Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
the un-converted by your way are under no Pastoral charge, but converted by Prophets, not in Office; Pastors as Pastors exercise all pastoral acts toward these only who are members of a visible Church, as toward these only who have professed by oath subjection to their ministery, ad are partakers of the precious faith, and are the sons and daughters of the Lord God Almighty. So you teach. So by this Text, Pastors as Pastors cannot convert infidels, and we desire a warrant from Gods Word for the pastoral acts in converting soule•; yea, seeing by this place persons out of office only do convert souls by your doctrine, with all reason persons out of place should baptize, for teaching and baptizing here, and by your own doctrine are of a like extent. See to this, and satisfy us in this point of such consequence as everteth the ministry of the New Testament, which we believe our brethren intend not, being so direct Anabaptism and Socinianism, points that, we know, our dear brethren do not love or affect.
the un-converted by your way are under no Pastorall charge, but converted by Prophets, not in Office; Pastors as Pastors exercise all pastorall acts toward these onely who are members of a visible Church, as toward these onely who have professed by oath subjection to their ministery, ad are partakers of the precious faith, and are the sonnes and daughters of the Lord God Almighty. So you teach. So by this Text, Pastors as Pastors cannot convert infidels, and we desire a warrant from Gods Word for the pastorall acts in converting soule•; yea, seeing by this place persons out of office onely doe convert soules by your doctrine, with all reason persons out of place should baptize, for teaching and baptizing here, and by your owne doctrine are of a like extent. See to this, and satisfie us in this point of such consequence as everteth the ministery of the New Testament, which we believe our brethren intend not, being so direct Anabaptatisme and Socinianisme, points that, we know, our deare brethren doe not love or affect.
. Which is a Commission of the same power, and to the same •ffect; and so the Apostles and the Churches both received the same power immediately from Christ: and therefore though the Church presented their Officers chosen by themselves to receive ordination from the Apostles, […] now when the Apostles are ceased, and no other successors left in t••• room from whom their officers might receive ordination, but fr•• the Presbytery of their own Churches; where such a Presbytery
⟨p. 195⟩
is yet wanting, and is now to be erected, the Church hath full power to give ordination to them themselves, by the imposition of their hands.
The Author addeth, He who said to the Apostles, Whose sinnes ye retaine they are retained, and whose sinnes ye remit they are remitted, Joh. 20. 23. He also said to the Church, Whatsoever ye bi•• on earth shall be bound in Heaven. Math. 18. 18. Which is a Commission of the same power, and to the same •ffect; and so the Apostles and the Churches both received the same power immediately from Christ: and therefore though the Church presented their Officers chosen by themselves to receive ordination from the Apostles, 〈…〉 now when the Apostles are ceased, and no other successors left in t••• roome from whom their officers might receive ordination, but fr•• the Presbyterie of their owne Churches; where such a Presbytery ⟨p. 195⟩is yet wanting, and is now to be erected, the Church hath full power to give ordination to them themselves, by the imposition of their hands.
Answ. If the Reverend Author had framed an Argument here, it should have been thus: Those who have received immediately from God a Commission of the same power, and to the same effect, by the Text Math. 18. 18. Which the Apostles of our Lord received by the Text, Joh. 20. 23. These may do what the Apostles did in ordaining of Elders, seeing they are the successors of the Apostles, where there be no Elders.
Answ. If the Reverend Authour had framed an Argument here, it should have been thus: Those who have received immediately from God a Commission of the same power, and to the same effect, by the Text Math. 18. 18. Which the Apostles of our Lord received by the Text, Joh. 20. 23. These may doe what the Apostles did in ordaining of Elders, seeing they are the successors of the Apostles, where there be no Elders.
But the Church of believers received the same Commission, Matth. 18. 18. which the Apostle did Joh. 20. 23. and where Elders are wanting in the Church, the Church of believers is their successors. Erge. &c.
But the Church of believers received the same Commission, Matth. 18. 18. which the Apostle did Joh. 20. 23. and where Edders are wanting in the Church, the Church of believers is their successors. Erge. &c.
First, the assumption is false; for if the Church receive the same Commission Math. 28. The Apostles received Joh. 20. and you must add Math. 28. 19. for the same Commission is given to the Apostles, Math. 28. 19. which is given Joh. 20. 23. But the Disciples received Commission, Joh. 20. and Math. 28. of Pastoral binding and loosing, and preaching, by virtue of their Office; and to administer the Sacraments in their own persons, as you grant: therefore the Church of believers received commission from Christ (where Presbyters are not) to preach by virtue of an Office, and administer the Sacraments in their own persons. Ergo, the Church of believers may, where there is no Presbytery, preach by verve of an Office, and administer the Sacraments. You will happily say, there is no such necessity of baptizing as of ordination of Ministers, and baptizing is incommunicable, because we read not that any in the Apostolic Church baptized, but Pastors. I answer, there is, in an extraordinary necessity where there are no Presbyters at all, as little necessity of ordination if there be Presbyters in other Congregations to ordain▪ And since you never read that any in the Apostolic Church ordained Pastors, but Pastors only; why, but we may have recourse to a Presbytery of other Congregations for ordination, as well as for baptizing; for it is petitio principii, a begging of the question, to say that baptizing is proper to Pastors, but ordination is not so. yea but ordination by precept & practice ⟨p. 196⟩is never given but to Pastors, and Elders in consociation 1 Tin. 4 14 1 Tim. 5. 22. 2 Tim. 1. 6. 2 Tim. 2. 2, 3. Tit. 1. 5. Act. 6. 6. Act. 13. 3Act. 14 23. 2. There is good reason why Pastors should be successors of the Apostles in the act of ordaining Pastors; & you grant, where Pastors and Elders are, they succeed to the Apostles in the acts of ordination; but that all believers men and women should be the Apostles successors to ordain Pastors, is a rare and unknown case of Divinity, for 1 Cor. 12. 29. Are all Apostles? are all Prophets? Yea, not long ago you said that Act. 1. an hundred and twenty, amongst whom there were women, had all hand in the ordination of Matthias to be an Apostle; so that believers by you are made the Apostles successors; and more, yea even co-ordainers, and joint-layers on of hands with the Apostles.
