Object. 2. Between the satisfaction and the crime there must be some proportion: But between one mans Passion, and the sins of infinite numbers of men there is no proportion: How then may the ransom of Christ alone answer for the sins of an infinite number of men? Answ It may, and that for these two causes: 1. For the dignity of the person suffering, because he is true God, and a pure and unspotted man. 2. For the grievousness of his punishment; because he suffered that which we should have suffered for ever. His passion therefore is equivalent to everlasting punishment; yea it surpasseth it. For that God should suffer, is more then that all the creatures should perish everlastingly. It was the strangest miracle that ever happened, that the Son of God should cry on the Cross,1 My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? Repl. God cannot die and suffer: Christ suffered and died: Therefore he is not God. Answ. God, that is, the person which is only God, cannot suffer, or is impassible, according to that whereby he is God. But Christ is not only God, but man withal. Or we may grant the whole reason: For Christ was not God according to that wherein he suffered and died, that is, his humanity. Repl. If Christ be not God according to that wherein he suffered, then it is false which is said; God hath purchased the Church with his own blood. Answ. This was spoken by a communicating of the properties; but this was in the person, not in the nature: that is, that person, which is God and man, purchased the Church by his blood which he shed in his man-hood.2 The communicating of the properties, is, to attribute that to the whole person, which is proper unto one nature, and this is attributed in a concrete voice, not in an abstract: because the concrete voice signifieth the person in which are both natures, and the property of that nature whereof something is affirmed. But the abstract name signifieth the nature which is in the person, but not the person. And therefore it is, that nothing hindereth, why that which is proper to one nature, may not be affirmed of the whole person, so that property it self be in the person: but contrariwise, of the abstract name, only the properties of that nature are affirmed unto which they properly belong.
Object. 2. Betweene the satisfaction and the crime there must be some proportion: But betweene one mans Passion, and the sinnes of infinite numbers of men there is no proportion: How then may the ransome of Christ alone answer for the sins of an infinite number of men? Answ It may, and that for these two causes: 1. For the dignity of the person suffering, because he is true God, and a pure and unspotted man. 2. For the grievousnesse of his punishment; because he suffered that which we should have suffered for ever. His passion therefore is equivalent to everlasting punishment; yea it surpasseth it. For that God should suffer, is more then that all the creatures should perish everlastingly. It was the strangest miracle that ever hapned, that the Son of God should cry on the Crosse,1 My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? Repl. God cannot die and suffer: Christ suffered and died: Therefore he is not God. Answ. God, that is, the person which is onely God, cannot suffer, or is impassible, according to that whereby he is God. But Christ is not onely God, but man withall. Or we may grant the whole reason: For Christ was not God according to that wherein he suffered and died, that is, his humanity. Repl. If Christ be not God according to that wherein he suffered, then it is false which is said; God hath purchased the Church with his owne bloud. Answ. This was spoken by a communicating of the properties; but this was in the person, not in the nature: that is, that person, which is God and man, purchased the Church by his bloud which he shed in his man-hood.2 The communicating of the properties, is, to attribute that to the whole person, which is proper unto one nature, and this is attributed in a concrete voyce, not in an abstract: because the concrete voyce signifieth the person in which are both natures, and the property of that nature whereof something is affirmed. But the abstract name signifieth the nature which is in the person, but not the person. And therefore it is, that nothing hindereth, why that which is proper to one nature, may not be affirmed of the whole person, so that property it selfe be in the person: but contrariwise, of the abstract name, only the properties of that nature are affirmed unto which they properly belong.
- 1Mat. 27.46.
- 2What the communicating of properties is.