DISCOURSE. SECT. II.
pp. 264–27888 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 264–27888 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
God so loves all men, as that he desires their eternal good; for the Apostle saith, he would have all to be saved, and he would have no man perish, nor thee in particular.
God so loves all men, as that he desires their eternall good; for the Apostle saith, he would have all to be saved, and he would have no man perish, nor thee in particular.
He proceeds very judiciously I confess, by way of gradation from the Apocryphal, to the Canonical; but at once he makes use both of corruptor stilus, and adulter sensus. The very words of the Apostle he corrupts; for the Apostle no where saith that God would have all to be saved, that God would have none to perish; 'tis [Greek or Hebrew] who will have all to be saved in the one; and [Greek or Hebrew], not willing any to perish in the other. Men would do many things that they cannot; it is not so with God. And if it be not adulter sensus, to apply this to all and every one, here is comfort indeed with a witness; For if God will save every one; and withal can save them, whereof there is no doubt to be made, then there are no Reprobates at all; every one is predestinate to salvation by the will, that is, by the decree of God; And who hath resisted his will, saith S. Paul. And will he not have all & every one to believe & repent? If not, then seeing he will have all to be saved, it follows that God, will have all men to be saved, whether they believe or no, repent or no; But if he will have all to believe & repent, by that will whereby he will have all to be saved; seeing God can give all men faith and repentance; what follows but that all and every one shall believe and repent, & be saved, and consequently, there are no Reprobates at all? But I know full well what their interpretation of this is, namely, that God is ready to give faith and repentance unto all, to wit, in case they will; but doth not God give the very will to believe and repent? Yes in case they will. Take this comfort then into thy bosom, and make the best use of it to persuade thee that thou art no cast-away; For if thou believest and repentest, all is safe, thou hast as good assurance of thy salvation as Gods word can give thee. And though faith ⟨p. 271⟩and repentance be the gift of God, yet this comforter doth assure thee, that if thou wilt believe thou shalt believe, if thou wilt repent thou shalt repent. For God doth not give the grace of faith and repentance, according to the mere pleasure of his own will, but according to mens works; for albeit the Apostle saith, God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardeneth; yet that is not to be understood of vocation, but rather of justification.
He proceeds very judiciously I confesse, by way of gradation from the Apocryphall, to the Canonicall; but at once he makes use both of corruptor stilus, and adulter sensus. The very words of the Apostle he corrupts; for the Apostle no where saith that God would have all to be saved, that God would have none to perish; 'tis 〈non-Latin alphabet〉 who will have all to be saved in the one; and 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, not willing any to perish in the other. Men would doe many things that they cannot; it is not so with God. And if it be not adulter sensus, to apply this to all and every one, here is comfort indeed with a witnesse; For if God will save every one; and withall can save them, whereof there is no doubt to be made, then there are no Reprobates at all; every one is predestinate to salvation by the will, that is, by the decree of God; And who hath resisted his will, saith S. Paul. And will he not have all & every one to believe & repent? If not, then seeing he will have all to be saved, it follows that God, wil have all men to be saved, whether they believe or no, repent or no; But if he will have all to believe & repent, by that will whereby he will have all to be saved; seeing God can give all men faith and repentance; what followes but that all and every one shall believe and repent, & be saved, and consequently, there are no Reprobates at all? But I know full well what their interpretation of this is, namely, that God is ready to give faith and repentance unto all, to wit, in case they will; but doth not God give the very will to believe and repent? Yes in case they will. Take this comfort then into thy bosome, and make the best use of it to perswade thee that thou art no cast-away; For if thou believest and repentest, all is safe, thou hast as good assurance of thy salvation as Gods word can give thee. And though faith ⟨p. 271⟩and repentance be the gift of God, yet this comforter doth assure thee, that if thou wilt believe thou shalt believe, if thou wilt repent thou shalt repent. For God doth not give the grace of faith and repentance, according to the meere pleasure of his own will, but according to mens workes; for albeit the Apostle saith, God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardneth; yet that is not to be understood of vocation, but rather of justification.
And let it not startle thee, that justification in Scripture phrase, is opposed to condemnation, and not to obduration, but to thy comfort be it spoken, it must be opposed to obduration here; least otherwise faith and repentance should not be given according to mens works, but according to the mere pleasure of God; which is a very uncomfortable doctrine. But be thou assured, that if thou wilt believe and repent, thou shalt believe and repent, such is Gods grace; and though it be as true, I confess, on the other side, that if thou wilt not believe and repent, thou shalt not believe and repent; yet that is not to be accounted Gods grace, least so we should say, that Gods grace is as active to evil, as it is unto good. So that hereby thou mayest still perceive, that all thy comfort depends on this, that the grace of faith and repentance is given according to mens works.
And let it not startle thee, that justification in Scripture phrase, is opposed to condemnation, and not to obduration, but to thy comfort be it spoken, it must be opposed to obduration here; least otherwise faith and repentance should not be given according to mens workes, but according to the meere pleasure of God; which is a very uncomfortable doctrine. But be thou assured, that if thou wilt believe and repent, thou shalt believe and repent, such is Gods grace; and though it be as true, I confesse, on the other side, that if thou wilt not believe and repent, thou shalt not believe and repent; yet that is not to be accounted Gods grace, least so we should say, that Gods grace is as active to evill, as it is unto good. So that hereby thou maist still perceive, that all thy comfort depends on this, that the grace of faith and repentance is given according to mens works.
All, is taken two ways: for all sorts and conditions of men, and for all particular men: God would have all sorts of men to be saved, but not all, or me in particular.
All, is taken two waies: for all sorts and conditions of men, and for all particular men: God would have all sorts of men to be saved, but not all, or mee in particular.
2. Or if he will have all particular men to be saved; yet he wills it only with a revealed Will, but not with a secret will, for with that he will have a great company damned. Under his revealed will am I, not the secret.
1. That All is taken after these two ways in Scripture, and that in this place 1 Tim. 2. it is to be taken of genera singulorum, I have formerly proved, both by the circumstances of the Text, and by the analogy of faith, for otherwise we should trench upon Gods omnipotency and unchangeableness; and lastly by the judgement of Austin. But take the meaning aright, not that God would, but that God will have all men, that is, of all sorts, even of Kings and Princes, some to be saved; but not all and every one.
1. That All is taken after these two waies in Scripture, and that in this place 1 Tim. 2. it is to be taken of genera singulorum, I have formerly proved, both by the circumstances of the Text, and by the analogy of faith, for otherwise we should trench upon Gods omnipotency and unchangeablenesse; and lastly by the judgement of Austin. But take the meaning aright, not that God would, but that God will have all men, that is, of all sorts, even of Kings and Princes, some to be saved; but not all and every one.
As for the distinction of a revealed will, and secret will applied to salvation, thou mayest learn that somewhere of Papists, but not of us. For the revealed will is Gods commandment; now that which God commands is a part of his Law, so is not salvation, but rather a reward of obedience. Yet they apply this distinction only in reference to faith and repentance, whereunto God hath annexed salvation. And it is Gods revealed will that all who hear the Gospel should believe and repent ex officio; but it is not Gods will to give every one of them grace to believe and repent, as we find by manifest experience. It was Gods will in like manner to command Abraham to sacrifice his son, but it was not Gods determination that Isaac should be sacrificed. In like sort he commanded Pharaoh to let Israel go, but withal he told Moses, he would harden Pharaohs heart, that he should not let them go for a long time.
As for the distinction of a revealed will, and secret will applyed to salvation, thou maist learne that somewhere of Papists, but not of us. For the revealed will is Gods commandement; now that which God commands is a part of his Law, so is not salvation, but rather a reward of obedience. Yet they apply this distinction only in reference to faith and repentance, whereunto God hath annexed salvation. And it is Gods revealed will that all who heare the Gospell should believe and repent ex officio; but it is not Gods will to give every one of them grace to believe and repent, as we find by manifest experience. It was Gods will in like manner to command Abraham to sacrifice his sonne, but it was not Gods determination that Isaack should be sacrificed. In like sort he commanded Pharaoh to let Israel goe, but withall he told Moses, he would harden Pharaohs heart, that he should not let them goe for a long time.
2. But in the accommodation of these distinctions unto thy self, What ground hast thou to affirm, that God willeth not thy salvation in particular? If thou believest, Gods word assureth thee thou shalt be saved; if thou believest not, yet thou mayest believe; and Gods word hath power to bring thee unto faith, as formerly I have discoursed. And as for the best of Gods Children who do believe, to the great comfort of their souls, rejoicing with joy unspeakable and glorious. 1 Pet. 1. They were sometimes in as uncomfortable a condition as thou now art. And the rather I put thee upon this, because I see he that takes upon him to comfort thee, doth take a course rather to feed thy humour, then to remove it, in as much as he never enquires into the cause thereof. For albeit he gave to understand, he would apply his argument with as much art and cunning as could be, yet it may be, that was rather with respect to the advantage of his own cause, then to thy consolation. But let us see whether he mends it in the next.
2. But in the accommodation of these distinctions unto thy selfe, What ground hast thou to affirme, that God willeth not thy salvation in particular? If thou believest, Gods word assureth thee thou shalt be saved; if thou believest not, yet thou maist believe; and Gods word hath power to bring thee unto faith, as formerly I have discoursed. And as for the best of Gods Children who doe believe, to the great comfort of their soules, rejoycing with joy unspeakable and glorious. 1 Pet. 1. They were sometimes in as uncomfortable a condition as thou now art. And the rather I put thee upon this, because I see he that takes upon him to comfort thee, doth take a course rather to feed thy humour, then to remove it, in as much as he never enquires into the cause thereof. For albeit he gave to understand, he would apply his argument with as much art and cunning as could be, yet it may be, that was rather with respect to the advantage of his own cause, then to thy consolation. But let us see whether he mends it in the next.
Christ came into the World to seek and to save what was lost; and is a propitiation, not for our sins only, i. e. the sins of a few particular men, or the sins of all sorts of men, but for the sins of the whole World; therefore he came to save thee, for thou wast lost; and to be a propitiation for thy sins, for thou art part of the whole World.
Christ came into the World to seeke and to save what was lost; and is a propitiation, not for our sinnes only, i. e. the sinnes of a few particular men, or the sinnes of all sorts of men, but for the sinnes of the whole World; therefore he came to save thee, for thou wast lost; and to be a propitiation for thy sinnes, for thou art part of the whole World.
Still he continues to afford thee as much comfort as any Reprobate in the world; and if thou desirest no more, thou mayest rest satisfied with this; but withal I confess, he affords thee as much comfort, as he can afford any of Gods elect, for he maketh elect and Reprobate all alike in receiving comfort from Gods Word. Christ came into the world to save that which was lost, but unless he came to save all that is lost, it will not follow that he came to save thee. We know that pardon of sin and salvation is procured by Christ, for none but such as believe; and therefore be not deceived, without faith look for neither; by faith be assured of both, and that thou art one of Gods elect and no Reprobate. And observe well he tells thee nothing of Christ meriting faith and repentance; this now a days is plainly denied by the Remonstrants; and this Author is content to say nothing of it; when he is put to it we know what must be the issue of it; if he sayeth Christ hath merited faith and repentance 1for thee, the meaning is but this; Christ hath merited that if thou wilt believe thou shalt believe, if thou wilt repent, thou shalt repent. And that Christ hath merited that God should bestow faith and repentance not on whom he will according to the mere pleasure of his will, but according to mens works.
Still he continues to afford thee as much comfort as any Reprobate in the world; and if thou desirest no more, thou maist rest satisfied with this; but withall I confesse, he affords thee as much comfort, as he can afford any of Gods elect, for he maketh elect and Reprobate all alike in receiving comfort from Gods Word. Christ came into the world to save that which was lost, but unlesse he came to save all that is lost, it will not follow that he came to save thee. We know that pardon of sinne and salvation is procured by Christ, for none but such as believe; and therefore be not deceived, without faith looke for neither; by faith be assured of both, and that thou art one of Gods elect and no Reprobate. And observe well he tells thee nothing of Christ meriting faith and repentance; this now a dayes is plainly denyed by the Remonstrants; and this Authour is content to say nothing of it; when he is put to it we know what must be the issue of it; if he sayeth Christ hath merited faith and repentance 1for thee, the meaning is but this; Christ hath merited that if thou wilt believe thou shalt believe, if thou wilt repent, thou shalt repent. And that Christ hath merited that God should bestow faith and repentance not on whom he will according to the meere pleasure of his will, but according to mens workes.
The comfort that our doctrine ministers unto thee, is this, If thou dost believe in Christ, thou mayest be assured thou art an elect of God, if thou dost not believe, there is no cause why thou shouldest think thy self a Cast-away; for albeit thou hast not faith to day, yet thou mayest have faith to morrow. Give thy self to Gods Word: and wait upon him in his ordinances, thou mayest be so wrought upon as that unbeliever was, 1 Cor: 14. Who is there represented falling down on his face, and confessing that God was in the Preacher of a truth. And though at first thou attendest to it, but in a carnal manner, yet God may open thy heart as he opened the heart of Lidia, and make thee attend unto it in a gracious manner.1
The comfort that our doctrine ministers unto thee, is this, If thou dost believe in Christ, thou maist be assured thou art an elect of God, if thou dost not believe, there is no cause why thou shouldest thinke thy selfe a Cast-away; for albeit thou hast not faith to day, yet thou maist have faith to morrow. Give thy selfe to Gods Word: and waite upon him in his ordinances, thou maist be so wrought upon as that unbeliever was, 1 Cor: 14. Who is there represented falling downe on his face, and confessing that God was in the Preacher of a truth. And though at first thou attendest to it, but in a carnall manner, yet God may open thy heart as he opened the heart of Lidia, and make thee attend unto it in a gracious manner.1
The World (as I have heard) is taken two ways in Scripture, Largely for all mankind; and strictly for the elect, or believers: In this latter sense Christ dyed for the World. Or if for all, yet it was only dignitate pretii, not voluntate propositi; thus only for a few selected ones, with whom it is not my lot to be numbered.
The World (as I have heard) is taken two waies in Scripture, Largely for all mankind; and strictly for the elect, or believers: In this latter sense Christ dyed for the World. Or if for all, yet it was only dignitate pretii, not voluntate propositi; thus only for a few selected ones, with whom it is not my lot to be numbred.
Suffer not thy self to be abused by them, who pretending thy comfort, yet seek nothing less, but only the promoting of their own cause. And observe how he takes notice of no other benefits of Christs death, then such as belong unto men upon the condition of faith, to wit, pardon of sin and Salvation; in which case the mention of Gods elect comes in very unseasonably. And thus is the love of God set forth unto us; so God loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish but have everlasting life: And if it be not thy lot to be numbered amongst believers, then we can give thee, by Gods Word, no assurance of thy Salvation. But if thou art not a believer yet, thou mayest be in good time as formerly I have spoken more at large; and therefore no reason to think thou art a Reprobate. And if once thou dost believe in Christ, our doctrine gives thee assurance of Justification, Salvation, and Election; the Arminian doctrine doth not.
Suffer not thy selfe to be abused by them, who pretending thy comfort, yet seeke nothing lesse, but only the promoting of their owne cause. And observe how he takes notice of no other benefits of Christs death, then such as belong unto men upon the condition of faith, to wit, pardon of sinne and Salvation; in which case the mention of Gods elect comes in very unseasonably. And thus is the love of God set forth unto us; so God loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Sonne, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish but have everlasting life: And if it be not thy lot to be numbred amongst believers, then we can give thee, by Gods Word, no assurance of thy Salvation. But if thou art not a believer yet, thou maist be in good time as formerly I have spoken more at large; and therefore no reason to think thou art a Reprobate. And if once thou dost believe in Christ, our doctrine gives thee assurance of Justification, Salvation, and Election; the Arminan doctrine doth not.
As for faith and repentance, we say Christ hath merited them also, but to be bestowed how? According to mens works say our Arminians, though foreign Arminians profess plainly that Christ merited not faith and regeneration for any. And if thou relishest this comfort, be satisfied with it; we say faith and repentance are bestowed absolutely according to the mere pleasure of Gods will, and accordingly ⟨p. 273⟩Christ merited them, but not for all, for then all should believe and repent and be saved; but only for some, and who can these be but Gods elect; whence it followeth clearly that whosoever believes may by our doctrine be assured of his election, not so by the doctrine of Arminians; but if thou believest not thou art in no worse case then the best of Gods children have been; for there was a time when they believed not; therefore thou hast no more cause to think thy self a cast-away then they had.
As for faith and repentance, we say Christ hath merited them also, but to be bestowed how? According to mens workes say our Arminians, though forraine Arminians professe plainly that Christ merited not faith and regeneration for any. And if thou relishest this comfort, be satisfied with it; we say faith and repentance are bestowed absolutely according to the meere pleasure of Gods will, and accordingly ⟨p. 273⟩Christ merited them, but not for all, for then all should believe and repent and be saved; but only for some, and who can these be but Gods elect; whence it followeth clearly that whosoever believes may by our doctrine be assured of his election, not so by the doctrine of Arminians; but if thou believest not thou art in no worse case then the best of Gods childern have been; for there was a time when they believed not; therefore thou hast no more cause to think thy selfe a cast-away then they had.
God hath founded an universal Covenant with men upon the blood of Christ, and therefore he intended it should be shed for all men universally; he hath made a promise of salvation to every one that will believe, and excludes none that will not believe.
God hath founded an universall Covenant with men upon the bloud of Christ, and therefore he intended it should be shed for all men universally; he hath made a promise of salvation to every one that will believe, and excludes none that will not believe.
This I confess is to administer as much comfort, as is administered to any Reprobate; but how can this qualify thy discomfort, and discontent, which riseth from this conceit, that thou art a Reprobate. And the truth is, that by our Doctrine, we were all in a miserable case, if Gods Covenant of grace extended no farther then this. But hath not God promised to be our Lord, and our God that sanctifieth us, to circumcise our hearts, and the hearts of our Children, to love the Lord our God 1with all our hearts: to take the stony heart out of our bowels, and give us an heart of flesh, and to put his own spirit within us; as he seeth our ways, so to heal them, yea, to heal our back-slidings, to heal our rebellions. All this, this sweet comforter takes no notice of, contenting himself with such a grace to be merited for him by Christ as this, if he will believe he shall believe; if he will repent he shall repent; if he will love God with all his heart, he shall love him with all his heart. Yet when a man doth believe, they are able to give him no assurance of his salvation, or of his election; because they maintain, that a man may totally and finally fall away from grace: And all because their doctrine is, that Gods effectual grace in working the act of faith and repentance, is given merely according to mens works.
This I confesse is to administer as much comfort, as is administred to any Reprobate; but how can this qualify thy discomfort, and discontent, which riseth from this conceit, that thou art a Reprobate. And the truth is, that by our Doctrine, wee were all in a miserable case, if Gods Covenant of grace extended no farther then this. But hath not God promised to be our Lord, and our God that sanctifyeth us, to circumcise our hearts, and the hearts of our Children, to love the Lord our God 1with all our hearts: to take the stony heart out of our bowells, and give us an heart of flesh, and to put his own spirit within us; as he seeth our waies, so to heale them, yea, to heale our back-slidings, to heale our rebellions. All this, this sweet comforter takes no notice of, contenting himselfe with such a grace to be merited for him by Christ as this, if he will believe he shall believe; if he will repent he shall repent; if he will love God with all his heart, he shall love him with all his heart. Yet when a man doth believe, they are able to give him no assurance of his salvation, or of his election; because they maintaine, that a man may totally and finally fall away from grace: And all because their doctrine is, that Gods effectuall grace in working the act of faith and repentance, is given meerely according to mens works.
God purposed that his Son should dye for all men, and that in his name an offer of remission of sins, and salvation should be made to every one, but yet upon this condition, that they will do that which he means the greatest part shall never do (i. e. Repent and believe) nor I among the rest.
God purposed that his Sonne should dye for all men, and that in his name an offer of remission of sinnes, and salvation should be made to every one, but yet upon this condition, that they will doe that which he meanes the greatest part shall never doe (i. e. Repent and believe) nor I among the rest.
How doth God mean that the greatest part of men shall never believe and repent, by our opinion? Is it in this sense, that they shall not believe and repent if they will? When was it ever known that any of our Divines ever wrote or taught this? We think rather it is impossible it should be otherwise, & therefore say it is a very absurd thing to call this [Grace] as the Arminians do. Indeed we say that God doth not mean by his preventing grace to work the wills of the greatest part of men to believe & repent: Do not the Arminians say so too? Yes verily, and a great deal more: for they deny that he works any mans will to believe and repent in this manner; but we say God purchaseth thus to work the wills of all his chosen ones, and when he hath wrought them, to keep them by his power through faith unto Salvation; and put his fear in their hearts, that they shall never depart a way from him. Jer 32. 40. And upon this 1ground we can assure believers of their election which Arminians cannot; And them that believe not, keep from despair in better manner then the Arminians can, for they leave them to themselves to believe; whereas the Scriptures show that to be impossible: so that they take upon them to comfort such quite against the hair. But we comfort them with a possibility. of being converted unto God by representing his almighty power, whose voice is able to pierce into the graves and make dead Lazarus hear it. This power he showed in converting Saul, when he marched furiously (Jehu like) against the Church of God. Therefore be thou of good comfort, especially considering thou art as it were under the wings of God, thou hearest his voice; many come out of their graves at his call; some at one time, some at another, ⟨p. 274⟩and so mayest thou God knows how soon; then shalt thou be assured of thine election, which by Arminianism thou canst not be; in the mean time thou hast no cause to conclude that thou art a Reprobate.
How doth God meane that the greatest part of men shall never believe and repent, by our opinion? Is it in this sence, that they shall not believe and repent if they will? When was it ever knowne that any of our Divines ever wrote or taught this? We think rather it is impossible it should be otherwise, & therefore say it is a very absurd thing to call this [Grace] as the Arminians doe. Indeed we say that God doth not meane by his preventing grace to work the wills of the greatest part of men to believe & repent: Doe not the Arminians say so too? Yes verily, and a great deale more: for they deny that he workes any mans will to believe and repent in this manner; but we say God purchaseth thus to worke the wills of all his chosen ones, and when he hath wrought them, to keepe them by his power through faith unto Salvation; and put his feare in their hearts, that they shall never depart a way from him. Jer 32. 40. And upon this 1ground we can assure believers of their election which Arminians cannot; And them that believe not, keepe from dispaire in better manner then the Arminians can, for they leave them to themselves to believe; whereas the Scriptures shew that to be impossible: so that they take upon them to comfort such quite against the haire. But we comfort them with a possibility. of being converted unto God by representing his allmighty power, whose voyce is able to pierce into the graves and make dead Lazarus heare it. This power he shewed in converting Saul, when he marched furiously (Jehu like) against the Church of God. Therfore be thou of good comfort, especially considering thou art as it were under the wings of God, thou hearest his voyce; many come out of their graves at his call; some at one time, some at another, ⟨p. 274⟩and so maist thou God knowes how soone; then shalt thou be assured of thine election, which by Arminianisme thou canst not be; in the meane time thou hast no cause to conclude that thou art a Reprobate.
God hath a true meaning, that all men who are called should repent and believe, that so they might be saved; as he would have all to be saved, so to come to the knowledge of the truth; and as he would have no man to perish, so he would have all men to repent, and therefore he calls them in the Preaching of the word to the one, as well as to the other.
He keeps his course to afford thee the best comfort his doctrine yields, which is as much as is incident to a Reprobate, and how that should make thee conceive better of thy self, then as of a Reprobate, I do not perceive, Gods meaning is that as many as hear the Gospel should believe and repent ex officio; that is, that it shall be their duty, for he commands it: but he hath no meaning to bestow on all and every one the grace of faith and repentance, as appears by experience. And if God did will they should de facto believe and be saved, then either God is not able to bring them to faith and to save them, or else his will is changed. In like sort if it were his will that all and every one should know his truth, then God is not able to make all and every one know his truth, for it is apparent that all do not; it is apparent that all have not the Gospel; The Apostle saith, That God will not have any of us to perish but all to come to repentance: he doth not say he would but he will: And this is true of [Greek or Hebrew], such as the Apostle speaks of, believers and elect. But as for others, the Scriptures plainly profess, that God blinds them, hardens them; and of Israel in the wilderness, The Lord (saith Moses) hath not given you an heart to perceive, nor eyes to see, nor ears to hear unto this day. Deut: 29. 4. He calls all that hear the Gospel indifferently by the Ministry of the Word, but he openeth not the heart of all to attend unto it, as to the Word of God, like as we read he opened the heart of Lidia. Acts. 16. 14.
He keepes his course to afford thee the best comfort his doctrine yeelds, which is as much as is incident to a Reprobate, and how that should make thee conceive better of thy selfe, then as of a Reprobate, I doe not perceive, Gods meaning is that as many as heare the Gospell should believe and repent ex officio; that is, that it shall be their duty, for he commands it: but he hath no meaning to bestow on all and every one the grace of faith and repentance, as appeares by experience. And if God did will they should de facto believe and be saved, then either God is not able to bring them to faith and to save them, or else his will is changed. In like sort if it were his will that all and every one should know his truth, then God is not able to make all and every one know his truth, for it is apparent that all doe not; it is apparent that all have not the Gospell; The Apostle saith, That God will not have any of us to perish but all to come to repentance: he doth not say he would but he will: And this is true of 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, such as the Apostle speakes of, believers and elect. But as for others, the Scriptures plainly professe, that God blinds them, hardens them; and of Israell in the wildernesse, The Lord (saith Moses) hath not given you an heart to perceive, nor eyes to see, nor eares to heare unto this day. Deut: 29. 4. He calls all that heare the Gospell indifferently by the Ministry of the Word, but he openeth not the heart of all to attend unto it, as to the Word of God, like as we read he opened the heart of •idia. Acts. 16. 14.
God hath a double call, outward by his word, inward by the irresistible work of his spirit; with this he doth not call every man to believe, but a very few only, whom he hath infallibly, and inevitably, ordained to eternal life, and therefore by the outward call, which I enjoy among many others, I cannot be assured of Gods good will and meaning, that I shall believe, repent, and be saved.
God hath a double call, outward by his word, inward by the irresistible work of his spirit; with this he doth not call every man to believe, but a very few only, whom he hath infallibly, and inevitably, ordained to eternall life, and therefore by the outward call, which I enjoy among many others, I cannot be assured of Gods good will and meaning, that I shall believe, repent, and be saved.
Our Doctrine teacheth not that God calls every one by his Word, that is an Arminian interjection. But the outward call belongs to many more then are chosen, as our Saviour saith, many are called but few are chosen; Indeed he gives faith and repentance to a very few, which no Arminian denies; only the Question is, Whether God gives faith and repentance to whom he will, or according to mens works. We say 'tis to whom he will, proceeding herein according to the mere pleasure of his will; and not according to mens works; which to affirm is manifest Pelagianism, and publicly condemned many hundred years ago. It is true, if thou dost not believe, Gods Word doth not assure thee that he will make thee believe; that were to assure thee of thine election before thy vocation; a most unreasonable thing to be expected. But God by his word assures thee, that tis his meaning that without faith thou shalt not be saved. Yet there is no cause thou shouldest think thy self a Reprobate; for this was the condition of every one of Gods elect before their calling. It may be thou mayest have experience of the same power of divine grace, to bring thee to faith also, and to repentance; therefore seeing Gods Word is the only means to work faith, wait daily at his Gates and give attendance at the posts of his doors; and do not prescribe unto him, or say with 1Joram, Shall I wait upon the Lord any longer? though it be longer he calls thee, yet it may go never a whit the worse with thee for that, for sometimes it falleth out that the last are first, and the first last: and the commendation that Austin makes, of the Thief's faith upon the Cross, is remarkable, De orig, animae, lib. 1. cap. 9. Tanto pondere ⟨p. 275⟩appensum est, tantumque valuit ap ud eum qui haec novit appendere, quod confessus est dominum crucifixum, quantum si fuisset pro Domino crucifixus. Tunc enim fides ejus de ligno floruit, quando discipulorum marcuit, nisi cujus mortis terror marcuerunt ejus resurrectione reviresceret. Illi enim desperaverunt de moriente, ille speravit in commorientem. Refugerunt illi authorem vitae, rogavit ille consortem poenae. Doluerunt illi tanquam homines mortem, credidit ille regnaturum esse post mortem, Deseruerunt illi sponsorem salutis, honoravit ille socium crucis. Inventa est in eo mensura Martyris, qui tunc in Christum credidit, quando defecerunt, qui futuri erant Martyres.
Our Doctrine teacheth not that God calls every one by his Word, that is an Arminian interjection. But the outward call belongs to many more then are chosen, as our Saviour sayth, many are called but few are chosen; Indeed he gives faith and repentance to a very few, which no Arminian denyes; only the Question is, Whether God gives faith and repentance to whom he will, or according to mens works. We saytis to whom he will, proceeding herein according to the meere pleasure of his will; and not according to mens workes; which to affirme is manifest Pelagianisme, and publikely condemned many hundred yeares agoe. It is true, if thou dost not believe, Gods Word doth not assure thee that he will make thee believe; that were to assure thee of thine election before thy vocation; a most unreasonable thing to be expected. But God by his word assures thee, that tis his meaning that without faith thou shalt not be saved. Yet there is no cause thou shouldest think thy selfe a Reprobate; for this was the condition of every one of Gods elect before their calling. It may be thou maist have experience of the same power of divine grace, to bring thee to faith also, and to repentance; therefore seeing Gods Word is the only meanes to worke faith, waite daily at his Gates and give attendance at the posts of his doores; and doe not prescribe unto him, or say with 1Joram, Shall I wait upon the Lord any longer? though it be longere he calls thee, yet it may goe never a whit the worse with thee for that, for sometimes it falleth out that the last are first, and the first last: and the commendation that Austin makes, of the Theef's faith upon the Crosse, is remarkeable, De orig, animae, lib. 1. cap. 9. Tanto pondere ⟨p. 275⟩appensum est, tantumque valuit ap ud eum qui haec novit appendere, quod confessus est dominum crucifixum, quantum si fuisset pro Domino crucifixus. Tunc enim fides ejus de ligno floruit, quando discipulorum marcuit, nisi cujus mortis terrore marcuerunt ejus resurrectione reviresceret. Illi enim desperaverunt de moriente, ille speravit in commorientem. Refugerunt illi authorem vitae, rogavit ille consortem poenae. Doluerunt illi tanquam homines mortem, credidit ille regnaturum esse post mortem, Deseruerunt illi sponsorem salutis, honoravit ille socium crucis. Inventa est in eo mensura Martyris, qui tunc in Christum credidit, quando defecerunt, qui futuri erant Martyres.
2. From the Comedy I come to the Tragedy, I mean the story of Spira. Sleidan saith of him, that Incredibili ardour caepit complecti puriorem doctrinam: & cum indies magis magisque proficeret, non domi tantum apud amicos quid sentiret de singulis dogmatis, verum etiam passim apud omnes explicabat. Tidings hereof coming to the Popes Legate then at Venice John Casa Arch-Bishop of Beneventum, he convents Spira, who confesseth his error before him, entreats pardon, and promiseth obedience for time to come. The Legate not contented with this, commands him to go home, and publicly to revoke his error. Sleidan writes no more here of but this, Accipit ille conditionem, & licet etiam tum inciperet ipsum paenitere facti, tamen urgentibus amicis, qui non ipsius modo, sed conjugis etiam & liberorum & facultatum ipsius spem totam in eo positam dicerent, obtemperavit. Osiander writes that pessimo consilio obsecutus, abnegando veritatem caelestem perrexit, eamque publice ut haeresin blasphemavit & abjuravit. The distress of conscience which overtook him hereupon is notorious, the issue whereof was to end his woeful days more woefully in despair. But nothing more strange then his discourses and meditations in the midst of this his desperate condition. As for the particulars following, 1: Touching the greatness of his sin, and that he was taken off from that by the example of Peter, I find no such thing neither in Sleidan, nor Osiander, nor in Goulartius; but rather in this latter, who makes the largest relation thereof taken out of the discourse of one Henry Scringer, a learned Lawyer who was then at Padua, who did see, and many times talk with this poor Spira; I find that which makes to the contrary, namely, that the sin which he laid to his own charge was the sin against the Holy Ghost. And no example I trust neither of Peter, nor any other was sufficient to take him off from despair in such a case. 2. And as for the discourse here suggested of his absolute reprobation, which he opposed against their comforts ministered unto him, no mention thereof, neither in Sleidan, nor in Osiander; nay Osiander writes that he was wished to revoke doctrinam Lutheranam, and this was it which he did (as he sayeth) blaspheme as an heresy, and abjure.
2. From the Comedy I come to the Tragedy, I meane the story of Spira. Sleidan saith of him, that Incredibili ardore caepit complecti puriorem doctrinam: & cum indies magis magisque proficeret, non domi tantum apud amicos quid sentiret de singulis dogmatis, verum etiam passim apud omnes explicabat. Tidings hereof coming to the Popes Legat then at Venice John Casa Arch-Bishop of Beneventum, he convents Spira, who confesseth his errour before him, intreats pardon, and promiseth obedience for time to come. The Legat not contented with this, commands him to goe home, and publiquely to revoke his errour. Sleidan writes no more here of but this, Accipit ille conditionem, & licet etiam tum inciperet ipsum paenitere facti, tamen urgentibus amicis, qui non ipsius modo, sed conjugis etiam & liberorum & facultatum ipsius spem totam in eo positam dicerent, obtemperavit. Osiander writes that pessimo consilio obsecutus, abnegando veritatem caelestem perrexit, eamque publice ut haeresin blasphemavit & abjuravit. The distresse of conscience which overtooke him hereupon is notorious, the issue whereof was to end his woefull dayes more woefully in despaire. But nothing more strange then his discourses and meditations in the midst of this his desperate condition. As for the particulars following, 1: Touching the greatnesse of his sinne, and that he was taken off from that by the example of Peter, I find no such thing neither in Sleidan, nor Osiander, nor in Goulartius; but rather in this latter, who makes the largest relation thereof taken out of the discourse of one Henry Scringer, a learned Lawyer who was then at Padua, who did see, and many times talke with this poore Spira; I find that which makes to the contrary, namely, that the sinne which he laid to his owne charge was the sinne against the Holy Ghost. And no example I trust neither of Peter, nor any other was sufficient to take him off from despaire in such a case. 2. And as for the discourse here suggested of his absolute reprobation, which he opposed against their comforts ministred unto him, no mention thereof, neither in Sleidan, nor in Osiander; nay Osiander writes that he was wish'd to revoke doctrinam Lutheranam, and this was it which he did (as he sayeth) blaspheme as an heresy, and abjure.
Goulartius indeed relates how he conceived himself to be reprobated of God, as justly he might in case he judged himself to have sinned against the Holy Ghost; And as for that which is here set down in Latin, of him that is a Reprobate, namely, that necessario condemnabitur, though his sins be small & few, & that nihil interest multa an pauca, magna an parva sint; quando nec Dei misericordia, nec Christi sanguis quicquam ad eos pertinet. Neither Sleidan, nor Osiander nor Goulartius makes any mention of it. And therefore I wonder not that he neither followeth Sleidan, nor Osiander much less that he follows not Goulartius. He cites Caelius secundus and Calvin as his Authors, and some others that wrote thereof to their friends, but names them not; as neither where it is that Caelius secundus makes mention of it, or in what book of Calvin it is found. I imagined it might be in his Epistles; I have spent some hours in searching therein from the year 1545 to the year 1663, and can find nothing concerning it. Now Goulartius wrote since Caelius secundus, and Calvin and Sleidan, and his relation is large; and it seems he inquired in to it somewhat better then they that went before him. And thus he relates it out of the discourse of Henry Scringer a Lawyer of Padua, who saw Spira at that time, and divers times spake with him.
Goulartius indeed relates how he conceived himselfe to be reprobated of God, as justly he might in case he judged himselfe to have sinned against the Holy Ghost; And as for that which is here set down in Latin, of him that is a Reprobate, namely, that necessario condemnabitur, though his sins be small & few, & that nihil interest multa an pauca, magna an parva sint; quando nec Dei misericordia, nec Christi sanguis quicquam ad eos pertinet. Neither Sleidan, nor Osiander nor Goulartius makes any mention of it. And therefore I wonder not that he neither followeth Sleidan, nor Osiander much lesse that he followes not Goulartius. He cites Caelius secundus and Calvin as his Authours, and some others that wrot thereof to their friends, but names them not; as neither where it is that Caelius secundus makes mention of it, or in what booke of Calvin it is found. I imagined it might be in his Epistles; I have spent some houres in searching therein from the yeare 1545 to the yeare 1663, and can find nothing concerning it. Now Goulartius wrote since Caelius secundus, and Calvin and Sleidan, and his relation is large; and it semes he inquired in to it somewhat better then they that went before him. And thus he relates it out of the discourse of Henry Scringer a Lawyer of Padua, who saw Spira at that time, and divers times spake with him.
In a small town of the territory of Padua called Civitelle there was a Learned Lawyer, and advocate, a wise and very rich, man and an honourable father of a family, called Francis Spira, who having said and done divers things against his conscience, to maintain himself and his charge, (observe by the way he delivers the cause only in general concealing the speciality, it being so strange a testimony and evidence against the Romish Religion) being returned to his house, he could never rest an hour, not a minute, nor have any ease of his continual anguish: And even from that night he was so terrified and had such horror of his actions, as he held himself for lost. For (as he himself did afterward confess) he did set plainly before his eyes, all the torments, all the pains of the damned, and in his soul did hear the fearful sentences, being drawn before the judgment seat of Jesus Christ (a fearful ⟨p. 276⟩example to all Apostates;) The next day and so following he was not seen to resume any courage, but his spirits were strangely troubled, and the terror took from him all rest and appetite. This accident was so grievous to his friends, as some repented them much that they had been the cause of so great an inconvenience, by their entreaties. Others, thinking it did proceed from some choleric or melancholy humour, were of opinion to send him to Padova to be Physicked by the Learned Physicians, revived by honourable company, and settled by the conference of Learned men there, to some of which he was well known. His Wife and Children with some of his familiar friends did accompany him, and he was lodged in one of the chief houses. Frisimilega Bellocat and Crassus (famous Physicians) did visit him, and give him Physic with singular affection: and soon found that he was little sick in body, but grievously in mind, for in all other things he discoursed gravely, and constantly, so as none of his familiar friends could discern that the quickness of his discourse was any thing impaired. Continuing still in his weakness, many were much troubled, and daily his Chamber was full of People; some curious to see and hear, others were desirous to draw him to hope in the mercies of God; I was present at many of his speeches, with some men of honour and Learning. To deliver that which I could observe, I began first to note his age and his fashion.
In a small towne of the territory of Padua called Civitelle there was a Learned Lawyer, and advocat, a wise and very rich, man and an honourable father of a family, called Francis Spira, who having sayd and done divers things against his conscience, to maintaine himselfe and his charge, (observe by the way he delivers the cause only in generall concealing the speciality, it being so strang a testimony and evidence against the Romish Religion) being returned to his house, he could never rest an houre, not a minut, nor have any ease of his continuall anguish: And even from that night he was so terrified and had such horrour of his actions, as he held himselfe for lost. For (as he himselfe did afterward confesse) he did set plainely before his eyes, all the torments, all the paines of the damned, and in his soule did heare the fearfull sentences, being drawne before the judgment seat of Jesus Christ (a fearfull ⟨p. 276⟩example to all Apostates;) The next day and so following he was not seene to resume any courage, but his spirits were strangely troubled, and the terrour tooke from him all rest and appetite. This accident was so greivous to his friends, as some repented them much that they had beene the cause of so great an inconvenience, by their intreaties. Others, thinking it did proceed from some cholerick or melancholy humour, were of opinion to send him to Padova to be Physicked by the Learned Physitians, revived by honorable company, and setled by the coference of Learned men there, to some of which he was well knowne. His Wife and Children with some of his familiar friends did accompany him, and he was lodged in one of the chiefe houses. Frisimilega Bellocat and Crassus (famous Physitians) did visit him, and give him Physicke with singular affection: and soone found that he was little sicke in body, but grievously in mind, for in all other things he discoursed gravely, and constanstly, so as none of his familiar friends could discerne that the quicknesse of his discourse was any thing impaired. Continuing still in his weaknesse, many were much troubled, and dayly his Chamber was full of People; some curious to see and heare, others were desirous to draw him to hope in the mercies of God; I was present at many of his speeches, with some men of honour and Learning. To deliver that which I could observe, I began first to note his age and his fashion.