OF THE LORDS SUPPER.
pp. 426–498279 passagespart 3 of 7
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 426–498279 passagespart 3 of 7
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
6. The conceit of a corporal presence and feeding on Christs flesh under the bread, is wholly different and diverse from the formal consideration of a Sacrament: Therefore it is to be rejected. The Antecedent is proved; because it cannot be accounted either for the sign, or the thing signified, of which two every Sacrament wholly consisteth. It is not the sign or sacrament, because it is not object to the senses; and if it were, there is nothing which it might signify. And further, it hath no proportion or similitude with the thing; that is, with the spiritual eating. Neither can it be said to be the thing signified, seeing the Scripture no where speaketh of an essential transfusion, and real commixtion of Christs flesh with our bodies, neither can there be any, except we entertain the follies and dreams of Eutychians and Schwenkfeldians: For the sacraments testify of those blessings only, and them only do they seal unto us, which are contained in the promise of the Gospel. Again, it is not the thing signified; because this eating may be without faith, and is common to the godly and ungodly: But the things signified in the sacraments are ⟨p. 441⟩received by faith alone, and of the faithful and godly alone. Besides, if it were the thing signified, none had ever been said, or at any time should have been saved without it. For, in all Sacraments the things signified are the same, and are given to all that are to be saved; because they are the benefits of the Messiah, comprehended in the promise of the Gospel: which benefits are the same unto all, and without them no man is saved: Therefore no place is left for a substantial presence, and mouthy eating of Christs body under the bread, or under the form of bread; and this substantial presence, and mouthy eating, is indeed nothing but a vain name, and Idol in the world. Object. The corporal eating is a sign of the spiritual eating, and a singular confirmation of faith: Therefore Christs body is also a Sacrament or sign; and invisible grace is the thing signified. Answ. The Antecedent is denied: 1. Because Christs flesh under the bread is invisible: Therefore it cannot signify another invisible thing, or strengthen faith. For Sacraments or signs ought to be visible; so that it deserveth not (saith Erasmus) to be called a Sacrament, which is not accomplished by an external sign.
6. The conceit of a corporall presence and feeding on Christs flesh under the bread, is wholly different and diverse from the formall consideration of a Sacrament: Therefore it is to be rejected. The Antecedent is proved; because it cannot be accounted either for the signe, or the thing signified, of which two every Sacrament wholly consisteth. It is not the signe or sacrament, because it is not object to the senses; and if it were, there is nothing which it might signifie. And further, it hath no proportion or similitude with the thing; that is, with the spirituall eating. Neither can it be said to be the thing signified, seeing the Scripture no where speaketh of an essentiall transfusion, and reall commixtion of Christs flesh with our bodies, neither can there be any, except wee entertain the follies and dreams of Eutychians and Swenckfeldians: For the sacraments testifie of those blessings only, and them onely doe they seale unto us, which are contained in the promise of the Gospel. Againe, it is not the thing signified; because this eating may be without faith, and is common to the godly and ungodly: But the things signified in the sacraments are ⟨p. 441⟩received by faith alone, and of the faithfull and godly alone. Besides, if it were the thing signified, none had ever beene sayed, or at any time should have beene saved without it. For, in all Sacraments the things signified are the same, and are given to all that are to be saved; because they are the benefits of the Messias, comprehended in the promise of the Gospel: which benefits are the same unto all, and without them no man is saved: Therefore no place is left for a substantiall presence, and mouthy eating of Christs body under the bread, or under the forme of bread; and this substantiall presence, and mouthy eating, is indeed nothing but a vaine name, and Idoll in the world. Object. The corporall eating is a signe of the spirituall eating, and a singular confirmation of faith: Therefore Christs body is also a Sacrament or signe; and invisible grace is the thing signified. Answ. The Antecedent is denied: 1. Because Christs flesh under the bread is invisible: Therefore it cannot signifie another invisible thing, or strengthen faith. For Sacraments or signes ought to be visible; so that it deserveth not (saith Erasmus) to be called a Sacrament, which is not accomplished by an externall signe.
For to this end and use are they given of God, that they may (as it were) effectually show to our outward senses, that which is promised in the Word, and performed by the holy Ghost in our hearts, that they may be visible testimonies and pledges of the promise of grace exhibited and applied. Whence is that saying of Augustine: a Sacrament is a visible word: And,1 it is a visible form of invisible grace. And, A sign is a thing besides that form which it presenteth to our senses, causing something else by it self to come into the knowledge. And, the signs indeed of divine things are visible, but the things themselves are invisible. And that of Prosper; The sacrifice of the Church consisteth in two things: in the visible form of elements, and the invisible flesh and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ: in the Sacrament or sign, and in the thing of the Sacrament; that is, the body of Christ. Therefore no thing or action which is invisible, insensible, and not natural, can make the nature or appellation of a Sacrament. And consequently they, who will have Christs flesh in, under, or with the bread to be a Sacrament, or will have the bread to be transubstantiated into his flesh, let them show us a visible or sensible eating of it in the Supper, lest they seem to dissent from the ancient Fathers. 2. There must be an analogy and proportion between the sign or Sacrament, and the thing signified, or the thing of the Sacrament. For, Except the Sacraments (saith Augustine) had some similitude of those things, whereof they are Sacraments, they were not verily and Sacraments. Now,2 if Christ flesh be also a Sacrament, and the thing of those Sacraments be invisible grace; what proportion then and similitude shall there be between the two Sacraments? but seeing there can be none, it followeth, that Christs flesh may not be called a Sacrament; as being no less the thing it self of the Sacrament, then eternal salvation signified, by way of proportion, by visible bread, as by a sign. Wherefore the sacramental eating, which is done naturally by the mouth, doth not belong unto the body of Christ, considered by it self, in any physical or natural respect: because unto this sacramental eating the external signs only are object in their own nature. S. Augustine demanding how bread is the body of Christ, and wine his blood:
For to this end and use are they given of God, that they may (as it were) effectually shew to our outward senses, that which is promised in the Word, and performed by the holy Ghost in our hearts, that they may be visible testimonies and pledges of the promise of grace exhibited and applyed. Whence is that saying of Austine: a Sacrament is a visible word: And,
These (saith he) brethren, are therefore called Sacraments: because in them one thing is seen, and another thing understood. That which is seen, 1hath a corporal form; that which is understood, hath a spiritual fruit. If then thou wilt understand the body of Christ, here the Apostle speaketh to the faithful, Ye are the body of Christ and his members. If then ye be the body of Christ, and his members, your mystery is set on the table, &c.
These (saith he) brethren, are therefore called Sacraments: because in them one thing is seene, and another thing understood. That which is seene, 1hath a corporall forme; that which is understood, hath a spirituall fruit. If then thou wilt understand the body of Christ, here the Apostle speaketh to the faithfull, Yee ar the body of Christ and his members. If then yee be the body of Christ, and his members, your mystery is set on the table, &c.
7. The communion of Christ, which is promised in his Word, and sealed in his Sacraments, is not corporal, but spiritual. But the communion of Christ, which is given in the Supper, is the same with that which is promised in the Word and sealed in all other Sacraments: Therefore the communion of Christ in the Supper, is not corporal, but spiritual. The Major is manifest. For, in the Gospel, no other communion is delivered or specified, but that which is spiritual. The Minor also is evident, because the same benefits are proposed in all the promises of the Gospel, which are presented and offered in the Sacraments. For the Sacraments are the visible ⟨p. 442⟩word; because they promise that which the Word promiseth, by visible signs, and are seals of the promise of the same grace.