First, the assumption is false; for if the Church receive the same Commission Math. 28. The Apostles received Joh. 20. and you must adde Math. 28. 19. for the same Commission is given to the Apostles, Math. 28. 19. which is given Joh. 20. 23. But the Disciples received Commission, Ioh. 20. and Math. 28. of Pastorall binding and loosing, and preaching, by vertue of their Office; and to administer the Sacraments in their owne persons, as you grant: therefore the Church of believers received commission from Christ (where Presbyters are not) to preach by vertue of an Office, and administer the Sacraments in their owne persons. Ergo, the Church of believers may, where there is no Presbytery, preach by verue of an Office, and administer the Sacraments. You will happily say, there is no such necessity of baptizing as of ordination of Ministers, and baptizing is incommunicable, because we read not that any in the Apostolique Church baptized, but Pastors. I answer, there is, in an extraordinary necessity where there are no Presbyters at all, as little necessity of ordination if there be Presbyters in other Congregations to ordaine▪ And since you never read that any in the Apostolique Church ordained Pastors, but Pastors onely; why, but we may have recourse to a Presbytery of other Congregations for ordination, as well as for baptizing; for it is petitio principii, a begging of the question, to say that baptizing is proper to Pastors, but ordination is not so. yea but ordination by precept & practice ⟨p. 196⟩is never given but to Pastors, and Elders in consociation 1 Tin. 4 14 1 Tim. 5. 22. 2 Tim. 1. 6. 2 Tim. 2. 2, 3. Tit. 1. 5.
Yea, if believers received immediately this same Commission from Christ, Math. 18. which the Apostles received Joh. 20. Believers are to ordain Pastors no less, when the Presbytery and Elders are present, then when they are absent; yea, and rather then the Apostles, because the Church of believers their patent passed the Seals first, even before the Lords resurrection. 3. It is good you grant that ordination and election are different, we will make use of it hereafter.
Yea, if believers received immediately this same Commission from Christ, Math. 18. which the Apostles received Ioh. 20. Believers are to ordaine Pastors no lesse, when the Presbytery and Elders are present, then when they are absent; yea, and rather then the Apostles, because the Church of beleevers their patent passed the Seales first, even before the Lords resurrection. 3. It is good you grant that ordination and election are different, we will make use of it hereafter.
The Author addeth, We willingly also acknowledge, where God 1hath furnished a Church with a Presbytery, to them it appertaineth by imposition of hands to ordain Elders and Deacons chosen by the Church; but if the Church want a Presbytery, they want a Warrant to repair to other Churches to receive imposition of hands to their Elders. 1. Because ordination is a work of Church power, now as Church hath power over another, so no Presbytery hath power over another Church then their own; All the Apostles received alike power, Joh. 20. 23. 2 The power of the keys is a liberty purchased by Christs blood, Math. 28. 8. Phil. 2. 8, 9 10. Therefore it is unlawful for any Church to put over that power into the hands of another.
The Authour addeth, We willingly also acknowledge, where God 1hath furnished a Church with a Presbytery, to them it appertaineth by imposition of hands to ordaine Elders and Deacons chosen by the Church; but if the Church want a Presbytery, they want a Warrant to repaire to other Churches to receive imposition of hands to their Elders. 1. Because ordination is a worke of Church power, now as Church hath power over another, so no Presbytery hath power over another Church then their owne; All the Apostles received alike power, Ioh. 20. 23. 2 The power of the keyes is a liberty purchased by Christs blood, Math. 28. 8. Phil. 2. 8, 9 10. Therefore it is unlawfull for any Church to put over that power into the hands of another.
Answ. We desire a warrant from Gods Word, where Elders, where they are present, are to ordain Elders by imposition of hands, and not believers; for ordination is a work of the Church; Officers are not the Church, nor are they parts or members of the Church, but only accidents; the Church hath its full being, ⟨p. 197⟩the power and use of the Keys given to them by Math. 18. though there be not a Pastor or Officer among them; and if Christ before his resurrection gave the Keys to believers as to his Spouse, living body, and such as have Peters faith Math. 16. Resolve us, we beseech you brethren, in this, how Christ can give the Keys after his resurrection, Joh. 20. 23. to the Apostles as Pastors, and as no believers, not his Spouse, not his body; for Officers, as Officers, are not the redeemed of God, nor Christs Spouse. If you say that Christ, Joh. 20. gave the Keys to his Disciples as believers, then he gave the power of baptizing after his resurrection also, by the parallel place Math. 28. 19. to the Apostles as to believers. Hence 1. Christ hath never given the Keys to Officers as Officers. 2. The place Joh. 20. is but a renewing of the Keys given to the Church, Math. 16. and Math. 18. and all believers are sent and called to be Pastors, as the Father sent Christ, and as Christ sent his Apostles, as our Lord speaketh, John 20. 21. This I think all good men will abhor, though M. Smith saith these words, and that power John 20. 21. was given to Cleo•has and Mary Magdalen. And by your way, Paul (as I think) without warrant interdicted women of the use of that power, that Christ purchased by his blood. 3. There is no warrant of the Word to make good, that Christ gave the Keys to Officers as Officers, by your way, but only to Officers as to believers; and therefore believers ought rather to ordain Pastors then the Officers, though there be Officers to ordain. 3. That Pastors of other Congregations may not ordain Pastors to Congregations, who have no Pastors of their own. as they may baptize infants to them also, we see no reason.
Answ. We desire a warrant from Gods Word, where Elders, where they are present, are to ordaine Elders by imposition of hands, and not believers; for ordination is a worke of the Church; Officers are not the Church, nor are they parts or members of the Church, but onely accidents; the Church hath its full being, ⟨p. 197⟩the power and use of the Keyes given to them by Math. 18. though there be not a Pastor or Officer among them; and if Christ before his resurrection gave the Keyes to beleevers as to his Spouse, living body, and such as have Peters faith Math. 16. Resolve us, we beseech you brethren, in this, how Christ can give the Keyes after his resurrection, Ioh. 20. 23. to the Apostles as Pastors, and as no believers, not his Spouse, not his body; for Officers, as Officers, are not the redeemed of God, nor Christs Spouse. If you say that Christ, Ioh. 20. gave the Keyes to his Disciples as beleevers, then he gave the power of baptizing after his resurrection also, by the parallel place Math. 28. 19. to the Apostles as to beleevers. Hence 1. Christ hath never given the Keyes to Officers as Officers. 2. The place Ioh. 20. is but a renewing of the Keyes given to the Church, Math. 16. and Math. 18. and all believers are sent and called to be Pastors, as the Father sent Christ, and as Christ sent his Apostles, as our Lord speaketh, John 20. 21. This I thinke all good men will abhorre, though M. Smith saith these words, and that power Iohn 20. 21. was given to Cleo•has and Mary Magdalen. And by your way, Paul (as I thinke) without warrant interdicted women of the use of that power, that Christ purchased by his blood. 3. There is no warrant of the Word to make good, that Christ gave the Keyes to Officers as Officers, by your way, but onely to Officers as to beleevers; and therefore believers ought rather to ordaine Pastors then the Officers, though there be Officers to ordaine. 3. That Pastors of other Congregations may not ordaine Pastors to Congregations, who have no Pastors of their owne. as they may baptize infants to them also, we see no reason.
Yea, and Church power is not a thing that cannot be communicated to another Church by your Doctrine, for ye grant members of one Congregation may receive the Lords Supper in another Congregation, except you deny all communion of sister Churches, for it is a work of Church power to give the Lords Supper to any, then if you give that Sacrament to members of another Congregation; consider if the liberty purchased by Christs Blood be not communicable to other Churches.
Yea, and Church power is not a thing that cannot be communicated to another Church by your Doctrine, for ye grant members of one Congregation may receive the Lords Supper in another Congregation, except you deny all communion of sister Churches, for it is a worke of Church power to give the Lords Supper to any, then if you give that Sacrament to members of another Congregation; consider if the liberty purchased by Christs Blood be not communicable to other Churches.
Thirdly, (saith he) if one Church repair to another Church for ordination, they may submit to another Church for ⟨p. 198⟩censuring of offenders, now how can Churches censure these that are not members? Is not this a transgression of the Royal Law of government? Mat. 18. 15, 16, 17, 18.
Thirdly, (saith he) if one Church repaire to another Church for ordination, they may submit to another Church for ⟨p. 198⟩censuring of offenders, now how can Churches censure these that are not members? Is not this a transgression of the Royall Law of governement? Mat. 18. 15, 16, 17, 18.
Answ. The offence being great, and the offender deserving to be cast out of all the visible congregations round about, yea and to be bound in Earth and Heaven, the congregation is to have recourse to all the congregations consociated, when they are convened in one presbytery; that they, being convened in their principal members, may all cast him out, because it concerneth them all: as if only one congregation do it, they transgress that royall Law, Quod omnes tangit, ab omnibus tractari debet. 2. The Author granteth, that the Church presented 1their officers chosen by them, to receive ordination from the Apostles; Ergo, The Church did give a way their liberty of ordination, bought by Christs blood, to the Apostles, not as to Apostles, but as to pastors: which is against our Brethren's Doctrine; for except the Apostles be said to ordain Officers, as Pastors, and not as Apostles, our Brethren shall find none to be the successors of Apostles in the power of ordination, but only Believers; so Pastors have no power at all to ordain Pastors, the contrary whereof our Brethren teach.
Answ. The offence being great, and the offender deserving to be cast out of all the visible congregations round about, yea and to be bound in Earth and Heaven, the congregation is to have recourse to all the congregations consociated, when they are convened in one presbytery; that they, being convened in their principall members, may all cast him out, because it concerneth them all: as if onely one congregation doe it, they transgesse that royall Law, Quod omnes tangit, ab omnibus tractari debet. 2. The Author granteth, that the Church presented 1their officers chosen by them, to receive ordination from the Apostles; Ergo, The Church did give a way their liberty of ordination, bought by Christs bloud, to the Apostles, not as to Apostles, but as to pastors: which is against our Brethrens Doctrine; for except the Apostles bee said to ordaine Officers, as Pastors, and not as Apostles, our Brethren shall find none to be the successors of Apostles in the power of ordination, but onely Believers; so Pastors have no power at all to ordaine Pastors, the contrary whereof our Brethren teach.
Now I come to the Brethren's mind in their Questions. It was objected aHow can it be lawful for mere lay and private men to ordain Elders? they answer, the persons ordaining are the public assembly, and so cannot, in any congruity of speech, be called mere Lay-men.
Now I come to the Brethrens minde in their Questions. It was objected aHow can it be lawfull for meere lay and private men to ordaine Elders? they answer, the persons ordaining are the publick assembly, and so cannot, in any congruity of speech, be called meere Lay-men.
I answ. Seeing they have no Church office, they can be nothing, but mere private men; For the unwarrantable action of ordination maketh them not public Officers. As if a Midwife baptize in the name of the Church, she is not a mere private person.
I answ. Seeing they have no Church office, they can be nothing, but meere private men; For the unwarrantable action of ordination maketh them not publick Officers. As if a Midwife baptize in the name of the Church, shee is not a meere private person.
2. They say, The Church hath power from Christ for the greater, to wit, for Election; Ergo, she hath power to do the less, which is ordination; or ordination dependeth upon Election, and it is nothing but the putting of a person in actual possession of that office, whereunto he had right by Election.
2. They say, The Church hath power from Christ for the greater, to wit, for Election; Ergo, she hath power to doe the lesse, which is ordination; or ordination dependeth upon Election, and it is nothing but the putting of a person in actuall possession of that office, wherunto he had right by Election.
Answ. Ordination, by your own grant, is more then Election, for the Apostles ordained, Acts 6. and must have done ⟨p. 199⟩the most, and the multitude elected the seven Deacons, Acts 6 2. Ordination is more then the installing of a person chosen, it is a supernatural act of the Presbytery separating a man to an holy calling, election is posterior to it, and is but an appropriation of a called person his Ministry, to such a particular flock.
Answ. Ordination, by your owne grant, is more then Election, for the Apostles ordained, Acts 6. and must have done ⟨p. 199⟩the most, and the multitude elected the seaven Deac̄ons, Acts 6 2. Ordination is more then the installing of a person chosen, it is a supernaturall act of the Presbytery separating a man to an holy calling, election is posterior to it, and is but an appropriation of a called person his Ministery, to such a particular flock.
3. Say they; Ordination may be performed by the Elders, where there be Elders, 1 Tim. 4. 14. yet it is an act of the whole Church, as 1the whole man seeth, but by the Eye.
4. They object, when the Church hath no Officers, the prime grave m•n perform ordination; as Nu•. 8, The Israelites laid on Hands on the Levites, that is, some prime Man laid on hands.
4. They object, when the Church hath no Officers, the prime grave m•n performe ordination; as Nu•. 8, The Israelites layd on Hands on the Levites, that is, some prime Man layd on hands.
5. They object; If B lievers may not ordain, it shall follow either that Officers may minister without ordination, against the Scripture, 1 Tim. 4. 14. Heb. 6. 1. or, by virtue of ordination received in another Church, they might minister. Now if this be, we establish an i•d•l•ble character of Papists, but if being called to another Church, there be need of a new Election, then there is need of a new ordination, for that dependeth upon this; Ergo, then ordination cometh by succession, but we see not what authority ordinary officers have to ordain Pastors to a Church, whereof themselves are not members.
5. They object; If B lievers may not ordaine, it shall follow either that Officers may minister without ordination, against the Sripture, 1 Tim. 4. 14. Heb. 6. 1. or, by vertue of ordination received in another Church, they might minister. Now if this be, we establish an i•d•l•ble character of Papists, but if being called to another Church, there be need of a new Election, then there is need of a new ordination, for that dependeth upon this; Ergo, then ordination commeth by succession, but we see not what authority ordinary officers have to ordaine Pastors to a Church, whereof themselves are not members.
Answ. 1. That ordination be wanting, where Ministers are wanting, is extraordinary, and not against, 1 Tim. 4 14. No more then that one not baptized for want of a Pastor should yet believe in Christ. 2. We see no indelible Character, because a Pastor is always a called Pastor; if the man commit scandals, the Church may call all his character from him, and turn him into a mere private man. But to renew ordination, when election to another congregation is renewed, is to speak ignorantly of ordination and election: for election maketh not the ⟨p. 200⟩man a Minister, nor giveth him a calling, but appropriateth his Ministry to such a flock. But they speak of Election to a charge as of marriage, which is not well understood, for by marriage a man is both made a Husband, and a Husband to this Wife only: by election a Pastor is not made a Pastor, by ordination he is made a Pastor of the Church Universal, though he be not made an Universal Pastor. 3. The ordination by succession of Pastors, where Pastors are, you hold your selves. But a popish personal succession, we disclaim, as well as you do:
Answ. 1. That ordination be wanting, where Ministers are wanting, is extraordinary, and not against, 1 Tim. 4 14. No more then that one not baptized for want of a Pastor should yet believe in Christ. 2. We see no indeleble Character, because a Pastor is alwayes a called Pastor; if the man commit scandals, the Church may call all his character from him, and turne him into a meere private man. But to renew ordination, when election to another congregation is renewed, is to speake ignorantly of ordination and election: for election maketh not the ⟨p. 200⟩man a Minister, nor giveth him a calling, but appropriateth his Ministery to such a flock. But they speake of Election to a charge as of marriage, which is not well understood, for by marriage a man is both made a Husband, and a Husband to this Wife onely: by election a Pastor is not made a Pastor, by ordination he is made a Pastor of the Church Universall, though hee be not made an Universall Pastor. 3. The ordination by succession of Pastors, where Pastors are, you hold your selves. But a popish personall succession, wee disclaime, as well as you doe:
The 5. Objection I omit to another time. The 6. *Objection is; If there be a magistrate before, the succeeding magistrate receiveth keys or (word from the preceding magistrate: but if there be none, he receiveth them from the people. So here.
Answ. Christs calling is not ordered according to the pattern of civill governments, his kingdom is not of this world. People may both ordain and elect to a civill office, without consent of the preceding Magistrate. But we read of no officers ordained by the people, only in an ordinary way.
Answ. Christs calling is not ordered according to the patterne of civill governments, his kingdome is not of this world. People may both ordaine and elect to a civill office, without consent of the preceding Magistrate. But we reade of no officers ordained by the people, only in an ordinary way.
Ordination (say they) is not of such eminency as is conceived, it is not mentioned in the Apostles first commission, Mat. 28, 19. Mark 16. 15, 16. The Apostles accounted preaching and praying principal. So aPerkins bWillet cWhittaker, dAmesius.
Ordination (say they) is not of such eminency as is conceived, it is not mentioned in the Apostles first commission, Mat. 28, 19. Marke 16. 15, 16. The Apostles accompted preaching and praying principall. So aPerkins bVVillet cVVhittaker, dAmesius.
aPerkins. on Gala.
bWillet synop. con. 1. 4, 3. p. 371.
cWhittaker de eccles. q. 5. c. 6.
dAmes. Bel. l•m. enerv. de cler. l. 3. de ordin. c. 2.
Answ. So answer Arminians eand so doth the Socinian fTheol. Nicolaides, and gSocinus; and so in your words saith ⟨p. 201⟩hto reform, but this is not to take away the necessity of ordination, by Pastors.
Answ. So answer Arminians eand so doth the Socinian fTheol. Nicolaides, and gSocinus; and so in your words saith ⟨p. 201⟩hto reforme, but this is not to take away the necessity of ordination, by Pastors.
eApol. Remostran. c. 21. •. 227 missio seu ordinatio Episcoporum non est •am necessaria in ecclesia constitute.Apol. Remostran. c. 21. •. 227 missio seu ordinatio Episcoporum non est •am necessaria in ecclesia constitut•.
fNicola•d. in d•s•tract. de miss. min. c. 1. •. 144. In c••ombus Apostolorum, quibus describuntur om•••. quae pertinent ad constituend•• Episcopos & Doctores, quondam nulla sit mentio missionis (ordinatio is;) h•nc concludinus eam ad ips• muneris Episcopalis substantiā & naturam nul•o modo requi•i.Nicola•d. in d•s•tract. de miss. min. c. 1. •. 144. In c••ombus Apostolorum, quibus describuntur om•••. quae pertinent ad constituend•• Episcopos & Doctores, quon•am nulla sit mentio missionis (ordinatio is;) h•nc concludinus eam ad ips• muneris Episcopalis substantiā & naturam nul•o modo requi•i.
hOstorodius in de sens. de Eccles. & miss. Ministr•. adversus M•edzeboz. c. 1. f. 10•. &. c. 2. falsum est Apostolos semper requisivisse in Ministro ordinationem.
I come now to answer, what Mr. Robinson doth add, to what is said for the ordination of Pastors by Pastors, and not by single Believers, Mr. Robinson isaith, the question is, whether succession of Pastors be of such absolute necessity, as that no Minister can in any case be made but by a Minister, and if they must be ordained by popes, and prelates.
I come now to answer, what Mr. Robinson doth adde, to what is said for the ordination of Pastors by Pastors, and not by single Believers, Mr. Robinson isaith, the question is, whether succession of Pastors be of such absolute necessity, as that no Minister can in any case be made but by a Minister, and if they must be ordained by popes, and prelates.
Answ. But we say that this is no question at all, we affirm ordination of pastors not to be of that absolute necessity, but in an exigence of necessity the election of the people, and some other thing, may supply the want of it. Nor do we think a calling from papists no calling, as we shall hear: before I proceed this must be discussed.
Answ. But we say that this is no question at all, wee affirme ordination of pastors not to be of that absolute necessity, but in an exigence of necessity the election of the people, and some other thing, may supply the want of it. Nor doe wee thinke a calling from papists no calling, as we shall heare: before I proceed this must be discussed.
•. Election we are to consider, to whom it belongeth of right. 2. The force and influence thereof to make a Church-officer; but let these considerations first be pondered.
1. Consid. Election is made either by a people gracious and able to discern, or by a people rude and ignorant; the former is valid, Jure & facto, the latter not so.
1. Consid. Election is made either by a people gratious and able to discerne, or by a people rude and ignorant; the former is valid, Jure & facto, the latter not so.
2. Consid. Election is either comparative or absolute; when Election is comparative, though people have nothing possibly positively to say against a person, yet though they reject him and choose one si•ter, the Election is reasonable.
3. Consid. Peoples Election is not of a person to the Ministry as a Wikis choice of a man to be a Husband, but of a Minister; Election doth not make a Minister.
3. Consid. Peoples Election is not of a person to the Ministery as a VVi•is choyse of a man to be a Husband, but of a Minister; Election doth not make a Minister.
4. Consid. Election is either to be looked to, quoad jus, or, quoad f•ctum. A people not yet called externally, cannot elect their own Minister, a Synod or others of charity (as Reverend Junius asaith) may choose for them, though, de facto, and in respect of their case, they cannot choose their own Pastor.
