THE COMMON PLACE OF THE TWO NATURES IN CHRIST.
pp. 273–392561 passagespart 2 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 273–392561 passagespart 2 of 15
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
albeit the flesh, because it hath not an infinite essence, but retaineth it circumscribed in place, is not made to be present substantially in all those places, in which the Word incarnate, or the Word man is. 2. There is an ambiguity also, and double signification in the word Presence: For the presence, whereby Christ is present with his Church is not of one kind. Wherefore, if the Major be understood of the presence of his substance in all places, and of his being amongst us, and all other things, it is true: For the substance or essence of the God-head only, and not of the man-hood too, is immense, and exceeding all measure, always existing and being the same and whole in all things. But it is false, if it be understood of the presence of his virtue or efficacy. For, according to this, not only whole Christ, but also the whole of Christ is present with his Church only: that is, not only his divinity, but his humanity also: but so, as the difference notwithstanding is kept of both natures and operations. The humanity therefore of Christ is present with all the elect, in what soever places they be dispersed through the whole world; not by any presence substantial of the flesh in the bread, and within their bodies: but, 1. By the efficacy and perpetual value of his merit. For God the Father doth even now behold the sacrifice of his Son, once accomplished on the Cross, and receiveth us for that, as a sufficient ransom and merit,1 into his favour. The blood of Jesus Christ his Son, purgeth us from all sin; that is, both by his merit, and the efficacy or virtue of his merit. 2. By the efficacy also of his humane will: because Christ, according to his humanity also, earnestly both would and will, that we be of God received into favour, quickened, and glorified through that his one only sacrifice. Thou art a Priest for ever: and also whatsoever he will,2 yea with his humane will, that he powerfully effecteth and worketh, not by the power of his flesh, but of his God-head, or spirit omnipotent; whom, not the flesh, but the God-head of Christ only sendeth into the hearts of the elect and chosen:3 It is the spirit that quickeneth the flesh profiteth nothing. God shall quicken your mortal bodies by his spirit dwelling in you. 3. He is present with us by conjunction and union.
albeit the flesh, because it hath not an infinite essence, but retaineth it circumscribed in place, is not made to be present substantially in all those places, in which the Word incarnate, or the Word man is. 2. There is an ambiguity also, and double signification in the word Presence: For the presence, whereby Christ is present with his Church is not of one kind. Wherefore, if the Major be understood of the presence of his substance in all places, and of his being amongst us, and all other things, it is true: For the substance or essence of the God-head onely, and not of the man-hood too, is immense, and exceeding all measure, alwaies existing and being the same and whole in all things. But it is false, if it be understood of the presence of his vertue or efficacy. For, according to this, not onely whole Christ, but also the whole of Christ is present with his Church onely: that is, not onely his divinity, but his humanity also: but so, as the difference notwithstanding is kept of both natures and operations. The humanity therefore of Christ is present with all the elect, in what soever places they be dispersed through the whole world; not by any presence substantiall of the flesh in the bread, and within their bodies: but, 1. By the efficacie and perpetuall value of his merit. For God the Father doth even now behold the sacrifice of his Sonne, once accomplished on the Crosse, and receiveth us for that, as a sufficient ransome and merit,1 into his favour. The bloud of Jesus Christ his Sonne, purgeth us from all sinne; that is, both by his merit, and the efficacie or vertue of his merit. 2. By the efficacy also of his humane will: because Christ, according to his humanity also, earnestly both would and will, that we be of God received into favour, quickned, and glorified through that his one onely sacrifice. Thou art a Priest for ever: and also whatsoever he will,2 yea with his humane will, that he powerfully effecteth and worketh, not by the power of his flesh, but of his God-head, or spirit omnipotent; whom, not the flesh, but the God-head of Christ only sendeth into the hearts of the elect and chosen:3 It is the spirit that quickneth the flesh profiteth nothing. God shall quicken your mortall bodies by his spirit dwelling in you. 3. He is present with us by conjunction and union.
Because all those that are to be saved, must needs be engrafted and knit together, even into Christs humane nature; that being engrafted into his humane mass, they may be quickened, as branches live fastened to the Vine, and members coupled and joined to the head: which joining yet of us with the flesh of Christ, is not made by any natural connection of Christ and our flesh, or by any existence of Christs flesh within our substance, or of ours within his, but by faith and the holy Ghost, in Christ our head,1 and dwelling in us his members. That Christ may dwell in your hearts by faith. If any man hath not the spirit of Christ, the same is not his. We are members of his body, of his flesh, and of his bones: And they twain shall be one flesh: This is a great secret, &c.
Because all those that are to be saved, must needs be engraffed and knit together, even into Christs humane nature; that being engrafted into his humane masse, they may be quickned, as branches live fastned to the Vine, and members coupled and joyned to the head: which joyning yet of us with the flesh of Christ, is not made by any naturall connexion of Christ and our flesh, or by any existence of Christs flesh within our substance, or of ours within his, but by faith and the holy Ghost, in Christ our head,1 and dwelling in us his members. That Christ may dwell in your hearts by faith. If any man hath not the spirit of Christ, the same is not his. We are members of his body, of his flesh, and of his bones: And they twain shall be one flesh: This is a great secret, &c.
Object. 2. Whatsoever is to be worshipped and adored, is omniscient, omnipotent, and every where present, that is, hath the essential properties of the God-head really communicated ⟨p. 284⟩with it. Christs flesh is to be adored, or is adorable, because whole Christ is adored. Therefore Christs flesh is really omniscient, and omnipotent, and present every where. Ans. This very same reason is among the principal arguments whereby the Schwenkfeldians endeavour to frame, after Eutiches manner, a Majesty, and deifying of the flesh of Christ: but both these, and the Ubiquitaries are deceived, and deceive by the ambiguity and diverse taking of the word, adored. That is omnipotent and omniscient which is adored; that is, which is adored in respect of it self, or for it self. The humane nature is adored, not for it self, or according to the proper nature of it self (for that were idolatrous;) but it is adored for the God-head united therewith personally. Wherefore of the adoration of whole Christ, is but ill inferred the omnipotency also of his flesh. For the reason doth not follow, from the honour of the person, to the properties of the natures. Repl. That which is adored by reason of another, is also really omnipotent, and omniscient by reason of another. Christs flesh is adored by reason of the God-head, in whose person his flesh subsisteth: Therefore Christs flesh is also really omniscient, and omnipotent, by reason of the God-head. Ans. The Major is false, as is this: That which is made base and humiliated by reason of another thing, is also by reason of another thing obnoxious and subject to alteration. For the Word was made base, or humiliated by reason of the flesh, and in the flesh, neither yet the Word it self, or the God-head, felt any change or alteration: but is humiliated, and so said to be after another manner, because the Word doth not show his God-head in the flesh, which he took in the form of a servant. So then, albeit the adoration of Christ, God and man, doth presuppose in him omnipotency, omniscience, presence every where, and the searching of hearts and reins: yet is it not of necessity that the humane nature also, which by reason of the God-head, united to it in the same person, is adored, should be really omnipotent, omniscient, and every where.
Object. 2. Whatsoever is to be worshipped and adored, is omniscient, omnipotent, and every where present, that is, hath the essentiall properties of the God-head really communicated ⟨p. 284⟩
For the adoration of Christ, is the honour and worship which agreeth, and is yielded one and the same to whole Christ, man and God, keeping notwithstanding the differences in natures, of the properties, and operations, whereon Christs office and honour doth depend. For, to adore and worship Christ, is, by the agnizing and knowledge of his person and office, to crave of him with a true trust and confidence, that those blessings which he hath promerited and promised, he will, as our Mediator, perform and give to us, according to the proper will and operation of each nature. This adoration consisteth of divers parts, compriseth both natures; and keepeth their properties and operations, though united, yet still distinct; and craveth, that whole Christ in performing his promised benefits, will work those things by his God-head, which are proper to his God-head, and by his flesh, those things which are proper to his flesh. For his benefits are no otherwise to be craved and asked of him, than as himself will, and doth perform them to us: and he performeth them still, keeping the difference of both natures. Wherefore, they who crave of Christ the Mediator, the benefits promised in the Word, do necessarily acknowledge him omniscient, the searcher of hearts, omnipotent, present every where, of himself beholding and hearing our necessities and complaints. This agnizing, and this honour is proper to God, and agreeth, and is yielded to Christman, in respect of his God-head only, and not of his humanity. For in one act, or view unchangeable, to behold, know, and understand, from everlasting of himself, all things past, present, and to come; but chiefly the needs, wants, necessities, and desires of his whole Church. Again, to send the holy Ghost into the hearts of all the elect and chosen, who have been even since the beginning of the world, and by his spirit, to teach them within, to justify, regenerate, comfort them, and to give to them eternal life; these, I say, are not proper to flesh created and finite, but to a nature infinite, omnipotent, and existing from everlasting. Therefore Christ promiseth the holy Ghost to his Disciples, which is the spirit of truth, wisdom, fear, prayer, grace, &c.
For the adoration of Christ, is the honour and worship which agreeth, and is yeelded one and the same to whole Christ, man and God, keeping notwithstanding the differences in natures, of the properties, and operations, whereon Christs office and honour doth depend. For, to adore and worship Christ, is, by the agnizing and knowledge of his person and office, to crave of him with a true trust and confidence, that those blessings which he hath promerited and promised, he will, as our Mediatour, perform and give to us, according to the proper will and operation of each nature. This adoration consisteth of divers parts, compriseth both natures; and keepeth their properties and operations, though united, yet still distinct; and craveth, that whole Christ in performing his promised benefits, will work those things by his God-head, which are proper to his God-head, and by his flesh, those things which are proper to his flesh. For his benefits are no otherwise to be craved and asked of him, than as himselfe will, and doth perform them to us: and he performeth them still, keeping the difference of both natures. Wherefore, they who crave of Christ the Mediatour, the benefits promised in the Word, doe necessarily acknowledge him omniscient, the searcher of hearts, omnipotent, present every where, of himself beholding and hearing our necessities and complaints. This agnizing, and this honor is proper to God, and agreeth, and is yeelded to Christman, in respect of his God-head onely, and not of his humanity. For in one act, or view unchangeable, to behold, know, and understand, from everlasting of himselfe, all things past, present, and to come; but chiefly the needs, wants, necessities, and desires of his whole Church. Againe, to send the holy Ghost into the hearts of all the elect and chosen, who have been even since the beginning of the world, and by his spirit, to teach them within, to justifie, regenerate, comfort them, and to give to them eternall life; these, I say, are not proper to flesh created and finite, but to a nature infinite, omnipotent, and existing from everlasting. Therefore Christ promiseth the holy Ghost to his Disciples, which is the spirit of truth, wisdome, feare, prayer, grace, &c.
But although after that manner which hath been spoken of, the God-head only, and Christ by reason of his God-head, doth behold and do all things, and is adored of us: yet, his humanity also doth behold, understand, and hear our necessities, ⟨p. 285⟩desires, complaints, and prayers; yet after another sort, that is, not of it self, but by the God head, revealing and showing our desires to the humane understanding, which is united to it. And further, it performeth those things which we crave, both by the efficacy of his merit, and by intercession made incessantly to the Father for us, whereby he willeth, and obtaineth of his Father all blessings for us: and by the force and omnipotency, not of his flesh, but of his God-head united thereunto, by which Christ-man doth effectually apply to us those benefits which he hath obtained for us of his Father. Now, to acknowledge, when we worship Christ the Mediator, these things in him, and to profess the same both in words, gestures, and actions, is the honour which is due, and is exhibited by us to his humanity by reason of the God-head united thereto: yet so, that this veneration of his humanity is not separated from the honour which agreeth to Christ, according to his God-head. For, with one and the same particular and individual invocation and worship we speak to, and honour whole Christ, God and man, according to the properties of both natures, which he retaineth, and will have also now in his glory, and for ever to be attributed to him unitely, but yet distinctly; that is, As the person and office of the Mediator, so the adoration or worship is compound, having parts, whereof some agree to the God-head, some to the flesh: and as in the office, so also in the honour of the person, the properties and operations of the natures are not separated, neither yet confounded; but being united, are distinguished. Wherefore, as it doth not follow, The God-head in Christ is Redemptresse by reason of the flesh assumed: Therefore it is always subject to sufferings, and mortal, did suffer, and was dead: So there is no necessity in this Ubiquitary argument: Christs humanity is adored by reason of his God-head: Therefore the same is also really omniscient, omnipotent, and after the same manner to be adored, as is the God-head.
But although after that manner which hath been spoken of, the God-head onely, and Christ by reason of his God-head, doth behold and doe all things, and is adored of us: yet, his humanity also doth behold, understand, and heare our necessities, ⟨p. 285⟩
The reason is, because of the fellowship or conjunction of office and honour in the person, the same properties and operations in natures are wrongly and heretically inferred. The sum of all is: That Christs humanity is adored by reason of his God-head; cometh not thereof, as if his humanity also were really omniscient, and omnipotent, as is the God-head: (For by reason of these and other like properties is the God-head only invocated) but because it doth truly know, understand, hear our necessities, cogitations, desires, prayers, the divine intelligence and understanding, which is united to it, revealing and opening them unto it: and also because what we crave at Christs hands, the same it effectually performeth, not by the bones, sinews, hands, fingers, feet; but by the force and power of the same God-head.
The reason is, because of the fellowship or conjunction of office and honour in the person, the same properties and operations in natures are wrongly and heretically inferred. The summe of all is: That Christs humanity is adored by reason of his God-head; cometh not thereof, as if his humanity also were really omniscient, and omnipotent, as is the God-head: (For by reason of these and other like properties is the God-head onely invocated) but because it doth truly know, understand, heare our necessities, cogitations, desires, prayers, the divine intelligence and understanding, which is united to it, revealing and opening them unto it: and also because what we crave at Christs hands, the same it effectually performeth, not by the bones, sinewes, hands, fingers, feet; but by the force and power of the same God-head.
Furthermore, that manner and form of speaking, whereby the properties of one nature are really attributed to the person denominated of the other nature, or of both natures, is usually called the communicating of the properties: Likewise, The communicating of names; because the names and attributes of both natures are affirmed of the same person, and of themselves interchangeably, by reason of the unity of person consisting of both natures. The communicating of properties hath some resemblance of the figure in speech called Synecdoche, and is termed by many Synecdoche, because that is affirmed of the whole person, which agreeth unto it only in respect of one of the natures, as a part. It is also called a mutual and interchangeable attribution, because as humane properties are attributed unto God, in respect of the humanity: so divine are attributed unto man, in respect of the divinity: As, God suffered, Man is omnipotent. So likewise, the communicating of names. For, Man is God, and God is man, by reason of the personal union of both natures.
Furthermore, that manner and forme of speaking, whereby the properties of one nature are really attributed to the person denominated of the other nature, or of both natures, is usually called the communicating of the properties: Likewise, The communicating of names; because the names and attributes of both natures are affirmed of the same person, and of themselves interchangeably, by reason of the unity of person consisting of both natures. The communicating of properties hath some resemblance of the figure in speech called Senecdoche, and is termed by many Synecdoche, because that is affirmed of the whole person, which agreeth unto it onely in respect of one of the natures, as a part. It is also called a mutuall and interchangeable attribution, because as humane properties are attributed unto God, in respect of the humanity: so divine are attributed unto man, in respect of the divinity: As, God suffered, Man is omnipotent. So likewise, the communicating of names. For, Man is God, and God is man, by reason of the personall union of both natures.
The names of Office and Honour agree unto the whole person, in respect of both natures; keeping still the difference in natures of properties and operations. These attributes are rightly affirmed of subjects, both concrete and abstract, that is, both ⟨p. 286⟩of the person and of the natures. For it is well said, The God-head quickeneth, the manhood quickeneth; and, God or man quickeneth.
THe names of Office and Honour agree unto the whole person, in respect of both natures; keeping still the difference in natures of properties and operations. These attributes are rightly affirmed of subjects, both concrete and abstract, that is, both ⟨p. 286⟩of the person and of the natures. For it is well said, The God-head quickneth, the manhood quickneth; and, God or man quickneth.
The attributes of office are, To be the Mediator, to make intercession, to redeem, to save, to justify, sanctify, purge from sins, to be Lord and Head of the Church, to be worshipped, to hear, and such like. These offices require the properties and operations of both natures not separated, neither yet confounded, but conjoined and distinct. For even for this very cause was it necessary that the two natures should be united in Christ Mediator; that, what neither nature could do, being set apart, in the work of our Redemption, that Christ, subsisting in both joined together, might do and accomplish by both. As therefore the natures themselves, so their properties also or faculties of working and operations are proper, and remain divers and distinct; yet so, that they concur to the effectuating and working of one effect, or work, and benefit, as parts and communicated labours. For albeit the natures do always labour and work together in the office and benefits of the Mediator, and neither without other: yet doth not therefore one work the same which the other doth: But each worketh, according to his property and force of working, only that which is proper to each nature, and not that also which belongeth unto the other. As neither the soul doth that which is proper to the body, neither the body that which is proper unto the soul, each doing their proper function. So likewise the humanity accomplisheth not that which is proper to the God-head, nor the God-head that which is proper to the manhood: but the same Christ executeth and performeth one and the same office and benefit, by both natures, which he hath in him as parts of his person; the Word working according to the property thereof, what belongeth to the Word; and the flesh in like manner executing according to the peculiar and proper faculties thereof, and not according to others, that which belongeth to the flesh. For the properties and operations proper to each nature, are not common to both natures, but to the same person consisting of both natures.
The attributes of office are, To be the Mediatour, to make intercession, to redeeme, to save, to justifie, sanctifie, purge from sinnes, to be Lord and Head of the Church, to be worshipped, to heare, and such like. These offices require the properties and operations of both natures not separated, neither yet confounded, but conjoyned and distinct. For even for this very cause was it necessary that the two natures should be united in Christ Mediatour; that, what neither nature could doe, being set apart, in the work of our Redemption, that Christ, subsisting in both joyned together, might doe and accomplish by both. As therefore the natures themselves, so their properties also or faculties of working and operations are proper, and remain divers and distinct; yet so, that they concurre to the effectuating and working of one effect, or work, and benefit, as parts and communicated labours. For albeit the natures doe alwayes labour and work together in the office and benefits of the Mediatour, and neither without other: yet doth not therefore one worke the same which the other doth: But each worketh, according to his property and force of working, onely that which is proper to each nature, and not that also which belongeth unto the other. As neither the soule doth that which is proper to the body, neither the body that which is proper unto the soule, each doing their proper function. So likewise the humanity accomplisheth not that which is proper to the God-head, nor the God-head that which is proper to the manhood: but the same Christ executeth and performeth one and the same office and benefit, by both natures, which he hath in him as parts of his person; the Word working according to the property therof, what belongeth to the Word; and the flesh in like manner executing according to the peculiar and proper faculties therof, and not according to others, that which belongeth to the flesh. For the properties and operations proper to each nature, are not common to both natures, but to the same person consisting of both natures.
Wherefore in such like phrases of speech concerning Christs office, which are called of the ancient [Greek or Hebrew], (that is, communicatings, or such as make things common) the properties and operations of natures are to be distinguished from the office of the person, and from the honour which, in respect of the office, is due unto the person: likewise, one effect, or act The antropall, (that is, both of God and man) or work, or benefit, from one operation or action as the whole from a part. The office is common to both natures: but the natures proper faculties of working, and actions in executing that office, are not common to both natures. For that the same should be both proper and common, doth imply a manifest contradiction. So the work and benefit of whole Christ, is a certain whole thing, and is as it were compound, and common to both natures: but there are two parts hereof, and diverse operations, proper to each nature, which are wrought jointly, and belong to the same person, which is Christ, God and man, that is, both are wrought of one person according to diverse causes and originals of working, or according to diverse natures, but not by one and the same nature.
Wherefore in such like phrases of speech concerning Christs office, which are called of the ancient 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, (that is, communicatings, or such as make things common) the properties and operations of natures are to be distinguisht from the office of the person, and from the honour which, in respect of the office, is due unto the person: likewise, one effect, or act The antropall, (that is, both of God and man) or worke, or benefit, from one operation or action as the whole from a part. The office is common to both natures: but the natures proper faculties of working, and actions in executing that office, are not common to both natures. For that the same should be both proper and common, doth imply a manifest contradiction. So the work and benefit of whole Christ, is a certaine whole thing, and is as it were compound, and common to both natures: but there are two parts hereof, and diverse operations, proper to each nature, which are wrought joyntly, and belong to the same person, which is Christ, God and man, that is, both are wrought of one person according to diverse causes and originals of working, or according to diverse natures, but not by one and the same nature.
By these grounds it is easy to dissolve and assoil most of the sophisms and cavils, with which at this time both the Schwenkfeldians, hard Ubiquitaries are wont to gloss and blanch that their real communicating of essential properties in natures, and their Eutychian deifying of Christs flesh, and to thrust the same upon the simple for the true majesty of Christ himself. For thus they reason: The office and benefits of the Mediator, his Redemption, intercession, purging from sins, quickening, sitting at the right hand of the Father, his dominion and Lordly power over all creatures, his presence with the Church, beholding, ruling all things, raising the dead, judging both quick and dead, all these agree to Christ according to both natures: Therefore the hum• ••y, as well as the divinity, is also it self really omniscient, searcher of hearts, omnipotent, present in the substance of his body, at the same moment, in all places, doth of it self know all things, hear our complaints and prayers, give the holy Ghost, and work ⟨p. 287⟩by him in the hearts of the chosen, faith and conversion: and to conclude, in respect of these things, the humanity it self also is for it self adorable, and to be adored, as well as the God-head. To these, and the like, there is one, and a ready answer, namely: That it is ill going from the person, and from the office and honour of the person, to the properties and operations of the natures: Or, The society and conjunction of the office and honour, doth not cause or infer the same properties or operations of both natures: Or, In the affirmation of the office and honour are not signified the same properties of both natures, nor the working of the same operations; but the conjunction or concurrence of distinct operations, proceeding from distinct properties, to the same effect or action Theantropall, that is, of God and man. The reason is, Because of redemption, quickening, adoration, and the like, which are the functions, benefits, and worship of the whole person, there are moe and diverse manners and parts, which will agree really to one and the same person, but not to one and the same nature, but some to the God-head only, some only to the manhood. Wherefore this Major of the reason is false:
By these grounds it is easie to dissolve and assoile most of the sophismes and cavils, with which at this time both the Swenckfieldians, ard Ubiquitaries are wont to glose and blanch that their reall communicating of essentiall properties in natures, and their Eutychian deifying of Christs flesh, and to thrust the same upon the simpe for the true majesty of Christ himselfe. For thus they reason: The office and benefits of the Mediatour, his Redemption, intercession, purging from sins, quickning, sitting at the right hand of the Father, his dominion and Lordly power over all creatures, his presence with the Church, beholding, ruling all things, raising the dead, judging both quick and dead, all these agree to Christ according to both natures: Therefore the hum y, as well as the divinity, is also it selfe really omniscient, searcher of hearts, omnipotent, present in the substance of his body, at the same moment, in all places, doth of it selfe know all things, heare our complaints and prayers, give the holy Ghost, and work
Whatsoever things agree unto Christ, God and man, according to both natures, the same also do agree after the same manner, and as touching all parts to both natures. For, it doth not follow, Because the God-head is Redemptresse, therefore also it suffered, and was dead.
