VCommutative justice in punishments, is a virtue observing equality of offences and punishments, inflicting either equal punishments unto the faults, or lesser, being induced thereto upon good cause, according to the respect and consideration to be had of circumstances in civill judgement, for the maintenance of Gods glory, and for the preservation of mens society. For when God forbiddeth the society of men to be harmed or impaired, and will have the Magistrate to be the maintainer of discipline according to the whole Decalogue, he will also have them with just punishments restrained, that make any grievous breach of this order. Wherefore a Magistrate may offend not only in cruelty, or unjust severity, but also in lenity or remissness, and in licensing men to hurt and injure others. Because thou hast let go out of thy hands a man whom I appointed to die, 2thy life shall go for his life, 3and thy people for his people. He that killeth any man, he shall be put to death. Ye shall take no recompense for the life of the murderer, which is worthy to die: 4but he shall be put to death. Life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth. The Fathers shall not be put to death for the children, nor the children put to death for the Fathers, but every man shall be put to death for his own sin. 5Thou shalt make cities of refuge, that innocent blood be not shed within thy Land. Here therefore is commanded, for the defence and safeguard of mens safety, severe justice, which remitteth not punishment without good cause, and observeth equality of the offence and punishment. Whereof it is manifest, that this Commandment doth not take away, but ordain and establish the office of the Magistrate in punishing transgressors.6 He is the Minister of God, and beareth not the sword for nought. For when God commandeth a man to be slain, not men now, but God himself putteth him to death by them, unto whom he giveth this in charge. And that the licentiousness of doing violence or outrage might not grow strong and increase, he would have transgressors ⟨p. 599⟩to be curbed and kept short by punishments. Wherefore the revenge due to Magistrates is comprehended in that saying, Vengeance is mine; I will repay, 7saith the Lord. And hereby is answer made unto this objection, It is said here, thou shalt do no murder: Therefore we must not at all put any man to death:
VCOmmutative justice in punishments, is a vertue observing equality of offences and punishments, inflicting either equall punishments unto the faults, or lesser, being induced thereto upon good cause, according to the respect and consideration to be had of circumstances in civill judgement, for the maintenance of Gods glory, and for the preservation of mens society. For when God forbiddeth the society of men to be harmed or impaired, and will have the Magistrate to be the maintainer of discipline according to the whole Decalogue, he will also have them with just punishments restrained, that make any grievous breach of this order. Wherefore a Magistrate may offend not onely in cruelty, or unjust severity, but also in lenity or remissnesse, and in licencing men to hurt and injure others. Because thou hast let goe out of thy hands a man whom I appointed to die, 2thy life shall goe for his life, 3and thy people for his people. He that killeth any man, he shall be put to death. Yee shall take no recompence for the life of the murtherer, which is worthy to die: 4but he shall be put to death. Life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth. The Fathers shall not be put to death for the children, nor the children put to death for the Fathers, but every man shall be put to death for his owne sin. 5Thou shalt make cities of refuge, that innocent blood be not shed within thy Land. Here therefore is commanded, for the defence and safegard of mens safety, severe justice, which remitteth not punishment without good cause, and observeth equality od the offence and punishment. Whereof it is manifest, that this Commandement doth not take away, but ordaine and establish the office of the Magistrate in punishing transgressors.6 He is the Minister of God, and beareth not the sword for nought. For when God commandeth a man to be slaine, not men now, but God himselfe putteth him to death by them, unto whom he giveth this in charge. And that the licentiousnesse of doing violence or outrage might not grow strong and increase, he would have transgressors ⟨p. 599⟩to be curbed and kept short by punishments. Wherefore the revenge due to Magistrates is comprehended in that saying, Vengeance is mine; I will repay,
- VCommutative justice.Commu•ative justice.
- 21 Kings 20.42.
- 3Levit. 24.17. Numb. 35.31.
- 4Exod. 21.23. Deut. 24.10.
- 5Deut. 19.
- 6Rom. 13.4.
- 7Rom. 12.19.