The Explication.
pp. 146–178129 passagespart 2 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 146–178129 passagespart 2 of 4
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
To grant this concerning the creatures as who may be furthered and enriched by the mutual duties of each other; yet will it by no means agree to God, seeing no man can help or harm him, and the true agnizing and magnifying of God, as also the whole conformity and agreement with him, is not his happiness and perfection, but the creatures. Object. 4. To whom is given that which is due unto him, to him something cometh thereby more then be had before: Unto God is yielded our obedience and worship, which is due unto him: Therefore somewhat cometh to him from us. Answ. The Major is true of that which is due of need or want, or which he needeth,1 and is furthered thereby to whom it is given: But our obedience is no such due, but that which God by order of his justice requireth of us, and that not for his, but our perfection and felicity. Lastly, if any man urge, That he who rejoiceth, doth receive some good of those things wherein he rejoiceth: And therefore some fruit certainly to redound unto God out of our obedience and salvation, seeing he pronounceth that he rejoiceth therein: We grant verily, that in men, rejoicing, and the like affections are stirred up by outward objects: But we must not deem that our virtues are the cause of that rejoicing which is in God: For therefore is a thing thought right and honest, because it is agreeing to the will and nature of God: and because God from everlasting is delighted with his own goodness and uprightness, and with things agreeing therewith, therefore doth he create and work such in men; and that everlasting approbation or liking which was the cause why God created good things, is the cause also why he now cherisheth and preserveth them being created.2 Wherefore the everlasting rejoicing in God for our obedience and salvation is the efficient cause of our obedience and salvation: but not contrariwise, our obedience the efficient cause of that rejoicing in God, as it cometh to pass in men, who are affected by outward objects. Or thus, God rejoiceth at our good as being an object, but not a cause; because objects are not the cause, but effects of Gods approbation and rejoicing.
To grant this concerning the creatures as who may be furthered and enriched by the mutuall duties of each other; yet will it by no means agree to God, seeing no man can help or harm him, and the true agnizing and magnifying of God, as also the whole conformity and agreement with him, is not his happinesse and perfection, but the creatures. Object. 4. To whom is given that which is due unto him, to him something cometh thereby more then bee had before: Unto God is yeelded our obedience and worship, which is due unto him: Therefore somewhat cometh to him from us. Answ. The Major is true of that which is due of need or want, or which he needeth,1 and is furthered thereby to whom it is given: But our obedience is no such due, but that which God by order of his justice requireth of us, and that not for his, but our perfection and felicity. Lastly, if any man urge, That hee who rejoyceth, doth receive some good of those things wherein hee rejoyceth: And therefore some fruit certainly to redound unto God out of our obedience and salvation, seeing he pronounceth that he rejoyceth therein: We grant verily, that in men, rejoycing, and the like affections are stirred up by outward objects: But we must not deem that our vertues are the cause of that rejoycing which is in God: For therefore is a thing thought right and honest, because it is agreeing to the will and nature of God: and because God from everlasting is delighted with his owne goodnesse and uprightnesse, and with things agreeing therewith, therefore doth hee create and work such in men; and that everlasting approbation or liking which was the cause why God created good things, is the cause also why hee now cherisheth and preserveth them being created.2 Wherefore the everlasting rejoycing in God for our obedience and salvation is the efficient cause of our obedience and salvation: but not contrariwise, our obedience the efficient cause of that rejoycing in God, as it cometh to passe in men, who are affected by outward objects. Or thus, God rejoyceth at our good as being an object, but not a cause; because objects are not the cause, but effects of Gods approbation and rejoycing.
Unchangeable.) When God pronounceth himself to be unchangeable, he showeth that he will be always such as he hath been from all eternity:1 so that, 1. Neither his essence, nor whatsoever is proper thereto can be augmented or diminished: 2. Neither his nature and will be changed: 3. Neither himself hath need to transport himself from place to place: This do Philosophers, induced thereto by reasons, confess: For, §11. Whatsoever is changed, that must needs have either some outward cause, or some original or beginning in it self of moving and changing, or both: But God cannot be moved or changed by any thing which is without him; for so himself should not be the first mover and maker of all that is good in nature. Neither can he suffer change from any inward original beginning of change: For whatsoever is so moved or changed, that must needs have parts, whereof some must move, and some be moved. Now that God should be divided into parts, neither doth his immensity suffer, nor his great perfection: for seeing every part is imperfecter then the whole, and in God is nothing which is not most perfect; it is impious to imagine any parts in him: Wherefore, neither by any outward nor inward cause is he moved or changed. §22. Whatsoever is changed, that must needs be changed either to the worse or the better, or into a state equal to the former: It is impossible that God should be made worse; for he should so become of perfect, imperfect. And to be made better is also impossible; for so he should have been once imperfect: But neither can he be translated into an equal condition and state, as thereby to leave some good which before he had, and to receive some good which before he had not: for thus should he be neither before nor after his change most perfect, as wanting some part of those good things which belonged unto him. §33. That which is infinite, neither can be made greater, for so it should not have been infinite before; nor lesser, for so it should be made finite. Seeing then both the essence, and power, and wisdom, and all the virtues of God are incomprehensible, and all things in God immense; therefore cannot any of them be either diminished or increased. §44. For the same cause, God doth not transport and remove himself from place to place, as creatures;
seeing by reason of his immensity whereby he filleth heaven and earth, he can neither depart, nor be absent from any place. §55. Seeing he is most wise, and therefore from everlasting hath most well purposed, decreed, and fore-seen all things; change of purpose and will cannot fall into him: And therefore God would have this in many places of holy Scripture inculcated unto us, that his nature and will is subject to no mutations, as being a thing most respecting his glory: God is not as man that he should lie,1 nor as the son of man that he should repent. Hath he said it then, and shall he not do it? Hath he spoken, and shall he not accomplish it? The counsel of the Lord shall endure for ever, 2and the thoughts of his heart from generation to generation. With whom is no variableness, 3neither shadow of change §1Object. 1. But God is said to repent. Ans. He is said to repent,4 not that he changeth his will: but, 1. Because he earnestly detesteth sins, and is not delighted, with the destruction of men. §22. Because by reason of this hatred against sin, and this mercy toward; repentant sinners, he maketh change of things and events, which from everlasting he decreed, as men are wont to do who repent them of their purpose: for among men, every change is an amending of that which disliketh them; amending riseth from repentance; wherefore the name of repentance, as also the names of other humane affections, are said to be attributed to God by an Anthropopathy, because the Scripture speaketh of God after the manner of men for our infirmity; that we, understanding those things which are in us to be shadows of those which are in God, may in some sort conceive something of the nature of God and his will towards mankind. Wherefore these forms of speaking do not signify any perturbation in God, or change or passion like unto our affections, but are used to signify these two things of God:5
not that he, as men, being moved by a present ⟨p. 158⟩or sudden affection of the mind, doth now first take counsel; but doth now at the length execute and do things which he decreed and appointed from all eternity. Object. 2. The promises and threatenings of God of tentimes are not fulfilled. Answ. The promises of God are always to be understood with an exception of the cross of the godly,1 and of the punishments and chastisements of such as depart from God, and sin; or with a condition of perseverance in faith and godliness: and also contrarily his threatenings with an exception of conversion and prayer, or with a condition of perseverance in sin.
not that he, as men, being moved by a present ⟨p. 158⟩or suddain affection of the minde, doth now first take counsell; but doth now at the length execute and doe things which he decreed and appointed from all eternity. Object. 2. The promises and threatnings of God of tentimes are not fulfilled. Answ. The promises of God are alwayes to be understood with an exception of the crosse of the godly,1 and of the punishments and chastisements of such as depart from God, and sin; or with a condition of perseverance in faith and godlinesse: and also contrarily his threatnings with an exception of conversion and prayer, or with a condition of perseverance in sin.
And these conditions are sometimes expressed, as Jer. 18 and 28. where plainly is set down this rule of understanding Gods promises and threatenings: as, That God will punish them who depart from him, unto whom he had promised blessings: and will spare those who repent, to whom he had threatened punishment. And sometimes they are closely understood, especially in the threatenings and comminations, thereby even to wrest repentance, and more timely and earnest prayers from us, by which, as means interposed and coming between, he hath decreed to save and deliver us. Repl. But these conditions are uncertain and changeable: Therefore the will of God is also changeable. Answ. In respect of the nature, will, and judgement of man, they are changeable; but in respect of the counsel and providence of God, unchangeable and most certain: for God hath decreed from everlasting the means and ends of things; as also he hath decreed in whom he will, and in whom he will not work conversion. Ob. 3. He changeth many his precepts, and observances, and works, as the Mosaical laws and government. Ans. He changeth them indeed, but so, as he would also from everlasting that change; neither are all things appointed of God for perpetuity; but he decreed from everlasting some things to last only for a time. Wherefore be it to us out of all controversy, that God is unchangeable: For,§1 1This is amongst those especial differences whereby the Creator will be discerned from all creatures, That he only can by no means be changed whereas all other things both are diversly changed, and may at the only pleasure of God be changed infinitely, howsoever for a while, so long as it is his pleasure, they are, and seem arm and immutable, according as it is said, Heaven and earth shall pass, but my word shall not pass. §22Hence we may understand, and are assured, That all things in the world are governed by the everlasting providence of God: For seeing no mutation happeneth to God, it must needs be, that an his counsels were purposed from everlasting. And seeing God both foreseeth all things unchangeably, and his counsels concerning the event and end of things are certain and unchangeable; it must needs be also that the second causes and means, or antecedents, without which those events were not to follow, must be certain and unchangeable.
And because in things created, especially in humane affairs, there is a great uncertainty and mutability, neither is there any cause of unchangeableness but the will of God; God could not have appointed any thing certain or unchangeable concerning the event and end, except he had also made all the means (by which the end is attained unto, and which, as concerning their own nature, are most certain and unchangeable) by his everlasting counsel and decree certain and unchangeable.1 Wherefore it is said, The Lord of hosts hath determined it, and who shall disannul it. §32The whole use, and force, and declaration of the promises, threatenings, and examples of Gods goodness, power justice, mercy, and wrath both old and new, to teach us, and to erect us with comfort, or by fear to hold and keep us in our duty and the fear of God, dependeth on Gods unchangeable nature: for all those do then affect us, when we think that the same nature and will of God which was in times past, is now also, and will be such to us repenting or persisting in our sins, as we see it was in times past, and now is towards others. And then do we truly rely upon the promises of God, when we know that his counsel shall never be changed.§4 3This doctrine inclineth mens minds to obedience and subjection, which is necessary in asking things at Gods hands: that we desire not God to do those things for us, or others, which he hath before-time assuredly told us that he will not do: and further, that we submit, and leave with reverence those things to his pleasure, whereof he would not as yet have known unto us what he hath decreed. ⟨p. 159⟩§54The unchangeableness of Gods will is the ground and foundation of the hope and comfort of the godly in this life: for it is most absurd to conceive of God, that now he loveth, and now he hateth us; now he will assuredly give unto us everlasting life, and a little after again he will not.
And because in things created, especially in humane affaires, there is a great uncertainty and mutability, neither is there any cause of unchangeablenesse but the will of God; God could not have appointed any thing certain or unchangeable concerning the event and end, except he had also made all the means (by which the end is attained unto, and which, as concerning their own nature, are most certaine and unchangeable) by his everlasting counsell and decree certain and unchangeable.
And therefore when once true faith and conversion unto God is begun in our hearts, and the Spirit of God hath begun to witness to our spirit that we are the sons of God, and heirs of everlasting life, God will have us certainly to resolve, that as he had this his will towards us from everlasting, so to everlasting he will not change it, but will assuredly bring us, at his pleasure, out of this wicked and miserable life, through all tentations and dangers whatsoever, to eternal and everlasting life, according to that article of our faith, I believe life everlasting.
And therefore when once true faith and conversion unto God is begun in our hearts, and the Spirit of God hath begun to witnesse to our spirit that we are the sons of God, and heirs of everlasting life, God will have us certainly to resolve, that as hee had this his will towards us from everlasting, so to everlasting hee will not change it, but will assuredly bring us, at his pleasure, out of this wicked and miserable life, through all tentations and dangers whatsoever, to eternall and everlasting life, according to that article of our faith, I beleeve life everlasting.
1Omnipotent.) When as Omnipotency is attributed to God, thereby is understood, §11. That whatsoever he will, or whatsoever, not impairing his nature and majesty, he is able to will, he is also able to perform. §22. That he is able to perform all those things without any difficulty and labour, even with his only beck and will. §33. That all the force and power of working and effecting any thing is so in God only, that there is not the least ability or efficacy of any creature, but what he continually imparteth and preserveth at his pleasure: and therefore the power of God is to be considered of us, not as being idle, but as creating, sustaining, moving, and ruling all things: The reasons are, 1. God is the first cause of all things; therefore he hath all things in his power, and their ability is so much as he giveth unto them. 2. He doth such things as can be done by no created and finite power: as are the creation and governing of all things the preservation of commonweals, the deluge. the delivery out of Egypt, and all his miracles. 3 He is unchangeable; therefore in him to be able to do, and to do, is the same which to will, and so of the contrary. But although all men affirm God to be omnipotent, yet there is a double difference between the sacred doctrine of the Church,2 and Philosophy concerning Gods omnipotency: For, §11. Without the doctrine of the Church men only know the universal and general power of God, whereby he createth, preserveth and governeth the whole world: but they know not that power whereby he saveth men, and restoreth the world by his Son, gathering and preserving an everlasting Church, and delivering it from sin and death, and endowing it with life and glory everlasting, by which works God especially showeth forth his power, as it is said Yet a little while and I shall shake the heavens, and the earth, and the sea, 3and the dry land. §22. Neither do they profess of the general power of God so much as is sufficient: for albeit they are enforced to confess, that God is the author and preserver of the world; yet are they not able to say, that all things were created of nothing by the word of God alone: and forasmuch as they are ignorant of the cause of sin and confusion, they cannot affirm all things so to be administered and governed by Gods omnipotency, as that all which is good is done by the powerful working of Gods will;
but they attribute many things to chance, fortune, and humane wisdom or virtue and so imagine the power of God to be idle in these, and doing nothing. Furthermore, That God cannot either sin, or will and allow of sin, or be changed, or diminished or suffer any thing, or make things done undone or will things flat repugnant and contradictory, or create another God, or some nature equal to himself, or be perceived by bodily senses, or do other things proper to a created or finite nature, or admit the same into himself; this doth not diminish or weaken, but rather augment and strengthen his power: For that is the greatest and most perfect power which can neither be destroyed, nor weakened, nor diminished; and that, none sustaining it, but only by it self. But contrariwise, to be able to be corrupted and impaired is a token of imbecility and imperfection.
but they attribute many things to chance, fortune, and humane wisdome or vertue and so imagine the power of God to be idle in these, and doing nothing. Furthermore, That God cannot either sin, or will and allow of sin, or be changed, or diminished or suffer any thing, or make things done undone or will things flat repugnant and contradictory, or create another God, or some nature equall to himselfe, or be perceived by bodily senses, or do other things proper to a created or finite nature, or admit the same into himselfe; this doth not diminish or weaken, but rather augment and strengthen his power: For that is the greatest and most perfect power which can neither be destroyed, nor weakened, nor diminished; and that, none sustaining it, but only by it selfe. But contrariwise, to be able to be corrupted and impaired is a token of imbecility and imperfection.
1Of exceeding and immense wisdom.) That we may rightly, and with profit and commodity know the power of God, it is necessary not to consider it but as it is joined with his immense wisdom and goodness, which moderateth it. Further, of his divine wisdom we learn, 1. That God doth of himself, in one act or view, under stand and behold perpetually and most perfectly. in marvellous manner, and that unknown to us, himself and the whole order of his mind declared in the nature of things, and in his ⟨p. 160⟩word; and what agreeth therewith, and disagreeth; and all his works, and all the works of all creatures, past, present, and to come; and all the causes and circumstances of all things. 2. That all Angels and men have no more knowledge of divine and humane matters then God doth work and maintain in their minds: for among other things, the most beautiful and sightly order which is in the nature of things, the ends and uses of all things, the signification of future events, arts and sciences, the everting and overturning of those devices which the devil and wicked men have most craftily contrived against God and all the godly, do enforce all men to confess, that these things could not proceed but from a most wise artificer and author. Wherefore also the Scripture it self willeth us to consider the wisdom of God shining in these his works:2 God hath made every thing beautiful in his time. Who is like me, that shall call, and shall declare it, and set it in order before me, since I appointed the ancient people? He taketh the wise in their craftiness: 3and of these it concludeth, that the wisdom of God is immense and unconceivable;4 as, His wisdom is infinite. O the deepness of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! But here again is to be observed a difference between Philosophy and the word of God: §11. That even in the creation, the known or legal wisdom was darkened and maimed in men through sin, and therefore needeth a renewing by the word delivered to the Church. §22. That men without this heavenly doctrine are altogether ignorant of the especial wisdom of God revealed in the Gospel, whereby he saveth the Church gathered from amongst mankind by the Son; as it is said I give thee thanks, O Father, because thou hast hid these things from the wise and men of understanding,
Good.1) The goodness of God signifieth sometimes his bountifulness: as, Praise the Lord because he is good: sometimes all the virtues, and whatsoever is spoken of the nature of God: as, Let thy Spirit lead me through the right way. That which also is meant by the name of holiness or sanctity and light: So in this place by the name of goodness are understood, §11. All those things which are attributed to God in his word, and are represented and resembled in his image, as those things which are termed good in Angles and men, as life, power, wisdom, joy, righteousness, &c. For such is the nature of God, as it hath manifested it self in the Law and Gospel; and the goodness of the reasonable creature is an image of the divine goodness: and therefore here also differ Philosophy and the Scripture; in that Philosophy attributeth only to God that his goodness which was opened in the Law, and yet neither that wholly; but of his goodness revealed in the Gospel it is altogether ignorant. §22. By reason of the great and huge difference between the Creator and the creature, we understand those good things to be in God, which are agreeing to his divine nature and majesty: for those which are proper unto created natures would not be good in God, but rather a diminishing of his goodness. §33. By reason of the immensity of his divine nature, those things which are finite in creatures are in God infinite. And therefore against sundry and divers disputes of the Philosophers concerning the chiefest good, we learn in the Church, that God is the chiefest good. §44. Because nothing is unperfect or not subsisting by it self in God: whatsoever is attributed unto him is not in him, as forms or accidents in creatures: but such is his essence and nature, in a manner not able to be comprehended by our knowledge and understanding. §55. His nature and will is a rule of that goodness and uprightness which is in the creatures: for so far forth things are, and are called good, as they agree with the will of God. §66. God is the only fountain of goodness, and the first cause of all good things: so shall all things have so much goodness as God doth create and maintain in them;
1Righteous.) The righteousness of God sometimes in Scripture signifieth that which is accounted righteousness before him, and whereby he maketh us righteous: and that elsewhere legal, which is holiness of life, or conformity with the law of God, which God worketh in us by his Spirit begun in this life, and to be perfected in the life to come;2 as, The wrath of man doth not accomplish the righteousness of God. Or sometimes Evangelical, which is the righteousness of Christ imputed to believers, ⟨p. 161⟩of the free mercy of God: as,3 But now is the righteousness of God made manifest without the Law, having witness of the Law and of the Prophets, to wit, the righteousness of God by the faith of Jesus Christ unto all, and upon all that believe. Sometimes is meant that righteousness whereby himself is righteous: and then also in many places it signifieth the faithfulness, or mercy and benignity of God, who, according to his promises, preserveth, defendeth, and delivereth the faithful: as,4 Deliver me in thy righteousness. But when it is properly spoken of the righteousness of God whereby himself is righteous, (as in this place) he is called just, §11. In respect of his general justice and righteousness, which is the order or nature of his divine understanding and will, whereby God willeth and approveth, doth him self, and worketh in others unchangeably and unspeakably such things as he hath commanded in his law: and neither willeth, nor approveth, nor worketh, nor causeth, nor furthereth any thing whatsoever disagreeth from this order, but horribly hateth and detesteth them; as it is said, The righteous Lord loveth righteousness. §22. In respect of his particular justice and righteousness, which is the unchangeable will of God, whereby God giveth to him self, and will have given him by others that glory which is due unto the chief good; as he saith, I will not give my glory to another: and punisheth all sin with such punishment as is equal to the offence, that is, with eternal, as in them who perish; or with equivalent, as in his Son Christ sustaining the punishment for all those who are saved by him, according as it is said;
as it is said,1 God is just in all his ways. God is no accepter of persons. §33. Gods divine will is the chief and perfect rule, and only square of uprightness; and therefore God alone, because he is exceeding good▪ cannot of his own nature will, or work any unjust thing: but the wills and actions of all creatures are so far just, as they are made by God conformable to divine will. Now although all confess God to be righteous and just, because God hath imprinted this notion and knowledge of him self among other in the reasonable creature: because he is perfectly good, and therefore is the rule of perfect righteousness: because he witnesseth by examples of punishments and rewards that he hateth and punisheth unjust things, and liketh the just: because he is the Judge of the world, to whom it belongeth to compose, or set, and administer all things in a just order: because lastly he oweth not any thing to any nature, but by the right of a Creator, it is lawful for him to dispose of all things at his will, and therefore cannot be to any injurious; as it is said, When ye have done all, say, 2We are unprofitable servants. Who hath given unto him first, and he shall be recompensed? Is it not lawful for me to do as I will with mine own? 3Yet notwithstanding it is far off that men should judge aright of the righteousness and justice of God without the doctrine of the Church, because they have not the whole knowledge, not so much as of the law, wherein God made known his justice, and can affirm nothing certain concerning the everlasting punishments of sins, and are altogether ignorant of the punishment which the Son of God sustained for sins. Moreover, mens minds are troubled, so that they doubt Whether all things be governed of God in a just and upright order: §141. When they see it go well with the bad, and ill with the good. And to this objection the doctrine of the Church only is able to make answer, which showeth that God deferreth the punishments of the wicked and the rewards of the good to another life; inviteth the ungodly by his mildness and lenity to repentance; proveth and confirmeth the godly by exercises and calamities; punisheth and chastiseth many for their sins who seem in mens judgments to be guiltless: It goeth therefore evil with the good, but not finally.
Now as he deferreth the punishment of the wicked, thereby to invite them to repentance: so he afflicteth the godly, §11. Because they yet retain many sins. §22. To prove and try them. §33. To confirm their faith in them. Object. But justice requireth, that never any good should be done to the wicked, who rather were presently to be punished. Answ. Except there be a reasonable and just cause why to defer their punishment. Repl. But yet no harm should ever be done to the good. Ans. Not to those who are perfectly good: But we in this life are not perfectly ⟨p. 162⟩good. Repl. We are perfect in Christ. Ans. And therefore we are not punished of God, but only chastised, proved, and exercised, that so at length we may be also perfect in our selves. §22. When men consider, that God doth not cause and bring to pass that no sin be committed, when yet he might most easily do it: but farther, that he punisheth sins which went before, with after sins, and passeth at his pleasure things from one to another, 1as the Egyptians goods to the Israelites; and yet these things to be forbidden us by his law: it seemeth unto them that God will, and doth some things contrary to his law. But these things are contrary to his law and justice, if they be done by men; but if God do them, they are most just, and most agreeable to his law: for creatures are bound one to another, one to provide for another's safety whatsoever he can; but God is bound to none. §33. Some, when they hear that God doth not give alike and equally to men who are all by nature equal, that is, the sons of wrath; when as he converteth and saveth some, hardeneth and condemneth others; they deem that by this reason accepting of persons is laid upon God. But these men mark not, that then it is unjust to give unequally to those who are equal, when a due and deserved reward is paid; and that God doth give his blessings unto men not of due, but of his free bountifulness. Repl. Those things which are done according to justice, are done as due: But that good should be done to those who are good, the order of justice requireth: Therefore good is done unto the good as due. Answ. All this is true, if we talk of creatures: but if of God, not so; because the Creator is bound to none, as the creatures are; neither can the creatures deserve any thing of God, as they may one of another.
Wherefore God punisheth of justice, but doth good of grace and mercy; according as it is said,1 When ye have done all, say, We are unprofitable servants, we have done that which was our duty to do. And if any man reply, That not men only, but God also is bound by order of justice to spare, and to do well to the good, out of those words of Abraham, 2Wilt thou also destroy the righteous with the wicked? It is to be observed, that this bond is not of any desert or right that may make the Creator to stand answerable to the creature, but of Gods promise and truth: for God did most freely and of his exceeding goodness, when he ought nothing to any, bind himself by promises indented to do good unto the godly; and this goodness of God, and faithfulness in keeping his promises is often called justice: And therefore it is well said, that it agreeth not with God to afflict any undeservedly, not because he should injure any, though he destroyed him not offending; but because his mercy, and bountifulness, and truth doth admit this. These things are necessary to be ascribed of us to the justice of God, that the cogitation thereof may ascertain us of the punishment of the wicked, and of the deliverance of the godly from their injuries after this life; that so we may patiently bear whatsoever he will lay upon us,3 as it is said, O Lord, righteousness belongeth unto thee, but unto us open shame.
Wherefore God punisheth of justice, but doth good of grace and mercy; according as it is said,1 When yee have done all, say, Wee are unprofitable servants, wee have done that which was our duty to do. And if any man reply, That not men only, but God also is bound by order of justice to spare, and to doe well to the good, out of those words of Abraham, 2Wilt thou also destroy the righteous with the wicked? It is to be observed, that this bond is not of any desert or right that may make the Creatour to stand answerable to the creature, but of Gods promise and truth: for God did most freely and of his exceeding goodnesse, when hee ought nothing to any, bind himselfe by promises indented to doe good unto the godly; and this goodnesse of God, and faithfulnesse in keeping his promises is often called justice: And therefore it is well said, that it agreeth not with God to afflict any undeservedly, not because he should injure any, though he destroyed him not offending; but because his mercy, and bountifulnesse, and truth doth admit this. These things are necessary to be ascribed of us to the justice of God, that the cogitation thereof may ascertain us of the punishment of the wicked, and of the deliverance of the godly from their injuries after this life; that so wee may patiently bear whatsoever hee will lay upon us,
1True.) God teacheth us in the Scripture to know his truth after this manner: §11. That his infinite wisdom suffereth none but most true and certain knowledge of all things to be in him: There is no creature which is not manifest in his sight, but all things are naked unto his eyes with whom we have to do. §22. that he neither appointeth,2 nor willeth, nor speaketh things repugnant and contradictory: The Son of God, 3Jesus Christ, who was preached among you by us, was not yea and nay, but in him it was yea. §33. That he feigneth nothing, nor deceiveth any man, but this is in truth and indeed his will which he openeth unto us:4 Let God be true, and every man a liar. §44. That he never changeth his mind: My covenant will I not break, nor alter the thing that is gone out of my lips. §555. That it certainly cometh to pass: whatsoever God avoucheth shall come to pass; which experience also witnesseth, and many sayings of holy Scripture:6 as, Heaven and earth shall pass, but my word shall not pass away. §66. That he is the lover, author, and preserver of the truth in the reasonable creatures, and an enemy to all lies, dissembling, and hypocrisy: therefore the holy Ghost is called,7 The Spirit of truth, who should teach us all truth. The lying lips are an abomination unto the Lord: but they that deal truly are his delight. He will give him his portion with hypocrites. Seeing then the truth of God is to be considered ⟨p. 163⟩
And Christ was indeed departing, except his disciples had desired him to stay in the inn at Emmaus. As for that which God saith, And if a Prophet be deceived, and hath spoken a thing, that He hath deceived him: he signifieth not thereby that he deceiveth by instilling lies into false Prophets,1 but that they are by him in just judgment delivered and given to be seduced by the devil; as God is said to have given a lying spirit into the mouths of all the Prophets of Ahab. Repl. But yet God would that the false Prophet should tell a false tale. Ans. 2He would, but in divers respects, and to a diverse end. God fore-told victory to Ahab by an Irony, and that a sharp and bitter one, thereby to recall him from making his expedition to war, and to punish him for not obeying, by delivering him to be seduced by the devil: the false Prophets fore-told victory to flatter him, the devil to destroy him, and to die.
And Christ was indeed departing, except his disciples had desired him to stay in the inne at Emaus. As for that which God saith, And if a Prophet be deceived, and hath spoken a thing, that He hath deceived him: he signifieth not thereby that hee deceiveth by instilling lies into false Prophets,1 but that they are by him in just judgment delivered and given to be seduced by the divell; as God is said to have given a lying spirit into the mouthes of all the Prophets of Achab. Repl. But yet God would that the false Prophet should tell a false tale. Ans. 2Hee would, but in divers respects, and to a diverse end. God fore-told victory to Achab by an Irony, and that a sharp and bitter one, thereby to recall him from making his expedition to war, and to punish him for not obeying, by delivering him to be seduced by the divell: the false Prophets fore-told victory to flatter him, the divell to destroy him, and to die.
1Chaste.) There is made also mention of Chastity in the former description of God, because amongst his especial and most notable differences, whereby he may be discerned from devils, he will have truth to be, and chastity: for as God will be acknowledged to be true, and will have truth loved of us, that it may certainly appear that he is, and what he is, and that men may think and speak the truth of him, and through his knowledge be partakers of everlasting life; so the devil attempteth to fill the world with lies; that he may both darken the glory of God, and, by forging lies of God, destroy mankind. Whereupon the holy Ghost is called the Spirit of truth; 2but the devil a liar and murderer from the beginning, and the father of lies. And as God, both by reason of the exceeding purity of his nature, 3as also because he will have the spousal love and conjunction of marriage to be the image of the unspeakable love and spiritual conjunction between him and the Church, will therefore have it accounted sacred and holy amongst men; and as in these respects he is the lover and author of chastity, and doth most severely detest and punish all uncleanness, both internal and external, which is repugnant to this order; as the examples of the Sodomites, of the tribe of Benjamin, and others of all other ages and nations testify: So the devil (both for his impurity, and also because whatsoever God would have held most holy and venerable, that (for the hatred he beareth to God) he studieth most to deprave, and most foully to deform) endeavoureth with obscenity and filthiness horribly to pollute mankind, and to withdraw them from God. Therefore it is said, This is the will of God, even your sanctification, 4and that you should abstain from fornication, that every one of you should know how to possess his vessel in holiness and honour.
1Chaste.) There is made also mention of Chastity in the former description of God, because amongst his especiall and most notable differences, whereby he may be discerned from divels, he will have truth to be, and chastity: for as God will be acknowledged to be true, and will have truth loved of us, that it may certainly appear that hee is, and what he is, and that men may think and speak the truth of him, and through his knowledge be partakers of everlasting life; so the divell attempteth to fill the world with lies; that hee may both darken the glory of God, and, by forging lies of God, destroy mankind. Whereupon the holy Ghost is called the Spirit of truth;
1Merciful.) The mercy or favour and inclinable will of God to preserve his creature, and especially mankind, the Scripture proposeth unto us, opened by these degrees: §11. That he taketh delight in the salvation of all, but in the destruction of none: As I live, saith the Lord God, I desire not the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way, and live. §22. That he deferreth, mitigateth,2 and taketh away punishments; inviting all men by his long-suffering to repentance, if not one way, yet by the testimony of their conscience: hereof he is said to be slow to anger. §333. That he debaseth himself to relieve our infirmity both by inward and outward supplies, as by his Spirit, word, oaths, sacraments and miracles. §44. That he embraceth with singular love his chosen: so that he saveth and delivereth them for ⟨p. 164⟩ever from sin and all evils, and comforteth them also in afflictions. Repl. God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes. 4Though a woman should forget her child, yet will I not forget thee. §55. That he chose rather to bring to pass this our delivery, even by the incarnation and death of his only begotten Son, then that all mankind should perish. So God loved the world, 5that he gave his only begotten Son. §66. That he promiseth and performeth all these things of his own free goodness: I will show mercy to whom I will show mercy: 6and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion. I, even I am he that putteth away thine iniquities for mine own sake, and will not remember thy sins.
Answ. The names of affections, when they are attributed unto God by an Anthropopathy, they do not signify any passion or change in God, but an unspeakable either dislike, or liking of the objects. God therefore is said to be merciful, 1. Because he is against the destruction of his creature. 2. Because he doth those things which merciful men are wont to do.1 Object. 2. God seemeth sometimes to rejoice in revengement. Ans. He rejoiceth not in the revengement or punishment, but in the executing of his own justice.2 Object. 3. It seemeth in some places of Scripture, that Gods mercy doth not extend it self unto the wicked. Ans. This is to be understood of that degree of mercy wherewith he embraceth his chosen: And yet he spareth also the wicked; neither rejoiceth at their destruction. Object. 4. But yet he saveth not all, whereas he is able to do it: Therefore he is not exceeding merciful, neither merciful towards all. Answ. He doth not save all for most just cause; for his mercy is so to be exercised, that it hinder not the execution of his justice. Object. 5. He doth not take mercy on any, or receive any into favour without the satisfaction of his Son: Therefore he doth it not freely. Answ. That which is concluded doth not follow, because God of his free grace giveth this satisfaction it self, and applieth it unto us: Now he giveth a thing freely, who giveth the price of a thing for which the thing it self is given.
Answ. The names of affections, when they are attributed unto God by an Anthropopathy, they do not signifie any passion or change in God, but an unspeakable either dislike, or liking of the objects. God therefore is said to be mercifull, 1. Because he is against the destruction of his creature. 2. Because he doth those things which mercifull men are wont to do.1 Object. 2. God seemeth sometimes to rejoyce in revengement. Ans. He rejoyceth not in the revengement or punishment, but in the executing of his own justice.2 Object. 3. It seemeth in some places of Scripture, that Gods mercy doth not extend it selfe unto the wicked. Ans. This is to be understood of that degree of mercy wherewith he imbraceth his chosen: And yet he spareth also the wicked; neither rejoyceth at their destruction. Object. 4. But yet he saveth not all, whereas hee is able to doe it: Therefore he is not exceeding mercifull, neither mercifull towards all. Answ. He doth not save all for most just cause; for his mercy is so to be exercised, that it hinder not the execution of his justice. Object. 5. He doth not take mercy on any, or receive any into favour without the satisfaction of his Son: Therefore hee doth it not freely. Answ. That which is concluded doth not follow, because God of his free grace giveth this satisfaction it selfe, and applyeth it unto us: Now hee giveth a thing freely, who giveth the price of a thing for which the thing it selfe is given.
1Bountiful.) God is also called bountiful, 1. Because he createth and governeth all things. 2. He is the only fountain of all good things, 3. which befall to all creatures, 4. Yea, to the wicked, 5. Of his goodness, love, and free mercy towards all creatures, 6. But especially towards mankind, which he hath made according to his image, and for whose sake he hath created all other things; 7. But in them also chiefly towards his Church, to whom he hath opened himself and his will; 8. And in this his Church, towards his chosen Angels and men, to whom by his Son he giveth life and glory everlasting. And further, whom he is angry with, and on whom he inflicteth punishment, he is not angry with their substance or nature which himself created, but with that corruption which came by other means to his divine work:2 The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness. Object. No creature visible is subject to so many evils as man: Therefore he is not bountiful towards men. Answ. He is subject to these evils by an accident, that is, because of sin: but withal he is enriched above other creatures, with great blessings, even when he is out of the Church: but is most happy and blessed if he repent.
1Bountifull.) God is also called bountifull, 1. Because hee createth and governeth all things. 2. He is the only fountain of all good things, 3. which befall to all creatures, 4. Yea, to the wicked, 5. Of his goodnesse, love, and free mercy towards all creatures, 6. But especially towards mankind, which he hath made according to his image, and for whose sake he hath created all other things; 7. But in them also chiefly towards his Church, to whom hee hath opened himself and his will; 8. And in this his Church, towards his chosen Angels and men, to whom by his Son he giveth life and glory everlasting. And further, whom he is angry with, and on whom he inflicteth punishment, he is not angry with their substance or nature which himself created, but with that corruption which came by other means to his divine work:2 The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodlinesse. Object. No creature visible is subject to so many evils as man: Therefore he is not bountifull towards men. Answ. He is subject to these evils by an accident, that is, because of sin: but withall he is enriched above other creatures, with great blessings, even when hee is out of the Church: but is most happy and blessed if he repent.
1Most free.) God also alone is most free, because he alone by nature is such, 1. That no fault or misery can fall upon him. 2. Neither can he be constrained of any. 3. Neither is he bound to any. 4. Neither is he subject or tied to the rule or lore of another. Wherefore whatsoever he willeth and doth, that he willeth and doth himself most freely, ⟨p. 165⟩when, as much, and in what manner he will; and what he will, that is most good and just. But here chiefly is considered the freedom of will, or liberty from constraint; which is the power and ability whereby God, without any necessity, hath from everlasting decreed the whole order of creation, preservation, and rule of all things, and doth accomplish the same, not being constrained or tied to other causes; yet so, that he never swerveth from his rightness. To this bear witness his miracles, and many examples of deliveries and punishments, and many places of Scripture; as, Whatsoever pleased the Lord, that did he in the heaven and earth, 2in the sea, and in all the depth. It is not hard to the Lord to save with many or with few. 3Object. 1. That without which second causes, which work necessarily, cannot work, doth it self also work necessarily: Without the first cause, which is God, second causes, which necessarily work, cannot work: Therefore the first cause also, which is God, worketh together with them necessarily. Answ. The Major is true of such causes as work with absolute necessity: but it is false of such as work only of a conditional necessity; that is, because it so pleased God (who notwithstanding could move them otherwise, or else at all not move them, or not so much as make them) that they should work, and should work after that manner which they do work: Therefore all second causes depend on the first, but not the first any way on the second. Object. 2. God is unchangeably good: Therefore not freely good. Ans. This unchangeableness doth not diminish, but establish the liberty of Gods will: for it is not the unchangeableness of a nature, but constraint and coaction which is contrary to liberty; and so much the more freely the will chooseth, with how much the greater and surer force and motion it is carried unto her object. Object. 3. It is said also of particular events, that God can only will those things which are best: But only those things which he hath decreed are best:
Therefore he cannot will other things. But answer is made to the Minor: What things God hath decreed, those are best, not before, but after his decree: for Gods will being the rule and square of rightness, therefore are all things good, because he willeth them. Wherefore if he would have from everlasting had any other thing, that then should have been best: As that Joseph should be sold, and made lord of Egypt, and give sustenance to his fathers family, was best, because God would so. Now if God would have any other way exercised Joseph, and taken vengeance on his brethren, that should then have been the best. It followeth therefore, that God willeth no other thing, after he hath once decreed what he will have done: but that he was able from everlasting to have decreed some other thing: for whatsoever he would, that from everlasting he would most freely. Object. 4. Some places of Scripture seem to intimate, that the will of God may be sometimes hindered by his creatures: as, I desire not the death of the wicked. 1How often would I have gathered thee, and thou wouldest not? Answ. These and the like places only show with what God is delighted, and to what he inviteth and calleth all: but not what by his mercy and Spirit he hath purposed to work in every one. Wherefore this doctrine of the liberty and free will of God let us diligently maintain, that both the glory of God may be vindicated from Stoical blasphemies; and in us faith, hope, invocating on God, and sedulity and earnestness in performing our duty may be established, if, acknowledging God most freely to govern all his creatures, we be neither secure in prosperity, nor in adversity do cast away hope and good endeavours.
Therefore he cannot will other things. But answer is made to the Minor: What things God hath decreed, those are best, not before, but after his decree: for Gods will being the rule and square of rightnesse, therefore are all things good, because hee willeth them. Wherefore if hee would have from everlasting had any other thing, that then should have been best: As that Joseph should be sold, and made lord of Egypt, and give sustenance to his fathers family, was best, because God would so. Now if God would have any other way exercised Joseph, and taken vengeance on his brethren, that should then have been the best. It followeth therefore, that God willeth no other thing, after he hath once decreed what he will have done: but that hee was able from everlasting to have decreed some other thing: for whatsoever he would, that from everlasting he would most freely. Object. 4. Some places of Scripture seem to intimate, that the will of God may be sometimes hindered by his creatures: as, I desire not the death of the wicked.
1Angry and wroth with sin.) Lastly, in the description of Gods nature is put, That he is angry and wroth with offences and sins: which horrible anger and wrath of God, whereby he detesteth and punisheth all sins, although all the wicked at length too late perceive and have experience of when they rush into eternal despair; yet such his displeasure and indignation as God will have to be known, they cannot so much as conceive who are without the Church, seeing they neither judge all those evils to be sins, which God in his law threateneth he will punish with everlasting torments: neither know the death and punishment of the Son of God, then which, God could not show a greater token and argument of his anger against sin. The elect and chosen alone are throughly moved by a right and saving ⟨p. 166⟩knowledge thereof, gathered out of Gods punishments and threatenings, to conversion and the fear of God. But the greatness of it no man can fully conceive; according as it is said,2 Who knoweth the power of thy wrath?
1Angry and wroth with sin.) Lastly, in the description of Gods nature is put, That he is angry and wroth with offences and sins: which horrible anger and wrath of God, whereby hee detesteth and punisheth all sins, although all the wicked at length too late perceive and have experience of when they rush into eternall despaire; yet such his displeasure and indignation as God will have to be knowne, they cannot so much as conceive who are without the Church, seeing they neither judge all those evils to be sins, which God in his law threatneth hee will punish with everlasting torments: neither know the death and punishment of the Son of God, then which, God could not shew a greater token and argument of his anger against sin. The elect and chosen alone are throughly moved by a right and saving ⟨p. 166⟩knowledge thereof, gathered out of Gods punishments and threatnings, to conversion and the fear of God. But the greatnesse of it no man can fully conceive; according as it is said,2
An Admonition to the Reader. Christian and courteous Reader, whereas in the conference of the two copies, I found in the former a large Paraphrase delivered by U•sinus on the description of God; and in the latter a brief Abstract thereof collected by David Pareus, I judged it meet to retain the Paraphrase for help of weaker understandings, and to adjoin the Abridgement for help of weaker memories. If on this advertisement thou advisedly peruse both the one and the other, I hope the fruit of both will be neither to thee nor me lost labour.
An Admonition to the Reader. CHristian and courteous Reader, whereas in the conference of the two copies, I found in the former a large Paraphrase delivered by U•sinus on the description of God; and in the latter a brief Abstract thereof collected by David Pareus, I judged it meet to retain the Paraphrase for help of weaker understandings, and to adjoyn the Abridgement for help of weaker memories. If on this advertisement thou advisedly peruse both the one and the other, I hope the fruit of both will be neither to thee nor me lost labour.
God is an essence.) That is, a thing which hath his being from none but himself, and is preserved and sustained of none, but subsisteth by himself, and is the only cause unto all other things of their being: therefore called Jehovah, as if you would say, Being by himself and causing others to be.
GOd is an essence.) That is, a thing which hath his being from none but himself, and is preserved and sustained of none, but subsisteth by himselfe, and is the only cause unto all other things of their being: therefore called Jehovah, as if you would say, Being by himself and causing others to be.
Spiritual.) Incorporeal, invisible, and to no sense of man perceivable. Likewise in that he liveth of and by himself, and quickeneth or giveth life to other things.1 Object. 1. He oftentimes appeared. Ans. True, in a bodily form assumed for a time. Object. 2. He was seen face to face. Ans. That is, by the clear knowledge of the mind, and not with the bodily eyes. Object. 3. He hath the parts of a mans body. Ans. Indeed they are ascribed unto him after the manner of men. Object. 4. The bodily man is the image of God. Ans. Surely he is so in the essence of his soul, in the faculties and uprightness thereof,2 in wisdom, righteousness, and true holiness; not in the shape and figure of his body.
S•i•ituall.) Incorporeall, invisible, and to no sense of man perceivable. Likewise in that he liveth of and by himselfe, and quickeneth or giveth life to other things.1 Object. 1. He oftentimes appeared. Ans. True, in a bodily form assumed for a time. Object. 2. He was seen face to face. Ans. That is, by the clear knowledge of the mind, and not with the bodily eyes. Object. 3. He hath the parts of a mans body. Ans. Indeed they are ascribed unto him after the manner of men. Object. 4. The bodily man is the image of God. Ans. Surely he is so in the essence of his soul, in the faculties and uprightnesse thereof,2 in wisdome, righteousnesse, and true holinesse; not in the shape and figure of his body.
Intelligent.) Witness hereof is the mind of man, and the notions shining therein, which all proceeded from God.1 Now, He that planted the ear, shall he not hear?
Intelligent.) Witnesse hereof is the mind of man, and the notions shining therein, which all proceeded from God.1 Now, He that planted the ear, shall he not hear?
Other from the creatures.) Not Nature it self (as some dream) not the matter or form, not any part, but the sole efficient, and the only maker of all things: neither intermingled with any thing, but of a quite different, or other essence, and utterly unlike all things.1 Object. 1. All things are of God. Ans. I grant they are, by creation out of nothing. Object. 2. We are the generation of God. Ans. Yea verily, by a similitude of properties,2 and by creation. Object. 3. The Saints are born of God. Ans. Questionless, by regeneration through the holy Ghost. Object. 4. We are made partakers of the divine nature. Answ. Undoubtedly, by the dwelling of God in us, and by our conformity with him. Obj. 5. Christ is God and hath a divine body. Ans. To wit, by a personal union and glorification.
Other from the creatures.) Not Nature it self (as some dream) not the matter or form, not any part, but the sole efficient, and the only maker of all things: neither intermingled with any thing, but of a quite different, or other essence, and utterly unlike all things.1 Object. 1. All things are of God. Ans. I grant they are, by creation out of nothing. Object. 2. We are the generation of God. Ans. Yea verily, by a similitude of properties,2 and by creation. Object. 3. The Saints are born of God. Ans. Questionlesse, by regeneration through the holy Ghost. Object. 4. We are made partakers of the divine nature. Answ. Undoubtedly, by the dwelling of God in us, and by our conformity with him. Obj. 5. Christ is God and hath a divine body. Ans. To wit, by a personall union and glorification.
Incomprehensible.) 1. In our cogitation, and the cogitation of any creature. 2. In the unmeasurablenesse of his essence. 3. By communication of the essence, which is in such sort the very substance of the three persons of the Divinity, that it remaineth in number one and the same.
Most perfect in himself.) 1. Sole possessor of all blessedness. 2. And that in himself, and of himself. 3. with sufficiency to replenish all other things. Object. 1. The Lord hath made all things for himself. 1Answ. Not to aid himself by them, but to communicate himself to them. Object. 2. He useth the creatures ministry in accomplishing many of his works. Answ. Not as needing, but honouring the creature. Object. 3. We yield him worship. Answ. It is our debt, his due, and the issue is our good and benefit alone. Object. 4. To whom is given that which is due unto him, to him something cometh thereby more then he had before. Answ. This assertion is false of that which is due by order of justice, and pertaineth to the ⟨p. 167⟩felicity of the giver. Obj. 5. God rejoiceth in our obedience. Ans. He doth so; our obedience being an object not an efficient cause of his rejoicing.
Most perfect in himself.) 1. Sole possessor of all blessednesse. 2. And that in himselfe, and of himself. 3. with sufficiency to replenish all other things. Object. 1. The Lord hath made all things for himself. 1Answ. Not to aid himselfe by them, but to communicate himselfe to them. Object. 2. Hee useth the creatures ministery in accomplishing many of his works. Answ. Not as needing, but honouring the creature. Object. 3. Wee yeeld him worship. Answ. It is our debt, his due, and the issue is our good and benefit alone. Object. 4. To whom is given that which is due unto him, to him something cometh thereby more then hee had before. Answ. This assertion is false of that which is due by order of justice, and pertaineth to the ⟨p. 167⟩felicity of the giver. Obj. 5. God rejoyceth in our obedience. Ans. He doth so; our obedience being an object not an efficient cause of his rejoycing.
Unchangeable.) 1. In his essence. 2. In his will. 3. In place, because he is immense, and filleth all things. Object. 1. God repenteth him of things done. Ans. To repent, and such like humane affections are attributed to God by Anthropopathy, or after the manner of men. Object. 2. He promiseth and threateneth that which he performeth not at all. Ans. True; but a condition and exception is always understood. Object. 3. He dependeth on a changeable condition. Ans. To wit, changeable in respect of mans will, but not of Gods decree and counsel. Object. 4. He changeth his precepts, observances and works. Ans. Namely, according to his everlasting decree.
Unchangeable.) 1. In his essence. 2. In his will. 3. In place, because he is immense, and filleth all things. Object. 1. God repenteth him of things done. Ans. To repent, and such like humane affections are attributed to God by Anthropopathy, or after the manner of men. Object. 2. He promiseth and threatneth that which he performeth not at all. Ans. True; but a condition and exception is alwaies understood. Object. 3. He dependeth on a changeable condition. Ans. To wit, changeable in respect of mans will, but not of Gods decree and counsell. Object. 4. He changeth his precepts, observances and works. Ans. Namely, according to his everlasting decree.
Omnipotent.) 1. He can do, and doth all things which he still. 2. And that at his beck, without difficulty. 3. As having all things in his own power. Object. Many things he cannot do. Ans. They are then the works of impotency and imperfection, as to lie, to die.
Of exceeding wisdom.) 1. In beholding and understanding himself, and perceiving at once the whole order of his mind and nature, which he doth perpetually, and exceeding perfectly. 2. In being the cause of all knowledge in Angels and men.
Of exceeding wisdome.) 1. In beholding and understanding himselfe, and perceiving at once the whole order of his minde and nature, which hee doth perpetually, and exceeding perfectly. 2. In being the cause of all knowledge in Angels and men.
Of exceeding goodness.) 1. Because Gods whole nature is such as is revealed in the Law and the Gospel. 2. Because he is the cause and rule of all good in his creatures. 3. Because he is the most supreme good. 4. Because he is the very essence of goodness.
Of exceeding goodnesse.) 1. Because Gods whole nature is such as is revealed in the Law and the Gospel. 2. Because he is the cause and rule of all good in his creatures. 3. Because hee is the most supreme good. 4. Because he is the very essence of goodnesse.
Just.) 1. In respect of his general justice and righteousness, whereby he willeth and worketh unchangeably such things as he hath commanded in his Law. 2. In respect of his particular justice, whereby he immutably dispenseth aright rewards and punishments. In that he is the rule of righteousness, and square of uprightness in his creatures. Object. 1. He doth good to the evil, and heapeth evils on the good. Answ. He doth; but not finally, but only for a time. Object. 2. He doth not punish the wicked out of hand. Answ. For he providently deferreth their punishments for special occasions best known to himself. Object. 3. No harm should ever be done to the good. Answ. Not to those which are perfectly good, which we in this life are not. Object. 4. He doth something contrary to his law. Answ. He abridgeth certainly something from his general will by his special will. Object. 5. He giveth to men of equal condition unequal rewards. Answ. Yet giveth he to each of them that which no way is their due. Repl. They are due by order of justice. Ans. God is bound unto no man. Repl. Promise is a debt. Ans. The promise of creatures, not of God the Creator.
Just.) 1. In respect of his generall justice and righteousnesse, whereby hee willeth and worketh unchangeably such things as he hath commanded in his Law. 2. In respect of his particular justice, whereby he immutably dispenseth aright rewards and punishments. In that he is the rule of righteousnesse, and square of uprightnesse in his creatures. Object. 1. Hee doth good to the evill, and heapeth evils on the good. Answ. Hee doth; but not finally, but onely for a time. Object. 2. Hee doth not punish the wicked out of hand. Answ. For he providently deferreth their punishments for speciall occasions best known to himself. Object. 3. No harm should ever be done to the good. Answ. Not to those which are perfectly good, which wee in this life are not. Object. 4. Hee doth something contrary to his law. Answ. He abridgeth certainly something from his generall will by his speciall will. Object. 5. Hee giveth to men of equall condition unequall rewards. Answ. Yet giveth he to each of them that which no way is their due. Repl. They are due by order of justice. Ans. God is bound unto no man. Repl. Promise is a debt. Ans. The promise of creatures, not of God the Creatour.
True.) 1. Because he hath the true and certain knowledge of all things. 2. Because he neither willeth, nor speaketh things repugnant or contrary. 3. Because he feigneth nothing, nor deceiveth any man. 4. Because he never changeth his mind. 5. Because he ratifieth his sayings by the events of things. 6. Because he enjoineth and prescribeth truth to be kept of all. Object. 1. He fore-telleth that which he will not have done. Ans. He fore-telleth that it shall come to pass, but conditionally. Object. 2. He deceiveth the Prophets. Answ. That is,1 he in his just judgment delivereth them up to the devil to be seduced.
True.) 1. Because he hath the true and certain knowledge of all things. 2. Because he neither willeth, nor speaketh things repugnant or contrary. 3. Because he faineth nothing, nor deceiveth any man. 4. Because he never changeth his mind. 5. Because he ratifieth his sayings by the events of things. 6. Because he enjoyneth and prescribeth truth to be kept of all. Object. 1. Hee fore-telleth that which hee will not have done. Ans. He fore-telleth that it shall come to passe, but conditionally. Object. 2. He deceiveth the Prophets. Answ. That is,1 he in his just judgment delivereth them up to the divell to be seduced.
Chaste.) 1. By reason of the exceeding purity of his nature. 2. Because he is the lover and author of chastity. 3. Because he doth most severely detest and punish all uncleanness, both internal and external. 4. Because by this notable note of difference he distinguisheth himself from unclean spirits and filthy devils:1 This is the will of God, even your sanctification, and that ye should abstain from fornication: That every one of you should know how to possess his vessel in holiness and honour, &c. 2Ye shall not defile your selves in any of these things; for in all these the nations are defiled.
Chaste.) 1. By reason of the exceeding purity of his nature. 2. Because he is the lover and author of chastity. 3. Because he doth most severely detest and punish all uncleannesse, both internall and externall. 4. Because by this notable note of difference he distinguisheth himself from unclean spirits and filthy divels:1 This is the will of God, even your sanctification, and that ye should abstain from fornication: That every one of you should know how to possesse his vessell in holinesse and honour, &c. 2Ye shall not defile your selves in any of these things; for in all these the nations are defiled.
seeing by reason of his immensity whereby he filleth heaven and earth, he can neither depart, nor be absent from any place. §55. Seeing he is most wise, and therefore from everlasting hath most well purposed, decreed, and fore-seen all things; change of purpose and will cannot fall into him: And therefore God would have this in many places of holy Scripture inculcated unto us, that his nature and will is subject to no mutations, as being a thing most respecting his glory: God is not as man that he should lie,1 nor as the son of man that he should repent. Hath he said it then, and shall he not do it? Hath hee spoken, and shall he not accomplish it? The counsell of the Lord shall endure for ever, 2and the thoughts of his heart from generation to generation. With whom is no variablenesse, 3neither shadow of change §1Object. 1. But God is said to repent. Ans. He is said to repent,4 not that he changeth his will: but, 1. Because he earnestly detesteth sins, and is not delighted, with the destruction of men. §22. Because by reason of this hatred against sin, and this mercy toward; repentant sinners, hee maketh change of things and events, which from everlasting hee decreed, as men are wont to doe who repent them of their purpose: for among men, every change is an amending of that which disliketh them; amending riseth from repentance; wherefore the name of repentance, as also the names of other humane affections, are said to be attributed to God by an Anthropopathy, because the Scripture speaketh of God after the manner of men for our infirmity; that we, understanding those things which are in us to be shadowes of those which are in God, may in some sort conceive something of the nature of God and his will towards mankind. Wherefore these forms of speaking do not signifie any perturbation in God, or change or passion like unto our affections, but are used to signifie these two things of God:5 §11. That it is not a fained or dissembled, but an earnest, eternall, unchangeable nature all will in God, a shadow and image whereof hee would have the affections and motions created in men to be: yet is it without all trouble, or hindrance, or diminishing of his blessednesse and joy. §22. That he doth those things which men are wont to go, being stirred up by those affections which are attributed to God;
And these conditions are sometimes expressed, as Jer. 18 and 28. where plainly is set down this rule of understanding Gods promises and threatnings: as, That God will punish them who depart from him, unto whom hee had promised blessings: and will spare those who repent, to whom hee had threatned punishment. And sometimes they are closely understood, especially in the threatnings and comminations, thereby even to wrest repentance, and more timely and earnest prayers from us, by which, as means interposed and coming between, hee hath decreed to save and deliver us. Repl. But these conditions are uncertain and changeable: Therefore the will of God is also changeable. Answ. In respect of the nature, will, and judgement of man, they are changeable; but in respect of the counsell and providence of God, unchangeable and most certain: for God hath decreed from everlasting the means and ends of things; as also he hath decreed in whom he will, and in whom he will not work conversion. Ob. 3. He changeth many his precepts, and observances, and works, as the Mosaicall laws and government. Ans. He changeth them indeed, but so, as he would also from everlasting that change; neither are all things appointed of God for perpetuity; but he decreed from everlasting some things to last only for a time. Wherefore be it to us out of all controversie, that God is unchangeable: For,§1 1This is amongst those especiall differences whereby the Creatour will be discerned from all creatures, That he only can by no means be changed whereas all other things both are diversly changed, and may at the only pleasure of God be changed infinitely, howsoever for a while, so long as it is his pleasure, they are, and seem arm and immutable, according as it is said, Heaven and earth shall passe, but my word shall not passe. §22Hence we may understand, and are assured, That all things in the world are governed by the everlasting providence of God: For seeing no mutation happeneth to God, it must needs be, that an his counsels were purposed from everlasting. And seeing God both foreseeth all things unchangeably, and his counsels concerning the event and end of things are certain and unchangeable; it must needs be also that the second causes and means, or antecedents, without which those events were not to follow, must be certain and unchangeable.
1Omnipotent.) When as Omnipotency is attributed to God, thereby is understood, §11. That whatsoever he will, or whatsoever, not impairing his nature and majesty, he is able to will, he is also able to perform. §22. That he is able to perform all those things without any difficulty and labour, even with his onely beck and will. §33. That all the force and power of working and effecting any thing is so in God onely, that there is not the least ability or efficacy of any creature, but what he continually imparteth and preserveth at his pleasure: and therefore the power of God is to be considered of us, not as being idle, but as creating, sustaining, moving, and ruling all things: The reasons are, 1. God is the first cause of all things; therfore he hath all things in his power, and their ability is so much as he giveth unto them. 2. He doth such things as can be done by no created and finite power: as are the creation and governing of all things the preservation of commonweals, the deluge. the delivery out of Egypt, and all his miracles. 3 Hee is unchangeable; therefore in him to be able to do, and to do, is the same which to will, and so of the contrary. But although all men affirme God to be omnipotent, yet there is a double difference between the sacred doctrine of the Church,2 and Philosophy concerning Gods omnipotency: For, §11. Without the doctrine of the Church men only know the universall and generall power of God, whereby hee createth, preserveth and governeth the whole world: but they know not that power whereby he saveth men, and restoreth the world by his Son, gathering and preserving an everlasting Church, and delivering it from sin and death, and endowing it with life and glory everlasting, by which works God especially sheweth forth his power, as it is said Yet a little while and I shall shake the heavens, and the earth, and the sea, 3and the drie land. §22. Neither do they professe of the generall power of God so much as is sufficient: for albeit they are enforced to confesse, that God is the author and preserver of the world; yet are they not able to say, that all things were created of nothing by the word of God alone: and forasmuch as they are ignorant of the cause of sin and confusion, they cannot affirm all things so to be administred and governed by Gods omnipotency, as that all which is good is done by the powerfull working of Gods will;
1Of exceeding and immense wisdome.) That wee may rightly, and with profit and commodity know the power of God, it is necessary not to consider it but as it is joyned with his immense wisdome and goodnesse, which moderateth it. Further, of his divine wisdome we learn, 1. That God doth of himself, in one act or view, under stand and behold perpetually and most perfectly. in marvellous manner, and that unknown to us, himselfe and the whole order of his minde declared in the nature of things, and in his ⟨p. 160⟩word; and what agreeth therewith, and disagreeth; and all his works, and all the works of all creatures, past, present, and to come; and all the causes and circumstances of all things. 2. That all Angels and men have no more knowledge of divine and humane matters then God doth work and maintain in their mindes: for among other things, the most beautifull and sightly order which is in the nature of things, the ends and uses of all things, the signification of future events, arts and sciences, the everting and overturning of those devices which the divell and wicked men have most craftily contrived against God and all the godly, doe enforce all men to confesse, that these things could not proceed but from a most wise artificer and author. Wherefore also the Scripture it selfe willeth us to consider the wisdome of God shining in these his works:2 God hath made every thing beautifull in his time. Who is like mee, that shall call, and shall declare it, and set it in order before me, since I appointed the ancient people? He taketh the wise in their craftinesse: 3and of these it concludeth, that the wisdome of God is immense and unconceivable;4 as, His wisdome is infinite. O the deepnesse of the riches both of the wisdome and knowledge of God! But here again is to be observed a difference between Philosophy and the word of God: §11. That even in the creation, the known or legall wisdome was darkned and maimed in men through sin, and therefore needeth a renewing by the word delivered to the Church. §22. That men without this heavenly doctrine are altogether ignorant of the especiall wisdome of God revealed in the Gospel, whereby hee saveth the Church gathered from amongst mankind by the Son; as it is said I give thee thanks, O Father, because thou hast hid these things from the wise and men of understanding, 5and hast opened them unto babes.
Good.1) The goodnesse of God signifieth sometimes his bountifulnesse: as, Praise the Lord because he is good: sometimes all the vertues, and whatsoever is spoken of the nature of God: as, Let thy Spirit lead me through the right way. That which also is meant by the name of holinesse or sanctity and light: So in this place by the name of goodnesse are understood, §11. All those things which are attributed to God in his word, and are represented and resembled in his image, as those things which are termed good in Angles and men, as life, power, wisdom, joy, righteousnesse, &c. For such is the nature of God, as it hath manifested it self in the Law and Gospel; and the goodnesse of the reasonable creature is an image of the divine goodnesse: and therefore here also differ Philosophy and the Scripture; in that Philosophy attributeth onely to God that his goodnesse which was opened in the Law, and yet neither that wholly; but of his goodnesse revealed in the Gospel it is altogether ignorant. §22. By reason of the great and huge difference between the Creator and the creature, we understand those good things to be in God, which are agreeing to his divine nature and majesty: for those which are proper unto created natures would not be good in God, but rather a diminishing of his goodnesse. §33. By reason of the immensity of his divine nature, those things which are finite in creatures are in God infinite. And therefore against sundry and divers disputes of the Philosophers concerning the chiefest good, we learn in the Church, that God is the chiefest good. §44. Because nothing is unperfect or not subsisting by it self in God: whatsoever is attributed unto him is not in him, as forms or accidents in creatures: but such is his essence and nature, in a manner not able to be comprehended by our knowledge and understanding. §55. His nature and will is a rule of that goodnesse and uprightnesse which is in the creatures: for so far forth things are, and are called good, as they agree with the will of God. §66. God is the only fountain of goodnesse, and the first cause of all good things: so shall all things have so much goodnesse as God doth create and maintain in them;2 and in this sense it is said, There is none good but God only, even so as he is most perfectly good, and the fountain of goodnesse.
1Righteous.) The righteousnesse of God sometimes in Scripture signifieth that which is accounted righteousnesse before him, and whereby he maketh us righteous: and that elsewhere legall, which is holinesse of life, or conformity with the law of God, which God worketh in us by his Spirit begun in this life, and to be perfected in the life to come;2 as, The wrath of man doth not accomplish the righteousnesse of God. Or sometimes Evangelicall, which is the righteousnesse of Christ imputed to beleevers, ⟨p. 161⟩of the free mercy of God: as,3 But now is the righteousnesse of God made manifest without the Law, having witnesse of the Law and of the Prophets, to wit, the righteousnesse of God by the faith of Jesus Christ unto all, and upon all that beleeve. Sometimes is meant that righteousnesse whereby himselfe is righteous: and then also in many places it signifieth the faithfulnesse, or mercy and benignity of God, who, according to his promises, preserveth, defendeth, and delivereth the faithfull: as,4 Deliver me in thy righteousness. But when it is properly spoken of the righteousnesse of God whereby himself is righteous, (as in this place) he is called just, §11. In respect of his generall justice and righteousnesse, which is the order or nature of his divine understanding and will, whereby God willeth and approveth, doth him self, and worketh in others unchangeably and unspeakably such things as he hath commanded in his law: and neither willeth, nor approveth, nor worketh, nor causeth, nor furthereth any thing whatsoever disagreeth from this order, but horribly hateth and detesteth them; as it is said, The righteous Lord loveth righteousnesse. §22. In respect of his particular justice and righteousnesse, which is the unchangeable will of God, whereby God giveth to him selfe, and will have given him by others that glory which is due unto the chief good; as he saith, I will not give my glory to another: and punisheth all sin with such punishment as is equall to the offence, that is, with eternall, as in them who perish; or with equivalent, as in his Son Christ sustaining the punishment for all those who are saved by him, according as it is said;5 Thou shalt not depart thence untill thou hast paid the utmost farthing: And cannot injure any creature, whatsoever hee determineth of him, or doth unto him, because hee oweth no man any thing;
as it is said,1 God is just in all his wayes. God is no accepter of persons. §33. Gods divine will is the chiefe and perfect rule, and only square of uprightnesse; and therefore God alone, because hee is exceeding good▪ cannot of his own nature will, or work any unjust thing: but the wils and actions of all creatures are so far just, as they are made by God conformable to divine will. Now although all confesse God to be righteous and just, because God hath imprinted this notion and knowledge of him selfe among other in the reasonable creature: because he is perfectly good, and therefore is the rule of perfect righteousnesse: because he witnesseth by examples of punishments and rewards that hee hateth and punisheth unjust things, and liketh the just: because he is the Judge of the world, to whom it belongeth to compose, or set, and administer all things in a just order: because lastly he oweth not any thing to any nature, but by the right of a Creatour, it is lawfull for him to dispose of all things at his will, and therefore cannot be to any injurious; as it is said, When ye have done all, say, 2Wee are unprofitable servants. Who hath given unto him first, and he shall be recompenced? Is it not lawfull for me to do as I will with mine own? 3Yet notwithstanding it is far off that men should judge aright of the righteousnesse and justice of God without the doctrine of the Church, because they have not the whole knowledge, not so much as of the law, wherein God made known his justice, and can affirme nothing certain concerning the everlasting punishments of sins, and are altogether ignorant of the punishment which the Son of God sustained for sins. Moreover, mens minds are troubled, so that they doubt Whether all things be governed of God in a just and upright order: §141. When they see it go well with the bad, and ill with the good. And to this objection the doctrine of the Church only is able to make answer, which sheweth that God deferreth the punishments of the wicked and the rewards of the good to another life; inviteth the ungodly by his mildnesse and lenity to repentance; proveth and confirmeth the godly by exercises and calamities; punisheth and chastiseth many for their sins who seem in mens judgments to be guiltlesse: It goeth therefore evill with the good, but not finally.5
Now as he deferreth the punishment of the wicked, thereby to invite them to repentance: so hee afflicteth the godly, §11. Because they yet retain many sins. §22. To prove and try them. §33. To confirm their faith in them. Object. But justice requireth, that never any good should be done to the wicked, who rather were presently to be punished. Answ. Except there be a reasonable and just cause why to deferre their punishment. Repl. But yet no harme should ever be done to the good. Ans. Not to those who are perfectly good: But wee in this life are not perfectly ⟨p. 162⟩good. Repl. Wee are perfect in Christ. Ans. And therefore we are not punished of God, but onely chastised, proved, and exercised, that so at length wee may be also perfect in our selves. §22. When men consider, that God doth not cause and bring to passe that no sin be committed, when yet he might most easily do it: but farther, that he punisheth sins which went before, with after sins, and passeth at his pleasure things from one to another, 1as the Egyptians goods to the Israelites; and yet these things to be forbidden us by his law: it seemeth unto them that God will, and doth some things contrary to his law. But these things are contrary to his law and justice, if they be done by men; but if God doe them, they are most just, and most agreeable to his law: for creatures are bound one to another, one to provide for anothers safety whatsoever he can; but God is bound to none. §33. Some, when they heare that God doth not give alike and equally to men who are all by nature equall, that is, the sons of wrath; when as hee converteth and saveth some, hardeneth and condemneth others; they deem that by this reason accepting of persons is laid upon God. But these men mark not, that then it is unjust to give unequally to those who are equall, when a due and deserved reward is payd; and that God doth give his blessings unto men not of due, but of his free bountifulnesse. Repl. Those things which are done according to justice, are done as due: But that good should be done to those who are good, the order of justice requireth: Therefore good is done unto the good as due. Answ. All this is true, if we talk of creatures: but if of God, not so; because the Creatour is bound to none, as the creatures are; neither can the creatures deserve any thing of God, as they may one of another.
1True.) God teacheth us in the Scripture to know his truth after this manner: §11. That his infinite wisdome suffereth none but most true and certain knowledge of all things to be in him: There is no creature which is not manifest in his sight, but all things are naked unto his eyes with whom wee have to doe. §22. that hee neither appointeth,2 nor willeth, nor speaketh things repugnant and contradictory: The Son of God, 3Jesus Christ, who was preached among you by us, was not yea and nay, but in him it was yea. §33. That he faineth nothing, nor deceiveth any man, but this is in truth and indeed his will which hee openeth unto us:4 Let God be true, and every man a lyar. §44. That he never changeth his minde: My covenant will I not breake, nor alter the thing that is gone out of my lips. §555. That it certainly cometh to passe: whatsoever God avoucheth shall come to passe; which experience also witnesseth, and many sayings of holy Scripture:6 as, Heaven and earth shall passe, but my word shall not passe away. §66. That he is the lover, author, and preserver of the truth in the reasonable creatures, and an enemy to all lyes, dissembling, and hypocrisie: therefore the holy Ghost is called,7 The Spirit of truth, who should teach us all truth. The lying lips are an abomination unto the Lord: but they that deale truely are his delight. Hee will give him his portion with hypocrites. Seeing then the truth of God is to be considered ⟨p. 163⟩out of his word and works, albeit men by nature confesse that God is true: yet are they ignorant wherein truth consisteth: for it is said, Thy word is truth. 8Thy truth in the congregation of the saints. Neither doth the conscience or the privie knowledge of any mans sins suffer him who knoweth not Christ the Mediatour to put any confidence in Gods promises; for, as it is said, All the promises of God in him are yea, 9and in him Amen, unto the glory of God. 10But if sometimes God fore-told that he would do those things which hee never decreed to doe, hee did not therein dissemble: for what hee threatned, that hee meant with this condition should so come to passe, except the conversion of men and prayers come between; and what hee promised, he meant with this condition, if they repented, and either persisted in godlinesse,11 or needed not affliction and chastisement. Wherefore hee would indeed have punished the Ninevites if they had persisted in their sins:
1Mercifull.) The mercy or favour and inclinable will of God to preserve his creature, and especially mankinde, the Scripture proposeth unto us, opened by these degrees: §11. That hee taketh delight in the salvation of all, but in the destruction of none: As I live, saith the Lord God, I desire not the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way, and live. §22. That he deferreth, mitigateth,2 and taketh away punishments; inviting all men by his long-suffering to repentance, if not one way, yet by the testimony of their conscience: hereof hee is said to be slow to anger. §333. That he debaseth himself to relieve our infirmity both by inward and outward supplies, as by his Spirit, word, oathes, sacraments and miracles. §44. That hee imbraceth with singular love his chosen: so that hee saveth and delivereth them for ⟨p. 164⟩ever from sin and all evils, and comforteth them also in afflictions. Repl. God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes. 4Though a woman should forget her child, yet will I not forget thee. §55. That he chose rather to bring to passe this our delivery, even by the incarnation and death of his only begotten Son, then that all mankind should perish. So God loved the world, 5that he gave his only begotten Son. §66. That he promiseth and performeth all these things of his own free goodnesse: I will shew mercy to whom I will shew mercy: 6and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion. I, even I am he that putteth away thine iniquities for mine owne sake, and will not remember thy sins. §77. That hee doth these things towards sinners, who not onely were unworthy of them,7 but also who are his deadly enemies: When wee were enemies we were reconciled unto God by the death of his Son. They also of the wiser sort, which are out of the Church, are compelled to attribute mercy unto God, because they see him so mercifully to spare sinners:8 whereupon Jeremie saith, It is the Lords mercie that we are not consumed, because his compassions faile not. But because the perfectnesse of Gods justice, and the privity of their own sins doth not permit them to conceive any firm perswasion of Gods mercy towards them neither know they ought concerning the salvation of men by the death of his Son: therefore are they not able either constantly or wholly to agnise Gods mercy. Object. 1. Mercy is a kinde of griefe or sorrow: Therefore there is sorrow and griefe in God.
1Most free.) God also alone is most free, because he alone by nature is such, 1. That no fault or misery can fall upon him. 2. Neither can he be constrained of any. 3. Neither is he bound to any. 4. Neither is he subject or tyed to the rule or lore of another. Wherefore whatsoever he willeth and doth, that hee willeth and doth himselfe most freely, ⟨p. 165⟩when, as much, and in what manner he will; and what he will, that is most good and just. But here chiefly is considered the freedome of will, or liberty from constraint; which is the power and ability whereby God, without any necessity, hath from everlasting decreed the whole order of creation, preservation, and rule of all things, and doth accomplish the same, not being constrained or tyed to other causes; yet so, that he never swerveth from his rightnesse. To this bear witnesse his miracles, and many examples of deliveries and punishments, and many places of Scripture; as, Whatsoever pleased the Lord, that did hee in the heaven and earth, 2in the sea, and in all the depth. It is not hard to the Lord to save with many or with few. 3Object. 1. That without which second causes, which worke necessarily, cannot worke, doth it selfe also work necessarily: Without the first cause, which is God, second causes, which necessarily worke, cannot work: Therefore the first cause also, which is God, worketh together with them necessarily. Answ. The Major is true of such causes as work with absolute necessity: but it is false of such as work only of a conditionall necessity; that is, because it so pleased God (who notwithstanding could move them otherwise, or else at all not move them, or not so much as make them) that they should work, and should worke after that manner which they do work: Therefore all second causes depend on the first, but not the first any way on the second. Object. 2. God is unchangeably good: Therefore not freely good. Ans. This unchangeablenesse doth not diminish, but establish the liberty of Gods will: for it is not the unchangeablenesse of a nature, but constraint and coaction which is contrary to liberty; and so much the more freely the will chuseth, with how much the greater and surer force and motion it is carried unto her object. Object. 3. It is said also of particular events, that God can only will those things which are best: But only those things which he hath decreed are best: