavours to make it a temporal or civil Magistracy, (which Mr Prynne also doth vindic. page 4, 5. yet he speaketh dubiously of their power of capital punishments.) ⟨p. 29⟩But this is confuted by the reasons which I have given. Whereunto I further add these few animadversions.
I know Erastus lib. 3. cap. 2. aud lib. 4. cap. 4. though he confesse plainly that the Jewish Sanhedrin mentioned in the Gosspell, and in the Acts of the Apostles, had onely power of judging causes belonging to Religion, and that the Romans did leave them no power to judge of civill injuries; yet he holdeth, that in these causes of Religion, the Sanhedrin had power not onely of imprisoning, and scourging, but even of death it selfe. And so endeavours to make it a temporall or civil Magistracy, (which Mr Prynne also doth vindic. page 4, 5. yet he speaketh dubiously of their power of capitall punishments.) ⟨p. 29⟩But this is confuted by the reasons which I have given. Whereunto I further adde these few animadversions.
1. The strongest proof which Erastus brings out of Josephus antiq. lib. 20. cap. 8. which (as he allegeth) puts the thing out of all controversy, is a very weak and insufficient proof. Josephus tells us in the close of that Chapter, that after the death of Herod and A chelaus, this was the Jewish Government, [Greek or Hebrew]. This he citeth page 177. and page 178. to prove that the Sanhedrin in Christs time, was a civill Magistracy, having power of the Sword. But I may with a great deal more probability argue contrariwise from these words. Josephus tells us the Constitution and form of the Jewish policy or Government was at that time Aristocratical, but it was an Ecclesiastical Aristocracy, the government was in the hands of the chief Priests. Or thus (if you will) the Jews at that time had a bare name of an aristocracy; they had their [Greek or Hebrew] Optimates, Primates, or Rulers: but it was titulo tenus, all power of civill government being taken from them by the Romans, and the government that was, was Ecclesiastical. That very Chapter gives us a better argument to prove, that the Romans did not permit to the Jews capital Judgements: for Josephus there records that Ananus the high Priest taking the opportunity after the death of Festus, while Albinus the Successor of Festus, was but yet on his journey toward Judea, did call a Council of Judges ([Greek or Hebrew]) before whom he presented James the brother of Christ, and some others, who were (as guilty of impiety) condemned to be stoned. Which mightily displeased all such as did observe the Laws. Albinus at that time coming from Alexandria, being informed of the thing, and that it was not lawful for Ananus to do any such thing, without the Roman Governor, wrote a chiding and threatening letter to Ananus. And further, the thing being secretly signified by some to King Agrippa, who did also beseech the King to command Ananus to do no such thing again, he having trespassed in this. Whereupon Agrippa was so highly offended, that he took away from Ananus the high Priests place, and gave it to Jesus the son of Damneus.
⟨p. 30⟩2. Whereas Erastus argueth from the imprisoning, beating, or scourging, yea taking counsel to kill the Apostles Acts 4, & 5. the stoning of Steven Acts 7.
1. The strongest proofe which Erastus brings out of Iosephus antiq. lib. 20. cap. 8. which (as he alledgeth) puts the thing out of all controversie, is a very weake and insufficient proof. Iosephus tels us in the close of that Chapter, that after the death of Herod and A chelaus, this was the Jewish Government, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. This he citeth page 177. and page 178. to prove that the Sanhedrin in Christs time, was a civill Magistracy, having power of the Sword. But I may with a great deale more probability argue contrariwise from these words. Iosephus tels us the Constitution and forme of the Jewish policy or Government was at that time Aristocraticall, but it was an Ecclesiasticall Aristocracy, the government was in the hands of the chiefe Priests. Or thus (if you will) the Jewes at that time had a bare name of an aristocracy; they had their 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Optimates, Primates, or Rulers: but it was titulo tenus, all power of civill government being taken from them by the Romans, and the government that was, was Ecclesiasticall. That very Chapter gives us a better argument to prove, that the Romans did not permit to the Jewes capitall Judgements: for Iosephus there records that Ananus the high Priest taking the opportunity after the death of Festus, while Albinus the Successour of Festus, was but yet on his journey toward Iudea, did call a Councell of Judges (〈non-Latin alphabet〉) before whom he presented Iames the brother of Christ, and some others, who were (as guilty of impiety) condemned to be stoned. Which mightily displeased all such as did observe the Laws. Albinus at that time comming from Alexandria, being enformed of the thing, and that it was not lawfull for Ananus to doe any such thing, without the Roman Governour, wrote a chiding and threatning letter to Ananus. And further, the thing being secretly signified by some to King Agrippa, who did also beseech the King to command Ananus to doe no such thing againe, he having trespassed in this. Whereupon Agrippa was so highly offended, that he tooke away from Ananus the high Priests place, and gaue it to Iesus the sonne of Damneus.
⟨p. 30⟩2. Whereas Erastus argueth from the imprisoning, beating, or scourging, yea taking counsell to kill the Apostles Acts 4, & 5. the stoning of Steven Acts 7.
Pauls letters from the high Priest, for binding and bringing to Jerusalem the Disciples of the Lord Acts 9. 1, 2. also the imprisoning and condemning to death the Saints Acts 26. 10. Unto all this I answer out of nJosephus, that in that degenerate age the high Priests and such as adhered to them, did use a great deal of violence, whereby they did many things for which they had no just nor lawful power. So that the Letters and Warrants given out to Saul, and the execution of the same by a cruel and bloody persecuting of the Saints, can not prove the [Greek or Hebrew] the power and authority which was allowed to the Sanhedrin, but only the [Greek or Hebrew] the present prevalent power of the high Priest and his faction in that confusion of affairs; and their extreme malice against the Saints, to have been such as made them to do things for which they had no legal power nor warrant. And this one Animadversion breaks all the strength of Mr Prynnes argument vindic. page 5. that the Council of the Jews had power (which no mere Ecclesiastical consistory can do) to scourge, imprison, torture, and out-law offenders, if not to condemn, put to death. (Where he citeth divers Texts, none of which proveth either torturing, or out-lawing, and the most of which, prove not so much as that the Council of the Jews at that time had authority to scourge or imprison, as Matth. 5. 22. & 10. 17. Mark 13. 9. Acts 6. 12, 13, 14. & 24. 20. & 25. 15.) The imprisonment of the Apostles was not without the authority of the Captain of the Temple Acts 4. 1, 3. This captain of the Temple, is thought by the best interpreters, to have been the Captain of the Garrison which the Romans placed in the ca•tle Antonia hard by the Temple, and that to prevent tumults and uproars when the people came to the Temple, especially at the solemn feasts in great multitudes. But that the Captain of the Temple was a civill Magistrate of the Jews, or one d putted with authority and power from the Sanhedrin, will never be proved. When the Council thought of slaying the Apostles Acts 5. 33. it was in a sudden passion, being cut to the heart at that which they heard. But Gamaliel tells them ⟨p. 31⟩Verse 35. Ye men of Israel take heed to your selves [Greek or Hebrew] warning them as Interpreters take it, of their own danger, from the Romans, if they should put any one to death.
Pauls letters from the high Priest, for biuding and bringing to Ierusalem the Disciples of the Lord Acts 9. 1, 2. also the imprisoning and condemning to death the Saints Acts 26. 10. Unto all this I answer out of nIosephus, that in that degenerate age the high Priests and such as adhered to them, did use a great deale of violence, whereby they did many things for which they had no just nor lawfull power. So that the Letters and Warrants given out to Saul, and the execution of the same by a cruell and bloody persecuting of the Saints, can not prove the 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 the power and authority which was allowed to the Sanhedrin, but onely the 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 the present prevalent power of the high Priest and his faction in that confusion of affaires; and their extreame malice against the Saints, to have been such as made them to doe things for which they had no legall power nor warrant. And this one Animadversion breakes all the strength of Mr Prynnes argument vindic. page 5. that the Councell of the Jewes had power (which no meere Ecclesiasticall consistory can doe) to scourge, imprison, torture, and out-law offenders, if not to c•ndemne, put to death. (Where he citeth divers Texts, none of which proveth either torturing, or out-lawing, and the most of which, prove not so much as that the Councell of the Jewes at that time had authority to scourge or imprison, as Matth. 5. 22. & 10. 17. Mark 13. 9. Acts 6. 12, 13, 14. & 24. 20. & 25. 15.) The imprisonment of the Apostles was not without the authority of the Captaine of the Temple Acts 4. 1, 3. This captaine of the Temple, is thought by the best interpreters, to have been the Captaine of the Garrison which the Romans placed in the ca•tle Antonia hard by the Temple, and that to prevent tumults and uproares when the people came to the Temple, especially at the solemne feasts in great multitudes. But that the Captaine of the Temple was a civill Magistrate of the Jewes, or one d puted with authority and power from the Sanhedrin, will never be proved. When the Councell thought of slaying the Apostles
nAntiq. Jud. lib. 20. cap 6. Ipsi […] pontifices dissiacre cae•erunt à Sacer•otibus & primatibus Hieroso• mi•anorum •ivium, singuléque m•edebant stipati manu au▪ dacissimorum & seditiosorum bominum, […] inter se mutu•S ce•tabant convitiis & […]: nec erat qui compesceret, quasi vacante urbe Magistratibus. In tantum autem exarsit summorum pontific•m impudentia, ut auderent servos suos in areas mittere, qui auf•rrent debitas Sacerdotibus decimas, aliquótque pauperiores è Sacerdo•um ordine alimentorum in•pia fame deficerent. Tantò plus •um pol•ebat violentia sedi- tiosorum quam justitia.Antiq. Iud. lib. 20. cap 6. Ipsi 〈…〉 pontifices dissiacre cae•erunt à Sacer•otibus & primatibus Hieroso• mi•anorum •ivium, singuléque m•edebant stipati manu au▪ dacissimorum & seditiosorum bominum, 〈…〉 inter se mutu•S ce•tabant convitiis & 〈…〉: nec erat qui compesceret, quasi vacante urbe Magistratibus. In tantum autem exarsit summorum pontific•m impudentia, ut auderent servos suos in areas mittere, qui auf•rrent debitas Sacerdotibus decimas, aliquótque pauperiores è Sacerdo•um ordine alimentorum in•pia fame deficerent. Tantò plus um polebat violentia sedi- tiosorum quam justitia.
The putting of Steven to death was upon pretence of Judicium zeli, or Jus zelotarum, as Grotius thinks d• Jure belli a• pacis lib. 2. cap 20. sect. 9. If so, it was an extraordinary act. I am sure it was done most tumultuously, disorderly and furiously, before either himself was heard speak out, or any sentence was given against him, as is manifest Acts 7. 54, 57, 58.
3. Erastus his gloss upon John 18. 31. It is not lawful for us to put any man to death, meaning (saith he) for making himself a King against Caesar, the cause for which they did chiefly accuse him to Pilate. So likewise Bishop Bilson (a great follower of Erastus) of the perpetual government of Christs Church cap. 4. But mark the words, Then said Pilate unto them, Take ye him and judge him according to your Law; The Jews therefore said unto him, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death. Pilate durst not have refused to judge a man who made himself a King against Caesar, nor durst he have put it over upon the Jews to have judged one in that which concerned Caesars crown. Nay, as soon as the Jews objected, If thou let this man go, thou art not Caesars friend; for whosoever maketh himself a King, speaketh against Caesar. Pilate when he heard that, went in again, and sate down on the Judgement seat John 19. 12. 13. Therefore when Pilate said to the Jews take ye him, and judge him according to your law, he spake it of matters of their Law. The Council of the chief Priests, Elders and Scribes had given sentence against Christ de ju•e, that he was guilty of blasphemy, and thereupon (not having power to put any man to death) they led him to Pilate, Matth. 26. 65, 66. with Matth. 27. 1, 2. Mark 14. 63, 64. with Mark 15. 1. Luke 22. 71. with Luke 23. 1. Pilate unwilling to meddle against Christ, waves the business in the Judgement-hall, I perceive (would he say) that this man is accused of such things as concern your Law and your Religion; therefore take him and judge him according to your Law. They reply, in reference to that which Pilate did drive at, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death. If they had meant, for causes which concerned Caesars Crown, it had been not ⟨p. 32⟩only an impertinent reply, but a yielding to Pilates intention;
The putting of Steven to death was upon pretence of Iudicium zeli, or Ius zelotarum, as Grotius thinks d• Jure belli a• pacis lib. 2. cap 20. sect. 9. If so, it was an extraordinary act. I am sure it was done most tumultuously, disorderly and furiously, before either himselfe was heard speake out, or any sentence was given against him, as is manifest Acts 7. 54, 57, 58.
3. Erastus his glosse upon Iohn 18. 31. It is not lawfull for us to put any man to death, meaning (saith he) for making himselfe a King against Caesar, the cause for which they did chiefly accuse him to Pilate. So likewise Bishop Bilson (a great follower of Erastus) of the perpetuall government of Christs Church cap. 4. But marke the words, Then said Pilate unto them, Take ye him and judge him according to your Law; The Jewes therefore said unto him, It is not lawfull for us to put any man to death. Pilate durst not have refused to judge a man who made himselfe a King against Caesar, nor durst he have put it over upon the Jewes to have judged one in that which concerned Caesars crowne. Nay, as soone as the Jewes objected, If thou let this man goe, thou art not Caesars friend; for whosoever maketh himselfe a King, speaketh against Caesar. Pilate when he heard that, went in againe, and sate down on the Judgement seat Iohn 19. 12. 13. Therefore when Pilate said to the Jewes take ye him, and judge him according to your law, he spake it of matters of their Law. The Councell of the chiefe Priests, Elders and Scribes had given sentence against Christ de ju•e, that he was guilty of blasphemy, and thereupon (not having power to put any man to death) they led him to Pilate, Matth. 26. 65, 66. with Matth. 27. 1, 2. Marke 14. 63, 64. with Marke 15. 1. Luke 22. 71. with Luke 23. 1. Pilate unwilling to meddle against Christ, waves the businesse in the Judgement-hall, I perceive (would he say) that this man is accused of such things as concerne your Law and your Religion; therefore take him and judge him according to your Law. They reply, in reference to that which Pilate did drive at, It is not lawfull for us to put any man to death. If they had meant, for causes which concerned Caesars Crown, it had been not
for he might have said, I do not mean, that ye shall judge him for that which concerneth Caesar, but for that which concerneth your own Law and Religion. Therefore certainly the answer which the Jews made to Pilate, did reply, that though they had power to judge a man in that which concerned their Law and Religion, yet they had no power to put any man to death, no not for that which concerned their Law.
4. There are several passages in the story of Paul which show us, that though the Jewish Sanhedrin might judge a man in matters of their Law, yet they were accusers, not Judges, in civill or capital punishments, I mean when a man was accused as worthy of bonds or of death, though it were for a matter of their Law, they had no liberty to judge, but only to accuse. The Jews drew Paul before the judgement seat of Gallio, even for a matter of their law. This fellow (say they to Gallio) persuadeth men to worship God, contrary to the Law Acts 18. 13. If they had intended only an Ecclesiastical censure, their recourse had been either to the Sanhedrin, or at least to the Synagogue, but because they intended a corporal temporal punishment, which neither the Sanhedrin nor the Synagogue had power to inflict, therefore they must prosecute Paul before Gallio; whose answer was to this purpose, that if it had been a matter of wrong or wicked lewdness, it had been proper for him to have judged it, but that since it was no such thing, he would not meddle in it, knowing also, that the Jews had no power to do it by themselves. Again, Acts 23. 28, 29. Claudius Lysias writeth to Faelix concerning Paul thus, and when I would have known the cause wherefore they accused him, I brought him forth into their Council. Whom I perceived to be accused of questions of their Law, but to have nothing laid to his charge worthy of death or of bonds. That which made Lysias interpose in the business, and rescue Paul from the hands of the Jews, was the Jews design to put Paul to death, under colour of judging him according to their Law (which was the pretence made by Tertullus Acts 24. 6.) Now in that which was to be punished, either by death, or so much as by bonds, Lysias conceives the Jews to be ⟨p. 33⟩no competent Judges, therefore he brings Paul into the council of the Jews, not to be judged by them, but to know what accusation they had against him.
for he might have said, I doe not meane, that ye shall judge him for that which concerneth Caesar, but for that which concerneth your owne Law and Religion. Therefore certainely the answer which the Jewes made to Pilate, did reply, that though they had power to judge a man in that which concerned their Law and Religion, yet they had no power to put any man to death, no not for that which concerned their Law.
4. There are severall passages in the story of Paul which shew us, that though the Jewish Sanhedrin might judge a man in matters of their Law, yet they were accusers, not Judges, in civill or capitall punishments, I meane when a man was accused as worthy of bonds or of death, though it were for a matter of their Law, they had no liberty to judge, but onely to accuse. The Jewes drew Paul before the judgement seat of Gallio, even for a matter of their law. This fellow (say they to Gallio) perswadeth men to worship God, contrary to the Law Acts 18. 13. If they had intended onely an Ecclesiasticall censure, their recourse had been either to the Sanhedrin, or at least to the Synagogue, but because they intended a corporall temporall punishment, which neither the Sanhedrin nor the Synagogue had power to inflict, therefore they must prosecute Paul before Gallio; whose answer was to this purpose, that if it had been a matter of wrong or wicked leudnesse, it had been proper for him to have judged it, but that since it was no such thing, he would not meddle in it, knowing also, that the Jewes had no power to doe it by themselves. Againe, Acts 23. 28, 29. Claudius Lysias writeth to Faelix concerning Paul thus, and when I would have knowne the cause wherefore they accused him, I brought him forth into their Councell. Whom I perceived to be accused of questions of their Law, but to have nothing laid to his charge worthy of death or of bonds. That which made Lysias interpose in the businesse, and rescue Paul from the hands of the Jewes, was the Jewes designe to put Paul to death, under colour of judging him according to their Law (which was the pretence made by Tertullus Acts 24. 6.) Now in that which was to be punished, either by death, or so much as by bonds, Lysias conceives the Jewes to be ⟨p. 33⟩no competent Judges, therefore he brings Paul into the councell of the Jewes, not to be judged by them, but to know what accusation they had against him.
For the same reason Paul himself did decline going to Jerusalem, to be judged there, no not of matters concerning the Religion and Law of the Jews, that accusation being so far driven on, as to make him worthy of death. His accusers (saith Festus to King Agrippa) brought none accusation of such things as I supposed, but had certain questions against him of their own superstition, and of one Jesus which was dead, whom Paul affirmed to be alive. And because I doubted of such manner of questions▪ I asked him whether he would go to Jerusalem, and there be judged of these matters, Acts 25. 18, 19, 20. This Paul had declined vers. 10. I stand at Caesars judgement seat (said he) where I ought to be judged. And why? but because his accusation was capital, even in that which concerned the Law of the Jews, and he knew the Jews at that time had no power of capital judgements. Some have alleged this example of Paul for appeals from Presbyteries or Synods to the civill Magistrate: by which argument themselves grant that the Jewish Sanhedrin then declined by Paul, was a Ecclesiastical, not a civill Court.
5. Besides all this Erastus his opinion is strongly confuted by that which Constantinus L'Empereur Annot. in remp. Jud. pag. 404. to 407. proving that the Jews after the thirtieth year of Christ, had no power of punishing with death; for proof hereof citeth a passage of Aboda zara, that forty years before the destruction of the Temple, the Sanhedrin (which had in former times exercised capital judgements) did remove from Jerusalem, quum viderent se non posse judicia capitalia exercere, when they perceived that they could not exercise capital judgements, they said let us remove out of this place, lest we be guilty: it being said Deut. 17. 10. according to the sentence which they of that place shall show thee: whence they collected, that if they were not in that place, they were not obliged to capital judgements: and so they removed. And if you would know when there he tells us out of Rosch Hasschana, they removed from Jerusalem to Jabua, thence to Ousa thence to Sc•aphrea, &c. He that desires to have further proofs for that which hath been said, may ⟨p. 34⟩read Buxtorf. lexic. Chald. Talmud. & rabbin. pag. 514, 515.
For the same reason Paul himselfe did decline going to Ierusalem, to be judged there, no not of matters concerning the Religion and Law of the Jewes, that accusation being so far driven on, as to make him worthy of death. His accusers (saith Festus to King Agrippa) brought none accusation of such things as I supposed, but had certaine questions against him of their owne superstition, and of one Iesus which was dead, whom Paul affirmed to be alive. And because I doubted of such manner of questions▪ I asked him whether he would goe to Ierusalem, and there be judged of these matters, Acts 25. 18, 19, 20. This Paul had declined vers. 10. I stand at Caesars judgement seat (said he) where I ought to be judged. And why? but because his accusation was capitall, even in that which concerned the Law of the Jewes, and he knew the Jewes at that time had no power of capitall judgements. Some have alledged this example of Paul for appeales from Presbyteries or Synods to the civill Magistrate: by which argument themselves grant that the Jewish Sanhedrin then declined by Paul, was a Ecclesiasticall, not a civill Court.
5. Besides all this Erastus his opinion is strongly confuted by that which Constantinus L'Empereur Annot. in remp. Jud. pag. 404. to 407. proving that the Jewes after the thirtieth yeere of Christ, had no power of punishing with death; for proofe hereof citeth a passage of Aboda zara, that forty yeers before the destruction of the Temple, the Sanhedrin (which had in former times exercised capitall judgements) did remove from Hierusalem, quum viderent se non posse judicia capitalia exercere, when they perceived that they could not exercise capitall judgements, they said let us remove out of this place, lest we be guilty: it being said Deut. 17. 10. according to the sentence which they of that place shall shew thee: whence they collected, that if they were not in that place, they were not obliged to capitall judgements: and so they removed. And if you would know whe ther he tels us out of Rosch Hasschana, they removed from Hieru salem to Iabua, thence to Ousa thence to Sc•aphrea, &c. He that desires to have further proofes for that which hath been said, may ⟨p. 34⟩read Buxtorf. lexic. Chald. Talmud. & rabbin. pag. 514, 515.
He proves that Judicia criminalia, criminal judgements did cease, and were taken away from the Jews forty years before the destruction of the second Temple. This he saith is plain in Talmud Hierosol. in lib. Sanhedrin cap. 7. in Talmud Babyl. in Sanbedrin fol. 41. 1. in Aboda z•ru fol. 8. 2. in Schab. fol. 15. 1. in Juchasin fol. 51. 1. Majen•on. in Sanhedrin cap. 14. sect. 13. He cites also a passage in Berachos fol. 58. 1. concerning one who for a heinous crime even for lying with a beast ought to be adjudged to death; but when one said that he ought to die, it was answered, that they had no power to put any man to death. And this saith Dr. Bux•orf is the very same, which the Jews said to Pilate John 18. 31. Now this power being taken from the Jews forty years before the destruction of the Temple and City, which was in the 71 year of Christ, his death being in the 34. Hence he proveth that this power was taken from the Jews near three years before the death of Christ. And I further make this inference, that since the Sanhedrin which had power of life and death, did remove from Jerusalem forty years before the destruction of the Temple (for which see also Tzemach David. edit. Hen. Vorst. pag. 89. and so about three years before the death of Christ; it must needs follow that the Council of the Priests, Elders, and Scribes, mentioned so often in, and before Christs passion, was not a civill Magistracy, nor the civill Sanhedrin, but an Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin. Whence also it follows, that the Church Matth. 18. 17. unto which Christ directs his Disciples to go with their complaints, was not the civill Court of Justice among the Jews, (as Mr Prynne takes it) for that civill Court of Justice had then removed from Jerusalem, and had lost its authority in executing Justice, I. Coch annot. in Exc. Gem. Sanhedrin. cap. 1. sect. 13. beareth witness to the same story above mentioned, that forty years before the destruction of the Temple, the Sanhedrin did remove from its proper seat (where he also mentions the ten stations or degrees of their removing) and Jam tum cessarunt judicia capitalia, saith he. Now at that time the capital judgements did cease. Thus we have three witnesses singularly learned in the Jewish Antiquities. Unto these add Casaubon ⟨p. 35⟩exerc. 16. anno 34. num. 76.
He proves that Iudicia criminalia, criminall judgements did cease, and were taken away from the Jewes forty yeeres before the destruction of the second Temple. This he saith is plaine in Talmud Hierosol. in lib. Sanhedrin cap. 7. in Talmud Babyl. in Sanbedrin fol. 41. 1. in Aboda z•ru fol. 8. 2. in Schab. fol. 15. 1. in Iuchasin fol. 51. 1. Majen•on. in Sanhedrin cap. 14. sect. 13. He cites also a passage in Berachos fol. 58. 1. concerning one who for a hainous crime even for lying with a beast ought to be adjudged to death; but when one said that he ought to die, it was answered, that they had no power to put any man to death. And this saith Dr. Bux•orf is the very same, which the Jewes said to Pilate John 18. 31. Now this power being taken from the Jewes forty yeeres before the destruction of the Temple and City, which was in the 71 yeere of Christ, his death being in the 34. Hence he proveth that this power was taken from the Jewes neere three yeeres before the death of Christ. And I further make this inference, that since the Sanhedrin which had power of life and death, did remove from Hierusalem forty yeers before the destruction of the Temple (for which see also Tzemach David. edit. Hen. Vorst. pag. 89. and so about three yeeres before the death of Christ; it must needs follow that the Councell of the Priests, Elders, and Scribes, mentioned so often in, and before Christs passion, was not a civill Magistracy, nor the civill Sanhedrin, but an Ecclesiasticall San•edrin. Whence also it follows, that the Church Matth. 18. 17. unto which Christ directs his Disciples to goe with their complaints, was not the civill Court of Justice among the Jewes, (as Mr Prynne takes it) for that civill Court of Justice had then removed from Hierusalem, and had lost its authority in executing Justice, I. Coch annot. in Exc. Gem. Sanhedrin. cap. 1. s•ct. 13. beareth witnesse to the same story above mentioned, that forty yeeres before the destruction of the Temple, the Sanhedrin did remove from its proper seat (where he also mentions the ten stations or degrees of their removing) and Iam tum cessarunt judicia capitalia, saith he. Now at that time the capitall judgements did cease. Thus we have three witnesses singularly learned in the Jewish Antiquities. Unto these adde Casau•on ⟨p. 35⟩exerc. 16. anno 34. num. 76.
He holds that though the Council of the Jews had cognizance of the offence (for otherwise how could they give a reason or cause when they demanded justice) in which respect the Council did judge Christ to be guilty of death, Mark 14. 64. yet their Council had then no more power of capital punishments, which saith he, the more learned modern writers do demonstrate è Juchasin, and from other Talmudical writings; he addeth that this power of putting any man to death was taken from the Jews some space before this time when they said to Pilate, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death: for this power was taken from them, saith he, forty years before the destruction of the second Temple, as the Rabbinical writers do record.
He holds that though the Councell of the Jewes had cognizance of the offence (for otherwise how could they give a reason or cause when they demanded justice) in which respect the Councell did judge Christ to be guilty of death, Marke 14. 64. yet their Councell had then no more power of capitall punishments, which saith he, the more learned moderne writers doe demonstrate è Iuchasin, and from other Talmudicall writings; he addeth that this power of putting any man to death was taken from the Jewes some space before this time when they said to Pilate, It is not lawfull for us to put any man to death: for this power was taken from them, saith he, forty yeeres before the destruction of the second Temple, as the Rabbinicall writers doe record.
The chief objection which ever I heard or read against this distinction of a Civill Sanhedrin and an Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin among the Jews, is this. That neither the Talmud nor the Talmudical writers mention any such distinction, but speak only of one supreme Sanhedrin of 71, and of other two Courts, which sate the one at the door of the Court before the Temple, the other at the gate which entereth to the mountain of the Temple. There were also Courts in the Cities where capital cases were judged by three and twenty, pecuniall mults by three.
The chiefe objection which ever I heard or read against this distinction of a Civill Sanhedrin and an Ecclesiasticall Sanhedrin among the Jewes, is this. That neither the Talmud nor the Talmudicall writers mention any such distinction, but speake onely of one supreme Sanhedrin of 71, and of other two Courts, which sate the one at the doore of the Court before the Temple, the other at the gate which entereth to the mountaine of the Temple. There were also Courts in the Cities where capitall cases were judged by three and twenty, pecuniall mults by three.
Answ. It must be remembered that not only the Talmudical Commentators, but the Talmud it self, is much later than the time of the Sanhedrin, and the integrity of the Jewish government. Yea later (by some Centuries) than the destruction of the Temple and City of Jerusalem. So that the Objection which is made is no stronger than as if one should argue thus, There is no mention of Elderships constituted of Pastors and Ruling Elders (without any Bishop having preeminence over the rest) neither in the Canon Law, nor decretals of Popes, ⟨p. 36⟩nor in the Book of the Canons of the Roman Church. Therefore when Paul wrote his Epistle to the Church of Rome, there was no such Eldership in that Church, constituted as hath been said. But if the Ecclesiastical Government either of the Church of Rome, or of the Church of the Jews can be proved from Scripture (as both may) it ought to be no prejudice against those truths, that they are not fou•d in the Writers of af•ertimes, and declining ages. Howbeit there may be seen some footsteps of a Civill and Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin, even in the Talmudical writers, in the opinion of Constantinus L'Empereur, and in that other passage cited by D. Buxtorf out of Elijah. Of which before. And so much concerning an Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin among the Jews.
Answ. It must be remembred that not onely the Talmudicall Commentators, but the Talmud it selfe, is much later than the time of the Sanhedrin, and the integrity of the Jewish government. Yea later (by some Centuries) than the destruction of the Temple and City of Ierusalem. So that the Objection which is made is no stronger than as if one should argue thus, There is no mention of Elderships constituted of Pastors and Ruling Elders (without any Bishop having preeminence over the rest) neither in the Canon Law, nor decretals of Popes, ⟨p. 36⟩nor in the Booke of the Canons of the Roman Church. Therefore when Paul wrote his Epistle to the Church of Rome, there was no such Eldership in that Church, constituted as hath been said. But if the Ecclesiasticall Government either of the Church of Rome, or of the Church of the Jewes can be proved from Scripture (as both may) it ought to be no prejudice against those truths, that they are not fou•d in the Writers of af•ertimes, and declining ages. Howbeit there may be seen some footsteps of a Civill and Ecclesiasticall Sanhedrin, even in the Talmudicall writers, in the opinion of Constantinus L'Empereur, and in that other passage cited by D. Buxtorf out of Elias. Of which before. And so much concerning an Ecclesiasticall Sanhedrin among the Jewes.
If after all this, any man shall be unsatisfied in this particular, yet in the issue, such as are not convinced that there was an Ecclesiastical Sanhedrin among the Jews, distinct from their civill Sanhedrin, may nevertheless be convinced not by the former arguments, but by other Mediums, that there was an Ecclesiastical government among the Jews distinct from their civill government. For it belonged to the Priests, (not to the Magistrates or Judges) to put difference between holy and unholy, and between unclean and clean. And the Priests (not the Magistrates) are challenged for not putting difference between the holy and profane Ezech. 22. 26. And this power of the Priests was not merely doctrinal or declarative, but decisive, binding, and juridical, so far as that according to their sentence men were to be admitted as clean, or excluded as unclean. Yea in other cases, as namely in trying and judging the scandal of a secret and unknown murder, observe what is said of the Priests, Deut. 21. 5. by their word shall every controversy and every stroke be tried. Yea themselves were Judges of controversies Ezech. 44. 24. And in controversy they shall stand in judgement, and they shall judge it according to my judgements. Where the Ministers of the Gospel are principally intended, but not without an allusion unto and parallel with the Priests of the old Testament, in this point of jurisdiction. Suppose now it were appointed by Law, that Ministers shall separate or put difference between the holy and profane, that by their ⟨p. 37⟩word every controversy concerning the causes of suspension or sequestration of men from the Sacrament, shall be tried; that in controversy they shall stand in judgement, and judge according to the word of God: Would not every one look upon this, as a power of government put into the hands of Ministers. And none readier to aggravate such government, then the Erastians. Yet all this amounts to no more, then by the plain and undeniable Scriptures above cited, was committed to the Priests.
If after all this, any man shall be unsatisfied in this particular, yet in the issue, such as are not convinced that there was an Ecclesiasticall Sanhedrin among the Jewes, distinct from their civill Sanhedrin, may neverthelesse be convinced not by the former arguments, but by other Mediums, that there was an Ecclesiasticall government among the Jewes distinct from their civill government. For it belonged to the Priests, (not to the Magistrates or Judges) to put difference between holy and unholy, and between unclean and cleane. And the Priests (not the Magistrates) are challenged for not putting difference between the holy and prophane Ezech. 22. 26. And this power of the Priests was not meerly doctrinall or declarative, but decisive, binding, and juridicall, so farre as that according to their sentence men were to be admitted as cleane, or excluded as uncleane. Yea in other cases, as namely in trying and judging the scandall of a secret and unknown murther, observe what is said of the Priests, Deut. 21. 5. by their word shall every controversie and every stroke be tried. Yea themselves were Judges of controversies Ezech. 44. 24. And in controversie they shall stand in judgement, and they shall judge it according to my judgements. Where the Ministers of the Gospell are principally intended, but not without an allusion unto and parallel with the Priests of the old Testament, in this point of jurisdiction. Suppose now it were appointed by Law, that Ministers shall separate or put difference between the holy and prophane, that by their ⟨p. 37⟩word every controversie concerning the causes of suspension or sequestration of men from the Sacrament, shall be tried; that in controversie they shall stand in judgement, and judge according to the word of God: Would not every one looke upon this, as a power of government put into the hands of Ministers. And none readier to aggravate such government, then the Erastians. Yet all this amounts to no more, then by the plaine and undeniable Scriptures above cited, was committed to the Priests.
Suppose also, that men were kept back from the Temple and from the Passover, not for any moral uncleanness, but for ceremonial uncleanness only (which is to be afterwards discussed) yet the Priests their judging and deciding of controversies concerning mens legal uncleanness, according to which judgement and decision, men were to be admitted to, or kept back from the Temple and Passover (yea sometime their own houses, as in the case of leprosy) could not choose but entitle them to a power of government, which power was peculiar to them, and is not in all the old Testament ascribed to Magistrates or Judges. And as the exercise of this power did not agree to the Magistrate, so the commission, charge, and power given to those who did keep back the unclean, was not derived from the Magistrate; for it did belong to the intrinsical sacerdotal authority 2 Kings 11. 18. The Priest (Jehojada) appointed Officers over the house of the Lord. The 70 thus, [Greek or Hebrew]. These Officers or overseers over the Temple, were appointed by Jehojada, for keeping back the unclean, as Grotius upon the place, following Josephus, hath observed. Compare 2 Chro. 23. 19. And he (Jehojada) set the Porters at the gates of the house of the Lord, that none which was unclean in any thing should enter in▪ For the same end did he appoint these overseers over the Temple, 2 Kings 11. It was also appointed by the Law, that the man who should do any thing presumptuously, contrary to the sentence of the Priests, should die the death, as well as the man who should do any thing presumptuously, contrary to the sentence of the Judge, Deut. 17. 9, 12.
Suppose also, that men were kept backe from the Temple and from the Passeover, not for any morall uncleannesse, but for ceremoniall uncleannesse onely (which is to be afterwards discussed) yet the Priests their judging and deciding of controversies concerning mens legall uncleannesse, according to which judgement and decision, men were to be admitted to, or kept backe from the Temple and Passover (yea sometime their owne houses, as in the case of leprosie) could not choose but entitle them to a power of government, which power was peculiar to them, and is not in all the old Testament ascribed to Magistrates or Judges. And as the exercise of this power did not agree to the Magistrate, so the commission, charge, and power given to those who did keepe backe the uncleane, was not derived from the Magistrate; for it did belong to the intrinsecall sacerdotall authority 2 Kings 11. 18. The Priest (Iehojada) appointed Officers over the house of the Lord. The 70 thus, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. These Officers or overseers over the Temple, were appointed by Iehojada, for keeping backe the uncleane, as Grotius upon the place, following Iosephus, hath observed. Compare 2 Chro. 23. 19. And he (Iehojada) set the Porters at the gates of the house of the Lord, that none which was uncleane in any thing should enter in▪ For the same end did he appoint these overseers over the Temple, 2 Kings 11. It was also appointed by the Law, that the man who should doe any thing presumptuously, contrary to the sentence of the Priests, should die the death, as well as the man who should doe any thing presumptuously, contrary to the sentence of the Judge, Deut. 17. 9, 12.
Finally, the high Priest was a ruler of the people, and to him is that law applied, Thou shalt not speak evil of the Ru•ers of thy ⟨p. 38⟩people Acts 23. 5. Which is not meant only in regard that he was president of the Sanhedrin; for there was an Ecclesiastical ruling power, which was common with him to some other Priests, 2 Chro. 35. 8. Hilkiah the high Priest, and Zachariah and Jehiel Priests of the second order, are called Rulers of the house of God: being in that very place thus distinguished from other Priests and Levites employed in the manual work of the Temple about Sacrifices and the like.
Finally, the high Priest was a ruler of the people, and to him is that law applied, Thou shalt not speake evill of the Ru•ers of thy ⟨p. 38⟩people Acts 23. 5. Which is not meant onely in regard that he was president of the Sanhedrin; for there was an Ecclesiasticall ruling power, which was common with him to some other Priests, 2 Chro. 35. 8. Hilkiah the high Priest, and Zachariah and Iehiel Priests of the second order, are called Rulers of the house of God: being in that very place thus distinguished from other Priests and Levites imployed in the manuall worke of the Temple about Sacrifices and the like.
IT hath been affirmed by some who pretend to more skill in Jewish antiquities than others, that though the Jews had an excommunication which did exclude a man from the liberty of civill fellowship, so that he might not come within four cubits of his neighbour, (and so one man might and did excommunicate another) yet no man was judicially or by sentence of a Court excommunicated, at least not from the Temple, Sacrifices, and holy assemblies.
IT hath been affirmed by some who pretend to more skill in Jewish antiquities than others, that though the Jewes had an excommunication which did exclude a man from the liberty of civill fellowship, so that he might not come within foure cubits of his neighbour, (and so one man might and did excommunicate another) yet no man was judicially or by sentence of a Court excommunicated, at least not from the Temple, Sacrifices, and holy assemblies.
To these I shall in the first place oppose the judgement of others who have taken very much pains in searching the Jewish antiquities, and are much esteemed for their skill therein. nD. Buxtors expoundeth [Greek or Hebrew] cherem to be a casting out of one from the holy assemblies, or an ejection from the Synagogue, and maketh it parallel to the Excommunicating of the incestuous man 1 Cor. 5. oMr Selden extendeth the Jewish Excommunication so far, as to comprehend an exclusion from fellowship in prayer and holy assemblies, and makes it parallel ⟨p. 39⟩to that which Tertullian tells us to have been used by the Primitive Church. Mr Brughton in his exposition of the Lords prayer page 14. makes a parallel between the Jewish and the Christian Church in many particulars, and among the rest, he saith they agree in the manner of Excommunication and absolution. pHenric. Vorstius in his late animadversions upon Pirke Rabbi Eliezer, wonders how any man can imagine that an Apostate, a blasphemer, or the like was admitted into the Temple. For his part, he thinks some excommunicate persons were absolutely excluded from the Temple, and that others for whom there were hopes of reconciliation, were admitted into it. qDrusius and rJohannes Coch hold, that there were such excommunicate persons among the Jews, as were removed from Church assemblies, and were not acknowledged for Church members. sSchindlerus describeth their excommunication to be a putting away of an impenitent obstinate sinner from the public assembly of the Church, and so a cutting him off from his people. tArias Montanus expounds their casting out of the Synagogue to be an excommunication (such as in the Christian Church) from religious fellowship. uSo do the Centurists plainly, where they do purposely show what was the Ecclesiastical policy and Church government of the Jews: They make it a distinct Question, whether the Jews in Christs time had any civill ⟨p. 40⟩Government, or Magistracy. xCornelius Bertramus thinks that to the Jewish Niddui answereth our suspension from the Sacrament, and that to their cherem answereth our excommunication from the Church: and that the Jews had the very same kind of excommunication, by which the incestuous Corinthian, Hymeneus and Philetus, and the Emperor Theodosius were excommunicated. Constansinus l' Empereur annot. in rempub. Jud. pag. 370. to 378.
To these I shall in the first place oppose the judgement of others who have taken very much pains in searching the Jewish antiquities, and are much esteemed for their skill therein. nD. Buxtors expoundeth 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 cherem to be a casting out of one from the holy assemblies, or an ejection from the Synagogue, and maketh it parallel to the Excommunicating of the incestuous man 1 Cor. 5. oMr Selden extendeth the Jewish Excommunication so farre, as to comprehend an exclusion from fellowship in prayer and holy assemblies, and makes it parallel ⟨p. 39⟩to that which Tertullian tels us to have been used by the Primitive Church. Mr Brughton in his exposition of the Lords prayer page 14. makes a parallel between the Jewish and the Christian Church in many particulars, and among the rest, he saith they agree in the manner of Excommunication and absolution. pHenric. Vorstius in his late animadversions upon Pirke Rabbi Eliezer, wonders how any man can imagine that an Apostate, a blasphemer, or the like was admitted into the Temple. For his part, he thinkes some excommunicate persons were absolutely excluded from the Temple, and that others for whom there were hopes of reconciliation, were admitted into it. qDrusius and rIohannes Coch hold, that there were such excommunicate persons among the Jewes, as were removed from Church assemblies, and were not acknowledged for Church members. sSchindlerus describeth their excommunication to be a putting away of an impenitent obstinate sinner from the publique assembly of the Church, and so a cutting him off from his people. tArias Montanus expounds their casting out of the Synagogue to be an excommunication (such as in the Christian Church) from religious fellowship. uSo doe the Centurists plainly, where they doe purposely shew what was the Ecclesiasticall policy and Church government of the Jewes: They make it a distinct Question, whether the Jewes in Christs time had any civill
nLexicon Chald. Talmud. & Rabbin. edit. 1639. pag. 8•7, 828. [Greek or Hebrew] Excommunicatio, exclusio • caetu sacro, ejectio ex syna▪ goga &c. Cum tali excommunicato non licet edere nec bibert. Quo fortè respicit Apostolus 1 Cor. 5. 11. [Greek or Hebrew], Nam admonitionem illam generalem facit, ex occasione incestuosi quem excommunicare jubet.Lexicon Chald. Talmud. & Rabbin. edit. 1639. pag. 8•7, 828. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Excommunicatio, exclusio • caetu sacro, ejectio ex syna▪ goga &c. Cum tali excommunicato non licet edere nec bibert. Quo fortè respicit Apostolus 1 Cor. 5. 11. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, Nam admonitionem illam generalem facit, ex occasione incestuosi quem excommunicare jubet.
oDe Jure natur. & Gentium lib. 4. cap. 9. Atque is planè à communication orationis, & convenius, & omnis sancti commercii relegabatur, quemadmodum de bujusmodi anathemate sub initils Ecclesie Christianae loquitur Tertullianus.De Iure natur. & Gentium lib. 4. cap. 9. Atque is planè à communicatione orationis, & convenius, & omnis sancti commercii relegabatur, quemadmodum de bujusmodi anathemate sub initils Ecclesie Christianae loquitur Tertullianus.
pAnimad in Pirke pag. 169. Qu• enim dicat apostatam, blashemum aliaque sacra capita intra templum suisse admissa? &c. Certe si quibuslibet excommunicatis permissum suisset in trare Templom, tum […] mitior Judaicae Synagoga disciplina esset statuenda, quam veteris Christianae Ecclesiae.Animad in Pirke pag. 169. Qu• enim dicat apostatam, blashemum aliaque sacra capita intra templum suisse admissa? &c. Certe si quibuslibet excommunicatis permissum suisset in trare Templom, tum 〈…〉 mitior Judaicae Synagoga disciplina esset statuenda, quam veteris Christianae Ecclesiae.
holdeth the same thing which Bertramus holdeth concerning the Jewish excommunication, and which hath now been cited. Godwin in his Moses and Aaron, lib. 5. cap. 1 speaketh of the Ecclesiastical Court of the Jews, unto which (saith he) belonged the power of excommunication, the several sorts of which censure he explaineth cap. 2. namely Niddui, cherem, and Shammata. After all which, he begins cap. 3. to speak of civill Courts of the Jews, a distinct government.
holdeth the same thing which Bertramus holdeth concerning the Jewish excommunication, and which hath now been cited. Godwyn in his Moses and Aacon, lib. 5. cap. 1 speaketh of the Ecclesiasticall Court of the Jewes, unto which (saith he) belonged the power of excommuication, the severall sorts of which censure he explaineth cap. 2. namely Niddui, cherem, and Shammata. After all which, he begins cap. 3. to speake of civill Courts of the Jewes, a distinct government.
Grotius. annot. in Luke 6. 22. compares the Jewish excommunication with that which was exercised by the Druids in France, who did interdicere saerificiis, interdict and prohibit from their Sacrifices impious and obstinate persons. Yea those who were excommunicate by Niddui or the lesser excommunication, he likens to those penitents or mourners in the ancient Christian Church, who were said to be [Greek or Hebrew], qui non cum caeteris orabant &c. He tells us the ancient Christians did in divers things follow the Jewish discipline, and among other things in excommunication; He cites the same passage of Tertullian which is cited by Mr Selden, concerning a shutting out, à communication orationis, & conventus, & omnis sancti commercii. Which is as full and high a description of the Ecclesiastical censure of Excommunication, as any can be. So that the Jewish Excommunication being paralleled with that Excommunication which Tertullian speaks of, and which was practised in the ancient Christian Church, what more can be required in this particular? And here I cannot but take notice, that Master Prynne doth very much mistake and misrepresent Mr Selden, as if he held the Jewish excommunication to have been no more but a shutting out from civill company or fellowship, whereas ⟨p. 41⟩he clearly holds lib. 4. de jure nat. & Gent. cap. 9. p. 522. that he who was excommunicated by the Jewish cherem, was put away and cast off from fellowship in prayer, and from all religious fellowship, even as Tertullian speaks of excommunicated persons in the Church.
Grotius. annot. in Luke 6. 22. compares the Jewish excommunication with that which was exercised by the Druides in France, who did interdicere saerificiis, interdict and prohibit from their Sacrifices impious and obstinate persons. Yea those who were excommunicate by Niddui or the lesser excommunication, he likens to those penitents or mourners in the ancient Christian Church, who were said to be 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, qui non cum caeteris orabant &c. He tels us the ancient Christians did in divers things follow the Jewish discipline, and among other things in excommunication; He cites the same passage of Tertullian which is cited by Mr Selden, concerning a shntting out, à communicatione orationis, & conventus, & omnis sancti commercii. Which is as full and high a description of the Ecclesiasticall censure of Excommunication, as any can be. So that the Jewish Excommunication being paralleld with that Excommunication which Tertullian speakes of, and which was practised in the ancient Christian Church, what more can be required in this particular? And here I cannot but take notice, that Master Prynne doth very much mistake and misrepresent Mr Selden, as if he held the Jewish excommunication to have been no more but a shutting out from civill company or fellowship, whereas ⟨p. 41⟩he clearly holds lib. 4. de jure nat. & Gent. cap. 9. p. 522. that he who was excommunicated by the Jewish cherem, was put away and cast off from fellowship in prayer, and from all religious fellowship, even as Tertullian speaks of excommunicated persons in the Church.
Lud. Capellus in Spicilegio upon Joh. 9. 22. speaking of the common distinction of the three degrees of the Jewish Excommunication, doth plainly bear witness to that which I plead for, namely, ythat there was a Jewish Excommunication from communion in the holy things. I confess he understands the Cherem, and the Shammata, otherwise then I do; for he takes the Cherem to be nihil aliud, nothing else than the forfeiture of a mans substance for the use of the Sanctuary: (whereas it is certain there was a Cherem of persons as well as of things, and the formulae of the Cherem which shall be cited afterward, contain another thing than forfeiture.) And Shammata he takes to be the devoting of men to death, and that being Shamatized they must needs die. (And yet the Jews did shamatize the Cuthites or Samaritans (as we shall see afterward) whom they had not power to put to death.) However he speaks of the Niddui as a mere Ecclesiastical censure, and therefore tells us it was formidable to the godly, it being a shutting out from communion in the holy things, but not formidable to wicked men; which must be upon this reason, because wicked men did care little or nothing for any censure or punishment, except what was civill. He granteth also that Niddui was included in the other two: so that in all three there was a shutting out from the holy things.
Lud. Capellus in Spicilegio upon Ioh. 9. 22. speaking of the common distinction of the three degrees of the Jewish Excommunication, doth plainly beare witnesse to that which I plead for, namely, ythat there was a Jewish Excommunication from communion in the holy things. I confesse he understands the Cherem, and the Shammata, otherwise then I doe; for he takes the Cherem to be nihil aliud, nothing else than the forfeiture of a mans substance for the use of the Sanctuary: (whereas it is certaine there was a Cherem of persons as well as of things, and the formulae of the Cherem which shall be cited afterward, containe another thing than forfeiture.) And Shammata he takes to be the devoting of men to death, and that being Shamatized they must needs die. (And yet the Jewes did shamatize the Cuthites or Samaritans (as we shall see afterward) whom they had not power to put to death.) However he speaks of the Niddui as a meere Ecclesiasticall censure, and therefore tels us it was formidable to the godly, it being a shutting out from communion in the holy things, but not formidable to wicked men; which must be upon this reason, because wicked men did care little or nothing for any censure or punishment, except what was civill. He granteth also that Niddui was included in the other two: so that in all three there was a shutting out from the holy things.
yHarum trium Excommunicationis specierum vel potius graduum, secunda primam, tertia utramque includebat. Prima piis quidem Judaeis erat formidabtlis, quia per eam à sacrorum communion submovebantur, at qui minus pii erant eâ non magnopere movebantur.Harum trium Excommunicationis specierum vel potius graduum, secunda primam, tertia utramque includebat. Prima piis quidem Iudaeis erat formidabtlis, quia per eam à sacrorum communione submovebantur, at qui minus pii erant eâ non magnopere movebantur.
I must not forget the Testimony of my Countryman Master Weemse in his Christian Synagogue lib. 1. cap. 6. sect. 3. paragr. 7. They had three sorts of Excommunication; first the lesser, then the middle sort, then the greatest. The lesser was called Niddui: and in the New Testament they were called [Greek or Hebrew], put out of the Synagogue: and they hold that Cain was excommunicated this way. The second was called Cherem or Anathema: with this sort of Excommunication was the Incestuous person censured 2 Cor. 2. The third Shammatha, they hold that Enoch instituted it, Jude v. 14. And after, these who were [Greek or Hebrew], put out of the Synagogue were not simply secluded ⟨p. 42⟩from the Temple, but suffered to stand in the Gate, &c. These who were Excommunicated by the second sort of Excommunication, were not permitted to come near the Temple. These who were Excommunicated after the third sort, were secluded out of the society of the people of God altogether.
I must not forget the Testimony of my Countreyman Master Weemse in his Christian Synagogue lib. 1. cap. 6. sect. 3. paragr. 7. They had three sorts of Excommunication; first the lesser, then the middle sort, then the greatest. The lesser was called Niddui: and in the New Testament they were called 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, put out of the Synagogue: and they hold that Cain was excommunicated this way. The second was called Cherem or Anathema: with this sort of Excommunication was the Incestuous person censured 2 Cor. 2. The third Shammatha, they hold that Enoch instituted it, Jude v. 14. And after, these who were 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, put out of the Synagogue were not simply secluded ⟨p. 42⟩from the Temple, but suffered to stand in the Gate, &c. These who were Excommunicated by the second sort of Excommunication, were not permitted to come neer the Temple. These who were Excommunicated after the third sort, were secluded out of the society of the people of God altogether.
And thus I have produced fifteen witnesses for the Ecclesiastical Excommunication of the Jews. I might produce many more, but I have made choice of these, because all of them have taken more than ordinary pains in searching the Jewish antiquities, and divers of them are of greatest note for their skill therein.
And thus I have produced fifteen witnesses for the Ecclesiasticall Excommunication of the Jewes. I might produce many more, but I have made choice of these, because all of them have taken more than ordinary paines in searching the Jewish antiquities, and divers of them are of greatest note for their skill therein.
In the next place let us observe the causes, degrees, manner and rites how, the authority by which, the ends and effects of excommunication among the Jews, and see whether all these do not help to make their Excommunication a pattern for ours. For the causes, there were 24 causes, for which a man was Excommunicated among the Jews. You may read them in Buxtorf's Lexicon Chald▪ Talmud & Rabbin. p. 1304, 1305. M. Selden de jure nat. & Gentium. lib. 4. cap. 8. Jo. Coch Annot. in Excerp. Gem. Sanhedrin cap. 2. pag. 147. divers of these causes did not at all concern personal or civill injuries (for such injuries were not accounted causes of Excommunication, but were to be punished otherwise, as shall be proved afterward) but matters of scandal, by which God was dishonoured, and the stumbling-block of an evil example laid before others; One cause was the despising of any of the precepts of the Law of Moses, or Statutes of the Scribes. Another was the selling of Land to a Gentile. Another was, a Priest not separating the gifts of the oblation. Another, he that in captivity doth not iterate or observe the second time a holy day. Another, yhe that doth any servile work upon Easter eve. Another, he that mentioneth the name of God rashly, or by a vain oath. Another, he that induceth, or giveth occasion to others to profane the name of God. Another, he that makes others to •ate holy things without the holy Temple. Another, he that maketh computation of years and months without the Land of Israel: that is, (as Dr Buxtorf) writeth Calendars, or (as M. Selden) computeth years and months otherwise than their ⟨p. 43⟩fathers had done. Another, he that retardeth or hindereth others from doing the Law and Commandment. Another, he that maketh the offering profane (as Dr Buxtorf) or offereth a sickly beast, (as I. Coch.) Another, a Sacrificer that doth not show his Sacrificing Knife before a Wise man or a Rabbi, that it may be known to be a lawful Knife, and not faulty. Another, he that cannot be made to know or to learn. Another, he that having put away his wife, doth thereafter converse familiarly with her. Another, a Wise man (that is, a Rabbi or Doctor) infamous for an evil life. The other causes had also matter of scandal in them, namely, the despising of a Wise man or Rabbi, though it were after his death.
In the next place let us observe the causes, degrees, manner and rites how, the authority by which, the ends and effects of excommunication among the Jewes, and see whether all these doe not helpe to make their Excommunication a patterne for ours. For the causes, there were 24 causes, for which a man was Excommunicated among the Jewes. You may read them in Buxtorfs Lexicon Chald▪ Talmud & Rabbin. p. 1304, 1305. M. Selden de jure nat. & Gentium. lib. 4. cap. 8. Jo. Coch Annot. in Excerp. Gem. Sanhedrin cap. 2. pag. 147. divers of these causes did not at all concerne personall or civill injuries (for such injuries were not accounted causes of Excommunication, but were to be punished otherwise, as shall be proved afterward) but matters of scandall, by which God was dishonoured, and the stumbling-blocke of an evill example laid before others; One cause was the despising of any of the preceps of the Law of Moses, or Statutes of the Scribes. Another was the selling of Land to a Gentile. Another was, a Priest not separating the gifts of the oblation. Another, he that in captivity doth not iterate or observe the second time a holy day. Another, yhe that doth any servile worke upon Easter eve. Another, he that mentioneth the name of God rashly, or by a vaine oath. Another, he that enduceth, or giveth occasion to others to prophane the name of God. Another, he that makes others to •ate holy things without the holy Temple. Another, he that maketh computation of yeeres and moneths without the Land of Israel: that is, (as Dr Buxtorf) writeth Calendars, or (as M. Selden) computeth yeeres and moneths otherwise than their ⟨p. 43⟩fathers had done. Another, he that retardeth or hindreth others from doing the Law and Commandement. Another, he that maketh the offering prophane (as Dr Buxtorf) or offereth a sickly beast, (as I. Coch.) Another, a Sacrificer that doth not shew his Sacrificing Knife before a Wise man or a Rabbi, that it may be knowne to be a lawfull Knife, and not faulty. Another, he that cannot be made to know or to learne. Another, he that having put away his wife, doth thereafter converse familiarly with her. Another, a Wise man (that is, a Rabbi or Doctor) infamous for an evill life. The other causes had also matter of scandall in them, namely, the despising of a Wise man or Rabbi, though it were after his death.
yBuxtors lexic. Rabbin. p. 2463 ex Pesachim fol. 50. Qui vesperâ sabbathi & aliorum dierum festorum operas serviles •cit, infaustum illud quidem est, neque videt signum benedictionis, sed non schammatisamus eum: at qui vesper• pas ch•tis operas serviles facit, hîc verò omnino schammatisamus eum. They did also excommunicate an heretical or Epicurean Israelite. Buxtorf ibid, pag. 195.Buxtors lexic. Rabbin. p. 2463 ex Pesachim fol. 50. Qui vesperâ sabbathi & aliorum dierum festorum operas serviles •cit, infaustum illud quidem est, neque videt signum benedictionis, sed non schammatisamus eum: at qui vesper• pas ch•tis operas serviles facit, hîc verò omnino schammatisamus eum. They did also excommunicate an hereticall or Epicurean Israelite. Buxtorf ibid, pag. 195.
The despising of an Officer or messenger of the house of judgement. He that casteth up to his neighbour a servile condition, or calls his neighbour servant. He that contumaciously refuseth to appear at the day appointed by the Judge. He that doth not submit himself to the Judicial sentence. He that hath in his house any hurtful thing, as a mad dog or a weak leather. He that before Heathen Judges beareth witness against an Israelite. He that maketh the blind to fall. He that hath Excommunicate another without cause, when he ought not to have been Excommunicate. Thus you have the 24 causes of the Jewish Excommunication; of which some were mere scandals: others of a mixed nature, that is, partly injuries, partly scandals; but they were reckoned among the causes of Excommunication qua scandals, not qua […]. Jo. Coch. Annot. in Exc. Gem. Sanhedrin. pag. 146▪ explaining how the wronging of a Doctor of the Law by contumelies, was a cause of Excommunication, showeth that the Excommunication was because of the scandall. Licet tamen condonare nisi res in praputulo gesta sit. Publicum Doctoris ludibrium in legis contemptum redundat. […] ob causam Doctor legis honorem […] remittere non potest. Ubi res clam & sine scandalo gesta est, magni animi & sapientis est injuriam contemptu vindicare. If there was no scandal, the injury might be remitted by the party injured, so as the offender was not to be Excommunicate▪ But if the contumely was known abroad, and was scandalous, though the party wronged were willing and desirous to bury it, yet because of the scandal, the Law ⟨p. 44⟩provided that the offender should be excommunicate. For they taught the people that he who did contend against a Rabbi did contend against the holy Ghost (for which see Gull. Vorstius annot. in Maimon. de fundam. legis. pag. 77, 78.) and hence did they aggravate an Ecclesiastical or Divine (not a Civill) injury. Whence it appeareth that the causes of Excommunication, were formally looked upon as scandals. Add that if qua injuries, then a quatenus ad omne, all personal or civill injuries had been causes of Excommunication. But all civill injuries do not fall within these 24. causes. If it be objected, that neither do all scandals fall within these 24. causes. I answer they do; for some of the causes are general and comprehensive, namely these two, the 5th.
The despising of an Officer or messenger of the house of judgement. He that casteth up to his neighbour a servile condition, or cals his neighbour servant. He that contumaciously refuseth to appeare at the day appointed by the Judge. He that doth not submit himselfe to the Judiciall sentence. He that hath in his house any hurtfull thing, as a mad dogge or a weake leather. He that before Heathen Judges beareth witnesse against an Israelite. He that maketh the blind to fall. He that hath Excommunicate another without cause, when he ought not to have been Excommunicate. Thus you have the 24 causes of the Jewish Excommunication; of which some were meere scandals: others of a mixed nature, that is, partly injuries, partly scandals; but they were reckoned among the causes of Excommunication qua scandals, not qua 〈…〉. Io. Coch. Annot. in Exc. Gem. Sanhedrin. pag. 146▪ explaining how the wronging of a Doctor of the Law by contumelies, was a cause of Excommunication, sheweth that the Excommunication was because of the scandall. Licet tamen condonare nisi res in praputulo gesta sit. Publicum Doctoris ludibrium in legis contemptum redundat. 〈…〉 ob causam Doctor legis honorem 〈…〉 remittere non potest. Ubi res clam & sine scandalo gesta est, magni animi & sapientis est injuriam contemptu vindicare. If there was no scandall, the injury might be remitted by the party injured, so as the offendor was not to be Excommunicate▪ But if the contumely was known abrond, and was scandalous, though the party wronged were willing and desirous to bury it, yet because of the scandall, the Law ⟨p. 44⟩provided that the offender should be excommunicate. For they taught the people that he who did contend against a Rabbi did contend against the holy Ghost (for which see Gul. Vorstius annot. in Maimon. de fundam. legis. pag. 77, 78.) and hence did they aggravate an Ecclesiasticall or Divine (not a Civill) injury. Whence it appeareth that the causes of Excommunication, were formally lookt upon as scandals. Adde that if qua injuries, then a quatenus ad omne, all personall or civill injuries had been causes of Excommunication. But all civill injuries doe not fall within these 24. causes. If it be objected, that neither doe all scandalls fall within these 24. causes. I answer they doe; for some of the causes are generall and comprehensive, namely these two, the 5th.
When I make mention of any particular heads, either of the Jewish Discipline, or of the ancient Christian discipline, let no man understand me, as if I intended the like Strictness of Discipline in these days. My meaning is only, to prove Ecclesiastical censures, and an Ecclesiastical Government. And let this be remembered upon all like occasions; though it be not everywhere expressed. And so much for the causes.
When I make mention of any particular heads, either of the Jewish Discipline, or of the ancient Christian discipline, let no man understand me, as if I intended the like Strictnesse of Discipline in these dayes. My meaning is onely, to prove Ecclesiasticall censures, and an Ecclesiasticall Government. And let this be remembred upon all like occasions; though it be not everywhere expressed. And so much for the causes.
The degrees of the Jewish excommunication, were [Greek or Hebrew] Niddui, [Greek or Hebrew] Cherem, [Greek or Hebrew] Schammata. Elijah in Tisbite, saith plainly that there were three kinds of excommunication, Niddui, Cherem, and Schammata. Niddui is […] out; but if he be not converted, they smite him with Cherem; and if neither so he repent, they schammatize him. These three Doctor Buxtorf thus distinguisheth, not only out of Elijah, the common sentence of the but Hebrew Doctors. The first and smallest excommunication is Niddui, which is a simple separation for a certain time. The greater excommunication is Cherem, which▪ is a separation with imprecations and curses. The greatest of all is Schammata, a final excommunication, without hope of returning to the Church. So likewise Hen. Uorstius animad. in Pirke pag. 230. And answerably hereunto some Divines have distinguished Excommunicatio Minor, Major, and Maxima. The first is suspension from the Sacrament. The second is a casting out ⟨p. 45⟩of the Church, and a delivering over to Satan: which yet is a medicinal excommunication for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved. The third is Anathema Maranatha, an accursing of a man to the coming of Christ, without hope of mercy; which is excommunicatio exterminativa, and cannot be done, without a prophetical Spirit. Corn. Bertramus de repub. Ebraeor cap. 7. saith that our suspension from the Sacrament answereth to their Niddui: our Excommunication to their Cherem. And for their Schammata, he thinks it was an adjudging of one to eternal death; whereunto answereth the Apostles Anathema, and the Churches devoting of Julian the Apostate, as one to be no more prayed for, but to be prayed against. Munsterus will have Schammata to be the same with Niddui. Wherein Master Selden agreeth with him, still holding a difference between Niddui, and Cherem, as between the lesser, and the greater excommunication: de Jure nat. & Gentium, l. 4. c. 8. Of the same opinion is Jo. Coch, Annot. in Exc. Gem. Sanhedrin. p. 149. But Constantinus l' Empereur annot. in rempub. Jud. tells us, that the Talmudists in divers places, do distinguish the three degrees of Excommunication, as Bertramus doth; and that Schammata was the highest Excommunication, greater then either Niddui or Cherem, he proves not only by the Epitheton adonai added by the Chaldee paraphrase Num.
The degrees of the Jewish excommunication, were 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Niddui, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Cherem, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Schammata. Elias in Tisbite, saith plainly that there were three kinds of excommunication, Niddui, Cherem, and Schammata. Niddui is 〈…〉 out; but if he be not converted, they smite him with Cherem; and if neither so he repent, they schammatize him. These three Doctor Buxtorf thus distinguisheth, not only out of Elias, the common sentence of the but Hebrew Doctors. The first and smallest excommunication is Niddui, which is a simple separation for a certain time. The greater excommunication is Cherem, which▪ is a separation with imprecations and curses. The greatest of all is Schammata, a finall excommunication, without hope of returning to the Church. So likewise Hen. Uorstius animad. in Pirke pag. 230. And answerably hereunto some Divines have distinguished Excommunicatio Minor, Major, and Maxima. The first is suspension from the Sacrament. The second is a casting out ⟨p. 45⟩of the Church, and a delivering over to Sathan: which yet is a medicinall excommunication for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved. The third is Anathema Maranatha, an accursing of a man to the comimg of Christ, without hope of mercy; which is excommunicatio exterminativa, and cannot be done, without a propheticall Spirit. Corn. Bertramus de repub. Ebraeor cap. 7. saith that our suspension from the Sacrament answereth to their Niddui: our Excommunication to their Cherem. And for their Schammata, he thinks it was an adjudging of one to eternall death; whereunto answereth the Apostles Anathema, and the Churches devoting of Iulian the Apostate, as one to be no more prayed for, but to be prayed against. Munsterus will have Schammata to be the same with Niddui. Wherein Master Selden agreeth with him, still holding a difference between Niddui, and Cherem, as between the lesser, and the greater excommunication: de Jure nat. & Gentium, l. 4. c. 8. Of the same opinion is Io. Coch, Annot. in Exc. Gem. Sanhedrin. p. 149. But Constantinus l' Empereur annot. in rempub. Jud. tels us, that the Talmudists in divers places, do distinguish the three degrees of Excommunication, as Bertramus doth; and that Schammata was the highest Excommunication, greater then either Niddui or Cherem, he proves not onely by the Epitheton adonai added by the Chaldee paraphrase Num.
21. 25. Et percussit eum Israel per Schammata dei; but further from the words of Rabbi Solomon, comparing one excommunicated by Schammata, to the fat cast in the Furnace, which is wholly consumed, and which never comes out, so he that is Schammatized, is lost for ever, and without all remedy unto all eternity. He confirmeth it also, from the words of Elijah above mentioned. It is not much to my present argument, to dispute whether the Jews had three distinct degrees of excommunication or two only. However it's agreed, that the Jews had their Excommunicatio Minor & Major. And Niddui▪ was an Excommunication for 30. days, during which time if the person (man or woman) repent, well and good: if not, he was excommunicate, for other 30. days. Yea, saith Doctor Buxtorf, the time might be triplicate to 90. days. And if after all that time he repent not, then he was excommunicate, with the ⟨p. 46⟩greater excommunication Cherem. And so much for the degrees.
21. 25. Et percussit eum Israel per Schammata dei; but further from the words of Rabbi Solomon, comparing one excommunicated by Schammata, to the fat cast in the Furnace, which is wholly consumed, and which never comes out, so he that is Schammatized, is lost for ever, and without all remedy unto all eternity. He confirmeth it also, from the words of Elias above mentioned. It is not much to my present argument, to dispute whether the Jewes had three distinct degrees of excommunication or two only. However it's agreed, that the Jews had their Excommunicatio Minor & Major. And Niddui▪ was an Excommunication for 30. dayes, during which time if the person (man or woman) repent, well and good: if not, he was excommunicate, for other 30. dayes. Yea, saith Doctor Buxtorf, the time might be triplicate to 90. dayes. And if after all that time he repent not, then he was excommunicate, with the ⟨p. 46⟩greater excommunication Cherem. And so much for the degrees.
As for the manner, and rites of their excommunication, it was done most solemnly, zDoctor Buxtorf tells us, if the party was present, the sentence of Excommunication was pronounced against him by word of mouth: If he was absent, there was a writ publicly affixed, containing the sentence of Excommunication, which writ was not published, till the offence was proved, at least by two witnesses.
As for the manner, and rites of their excommunication, it was done most solemnly, zDoctor Buxtorf tells us, if the party was present, the sentence of Excommunication was pronounced against him by word of mouth: If he was absent, there was a writ publikely affixed, containing the sentence of Excommunication, which writ was not published, till the offence was proved, at least by two witnesses.
zLexicon. Chald. Talmud. & Rabbin. pag. 2468. Excom municatio siebat quandoque verbis expressis, quando excommunicandus erat praesens: quandeque scripto publicè affixo, quando absens erat. Hinc legitur in Majemone in libro Madda cop. 7. Sect. 2. Quomodo sit Niddui: dicit N. esto in excommunication. Si. excommunicant eum in faciem, id est presentem, dicit N. hic esto in excommunicatione sive banno. Ibid. pag. 2469. Nuncius vel minister publicus judicii câ side habetur, ut si dicat, N. à me citatus ad Judicium, contempsit me, aut vilipendit Judicem, aut dixit sa nolle comparere in Judicio, tunc sammatisent ipsum ad verba ejus, sed non scribunt super eo Schedam Excommunicationis Shammata, donec veverint duc quo testentur ipsum noluisse comparere ad Judicium.Lexicon. Chald. Talmud. & Rabbin. pag. 2468. Excom municatio siebat quandoque verbis expressis, quando excommunicandus erat praesens: quandeque scripto publicè affixo, quando absens erat. Hinc legitur in Majemone in libro Madda cop. 7. Sect. 2. Quomodo sit Niddui: dicit N. esto in excommunicatione. Si. excommunicant eum in faciem, id est presentem, dicit N. hic esto in excommunicatione sive banno. Ibid. pag. 2469. Nuncius vel minister publicus judicii câ side habetur, ut si dicat, N. à me citatus ad Judicium, contempsit me, aut vilipendit Judicem, aut dixit sa nolle comparere in Judicio, tunc sammatisent ipsum ad verba ejus, sed non scribunt super eo Schedam Excommunicationis Shammata, donec veuerint duc quo testentur ipsum noluisse comparere ad Judicium.
It is certain from Pirke Rabb. Elierser cap. 38. that Cherem was not without an assembly of ten at least. And it is as certain that Cherem was not only in a solemn, but in a sacred manner performed, which is manifest from that Formula Anathematis, which aDoctor Buxtorf hath transcribed out of an old Hebrew Manuscript; and from banother form, which Hen. Vorstius ⟨p. 47⟩taketh out of Col Bo both showing, that it was not a civill, but a sacred business, done in the name and authority of the God of heaven: and the latter formula still used in most of the Jewish Synagogues as Vorstius informs us
It is certain from Pirke Rabb. Elierser cap. 38. that Cherem was not without an assembly of ten at least. And it is as certaine that Cherem was not onely in a solemn, but in a sacred manner performed, which is manifest from that Formula Anathematis, which aDoctor Buxtorf hath transcribed out of an old Hebrew Manuscript; and from banother forme, which Hen. Vorstius ⟨p. 47⟩taketh out of Col Bo both shewing, that it was not a civill, but a sacred businesse, done in the name and authority of the God of heaven: and the latter formula still used in most of the Jewish Synagogues as Vorstius informes us
aLexicon Rabbin. p. 828. Ex sententia domini Dominorum, sit in Anathemate Ploni Filius Ploni, in utraque domo Judicii, Superiorum scilicet & Inferiorum, in Anathemate item Sanctorum Excelsorum, in anathemate Seraphim & Ophannim, in anathemate denique totius Ecclesiae, maximorum & minimorum &c.
bAnother form more full and large see in Vorstius his Animadversions upon Pirke pag. 226. to 230. Decreto vigilum atque edicto Sanctotum anathemizamus. adju•amus, excommunicamus Schammatizamus, maledicimus, execramus ex sententia hujus loci atque ex scientia hujus coe•ûs, hoc libro legis, sexcentis tredecim praeceptis in illo conscriptis. Anathe. mate quo Joshua devo vie Jericho; malediction quâ maledixit Elisha pueris, & maledictione quam imprecatus est Gichazi servo suo. Shammate quo Schammatizavit Barack Meroz, &c. Nomine Aebthariel Jah Domini Zehaoth. Nomine Michael Principis magni. Nomine Mathatheron cujus nomen est sicuti nomen Domini ejus. Nomine Sandalphon qui nectit coronas pro domino suo. Nomine Nominis 42. literarum. Nomine quod apparuit Mosi in Sinai. Nomine quo dissecuit Moses Mare. Nomine Ehieh ascher Ehieh, Ero qui ero. Arcano nominis Amphor•sch. Scripturâ quae exarata est in tabulis. Nomine Domini exercituum Dei Israelis, qui sedit inter cherubim, &c. Maledictus ex ore nominis celebrandi, & tremendi, quod e•reditur ex ore Sacerdotis magni die expiationum, &c. Evellatur ipse è tabernaculo. Nolit dominus illi condonare, sed tunc sumet furor & indignatio contra virum illum. Incumbant illi omnes maledictiones conscriptae in hoc libro legis. Expellat nomen ejus sub caelo, & segreget illum in malum ex omnibus tribubus Israelis, juxta omnes execrationes hujus faederis consignatas in hoc libro legis, &c. Haec sit voluntas Dei & dicatur Amen.Another forme more full and large see in Vorstius his Animadversions upon Pirke pag. 226. to 230. Decreto vigilum atque edicto Sanctotum anathemizamus. adju•amus, excommunicamus Schammatizamus, maledicimus, execramus ex sententia hujus loci atque ex scientia hujus coe•ûs, hoc libro legis, sexcentis tredecim praeceptis in illo conscriptis. Anathe. mate quo Joshua devo vie Jericho; maledictione quâ maledixit Eliseus pueris, & maledictione quam imprecatus est Gichazi servo suo. Shammate quo Schammatizavit Barack Meroz, &c. Nomine Aebthariel Jah Domini Zehaoth. Nomine Michael Principis magni. Nomine Mathatheron cujus nomen est sicuti nomen Domini ejus. Nomine Sandalphon qui nectit coronas pro domino suo. Nomine Nominis 42. literarum. Nomine quod apparuit Mosi in Sinai. Nomine quo dissecuit Moses Mare. Nomine Ehieh ascher Ehieh, Ero qui ero. Arcano nominis Amphor•sch. Scripturâ quae exarata est in tabulis. Nomine Domini exercituum Dei Israelis, qui sedit inter cherubim, &c. Maledictus ex ore nominis celebrandi, & tremendi, quod e•reditur ex ore Sacerdotis magni die expiationum, &c. Evellatur ipse è tabernaculo. Nolit dominus illi condonare, sed tunc sumet furor & indignatio contra virum illum. Incumbant illi omnes maledictiones conscriptae in hoc libro legis. Expellat nomen ejus sub caelo, & segreget illum in malum ex omnibus tribubus Israelis, juxta omnes execrationes hujus faederis consignatas in hoc libro legis, &c. Haec sit voluntas Dei & dicatur Amen.
We read also in Pirke Rabb. Elieser cap. 38. cthat the Cuthites (who were also called Samaritans) after they had been circumcised by Rabb. D•stai, and Rabbi Zechariah, and had been taught by them out of the Book of the Law; they were excommunicate by Ezra, Zerubbabel, and Joshua the high Priest, 300. Priests, and 300. Disciples, and the whole Church, in the Temple; the Trumpets sounding, and the Levites singing; they did even by the great name of God, excommunicate the Cuthites, that there should be no fellow-ship between any man of Israel and the Cuthites, that no Proselyte should be received of the Cuthites; and that they should have no part in the resurrection of the dead, nor in the building of the house of God, nor in Jerusalem. This passage Doctor Buxtorf, in his Rabbinical Lexicon, p. 2464. and Master Selden de Jure nat. & Gentium. l. 4. c. 8. have observed out of Pirke; and Doctor Buxtorf, both there and dissert de lit. Hebr. thes. 49. noteth the three words used by the Hebrews in this relation, [Greek or Hebrew] that is, they did excommunicate them both by Niddui, Cherem, and Schammata. And so much for the manner and rites.
We read also in Pirke Rabb. Elieser cap. 38. cthat the Cuthites (who were also called Samaritans) after they had been circumcised by Rabb. D•stai, and Rabbi Zacharias, and had been taught by them out of the Book of the Law; they were excommunicate by Ezra, Zerubbabel, and Ioshua the high Priest, 300. Priests, and 300. Disciples, and the whole Church, in the Temple; the Trumpets sounding, and the Levites singing; they did even by the great name of God, excommunicate the Cuthites, that there should be no fellow-ship between any man of Israel and the Cuthites, that no Proselyte should be received of the Cuthites; and that they should have no part in the resurrection of the dead, nor in the building of the house of God, nor in Ierusalem. This passage Doctor Buxtorf, in his Rabbinicall Lexicon, p. 2464. and Master Selden de Jure nat. & Gentium. l. 4. c. 8. have observed out of Pirke; and Doctor Buxtorf, both there and dissert de lit. Hebr. thes. 49. noteth the three words used by the Hebrews in this relation, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 that is, they did excommunicate them both by Niddui, Cherem, and Schammata. And so much for the manner and rites.
cQuid tum fec•runt Ezra, Zerobahel, & Jehoshua? Congregaveront totam Ecclesiam seu caetum populi in templum dom ni & introduxerant 300. sacerdotes, & 300. adoles▪ centes (seu discipulos minores) quibus erant in manibus 300. buccinae, & 300. libri legis. Hi clangebant; Levitae autem cantabant & psallebant: & excommunicabant Cuthaeos per mysterium nominis Te r•grammati, & per scripturam descriptam in Tabulis legis, & per anathema fori superioris seu caelestis, & per anathema fori inferioris seu terrestris, ita ut nemo Israelitarum unquam in posterum comederet buccellam aliquam Cuthaeorum. Hinc dicunt Quicunque comedit carnem Cuthaei, is vescitur quasi carne poreinâ. Cuthaeus quoque ne seret proselytus, neque haberet partem in resurrectione mortuorum, juxta illud quod scriptum est. Non ad vos simul nobiscum attinet instauratio domus dei nostri: neque in hoc neque in suturo seculo. Praeterea quoque ne haberet partem in Jerusalem. hinc dicitur, Uobis non est pars neque jus, neque memoria in Jerusalem. Transmisetunt autem Anathema hoc ad Israelitas qui erant in Babylonia.
As for the authority, by which a man was excommunicated, we see (by that which hath been already noted) that it was a public and judicial act, and it was necessary there should be at least an Assembly of ten. Those formulae before cited, make it evident, that it was an authoritative sentence of an Ecclesiastical Assembly, (and therefore done as it were in name of the Court ⟨p. 48⟩of heaven, to which purpose domus Judicii superioris seu coelestis, was mentioned in the business, and it was a juridical or forensicall act, and done solemnly in the Temple, in that case of the Cuthites) Drusius de tribus Sectis Judaeorum lib. 4. Num. 237. concerning the Discipline of the Essaeans, and their Excommunicating of ungodly persons, tells us it was done by a hundred men Assembled together. It is very true, which Mr. Selden observeth, de Jure nat. & Gentium l. 4. c. 8. the Hebrews writ of a Judicial excommunication, and of an extrajudicial excommunication, by which one private man might excommunicate another. Yet, that extrajudicial excommunication could not stand in force, unless it were ratified by the Court; and of it self, it was rather optative, or imprecative, than obligative: as is manifest by the Instance, which dJo. Coch gives us ex Gem. Moed Caton. Two men having mutually excommunicated each other, it cometh to an authoritative decision. He that had excommunicated the other, for that for which he ought to have been punished by a pecuniall mulct, but not by excommunication, was himself justly excommunicate by the other, according to the last of the 24. causes of excommunication before mentioned, that is, that he who unjustly excommunicateth another, shall be himself excommunicated. So the excommunicating of the one man for a civill injury was declared null: and the excommunicating of the other, for his unjust act of excommunication, was ratified. Which doth not only prove what I have said of private, or extrajudicial excommunication: but also confirm what I asserted before, concerning the causes of excommunication, that it was not for personal or civill injuries, but for matter of scandal. And that pecuniary mulcts and excommunication, were not inflicted for the same but for different causes. And so much for the authority.
As for the authority, by which a man was excommunicated, we see (by that which hath been already noted) that it was a publike and judiciall act, and it was necessary there should be at least an Assembly of ten. Those formulae before cited, make it evident, that it was an authoritative sentence of an Ecclesiasticall Assembly, (and therefore done as it were in name of the Court ⟨p. 48⟩of heaven, to which purpose domus Judicii superioris seu coelestis, was mentioned in the businesse, and it was a juridicall or forensicall act, and done solemnly in the Temple, in that case of the Cuthites) Drusius de tribus Sectis Judaeorum lib. 4. Num. 237. concerning the Discipline of the Essaeans, and their Excommunicating of ungodly persons, tells us it was done by a hundreth men Assembled together. It is very true, which Mr. Selden observeth, de Jure nat. & Gentium l. 4. c. 8. the Hebrews writ of a Judiciall excommunication, and of an extrajudiciall excommunication, by which one private man might excommunicate another. Yet, that extrajudiciall excommunication could not stand in force, unlesse it were ratified by the Court; and of it selfe, it was rather optative, or imprecative, than obligative: as is manifest by the Instance, which dIo. Coch gives us ex Gem. Moed Caton. Two men having mutually excommunicated each other, it commeth to an authoritative decision. He that had excommunicated the other, for that for which he ought to have been punished by a pecuniall mulct, but not by excommunication, was himself justly excommunicate by the other, according to the last of the 24. causes of excommunication before mentioned, that is, that he who unjustly excommunicateth another, shall be himselfe excommunicated. So the excommunicating of the one man for a civill injury was declared null: and the excommunicating of the other, for his unjust act of excommunication, was ratified. Which doth not onely prove what I have said of private, or extrajudiciall excommunication: but also confirme what I asserted before, concerning the causes of excommunication, that it was not for personall or civill injuries, but for matter of scandall. And that pecuniary mulcts and excommunication, were not inflicted for the same but for different causes. And so much for the authority.
dAnnot Gem in Ex. Sanhedrin. p. 147. R. Simon, si•. Lakisch custodiebat hortum. venit quidam & ficus caepit vovare. Ille inclamare: hic non nauci facere. Tum ille▪ excommunicatus esto. Tu vicissim inquit alter excommunicatus esto. Nam si ad pecuniam tibi obstrictus sum, numquid anathemati obnoxius sum? Adiit R. Lakisch super hoc Scholae rectores. Responsum est: Ipsius Anathema anathema est▪ tuum nullum est.
The effects of excommunication were ethese. He might not be admitted into an Assembly of ten persons. He might not sit within four cubits to his neighbour. He might not shave▪ his hair, nor wash himself. It was not lawful to eat nor drink with him. He that dyed in excommunication got no Funerals, nor was there any mourning made for him, but a stone was set over him, to signify that he was worthy to be ⟨p. 49⟩stoned, because he did not repent, and because he was separated from the Church. An excommunicate person might not make up the number of ten, where there were nine. The reason was because he might not be acknowledged for a Church Member, or one who could make up a lawful Assembly. Drusius de tribus sectis Judaeorum lib. 3. cap. 11. draweth two consequences from that excommunication of the Cuthites before mentioned. 1. That it was not lawful for a Jew, to eat bread with a Samaritan. 2. That the Samaritans were cut off from the Jewish Church, and that without hope of regress, being Shammatized.
The effects of excommunication were ethese. He might not be admitted into an Assembly of ten persons. He might not sit within foure cubits to his neighbour. He might not shave▪ his hair, nor wash himself. It was not lawfull to eat nor drinke with him. He that dyed in excommunication got no Funerals, nor was there any mourning made for him, but a stone was set over him, to signifie that he was worthy to be ⟨p. 49⟩stoned, because he did not repent, and because he was separated from the Church. An excommunicate person might not make up the number of ten, where there were nine. The reason was because he might not be acknowledged for a Church Member, or one who could make up a lawfull Assembly. Drusius de tribus sectis Judaeorum lib. 3. cap. 11. draweth two consequences from that excommunication of the Cuthites before mentioned. 1. That it was not lawfull for a Jew, to eat bread with a Samaritan. 2. That the Samaritans were cut off from the Jewish Church, and that without hope of regresse, being Shammatized.
eBuxtorf. Lexion Chald. Talm. & Rab. p. 1305. 828.
It is more disputable, how far forth Excommunication did deprive a man of the liberty of access into the Temple. The Talmudists hold, that of old an Excommunicate person might enter into the Temple, yet so as he might be known that he was Excommunicate. It is said in Pirke Rabb. Elieser cap. 17. that Solomon built two Gates, one for Bride-grooms, another for Mourners and Excommunicated persons; and when the Children of Israel, sitting between these two Gates, upon the Sabbath-days and Holy-days, did see a Bride-groom come in, they knew him, and did congratulate with him: but when they saw one come in at the door of the mourners, having his Lips covered, they knew him to be a mourner, and said, He that dwells in this house, comfort thee. But when they saw one come in at the door of mourners, with his Lips not covered, they knew him to be Excommunicated, and spake to him on this manner. He that dwells in this house comfort thee, and put into thy mind, to hearken unto thy Neighbours. The like you have in codice Middoth cap. 2. Sect. 2. where it is said that ordinarily, all that came into the Temple, did enter upon the right hand; and they went out upon the left hand, those excepted to whom some sad thing had befallen; and when it was asked of such a one, why dost thou enter upon the left hand, he either answered, that he was a mourner, and then it was said to him, He that dwells in this house comfort thee, or he answered, because I am Excommunicate (so readeth Buxtorf) or quia ego contaminatus rejicior (so readeth l' Empereur) and then it was said to him, He that dwells in this house, put into thy mind, to hearken to the words of thy companions, that they may restore thee. The same ⟨p. 50⟩thing is cited e libro Musar by Drusius praeter. lib. 4. in Jo. 9. 22. His opinion is that [Greek or Hebrew] those that were separate and excommunicate by the lesser excommunication, were admitted into the Temple, in the manner aforesaid: but that they were not admitted into the Synagogue: because its added in libro Musar, (which I find also added in the fore-mentioned place of Pirke R Elies.) that after the temple was destroyed, it was decreed, that Bride-grooms and Mourners should come into the Synagogues, and that they in the Synagogue, should congratulate with the one, & condole with the other.
It is more disputable, how farre forth Excommunication did deprive a man of the liberty of accesse into the Temple. The Talmudists hold, that of old an Excommunicate person might enter into the Temple, yet so as he might be known that he was Excommunicate. It is said in Pirke Rabb. Elieser cap. 17. that Solomon built two Gates, one for Bride-grooms, another for Mourners and Excommunicated persons; and when the Children of Israel, sitting between these two Gates, upon the Sabbath-dayes and Holy-dayes, did see a Bride-groome come in, they knew him, and did congratulate with him: but when they saw one come in at the doore of the mourners, having his Lips covered, they knew him to be a mourner, and said, He that dwells in this house, comfort thee. But when they saw one come in at the doore of mourners, with his Lips not covered, they knew him to be Excommunicated, and spake to him on this manner. He that dwells in this house comfort thee, and put into thy minde, to hearken unto thy Neighbours. The like you have in codice Middoth cap. 2. Sect. 2. where it is said that ordinarily, all that came into the Temple, did enter upon the right hand; and they went out upon the left hand, those excepted to whom some sad thing had befallen; and when it was asked of such a one, why dost thou enter upon the left hand, he either answered, that he was a mourner, and then it was said to him, He that dwells in this house comfort thee, or he answered, because I am Excommunicate (so readeth Buxtorf) or quia ego contaminatus rejicior (so readeth l' Empereur) and then it was said to him, He that dwells in this house, put into thy minde, to hearken to the words of thy companions, that they may restore thee. The same ⟨p. 50⟩thing is cited e libro Musar by Drusius praeter. lib. 4. in Jo. 9. 22. His opinion is that 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 those that were separate and excommunicate by the lesser excommunication, were admitted into the Temple, in the manner aforesaid: but that they were not admitted into the Synagogue: because its added in libro Musar, (which I finde also added in the fore-mentioned place of Pirke R Elies.) that after the temple was destroyed, it was decreed, that Bride-grooms and Mourners should come into the Synagogues, and that they in the Synagogue, should congratulate with the one, & condole with the other.
Behold saith Drusius, no mention here of excommunicate persons, for they did not come into the Synagogues. Peradventure every Excommunicate person, had not access to the Temple neither, but he that was extrajudicially, or by private persons excommunicate, as those words might seem to intimate, He that dwells in this house put into thy mind, to hearken to thy neighbours or companions, that they may restore thee. Or if you take it to extend to judicial excommunication, then Hen. Vorstius doth expound it, animad. in Pirke p. 169. fso, as it may be understood only of the lesser excommunication, when there was still hope of repentance, and reconciliation. So Jo. Coch. ubi supra pag. 149. thinks that an excommunicate person was not altogether cast out of the Synagogue, but was permitted to hear, and to be partaker of the Doctrine, but otherwise and in other things he was separate, and not acknowledged for a Church Member; and this he saith of [Greek or Hebrew] menudde, of him that was simply excommunicate by the lesser excommunication or Niddui. But he saith otherwise of him that was excommunicate with Cherem. Non docet, non docetur. He is neither permitted to teach, nor to be taught. Grotius on Luke 6. 22. tells us, that excommunicate persons under Niddui, came no otherwise to the Temple than Heathens did, that is, had no liberty to come into the Court of Israel. However, such as were excommunicate by Cherem were not permitted to come near the Temple, saith Master Weemse in his Christian Synag. p. 138. An excommunicate person of the first sort, (Niddui,) when he came to the Temple, or Synagogue, you see (by what hath been said) he was there publicly bearing his shame, and looked upon as one separate from the ⟨p. 51⟩Communion of the people of God. And so much for the effects.
Behold saith Drusius, no mention here of excommunicate persons, for they did not come into the Synagogues. Peradventure every Excommunicate person, had not accesse to the Temple neither, but he that was extrajudicially, or by private persons excommunicate, as those words might seeme to intimate, He that dwells in this house put into thy mind, to hearken to thy neighbours or companions, that they may restore thee. Or if you take it to extend to judiciall excommunication, then Hen. Vorstius doth expound it, animad. in Pirke p. 169. fso, as it may be understood onely of the lesser excommunication, when there was still hope of repentance, and reconciliation. So Io. Coch. ubi supra pag. 149. thinks that an excommunicate person was not altogether cast out of the Synagogue, but was permitted to heare, and to be partaker of the Doctrine, but otherwise and in other things he was separate, and not acknowledged for a Church Member; and this he saith of 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 menudde, of him that was simply excommunicate by the lesser excommunication or Niddui. But he saith otherwise of him that was excommunicate with Cherem. Non docet, non docetur. He is neither permitted to teach, nor to be taught. Grotius on Luke 6. 22. tells us, that excommunicate persons under Niddui, came no otherwise to the Temple than Heathens did, that is, had no liberty to come into the Court of Israel. However, such as were excommunicate by Cherem were not permitted to come neere the Temple, saith Master Weemse in his Christian Synag. p. 138. An excommunicate person of the first sort, (Niddui,) when he came to the Temple, or Synagogue, you see (by what hath been said) he was there publikely bearing his shame, and looked upon as one separate from the ⟨p. 51⟩Communion of the people of God. And so much for the effects.
fDe his meritò dubitari potest, num licuerit ipsis sacra adire limina, imprimis qui severi•i ex communicationis genere vel [Greek or Hebrew] multati erant. Quis enim dicat Apostatam, blasphemum, al•áque sacra capita intra Templum suisse admissa? De [Greek or Hebrew] alia ratio •sse potest, eum his spes veniae non fuerit adempta.De his meritò dubitari potest, num licuerit ipsis sacra adire limina, imprimis qui severi•i ex communicationis genere vel 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 multati erant. Quis enim dicat Apostatam, blasphemum, al•áque sacra capita intra Templum suisse admissa? De 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 alia ratio •sse potest, eum his spes veniae non fuerit adempta.
. Hence Protestant writers draw an argument against Papists, to overthrow their infallibility of Councels: unto which argument Bellarmine deviseth foure answers. But it came not once into his thoughts, to reply that this councell was civill, not Ecclesiasticall, which had been his best answer, if any probability for it. It hath been supposed, both by Protestant, and Popish Writers, that it was an Ecclesiasticall Councell, such as the controversie is about: otherwise our Argument had been as impertinent, as their answer was insufficient. 4. Our opposites have no evasion here, but that which Bilson, Saravia, and others of the Prelaticall party did answer in opposition to ruling Elders; namely, that the Jewish Elders were Judges or Magistrates; But the reply which served then, will serve now:
. but all judgement in whatsovever civill, or criminall offences, falling out among the Jews, meant by matters of wrong or wicked leudness,
. And having left to the Jewes no government, nor any power of judgement, except in things pertaining to their religion onely Ib. verse 15. These six things considered, it is very unprobable (if not unpossible) that the Councell of the Priests, Elders, and Scribes, mentioned so often in the New Testament, should be no Ecclesiasticall Court, but a temporall and civill Magistracy. The Centurists Cent. 1. lib. 1. cap. 10. reckon that Councell for an Ecclesiasticall Court, distinct from civill Magistracy: and they propose these two to be distinctly treated of, Acta coram Pontificibus seu Magistratu Ecclesiastico, (and here they bring in the councell of the Priests, Elders, and Scribes,) And Actio coram Pilato seu magistratu politico.
. it was in a sudden passion, being cut to the heart at that which they heard. But Gamaliel tels them
⟨p. 31⟩
Verse 35. Ye men of Israel take heed to your selves 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 warning them as Interpreters take it, of their own danger, from the Romans, if they should put any one to death.
•
•
⟨p. 32⟩
onely an impertinent reply, but a yeelding to Pilates intention;
Cornelius Bertramus thinks that to the Jewish Niddui answereth our suspension from the Sacrament, and that to their cherem answereth our excommunication from the Church: and that the Jewes had the very same kind of excommunication, by which the incestuous Corinthian, Hymeneus and Philetus, and the Emperour Theodosius were excommunicated. Constansinus l' Empereur annot. in rempub. Jud. pag. 370. to 378.
q
Quest. & Resp. l. 1. quaest. 9 Solebant autem veteres (I• der) si qu• gravius deliquerat, primum eum movere caetu Ecclesiastico: si non emendabat se, tum feriebant […]: quòd si ne tum quidem redibat ad srugem, ultimo ac postremo loco samatizabant.Quest. & Resp. l. 1. quaest. 9 Solebant autem veteres (I• der) si qu• gravius deliquerat, primum eum movere caetu Ecclesiastico: si non emendabat se, tum feriebant 〈…〉: quòd si ne tum quidem redibat ad srugem, ultimo ac postremo loco samatizabant.
rAnnot. in Exc. Gemar. Sanhedrin cap. 1. Qui simpliciter excommunicatus est (menudde) est ille quidem separatus à caetu, ita ut pro vero membro Ecclesie non habeatur.
sLexicon pentaglot. pag. 655. [Greek or Hebrew] Excommunicatio, cum quis se non emendans catu Ecclesiastico •ovetur, & ex populo suo excinditur. Where he also mentioneth the three distinct kinds of Excommunication Niddui, Cherem, and Schammata. Ibid. pag. 1076. [Greek or Hebrew] remetio, excommunicatio, ejectio ex caetu piorum, illa anathematis species, qua quis immundus ab bominum contubernio, aut qua aliquis • caetu Ecclesiastico removetur ad tempus▪ à lege praescriptum.Lexicon pentaglot. pag. 655. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 Excommunicatio, cum quis se non emendans catu Ecclesiastico •ovetur, & ex populo suo excinditur. Where he also mentioneth the three distinct kinds of Excommunication Niddui, Cherem, and Schammata. Ibid. pag. 1076. 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 remetio, excommunicatio, ejectio ex caetu piorum, illa anathematis species, qua quis immundus ab bominum contubernio, aut qua aliquis • caetu Ecclesiastico removetur ad tempus▪ à lege praescriptum.
tDe arcano sermone cap. 47. Ejectio autem è Synagega, communicationis abnegatio est, & abalienatio a religiosa consuetudine, quae á nostris recepto jam verbo sixcommunicatio dicitur.
uMagdeb. Cent. 1. •ib. 1. cap 7. Judicabant degmata & promulgobant eorum damnationes, unà cum personis: quae quidem res▪ nihil aliud quam publica Excommunicatio erat Jo. 9. 22. & 11. 47. 48. & 1•. 4•. Et infra. Extra Synagogam fieret, ▪hoc est excommunicaretur.
x[…] ▪ Ebr. cap 7. legis sanctio triplex &c. Prima est [Greek or Hebrew] aversatio, antolitio & amandatio &c. Secunda est [Greek or Hebrew] devo• extremo cuidam exitio. Excommunicatio: quando videlicet a•quis excindi duebatur ex populo sue, & in eo amplius non censeri (ut jam supra expo▪ suimus) ex majore aliquo delicto. atque hoc p•to esse [Greek or Hebrew] fieri &c. Primae illae speciei respondet quod in Ecclesiis nostris vocamus prohibitionem seu suspensionem à Sacramentis: […] Excommunicatio publice facta.〈…〉▪ Ebr. cap 7. legis sanctio triplex &c. Prima est 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 aversatio, antolitio & amandatio &c. Secunda est 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 devo• extremo cuidam exitio. Excommunicatio: quando videlicet a•quis excindi duebatur ex populo sue, & in eo amplius non censeri (ut jam supra expo▪ suimus) ex majore aliquo delicto. atque hoc p•to esse 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 fieri &c. Primae illae speciei respondet quod in Ecclesiis nostris vocamus prohibitionem seu suspensionem à Sacramentis: 〈…〉 Excommunicatio publice facta.