7. The communion of Christ, which is promised in his Word, and sealed in his Sacraments, is not corporall, but spirituall. But the communion of Christ, which is given in the Supper, is the same with that which is promised in the Word and sealed in all other Sacraments: Therefore the communion of Christ in the Supper, is not corporall, but spirituall. The Major is manifest. For, in the Gospel, no other communion is delivered or specified, but that which is spirituall. The Minor also is evident, because the same benefits are proposed in all the promises of the Gospel, which are presented and offered in the Sacraments. For the Sacraments are the visible ⟨p. 442⟩word; because they promise that which the Word promiseth, by visible signes, and are seales of the promise of the same grace.
8. There is one and the same signification of all the Sacraments of the Old and New Testament; and in them, one and the same communion of Christ. But the signification of all other Sacraments, and their communion is spiritual only: Therefore there is no other in the Supper. The Minor is granted on all sides. The Major is demonstrated by the Apostle in these words;1 By one spirit we are all baptized into one body: And, All were baptized unto Moses in the cloud and in the sea, and did all cate the same spiritual meat. Object. There is not the same thing signified of all Sacraments. For, in Baptism, the thing is, The washing by the blood of Christ; in the Supper, The body and blood of Christ. Ans. The thing is not diverse: because it is the same, To be washed by the blood of Christ, and, To drink the blood of Christ: as we have heretofore proved. But the manner of the signifying one and the same thing is diverse: that is, there is a diverse similitude of one and the same thing signified by the signs, or one and the same thing hath a diverse similitude or proportion: Therefore, as in Baptism, so in Circumcision likewise and the Passover, is promised a spiritual thing, not a corporal; and so also here in the Lord's Supper.
8. There is one and the same signification of all the Sacraments of the Old and New Testament; and in them, one and the same communion of Christ. But the signification of all other Sacraments, and their communion is spirituall onely: Therefore there is no other in the Supper. The Minor is granted on all sides. The Major is demonstrated by the Apostle in these words;1 By one spirit we are all baptized into one body: And, All were baptized unto Moses in the cloud and in the sea, and did all cate the same spirituall meate. Object. There is not the same thing signified of all Sacraments. For, in Baptisme, the thing is, The washing by the bloud of Christ; in the Supper, The body and bloud of Christ. Ans. The thing is not diverse: because it is the same, To be washed by the bloud of Christ, and, To drink the bloud of Christ: as we have heretofore proved. But the manner of the signifying one and the same thing is diverse: that is, there is a diverse similitude of one and the same thing signified by the signes, or one and the same thing hath a diverse similitude or proportion: Therefore, as in Baptisme, so in Circumcision likewise and the Passeover, is promised a spirituall thing, not a corporall; and so also here in the Lors Supper.
1. Firm and strong reasons are drawn from the Article, which is concerning the truth of Christs humane nature. Christ took a humane nature, like unto us in all things, sin only excepted, and retaineth the same through all eternity, for our comfort and safety: but humane nature is neither infinite, neither can it be in moe places at once, nor visible and invisible both together. For, it is proper unto the Deity only, which is unmeasurable, to be essentially in many, or in all places at once, according to that saying of Scripture:1 Am not I he which fill heaven and earth? and by this very attribute or property God is distinguished from all creatures. Now, the God-head it self cannot at the same time be both visible and invisible, finite, and infinite, but in its own substance remaineth always invisible, incomprehensible and infinite, else could it not be unchangeable. We may not therefore imagine, that when Christ said, This is my body, his body then sate both visible to them at the Table, and yet was invisible also in the bread: or that now it is both visibly conversant in heaven, and invisibly contained in the bread.
1. FIrme and strong reasons are drawne from the Article, which is concerning the truth of Christs humane nature. Christ took a humane nature, like unto us in all things, sinne only excepted, and retaineth the same through all eternity, for our comfort and safety: but humane nature is neither infinite, neither can it be in moe places at once, nor visible and invisible both together. For, it is proper unto the Deity only, which is unmeasurable, to be essentially in many, or in all places at once, according to that saying of Scripture:1 Am not I he which fill heaven and earth? and by this very attribute or property God is distinguished from all creatures. Now, the God-head it selfe cannot at the same time be both visible and invisible, finite, and infinite, but in its own substance remaineth alwayes invisible, incomprehensible and infinite, else could it not be unchangeable. We may not therefore imagine, that when Christ said, This is my body, his body then sate both visible to them at the Table, and yet was invisible also in the bread: or that now it is both visibly conversant in heaven, and invisibly contained in the bread.
2. From the Article of Ascension: Christ ascended truly; that is, was in his body visibly and locally taken up into heaven, so that his body remained not, nor now remaineth on earth, but in heaven, whence he shall visibly return to judgement. He is not therefore in the bread. Or thus we may urge the reason: Christs body is finite, as being a true body. But it is now in heaven: Therefore Christs body is not in While they beheld him, he was taken up. 1Seek the things which are above, where Christ is. The Major also is evident. For if the true and very body of Christ be infinite, it is on earth, was no true body of Christ, but apparent and fantastical: because it cannot agree, no not to the God-head it self, to be at one time finite and infinite, sensible and insensible: and so all those things which are spoken of Christ in the Articles of our Belief, should not have been done indeed, but only should have seemed and appeared to be done; and so we should as yet remain in death. Now here are two things to be noted: 1. That by the argument drawn from the ascension, Christs body is not clean taken out of the Supper, as some cavil, but only out of the bread. For the distance of heaven and earth only hindereth the existence of Christs body, both in heaven and in the bread together, but not his presence in the Supper to be spiritual eaten by faith. For our faith in the word of the promise, annexed to the bread and wine, beholdeth and embraceth the body and blood of Christ, and all his benefits there present. 2. That the Argument of the Ascension (not done, but together with the former ⟨p. 443⟩Argument of the truth of his humane nature) overthroweth the opinion of a corporal presence of Christ in the bread. For if Christs humane nature might be every-where, or present in many places; his Ascension could not hinder, but that he might at once be both in heaven and in the bread. But whereas the humane nature is finite, not present in many places, nor every-where: hence it is, that the Argument, borrowed from the Article of his Ascension, presseth most powerfully; and, as in the first Supper, the consequence derived from the property of his humane nature thus; Christs body sits at the Table, Therefore it is not in the bread, or in the mouth of his Disciples, is sound and good: so now we necessarily conclude out of the truth of his Ascension thus;
2. From the Article of Ascension: Christ ascended truly; that is, was in his body visibly and locally taken up into heaven, so that his body remained not, nrr now remaineth on earth, but in heaven, whence he shall visibly returne to judgement. He is not therefore in the bread. Or thus we may urge the reason: Christs body is finite, as being a true body. But it is now in heaven: Therefore Christs body is not in While they beheld him, he was taken up.
Christs body is in heaven, Therefore it is not in the bread, or elsewhere on earth. Object. It is humane reason alone that judgeth Christs corporal presence in the bread contrary to these Articles of faith: Therefore they are not indeed contrary. Answ. We deny the Antecedent. For not reason only, but the Christian faith, and Gods Word reacheth us, that Christs body is a true humane and finite body, and not conversant at once in all, or many places; and that now, since it ascended into heaven, it is not in the earth, but remaineth and abideth in heaven, until he return thence to judge the quick and the dead. That Christs body then should be present at once in heaven and in the bread, is repugnant not to humane reason only, but also to Gods Word. This indeed is a principle uncontroversed,1 That mans reason in divine matters, oppugning Gods Word, is not to be regarded, but ought to be subject thereunto. Notwithstanding, it is not simply to be cashiered or discharged, no not in controversies of Divinity, as if we were to bring a mere brutish and blockish sense to the sifting of the truth of Gods Word: but we are to use reason aright, to discern thereby truth from falsehood. For to this end was reason given to us men, that we should discern by the light of understanding contradictory opinions; and fully conceiving what is consonant with Gods Word, and what jarreth therewith, should applaud and embrace the one, and reject the other. If this be not grounded and settled in us, there will be no opinion so absurd and impious, there will be nothing in the polluted sinks of all Heretics so filthy and monstrous, which may be confuted by holy Scripture. For Heretics and Deceivers will always except against us, that their opinions impugn not the truth of Gods Word, but that they seem only in mans reason so to do. Repl. The Scripture attributeth to Christs body many properties and prerogatives supernatural, or above and beyond nature, which are not incident to our bodies: as, to walk on the waters, to be transfigured, to be carried up into heaven, to pierce and pass through a stone and closed doors, to be united to the God-head personally, to be made a sacrifice for our sins, &c. Therefore it is no absurdity to attribute unto it presence in heaven and in the bread both at once, or even ubiquity it self. Ans.
Christs body is in heaven, Therefore it is not in the bread, or elsewhere on earth. Object. It is humane reason alone that judgeth Christs corporall presence in the bread contrary to these Articles of faith: Therefore they are not indeed contrary. Answ. We deny the Antecedent. For not reason onely, but the Christian faith, and Gods Word reacheth us, that Christs body is a true humane and finite body, and not conversant at once in all, or many places; and that now, since it ascended into heaven, it is not in the earth, but remaineth and abideth in heaven, untill he returne thence to judge the quick and the dead. That Christs body then should be present at once in heaven and in the bread, is repugnant not to humane reason only, but also to Gods Word. This indeed is a principle uncontroversed,
In the Antecedent are many untruths mingled with some truths. For the penetration of Christs body through the stone, and through the doors, is no where expressed in Scripture: and therefore we deny it. The rest of the prerogatives are there expressed indeed, but they abrogate not the truth of humane nature. For Peter also walked on the waters; and we shall be transformed, and lifted up: but ubiquity and presence of Christs flesh in all, or many places, is no where extant in Scripture, and it suffereth not Christs flesh to be any longer a creature, much less a true body. For, to be every-where, or in divers places at once in its own substance, is the property of the unmeasurable Deity alone: but every creature is finite,1 and by his finiteness is discerned from his Creator. Now that which is finite, cannot be in moe places then one. Hence it is, that the Scripture and and Doctors of the ancient Church produce this property of presence in many places, as a certain argument of true and sole Divinity: as Christ himself, speaking of himself, saith: The Son of man, 2which is in heaven. And Dydimus saith: The holy Ghost himself, if he were a creature, 3should at least have a circumscribed or limited substance, as all things else which are made: For although the invisible creatures be not circumscribed in place; yet they are finite in the property of their substance. But the holy Ghost being in many, hath no circumscribed or limited substance. Tertullian also saith: If Christ be man only, 4how then is he present wheresoever he is called on? sith this is not the nature of man, but of God, To be present in every ⟨p. 444⟩place. Our adversaries therefore thus reasoning, that those prerogatives are the cause of his presence every-where, or in many places, which verily are no causes hereof, commit the fallacy of alleging a false cause. For indeed the reason of those prerogatives, and the ubiquity, are very diverse.
In the Antecedent are many untruths mingled with some truths. For the penetration of Christs body through the stone, and through the doores, is no where expressed in Scripture: and therefore we deny it. The rest of the prerogatives are there expressed indeed, but they abrogate not the truth of humane nature. For Peter also walked on the waters; and we shall be transformed, and lifted up: but ubiquity and presence of Christs flesh in all, or many places, is no where extant in Scripture, and it suffereth not Christs flesh to be any longer a creature, much lesse a true body. For, to be every-where, or in divers places at once in its owne substance, is the property of the unmeasurable Deity alone: but every creature is finite,
3. From the Article of the communion of Saints: 1. Such is the communion of Saints with Christ now, as it was of old ever since the beginning, and shall be ever hereafter; as well of those who use the Sacraments, as of them who are by necessity excluded from them.1 For there is but one only communion of Saints with Christ; because we are all one body with Christ. But this communion of Saints with Christ was always spiritual: as the Apostle doth show; He that is joined to the Lord, is one spirit. Hereby know we, that we dwell in him, and he in us; because he hath given us of his spirit. He is the Vine, we are the branches: He is the Head, we are the members: He is the Bridegroom, and we (with the whole Church) are his Spouse. Or the argument may be thus formed: All the Saints have the same communion with Christ, both in the Old and New Testament (as well they, who have power to approach and partake of the Supper, as they who have not:) and we cannot eat Christ any otherwise, then his Disciples did eat him in the first Supper. But they did eat him spiritually: Therefore we eat him also spiritually. Out of the self same Article we thus argue: 2. Such is our eating of Christ, as is his abiding in us. But this is spiritual: Therefore our eating of him is spiritual. The Major is out of question, because he is therefore eaten, that he may remain in us, and we in him; not that being once eaten, he should forthwith vanish away;2 He which cateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, abideth in me, and I in him. The Minor, namely, that Christs abiding in us is spiritual, is sufficiently proved and perceived by this, in that such is his abiding in us, as is his Fathers:3 If any man love me, he will keep my word, and my Father will love him, and we will come unto him, and will dwell with him. But how doth the Father dwell in us or abide with us? Truly by his holy Spirit: Therefore Christ also so abideth with us, or dwelleth in us.4 Hereunto belong those sayings: By this we know that he dwelleth in us, and we in him, because he hath given us of his Spirit. That Christ may dwell in your hearts through faith. I am the Vine, ye are the branches: he that abideth in me, and I in him, 5
because, as touching his humane nature,1 he saith, Me ye shall not have always: Therefore he is not eaten of us corporally; nay, he cannot be eaten of us corporally, except he be in us corporally, and that also perpetually.
because, as touching his humane nature,1 he saith, Me ye shall not have alwayes: Therefore he is not eaten of us corporally; nay, he cannot be eaten of us corporally, except he be in us corporally, and that also perpetually.
4. From the Article of remission of sins. If Christ be corporally in the bread, and be reached out and delivered unto us by the hand of the Minister, then we are to crave remission of sins at Gods hands, for his sake, who is in the bread, and whom the Minister handleth, whether the bread still remain together with him, or no. For remission of sins is most especially to be craved then, when we celebrate the Supper. So then every communicant must thus pray: I beseech thee, O heavenly Father, to be gracious and merciful unto me for this thy Sons sake, who is here present in this bread, and whom the Minister handleth, and whom I eat with my mouth: But this is that horrible Idolatry, which is practised in the Popish Mass, which without doubt is so abominable in the sight of God, that it were better for us to suffer a thousand deaths, then once commit the same. For the Gospel teacheth us to beg of God remission of sins, not for that Christs sake, who is in the bread, and is carried about in the Ministers hands, and eaten with mens mouths: but for that Christs sake, who suffered and died for us, who is now in heaven at the right hand of his Father, and maketh intercession for us. So then thus we reason, That which establisheth the horrible Idolatry of the Mass, is to be avoided of the true professors of the Gospel: But the corporal presence of Christ, and the eating of him with our mouths in the bread, establisheth the horrible Idolatry of the Mass: Therefore it is to be avoided by all true professors of Christs Gospel.
4. From the Article of remission of sinnes. If Christ be corporally in the bread, and be reached out and delivered unto us by the hand of the Minister, then we are to crave remission of sinnes at Gods hands, for his sake, who is in the bread, and whom the Minister handleth, whether the bread still remaine together with him, or no. For remission of sinnes is most especially to be craved then, when we celebrate the Supper. So then every communicant must thus pray: I beseech thee, O heavenly Father, to be gracious and mercifull unto me for this thy Sonnes sake, who is here present in this bread, and whom the Minister handleth, and whom I eat with my mouth: But this is that horrible Idolatry, which is practised in the Popish Masse, which without doubt is so abominable in the sight of God, that it were better for us to suffer a thousand deaths, then once commit the same. For the Gospel teacheth us to begge of God remission of sinnes, not for that Christs sake, who is in the bread, and is carried about in the Ministers hands, and eaten with mens mouths: but for that Christs sake, who suffered and died for us, who is now in heaven at the right hand of his Father, and maketh intercession for us. So then thus we reason, That which establisheth the horrible Idolatry of the Masse, is to be avoided of the true professors of the Gospel: But the corporall presence of Christ, and the eating of him with our mouths in the bread, establisheth the horrible Idolatry of the Masse: Therefore it is to be avoided by all true professors of Christs Gospel.
5. Unto the former may be adjoined also arguments taken from the sacrifice and adoration of Christ. Wherefore Christ is present corporally, whether it be after a ⟨p. 445⟩visible or invisible manner, there he is so to be adored, to wit, by our minds, and the motions of our bodies converted and turned thither. But he is not thus to be adored in the Supper: Therefore he is not present in the Supper corporally, either in the bread, or in the place of bread. The Minor, That he is not to be adored in the Supper, is easily proved: because in the New Testament since Christs ascension it hath not been, nor is lawful to tie and bind invocation to any certain place or thing, without the express command and permission of God, except we will commit open Idolatry. For all adoration, bound and restrained to any certain place or thing on earth, is abrogated and cancelled by Christ. The hour cometh, 1when ye shall neither in this mountain, nor in Jerusalem worship the Father. Ye worship that which ye know not; we worship that which we know: for salvation is of the Jews. But the hour cometh, and now is, when the true worshippers shall worship the Father in spirit and truth: For the Father requireth even such to worship him. God is a Spirit: and they that worship him, must worship him in spirit and truth. Again, if Christ be so to be adored and worshipped in the Supper, by our minds and motions of body converted unto the bread, that whole oblation and sacrifice should consist in the hands of sacrificing Mass-Priests, because they offer the Son unto the Father, to obtain remission of sins: and so were his crucifying to be re-iterated. Object. Christ commanded not himself to be offered or adored, but to be eaten: Therefore we establish not the Papists offering up of Christ to his Father, or their worshipping of him in the bread, by that corporal presence which we uphold. Ans. This their reasoning is two ways faulty: First, they beg that which is in question, whilst they say, that Christ commanded us to eat him in the bread: for this is no where found in Scripture. 2. They shift and seek to slide from the question, in averring, that Christ commanded not himself to be adored: for we have a general precept of adoring Christ in these words;2 He is the Lord thy God, and thou shalt worship him. And let all the Angels of God worship him.
This general precept, without any special exception or expectation of any particular injunction, should no less bind us all unto obedience, and to the adoring of Christ in the bread, if we had any evident proof of his invisible existence therein, than if we beheld him present with our eyes. Thus Thomas expecteth not some special express warrant, but doth well in worshipping towards the place where he seeth Christ standing, saying; My Lord, and my God. Wherefore,1 as long as the opinion of corporal presence standeth, so long the Papists idolatrous adoration and oblation, and their whole Mass must needs stand also. For the Papists themselves will not have, that we understand their offering of Christ in the Mass of any slaughtering or murdering him, but only of a public showing him being there corporally present, and of a craving and obtaining remission of sins for his sake, whom the Priests bear in their hands, and present unto God the Father.
This generall precept, without any speciall exception or expectation of any particular injunction, should no lesse binde us all unto obedience, and to the adoring of Christ in the bread, if we had any evident proofe of his invisible existence therein, than if we beheld him present with our eyes. Thus Thomas expecteth not some speciall expresse warrant, but doth well in worshipping towards the place where he seeth Christ standing, saying; My Lord, and my God. Wherefore,1 as long as the opinion of corporall presence standeth, so long the Papists idolatrous adoration and oblation, and their whole Masse must needs stand also. For the Papists themselves will not have, that we understand their offering of Christ in the Masse of any slaughtering or murthering him, but only of a publique shewing him being there corporally present, and of a craving and obtaining remission of sinnes for his sake, whom the Priests beare in their hands, and present unto God the Father.
1. Like phrases have a like sense and interpretation. But all these phrases are accounted for like; namely, for sacramental forms of speech, wherein the names or proper effects of the things signified, are attributed to the sign: as, Circumcision is the Govenant of God. The Lamb is the Passover of the Lord. 1The Sabbath is the Covenant of the Lord. The Levitical sacrifices are an expiation or doing away of sin. The blood of sacrifices is the blood of the Covenant. The covering of the Ark is the mercy seat. The Rock was Christ. The bread is the body of Christ. The cup is the New Testament. Baptism washeth away sin. Baptism is the washing of the new birth. Baptism saveth us, &c. Therefore their interpretation is alike. Now God himself interpreteth some of them thus; Circumcision is a sign of the Covenant. The Lamb is a sign and memorial of the Passover. The Sabbath is a sign of the Covenant: Therefore we may justly interpret the rest on the same manner. The Levitical sacrifices signify the atonement for sins, made by the Messiah. The blood of sacrifices is a Sacrament ⟨p. 446⟩or sign confirming the Covenant; or a sign of Christs blood, whereby the Covenant was established. The covering of the Ark signifieth the Mercy-seat. The Rock signifieth Christ. The bread is a Sacrament of the body of Christ. The cup is a Sacrament sealing the new Covenant. Baptism is a Sacrament of the washing away of sins, and of our regeneration and salvation.
1. LIke phrases have a like sense and interpretation. But all these phrases are accounted for like; namely, for sacramentall formes of speech, wherein the names or proper effects of the things signified, are attributed to the signe: as, Circumcision is the Govenant of God. The Lamb is the Passeover of the Lord. 1The Sabbath is the Covenant of the Lord. The Leviticall sacrifices are an expiation or doing away of sinne. The bloud of sacrifices is the bloud of the Covenant. The covering of the Arke is the mercy seate. The Rock was Christ. The bread is the body of Christ. The cup is the New Testament. Baptisme washeth away sinne. Baptisme is the washing of the new birth. Baptisme saveth us, &c. Therefore their interpretation is alike. Now God himselfe interpreteth some of them thus; Circumcision is a signe of the Covenant. The Lamb is a signe and memoriall of the Passeover. The Sabbath is a signe of the Covenant: Therefore we may justly interpret the rest on the same manner. The Leviticall sacrifices signifie the attonement for sinnes, made by the Messias. The bloud of sacrifices is a Sacrament
2. As the cup is the New Testament, so is the blood of Christ the New Testament. The cup is the New Testament Sacramentally; that is, it is a sign of the New Testament: Therefore Christs blood is a sign of the New Testament. The Major is apparent, because without doubt the words of Luke and Paul, This cup is the New Testament in my blood; and the words of Matthew and Mark, This is my blood of the New Testament, have all one meaning. The Minor is proved before in the first argument, and cannot be taken otherwise. For the New Testament is no external thing or ceremony, but a free reconciliation with God, promised in the Gospel, through the blood and death of Christ. The cup then is either the thing promised, or the seal of the promise; but it is not the promise, nor the thing promised: Therefore it is the seal of the promise.
2. As the cup is the New Testament, so is the bloud of Christ the New Testament. The cup is the New Testament Sacramentally; that is, it is a signe of the New Testament: Therefore Christs bloud is a signe of the New Testament. The Major is apparent, because without doubt the words of Luke and Paul, This cup is the New Testament in my bloud; and the words of Matthew and Marke, This is my bloud of the New Testament, have all one meaning. The Minor is proved before in the first argument, and cannot be taken otherwise. For the New Testament is no externall thing or ceremony, but a free reconciliation with God, promised in the Gospel, through the bloud and death of Christ. The cup then is either the thing promised, or the seale of the promise; but it is not the promise, nor the thing promised: Therefore it is the seale of the promise.
3. The bread which we break (saith the Apostle) is it not the communion of the body of Christ? As bread is the communion of the body of Christ, so also it is the body of Christ. The reason is clear, because Pauls words and Christs have both one meaning; seeing Paul interpreteth Christ. But the bread is the communion of the body of Christ sacramentally; that is, it is a Sacrament or sign of our spiritual communion with Christs body. For properly and literally, bread cannot be termed a communion: Therefore, bread also is Christs body sacramentally; that is, it is a Sacrament or sign of Christs body. Now that the communion or communication of Christs body is spiritual, is thus proved: 1. Paul speaketh of such a communion, as whereby we being many, are made one bread, one body. But we being many, are one body spiritually: Therefore the communion mentioned of Paul is spiritual. 2. The communion of Christ, whereof he speaketh, cannot stand with the communion of Devils:1 Ye cannot (saith he) drink the cup of the Lord, and the cup of the Devils: ye cannot be partakers of the Lords Table, and of the table of the Devils. The argument is not deduced from an inconvenience or an undecency, as some fondly tell us,2 but from an impossibility: as that of Christ, Ye cannot serve God and Mammon. Where the words [Greek or Hebrew], ye are not able; or, ye have no possibility, are likewise used, as well as in this place:3 and as that of the same Apostle else-where; What concord hath Christ with Belial? or what part hath the Believer with the Infidel? 3. This communion of the Saints with Christ, and Christ with the Saints, is spiritually expounded in Scripture,4 Our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ. If we say, that we have fellowship with him, and walk in darkness, we lye, and do not truly. But if we walk in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the blood of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sin. Neither do we in the Creed believe any other communion of the Saints with Christ, and Christ with the Saints, but that which is spiritual. 54. Lastly, Chrysostom interpreteth Pauls words of a spiritual communion. Why said he not participation? That he might manifest unto thee somewhat more excellent then it, to wit, the strongest and mightiest union that can be.
And a little after, Why call I it communion? Yea, we are the self-same body of Christ. What is the bread? even the body of Christ. What are they made, who receive the body of Christ? not many bodies, but one body. For as the bread is kneaded of many grains, so we also are joined with Christ.
And a little after, Why call I it communion? Yea, we are the selfe-same body of Christ. What is the bread? even the body of Christ. What are they made, who receive the body of Christ? not many bodies, but one body. For as the bread is kneaded of many graines, so we also are joyned with Christ.
4. Out of the words of Christ:1 What then if ye should see the Son of man ascend up where he was before? It is the Spirit that quickeneth, the flesh profiteth nothing: the words that I speak unto you are spirit and life. In these words Christ expressly rejecteth all eating of his flesh with our mouths, and overthroweth by two arguments, which we have heretofore declared: and on the other side he approveth and confirmeth our spiritual eating his flesh. Wherefore we may not forge any corporal eating of Christs body in the Supper, when such a kind of eating is precisely reproved in the Gospel. Object. The sixth chapter of John treateth not of the Supper: ⟨p. 447⟩Therefore this testimony maketh nought against the eating of Christs body with our mouths instituted in the Supper. Answ. Here our Adversaries deceitfully argue from the denial of a part, to the denial of the whole. This Chapter, we grant, pertaineth not to the Ceremony of the Supper: But hence it followeth not, that simply it pertaineth not to the Supper. For it concerneth the promise; This is my body, which is given for you: because this promise is desumed out of this Christs Sermon registered in this sixth of John, and is ratified and confirmed by the signs of bread and wine. Wherefore it cannot be understood of any other eating of Christs body in the Supper, then of that which is delivered in the sixth of John, which is spiritual. For, bodily eating is in that Sermon condemned. Repl. It is not simply the eating with the mouth that is there condemned, but a Capernaiticall eating. Answ. All eating with the mouth is Capernaiticall. For, a Capernaiticall eating is not a bloody renting only and eating of Christs flesh, and chewing it between the teeth, but simply any eating with the mouth. For the Capernaites say not among themselves: How can this man give us his flesh to devour, to gnaw on with our teeth, to rend asunder? &c. But they say: How can this man give us his flesh to eat? 2Neither doth Christ re-call them from a gross eating with the mouth, to a subtle kind of eating with the mouth; but to his ascension into Heaven, which should shortly come to pass, and thereby his body should be far removed from their mouths, and trained them to a spiritual eating, which is with the heart by faith.
4. Out of the words of Christ:
5. Out of the same sixth Chapter of John, To eat Christs flesh, and, To drink his blood, signifieth, To believe in Christ, To dwell in Christ, and, 1To have Christ dwelling in us: as appeareth, because he attributeth the same effect of eternal life to both; namely, to the eating of his flesh, and to faith in him: But in the Supper this eating is authorised: (For no other purpose besides this can be showed in the whole Gospel, for sealing whereof the Supper was instituted.) Therefore, To eat Christs body, and, To drink his blood, is, To believe in Christ, To dwell in Christ, and, To have him dwelling in us.
5. Out of the same sixth Chapter of John, To eate Christs flesh, and, To drinke his bloud, signifieth, To beleeve in Christ, To dwell in Christ, and, 1To have Christ dwelling in us: as appeareth, because he attributeth the same effect of eternall life to both; namely, to the eating of his flesh, and to faith in him: But in the Supper this eating is authorised: (For no other purpose besides this can be shewed in the whole Gospel, for sealing whereof the Supper was instituted.) Therefore, To eate Christs body, and, To drink his blood, is, To beleeve in Christ, To dwell in Christ, and, To have him dwelling in us.
6. By one spirit are we all baptised into one body, whether we be Jews or Grecians, 1whether we be bond or free, and have been all made to drink into one spirit. Hence we draw two arguments: 1. Such as is the drinking of Christ, such is the eating of him in the Supper. The drinking of him is spiritual: Therefore the eating of him is spiritual. 2. The eating of Christs body, and drinking his blood, is common to all the faithful, even to the Fathers of the Old Testament. For we have all bin made to drink into one spirit. But the eating with the mouth is not common to all the faithful: (For the Fathers before Christs birth could not, and at this day Infants, and many of ripe years, having not liberty to partake of the Supper, cannot eat his flesh with their mouths.) Wherefore, this mouthy eating of Christs flesh, urged by our Adversaries, is not that true eating which the Gospel promiseth, and which the Supper sealeth.
6. By one spirit are we all baptised into one body, whether we be Jews or Grecians, 1whether we be bond or free, and have beene all made to drink into one spirit. Hence we draw two arguments: 1. Such as is the drinking of Christ, such is the eating of him in the Supper. The drinking of him is spirituall: Therefore the eating of him is spirituall. 2. The eating of Christs body, and drinking his bloud, is common to all the faithfull, even to the Fathers of the Old Testament. For we have all bin made to drink into one spirit. But the eating with the mouth is not common to all the faithfull: (For the Fathers before Christs birth could not, and at this day Infants, and many of ripe yeeres, having not liberty to partake of the Supper, cannot eate his flesh with their mouthes.) Wherefore, this mouthy eating of Christs flesh, urged by our Adversaries, is not that true eating which the Gospel promiseth, and which the Supper sealeth.
Unto these arguments drawn out of the sacred Scripture, and the ground of our faith, may be added testimonies of the Fathers, and the purer Church; who, if we look into their writings, we shall find, that they plainly teach the same doctrine touching the Lords holy Supper, which we do. Among many we will produce only some few notable and clear in this point. Irenaeus saith,1 The earthly bread, taking his name from the word of God, is no longer common bread, but becometh the Eucharist or Sacrament, which consisteth of two things; an earthly, and an heavenly thing. Tertullian, The bread which he took and distributed among his Disciples, he made it his body, saying, This is my body; that is, The figure of my body.2 Clemens of Alexandria, This is to drink Christs blood, to be partaker of Christs immortality. Cyprian, Neither can his blood, wherewith we are redeemed and justified, seem to be in the Chalice, when the wine faileth in the Chalice, wherein Christs blood is showed, which is spoken of in every Sacrament and testimony of Scripture. Again, the same Father saith, As often as ⟨p. 448⟩we do this, we sharpen not our teeth to bite withal, but we break and part the sanctified bread with a sincere faith, whilst we distinguish and separate that which is divine, from that which is humane, and joining them again after their separation, confess one God and man: yea, we our selves are made his body by this Sacrament, and knit and united to our head by the thing signified by the Sacrament. 3The Canon of the Nicene Council: Again, here also is the Lords Table: Let us not childishly cleave to the bread and wine set before us, but lifting up our minds on high, by faith, let us consider, that on that Table is set the Lamb of God taking away the sins of the world, which is offered of the Priests without killing: and let us, truly receiving his precious body and blood, believe that they are SIGNS of our resurrection. For therefore we receive not much, but little; thereby to acknowledge that it is not received to satisfy, 4but to sanctify us. Basil: We have set on the Table the figures of the sacred body and blood. Hillary: The bread and wine received, and drunk, effect and work that both we are in Christ,
being mindful thereof, in eating, and drinking we Signify, (or Represent) the flesh and blood that were offered up for us. 1Again, This oblation is the FIGURE OF THE BODY AND BLOOD of our LORD Jesus CHRIST. Augustine: Our Lord doubted not to say, This is my body, when he gave a TOKEN of his body. Again, The Lord admitted Judas to that banquet, wherein he ministered and gave to his disciples the FIGURE of his body and blood. The same Father saith: Unless Sacraments had a certain likeness of the things, whereof they be Sacraments, without question they were no Sacraments. And in consideration of this likeness, oftentimes they bear the names of the things themselves. As therefore the Sacrament of the body of CHRIST is AFTER A CERTAIN MANNER the body of Christ: and the Sacrament of Christs blood is his blood: so the Sacrament of faith is faith. 2Again, As then the celestial bread, Christs flesh, is IN SOME SORT called Christs body, whereas indeed it is a Sacrament of Christs body; namely, that visible, palpable, and mortal body which was nailed on the Cross, and the sacrificing of his flesh, done by the hands of the Minister, is called Christs Passion, death, and crucifying, NOT IN THE TRUTH OF THE THING, but in a mystery SIGNIFYING it: So the Sacrament of faith, by which is meant Baptism, is faith. 3Also: These, my brethren, are therefore called Sacraments, because in them one thing is seen, another understood. That which is seen hath a bodily form: that which is understood, hath a spiritual fruit or benefit. 4Chrysostom: This is my blood, which is shed for the remission of sins; which Christ said, to show that his Passion and Cross was a mystery, and to comfort his disciples. 5Theodoret: Our Saviour verily changed the names of the signs and the things signified, and gave the same name to the body, which is proper to the sign; and that to the sign which is proper to the body. The cause of this change is manifest to them that are entered into the first principles of divine mysteries. For he would that they who use the Sacraments should not bend and set their minds on the nature of the things which are seen, but, for the alteration of the names, should believe that alteration which is made through grace.
For he who termed that by name of corn and bread, which is by nature a body, and called himself a vine, he honoured the signs, which are seen, with the title and name of his body and blood, not by changing the nature, but by adding grace to the nature. Macarius the Monk hath a famous saying to this purpose:1 Bread and wine are a correspondent type of his flesh, and they who receive the bread which is showed, eat the flesh of Christ spiritually. Other testimonies for briefness sake we omit.
For he who tearmed that by name of corne and bread, which is by nature a body, and called himselfe a vine, he honoured the signes, which are seene, with the title and name of his body and bloud, not by changing the nature, but by adding grace to the nature. Macarius the Monke hath a famous saying to this purpose:1 Bread and wine are a correspondent type of his flesh, and they who receive the bread which is shewed, eate the flesh of Christ spiritually. Other testimonies for briefenesse sake we omit.
Now it is easy to see what we are to think of Transubstantiation, even that it is an impious invention and device of the Papists: which also we will show and prove briefly by divers reasons. But first we must declare in a word what the Papists properly mean by their Transubstantiation. They suppose that by force of Consecration; that is, of uttering these words upon the creatures of bread and wine, This is my body, This is the cup of the new Testament in my blood, the bread and wine is substantially ⟨p. 449⟩converted or turned into the body and blood of Christ, the forms only or accidents of bread and wine remaining; namely, the shape or figure, the heat, the taste, the weight, &c. They therefore call these words of Consecration, operatorie, and effective, able to work and effect the conversion and change: and they say, that the change is fully accomplished in the very last instant of uttering the syllable* DY, This is my boDY: and then there is no longer bread and wine, but the body and blood of Christ is present, and is contained under the forms of bread and wine, and is eaten and drunk in the Eucharist or Supper by the mouth of the Communicants. Concerning the manner of the change, it is not agreed on by all. Some say, that the substance of bread and wine is by Transubstantiation changed into the substance of Christs body and blood: so that the bread and wine is essentially made the very body and blood of Christ, the external forms only remaining; and this they term a substantial change, or change of the substance.2 Others are of opinion that the substance of bread and wine is not changed, but vanisheth by annihilation, or by being brought to nothing; and that then the substance of Christs body and blood succeedeth in place thereof; so that the substance of Christs body and blood after the consecration, cometh under these forms and accidents, under which before was the substance of the bread and wine: And this they call a formal change, or a change of forms. Lombard in his Sentences expoundeth both these opinions,3 and seemeth to approve the former alone. Howbeit they call both these changes by the name of Transubstantiation.
NOw it is easie to see what we are to think of Transubstantiation, even that it is an impious invention and device of the Papists: which also we will shew and prove briefly by divers reasons. But first we must declare in a word what the Papists properly meane by their Transubstantiation. They suppose that by force of Consecration; that is, of uttering these words upon the creatures of bread and wine, This is my body, This is the cup of the new Testament in my bloud, the bread and wine is substantially
They affirm also that the particle This, in the words of consecration, doth note some indeterminate substance in general (as they use to speak) without quantity or quality, contained under those accidents, so that it demonstrateth unto us neither bread, nor Christs body, but only something contained under the forms and accidents, which before Consecration was bread, but by vigour and force of the words of Consecration, began to be the body of Christ: so that the meaning is on this wise; This is my body, that is,1 that which is contained under this, or these forms, is my body. Touching the accidents, where they are grounded and seated, whether in the body of Christ, or in the air, or in the surface of the bread and wine, or in nothing, they curiously and diversely dispute; and the common received opinion is, that they are existent without any subject. This is the doctrine of the School-men and all Papists, whereof (as we see) there are two main heads: one of Transubstantiation, another of eating Christs body with the mouth. But each of them is a false profane forgery, utterly repugnant with the words of Christ. As for the later of these, it is overthrown and refuted by the same arguments whereby we have already proved the spiritual eating of Christs body; and Transubstantiation is thus oppugned:
They affirm also that the particle This, in the words of consecration, doth note some indeterminate substance in generall (as they use to speak) without quantity or quality, contained under those accidents, so that it demonstrateth unto us neither bread, nor Christs body, but only something contained under the formes and accidents, which before Consecration was bread, but by vigour and force of the words of Consecration, began to be the body of Christ: so that the meaning is on this wise; This is my body, that is,1 that which is contained under this, or these formes, is my body. Touching the accidents, where they are grounded and seated, whether in the body of Christ, or in the aire, or in the surface of the bread and wine, or in nothing, they curiously and diversely dispute; and the common received opinion is, that they are existent without any subject. This is the doctrine of the Schoole-men and all Papists, whereof (as we see) there are two maine heads: one of Transsubstantiation, another of eating Christs body with the mouth. But each of them is a false profane forgery, utterly repugnant with the words of Christ. As for the later of these, it is overthrown and refuted by the same arguments whereby we have already proved the spirituall eating of Christs body; and Transsubstantiation is thus oppugned:
1. That which is Christs body in the Supper, remaineth and is not therein transformed, nor reduced to nothing: else Christs body should not remain,1 nor be present in the Eucharist: But in the bread is Christs body, namely, sacramentally, as before we have made evident demonstrance:) Therefore bread remaineth in the Supper, and is not transformed, or reduced to nothing. The Minor is already proved, and is confirmed,2 1. By the authority of Luke and Paul, in these words: This cup is the new testament: and, The bread is the communion of the body of Christ. 2. Farther proofs are deduced also out of these words thus: What Christ brake, that he called his body: But he brake bread, not some uncertain substance, nor the mere accidents of the bread. Therefore the bread is the body of Christ. Again, The Article THIS demonstrateth and pointeth out either the bread, or the mere accidents, or the body of Christ, or some determinate thing or substance whatsoever. But it concerneth not any indeterminate substance; Because Christ brake not any undeterminate thing, that is, I know not what: but determinately and precisely it is said, He brake bread, it concerneth not Christs visible or invisible body; for his visible body sate and talked with his Disciples: and an invisible body Christ never had: and moreover the Papists themselves confess, that Christs body is not yet present under the form of bread, when the Priest beginneth to pronounce the particle THIS, but then, when once the change is made; the change (say they) is made in the last instant of consecration, at the pronouncing of this ⟨p. 450⟩last syllable DY, in these words, This is my boDY. Lastly, it concerneth not the accidents only of the bread; For Christ brake not bare and mere accidents. Wherefore, the Article THIS intimateth nothing else but the bread; and Christs words. This is my body, have no other meaning then this, This bread is my body.
1. That which is Christs body in the Supper, remaineth and is not therein transformed, nor reduced to nothing: else Christs body should not remaine,1 nor be present in the Eucharist: But in the bread is Christs body, namely, sacramentally, as before we have made evident demonstrance:) Therefore bread remaineth in the Supper, and is not transformed, or reduced to nothing. The Minor is already proved, and is confirmed,
2.Christ brake bread: but he did not then break his body: therefore the bread is not really his body.
3. Christs body was given for us: The bread was not given for us: Therefore the bread is not really Christs body.
4. Christ saith not, as the Transsubstantiaries say, Under these forms is my body, or, My body is contained under these forms: Therefore the Transsubstantiaries retain not, but pervert Christs words.
4. Christ saith not, as the Transsubstantiaries say, Ʋnder these formes is my body, or, My body is contained under these formes: Therefore the Transsubstantiaries retaine not, but pervert Christs words.
5. Christ said not, Let this be made, but, This is my body. Therefore Christs words turn not the bread into the substance of his body; but they teach only that the bread in this use is Christs body, to wit sacramentally.
5. Christ said not, Let this be made, but, This is my body. Therefore Christs words turne not the bread into the substance of his body; but they teach onely that the bread in this use is Christs body, to wit sacramentally.
6. Paul expressly calleth that which is taken, bread, both before and after the eating: Therefore the bread is not reduced to nothing, nor changed into the substance of Christs body, but continueth bread.
6. Paul expresly calleth that which is taken, bread, both before and after the eating: Therefore the bread is not reduced to nothing, nor changed into the substance of Christs body, but continueth bread.
7. Two things there are in every Sacrament: the sign, and the thing signed: or, as Irenaeus speaketh, the earthly, and the heavenly thing; and without these two, no Sacrament can consist or stand. But Transubstantiation taketh away the sign or earthly thing, namely bread and wine from the Eucharist. Therefore it taketh away the whole fence or nature of a Sacrament.
7. Two things there are in every Sacrament: the signe, and the thing signed: or, as Irenaeus speaketh, the earthly, and the heavenly thing; and without these two, no Sacrament can consist or stand. But Transsubstantiation taketh away the signe or earthly thing, namely bread and wine from the Eucharist. Therefore it taketh away the whole fence or nature of a Sacrament.
8. A bare imagination of bread and wine cannot confirm the faith of heavenly things, but will mock and deceive it, as being a vain thing, and not that which it seemeth. But the sign in the Lords Supper must confirm the faith of heavenly things, to wit, that we are as certainly fed with the body and blood of our Lord, as we are sure we receive the bread and wine. For Sacraments were instituted to confirm faith by visible signs. Farewell Transubstantiation, which transformeth the sign into a shadow and imagination.
8. A bare imagination of bread and wine cannot confirme the faith of heavenly things, but will mock and deceive it, as being a vaine thing, and not that which it seemeth. But the signe in the Lords Supper must confirme the faith of heavenly things, to wit, that we are as certainly fed with the body and bloud of our Lord, as we are sure we receive the bread and wine. For Sacraments were instituted to confirme faith by visible signes. Farewell Transsubstantiation, which transformeth the signe into a shadow and imagination.
9. Transubstantiation taketh away the analogy or proportion of the sign and the thing signed;1 whereof Saint Augustine saith, that The body so feedeth the soul, as the bread nourisheth the body: and as corn bread, is one mass made of many grains; so many are made one bread and one body, which partake of one bread. For, the bare accidents of bread and wine cannot uphold and bear this Analogy, seeing they nourish not; neither can you say, As the accidents of the bread and wine nourish the body, to the maintenance of this life; so Christs body nourisheth my soul to life eternal: for then the comparison will be between a true and a false thing: wherefore the very Analogy of the sign, and the thing, do sufficiently refute Transubstantiation.
9. Transsubstantiation taketh away the analogie or proportion of the signe and the thing signed;1 whereof Saint Augustine saith, that The body so feedeth the soule, as the bread nourisheth the body: and as corn bread, is one masse made of many grains; so many are made one bread and one body, which partake of one bread. For, the bare accidents of bread and wine cannot uphold and beare this Analogie, seeing they nourish not; neither can you say, As the accidents of the bread and wine nourish the body, to the maintenance of this life; so Christs body nourisheth my soule to life eternall: for then the comparison will be betweene a true and a false thing: wherefore the very Analogie of the signe, and the thing, doe sufficiently refute Transsubstantiation.
3. From the Article of the communion of Saints: 1. Such is the communion of Saints with Christ now, as it was of old ever since the beginning, and shall be ever hereafter; as well of those who use the Sacraments, as of them who are by necessity excluded from them.1 For there is but one only communion of Saints with Christ; because we are all one body with Christ. But this communion of Saints with Christ was alwayes spirituall: as the Apostle doth shew; He that is joyned to the Lord, is one spirit. Hereby know we, that we dwell in him, and he in us; because he hath given us of his spirit. He is the Vine, we are the branches: He is the Head, we are the members: He is the Bridegroome, and we (with the whole Church) are his Spouse. Or the argument may be thus formed: All the Saints have the same communion with Christ, both in the Old and New Testament (as well they, who have power to approach and partake of the Supper, as they who have not:) and we cannot eat Christ any otherwise, then his Disciples did eat him in the first Supper. But they did eat him spiritually: Therefore we eat him also spiritually. Out of the selfe same Article we thus argue: 2. Such is our eating of Christ, as is his abiding in us. But this is spirituall: Therefore our eating of him is spirituall. The Major is out of question, because he is therefore eaten, that he may remaine in us, and we in him; not that being once eaten, he should forthwith vanish away;2 He which cateth my flesh, and drinketh my bloud, abideth in me, and I in him. The Minor, namely, that Christs abiding in us is spirituall, is sufficiently proved and perceived by this, in that such is his abiding in us, as is his Fathers:3 If any man love me, he will keep my word, and my Father will love him, and we will come unto him, and will dwell with him. But how doth the Father dwell in us or abide with us? Truly by his holy Spirit: Therefore Christ also so abideth with us, or dwelleth in us.4 Hereunto belong those sayings: By this we know that he dwelleth in us, and we in him, because he hath given us of his Spirit. That Christ may dwell in your hearts through faith. I am the Vine, ye are the branches: he that abideth in me, and I in him, 5the same bringeth forth much fruit. 3. Christ abideth in us perpetually: Therefore that abiding or presence is not corporall:
3. The bread which we breake (saith the Apostle) is it not the communion of the body of Christ? As bread is the communion of the body of Christ, so also it is the body of Christ. The reason is cleere, because Pauls words and Christs have both one meaning; seeing Paul interpreteth Christ. But the bread is the communion of the body of Christ sacramentally; that is, it is a Sacrament or signe of our spirituall communion with Christs body. For properly and literally, bread cannot be termed a communion: Therefore, bread also is Christs body sacramentally; that is, it is a Sacrament or signe of Christs body. Now that the communion or communication of Christs body is spirituall, is thus proved: 1. Paul speaketh of such a communion, as whereby we being many, are made one bread, one body. But we being many, are one body spiritually: Therefore the communion mentioned of Paul is spirituall. 2. The communion of Christ, whereof he speaketh, cannot stand with the communion of Divels:1 Ye cannot (saith he) drink the cup of the Lord, and the cup of the Divels: ye cannot be partakers of the Lords Table, and of the table of the Divels. The argument is not deduced from an inconvenience or an undecency, as some fondly tell us,2 but from an impossibility: as that of Christ, Ye cannot serve God and Mammon. Where the words 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, ye are not able; or, ye have no possibility, are likewise used, as well as in this place:3 and as that of the same Apostle else-where; What concord hath Christ with Belial? or what part hath the Beleever with the Infidell? 3. This communion of the Saints with Christ, and Christ with the Saints, is spiritually expounded in Scripture,4 Our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ. If we say, that we have fellowship with him, and walke in darkenesse, we lye, and do not truely. But if we walke in the light, as he is in the light, we have fellowship one with another, and the bloud of Jesus Christ cleanseth us from all sinne. Neither doe we in the Creed beleeve any other communion of the Saints with Christ, and Christ with the Saints, but that which is spirituall. 54. Lastly, Chrysostome interpreteth Pauls words of a spirituall communion. Why said he not participation? That he might manifest unto thee somewhat more excellent then it, to wit, the strongest and mightiest union that can be.
UNto these arguments drawne out of the sacred Scripture, and the ground of our faith, may be added testimonies of the Fathers, and the purer Church; who, if we looke into their writings, we shall finde, that they plainly teach the same doctrine touching the Lords holy Supper, which we do. Among many we will produce onely some few notable and cleere in this point. Irenaeus saith,1 The earthly bread, taking his name from the word of God, is no longer common bread, but becometh the Eucharist or Sacrament, which consisteth of two things; an earthly, and an heavenly thing. Tertullian, The bread which he tooke and distributed among his Disciples, he made it his body, saying, This is my body; that is, The figure of my body.2 Clemens of Alexandria, This is to drinke Christs bloud, to be partaker of Christs immortality. Cyprian, Neither can his blood, wherewith we are redeemed and justified, seeme to be in the Chalice, when the wine faileth in the Chalice, wherein Christs bloud is shewed, which is spoken of in every Sacrament and testimony of Scripture. Againe, the same Father saith, As often as ⟨p. 448⟩we doe this, we sharpen not our teeth to bite withall, but we breake and part the sanctified bread with a sincere faith, whilst we distinguish and separate that which is divine, from that which is humane, and joyning them againe after their separation, confesse one God and man: yea, we our selves are made his body by this Sacrament, and knit and united to our head by the thing signified by the Sacrament. 3The Canon of the Nicene Councell: Againe, here also is the Lords Table: Let us not childishly cleave to the bread and wine set before us, but lifting up our minds on high, by faith, let us consider, that on that Table is set the Lamb of God taking away the sinnes of the world, which is offered of the Priests without killing: and let us, truely receiving his precious body and bloud, beleeve that they are SIGNES of our resurrection. For therefore we receive not much, but little; thereby to acknowledge that it is not received to satisfie, 4but to sanctifie us. Basil: We have set on the Table the figures of the sacred body and blood. Hillarie: The bread and wine received, and drunke, effect and worke that both we are in Christ, 5and Christ in us. Gregory Nazianzene: The figures of the precious body and bloud of Christ. Ambrose: Because we are delivered by our LORDS death;
being mindfull thereof, in eating, and drinking wee Signifie, (or Represent) the flesh and bloud that were offered up for us. 1Againe, This oblation is the FIGƲRE OF THE BODY AND BLOƲD of our LORD Jesus CHRIST. Augustine: Our Lord doubted not to say, This is my body, when he gave a TOKEN of his body. Againe, The Lord admitted Judas to that banquet, wherein he ministred and gave to his disciples the FIGƲRE of his body and bloud. The same Father saith: Ʋnlesse Sacraments had a certaine likenesse of the things, whereof they bee Sacraments, without question they were no Sacraments. And in consideration of this likenesse, oftentimes they beare the names of the things themselves. As therefore the Sacrament of the body of CHRIST is AFTER A CERTAINE MANER the body of Christ: and the Sacrament of Christs bloud is his bloud: so the Sacrament of faith is faith. 2Againe, As then the celestiall bread, Christs flesh, is IN SOME SORT called Christs body, whereas indeed it is a Sacrament of Christs body; namely, that visible, palpable, and mortall body which was nailed on the Crosse, and the sacrificing of his flesh, done by the hands of the Minister, is called Christs Passion, death, and crucifying, NOT IN THE TRƲTH OF THE THING, but in a mysterie SIGNIFYING it: So the Sacrament of faith, by which is meant Baptisme, is faith. 3Also: These, my brethren, are therefore called Sacraments, because in them one thing is seene, another understood. That which is seene hath a bodily forme: that which is understood, hath a spirituall fruit or benefit. 4Chrysostome: This is my bloud, which is shed for the remission of sinnes; which Christ said, to shew that his Passion and Crosse was a mysterie, and to comfort his disciples. 5Theodoret: Our Saviour verily changed the names of the signes and the things signified, and gave the same name to the body, which is proper to the signe; and that to the signe which is proper to the body. The cause of this change is manifest to them that are entred into the first principles of divine mysteries. For he would that they who use the Sacraments should not bend and set their minds on the nature of the things which are seene, but, for the alteration of the names, should beleeve that alteration which is made through grace.