Object. 8. S. James saith, Ye see then, how that of works a man is justified, and not of faith only: Therefore faith only justifieth not. 1Ans. There is a double ambiguity in the words: and first in the word justified. For S. Jam. speaketh not of that justice whereby we are justified before God; that is, whereby we are reputed of God just for unjust: but he speaketh of that justice, whereby through our works we are justified before men; that is, are approved just, or are found to be justified. This is proved, 1. Out of the 18. verse; Show me thy faith by thy works, and I will show thee my faith by my works. Show it me (saith he) to wit, who am a man. Wherefore, he speaketh of manifesting our faith and righteousness before men. 2. Out of the 21. verse; Was not Abraham our Father justified through works, when he offered his Son upon the altar? 2This cannot be understood of justification before God. For the story testifieth that Abraham was reputed just by God, long before the offering of his Son. And Paul saith: Abraham was justified before God, not by works, but by faith. S. James his meaning is, that Abraham was justified before God, because it is written: Abraham believed God, and it was imputed to him for righteousness: 3but by good works and obedience towards God, he witnessed his justice before men. This is the first ambiguity in the word justified. The second ambiguity is in the word faith: For S. James, when he taketh away justification of faith, speaketh not of a true or lively faith, as Paul doth; but of a dead faith, which is a bare knowledge without confidence or works. This appeareth in those words: Even so faith, if it have not works, is dead in it self: and such faith he ascribeth to devils, who, questionless, have not true justifying faith. Lastly, in the 16. ver. he compareth that faith which he denieth to justify, with a dead body: but such is not true and justifying faith. The sum of all is: If the word justified in this text of James be understood properly of justification before God, then the name of faith there signifieth a dead faith: If faith be taken for true justifying faith, then the ambiguity rests in the word justified.
Object. 8. S. James saith, Yee see then, how that of works a man is justified, and not of faith only: Therefore faith only justifieth not. 1Ans. There is a double ambiguity in the words: and first in the word justified. For S. Jam. speaketh not of that justice whereby we are justified before God; that is, whereby we are reputed of God just for unjust: but he speaketh of that justice, whereby through our works we are justifed before men; that is, are approved just, or are found to be justified. This is proved, 1. Out of the 18. verse; Shew me thy faith by thy works, and I will shew thee my faith by my workes. Shew it me (saith he) to wit, who am a man. Wherefore, hee speaketh of manifesting our faith and righteousnesse before men. 2. Out of the 21. verse; Was not Abraham our Father justified through works, when he offered his Son upon the altar? 2This cannot be understood of justification before God. For the story testifieth that Abraham was reputed just by God, long before the offering of his Son. And Paul saith: Abraham was justified before God, not by works, but by faith. S. James his meaning is, that Abraham was justified before God, because it is written: Abraham beleeved God, and it was imputed to him for righteousnesse: 3but by good works and obedience towards God, he witnessed his justice before men. This is the first ambiguity in the word justified. The second ambiguity is in the word faith: For S. James, when he taketh away justification of faith, speaketh not of a true or lively faith, as Paul doth; but of a dead faith, which is a bare knowledge without confidence or works. This appeareth in those words: Even so faith, if it have not works, is dead in it self: and such faith he ascribeth to divels, who, questionlesse, have not true justifying faith. Lastly, in the 16. ver. he compareth that faith which he denieth to justifie, with a dead body: but such is not true and justifying faith. The summe of all is: If the word justified in this text of James be understood properly of justification before God, then the name of faith there signifieth a dead faith: If faith be taken for true justifying faith, then the ambiguity rests in the word justified.
- 1James 2.24.
- 2Gen. 15.60
- 3Rom 4.1, 2. Gen. 15, 6.