1Object. 2. In many Churches, which profess true doctrine, this third mark is not seen: Therefore they are no Churches. Ans. 1. There are many in them, who indeed yield and endeavour to yield obedience. 2. All obey, acknowledging by their profession, that sins ought not to be maintained. But it is necessary, that this third mark should be added: because they should mock God,2 who would say that they received this Doctrine of Christ, and would not frame their lives according unto it. Object. 3. But those which all Schismatics and Heretics do challenge unto them, are not the marks of the true Church. But all of them do challenge these unto them: Therefore they are not marks of the true Church. Ans. I deny the Major. For we are not to see whether they challenge them, but whether they have them. So also would it follow, that the heavenly blessings, which are proper to the true Church, are theirs also, because they challenge them. Object. 4. Without which the Church cannot be, that is a mark thereof. But without the ordinary succession of Bishops the Church cannot be: Therefore it is a mark thereof. Ans. By ordinary succession in the ministry, is meant the succession of Ministers, in the same doctrine and administration of Sacraments. And if the proposition be so understood, it is true: for such a succession is nothing else, then those notes which we have put. But in the conclusion of this objection, is understood, that there should be an ordinary succession into the same place, whether they teach the same doctrine, or a diverse from it. And so also it should be a tying of the Church to a certain City, Region, and so forth. But in this sense the Minor and Conclusion are false.
1Object. 2. In many Churches, which professe true doctrine, this third mark is not seene: Therefore they are no Churches. Ans. 1. There are many in them, who indeed yeeld and indeavour to yeeld obedience. 2. All obey, acknowledging by their profession, that sins ought not to be maintained. But it is necessary, that this third mark should be added: because they should mock God,2 who would say that they received this Doctrine of Christ, and would not frame their lives according unto it. Object. 3. But those which all Schismaticks and Hereticks doe challenge unto them, are not the marks of the true Church. But all of them doe challenge these unto them: Therefore they are not marks of the true Church. Ans. I deny the Major. For we are not to see whether they challenge them, but whether they have them. So also would it follow, that the heavenly blessings, which are proper to the true Church, are theirs also, because they challenge them. Object. 4. Without which the Church cannot be, that is a mark thereof. But without the ordinary succession of Bishops the Church cannot be: Therefore it is a mark thereof. Ans. By ordinary succession in the ministery, is meant the succession of Ministers, in the same doctrine and administration of Sacraments. And if the proposition be so understood, it is true: for such a succession is nothing else, then those notes which we have put. But in the conclusion of this objection, is understood, that there should be an ordinary succession into the same place, whether they teach the same doctrine, or a diverse from it. And so also it should be a tying of the Church to a certaine City, Region, and so forth. But in this sense the Minor and Conclusion are false.
- 1Against the third mark.Against the third marke.
- 2Against all the foresaid marks. Not all that challenge these marks are the Church, because all have them not, though they challenge them. The ordinary succession of Bishops no necessary mark of the Church.Against all the foresaid markes. Not all that challenge these marks are the Church, because all have them not, though they challenge them. The ordinary succession of Bishops no necessary mark of the Church.