THE COMMON PLACE OF THE TWO NATURES IN CHRIST.
pp. 273–392561 passagespart 3 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 273–392561 passagespart 3 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
11. THE love of God towards mankind. So God loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son. 2. The mercy of God towards man fallen into sin. Of his mercy he saved us. 23. The will of God to revenge the injury of the Devil, who in reproach and despite of God averted us from him: and maimed the image of God in us, in despite of the Creator.
11. THE love of God towards mankind. So God loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son. 2. The mercy of God towards man fallen into sin. Of his mercy he saved us. 23. The will of God to revenge the injury of the Devill, who in reproach and despight of God averted us from him: and maimed the image of God in us, in despight of the Creatour.
THE final causes and fruits of Christs Passion are all one, save that they differ in divers respects. For in respect of Christ, who suffered, they are termed final causes: in respect of us, they are called fruits. The final causes or ends of his Passion are. 1. The manifesting of the love, goodness, mercy, righteousness of God, while he punisheth his Son for us. 2. That his Passion might be a sufficient ransom of our sins, or the redeeming of us. The chief final causes then are, The glory of God, and our salvation. To the former final cause belongeth the knowledge of the greatness of sin, that we may know how great an evil sin is, and what it deserveth. To the latter belongeth our justification, wherein all the benefits are comprehended, which Christ merited, by dying, and by his freeing himself from death. Hence know we that death is not now pernicious and hurtful to the godly, and therefore not to be feared.
THE finall causes and fruits of Christs Passion are all one, save that they differ in divers respects. For in respect of Christ, who suffered, they are termed finall causes: in respect of us, they are called fruits. The finall causes or ends of his Passion are. 1. The manifesting of the love, goodnesse, mercy, righteousnesse of God, while he punisheth his Sonne for us. 2. That his Passion might be a sufficient ransome of our sins, or the redeeming of us. The chiefe finall causes then are, The glory of God, and our salvation. To the former finall cause belongeth the knowledge of the greatnesse of sinne, that we may know how great an evill sinne is, and what it deserveth. To the latter belongeth our justification, wherein all the benefits are comprehended, which Christ merited, by dying, and by his freeing himselfe from death. Hence know we that death is not now pernicious and hurtfull to the godly, and therefore not to be feared.
Answ. That he being innocent and condemned before a civill Judge,a might deliver us from the severe judgement of God, which remained for all men.b
Mention is made of Pilate in Christs Passion: §11. Because Christ did receive from him a testimony of his innocency; that thereby we might know that he was pronounced innocent by the voice of the Judge himself. §22. That we might know that he, though innocent, was notwithstanding solemnly condemned. §33. That we might be advertised of the fulfilling of the prophecy:1 I will over-turn, over-turn, over-turn it, and it shall be no more, until he come, 2whose right it is, and I will give it him. The Sceptre shall not depart from Judah, nor a Law-giver from between his feet, until Shiloh come. For then was the Sceptre taken from Judah, when Christ was a little after condemned of Pilate a Roman governor, of whom before he was absolved. This circumstance therefore is diligently to be considered in Christs passion, that we may know him to be the Messiah: because all conditions are fulfilled in him, which are required in the Messiah. Whereof this Prophecy,3 of the taking away of the Sceptre from Judah, was one. Quest. But why was it requisite that Christ should suffer under a Judge; and be condemned by order of law? §11. That we might know that Christ was condemned of God himself also, and ⟨p. 295⟩therefore that he satisfied God for us, that we might not be condemned in Gods severe judgement; even as he also suffered death for us, that we might be delivered from the power of death. For the head and governor of ordinary judgement is God himself. §22. That Christ might obtain a testimony of his innocency from that Judge, by whom he was condemned. Wherefore Christ was not to have been privily taken away by the Jews, neither to be drawn to death by tumult, and disorderly, but by lawful order, and judgement, and by inquisition made concerning all the accusations of Christ. God would have him, 1. To be examined, that his innocency might appear. 2. To be condemned, that it might appear, that he being before pronounced innocent, was now condemned, not for his own fault, but for ours; and so his unjust condemnation might be in stead of our most just condemnation, 3. To be put to death, both that the Prophecies might be fulfilled, and also that it might appear that both Jews and Gentiles did put Christ to death.
1Quest. Now, what is it to believe in Jesus Christ, which suffered under Pontius Pilate? Ans. To believe that Christ suffered, is so to believe, as to have an historical faith only of Christs passion, and not to repose any confidence in him. To believe in Christ which suffered, is to believe not only that Christ suffered, but also to repose and place our trust and confidence in Christs suffering and passion. Thus to believe, is, §11. To believe that Christ, from the very moment of his conception, sustained calamities and miseries of all sorts; but especially that at his last time of life he suffered all the most bitter torments both of body and soul, and felt the horrible and dreadful wrath of God to this end, to satisfy for the sins of the whole world, and to appease Gods wrath against sin. §22. To believe that he suffered all these for my sake; that is, that by his passion he hath satisfied for my sins, hath merited for me remission of sins, the holy Ghost, and life everlasting.