4. Consid. Election is either to be looked to, quoad jus, or, quoad f•ctum. A people not yet called externally, cannot elect their own Minister, a Synod or others of charity (as Reverend Junius asaith) may chuse for them, though, de facto, and in respect of their case, they cannot chuse their own Pastor.
aJunius contra Bellarm. de Cl•r. l. 1. c. 7.Iunius contra Bellarm. de Cl•r. l. 1. c. 7.
1. Conclus. The people have Gods right to choose, for so the bword prescribeth. So cTertullian, dEyprian. Non blandiatur sibi plebs, quasi immunis à contagione delicti esse possit, cum sacerdote peccatore communicans & ad injustum ⟨p. 202⟩atque illicitum propositi Episcopatum consensum s•um accommodans, &c. and dnefas sine consensu po•uli: and this Cyprian writ an hundred years before the Nicene Council. Bellarmine lo•ed hi• face eto say this custom began in the time of the Nicene Council. It was not a consuetude fQu•d ipsum (inquit Cyprianus) videmus de Divina autoritate descender•; gIgnatius, It is your part, as the Church of God to choose the Pastor; [Greek or Hebrew]. So speaketh he to the people of Philadelphia; and so speaketh hAmbrose to Valentinian, Omitto, quia jam ipse populus judicavit, iOrigen: Requiritur ergo in ordinando sacerd te praesentia populi, &c. and his reason is Scripture, a pastor must be of good report. And kChrysostom saith, all elections of pastors are null, [Greek or Hebrew], without the conscience of the people. And the Council of Nice did write this to the Bishops of Alexandria as lTheodoret saith, and the fi•st general council of Constantinople wrote the same to Daemasus, Ambrose, and others, as mTheodoret also showeth nThe council of Africa is cited by Cyprian producing Scripture, as Acts 1. 23. Acts 6. to prove that the people had their consent in elections; and othe council of Chalcedon pthe council of Ancyron, and qof Laodicea; and the Popes own rCanons say this, sso Nicolaus the Pope in his Decrees saith, the Clergy and people did choose the pope, Reliquus clerus & populus Romanus ad consensum nova electionis pontificis à Cardinalibus factae accedant. So tGelasius the pope writeth to Philippus and Cernuti•• Bishops, so Stephanus ad Romanum uarchiepiscopum Rav•• natensem, is cited in the gloss to that purpose; in xthe Epistles of Ivo Bishop of Chartres, we being called, by the will of God, the Clergy and people of such a City, and this Pope Ur••• practised upon Ivo.
1. Conclus. The people have Gods right to chuse, for so the bword prescribeth. So cTertullian, dEyprian. Non blandiatur sibi plebs, quasi immunis à contagione delicti esse possit, cum sacerdote peccatore communicans & ad injustum ⟨p. 202⟩atque illicitum propositi Episcopatum consensum s•um accommodans, &c. and dnefas sine consensu po•uli: and this Cyprian writ an hundreth yeeres before the Nicen Councell. Bellarmine lo•ed hi• face eto say this custome began in the time of the Nicon Councell. It was not a consuetude fQu•d ipsum (inquit Cyprianus) videmus de Divina autoritate descender•; gIgnatius, It is your part, as the Church of God to chuse the Pastor; 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. So speaketh hee to the people of Philadelphia; and so speaketh hAmbrose to Valentinian, Omitto, quia jam ipse populus judicavit, iOrigen: Requiritur ergo in ordinando sacerd te praesentia populi, &c. and his reason is Scripture, a pastor must be of good report. And kChrysostome saith, all elections of pastors are null, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, without the conscience of the people. And the Councell of Nice did write this to the Bishops of Alexandria as
2. Conclus. But elections in the ancient Church were not by one single congregation, but by the Bishops of diverse other Churches. In the ycouncil of Sardis, Si unum tantùm in provincia contigerit remanere Episcopum, suporstes Episcopus con•• care debet Episcopos vicinae provinciae. & cum iis orainare sibi comprovincales Episcopos; quod si id facero negligat, populus convocare debet Episcopos vicinae provinciae & peter• sibi rectorem. ⟨p. 203⟩In the zcouncil of Toledo it was ordained, that the Bishop of Toledo might choose in quibustibee Pr•vinciis, in any provinces about Bishops to be his successors, salvo privilegio unius•njusqu• provinciae. Cardinals are forbidden to usurp to choose a Bishop, if the see vace in the time of a general Council, this was enacted in the council of *Constance and aBasil. The Abbot of Panormo saith, it was obtained of the council of Carthage bto avoid dissension, that they should transfer their right to the Cardinals. So cAlmain and dGerson prove the equity of this by good reasons. That wicked council of Trent, labouring to exalt the popes chair, did abrogate these good acts to the offence of many, as the Author eof the review of the council of Trent showeth; nor should good men stand for Leo his abrogation of what the council of Basil did in this kind, as may be seen in that wicked council of Lateran fwherein much other wicked power is given to the pope and his Legates by Julius III. and Paul the III. and Pius the IIII. and gTheodoret saith, all the Bishops of a Province ought to be at the ordination of a Bishop. The ordination of the worthy, Ambrose, as he hhimself saith, was confirmed by all the Bishops of the East and West. Cornelius Bishop of Rome was confirmed by the Bishops of Africa. More of this may be seen in iZonaras, In kTheodoret lthe council of Carthage and mPetrus a Navarre, who all witness ordination of a Bishop was never done in the ancient Church by one single Congregation, and these destitute of pastors and Elders. The learned say, that Gregory the VII. or Hildebrand did first exclude the people from voicing in elections of pastors. Illiricus saith only from the time of Frederick the XI. about the year, 1300 they were excluded from this power. And though it were true, that the election of Alexander the III.
2. Conclus. But elections in the ancient Church were not by one single congregation, but by the Bishops of diverse other Churches. In the ycouncell of Sardis, Si unum tantùm in provincia contigerit remanere Episcopum, suporstes Episcopus con•• care debet Episcopos vicinae provinciae. & cum iis orainare sibi comprovincales Episcopos; quod si id facero negligat, populus convocare debet Episcopos vicinae provinciae & peter• sibi rectorem. ⟨p. 203⟩In the zcouncell of Toledo it was ordained, that the Bishop of Toledo might chuse in quibustibee Pr•vinciis, in any provinces about Bishops to be his successors, salvo privilegio unius•njusqu• provinciae. Cardinalls are forbidden to usurp to chuse a Bishop, if the see vace in the time of a generall Councell, this was enacted in the councell of *Constance and aBasil. The Abbot of Panormo saith, it was obtained of the councell of Carthage bto avoyde dissension, that they should transfer their right to the Cardinalls. So cAlmain and dGerson prove the equity of this by good reasons. That wicked councell of Trent, labouring to exalt the popes chaire, did abrogate these good acts to the offence of many, as the Author eof the review of the councell of Trent sheweth; nor should good men stand for Leo his abrogation of what the councell of Basil did in this kinde, as may be seene in that wicked councell of Lateran fwherein much other wicked power is given to the pope and his Legates by Iulius III. and Paul the III. and Pius the IIII. and
yConcil. Sardicens. ut ha be•ure. 3. dist. 65.
zConcil. Tolet, 12. can. 6. ut citatur cum longe dist. 63.
was made 400 years before that, by the Cardinals only, without the peoples consent, the Law and Logic both say; from one fact no Law can be concluded. Yea the election of Gregory the VII. (saith nVasquez) was five hundred years before that, and like enough that such a monster and such a seditious head to the Lords anointed to Henry the IIII, as this Gregory was, could violate Christs order. oPlatina saith so; yet Bellarmine, ⟨p. 204⟩Suarez and others grant, in the Apostles time it was so; b•• because it was a positive Law (some say) and others that it was a Church constitution, not a divine Law, the Pope might change it. Yet the Jesuit Sanctius pin his comment proveth it from Scripture, qAzorius saith, it should be common Law, communi jure, rKrantius layeth the blame of wronging the people in this, on Gregory the IX. yea sthe council of Bracare, the tsecond council of Nice; The council of Constantinople. 4 called the eight general Council uthe council of *Laodicea are corruptly expounded by xBellarmin. yVasquez and others: because. 1. They forbid only disorder and confusion. 2. That all the multitude, without exceptionosage, gifts, or sexes, should come, and speak and voice at the election. For in the council of Antioch zit is expressly forbidden that the multitude should be debarred. And we will not deny but a pastor may be sent to a Church of Infidels that knoweth nothing of Christ, without their knowledge, as aRuffinu• saith, that Frumentius was ordained Bishop to the Indians, they knowing nothing of it, Indis nihil scientibus neque cogitantibus. Epiphanius writeth to John Bishop of Jerusalem, that he had ordained Paulinianus a presbyter, the people not consenting. Gregorius ordained Augustine Bishop of England and sent him to them to teach them, Anglis nescientibus. And Gregorius II. ordained Bonifacius a Bishop to be sent to Germany, Germanis nihil de eare cogitantibus. And thus bPerkins, if the Gospel should arise in America, where there were no Ministers, ordination might be wanting. And why not (say I) election also in another case, if as cPetrus Martyr saith well; a woman may be a Preacher of the Gospel; Yea, and a Turk (saith dZanchius) converted by reading the New Testament, and converting others, may baptize them whom he converteth, and be baptized where both ordination and election should be wanting:
was made 400 yeeres before that, by the Cardinalls onely, without the peoples consent, the Law and Logick both say; from one fact no Law can be concluded. Yea the election of Gregory the VII. (saith nVasquez) was five hundred yeeres before that, and like enough that such a monster and such a seditious head to the Lords annoynted to Henry the IIII, as this Gregory was, could violate Christs order. oPlatina sayth so; yet Bellarmine, ⟨p. 204⟩Suarez and others grant, in the Apostles time it was so; b•• because it was a positive Law (some say) and others that it was a Church constitution, not a divine Law, the Pope might change it. Yet the Jesuite Sanctius pin his comment proveth it from Scripture, qAzorius sayth, it should be common Law, communi jure, rKrantius layeth the blame of wronging the people in this, on Gregory the IX. yea sthe councell of Bracare, the tsecond councell of Nice; The councell of Constantinople. 4 called the eight generall Councell uthe councell of *Laodicea are corruptly expounded by xBellarmin. yV•squez and others: because. 1. They forbid onely disorder and confusion. 2. That all the multiude, without exceptionosage, gifts, or sexes, should come, and speak and voyce at the election. For in the councell of Antioch zit is expressely forbidden that the multitude should be debarred. And wee will not deny but a pastor may be sent to a Church of Infidels that knoweth nothing of Christ, without their knowledge, as
nVasquez 3. […]. 3. disp. 144. c. 5. uum. 55.Vasquez 3. 〈…〉. 3. disp. 144. c. 5. uum. 55.
Nor did the people first begin to have hand in election in fTertullians time, as Bellarmine saith, nor yet that the people might love their Bishops, nor yet by mere custom.
Nor did the people first begin to have hand in election in fTertullians time, as Bellarmine saith, nor yet that the people might love their Bishops, nor yet by meere custome.
Conclus. III. It is false our gBrethren say, that the calling of a Minister consisteth principally and essentially in election of the people, for the Apostles were essentially pastors, yet not one of them, except Matthias was chosen by the people. 2. If, as our Brethren say, the peoples after acceptance may supply the want of Election at first, as Jacobs after consent to Leah made her his Wife, yet all the pastoral acts of Word, Sacraments, and censures going before the after consent shall be null, because he wanteth that which most principally and essentially is required in a calling. And all baptized by him must be rebaptized. And what if the people shall never assent, and it is ordinary that hypocrites in hearts will never consent to the Ministry of a gracious pastor, shall his acts of converting, and baptizing be no pastoral acts, and to the hypocrites no pastoral acts: and shall all be Infidels, who are baptized by him? The people are not infallible in their choice, and may refuse a man for a pastor, whom God hath called to be a pastor; election maketh not one a pastor, in foro Dei, then he shall be no pastor whom God hath made a Pastor, because people out of ignorance or prejudice consent not to his Ministry. Nor are we of Dr. Ames judgement, that the calling of a Minister doth essentially consist in the peoples election; for his external calling consisteth in the presbyters separation of a man for such a holy calling, as the Holy Ghost speaketh. We find no Church-calling in all Gods Word of sole election of the people, and therefore it cannot be the essential form of a right calling. All the arguments of Doctor Ames prove, that election is necessary to appropriate a made Minister to such a Congregation, but concludeth not the point.
Conclus. III. It is false our gBrethren say, that the calling of a Minister consisteth principally and essentially in election of the people, for the Apostles were essentially pastors, yet not one of them, except Matthias was chosen by the people. 2. If, as our Brethren say, the peoples after acceptance may supply the want of Election at first, as Iacobs after consent to Leah made her his Wife, yet all the pastorall acts of Word, Sacraments, and censures going before the after consent shall be null, because he wanteth that which most principally and essentially is required in a calling. And all baptized by him must be rebaptized. And what if the people shall never assent, and it is ordinary that hypocrites in hearts will never consent to the Ministry of a gratious pastor, shall his acts of converting, and baptizing be no pastorall acts, and to the hypocrites no pastorall acts: and shall all be Infidels, who are baptized by him? The people are not infallible in their choise, and may refuse a man for a pastor, whom God hath called to be a pastor; election maketh not one a pastor, in foro Dei, then he shall be no pastor whom God hath made a Pastor, because people out of ignorance or prejudice consent not to his Ministery. Nor are we of Dr. Ames judgement, that the calling of a Minister doth essentially consist in the peoples election; for his externall calling consisteth in the presbyters separation of a man for such a holy calling, as the Holy Ghost speaketh. Wee finde no Church-calling in all Gods Word of sole election of the people, and therefore it cannot be the essentiall forme of a right calling. All the arguments of Doctor Ames prove, that election is necessary to appropriate a made Minister to such a Congregation, but concludeth not the poyn.
. 2. There is good reason why Pastors should be successours of the Apostles in the act of ordaining Pastors; & you grant, where Pastors and Elders are, they succeed to the Apostles in the acts of ordination; but that all believers men and women should be the Apostles successours to ordaine Pastors, is a rare and unknowne case of Divinity, for
. an hundred and twenty, amongst whom there were women, had all hand in the ordination of Matthias to be an Apostle; so that beleevers by you are made the Apostles successours; and more, yea even co-ordainers, and joynt-layers on of hands with the Apostles.
so Nicolaus the Pope in his Decrees saith, the Clergy and people did chuse the pope, Reliquus clerus & populus Romanus ad consensum nova electionis pontificis à Cardinalibus factae accedant. So
the Epistles of Ivo Bishop of Chartres, we being called, by the will of God, the Cle•gy and people of such a City, and this Pope Ur••• practised upon Ivo.
himselfe saith, was confirmed by all the Bishops of the East and West. Cornelius Bishop of Rome was confirmed by the Bishops of Africa. More of this may be seene in
Petrus a Navarre, who all witnes ordination of a Bishop was never done in the ancient Church by one single Congregation, and these destitute of pastors and Elders. The learned say, that Gregory the VII. or Hildebrand did first exclude the people from voycing in elections of pastors. Illiricus sayth onely from the time of Frederick the XI. about the yeare, 1300 they were excluded from this power. And though it were true, that the election of Alexander the III.
Ruffinu• sayth, that Frumentius was ordained Bishop to the Indians, they knowing nothing of it, Indis nihil scientibus neque cogitantibus. Epiphanius writeth to Iohn Bishop of Ierusalem, that hee had ordained Paulinianus a presbyter, the people not consenting. Gregorius ordained Augustine Bishop of England and sent him to them to teach them, Anglis nescientibus. And Gregorius II. ordained Bonifacius a Bishop to bee sent to Germany, Germanis nihil de eare cogitantibus. And thus
Perkins, if the Gospell should arise in America, where there were no Ministers, ordination might be wanting. And why not (say I) election also in another case, if as
Zanchius) converted by reading the New Testament, and converting others, may baptize them whom hee converteth, and be baptized where both ordination and election should be wanting: