Chapter 3
pp. 48–10449 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
They seem to be parts of Worship relatively, as they are in conjunction with the holy things of God. The Cross is so interwoven with Baptism in the administration of it, that it looks like a part of it. Before Baptism the Minister prays for those that are dedicated to God; and that dedication is, as ⟨p. 98⟩the Canon tells us, by the Cross. After Baptism, thanks are given that the Child is received into the Congregation, and this is done by the Cross also: For upon making the Cross, the Minister saith, We receive this Child into the Congregation. 1Thus, as Mr. Parker hath noted, the Cross is incorporated into Baptism in the administration of it. They are knit together, à priori & à posteriori, by the precedent and subsequent Prayers.
- 1Parker Of the Cross fol. 115.
Moreover, they seem to be parts of Worship reputatively, as they are highly valued. Our Saviour charges the Pharisees, that they preferred their Traditions above the Commands of God, Matt. 15.3, 6, 9. Their Corban swallowed up their duty to Parents. The Jews say, that there is more in the words of the Scribes, than in the words of the Law; and that it were better to die, than to violate a Tradition. Our Divines charge the very same thing upon the Papists. Whitaker tells Duraeus, That it was a greater Offence,1 Quadragesimam violare quam Dei verbum contemnere, to break Lent, than to despise the ⟨p. 99⟩Word of God. Gregorius Hemburgius, 2Doctor of Law, was wont to say, That for many years men might speak more freely, de potestate Dei quàm Papae, of the Power of God, than of the Pope. And what is the value that is now upon Ceremonies among our selves? Hath there not been too high a rate set upon them? May we not complain in the words of St. Cyprian, 3Divina praecepta solvit, & praeterit humana traditio. Human Tradition dissolves and passes over Divine Precepts? It is apparent, that if Learning and Piety could have outweighed a Ceremony, many Worthy and Excellent Persons had been now in the Church, who are at this time out of it. I may add, it is also clear, that if that Heat and Zeal which hath run out against Nonconformity, could have been turned against Impiety and Profaneness, we had now been a much more excellent People than at this time we are. It was often the complaint of Erasmus, 4Divina contemni, Humana urgeri. That Divine things were contemned, and Human urged. If this should be our case, it ⟨p. 100⟩would be no wonder at all for men to say, that the Ceremonies are made parts of Worship.
- 1Tom 1.206.
- 2
Thus much touching the Ceremonies: And if what hath been alleged against them be true, the Separation of the Nonconformists can hardly be imagined to be without cause. But because not only the Ceremonies, but some other terms lay as blocks in their way; I shall add one short word more. They were by an Act of Uniformity deprived of their People, and their People of them. They could not come up to the terms of a public Ministry, neither would their People come to the public Ordinances; in this, which I take it, was their case, it is extreme hard to charge criminous Schism upon them. When the Emperor put Chrysostom out of his Church,1 the Joannites separated from the Public, and those not only People, but Bishops and Presbyters; yet I do not know that they were charged with the crime of Schism for it.2 When Eustathius Bishop of Antioch was banished, many people and Ministers left the Public ⟨p. 101⟩Assemblies. Yet I find not that these Separations were charged with the crime of Schism. The Nonconformists being in the same, or a very like case, Charity would make the same construction of them. Thus much touching the sixth Character. Now I proceed to the last.
Thus much touching the Ceremonies: And if what hath been alledged against them be true, the Separation of the Nonconformists can hardly be imagined to be without cause. But because not only the Ceremonies, but some other terms lay as blocks in their way; I shall add one short word more. They were by an Act of Ʋniformity deprived of their People, and their People of them. They could not come up to the terms of a publick Ministry, neither would their People come to the publick Ordinances; in this, which I take it, was their case, it is extream hard to charge criminous Schism upon them. When the Emperor put Chrysostom out of his Church,1 the Joannites separated from the Publick, and those not only People, but Bishops and Presbyters; yet I do not know that they were charged with the crime of Schism for it.2 When Eustathius Bishop of Antioch was banished, many people and Ministers left the Publick ⟨p. 101⟩
7thly. Schismatical Separation is not only from a particular Church, but from the Catholic one. It is a memorable Passage of the Reverend Usher, whose words I shall transcribe. Neither particular Persons, 1nor particular Churches, are to work as several divided Bodies by themselves (which is the ground of all Schism) but are to teach, and to be taught, and to do all other Christian Duties, as parts conjoined to the whole, and Members of the same Commonwealth or Corporation. The Excellent Davenant, 2in his Rules for Peace, saith, Proscindi nec debent nec possunt à communione particularium Ecclesiarum, quae manent conjunctae cum Ecclesiâ Catholicâ; Those may not be cut off from communion with particular Churches, who remain joined to the Catholic ⟨p. 102⟩Church. I may add, Those may not be esteemed Schismatics by any particular Church, who are in conjunction with the Universal. Schismatical Separation is not only from a particular Church, but from the Universal. And is it thus with the Nonconformists? Do they separate from the Church-Catholic? I take it they do not; and for this I shall lay down two or three things.
7thly. Schismatical Separation is not only from a particular Church, but from the Catholick one. It is a memorable Passage of the Reverend Ʋsher, whose words I shall transcribe. Neither particular Persons, 1nor particular Churches, are to work as several divided Bodies by themselves (which is the ground of all Schism) but are to teach, and to be taught, and to do all other Christian Duties, as parts conjoined to the whole, and Members of the same Commonwealth or Corporation. The Excellent Davenant, 2in his Rules for Peace, saith, Proscindi nec debent nec possunt à communione particularium Ecclesiarum, quae manent conjunctae cum Ecclesiâ Catholicâ; Those may not be cut off from communion with particular Churches, who remain joined to the Catholick ⟨p. 102⟩Church. I may add, Those may not be esteemed Schismaticks by any particular Church, who are in conjunction with the Universal. Schismatical Separation is not only from a particular Church, but from the Universal. And is it thus with the Nonconformists? Do they separate from the Church-Catholick? I take it they do not; and for this I shall lay down two or three things.
A Particular Church may be considered two ways, either in that which it hath in common with other particular Churches, now, or heretofore in being; or in that which it hath particular to it self. A particular Church in the first respect acts as a part of the Church-Catholic; but in the second respect it acts by it self. A Separation from a particular Church, considered in the first respect, is a separation from the Church Catholic; but a separation from it, considered in the second respect, is not so. The Nonconformists differ from our Church, not in that which it hath in common with other Churches, but in that which it hath in peculiar. They differ ⟨p. 103⟩from it in Episcopacy, so do the Foreign Churches; they differ from its Liturgy, so do the Foreign Churches, at least in part. Their Congregations are distinct, and distant from the Parochial Churches, so is one Parochial Church from another. If the Foreign Churches, notwithstanding such differences, are in unity with our Church, so are the Nonconformists. If the Nonconformists, by reason of such differences are Schismatics, what are the Foreign Churches which have the same? You will say the case is different. Those of Foreign Churches never did, as our Nonconformists do, go out from our Parochial Churches. Very true, but every local separation doth not amount to Schism; neither have others the same occasion of separation from our Churches as the Nonconformists have.
A Particular Church may be considered two ways, either in that which it hath in common with other particular Churches, now, or heretofore in being; or in that which it hath particular to it self. A particular Church in the first respect acts as a part of the Church-Catholick; but in the second respect it acts by it self. A Separation from a particular Church, considered in the first respect, is a separation from the Church Catholick; but a separation from it, considered in the second respect, is not so. The Nonconformists differ from our Church, not in that which it hath in common with other Churches, but in that which it hath in peculiar. They differ ⟨p. 103⟩from it in Episcopacy, so do the Foreign Churches; they differ from its Liturgy, so do the Foreign Churches, at least in part. Their Congregations are distinct, and distant from the Parochial Churches, so is one Parochial Church from another. If the Foreign Churches, notwithstanding such differences, are in unity with our Church, so are the Nonconformists. If the Nonconformists, by reason of such differences are Schismaticks, what are the Foreign Churches which have the same? You will say the case is diferent. Those of Foreign Churches never did, as our Nonconformists do, go out from our Parochial Churches. Very true, but every local separation doth not amount to Schism; neither have others the same occasion of separation from our Churches as the Nonconformists have.
When a Law or Canon made by those who have particular jurisdiction in a Nation or Church, will justify Separation, and make it no Schism, then the Separation is not from the Church-Catholic. But such is the case of the Nonconformists. Should there be such a ⟨p. 104⟩Law or Canon made among us, it would justify their Separation, and make it no Schism; therefore their Separation is not from the Church Catholic.
When a Law or Canon made by those who have particular jurisdiction in a Nation or Church, will justify Separation, and make it no Schism, then the Separation is not from the Church-Catholick. But such is the case of the Nonconformists. Should there be such a ⟨p. 104⟩Law or Canon made among us, it would justify their Separation, and make it no Schism; therefore their Separation is not from the Church Catholick.
When men separate from a Church in pride, and contempt, as if they only were the Church, then the Separation is from the Church Catholic. Thus the Novatians thought that the pure Church was with them only. Thus the Donatists said, that the Church was only in part Donati. Thus the Papists say, that the Church is only in part Papae: but the Nonconformists do not do so. They acknowledge our Church to be a true Church, they are joined to it in all that which is true unity. They would further bear a part in it, if some Stumbling blocks were out of the way. By these things it may appear, that they still remain in conjunction with the Church-Catholic.
When men separate from a Church in pride, and contempt, as if they only were the Church, then the Separation is from the Church Catholick. Thus the Novatians thought that the pure Church was with them only. Thus the Donatists said, that the Church was only in parte Donati. Thus the Papists say, that the Church is only in parte Papae: but the Nonconformists do not do so. They acknowledge our Church to be a true Church, they are joined to it in all that which is true unity. They would further bear a part in it, if some Stumbling blocks were out of the way. By these things it may appear, that they still remain in conjunction with the Church-Catholick.
Thus I have gone over the Characters of Schismatical Separation; and in so doing have briefly examined the Case of the Nonconformists.
FINIS.