1Quest. Now, what is it to beleeve in Jesus Christ, which suffered under Pontius Pilate? Ans. To beleeve that Christ suffered, is so to beleeve, as to have an historicall faith onely of Christs passion, and not to repose any confidence in him. To beleeve in Christ which suffered, is to beleeve not onely that Christ suffered, but also to repose and place our trust and confidence in Christs suffering and passion. Thus to beleeve, is, §11. To beleeve that Christ, from the very moment of his conception, sustained calamities and miseries of all sorts; but especially that at his last time of life he suffered all the most bitter torments both of body and soule, and felt the horrible and dreadfull wrath of God to this end, to satisfie for the sins of the whole world, and to appease Gods wrath against sin. §22. To beleeve that he suffered all these for my sake; that is, that by his passion he hath satisfied for my sins, hath merited for me remission of sins, the holy Ghost, and life everlasting.
Ans. There is more. For by this, I am assured that he took upon himself the curse which did lie on me.a For the death of the Cross was accursed of God.b
Ans. There is more. For by this, I am assured that he took upon himselfe the curse which did lie on me.a For the death of the Crosse was accursed of God.b
The death of the Cross is an exaggeration or aggravation of Christs punishment, and a confirmation of our faith. For if Christ be crucified,1 then, 1. He took the curse; for this death was a type of the curse. 2. He bare it for us, seeing in himself he was just. Now, for these causes would God have his Son to suffer the punishment of so ignominious a death: §11. That we might know the curse due for our sins to have lain upon him. For the death of the Cross was cursed of God: Cursed is every one that hangeth on a tree. §22. That it might be an exasperating of the punishment, and so we much the more confirmed in a true faith, when we consider Christ, by this kind of punishment, to have taken upon him our guilt, and even our punishment also and curse, to free us from it. This Paul teacheth: Christ hath redeemed us from the curse of the Law, when he was made a curse for us: for it is written, 2Cursed is every one that hangeth on a tree. §33. To stir us up to greater thankfulness, considering how detestable a thing sin is, to wit, so great, that it could not be expiated and satisfied for, but with the most bitter and most opprobrious and shameful death of the only begotten Son of God. §44. That the truth might answer according to the types and figures, and so we might know the types to be fulfilled in Christ.3 For the old sacrifices, which shadowed the sacrifice of Christ, were laid on the wood, and before their burning were lifted up on high by the Priest, thereby to signify that Christ ⟨p. 296⟩should be exalted and lifted up on the Altar of the Cross, there to offer himself an holy sacrifice unto his Father for us. The same was shadowed in Isaac, who being laid on the wood, was to have been sacrificed of his Father. Lastly, the brazen serpent which Moses set up upon a pole in the wilderness, depainteth this kind of punishment.4
1What is it then To believe in Christ crucified? Ans. It is to believe that Christ was made obnoxious for my sake to Gods curse, to redeem me from the same.
1What is it then To beleeve in Christ crucified? Ans. It is to beleeve that Christ was made obnoxious for my sake to Gods curse, to redeeme me from the same.
Here we are to consider, 1. How Christ is said to have been dead. 2. Whether it was requisite and necessary that Christ should dye. 3. For whom he died.
1IT is needful to move this question, because of the Heretics who have depraved the sense of this Article. Marcion denied that he dyed indeed: as also he affirmed the whole ordinary dispensation and ministry of the humane nature in Christ, and all those things which he did undergo for us, to have been but imaginary, and that he only seemed to be as a man, but was not a man. Nestorius separated the two natures in Christ;2 neither would have the Son of God, but man only to have died. Do not boast thou Jew (saith Nestorius) thou hast not crucified God, but man. The Ubiquitaries believe that the humanity of Christ, 3from the moment of his incarnation, was so endowed with all the properties of the God-head, as that only in this the humanity differeth from the God-head, that the humanity hath by an accident, whatsoever the God-head hath by, and of it self. Hereof it cometh, that they imagine that Christ was in the time of his death, yea when he was enclosed in the Virgins womb, in heaven, and every where, not only as touching his God-head, but with his body too. This is it which they call the form of God.4
1IT is needfull to move this question, because of the Heretiks who have depraved the sense of this Article. Marcion denied that he dyed indeed: as also he affirmed the whole ordinary dispensation and ministery of the humane nature in Christ, and all those things which he did undergo for us, to have been but imaginary, and that he onely seemed to be as a man, but was not a man. Nestorius separated the two natures in Christ;2 neither would have the Sonne of God, but man onely to have died. Doe not boast thou Jew (saith Nestorius) thou hast not crucified God, but man. The Ubiquitaries beleeve that the humanity of Christ, 3from the moment of his incarnation, was so endowed with all the properties of the God-head, as that onely in this the humanity differeth from the God-head, that the humanity hath by an accident, whatsoever the God-head hath by, and of it selfe. Hereof it cometh, that they imagine that Christ was in the time of his death, yea when he was inclosed in the Virgins womb, in heaven, and every where, not only as touching his God-head, but with his body too. This is it which they call the forme of God.
Wherefore, against all these we affirm, and in the Creed believe, that Christ died truly and corporally, even by a true divulsion and separation of his soul from his body,1 and that a local separation; so that not only his soul and body were not together every where, but were not together in one place; the soul was not where the body was,2 nor the body where the soul was. Then Jesus cried again with a loud voice, and yielded up the Ghost. Jesus cried with a loud voice, and gave up the Ghost. Father, into thy hands I commend my spirit. And when he had said these words, he gave up the Ghost. He bowed his head, and gave up the Ghost. Object. But as virtue, that is, his divinity, is said to have gone out of him; so also he gave up the Ghost. Answ. There is a dissimilitude in these: Because the divinity remaining united with the humane nature, yet did work abroad without it. The soul did depart from the body. The reason of this dissimilitude is, because the act of his divinity is increate and infinite, but the act and power of his soul finite and created. But yet this is further to be added,3 that although his soul was truly separated from his body, yet the Word notwithstanding did not forsake neither body nor soul, but remained nevertheless joined both to body and soul: and therefore the two natures in Christ were not divelled or sundered by that divulsion of the soul and body. Object. Why then cried he, 4My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? Answ. Because of his delay and ⟨p. 297⟩deferring of help and succour: For the two natures in Christ ought not to have been divelled or sundered, because it is written, God hath purchased the Church with his own blood. And he was to be the Son of God, who should die for our sins,5 that he might be a sufficient price for them. Hereby also it doth clearly appear, That The union of both natures in Christ is no Ubiquity: For the soul being separated from the body, was not in the grave with the body, and by a consequent not every where, because that which is every where, can never be separated: and yet in death, and in the grave the union of both natures remained and continued.
IT was requisite and necessary that Christ, to make full satisfaction, not only should suffer, but also should die: §11. In respect of the justice of God, that so his justice might be satisfied, which required the death of men, by whom it was violated: For the hurting and offending of the greatest good, is to be expiated with the greatest punishment, or with the utmost destruction of nature; that is, with the death of the guilty condemned for sin, according to that, The wages of sin is death. 1But Christ succeeded in our stead, and took on him our person, who had sinned, and had deserved death, not only eternal, but temporal also: For we deserved destruction, which is the dissolution of the soul from the body, whereon ensueth the dissolution of the body, as a house is said to be subverted and destroyed, when one part is separated from another. Now it was requisite that the Son of God should die, that he might be a sufficient ransom for our sins: For no creature could have sustained such a punishment, as should have been equivalent to eternal punishment, and yet withal should have been temporal. Object. They have deserved eternal punishment, whosoever are not reconciled to God by Christ; therefore the souls ought not to be separated from their bodies, that they might suffer eternal damnation. Ans. It doth not follow; but this rather, That therefore both body and soul must be together, that they may suffer it, which at length shall so come to pass: Therefore it was necessary that Christ should die for us, and his soul be separated from his body. §22. In respect of Gods truth, that the truth of God may be satisfied: For God threatened and denounced death, when ever we sinned: which denouncing was to be fulfilled after sin was once committed: And this is that commination or threatening pronounced by God himself, In the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt die the death. Obj. But Adam did not presently die. Ans. Truly, he forth-with died not a bodily death,2 howbeit he became mortal straight upon it, and by little and little he daily died, and even now already had he died spiritually eternal death, and now was dead; I heard (saith he) thy voice, and I was afraid, because I was naked. 3There was a terror in him, and a feeling of Gods wrath, a strife with death, the loss of all the gifts both of body and mind.
But there followed the equity, moderation and lenity of the Gospel: For God had not expressly said, that he should certainly die wholly, and presently: For so had he perished for ever. Wherefore the Son offered a mitigation and lenifying, raised him up to a new life, that notwithstanding he should remain subject to the corporal death, which yet should not be deadly and pernicious unto him. §33. In respect of the promise made to the Fathers, both by words, He is brought as a sheep to the slaughter, and as a sheep before be shearer is dumb,1 so openeth he not his mouth: and by sacrifices, whereby God promiseth that Christ should die such a death, as should be an equivalent price for the sins of the whole world. This could not be the work of a mere creature, but of the Son of God only: and therefore it was requisite and necessary, that the Son of God should suffer so grievous a death for us. Ob. Then they do not satisfy Gods justice, who are punished, because their punishment is endless and eternal. Ans. They satisfy by eternal punishment. Rep. So then might we also be delivered from the curse by our selves. Ans. So then shall we never be delivered, but shall sustain punishment eternal, which is without end. 4. Christ also himself hath fore-told, that it was necessary that he should die: Except I go away, 2the Comforter ⟨p. 298⟩will not come unto you. 3If I wash thee not, thou shalt have no part with me. In this question therefore three memorable circumstances concur: 1. That it was necessary that Gods justice should be satisfied. 2. That this satisfaction was to be made by death. 3. That it was to be accomplished by the death of the Son of God alone. Out of this which hath bin said, we may draw these doctrines: 1. That sin is most of all to be eschewed of us, which could not be expiated but by the death of the Son of God. 2. That we ought to be thankful to the Son of God, for this his so great a benefit of unspeakable grace and favour bestowed upon us. 3. That all our sins, how many, how great, and how grievous soever they be, are expiated and done away by the death alone of Christ.
WE must answer this question by distinguishing the terms thereof, that so we may reconcile such Scriptures as carry a show of contrariety: For in some places Christ is said to have died for all, 1and for the whole world: as, Who is a reconciliation for our sins, and not for our sins only, but for the sins of the whole world. That by Gods grace he might taste of death for all men. 2We thus judge, that if one be dead for all, then were all dead. And he died for all, that they which live should not henceforth live unto themselves, but unto him which died for them, and rose again. Who gave himself a ransom for all men. Contrariwise, in as many places Christ is said to have died, prayed, offered up himself,3 &c. only for many, only for the elect, for his peculiar people, for his Church, for his sheep, &c. Not for the world, not for the unfaithful. I pray for them: I pray not for the world; but for them which thou hast given me, for they are thine: that is, for the elect alone. The Son of man came not to be served, but to serve, and to give his life for the ransom of many. I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of Israel. He shall save his people from their sins. This is my blood of the New Testament, that is shed for many for the remission of sins. Christ was once offered to take away the sins of many. By his knowledge shall my righteous servant justify many: for he shall bear their iniquities. Christ loved the Church, and gave himself for it.
WE must answer this question by distinguishing the termes thereof, that so we may reconcile such Scriptures as carry a shew of contrariety: For in some places Christ is said to have died for all, 1and for the whole world: as, Who is a reconciliation for our sins, and not for our sins only, but for the sins of the whole world. That by Gods grace he might taste of death for all men. 2We thus judge, that if one be dead for all, then were all dead. And he died for all, that they which live should not henceforth live unto themselves, but unto him which died for them, and rose again. Who gave himself a ransom for all men. Contrariwise, in as many places Christ is said to have died, prayed, offered up himselfe,
1What shall we say then? Is Scripture disagreeable with Scripture? No verily. Howbeit it seemeth so, unless these general and particular Aphorisms be reconciled by some pithy and plausible distinction. The distinction and reconcilement of these places is two-fold, either of which is true and sound. 1. Some interpret these general allegations, of the whole number of the faithful, or of all the believing: because the promises of the Gospel do properly appertain to all the faithful, and because the whole course of Scripture restraineth those promises to the believing. Whosoever believeth in him, 2shall not perish. The righteousness of God by the faith of Jesus Christ, unto all, and upon all that believe. Through his name all that believe in him shall receive remission of sins. S. Ambrose expoundeth the general texts of Scripture on this wise:3 The people of God, saith he, have their fullness, and although a great number of men neglect or cast from them the grace of their Saviour, yet there is a certain special university of the elect and fore-known of God, severed and discerned from the generality of all, to this intent, that a whole world might seem to be saved out of a whole world; and all men might seem to be redeemed from out of all men. Thus is there no repugnancy, no contrariety between these Scriptures: For all true believers are those many, that peculiar people, that Church, those sheep, those chosen, which were given unto Christ, and for whom Christ gave himself.
1What shall we say then? Is Scripture disagreeable with Scripture? No verily. Howbeit it seemeth so, unlesse these generall and particular Aphorismes be reconciled by some pithy and plausible distinction. The distinction and reconcilement of these places is two-fold, either of which is true and sound. 1. Some interpret these generall allegations, of the whole number of the faithfull, or of all the beleeving: because the promises of the Gospel do properly appertain to all the faithfull, and because the whole course of Scripture restraineth those promises to the beleeving. Whosoever beleeveth in him, 2shall not perish. The righteousnesse of God by the faith of Jesus Christ, unto all, and upon all that beleeve. Through his name all that beleeve in him shall receive remission of sins. S. Ambrose expoundeth the generall texts of Scripture on this wise:
1Others reconcile these Scriptures by a distinction of the sufficiency and efficacy of Christs death: For certain wrangling Sophists there are, who admit not this restriction of these general promises to the faithful alone: that is, they deny that the letter of Scripture enforceth any such restriction: and for proof of their conceit, they quote and allege certain places, which seem to impart redemption and salvation not only to the faithful, but to Hypocrites also and Apostates: as that of Peter; Denying the Lord which hath bought them. And, Hath forgotten that he was purged from his old sins: 2all which Scriptures, it is manifest, are to be understood ⟨p. 299⟩and interpreted either of the vain glorying of Hypocrites of their redemption and sanctification, or of the extent and sufficiency of Christs satisfaction. Wherefore, that we be not forced to maintain frivolous contention, with such crabbed perverse disputers, touching the restriction of these general promises before specified; and for more sound and ample answer unto those places concerning the redemption of Hypocrites, some choose rather (and not unfitly as I suppose) to interpret those Scriptures in show contrary one to the other, partly of the sufficiency, and partly of the application and efficacy of Christs death. They answer therefore that Christ died for all: And again, died not for all, in a diverse respect.3 1. Christ died for all men absolutely and without exception, as touching the sufficiency of the price which he paid. 2. Christ died not for all men, but for the elect alone, and the faithful, as touching the application, participation, and efficacy of his merit and Passion. The reason of the former is, because Christs ransom is of such weight and worth, that it may serve and be sufficient to purge and cleanse all the sins of all men; if at least all men would apprehend by faith this salve of sin. For it can no way be said that it is insufficient, lest this blasphemous inconvenience (which God forbid) should follow: That some cause of the destruction of the wicked, resteth in the defect of the merit of the Mediator. The reason of the latter is, because all the elect and faithful, and they alone, do by faith apply unto themselves the merit of Christs death, and by his application obtain the efficacy thereof, even their justification and salvation:
according to that saying of Scripture; He which believeth in the Son hath life everlasting. The rest are excluded from this efficacy of Christs death by their own infidelity, according as it followeth in the same place; He which believeth not, shall not see life, but the wrath of God abideth on him. Wherefore,1 whom the Scripture cancelleth from the participation of the efficacy of Christs death, for them Christ cannot be said to have died with respect of the efficacy of his death, but in respect only of the sufficiency of his sacrifice: because the death of Christ is sufficient to save them, if they believed: but it saveth them not, because they believe not.
according to that saying of Scripture; He which beleeveth in the Son hath life everlasting. The rest are excluded from this efficacy of Christs death by their own infidelity, according as it followeth in the same place; He which beleeveth not, shall not see life, but the wrath of God abideth on him. Wherefore,1 whom the Scripture cancelleth from the participation of the efficacy of Christs death, for them Christ cannot be said to have died with respect of the efficacy of his death, but in respect only of the sufficiency of his sacrifice: because the death of Christ is sufficient to save them, if they beleeved: but it saveth them not, because they beleeve not.
If any demand what the will of Christ herein was, whether he had a will to die for all; he is answered by the same distinction. For as he died, so would he die.1 As therefore he died for all, in respect of the sufficiency of his ransom; but for the faithful alone, in regard of the efficacy of the same: so would he also die for all in general, as concerning the sufficiency of his merit; that is, he would in most sufficient manner demerit for all, by his death, grace, righteousness, and life everlasting; seeing he would that nothing should be wanting on his part, that there should be no defect in his merit, that so all the wicked and reprobate might perish without excuse: But for the elect alone he would die, as touching the efficacy of his merit; that is, he would not only sufficiently merit grace and salvation, but also effectually impart them on the elect alone; namely, he would give unto them faith and the holy Ghost, and accomplish or effect in them, that they should apply unto themselves by faith, the benefits of his death, and so obtain the fruits thereof. In this sense Christ is well said to have died in a different manner for the faithful and unfaithful. Neither hath this interpretation any inconvenience consequent thereon; but accordeth not only with Scripture, but even with very experience also: both which testify unto us, that the salve of sin and death is most sufficiently and plentifully offered in the Gospel unto all; but it is applied, and it cureth the faithful alone. The whole current of Scripture restraineth the efficacy of redemption to some particulars only, as to Christs sheep, to the elect, and to the believing: whereas on the other side it apparently abandoneth and sequestereth from the grace of Christ the reprobate and unfaithful, as long as they remain such: What concord hath Christ with Belial? or what part hath the believer with the infidel? Again,2 Christ prayed for the Elect only and believing, and such as hereafter should believe on him: I pray not for the world, but for those whom thou hast given me. If Christ would not pray for the world, to wit, for the unfaithful, much less would he so die for them,3 as by his death to effect their salvation: For it is a less thing to pray for a man, than to die for him:
If any demand what the will of Christ herein was, whether he had a will to die for all; hee is answered by the same distinction. For as hee died, so would hee die.
and intercession and suffering of death, are the two individual or inseparable ⟨p. 300⟩parts of Christs sacrifice; of which if Christ deny the ungodly the one, who is he that dareth reach out unto them the other?
and intercession and suffering of death, are the two individuall or inseparable ⟨p. 300⟩parts of Christs sacrifice; of which if Christ deny the ungodly the one, who is he that dareth reach out unto them the other?
Lastly, the sounder Fathers and School-men do thus restrain these texts of Scriptures,1 and distinguish on them as we do: especially Augustine, Cyril, and Prosper. Lombard thus writeth; Christ offered up himself to God the Trinity for all men, as touching the sufficiency of the price paid: but for the elect alone, as touching the efficacy, because he wrought salvation only for the Predestinate. Thomas saith, The merit of Christ, as concerning the sufficiency thereof, equally belongeth unto all, but not concerning the efficacy which happeneth, partly by reason of free-will, and partly by reason of Gods election, whereby the effects and fruits of Christs merits are mercifully bestowed on some; and by the just judgement of God are with-held from others. This is the language of other School-men also. Whence it is evident, that Christ so died for all, that notwithstanding the benefits of his death properly concern the faithful alone, to whom only they are available. Object. 1. The promise of the Gospel is universal, as appeareth, in that Christ saith, Come unto me all. And again, That every man might be saved; Also, That he might have mercy on all: Therefore it concerneth not the faithful alone. Ans. The promise indeed is universal, but in regard of the faithful and penitent. For to extend it unto filthy dogs and hogs, that is, to the reprobate, were open blasphemy. There is (saith Ambrose) a certain special university of the elect, and fore-known of God. severed and discerned from the generality of all. This manner of restraint is deduced out of the very letter of the promise:2 That every one which believeth should not perish, but have everlasting life. The righteousness of God by the faith of Christ Jesus unto all, and upon all that believe. Come unto me all ye which labour and travel, and I will refresh you. He is rich unto all that call upon him. Whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved. 3He is made the author of salvation unto all that obey him. And out of the words of Christ. Give not that which is holy unto dogs, and cast not pearls before swine. Obj. 2. Christ died for all: Therefore his death appertaineth not to the faithful only. Answ. Christ died for all, as touching the merit and sufficiency of his ransom: for the faithful only, as touching the application and efficacy thereof:
For, inasmuch as the death of Christ is imparted unto them, and profiteth them only, it is rightly said to appertain properly unto them alone, as before hath bin proved at large.
Ans. That thereby he might make manifest that he was dead indeed.a
THE causes of Christs burial are many: For, §11. He would be buried in testimony of his true death, that we might know that he was dead indeed: For the living are not buried, but the dead only. As then after his resurrection he offered himself to be seen, handled, &c. for evident proof of the truth of his body, raised from death: so after his death he offered his body to be felt, and buried, that men might know it to be a dead crops. Hither belong some parts of the story penned by the Evangelists; as that Christ was pierced with a lance, that he was taken down from the Cross, that he was anointed, and wrapped in linen clothes, &c. For these are good evidences of the truth of his death. We therefore by his burial are ascertained of his true death and by his death assured of our redemption: For our salvation consisteth in his death, the testimony whereof is his burial. §22. That the last part of his humiliation, whereby he did debase himself for our sakes, might be accomplished: For burial was a part of the punishment, curse,1 and ignominy which we had deserved: as it is said, To dust shalt thou return. A dead body is indeed void of sense and feeling; but yet notwithstanding ignominious it was for the body to be committed to the earth, as any other dead corps. ⟨p. 301⟩As then Christs resurrection from the dead and death is a part of his glory: so his burial, that is, the debasing of his body to be in the same state with other dead carcasses, is a part of that humiliation which he sustained for our sakes. §33. He would be buried, that we might not be afraid of the grave, but might know that our head Christ had sanctified our graves by his burial, that now they are no longer graves unto us, but chambers of quiet repose, until we be raised again unto life. §44. That it might be apparent or manifest, as concerning his resurrection, that he had truly overcome death in his body, that by his own power and vigour he had shaken off death from himself, and that his resurrection was not imaginary, but a resurrection of a reviving corps. §55. That he might confirm in us an hope of the resurrection: to wit, that the time shall once come, when we after his example shall be buried, and by his power shall rise again; knowing that Christ our head hath laid open the way unto us by the grave and death, to celestial glory:
and therefore shall we be raised out of the grave, though we die and give up the Ghost. §66. That we being spiritually dead, that is, to sin, might rest from sin. We are buried with Christ by baptism into his death, 1that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, so we also should walk in newness of life. §77. That the truth might be answerable to the type of Jonah, and the prophecies might be fulfilled concerning the burial of the Messiah: Thou2 shalt not leave my soul in hell. He made his grave with the wicked.
and therefore shall wee be raised out of the grave, though we die and give up the Ghost. §66. That we being spiritually dead, that is, to sin, might rest from sin. We are buried with Christ by baptisme into his death, 1that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, so we also should walke in newnesse of life. §77. That the truth might be answerable to the type of Jonas, and the prophecies might be fulfilled concerning the buriall of the Messias: Thou2 shalt not leave my soule in hell. He made his grave with the wicked.
MEntion is made of Pilate in Christs Passion: §11. Because Christ did receive from him a testimony of his innocency; that thereby we might know that he was pronounced innocent by the voyce of the Judge himself. §22. That we might know that he, though innocent, was notwithstanding solemnely condemned. §33. That we might be advertised of the fulfilling of the prophecy:1 I will over-turne, over-turne, over-turne it, and it shall be no more, untill he come, 2whose right it is, and I will give it him. The Scepter shall not depart from Judah, nor a Law-giver from between his feet, untill Shilo come. For then was the Scepter taken from Judah, when Christ was a little after condemned of Pilate a Roman governour, of whom before he was absolved. This circumstance therefore is diligently to be considered in Christs passion, that we may know him to be the Messias: because al conditions are fulfilled in him, which are required in the Messias. Whereof this Prophecie,3 of the taking away of the Scepter from Judah, was one. Quest. But why was it requisite that Christ should suffer under a Judge; and be condemned by order of law? §11. That we might know that Christ was condemned of God himselfe also, and ⟨p. 295⟩therefore that he satisfied God for us, that we might not be condemned in Gods severe judgement; even as he also suffered death for us, that we might be delivered from the power of death. For the head and governour of ordinary judgement is God himselfe. §22. That Christ might obtaine a testimony of his innocency from that Judge, by whom he was condemned. Wherefore Christ was not to have been privily taken away by the Jewes, neither to be drawne to death by tumult, and disorderly, but by lawfull order, and judgement, and by inquisition made concerning all the accusations of Christ. God would have him, 1. To be examined, that his innocency might appeare. 2. To be condemned, that it might appeare, that he being before pronounced innocent, was now condemned, not for his own fault, but for ours; and so his unjust condemnation might be in stead of our most just condemnation, 3. To be put to death, both that the Prophecies might be fulfilled, and also that it might appeare that both Jewes and Gentiles did put Christ to death.
THe death of the Crosse is an exaggeration or aggravation of Christs punishment, and a confirmation of our faith. For if Christ be crucified,1 then, 1. He took the curse; for this death was a type of the curse. 2. He bare it for us, seeing in himselfe he was just. Now, for these causes would God have his Son to suffer the punishment of so ignominious a death: §11. That we might know the curse due for our sins to have layen upon him. For the death of the Crosse was cursed of God: Cursed is every one that hangeth on a tree. §22. That it might be an exasperating of the punishment, and so we much the more confirmed in a true faith, when we consider Christ, by this kind of punishment, to have taken upon him our guilt, and even our punishment also and curse, to free us from it. This Paul teacheth: Christ hath redeemed us from the curse of the Law, when he was made a curse for us: for it is written, 2Cursed is every one that hangeth on a tree. §33. To stir us up to greater thankfulnesse, considering how detestable a thing sinne is, to wit, so great, that it could not be expiated and satisfied for, but with the most bitter and most opprobrious and shamefull death of the onely begotten Sonne of God. §44. That the truth might answer according to the types and figures, and so we might know the types to be fulfilled in Christ.3 For the old sacrifices, which shadowed the sacrifice of Christ, were laid on the wood, and before their burning were lifted up on high by the Priest, thereby to signifie that Christ ⟨p. 296⟩should be exalted and lifted up on the Altar of the Crosse, there to offer himselfe an holy sacrifice unto his Father for us. The same was shadowed in Isaac, who being laid on the wood, was to have been sacrificed of his Father. Lastly, the brasen serpent which Moses set up upon a pole in the wildernesse, depainteth this kind of punishment.4 Christ himselfe interpreteth of himselfe this type of the brasen serpent: As Moses lift up the serpent in the wildernesse, so must the Son of man be lift up. And I, if I were lift up from the earth, will draw all men unto me,
Wherefore, against all these we affirme, and in the Creed beleeve, that Christ died truly and corporally, even by a true divulsion and separation of his soule from his body,1 and that a locall separation; so that not onely his soule and body were not together every where, but were not together in one place; the soule was not where the body was,2 nor the body where the soule was. Then Jesus cried againe with a loud voyce, and yeelded up the Ghost. Jesus cried with a lowd voyce, and gave up the Ghost. Father, into thy hands I commend my spirit. And when he had said these words, he gave up the Ghost. He bowed his head, and gave up the Ghost. Object. But as vertue, that is, his divinity, is said to have gone out of him; so also he gave up the Ghost. Answ. There is a dissimilitude in these: Because the divinity remaining united with the humane nature, yet did work abroad without it. The soule did depart from the body. The reason of this dissimilitude is, because the act of his divinity is increate and infinite, but the act and power of his soule finite and created. But yet this is further to be added,3 that although his soule was truly separated from his body, yet the Word notwithstanding did not forsake neither body nor soule, but remained neverthelesse joyned both to body and soule: and therefore the two natures in Christ were not divelled or sundered by that divulsion of the soule and body. Object. Why then cryed he, 4My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? Answ. Because of his delay and ⟨p. 297⟩deferring of help and succour: For the two natures in Christ ought not to have been divelled or sundred, because it is written, God hath purchased the Church with his own bloud. And he was to be the Son of God, who should die for our sins,5 that he might be a sufficient price for them. Hereby also it doth cleerly appeare, That The union of both natures in Christ is no Ʋbiquity: For the soule being separated from the body, was not in the grave with the body, and by a consequent not every where, because that which is every where, can never be separated: and yet in death, and in the grave the union of both natures remained and continued.
IT was requisite and necessary that Christ, to make full satisfaction, not only should suffer, but also should die: §11. In respect of the justice of God, that so his justice might be satisfied, which required the death of men, by whom it was violated: For the hurting and offending of the greatest good, is to be expiated with the greatest punishment, or with the utmost destruction of nature; that is, with the death of the guilty condemned for sinne, according to that, The wages of sinne is death. 1But Christ succeeded in our stead, and took on him our person, who had sinned, and had deserved death, not only eternall, but temporall also: For wee deserved destruction, which is the dissolution of the soule from the body, whereon ensueth the dissolution of the body, as a house is said to be subverted and destroyed, when one part is separated from another. Now it was requisite that the Sonne of God should die, that he might be a sufficient ransome for our sins: For no creature could have sustained such a punishment, as should have been equivalent to eternall punishment, and yet withall should have been temporall. Object. They have deserved eternall punishment, whosoever are not reconciled to God by Christ; therefore the soules ought not to be separated from their bodies, that they might suffer eternall damnation. Ans. It doth not follow; but this rather, That therefore both body and soule must be together, that they may suffer it, which at length shall so come to passe: Therefore it was necessary that Christ should die for us, and his soule be separated from his body. §22. In respect of Gods truth, that the truth of God may be satisfied: For God threatned and denounced death, when ever we sinned: which denouncing was to be fulfilled after sin was once committed: And this is that commination or threatning pronounced by God himself, In the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt die the death. Obj. But Adam did not presently die. Ans. Truely, he forth-with died not a bodily death,2 howbeit he became mortall straight upon it, and by little and little he dayly died, and even now already had he died spiritually eternall death, and now was dead; I heard (saith he) thy voice, and I was affraid, because I was naked. 3There was a terrour in him, and a feeling of Gods wrath, a strife with death, the losse of all the gifts both of body and mind.
1Others reconcile these Scriptures by a distinction of the sufficiency and efficacy of Christs death: For certain wrangling Sophists there are, who admit not this restriction of these generall promises to the faithfull alone: that is, they deny that the letter of Scripture enforceth any such restriction: and for proof of their conceit, they quote and alledge certain places, which seem to impart redemption and salvation not only to the faithfull, but to Hypocrites also and Apostates: as that of Peter; Denying the Lord which hath bought them. And, Hath forgotten that hee was purged from his old sinnes: 2all which Scriptures, it is manifest, are to be understood ⟨p. 299⟩and interpreted either of the vaine glorying of Hypocrites of their redemption and sanctification, or of the extent and sufficiency of Christs satisfaction. Wherefore, that wee be not forced to maintaine frivolous contention, with such crabbed perverse disputers, touching the restriction of these generall promises before specified; and for more sound and ample answer unto those places concerning the redemption of Hypocrites, some chuse rather (and not unfitly as I suppose) to interpret those Scriptures in shew contrary one to the other, partly of the sufficiency, and partly of the application and efficacy of Christs death. They answer therefore that Christ died for all: And againe, died not for all, in a diverse respect.3 1. Christ died for all men absolutely and without exception, as touching the sufficiency of the price which hee pay'd. 2. Christ died not for all men, but for the elect alone, and the faithfull, as touching the application, participation, and efficacy of his merit and Passion. The reason of the former is, because Christs ransome is of such weight and worth, that it may serve and be sufficient to purge and cleanse all the sins of all men; if at least all men would apprehend by faith this salve of sin. For it can no way be said that it is insufficient, lest this blasphemous inconvenience (which God forbid) should follow: That some cause of the destruction of the wicked, resteth in the defect of the merit of the Mediatour. The reason of the latter is, because all the elect and faithfull, and they alone, doe by faith apply unto themselves the merit of Christs death, and by his application obtaine the efficacy thereof, even their justification and salvation:
THE causes of Christs buriall are many: For, §11. He would be buried in testimony of his true death, that we might know that hee was dead indeed: For the living are not buried, but the dead only. As then after his resurrection hee offered himselfe to be seen, handled, &c. for evident proof of the truth of his body, raised from death: so after his death he offered his body to be felt, and buried, that men might know it to be a dead crops. Hither belong some parts of the story penned by the Evangelists; as that Christ was pierced with a lance, that he was taken down from the Crosse, that he was annointed, and wrapt in linnen cloathes, &c. For these are good evidences of the truth of his death. We therefore by his buriall are ascertained of his true death and by his death assured of our redemption: For our salvation consisteth in his death, the testimony whereof is his buriall. §22. That the last part of his humiliation, whereby hee did debase himselfe for our sakes, might be accomplished: For buriall was a part of the punishment, curse,1 and ignominy which we had deserved: as it is said, To dust shalt thou returne. A dead body is indeed void of sense and feeling; but yet notwithstanding ignominious it was for the body to be committed to the earth, as any other dead corps. ⟨p. 301⟩As then Christs resurrection from the dead and death is a part of his glory: so his buriall, that is, the debasing of his body to be in the same state with other dead carkases, is a part of that humiliation which he sustained for our sakes. §33. Hee would be buried, that we might not be affraid of the grave, but might know that our head Christ had sanctified our graves by his buriall, that now they are no longer graves unto us, but chambers of quiet repose, untill we be raised againe unto life. §44. That it might be apparent or manifest, as concerning his resurrection, that hee had truely overcome death in his body, that by his own power and vigour he had shaken off death from himselfe, and that his resurrection was not imaginary, but a resurrection of a reviving corps. §55. That he might confirme in us an hope of the resurrection: to wit, that the time shall once come, when we after his example shall be buried, and by his power shall rise again; knowing that Christ our head hath laid open the way unto us by the grave and death, to celestiall glory: