The Explication.
pp. 347–35225 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 347–35225 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The Questions to be observed: 1. What the Church is. 2. How many ways it is taken. 3. What are the marks thereof. 4. Wherefore it is called one, holy, and Catholic. 5. What is the difference between the Church and Common-weal, or civill State. 6. Whence it is, that the Church differeth from the rest of mankind. 7. Whether any man be saved out of the Church.
The Questions to be observed: 1. What the Church is. 2. How many wayes it is taken. 3. What are the marks thereof. 4. Wherefore it is called one, holy, and Catholike. 5. What is the difference betweene the Church and Common-weale, or civill State. 6. Whence it is, that the Church differeth from the rest of mankind. 7. Whether any man be saved out of the Church.
When the Question is, What the Church is, it is presupposed, that there is a Church; so that it is not necessary to make question, Whether there be a Church: For there was always, and shall be some Church, sometimes greater, sometimes lesser; because Christ always was, and shall remain for ever the King and Head, and Priest of the Church; as hereafter in the fourth Question of this Common-place shall more plentifully be proved. Now, as concerning the name Ecclesia (which we call the Church) it is natively a Greek word,1 and cometh from a word which signifieth, to call forth. For the custom was in Athens, that a company of the Citizens were called forth, by the voice of a Crier, from the rest of the multitude, as it were, namely, and by their hundreds, to an Assembly, wherein some public speech was had, or to hear relation made of some sentence or judgement of the Senate. And thus differeth the word Ecclesia from Synagoga, or Synagogue.2 For Synagoga signifieth any manner of Congregation, be it never so common and inordinate. But Ecclesia betokeneth an ordained Congregation, and such as is called together for some cause. From hence the Apostles translated the name, Ecclesia, to their purpose, terming the Church by it, for resemblance and likeness sake. For the Church is Gods Congregation, neither coming together by chance without cause, nor being inordinate: but called forth by the voice of the Lord, and the cry of the Word, that is, by the Ministers of the Gospel, from the Kingdom of Satan, to hear or embrace Gods word. This Congregation or company of those which are called of God to the knowledge of the Gospel, the Latins, keeping still the Greek word, call Ecclesia. The Dutch word Kyrc (which, by adding letters of aspiration, we call in English Church) seemeth to come from the Greek word [Greek or Hebrew], which signifieth, The Lords house, 3or, Gods house. But it shall be requisite, that we a little more fully define what the Church is. The Church of God is a Congregation, or company of men, chosen from everlasting of God to eternal life, which, from the beginning of the world to the end thereof, 4is gathered of the sons of God out of all mankind by the holy Ghost and the Word, consenting in true faith, and which the Son of God defendeth, preserveth, and at length glorifieth with glory and life everlasting.
WHen the Question is, What the Church is, it is presupposed, that there is a Church; so that it is not necessary to make question, Whether there be a Church: For there was alwayes, and shall be some Church, sometimes greater, sometimes lesser; because Christ alwayes was, and shall remaine for ever the King and Head, and Priest of the Church; as hereafter in the fourth Question of this Common-place shall more plentifully be proved. Now, as concerning the name Ecclesia (which we call the Church) it is natively a Greek word,1 and cometh from a word which signifieth, to call forth. For the custome was in Athens, that a company of the Citizens were called forth, by the voyce of a Crier, from the rest of the multitude, as it were, namely, and by their hundreds, to an Assembly, wherein some publike speech was had, or to heare relation made of some sentence or judgement of the Senate. And thus differeth the word Ecclesia from Synagoga, or Synagogue.2 For Synagoga signifieth any manner of Congregation, be it never so common and inordinate. But Ecclesia betokeneth an ordained Congregation, and such as is called together for some cause. From hence the Apostles translated the name, Ecclesia, to their purpose, terming the Church by it, for resemblance and likenesse sake. For the Church is Gods Congregation, neither coming together by chance without cause, nor being inordinate: but called forth by the voyce of the Lord, and the cry of the Word, that is, by the Ministers of the Gospel, from the Kingdome of Sathan, to heare or imbrace Gods word. This Congregation or company of those which are called of God to the knowledge of the Gospel, the Latines, keeping still the Greek word, call Ecclesia. The Dutch word Kyrc (which, by adding letters of aspiration, we call in English Church) seemeth to come from the Greek word 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, which signifieth, The Lords house, 3or, Gods house. But it shall be requisite, that we a little more fully define what the Church is. The Church of God is a Congregation, or company of men, chosen from everlasting of God to eternall life, which, from the beginning of the world to the end thereof, 4is gathered of the sonnes of God out of all mankind by the holy Ghost and the Word, consenting in true faith, and which the Sonne of God defendeth, preserveth, and at length glorifieth with glory and life everlasting.
Thus is the true Church of God defined, whereof the Creed doth properly speak.
1THE Church is taken either for the true Church, or for the false. The false Church is unproperly called the Church, and is a company, arrogating unto themselves the title of Christs Church, but which do not follow the same, but rather persecute it. The true Church is either Triumphant; 2which even now triumpheth with the blessed Angels in heaven, and shall have their full accomplished ⟨p. 348⟩triumph after the Resurrection:3 or Militant; which in this world fighteth under Christs Banner against the world, the flesh, and the Devil. This Militant Church is either visible or invisible. The visible Church is a company among men, embracing and professing the true and uncorrupt Doctrine of the Law and the Gospel, and using the Sacraments aright, according to Christs institution, and professing obedience unto the Doctrine: in which company are many unregenerated, or hypocrites, consenting notwithstanding and agreeing to the Doctrine: in which also the Son of God is forcible to regenerate some by the virtue of his Spirit unto everlasting life. Or, it is a company of such as consent in the Doctrine they profess, wherein notwithstanding are many dead and unregenerate members.4 Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the Kingdom of heaven. Hither pertain the parables of the Seed and the Tares: likewise, of the Net gathering both good and bad Fish. The invisible Church is a company of those which are elected to eternal life,5 in whom a new life is begun here by the holy Ghost, and is perfected in the life to come. This Church, as long as it warfareth and sojourneth on earth, always lieth hid in the visible Church. It is otherwise called the Church of the Saints. They which are in this invisible Church, never perish; therefore neither are any Hypocrites therein, but the Elect only,6 of whom it is said: No man shall pluck my sheep out of mine hands. The foundation of the Lord remaineth sure, and hath this seal; The Lord knoweth who are is. It is called invisible, not that the men therein are invisible, but because their faith and godliness is invisible, neither is known of any but of themselves, in whom it is; and because we are not able certainly to distinguish or discern in the visible Church the true godly from the Hypocrites.
1THE Church is taken either for the true Church, or for the false. The false Church is unproperly called the Church, and is a company, arrogating unto themselves the title of Christs Church, but which doe not follow the same, but rather persecute it. The true Church is either Triumphant; 2which even now triumpheth with the blessed Angels in heaven, and shall have their full accomplished ⟨p. 348⟩triumph after the Resurrection:3 or Militant; which in this world fighteth under Christs Banner against the world, the flesh, and the Divell. This Militant Church is either visible or invisible. The visible Church is a company among men, imbracing and professing the true and uncorrupt Doctrine of the Law and the Gospel, and using the Sacraments aright, according to Christs institution, and professing obedience unto the Doctrine: in which company are many unregenerated, or hypocrites, consenting notwithstanding and agreeing to the Doctrine: in which also the Son of God is forcible to regenerate some by the vertue of his Spirit unto everlasting life. Or, it is a company of such as consent in the Doctrine they professe, wherein notwithstanding are many dead and unregenerate members.4 Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the Kingdome of heaven. Hither pertain the parables of the Seed and the Tares: likewise, of the Net gathering both good and bad Fish. The invisible Church is a company of those which are elected to eternall life,5 in whom a new life is begun here by the holy Ghost, and is perfected in the life to come. This Church, as long as it warfareth and sojourneth on earth, alwayes lieth hid in the visible Church. It is otherwise called the Church of the Saints. They which are in this invisible Church, never perish; therefore neither are any Hypocrites therein, but the Elect only,6 of whom it is said: No man shall pluck my sheep out of mine hands. The foundation of the Lord remaineth sure, and hath this seale; The Lord knoweth who are is. It is called invisible, not that the men therein are invisible, but because their faith and godlinesse is invisible, neither is known of any but of themselves, in whom it is; and because we are not able certainly to distinguish or discerne in the visible Church the true godly from the Hypocrites.
Moreover, both these parts of the true Church, both visible and invisible, are either universal or particular.1 The universal visible Church is the company of all those which profess the Doctrine, wheresoever in the world they be. The particular visible Church, 2is also a company of those which profess the doctrine, but in some certain place. The visible Church is universal, in respect of the profession of one faith in Christ, and of one Doctrine and worship. But it is particular, in respect of place and habitation,3 and of diversity of rites and customs. So also the invisible Church is universal: as all the Elect, in whatsoever place they be, and whatsoever time they lived, have one faith: again it is particular, as either in this or that place they have the same faith. Now, all particular Churches are parts of the universal: and the visible, are parts of the universal Church visible, as also the invisible are parts of the universal Church invisible. And of this personal visible Church doth the Article or Creed speak properly, I believe the holy Catholic Church. For, besides that the universal invisible Church is Catholic, it is also nobilitated with this title, that it is Holy. Further, in this is the true communion of Saints between Christ and all his members.4 There is almost the same difference between the visible and invisible Church, which is between the whole and part. For the invisible lieth hid in the visible as a part in the whole. Which appeareth out of this place of Paul; Whom the Lord predestinated them also he called. This calling, whereby the Lord calleth us, is of two sorts; inward and outward. The inward Saint Paul saith was wrought according to the purpose of saving men: and the Elect are called by both; Hypocrites are called only by the outward calling. And in respect of this outward calling is the Church called visible, and the Church of the called; where are Hypocrites also. But the invisible is called the Company or Church of the Elect and Chosen. Object. 1. If the whole be visible, the part also is visible. Answ. That part also is visible, as concerning men elected, or as they are men, and as they profess the Doctrine of the visible Church: but it is not visible, as concerning the godliness or faith of men, or as concerning faith and repentance in men. Object. 2.
Moreover, both these parts of the true Church, both visible and invisible, are either universall or particular.1 The universall visible Church is the company of all those which professe the Doctrine, wheresoever in the world they be. The particular visible Church, 2is also a company of those which professe the doctrine, but in some certaine place. The visible Church is universall, in respect of the profession of one faith in Christ, and of one Doctrine and worship. But it is particular, in respect of place and habitation,3 and of diversity of rites and customes. So also the invisible Church is universall: as all the Elect, in whatsoever place they be, and whatsoever time they lived, have one faith: againe it is particular, as either in this or that place they have the same faith. Now, all particular Churches are parts of the universall: and the visible, are parts of the universall Church visible, as also the invisible are parts of the universall Church invisible. And of this personall visible Church doth the Article or Creed speak properly, I beleeve the holy Catholike Church. For, besides that the universall invisible Church is Catholike, it is also nobilitated with this title, that it is Holy. Further, in this is the true communion of Saints between Christ and all his members.4 There is almost the same difference betweene the visible and invisible Church, which is between the whole and part. For the invisible lieth hid in the visible as a part in the whole. Which appeareth out of this place of Paul; Whom the Lord predestinated them also he called. This calling, whereby the Lord calleth us, is of two sorts; inward and outward. The inward Saint Paul saith was wrought according to the purpose of saving men: and the Elect are called by both; Hypocrites are called onely by the outward calling. And in respect of this outward calling is the Church called visible, and the Church of the called; where are Hypocrites also. But the invisible is called the Company or Church of the Elect and Chosen. Object. 1. If the whole be visible, the part also is visible. Answ. That part also is visible, as concerning men elected, or as they are men, and as they professe the Doctrine of the visible Church: but it is not visible, as concerning the godlinesse or faith of men, or as concerning faith and repentance in men. Object. 2.
They which are in the Church, perish not, as the definition of the Church affirmeth: Many Hypocrites are in the Church: Therefore either Hypocrites shall not perish; or it is false, that they which are in the Church perish not, Answ. They which are in the invisible Church perish not; and of this was our definition. But the Minor proposition speaketh of the visible Church, in which are many Hypocrites. Object. 3. Where the invisible Church is not, neither is the visible: ⟨p. 349⟩In the time of Popery was not the invisible: Therefore there was not the visible. Ans. I deny the Minor. For there also were remnants; that is, there were always some mingled with those dregs, who held the foundation, some more purely, some less. In sum, The Church was oppressed, but not extinguished.
They which are in the Church, perish not, as the definition of the Church affirmeth: Many Hypocrites are in the Church: Therefore either Hypocrites shall not perish; or it is false, that they which are in the Church perish not, Answ. They which are in the invisible Church perish not; and of this was our definition. But the Minor proposition speaketh of the visible Church, in which are many Hypocrites. Object. 3. Where the invisible Church is not, neither is the visible: ⟨p. 349⟩In the time of Popery was not the invisible: Therefore there was not the visible. Ans. I deny the Minor. For there also were remnants; that is, there were alwayes some mingled with those dregs, who held the foundation, some more purely, some lesse. In summe, The Church was oppressed, but not extingnished.
1There is also another division of the Church, into the Church of the Old Testament and of the New. The Church of the Old Testament is a company or congregation, embracing the Doctrine of Moses and the Prophets, and making profession, that they will embrace in Jury the Mosaical Ceremonies, and keep them; and as well in Jury, as also out of Jury, embrace the things signified by those Ceremonies: that is, believing the Messiah which was to be exhibited. The Church of the New Testament hath not these differences, because all believe in the Messiah already exhibited. This Church is a company embracing the Doctrine of the Gospel, using the Sacraments instituted by Jesus Christ, and believing in him, being exhibited the true Messiah.
1There is also another division of the Church, into the Church of the Old Testament and of the New. The Church of the Old Testament is a company or congregation, imbracing the Doctrine of Moses and the Prophets, and making profession, that they will imbrace in Jury the Mosaicall Ceremonies, and keep them; and as well in Jury, as also out of Jury, imbrace the things signified by those Ceremonies: that is, beleeving the Messias which was to be exhibited. The Church of the New Testament hath not these differences, because all beleeve in the Messias already exhibited. This Church is a company imbracing the Doctrine of the Gospel, using the Sacraments instituted by Jesus Christ, and beleeving in him, being exhibited the true Messias.
1The marks of the true Church are, Profession of the true, uncorrupt, and rightly understood Doctrine of the Law and Gospel; that is, of the Doctrine of the Prophets and Apostles. There concur withal oftentimes errors; but yet notwithstanding this mark is sure, if the foundation be kept, albeit stubble be builded thereon: yet so, that those errors of stubble be not maintained. §22The right and lawful use of the Sacraments. For amongst other ends of the Sacraments, this is one, that this company of Gods Church may be discerned from all Sect and Heretics. §33Profession of obedience to the Doctrine or Ministry. These three marks of the Church are contained in those words of Christ: Go and teach all Nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and the Son, and the holy Ghost: teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you: And we are to hold and keep these notes and marks, 1. In respect of Gods glory, that enemies may be discerned from sons. 2. In respect of our own salvation, that we may join our selves to the true Church. Object. 1. There were in all ages great errors, both public and private in the Church. 4Ans. 1. But still the foundation was held, on which some built gold, some stubble. 2. Errors are not defended by the Church: and this mark standeth sure, if the foundation be held, though on it stubble be built, so that such errors, and such stubble be not maintained.
1THe marks of the true Church are, Profession of the true, uncorrupt, and rightly understood Doctrine of the Law and Gospel; that is, of the Doctrine of the Prophets and Apostles. There concurre withall oftentimes errours; but yet notwithstanding this mark is sure, if the foundation be kept, albeit stubble be builded thereon: yet so, that those errours of stubble be not maintained. §22The right and lawfull use of the Sacraments. For amongst other ends of the Sacraments, this is one, that this company of Gods Church may be discerned from all Sect and Hereticks. §33Profession of obedience to the Doctrine or Ministery. These three marks of the Church are contained in those words of Christ: Go and teach all Nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and the Sonne, and the holy Ghost: teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you: And we are to hold and keep these notes and marks, 1. In respect of Gods glory, that enemies may be discerned from sons. 2. In respect of our own salvation, that we may joyn our selves to the true Church. Object. 1. There were in all ages great errours, both publike and private in the Church. 4Ans. 1. But still the foundation was held, on which some built gold, some stubble. 2. Errours are not defended by the Church: and this mark standeth sure, if the foundation be held, though on it stubble be built, so that such errours, and such stubble be not maintained.
1Object. 2. In many Churches, which profess true doctrine, this third mark is not seen: Therefore they are no Churches. Ans. 1. There are many in them, who indeed yield and endeavour to yield obedience. 2. All obey, acknowledging by their profession, that sins ought not to be maintained. But it is necessary, that this third mark should be added: because they should mock God,2 who would say that they received this Doctrine of Christ, and would not frame their lives according unto it. Object. 3. But those which all Schismatics and Heretics do challenge unto them, are not the marks of the true Church. But all of them do challenge these unto them: Therefore they are not marks of the true Church. Ans. I deny the Major. For we are not to see whether they challenge them, but whether they have them. So also would it follow, that the heavenly blessings, which are proper to the true Church, are theirs also, because they challenge them. Object. 4. Without which the Church cannot be, that is a mark thereof. But without the ordinary succession of Bishops the Church cannot be: Therefore it is a mark thereof. Ans. By ordinary succession in the ministry, is meant the succession of Ministers, in the same doctrine and administration of Sacraments. And if the proposition be so understood, it is true: for such a succession is nothing else, then those notes which we have put. But in the conclusion of this objection, is understood, that there should be an ordinary succession into the same place, whether they teach the same doctrine, or a diverse from it. And so also it should be a tying of the Church to a certain City, Region, and so forth. But in this sense the Minor and Conclusion are false.
1Object. 2. In many Churches, which professe true doctrine, this third mark is not seene: Therefore they are no Churches. Ans. 1. There are many in them, who indeed yeeld and indeavour to yeeld obedience. 2. All obey, acknowledging by their profession, that sins ought not to be maintained. But it is necessary, that this third mark should be added: because they should mock God,2 who would say that they received this Doctrine of Christ, and would not frame their lives according unto it. Object. 3. But those which all Schismaticks and Hereticks doe challenge unto them, are not the marks of the true Church. But all of them doe challenge these unto them: Therefore they are not marks of the true Church. Ans. I deny the Major. For we are not to see whether they challenge them, but whether they have them. So also would it follow, that the heavenly blessings, which are proper to the true Church, are theirs also, because they challenge them. Object. 4. Without which the Church cannot be, that is a mark thereof. But without the ordinary succession of Bishops the Church cannot be: Therefore it is a mark thereof. Ans. By ordinary succession in the ministery, is meant the succession of Ministers, in the same doctrine and administration of Sacraments. And if the proposition be so understood, it is true: for such a succession is nothing else, then those notes which we have put. But in the conclusion of this objection, is understood, that there should be an ordinary succession into the same place, whether they teach the same doctrine, or a diverse from it. And so also it should be a tying of the Church to a certaine City, Region, and so forth. But in this sense the Minor and Conclusion are false.
1The Church is called one, not in regard of the cohabitation, or the near dwelling of the members thereof, or for their agreement in rites and ceremonies of their Religion; but in respect of their consent in faith and doctrine. It is also called Holy, because it is sanctified of God by the blood and spirit of Christ, that it may be like unto him, not in perfection, but, §12By imputation of righteousness; because Christs holiness and obedience is imputed unto it. §23By inchoation of righteousness; because the holy Ghost doth renew it by little and little, and cleanse it from the filth of sin, that all the members may begin all the parts of obedience. §34Because it is consecrated to an holy and divine use, and therefore sequestered from the rout of wicked ones, who are without the Church. It is called Catholic, 1. In respect of place: because it is spread through the whole world. For there is one universal Church of all places, and degrees of life, neither is it tied to a certain place and kingdom, or to a certain succession. 2. In respect of time: because there is but one true Church of all times, which also is at all times so Catholic, as that it is dispersed through the whole world, neither is it at any time tied to any certain place. 3. In respect of the men, who are members of the same: For the Church is gathered out of all sorts of men, all states, kindreds, and nations. It is not Catholic, because it possesseth many kingdoms: For Catholic is a title given unto the Church in the Apostles time; for before time the Church was limited within narrow bounds. Now, that there is but one Church of all times and ages, 5from the beginning of the world unto the end, it is out of doubt. For, 1. It is manifest, that the Church hath ever been. Neither can Abraham's days be objected, as if before he was called, there had been no worship of the true God in his family, and himself had been after his calling alone without any others. For, before his calling, he held the foundation and grounds of doctrine of the true God, though it were darkened with superstitions mingled therewith. Again, Melchizedek lived at the same time, who was the Priest of the most high God; and therefore neither was Abraham after his calling alone, but there were others besides him, worshippers of the true God, whose Priest was Melchizedek. 2.
1THe Church is called one, not in regard of the cohabitation, or the neere dwelling of the members thereof, or for their agreement in rites and ceremonies of their Religion; but in respect of their consent in faith and doctrine. It is also called Holy, because it is sanctified of God by the bloud and spirit of Christ, that it may be like unto him, not in perfection, but, §12By imputation of righteousnesse; because Christs holinesse and obedience is imputed unto it. §23By inchoation of righteousnesse; because the holy Ghost doth renue it by little and little, and cleanse it from the filth of sin, that all the members may begin all the parts of obedience. §34Because it is consecrated to an holy and divine use, and therefore sequestred from the rout of wicked ones, who are without the Church. It is called Catholike, 1. In respect of place: because it is spread through the whole world. For there is one universall Church of all places, and degrees of life, neither is it tied to a certaine place and kingdome, or to a certaine succession. 2. In respect of time: because there is but one true Church of all times, which also is at all times so Catholike, as that it is dispersed through the whole world, neither is it at any time tied to any certaine place. 3. In respect of the men, who are members of the same: For the Church is gathered out of all sorts of men, all states, kindreds, and nations. It is not Catholike, because it possesseth many kingdomes: For Catholike is a title given unto the Church in the Apostles time; for before time the Church was limited within narrow bounds. Now, that there is but one Church of all times and ages, 5from the beginning of the world unto the end, it is out of doubt. For, 1. It is manifest, that the Church hath ever beene. Neither can Abrahams daies be objected, as if before he was called, there had been no worship of the true God in his family, and himselfe had beene after his calling alone without any others. For, before his calling, he held the foundation and grounds of doctrine of the true God, though it were darkned with superstitions mingled therewith. Againe, Melchisedech lived at the same time, who was the Priest of the most high God; and therefore neither was Abraham after his calling alone, but there were others besides him, worshippers of the true God, whose Priest was Melchisedech. 2.
That the Church, as it hath been ever, so shall it also continue ever, appeareth by these testimonies: My words shall not depart out of thy mouth, nor out of the mouth of thy seed. If the night and day may be changed, 1then shall my Covenant also be changed. I am with you always unto the end of the world. 2Moreover, Christ was ever, and ever shall be King, Head, and Priest of the Church. Wherefore the Church was ever, and ever shall be. And hence also it is manifest, That the Church of both Testaments, is one and the same: that which is confirmed also by the article following. For Christ is the sanctifier of his Church, who is common to men of both Testaments.
That the Church, as it hath beene ever, so shall it also continue ever, appeareth by these testimonies: My words shall not depart out of thy mouth, nor out of the mouth of thy seed. If the night and day may be changed, 1then shall my Covenant also be changed. I am with you alwayes unto the end of the world. 2Moreover, Christ was ever, and ever shall be King, Head, and Priest of the Church. Wherefore the Church was ever, and ever shall be. And hence also it is manifest, That the Church of both Testaments, is one and the same: that which is confirmed also by the article following. For Christ is the sanctifier of his Church, who is common to men of both Testaments.
Hitherto appertaineth the question of the authority of the Church. The Papists maintain, that the authority of the Church is greater then the authority of the Scripture. But this is false: For the Church made not the Scripture, but the Scripture made the Church. They urge S. Augustine his testimony. S. Augustine against Manichaeus his Epistle, cap. 5. showeth how he was brought to the faith of the Catholic Church. For he saith, That he obeyed the Catholics, when they said, Believe the Gospel: and there he bringeth forth that common saying, I would not believe the Gospel, except the authority of the Catholic Church moved me thereunto. By the testimony therefore of the Church he was moved to read the Gospel, and to believe, that heavenly doctrine was contained therein. But doth he, after he believed the Gospel, promise that he would believe the Church more then the Gospel, if the Church determine or propound any thing, which is either contrary to the Gospel, or can be proved by no testimony of Scripture? This doubtless Augustine never meant. Nay, elsewhere he denounceth Anathema, and biddeth a curse to come to them, who declare any thing besides that that we have received in the writings of the Law and Gospel. And in the self-same place he witnesseth, That he, because he believeth the Gospel, cannot believe Manichaeus, for that he readeth nothing in the Gospel of Manichaeus Apostleship: ⟨p. 351⟩Therefore traditions or ordinances of the Church bring us unto the Scripture, and tie us to that voice, which soundeth in the Scripture.
Hitherto appertaineth the question of the authority of the Church. The Papists maintaine, that the authority of the Church is greater then the authority of the Scripture. But this is false: For the Church made not the Scripture, but the Scripture made the Church. They urge S. Augustine his testimony. S. Augustine against Manichaeus his Epistle, cap. 5. sheweth how he was brought to the faith of the Catholike Church. For he saith, That he obeyed the Catholikes, when they said, Beleeve the Gospel: and there he bringeth forth that common saying, I would not beleeve the Gospel, except the authority of the Catholike Church moved me thereunto. By the testimony therefore of the Church he was moved to read the Gospel, and to beleeve, that heavenly doctrine was contained therein. But doth he, after he beleeved the Gospel, promise that he would beleeve the Church more then the Gospel, if the Church determine or propound any thing, which is either contrary to the Gospel, or can be proved by no testimony of Scripture? This doubtlesse Augustine never meant. Nay, elswhere he denounceth Anathema, and biddeth a curse to come to them, who declare any thing besides that that we have received in the writings of the Law and Gospel. And in the selfe-same place he witnesseth, That he, because he beleeveth the Gospel, cannot beleeve Manichaeus, for that he readeth nothing in the Gospel of Manichaeus Apostleship: ⟨p. 351⟩Therefore traditions or ordinances of the Church bring us unto the Scripture, and tie us to that voice, which soundeth in the Scripture.
1But here it must be observed, how honestly and fairly the Papists deal. For wheresoever they meet with the word, Tradition, that by and by they wrest to their traditions, which cannot be proved out of the Word of God: as when Paul saith, I delivered unto you that which I received; Straight-ways they cry out, Hear you traditions? I hear; but read on there in the words following, Paul himself by writing declaring what those traditions are: I delivered unto you, how that Christ died for our sins, according to the Scripture. And that he was buried, and that he arose the third day, according to the Scripture. Here you hear Pauls traditions to be double things written: For first, they were taken out of the Scripture of the Old Testament. Secondly, they were committed to writing by Saint Paul himself. So Paul saith of the Lords Supper, I have received of the Lord, that which I have delivered unto you. 2But this traditions, after the Evangelists, himself also hath set down in writing.3 The Jesuits cite the saying of Paul, Withdraw your selves from every brother that walketh inordinately, and not after the traditions which ye received of us. But a little after, in the same Chapter he describeth what tradition he meaneth, as it is manifest to him that looketh on the place. And yet will they thence prove, that many things are to be believed, which cannot be proved by any testimony of Scripture. The like impudency they show in another testimony taken our of Luke. 4They delivered them the decrees to keep, ordained of the Apostles and Elders, which were at Jerusalem: 5When a little before he witnesseth, that those decrees were set down in letters written by the Apostles.
1But here it must be observed, how honestly and fairly the Papists deale. For wheresoever they meet with the word, Tradition, that by and by they wrest to their traditions, which cannot be proved out of the Word of God: as when Paul saith, I delivered unto you that which I received; Straight-wayes they cry out, Heare you traditions? I hear; but read on there in the words following, Paul himself by writing declaring what those traditions are: I delivered unto you, how that Christ died for our sinnes, according to the Scripture. And that he was buried, and that he arose the third day, according to the Scripture. Here you heare Pauls traditions to be double things written: For first, they were taken out of the Scripture of the Old Testament. Secondly, they were committed to writing by Saint Paul himselfe. So Paul saith of the Lords Supper, I have received of the Lord, that which I have delivered unto you. 2But this traditions, after the Evangelists, himself also hath set downe in writing.3 The Jesuites cite the saying of Paul, Withdraw your selves from every brother that walketh inordinately, and not after the traditions which yee received of us. But a little after, in the same Chapter he describeth what tradition he meaneth, as it is manifest to him that looketh on the place. And yet will they thence prove, that many things are to be beleeved, which cannot be proved by any testimony of Scripture. The like impudency they shew in another testimony taken our of Luke. 4They delivered them the decrees to keep, ordained of the Apostles and Elders, which were at Jerusalem: 5When a little before he witnesseth, that those decrees were set downe in letters written by the Apostles.
1That opinion, or saying of the Papists, The Church doth not err, is true after this sort: 1. The whole doth not err, though some members thereof do err. 2. It doth not err universally, although in some points of doctrine it may. 3. It erreth not in the foundation.
1That opinion, or saying of the Papists, The Church doth not erre, is true after this sort: 1. The whole doth not erre, though some members thereof doe erre. 2. It doth not erre universally, although in some points of doctrine it may. 3. It erreth not in the foundation.
1The Church differeth from the Common-weal: §11. Because Common-weals are distinct, and Kingdoms of the world, are in divers places and times: The Church is always one and the same at all times, and with all men. §22. The Kingdoms and States of the world have many heads, or one chief Head, and many other inferior heads besides, and that on earth: The Church hath but one, and that in heaven. §33. The Common-wealth is governed by certain Laws made for the maintenance of outward peace and tranquillity: The Church is ruled by the holy Ghost and the Word of God. §44. The Common-wealth or civill State requireth outward obedience only: The Church requireth both, as well inward obedience as outward. §55. In civill States and Common-wealths there is power and liberty to make new Laws positive by the authority of the Magistrate, the violating of which Laws bindeth mens consciences, and deserveth corporal punishments: The Church is tied to the Word of God, to which it is not lawful to add ought, or to detract ought from it. §66. The civill State hath corporal power, wherewith it is armed against the obstinate and disobedient; for he may, and ought by force to curb these, and to punish them by the sword: The Church punisheth by denouncing Gods wrath out of the Word of God. §77. In the Church are always some elect and holy; but not always in the Common-wealth.
1THe Church differeth from the Common-weale: §11. Because Common-weales are distinct, and Kingdomes of the world, are in divers places and times: The Church is alwayes one and the same at all times, and with all men. §22. The Kingdoms and States of the world have many heads, or one chiefe Head, and many other inferiour heads besides, and that on earth: The Church hath but one, and that in heaven. §33. The Common-wealth is governed by certaine Lawes made for the maintenance of outward peace and tranquillity: The Church is ruled by the holy Ghost and the Word of God. §44. The Common-wealth or civill State requireth outward obedience onely: The Church requireth both, as well inward obedience as outward. §55. In civill States and Common-wealths there is power and liberty to make new Lawes positive by the authority of the Magistrate, the violating of which Lawes bindeth mens consciences, and deserveth corporal punishments: The Church is tied to the Word of God, to which it is not lawfull to adde ought, or to detract ought from it. §66. The civill State hath corporall power, wherewith it is armed against the obstinate and disobedient; for he may, and ought by force to curb these, and to punish them by the sword: The Church punisheth by denouncing Gods wrath out of the Word of God. §77. In the Church are alwayes some elect and holy; but not alwayes in the Common-wealth.
1There are three sorts of men very much different one from another: For, §11. Some men are even in profession estranged and aliens from the Church; as who deny faith and repentance: and therefore are open enemies of God and the Church. §22. Others are called, but not effectually; which are Hypocrites, who profess indeed the faith, but without any true conversion unto God. §33. Others are called effectually; ⟨p. 352⟩which are the elect, who are but a little portion, according to that of Christ: Many are called, 2but few are chosen. Now the difference being known, let us in a word see what is the cause of this difference. 1. The efficient cause of this difference is the Election of God, willing to gather unto himself a Church in earth. 2. The Son of God is the mediate executor of this his will and purpose, the holy Ghost the immediate.3 3. The word of God is the instrumental cause: In times past God suffered all the Gentiles to walk in their own ways. God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardeneth. All that the Father giveth me, shall come to me. Those which he knew before, he also predestinate to be made like to the Image of his Son: and whom he predestinate, them also he called, &c. By these words we are taught, that the promise of grace is general in respect of the Elect, or Believers. God verily would have all to be saved; and that, 1. In respect that he loveth the salvation of all: But the Elect only have attained to that salvation. 2. In respect that he inviteth all to salvation: But the rest have been hardened.4
1THere are three sorts of men very much different one from another: For, §11. Some men are even in profession estranged and alients from the Church; as who deny faith and repentance: and therefore are open enemies of God and the Church. §22. Others are called, but not effectually; which are Hypocrites, who professe indeed the faith, but without any true conversion unto God. §33. Others are called effectually; ⟨p. 352⟩which are the elect, who are but a little portion, according to that of Christ: Many are called, 2but few are chosen. Now the difference being known, let us in a word see what is the cause of this difference. 1. The efficient cause of this difference is the Election of God, willing to gather unto himselfe a Church in earth. 2. The Sonne of God is the mediate executor of this his will and purpose, the holy Ghost the immediate.3 3. The word of God is the instrumentall cause: In times past God suffered all the Gentiles to walk in their owne wayes. God hath mercy on whom he will, and whom he will he hardneth. All that the Father giveth me, shall come to me. Those which he knew before, he also predestinate to be made like to the Image of his Sonne: and whom he predestinate, them also he called, &c. By these words we are taught, that the promise of grace is generall in respect of the Elect, or Beleevers. God verily would have all to be saved; and that, 1. In respect that he loveth the salvation of all: But the Elect onely have attained to that salvation. 2. In respect that he inviteth all to salvation: But the rest have beene hardened.4
NO man can be saved out of the Church;1 Because without the Church there is no Saviour; therefore no salvation also. Without me you can do nothing. 2. Because whomsoever God hath chosen and elected to the end, which is eternal life, them he hath chosen to the means; which is the inward and outward calling. The elect therefore, though they be not at all times members of the visible Church, yet they are all made such before they die. Object. Therefore election is not free. Answ. It is free, because God chose freely, both to the end, and to the means. But after he hath once destined and ordained men to means, he never changeth: We here also are to hold against the Anabaptists, that Infants, which are borne in the Church, are also of the Church.
NO man can be saved out of the Church;1 Because without the Church there is no Saviour; therefore no salvation also. Without me you can doe nothing. 2. Because whomsoever God hath chosen and elected to the end, which is eternall life, them he hath chosen to the meanes; which is the inward and outward calling. The elect therefore, though they be not at all times members of the visible Church, yet they are all made such before they die. Object. Therefore election is not free. Answ. It is free, because God chose freely, both to the end, and to the meanes. But after he hath once destined and ordained men to meanes, he never changeth: We here also are to hold against the Anabaptists, that Infants, which are borne in the Church, are also of the Church.