Whatsoever things agree unto Christ, God and man, according to both natures, the same also doe agree after the same manner, and as touching all parts to both natures. For, it doth not follow, Because the God-head is Redemptresse, therefore also it suffered, and was dead.
Now, That those things which in the person and office of the Mediator are, and abide proper unto one nature, neither are made, nor are by reason of the union, common to both natures, may be showed at large: but now let these few suffice: §11. Such as is the union of the natures, such is the communicating of the properties. But the union of the natures was not made in the natures, or into one nature, but in the person, or in one person: Therefore the communicating of the properties was made in the person, not in the nature; that is, the union maketh the properties of both natures common, not to one nature, but to one person. For not one nature, but one person, hath truly, as two natures, so also double properties and operations, and those infinitely differing; created, and increate, finite, and infinite. Wherefore, as by union the manhood was not made the God-head or God; so neither is it immense, infinite, and omnipotent. But contrariwise, man is truly and really as God eternal, so omnipotent also, and every-where, and giver of the holy Ghost. The reason is, because not the manhood, but the man-Christ hath indeed in his substance the eternal and immense God-head. §22. That which is proper to one, cannot be common to moe; that is, cannot exist or be found together in other subjects also of divers natures. For, To be proper, and, To be common, are contradictory, and therefore in farthest repugnancy. §33. There cannot be made one omnipotency, and one omnipotent operation to be both natures, whereby as well the manhood, as the God-head, should be really omnipotent, and work divine things, but there must needs be also one essence of both, whereby the manhood also must be really God. For the omnipotency, which they will have one and the same to be communicated to the flesh, is the God-head it self. §44. If Christs humanity, in the office of the Mediator, doth it self really and effectually perform not only that which belongeth unto the flesh, but also those things which are proper unto the God-head, then either his God-head shall be idle, and do nothing in the work of our Redemption, or surely the flesh assumed shall do more, and more shall be due and yielded unto it, than unto the Word, which assumed and took it. §55.
Now, That those things which in the person and office of the Mediatour are, and abide proper unto one nature, neither are made, nor are by reason of the union, common to both natures, may be shewed at large: but now let these few suffice:
If the flesh, because it is said to be quickening, is sort also may it be said, that the God-head also, because it is Redemptresse, is subject to suffering, and did suffer. For, both quickening and redeeming are properties of the office, common to both natures; but not after one and the same manner. §66. The whole Majesty of the God-head is, that it is an essence existing, not of another, but of it self, and subsisting by it self, spiritual, or incorporeal, eternal, immense, unchangeable, of infinite power, wisdom, goodness, &c. That is, the whole Majesty compriseth all the perfections and operations proper unto the God-head. But omnipotency is the whole Majesty of the God-head, according to the supposition of the Ubiquitaries: For so Schmideline writeth in the 142. conclusion of his disputation of the Lords Supper, and of the communicating of the properties, had at ⟨p. 288⟩Tubing, in the year 1582. In the word omnipotency I comprise the whole Majesty of the God-head. And in his 143. conclusion, Omnipotency is the very essence it self of the God-head, &c. Therefore, If Gods omnipotency be really communicated to Christs humanity, so that this also is, by reason of the omnipotency communicated unto it, really omnipotent; of necessity then, by reason of the same omnipotency really communicated, Christs humanity shall be indeed an essence subsisting of it self, and by it self, incorporeal, eternal immense, Creatress of all things: that is, God himself, blessed for ever, and so by consequent, the divine person. For an essence intelligent, subsisting by it self, and which also is God, must needs be the person. And these are the fruits of real communicating of properties in natures.
If the flesh, because it is said to be quickning, is sort also may it be said, that the God-head also, because it is Redemptresse, is subject to suffering, and did suffer. For, both quickning and redeeming are properties of the office, common to both natures; but not after one and the same manner. §66. The whole Majesty of the God-head is, that it is an essence existing, not of another, but of it selfe, and subsisting by it selfe, spirituall, or incorporeall, eternall, immense, unchangeable, of infinite power, wisdome, goodnesse, &c. That is, the whole Majesty compriseth all the perfections and operations proper unto the God-head. But omnipotency is the whole Majesty of the God-head, according to the supposition of the Ubiquitaries: For so Schmideline writeth in the 142. conclusion of his disputation of the Lords Supper, and of the communicating of the properties, had at
The participation of the God-head, exaltation and majesty of the flesh, and such like, is not a real communicating of the essential properties of the God head made into the humane nature, or an omnipresence, omniscience, omnipotency; that is, a God-head of the manhood. (For such a communicating should not perfect, but destroy the manhood. and convert it into the God-head, and dissolve the personal union of distinct natures) but it is, 1. The very union of the humanity with the Word, in such sort, as it, being created and finite, doth, together with all the essential properties thereof, subsist, not in a created person of the same humane nature, but in the increate, and eternal person of God the Word: by reason of which union, God the Word (but not the God-head) is, and is called truly man: and contrary, man (but not the manhood) is, and is called truly eternal God. No dignity and eminency can be imagined greater than this, neither doth it agree to any, but to the flesh of Christ only. 2. It is the excellency of gifts. For, these Christs humanity received without measure; that is, all whatsoever, and most great, and most perfect, that may fall into a created and finite nature. 3. The office of the Mediator: to the performing whereof, the united, but yet distinct, properties and operations of both natures do necessarily concur. 4. The honour and worship, which, by reason of the Mediatorship, agreeth, and is given to whole Christ according to both natures, keeping still, as was before said, the difference of properties and operations in natures.
The participation of the God-head, exaltation and majesty of the flesh, and such like, is not a reall communicating of the essentiall properties of the God head made into the humane nature, or an omnipresence, omniscience, omnipotency; that is, a God-head of the manhood. (For such a communicating should not perfect, but destroy the manhood. and convert it into the God-head, and dissolve the personall union of distinct natures) but it is, 1. The very union of the humanity with the Word, in such sort, as it, being created and finite, doth, together with all the essentiall properties thereof, subsist, not in a created person of the same humane nature, but in the increate, and eternall person of God the Word: by reason of which union, God the Word (but not the God-head) is, and is called truly man: and contrary, man (but not the manhood) is, and is called truly eternall God. No dignity and eminency can be imagined greater than this, neither doth it agree to any, but to the flesh of Christ only. 2. It is the excellency of gifts. For, these Christs humanity received without measure; that is, all whatsoever, and most great, and most perfect, that may fall into a created and finite nature. 3. The office of the Mediatour: to the performing whereof, the united, but yet distinct, properties and operations of both natures doe necessarily concur. 4. The honour and worship, which, by reason of the Mediatourship, agreeth, and is given to whole Christ according to both natures, keeping still, as was before said, the difference of properties and operations in natures.
Now, whatsoever testimonies some bring either out of the Scriptures, or out of the Fathers which were sound in faith, thereby to prove that their Eutychian transmutation, and a third kind of communicating forged by themselves; that is, exequation or equalling of natures; all those testimonies indeed belong either to the grace of union of the natures, which is signified by the communicating of properties; or, to the grace of Christs headship, which compriseth the office and honour of the Mediator, which are affirmed of whole Christ by way of communicating: or to the habitual grace; that is, the created gifts, which Christ received without measure, which are properly affirmed of the flesh or humanity. These gifts, which are also called graces, are not properly effects of the personal union, as are the attributes or properties of the natures and office: 1. Because they are communicated to the manhood, as well of the Father and the holy Ghost, as of the Word or Son. For he is said to have received of the Father, the spirit without measure; that is, abundantly: likewise, to be anointed with the holy Ghost. And, if the gifts were effects of the union, it would follow of necessity, that the flesh was united, not to the Son only, but to the Father also, and the holy Ghost. 2. The union of the flesh with the Word was from the very moment of the conception always most perfect. But the consummation and perfection of gifts was not until the accomplished time of his resurrection and ascension. For he was indeed humble, weak, and contemned: he was indeed ignorant of some things: he did indeed increase in wisdom, stature, and in favour, not with men only, but also with God himself. 3. The flesh, when it was in the state of humility, had not immortality, or a nature not subject to sufferings, or the like; and yet remained it always united with the Word. Wherefore the habitual gifts or graces of the humanity, for which it is also in it self really wise, mighty, just, holy, follow not the personal union in respect of dependency, as the effect followeth, and dependeth of his cause: but only in respect of order: Because, indeed, the humane nature was first to subsist and be, before it were enriched with gifts: and it subsisted united to the Word in the ⟨p. 289⟩very first moment of the conception.
Now, whatsoever testimonies some bring either out of the Scriptures, or out of the Fathers which were sound in faith, thereby to prove that their Eutychian transmutation, and a third kind of communicating forged by themselves; that is, exequation or equalling of natures; all those testimonies indeed belong either to the grace of union of the natures, which is signified by the communicating of properties; or, to the grace of Christs headship, which compriseth the office and honour of the Mediatour, which are affirmed of whole Christ by way of communicating: or to the habituall grace; that is, the created gifts, which Christ received without measure, which are properly affirmed of the flesh or humanity. These gifts, which are also called graces, are not properly effects of the personall union, as are the attributes or properties of the natures and office: 1. Because they are communicated to the manhood, as well of the Father and the holy Ghost, as of the Word or Son. For he is said to have received of the Father, the spirit without measure; that is, abundantly: likewise, to be annointed with the holy Ghost. And, if the gifts were effects of the union, it would follow of necessity, that the flesh was united, not to the Son onely, but to the Father also, and the holy Ghost. 2. The union of the flesh with the Word was from the very moment of the conception alwayes most perfect. But the consummation and perfection of gifts was not untill the accomplished time of his resurrection and ascension. For he was indeed humble, weake, and contemned: he was indeed ignorant of some things: he did indeed increase in wisdome, stature, and in favour, not with men onely, but also with God himselfe. 3. The flesh, when it was in the state of humility, had not immortality, or a nature not subject to sufferings, or the like; and yet remained it alwayes united with the Word. Wherefore the habituall gifts or graces of the humanity, for which it is also in it selfe really wise, mighty, just, holy, follow not the personall union in respect of dependency, as the effect followeth, and dependeth of his cause: but only in respect of order: Because, indeed, the humane nature was first to subsist and be, before it were inriched with gifts: and it subsisted united to the Word in the
But after what manner the humanity is united unto the Son of God, hath been said before. For by the special and miraculous working of the holy Ghost, in the womb of the Virgin, of her blood was the flesh of Christ formed, sanctified, and united according to subsistence, or personally unto the Word.
But after what manner the humanity is united unto the Sonne of God, hath been said before. For by the speciall and miraculous working of the holy Ghost, in the womb of the Virgin, of her bloud was the flesh of Christ formed, sanctified, and united according to subsistence, or personally unto the Word.
For what cause Christ our Mediator was to be together both a true and perfect just man, and true (that is, by nature) man, and withal true God, hath been declared of us before in the Common-place of the Mediator. For the work of our Redemption could not have been compassed and finished by the Mediator, without the concurrence of divers natures and operations in the same person. For albeit he suffered, and died in the flesh; yet his passion and suffering could not have that force and efficacy to redeem, justify, and sanctify us; neither could Christ have applied those benefits unto us, except he had been withal true and natural God.
FOr what cause Christ our Mediatour was to be together both a true and perfect just man, and true (that is, by nature) man, and withall true God, hath been declared of us before in the Common-place of the Mediatour. For the work of our Redemption could not have been compassed and finished by the Mediatour, without the concurrence of divers natures and operations in the same person. For albeit he suffered, and died in the flesh; yet his passion and suffering could not have that force and efficacy to redeem, justifie, and sanctifie us; neither could Christ have applyed those benefits unto us, except he had been withall true and naturall God.
1WE confess our Lord Jesus Christ, begotten before all worlds of his Father, but in the last times borne according to the flesh of the Virgin by the holy Ghost, subsisting in one person only, made of the celestial God-head and humane flesh. Whole God and whole man. Whole God also with his body, but not according to his body God; whole man also with his God-head, but not according to his Godhead man. Again, whole adorable also with his body, but not according to his body adorable. Whole adoring also with his God-head, but not according to his God-head adoring. Whole increate also with his body, but not according to his body increated. Whole formed also with his God-head, but not according to his God-head formed. Whole consubstantial with God also with his body, but not according to his body consubstantial: as neither also, according to his God-head he is co-essential with men: but he is according to the flesh consubstantial unto us, existing also in his God-head. For when we say he is according to the spirit consubstantial with God, we do not say he is according to the spirit co-essential with men. And contrarily, when we affirm him to be according to the flesh consubstantial with men, we do not affirm him to be according to the flesh consubstantial with God. For as according to the spirit he is not consubstantial with us (for according to this he is consubstantial with God): So, on the other side, he is not according to the flesh co-essential with God: but according to this he is consubstantial with us. And as we pronounce these to be distinct: and divers one from the other, not to bring in a division of one undivided person, but to note the distinction and unconfoundablenes of the natures and properties of the Word and the flesh: so we affirm and worship those as united, which make to the manner of the undivided union or composition.
1WE confesse our Lord Jesus Christ, begotten before all worlds of his Father, but in the last times borne according to the flesh of the Virgin by the holy Ghost, subsisting in one person only, made of the celestiall God-head and humane flesh. Whole God and whole man. Whole God also with his body, but not according to his body God; whole man also with his God-head, but not according to his Godhead man. Againe, whole adorable also with his body, but not according to his body adorable. Whole adoring also with his God-head, but not according to his God-head adoring. Whole increate also with his body, but not according to his body increated. Whole formed also with his God-head, but not according to his God-head formed. Whole consubstantiall with God also with his body, but not according to his body consubstantiall: as neither also, according to his God-head he is co-essentiall with men: but he is according to the flesh consubstantiall unto us, existing also in his God-head. For when we say he is according to the spirit consubstantiall with God, we doe not say he is according to the spirit co-essentiall with men. And contrarily, when we affirme him to be according to the flesh consubstantiall with men, we doe not affirme him to be according to the flesh consubstantiall with God. For as according to the spirit he is not consubstantiall with us (for according to this he is consubstantiall with God): So, on the other side, he is not according to the flesh co-essentiall with God: but according to this he is consubstantiall with us. And as we pronounce these to be distinct: and divers one from the other, not to bring in a division of one undivided person, but to note the distinction and unconfoundablenes of the natures and properties of the Word and the flesh: so we affirme and worship those as united, which make to the manner of the undivided union or composition.
IF there be one nature of the Word and flesh, how then, seeing the Word is every-where, is not the flesh also found every-where? For when it was in the earth, it was not verily in heaven: and now because it is in heaven, it is not verily in the earth: and insomuch it is not, as that, as touching it, we look for Christ to come from heaven, whom, as touching the Word, we believe to be in the earth with us. Wherefore, according to your opinion, either the Word is contained in place with the flesh, or the flesh is every-where with the Word; whereas one nature receiveth not any contrary or divers thing in it self: and it is a thing diverse and far unlike ⟨p. 290⟩to be circumscribed in place, and to be every-where: and seeing the Word is every-where, and the flesh is not every-where; it is apparent, that one and the same Christ is of both natures, and is every-where as touching the nature of his God-head, but is not every-where as touching the nature of his man-hood: is created, and hath no beginning: is subject to death, and cannot die: the one he hath by the nature of the Word, whereby he is God: the other by the nature of his flesh, whereby the same God is man. Wherefore that one Son of God, and the same made the Son of man, hath a beginning by the nature of flesh, and hath no beginning by the nature of his God-head: was created by the nature of his flesh, and was not created by the nature of his God-head: circumscribed in place by the nature of his flesh, and not contained in any place by the nature of his God-head; is lower also then the Angels by the nature of his flesh, and is equal with the Father according to the nature of his God-head: died by the nature of his flesh, and never died by the nature of his God-head. This is the Catholic faith and confession, which the Apostles delivered, the Martyrs established, and the faithful hitherto hold and maintain.
IF there be one nature of the Word and flesh, how then, seeing the Word is every-where, is not the flesh also found every-where? For when it was in the earth, it was not verily in heaven: and now because it is in heaven, it is not verily in the earth: and insomuch it is not, as that, as touching it, we look for Christ to come from heaven, whom, as touching the Word, we beleeve to be in the earth with us. Wherefore, according to your opinion, either the Word is contained in place with the flesh, or the flesh is every-where with the Word; whereas one nature receiveth not any contrary or divers thing in it selfe: and it is a thing diverse and far unlike ⟨p. 290⟩
Answ. That he, all the time of his life which he led in the earth, but especially at the end thereof, sustained the wrath of God both in body and soul, against the sin of all mankind,a that he might by his passion, as the only propitiatory sacrifice,b deliver our body and soul from everlasting damnation,c and purchase unto us the favour of God, righteousness, and everlasting life.d
Answ. That he, all the time of his life which he led in the earth, but especially at the end thereof, sustained the wrath of God both in body and soule, against the sin of all mankind,a that he might by his passion, as the only propitiatory sacrifice,b deliver our body and soule from everlasting damnation,c and purchase unto us the favour of God, righteousnesse, and everlasting life.d
Now have we in few words expounded those Articles of the Apostolic Creed, which entreat of the person of Christ; and have withal declared in the exposition thereof, those things which are necessary for us to know, both of the Divinity of Christ, and of his humane nature, which was taken by the Word of the seed of David, united personally with the Word by the virtue of the holy Ghost, and begotten in marvellous manner of the Virgins substance: The course of order requireth, that now consequently we expound and declare those Articles which treat of the office of Christ: and first of all of his Humiliation, or humbling, which is the former part of Christs office, whereunto belong these Articles; He suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, dead, and buried: He descended into hell. After we have expounded these, we will come unto the rest of the Articles, which speak of his Glorification; which is the other part of Christs office. The Passion of Christ doth follow next his Conception and Nativity:1 1. Because in his Passion and Death consisteth our salvation. 2. Because his whole life was a continual passion, suffering, and calamity. Yet notwithstanding, many things may, and ought to be profitably observed out of the story of the whole race of his life on earth, set down by the Evangelists. For that doth show, 1. This person to be the promised Messiah, seeing in him concur, and are fulfilled all the prophecies. 2. That story is a consideration or meditation of that humility or obedience, which he performed unto his Father. Hither belong those things, which are especially to be considered in Christs Passion: 1. The history it self of Christs Passion agreeing with Gods sacred Oracles and Prophecies. 2. The causes or fruits of Christs Passion. 3. His example, that we are also to enter into eternal life & heavenly glory, ⟨p. 291⟩by suffering death, as did Christ. But, for fuller explication, these four Questions touching Christs Passion are to be considered: 1. What is understood by the name of Passion, or what Christ suffered. 2. Whether he suffered according to both natures. 3. What was the impellent cause of Christs Passion. 4. What the final causes or ends and fruits thereof.
NOw have we in few words expounded those Articles of the Apostolike Creed, which intreate of the person of Christ; and have withall declared in the exposition thereof, those things which are necessary for us to know, both of the Divinity of Christ, and of his humane nature, which was taken by the Word of the seed of David, united personally with the Word by the vertue of the holy Ghost, and begotten in marvellous manner of the Virgins substance: The course of order requireth, that now consequently we expound and declare those Articles which treat of the office of Christ: and first of all of his Humiliation, or humbling, which is the former part of Christs office, whereunto belong these Articles; He suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, dead, and buried: He descended into hell. After we have expounded these, we will come unto the rest of the Articles, which speak of his Glorification; which is the other part of Christs office. The Passion of Christ doth follow next his Conception and Nativity:
BY the name of Passion is understood the whole humiliation, or the obedience of Christs whole humiliation, all the miseries, infirmities, torments, ignominies, pains, and griefs, unto all which Christ for our sakes was subject and obnoxious, as well in soul, as in body, from the point of his nativity, until the hour of his death and resurrection. For the chief part of his pains and dolours, were the torments in his soul, wherein he felt the ire and wrath of God against the sin of mankind. But principally by the name Passion is signified the last part of his humiliation, even the last act of his life,1 wherein he suffered extreme torments of soul and body for our fins. My soul is very heavy, even unto the death. My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? Surely he hath carried our sorrows. The Lord hath laid upon him the iniquities of us all. The Lord would break him, and make him subject to infirmities. What then did Christ suffer? He suffered, §11. A privation and want of incomparable happiness, joy and all other heavenly blessings, which he should have enjoyed. §22. All the infirmities of mans nature, sin only excepted: he hungered, thirsted,2 was weary, was stricken with sadness and grief, &c. §33. Extreme need and poverty: The son of man hath not whereon to lay his head. §44. For infinite injuries, contumelies, slanders, layings in wait for him, back-bitings, reproaches, blasphemies, annihilating,3 and contempt: I am a worm, and not a man. He hath neither form nor beauty: when we shall see him, there shall be no form that we should desire him. §545. The temptations of the Devil: He was in all things tempted in like sort, yet without sin. §66. The death of the body; and that, reproachful and contumelious, even the death of the Cross, §77. The most grievous torments of soul: that is,
especially seeing other Martyrs have been much more stout and courageous in their torments? 1Ans. The cause hereof was the diversity of the punishment which Christ endured, from that which other Martyrs abide. Saint Laurence lying on the grid-iron, felt not Gods dreadful wrath against his own sins, and the sins of mankind (the whole punishment whereof was laid on the Son of God, as Isaiah saith, Christ was stricken, and humbled for our iniquities) Saint Laurence, I say, then felt not God angry and striking, but reconciled and appeased with him & gracious and favourable towards him: neither sustained he (as Christ sustained) the horrors of death and hell; but had great comfort in that he suffered for the confession of the Gospel, and was assured of remission of his sins by, and for the Son of God, on whom God laid them, as it is said: Behold the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sins of the world. 2Hence is it that S. Laurence may seem to have bin more stout and courageous in his martyrdom, than Christ in his Passion. And hereof it was that the humane nature of Christ, though united to the God-head, did sweat blood in the Garden, & brake into that out-cry: My God my God, why hast thou forsaken me? 3not that there was any separation of the natures, but because the humanity was for a time forsaken of the ⟨p. 292⟩Divinity,4 in as much as the Word (as Irenaeus speaketh) was at quiet, and assisted not, nor delivered the afflicted man-hood, until a sufficient Passion was finished and fulfilled. Christs Passion therefore differeth from the torments of other men, 1. In the very form: for Christ felt the whole wrath of God, both in his body, and in his soul; others not so. 2. In the impulsive cause: for Christ suffered not for his own sins, but for ours. 3. In the end: for Christs Passion is the ransom and only propitiatory sacrifice for our sins; the sufferings of other men are no ransom, but either punishments, or trials, or witnessings of the truth.
especially seeing other Martyrs have been much more stout and courageous in their torments?
Object. 1. The order of Gods justice, permitteth not that the innocent and righteous should suffer for the unrighteous. For it is the point of justice to punish the guilty offenders. But Christ was an innocent. Therefore Christs Passion seemeth to overthrow Gods justice. Ans. The righteous may not suffer for the unrighteous, unless these conditions concur in his Passion. 1. That of his own accord he offer himself to punishment. 2. That he so voluntarily offer himself to punishment, that he be able also to pay a sufficient ransom for the offenders, whose punishment he undergoeth. 3. That he be able to preserve himself from perishing therein, and able to recover thence. 4. That he effect in those for whom he satisfieth, that they offend no more hereafter. 5. That he be of the same nature which the offenders are, for whom he satisfieth. If such a satisfier be deputed, Gods justice is no way impaired. For thus, both he that suffereth, and they for whom he suffereth are saved. Now Christ is such a satisfier. For Christ both performed all the forenamed conditions, and is not only a man of the same nature with us, but we in a nigher degree of conjunction with him are his very members. In regard whereof, his punishment becometh our punishment: and the Apostles every where teach, that we all suffered and died in Christ. For when the head is afflicted, all the members suffer with it. More of this argument shall be spoken hereafter in the Article of the remission of sins. In a word, these conditions must concur to this, that one should satisfy for another: 1. This satisfaction must be sufficient. 2. It must be voluntary. 3. It must content him to whom it is due. These all are found in Christs satisfaction.
Object. 1. The order of Gods justice, permitteth not that the innocent and righteous should suffer for the unrighteous. For it is the point of justice to punish the guilty offendors. But Christ was an innocent. Therefore Christs Passion seemeth to overthrow Gods justice. Ans. The righteous may not suffer for the unrighteous, unlesse these conditions concurre in his Passion. 1. That of his own accord he offer himselfe to punishment. 2. That he so voluntarily offer himselfe to punishment, that he be able also to pay a sufficient ransome for the offendors, whose punishment he undergoeth. 3. That he be able to preserve himselfe from perishing therein, and able to recover thence. 4. That he effect in those for whom he satisfieth, that they offend no more hereafter. 5. That he be of the same nature which the offenders are, for whom he satisfieth. If such a satisfier be deputed, Gods justice is no way impaired. For thus, both he that suffereth, and they for whom he suffereth are saved. Now Christ is such a satisfier. For Christ both performed all the forenamed conditions, and is not only a man of the same nature with us, but we in a nigher degree of conjunction with him are his very members. In regard whereof, his punishment becometh our punishment: and the Apostles every where teach, that we all suffered and died in Christ. For when the head is afflicted, all the members suffer with it. More of this argument shall be spoken hereafter in the Article of the remission of sinnes. In a word, these conditions must concurre to this, that one should satisfie for another: 1. This satisfaction must be sufficient. 2. It must be voluntary. 3. It must content him to whom it is due. These all are found in Christs satisfaction.
Object. 2. Between the satisfaction and the crime there must be some proportion: But between one mans Passion, and the sins of infinite numbers of men there is no proportion: How then may the ransom of Christ alone answer for the sins of an infinite number of men? Answ It may, and that for these two causes: 1. For the dignity of the person suffering, because he is true God, and a pure and unspotted man. 2. For the grievousness of his punishment; because he suffered that which we should have suffered for ever. His passion therefore is equivalent to everlasting punishment; yea it surpasseth it. For that God should suffer, is more then that all the creatures should perish everlastingly. It was the strangest miracle that ever happened, that the Son of God should cry on the Cross,1 My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? Repl. God cannot die and suffer: Christ suffered and died: Therefore he is not God. Answ. God, that is, the person which is only God, cannot suffer, or is impassible, according to that whereby he is God. But Christ is not only God, but man withal. Or we may grant the whole reason: For Christ was not God according to that wherein he suffered and died, that is, his humanity. Repl. If Christ be not God according to that wherein he suffered, then it is false which is said; God hath purchased the Church with his own blood. Answ. This was spoken by a communicating of the properties; but this was in the person, not in the nature: that is, that person, which is God and man, purchased the Church by his blood which he shed in his man-hood.2 The communicating of the properties, is, to attribute that to the whole person, which is proper unto one nature, and this is attributed in a concrete voice, not in an abstract: because the concrete voice signifieth the person in which are both natures, and the property of that nature whereof something is affirmed. But the abstract name signifieth the nature which is in the person, but not the person. And therefore it is, that nothing hindereth, why that which is proper to one nature, may not be affirmed of the whole person, so that property it self be in the person: but contrariwise, of the abstract name, only the properties of that nature are affirmed unto which they properly belong.
Object. 2. Betweene the satisfaction and the crime there must be some proportion: But betweene one mans Passion, and the sinnes of infinite numbers of men there is no proportion: How then may the ransome of Christ alone answer for the sins of an infinite number of men? Answ It may, and that for these two causes: 1. For the dignity of the person suffering, because he is true God, and a pure and unspotted man. 2. For the grievousnesse of his punishment; because he suffered that which we should have suffered for ever. His passion therefore is equivalent to everlasting punishment; yea it surpasseth it. For that God should suffer, is more then that all the creatures should perish everlastingly. It was the strangest miracle that ever hapned, that the Son of God should cry on the Crosse,
As of the ⟨p. 293⟩God-head (which is the abstract name) no property of the man-hood may be affirmed, but only the properties of the God-head; because the God-head signifieth not the person which hath both names, but only the divine nature it self. But of God (which is the concrete name) the properties not of the God-head only, but of the man-hood also may be affirmed: because God signifieth not the divine nature, but the person which hath both the divine nature, and the humane.
As of the ⟨p. 293⟩God-head (which is the abstract name) no property of the man-hood may be affirmed, but only the properties of the God-head; because the God-head signifieth not the person which hath both names, but only the divine nature it selfe. But of God (which is the concrete name) the properties not of the God-head only, but of the man-hood also may be affirmed: because God signifieth not the divine nature, but the person which hath both the divine nature, and the humane.
Object. 3. There is no proportion between temporal punishment and eternal. Christ suffered only temporal pains and punishments: therefore he could not satisfy for eternal punishment. Answ. There is no proportion between temporal and eternal punishment, if they be considered as being both in the same subject: but in diverse subjects there may be. The temporal punishment of the Son of God is of more value and worth, than the eternal punishment of the whole world, for divers causes heretofore alleged.
Object. 3. There is no proportion between temporall punishment and eternall. Christ suffered onely temporall paines and punishments: therefore he could not satisfie for eternall punishment. Answ. There is no proportion between temporall and eternall punishment, if they be considered as being both in the same subject: but in diverse subjects there may be. The temporall punishment of the Son of God is of more value and worth, than the eternall punishment of the whole world, for divers causes heretofore alledged.
Object. 4. If Christ satisfied perfectly for all, then all must be saved. But all are not saved. Therefore he satisfied not perfectly for all. Answ. Christ satisfied for all men, as concerning the application of his merit and satisfaction. True it is, that Christ fulfilled the Law two ways. 1. By his own righteousness. 2. By satisfying for our unrighteousness; and both these he performed most perfectly. But the satisfaction is made outs by our private application, which is two-fold: the former is wrought by God, when he justifieth us for his Sons merit, and causeth us to cease from sin; the latter is effected by us through faith. For we then apply unto our selves the merit of Christ, when by a true faith we are persuaded, that God remitteth our sins for his Sons sacrifice and satisfaction: and without this application, Christs satisfaction availeth us nothing.
Object. 4. If Christ satisfied perfectly for all, then all must be saved. But all are not saved. Therefore he satisfied not perfectly for all. Answ. Christ satisfied for all men, as concerning the application of his merit and satisfaction. True it is, that Christ fulfilled the Law two wayes. 1. By his owne righteousnesse. 2. By satisfying for our unrighteousnesse; and both these he performed most perfectly. But the satisfaction is made outs by our private application, which is two-fold: the former is wrought by God, when he justifieth us for his Sons merit, and causeth us to cease from sin; the latter is effected by us through faith. For we then apply unto our selves the merit of Christ, when by a true faith we are perswaded, that God remitteth our sins for his Sons sacrifice and satisfaction: and without this application, Christs satisfaction availeth us nothing.
Object. 5. There were also propitiatory sacrifices in Moses Law. Answ. There were no sacrifices which might properly be termed expiatory: but those that were, were shadows only of Christs sacrifice, which only is propitiatory.1 For it is impossible that the blood of Bulls and Goats should take away sins. The blood of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sin. He is the propitiation for the sins of the whole world.
Object. 5. There were also propitiatory sacrifices in Moses Law. Answ. There were no sacrifices which might properly be termed expiatory: but those that were, were shadowes onely of Christs sacrifice, which onely is propitiatory.1 For it is impossible that the bloud of Buls and Goates should take away sinnes. The bloud of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sinne. He is the propitiation for the sinnes of the whole world.
Christ suffered not according to both natures, neither according to his God-head, but according to his humane nature only, both in body and soul. For his divine nature is immutable, impassible, immortal, and very life it self; which cannot die. Now, he so suffered according to his humanity, that by his death and passion he made satisfaction for infinite sins of men. And the divinity sustained and upheld the humanity in the griefs and pains thereof, and raised it again to life, when it had been dead. Christ was put to death concerning the flesh, but was quickened in the spirit. 1For Christ also hath once suffered for sins, the just for the unjust, that he might bring us unto God. Destroy this Temple, and I will raise it up again in three days. I was dead, and lo I am alive. I have power to lay down my life, and to take it up again. These testimonies prove that there was another nature in Christ besides his flesh, which other nature neither suffered nor died.
CHrist suffered not according to both natures, neither according to his God-head, but according to his humane nature onely, both in body and soule. For his divine nature is immutable, impassible, immortall, and very life it selfe; which cannot die. Now, he so suffered according to his humanity, that by his death and passion he made satisfaction for infinite sinnes of men. And the divinity sustained and upheld the humanity in the griefes and paines thereof, and raised it againe to life, when it had been dead. Christ was put to death concerning the flesh, but was quickned in the spirit. 1For Christ also hath once suffered for sinnes, the just for the unjust, that he might bring us unto God. Destroy this Temple, and I will raise it up againe in three dayes. I was dead, and loe I am alive. I have power to lay downe my life, and to take it up againe. These testimonies prove that there was another nature in Christ besides his flesh, which other nature neither suffered nor died.
Irenaeus saith: As Christ was man, that so he might be tempted: 1so he was the Word, that so he might be glorified: The Word indeed and Deity so resting in him, that he might be tempted, crucified, and suffer death; and yet united to his humanity, that so he might overcome temptation, death, &c. Object. God purchased the Church with his own blood: therefore the God-head suffered. Ans. It doth not follow:2 because an argument from the concrete (which is God) to the abstract (which is the God head) is of no consequence. Again, the kind of affirmation is altered. God is said to have dyed, by a figurative speech, which is Synecdoche (use when we signify the whole by a part, as whole Christ by God) and by a communicating of the properties. But when it is said, The God head died, this affirmation admitteth no figure, seeing the subject in it is a mere abstract. The concrete signifieth the subject, or person having the nature ⟨p. 294⟩or form: but the abstract signifieth the bare nature and form only. Wherefore; as the argument doth not follow, A man is compounded of the clements, and is corporeal: Therefore his soul also is corporeal; (this cannot follow, because all things agree not to the form, which agree to the subject; the soul is the form of man, man is the essential subject of the soul) So neither doth it follow; Christ-God died: therefore Christs God-head died: For, from the concrete to the abstract, the reason doth not follow.
Irenaeus saith: As Christ was man, that so he might be tempted: 1so he was the Word, that so he might be glorified: The Word indeed and Deity so resting in him, that he might be tempted, crucified, and suffer death; and yet united to his humanity, that so he might overcome temptation, death, &c. Object. God purchased the Church with his owne bloud: therefore the God-head suffered. Ans. It doth not follow:2 because an argument from the concrete (which is God) to the abstract (which is the God head) is of no consequence. Againe, the kind of affirmation is altered. God is said to have dyed, by a figurative speech, which is Synecdoche (use when we signifie the whole by a part, as whole Christ by God) and by a communicating of the properties. But when it is said, The God head died, this affirmation admitteth no figure, seeing the subject in it is a meer abstract. The concrete signifieth the subject, or person having the nature
BY the name of Passion is understood the whole humiliation, or the obedience of Christs whole humiliation, all the miseries, infirmities, torments, ignominies, paines, and griefs, unto all which Christ for our sakes was subject and obnoxious, as well in soule, as in body, from the point of his nativity, untill the houre of his death and resurrection. For the chiefe part of his paines and dolours, were the torments in his soule, wherein he felt the ire and wrath of God against the sin of mankind. But principally by the name Passion is signified the last part of his humiliation, even the last act of his life,1 wherein he suffered extreme torments of soule and body for our finnes. My soule is very heavie, even unto the death. My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? Surely he hath carried our sorrowes. The Lord hath laid upon him the iniquities of us all. The Lord would break him, and make him subject to infirmities. What then did Christ suffer? He suffered, §11. A privation and want of incomparable happinesse, joy and all other heavenly blessings, which he should have injoyed. §22. All the infirmities of mans nature, sinne onely excepted: he hungred, thirsted,2 was weary, was stricken with sadnesse and griete, &c. §33. Extreme need and poverty: The sonne of man hath not whereon to lay his head. §44. For infinite injuries, contumelies, slanders, layings in wait for him, back-bitings, reproaches, blasphemies, annihilating,3 and contempt: I am a worme, and not a man. He hath neither forme nor beauty: when we shall see him, there shall be no forme that we should desire him. §545. The temptations of the Devill: He was in all things tempted in like sort, yet without sinne. §66. The death of the body; and that, reproachfull and contumelious, even the death of the Crosse, §77. The most grievous torments of soule: that is,5 he found the sense and feeling of the wrath of God against the sins of all mankind to be laid upon him. Hereof it was, that he cried with a loud voyce; My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? as if he should say; Why doest thou not drive and put away from me such torments?6 We see then, what, and how great things Christ hath suffered for us. Quest. But whereas the divine nature was united to the humane, how could it be that the humane nature should be so broken and weakened, that he should breake forth into such out cries: