[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostatical Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Wittenberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostaticall Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Witteberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.
pp. 770–844447 passagespart 11 of 12
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Calling grace, or, of external vocation, is that, by which God is pleased outwardly to call, or invite to faith, obedience, and salvation, by the voice of the Law, men not yet regenerate. Hear, O Israel, &c. Walk in my precepts, &c. Do this, 1&c. And by Evangelical Sermons, Come to me all, &c. Repent, and believe the Gospel. This grace (which is usually called preventing, precedaneous, exciting, inviting, persuading) God did not bestow, in the Old Testament upon every nation, but on Israel only, according to that, He hath declared his Statutes to Israel, he hath not done so to any ⟨p. 834⟩other nation. So in the New Testament, God confers not this grace on all people, but on Christians alone. Now, concerning this grace, we answer to the Question, that it is not irresistible, 2but too much resistible: yea, that the will before conversion can do nothing, but resist this calling grace; seeing the wisdom of the flesh is enmity against God, and is not subject to the Law of God, neither, indeed, can be. Hence are those complaints of God, of Christ, of the Prophets and Apostles in both Testaments, concerning the resistance and contumacy of those who are called:3 I spake to you, rising early in the morning, and calling, and you heard not; I called you, and you did not answer. O, if my people had hearkened to me! If Israel had walked in my ways. How often would I have gathered thee, and thou wouldst not? You always resist the holy Ghost, &c. The Remonstrants in their second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh & eighth Arguments, prove only this, and no other resistibility of grace. What do they then with all these pains, but thresh husks, as they say? For, of the resistibility of this grace, there is no doubt, or question.
Calling grace, or, of externall vocation, is that, by which God is pleased outwardly to call, or invite to faith, obedience, and salvation, by the voice of the Law, men not yet regenerate. Heare, O Israel, &c. Walk in my precepts, &c. Doe this, 1&c. And by Evangelicall Sermons, Come to mee all, &c. Repent, and beleeve the Gospel. This grace (which is usually called preventing, precedaneous, exciting, inviting, perswading) God did not bestow, in the Old Testament upon every nation, but on Israel only, according to that, He hath declared his Statutes to Israel, he hath not done so to any ⟨p. 834⟩other nation. So in the New Testament, God confers not this grace on all people, but on Christians alone. Now, concerning this grace, we answer to the Question, that it is not irresistible, 2but too much resistible: yea, that the will before conversion can doe nothing, but resist this calling grace; seeing the wisdom of the flesh is enmity against God, and is not subject to the Law of God, neither, indeed, can be. Hence are those complaints of God, of Christ, of the Prophets and Apostles in both Testaments, concerning the resistance and contumacie of those who are called:3 I spake to you, rising early in the morning, and calling, and you heard not; I called you, and you did not answer. O, if my people had hearkened to mee! If Israel had walked in my waies. How often would I have gathered thee, and thou wouldst not? You alwaies resist the holy Ghost, &c. The Remonstrants in their second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh & eighth Arguments, prove onely this, and no other resistibilitie of grace. What doe they then with all these paines, but thresh huskes, as they say? For, of the resistibilitie of this grace, there is no doubt, or question.
Co-operating grace (for, of this we will speak first) or subsequent, by them called consequent, is that, by which God inwardly co-operates with the good will of the regenerate man; and, by which, the regenerate man is corroborated in the state of grace.1 Of this it is said, The mercy of the Lord shall follow me all the days of my life. I will put my fear in their hearts, that they shall not depart from me. Thy right Spirit shall lead me in the way of righteousness. God will strengthen you unblameable, even to the end. This is it wch Paul wisheth to all Churches in the end of all his Epistles. And of this also there is no question: For, though God doth never totally nor finally withdraw this from the regenerate (according to his own promises, and their prayers;) yet in his wisdom he so moderates it, that now & then he leaves a wrestling of the spirit & flesh in them; either to free, or humble, or excite, or chastise them. In which sometimes the spirit is mastered by the flesh, sometime the flesh by the spirit: as the fallings, and groanings, and complaints of the Saints witness, and the Apostle confirms, The flesh covets against the spirit, 2and the spirit against the flesh. This also we are content should be called resistible; yet not simply, but in some respect: For this resistibility or resistance is not (as the former) between grace & the will, but between sensuality, or that remainder of the flesh in the Saints, & between grace▪ as the Apostle witnesseth, That which I would, 3I do not; but what I would not, that I do: For, I do not the good, which I would; but the evil, which I would not, that do I. And so, that the flesh at last is overcome by the spirit, sensuality by the regenerate will, & concupiscence by grace.
Co-operating grace (for, of this we will speak first) or subsequent, by them called consequent, is that, by which God inwardly co-operates with the good will of the regenerate man; and, by which, the regenerate man is corroborated in the state of grace.1 Of this it is said, The mercy of the Lord shall follow me all the daies of my life. I will put my fear in their hearts, that they shal not depart from me. Thy right Spirit shal lead me in the way of righteousness. God will strengthen you unblameable, even to the end. This is it wch Paul wisheth to all Churches in the end of all his Epistles. And of this also there is no question: For, though God doth never totally nor finally withdraw this from the regenerate (according to his own promises, and their prayers;) yet in his wisdome he so moderates it, that now & then he leaves a wrestling of the spirit & flesh in them; either to free, or humble, or excite, or chastise them. In which sometimes the spirit is mastered by the flesh, sometime the flesh by the spirit: as the fallings, and groanings, and complaints of the Saints witnesse, and the Apostle confirmes, The flesh covets against the spirit,
Lastly, Operating grace (which by them is confounded with the two former) is the motion of Gods mercy (as Austin calls it) by which he worketh inwardly in the minds, wills, and hearts of the unregenerate these things which belong to mans conversion. This grace or motion is Gods peculiar work, and this is questioned, but not all: for, Scripture and experience witness, that there are three distinct degrees of this grace: For, some God pities so much, that he bestows the gift of illumination and historical faith on them; on others, the gift of temporary faith, and some measure of joy: Lastly, on some, the gift of saving faith and regeneration. This first degree the Remonstrants themselves deny not to be irresistible:1 For, when (say they) God reveals his will, we acknowledge the irresistible virtue of the holy Spirit in our mind; because our mind cannot avoid ipsum scire, or the knowledge it self, and in our soul, when he knocketh: because, nill we, will we, we are forced to feel it. Concerning the resistibility of the second degree, we will not trouble our selves: for, they deny not the illumination of them to be irresistible also. But for the motion to assent, and some measure of joy, they may, for us, think what they please. If they say it is resistible, because the motion doth not so effectually work upon the will, this is nothing to the question. But, for a final resistance, both Scripture and example prove, They receive the word with joy; 2but have no root, who believe for a while, and in time of tentation fail. After that, many of his disciples departed from him. Some have made shipwreck of their faith. Some depart from the faith, denying the Lord that bought them; they forsake the holy doctrine delivered to them.
Lastly, Operating grace (which by them is confounded with the two former) is the motion of Gods mercie (as Austin calls it) by which hee worketh inwardly in the minds, wills, and hearts of the unregenerate these things which belong to mans conversion. This grace or motion is Gods peculiar work, and this is questioned, but not all: for, Scripture and experience witnesse, that there are three distinct degrees of this grace: For, some God pities so much, that he bestowes the gift of illumination and historicall faith on them; on others, the gift of temporarie faith, and some measure of joy: Lastly, on some, the gift of saving faith and regeneration. This first degree the Remonstrants themselves denie not to be irresistible:
The whole question is, concerning the operation of the third degree (which is ⟨p. 835⟩called inward vocation;) that this is the irresistible motion of God, the orthodox Doctors have firmly proved.
1. Because, as God doth irresistibly illuminate those, whom he doth effectually intend to convert; so likewise he doth irresistibly bestow on them, not only the power, but the act also of believing, Phil. 1.29. and 2.13. therefore, by his effectual moving, he doth not only take away resistance, but resistibility also from them. Whereas they object, To you it is given to suffer for Christ: 1this belongs not to the operating, but to the co-operating grace. Of which wrestling we said already:2 therefore 'tis nothing to the purpose. 2. Because God, by converting us, gives us a new heart, and a new spirit: he removes the heart of stone, and gives flesh,3 and makes us walk in his ways. But it is absurd, to imagine a new heart, a new spirit, and the act of walking in Gods laws, with resistance or resistibility, Jer. 31.18. Deut. 29.4. Ezek. 36.26. against which no solid thing is alleged, though much is said. 3. Because the quickening, regeneration, conversion, new creation of the natural man,4 dead in sin, with resistibility, is no less an absurdity,5 then to feign or imagine such a resistance in mans first creation, or daily generation, or last resuscitation, John 3.3. and 5.25. Ephes. 2.5. &c. which reason will never be refuted with verbosity.6
otherwise, no man would come, being drawn:1 and yet for all this, we are not drawn against our will by the Father (which is objected) no more then against our will we are illuminated. 8. Because the gift of faith and repentance is said to be given by Gods Spirit, not only,2 because it is offered to the will irresistibly, but because it is put into the heart, or infused irresistibly,3Joh. 6.63. Eph. 2.8. Phil. 1.19. 2 Tim. 2.25. Rom. 5.5. The contrary cavils are altogether Atheological, or inconsistent with Divinity. 9. Because the resistibility of grace, if there ought to be a conversion, supposeth in the unregenerate will,4 a power of […] resisting; but this the Scripture generally denieth. The Remonstrants will at length consider, whether this reason concludeth not against them. 10. Because, if we yield a resistibility of grace, the work chiefly necessary for our salvation; to wit, faith and repentance, should be placed in mans arbitrement, as in the proximate cause. And the reason of this difference, why of two unregenerate, the one in hearing the Gospel believeth, the other believeth not, should proceed from man: because one would resist grace, the other would not; against that place, Who separated thee? 5What hast thou that thou hast not received? Which is spoken, not only in respect of Infidels (as they think) but likewise in respect of grace: For, if in two Infidels we put grace equally resistible, surely, he that resisteth not grace, but receives it, and believes, he may answer not only to him that resisteth and believeth not, but even to grace,6
and he hath a greater power over mens wills, 1then they have over their own) and who, by an internal and occult, miraculous and ineffable power, worketh in mens hearts, not only new revelations, but also good wills; and this he doth not, but by the wills of men themselves. He, by his grace, worketh faith and conversion in mens hearts, not by a resistible operation, but altogether irresistible, and yet not by coaction. But God hath a most omnipotent power over mens wills, &c. and he worketh upon the same, as he said: Ergo, &c. The Major hath a most evident truth, out of the knitting of the proper cause with its effect, that it cannot be any wise denied. The Assumption Austin teacheth by two examples: the first is out of 1 Sam. 10.26. concerning Saul, to whom, when God would give the kingdom, and the Israelites had power either to resist him, or to submit themselves to him, God touched their hearts, that they neither could, nor would resist: and this he did, by working on their wills. The other is out of 1 Chro. 11. and 12. of David, whom, when God decreed to settle him in the kingdom with better success, the Spirit of the Lord came upon Abisai, a prince among thirty, that he said, We are thine, O David, and will be with thee, thou son of Jesse. Can he (saith Austin) resist the will of God, and not rather do his will, who in his heart did work by his Spirit, which came upon him, that he should will, say, and do this? And by them Almighty God, who was with him brought them to make him king. What? did he bind him with any corporeal bands? He wrought within, he held the heart, he moved the heart, and drew them by their wills, which wills he wrought in them.
and he hath a greater power over mens wills, 1then they have over their owne) and who, by an internall and occult, miraculous and ineffable power, worketh in mens hearts, not onely new revelations, but also good wills; and this he doth not, but by the wills of men themselves. He, by his grace, worketh faith and conversion in mens hearts, not by a resistible operation, but altogether irresistible, and yet not by coaction. But God hath a most omnipotent power over mens wills, &c. and he worketh upon the same, as he said: Ergo, &c. The Major hath a most evident truth, out of the knitting of the proper cause with its effect, that it cannot be any wise denied. The Assumption Austin teacheth by two examples: the first is out of
At length he premises the Conclusion, in these words, No mans free-will resisteth God, when he is willing to save a man: for, to will and nill is so in the power of the willer and niller, that, as it cannot hinder the divine will, so it cannot hinder the divine power. But, lest any should except, that God takes away resistance, but not resistibility, he adds further, It is therefore out of doubt, that mens wills cannot resist the will of God, who hath done in heaven and earth whatsoever he pleased, and who hath also done these things that are to come; he cannot, I say, resist or hinder him from doing that which he pleaseth, seeing that even upon mens wills he worketh what he pleaseth. It is therefore most clear, that this holy Father doth strongly assever the irresistible operation of divine grace, not only in mans conversion and salvation, but also in directing of other difficult actions: such as is the election of Kings, and this for the glory of God. And that he also refutes the vain pretexts of resistibility and coaction. 13. If the grace, that worketh faith and conversion, is not irresistible, after the manner we speak of, but resistible, that it may, or may not be hindered by mens wills; it follows, that all is vain verbal smoke, what they ascribe so magnifically to Gods grace in the third and fourth Article: and, that these effects, which they speak of, are not to be attributed to Gods grace only indifferently and remotely, but to mens unresisting wills specifically and proximately, which appears thus:
At length he premises the Conclusion, in these words, No mans free-will resisteth God, when he is willing to save a man: for, to will and nill is so in the power of the willer and niller, that, as it cannot hinder the divine will, so it cannot hinder the divine power. But, lest any should except, that God takes away resistance, but not resistibility, he addes further, It is therefore out of doubt, that mens wills cannot resist the will of God, who hath done in heaven and earth whatsoever he pleased, and who hath also done these things that are to come; he cannot, I say, resist or hinder him from doing that which he pleaseth, seeing that even upon mens wills he worketh what he pleaseth. It is therefore most cleere, that this holy Father doth strongly assever the irresistible operation of divine grace, not only in mans conversion and salvation, but also in directing of other difficult actions: such as is the election of Kings, and this for the glory of God. And that he also refutes the vain pretexts of resistibility and coaction. 13. If the grace, that worketh faith and conversion, is not irresistible, after the maner we speak of, but resistible, that it may, or may not be hindred by mens wills; it followes, that all is vaine verball smoak, what they ascribe so magnifically to Gods grace in the third and fourth Article: and, that these effects, which they speak of, are not to be attributed to Gods grace only indifferently and remotely, but to mens unresisting wills specifically and proximately, which appeares thus:
The effect of that cause, which works resistibly; that is, so that its production or inhibition, may depend from another resisting, or not resisting cause: if it be produced, the production thereof is to be ascribed indifferently and remotely to the worker, specifically and proximately to him who resisteth not, but admits it: On the contrary, if it be hindered, the inhibition thereof is to be attributed specifically and proximately to the resister, or him that will not admit it: For example, A Prince proposeth a reward to many of his subjects resistibly, that he who will fight may have it, he that will not, may not have it: The Princes action is indifferent to these many: he that will fight, doth well specificate the Princes action, because he is to receive the reward; but he that will not fight, doth not specificate it well; because he is to want the reward. Who seeth not, that as well the one as the other action is specifically and proximately to be ascribed to him that will fight, or not fight; but to the Prince indifferently, and remotely? I will add another, by which, in my hearing once resistible grace was declared: A father sets down on the table a dish of meat equally to his children, but resistibly, that he who will may have meat, who will not, may not have it. Here the fathers operation is indifferent to all: they that will take the meat, do specificate it well; but they that will not, specificate it ill. ⟨p. 837⟩Who now again doth not see, that the meat is to be ascribed specifically and proximately to the takers, but to the father indifferently and remotely? Such is the resistibility of grace, which these men teach.
The effect of that cause, which works resistibly; that is, so that its production or inhibition, may depend from another resisting, or not resisting cause: if it be produced, the production thereof is to be ascribed indifferently and remotely to the worker, specifically and proximately to him who resisteth not, but admits it: On the contrary, if it be hindred, the inhibition thereof is to be attributed specifically and proximately to the resister, or him that will not admit it: For example, A Prince proposeth a reward to many of his subjects resistibly, that he who will fight may have it, he that will not, may not have it: The Princes action is indifferent to these many: he that will fight, doth well specificate the Princes action, because he is to receive the reward; but he that will not fight, doth not specificate it well; because he is to want the reward. Who seeth not, that as well the one as the other action is specifically and proximately to be ascribed to him that will fight, or not fight; but to the Prince indifferently, and remotely? I will adde another, by which, in my hearing once resistible grace was declared: A father sets down on the table a dish of meat equally to his children, but resistibly, that he who will may have meat, who will not, may not have it. Here the fathers operation is indifferent to all: they that will take the meat, doe specificate it well; but they that will not, specificate it ill.
But if this be so, all the effects of grace must needs be deluding and false, which they rehearse: deluding or false, because man hath not faith from himself, or by force of his free-will: but he shall have from himself the specification of the working of grace, because, by being unwilling to resist grace, he hath severed himself from others; because of himself he cannot think, will, or do good: for, of ones self to specificate well, a resistible, indifferent operation is a good thing; because God, by his holy Spirit, doth regenerate and renew us, &c. For, God doth not by his Spirit renew and regenerate us, but indifferently, remotely, resistibly, and therefore improperly: but we regenerate and renew our selves specifically, proximately, and properly; because this grace is the beginning (for of the progress and perfection of this grace, the question is not) of all good: for, the beginning of a good specification of a resistible and indifferent operation of grace, is good, from our not resisting, &c.
But if this be so, all the effects of grace must needs be deluding and false, which they rehearse: deluding or false, because man hath not faith from himself, or by force of his free-will: but he shal have from himself the specification of the working of grace, because, by being unwilling to resist grace, he hath severed himself from others; because of himself he cannot think, will, or do good: for, of ones self to specificate well, a resistible, indifferent operation is a good thing; because God, by his holy Spirit, doth regenerate and renew us, &c. For, God doth not by his Spirit renew and regenerate us, but indifferently, remotely, resistibly, and therefore improperly: but we regenerate and renew our selves specifically, proximately, and properly; because this grace is the beginning (for of the progresse and perfection of this grace, the question is not) of all good: for, the beginning of a good specification of a resistible and indifferent operation of grace, is good, from our not resisting, &c.
What besides? We must ask of God only such an operation of grace as is resistible and indifferent: and only for this grace must we thank God; the not resistance and good specification of grace, shall be in our will and power. Is not God here robbed of his glory? Hath not man reason to sacrifice to his own net, that he may be puffed up with pride against God, and that he may say, I have separated my self? This is to be cast headlong with Satan into hell fire: but, if of our selves we do not resist resistible grace, if we receive that grace which is offered, & specificate that which is indifferent (which, with the closure of the fourth Article, do necessarily cohere) is not this to establish the idol of free-will? Original sin is by this denied, and the natural mans native impotency, corruption, and pravity, of which God so often complains in Scripture; and so do the Prophets, and Apostles, and the Saints themselves. What will become of our Catechism, which saith, That by nature we are propense to hate God and our neighbour, that we are so corrupt, that to do well we are altogether unapt. This sure is it which resistible grace goeth about to abolish.
What besides? We must aske of God only such an operation of grace as is resistible and indifferent: and onely for this grace must we thank God; the not resistance and good specification of grace, shall be in our will and power. Is not God here robbed of his glory? Hath not man reason to sacrifice to his owne net, that he may be puffed up with pride against God, and that he may say, I have separated my self? This is to be cast headlong with Satan into hell fire: but, if of our selves we do not resist resistible grace, if we receive that grace which is offered, & specificate that which is indifferent (which, with the closure of the fourth Article, doe necessarily cohere) is not this to establish the idoll of free-will? Originall sin is by this denied, and the naturall mans native impotencie, corruption, and pravitie, of which God so often complains in Scripture; and so do the Prophets, and Apostles, and the Saints themselves. What will become of our Catechisme, which saith, That by nature we are propense to hate God and our neighbour, that we are so corrupt, that to doe well we are altogether unapt. This sure is it which resistible grace goe•h about to abolish.
Out of all this it is manifest, that the Remonstrants in both Articles,1 especially in the closure of the fourth, either abuse the equivocation of the word grace explained above, affirming, that the operation of calling, persuading, exciting grace (which they call adventitious and precedaneous) is resistible, which orthodoxall men deny not; and so, with vain debates, they trouble the Church and State: or, by understanding the operation of grace, producing faith and conversion, they dangerously corrupt the doctrine of grace with Pelagius: or lastly, they do entangle themselves again with the knot of contradiction, in ascribing to operating grace alone faith and conversion, and making the same resistible; that is, indifferently depending from the will of man. Again, while they profess, that faith is the mere gift of God, and yet make the same to depend resistibly from the assent of mans will, they fall into such contradictions, that no Sophistry can reconcile. But,2 when the Adversary (as we said before) is forced to contradict himself, it is known, that he is subdued.
Out of all this it is manifest, that the Remonstrants in both Articles,1 especially in the closure of the fourth, either abuse the equivocation of the word grace explained above, affirming, that the operation of calling, perswading, exciting grace (which they call adventitious and precedaneous) is resistible, which orthodoxall men deny not; and so, with vain debates, they trouble the Church and State: or, by understanding the operation of grace, producing faith and conversion, they dangerously corrupt the doctrine of grace with Pelagius: or lastly, they do entangle themselves again with the knot of contradiction, in ascribing to operating grace alone faith and conversion, and making the same resistible; that is, indifferently depending from the will of man. Again, while they professe, that faith is the meer gift of God, and yet make the same to depend resistibly from the assent of mans will, they fall into such contradictions, that no Sophistry can reconcile. But,2 when the Adversary (as we said before) is forced to contradict himselfe, it is knowne, that he is subdued.
They deny, that grace (whether resistible,1 or not) proceeds from Gods absolute decree; for this they hate worse then dog or snake. But it is sufficient, that the Apostle witnesseth this, where he conjoins vocation, not external only,2 but most properly internal justification, the producer of faith, immediately with predestination, as the effect with the first cause. But what-ever this is, it will no wise help their turn. Suppose there were no predestination in heaven, no election; yet this most firm principle of Scripture remains asserted by Austin in the fore-alleged places, That Almighty God hath a most omnipotent power over the wills of men; and, that he can, according to his pleasure, either leave the wills themselves in their sins, or incline them to good: i.e. make them irresistible to his grace. With which principle, if resistibility of grace could stand, which they feign; i.e. the imbecility and indifferency for effecting of faith, and that power of mens wills in rebelling against grace, and God himself, working in man; I say, if these could stand, God could not be Almighty, nor would there ever be any conversion of man to God, nor regeneration; which is so evident, that no Sophistry can elude it. And this is sufficient concerning the 3d. & 4th. Article. And how tolerable these are, every man may see.
They deny, that grace (whether resistible,1 or not) proceeds from Gods absolute decree; for this they hate worse then dog or snake. But it is sufficient, that the Apostle witnesseth this, where he conjoynes vocation, not externall onely,2 but most properly internall justification, the producer of faith, immediately with predestination, as the effect with the first cause. But what-ever this is, it will no wise help their turn. Suppose there were no predestination in heaven, no election; yet this most firm principle of Scripture remains asserted by Austin in the fore-alledged places, That Almighty God hath a most omnipotent power over the wills of men; and, that he can, according to his pleasure, either leave the wills themselves in their sins, or encline them to good: i.e. make them irresistible to his grace. With which principle, if resistibilitie of grace could stand, which they feign; i.e. the imbecillitie and indifferencie for effecting of faith, and that power of mens wils in rebelling against grace, and God himself, working in man; I say, if these could stand, God could not be Almighty, nor would there ever be any conversion of man to God, nor regeneration; which is so evident, that no Sophistry can elude it. And this is sufficient concerning the 3d. & 4th. Article. And how tolerable these are, every man may see.
Who are by true faith engrafted into Jesus Christ, and therefore partakers of his quickening Spirit; they have power sufficient to fight against Satan, sin, the world, and their own flesh, and to obtain the victory: but, by the help of the grace of the holy Spirit. So Jesus Christ is present by his spirit to them in all tentations, stretching out his hand, and confirming them, if they be ready for the combat, if they require his help, nor be wanting to themselves; and this so much,1 that by no cunning of Satan, or strength, can they be seduced, or taken out of Christs hands, according to that of John 10. No man can take them out of mine hand. But whether these same may not, by their negligence, desert their beginning in Christ, and embrace again this present world; and, whether they may not fall off from the holy doctrine, once delivered to them, make shipwreck of their consciences, and fall away from grace, ought to be weighed fully out of holy Scriptures, before they can be taught with full tranquillity of mind, and plenitude of confidence.
Who are by true faith ingraffed into Jesus Christ, and therefore partakers of his quickning Spirit; they have power sufficient to fight against Satan, sin, the world, and their owne flesh, and to obtain the victory: but, by the help of the grace of the holy Spirit. So Jesus Christ is present by his spirit to them in all tentations, stretching out his hand, and confirming them, if they be ready for the combate, if they require his help, nor be wanting to themselves; and this so much,1 that by no cunning of Satan, or strength, can they be seduced, or taken out of Christs hands, according to that of John 10. No man can take them out of mine hand. But whether these same may not, by their negligence, desert their beginning in Christ, and embrace again this present world; and, whether they may not fall off from the holy doctrine, once delivered to them, make shipwrack of their consciences, and fall away from grace, ought to be weighed fully out of holy Scriptures, before they can be taught with full tranquillitie of mind, and plenitude of confidence.
Whereas the Remonstrants in this Article profess, that they deliver in their Conference the doctrine of the Saints perseverance in faith, we may justly wonder why they are so wary, in expressing the word perseverance, or persevering: and much more, why they are afraid once to name God; except it be, because they betray in the adversative clause, that they would have both the name and the thing quite extermined out of the Church. But their consciences did so dictate to them, that God would never bless so wicked a design, that they cannot endure perseverance should be called the gift of God:1 and are not ashamed to write, that it is ill done to call it so. But, if we must speak the truth, by this means they do too much bewray their perverseness and ignorance: For, is it not perverseness to say, that is not rightly called the gift of God, which God hath so often in Scripture promised to bestow upon the faithful; and which the Saints so earnestly desire God to bestow on them? Is it not ignorance to deny perseverance to be a gift, and that infused; and not to think, that perseverance is nothing else, but faith it self persevering to the end? But, is not faith the gift of God infused?2 Do not they themselves confess, that it is the mere gift of God?
WHereas the Remonstrants in this Article professe, that they deliver in their Conference the doctrine of the Saints perseverance in faith, wee may justly wonder why they are so wary, in expressing the word perseverance, or persevering: and much more, why they are afraid once to name God; except it be, because they betray in the adversative clause, that they would have both the name and the thing quite extermined out of the Church. But their consciences did so dictate to them, that God would never blesse so wicked a designe, that they cannot endure perseverance should be called the gift of God:1 and are not ashamed to write, that it is ill done to call it so. But, if we must speak the truth, by this means they do too much bewray their perversnesse and ignorance: For, is it not perversnesse to say, that is not rightly called the gift of God, which God hath so often in Scripture promised to bestow upon the faithfull; and which the Saints so earnestly desire God to bestow on them? Is it not ignorance to deny perseverance to be a gift, and that infused; and not to think, that perseverance is nothing else, but faith it selfe persevering to the end? But, is not faith the gift of God infused?
But they cannot be ignorant, that Austin, in a book by it self, asserted the gift of perseverance against the remainders of the Pelagians, to which book he gave the title, Of the good of perseverance: the argument thereof is nothing else but the same; to wit, That perseverance in faith to the end, is the gift of God, is to be sought of God, and is given truly to all that are called and predestinate, according to the purpose of God. This is Austins opinion. These men, throughout all their Conference, as appears, can well enough endure the perseverance of the Saints: but no ways that it should proceed from predestination, as the effect from the cause; or, that it should be held certain, seeing all the engines of these five Articles are devised and directed, to overthrow the counsel of Gods discretive predestination: And, on the contrary, to erect the idol of self-power in us. But let us weigh the words of this fifth Article.
But they cannot be ignorant, that Austin, in a book by it selfe, asserted the gift of perseverance against the remainders of the Pelagians, to which book he gave the title, Of the good of perseverance: the argument thereof is nothing else but the same; to wit, That perseverance in faith to the end, is the gift of God, is to be sought of God, and is given truly to all that are called and predestinate, according to the purpose of God. This is Austins opinion. These men, throughout all their Conference, as appeares, can well enough endure the perseverance of the Saints: but no waies that it should proceed from predestination, as the effect from the cause; or, that it should be held certaine, seeing all the engines of these five Articles are devised and directed, to overthrow the counsell of Gods discretive predestination: And, on the contrary, to erect the idoll of self-power in us. But let us weigh the words of this fifth Article.
The fifth answereth the fourth: For, whereas the fourth, with the third, is very bountiful, in extolling of grace; but what it gave, in the last clause it took away: so this very carefully provides for the means and security of salvation in the faithful, in the three former parts; for, it is quadripartite, as it seems: 1. That they have means sufficient to resist Satan and sin, by the help of grace. 2. That Jesus Christ in all tentations is present with them, and reacheth out his hands to them. 3. That he so confirms them, that they cannot be seduced, or taken out of Christs hands by any deceit or violence of Satan. With such large privileges they have sufficiently provided for perseverance.
The fifth answereth the fourth: For, whereas the fourth, with the third, is very bountifull, in extolling of grace; but what it gave, in the last clause it took away: so this very carefully provides for the means and security of salvation in the faithfull, in the three former parts; for, it is quadripartite, as it seems: 1. That they have meanes sufficient to resist Satan and sin, by the help of grace. 2. That Jesus Christ in all tentations is present with them, and reacheth out his hands to them. 3. That he so confirmes them, that they cannot be seduced, or taken out of Christs hands by any deceit or violence of Satan. With such large priviledges they have sufficiently provided for perseverance.
But, as before, so here, there is poison in the tail: for, what they granted in the adversative appendix, they call it in question: in their Conference they plainly take it away; yet, nor without buskin-phrases, but such, as bring in the same inconveniences, which before they did: so that either they betray themselves to be equivocating disturbers, ⟨p. 839⟩or entangle themselves with contradictions; which thus appear.
But, as before, so here, there is poyson in the taile: for, what they granted in the adversative appendix, they call it in question: in their Conference they plainly take it away; yet, nor without buskin-phrases, but such, as bring in the same inconveniencies, which before they did: so that either they betray themselves to be equivocating disturbers, ⟨p. 839⟩or entangle themselves with contradictions; which thus appeare.
In the appendix or addition they say, But whether they, who by true faith are inserted into Jesus Christ, and therefore partakers of his quickening Spirit, may not forsake the beginning of their being in Christ, fall away from faith, lose grace, is to be more exactly considered out of Scripture, before they can teach it with confidence; that is, they doubt whether it be true. But, if before they speak the truth, they cannot doubt of this: For, if they, who by true faith are inserted into Christ, have sufficient strength to obtain the victory over sin, Satan, &c. and Christ in all tentations is present with them, and reacheth out his hand, that they cannot be seduced or taken out of Christs hand, by any cunning or strength of Satan; how, I pray, can it be doubted, but that such, by reason of the helps given to them by Christ, and by reason of his assistance, and of his confirming and aiding of them in all tentations; but chiefly of defection, can never forsake the beginning of their being in Christ, can never fall away from faith, and can never be robbed of their grace? In questioning then that which before they asserted, and that, indeed, most truly, do not they fight against themselves?
In the appendix or addition they say, But whether they, who by true faith are inserted into Jesus Christ, and therefore partakers of his quickning Spirit, may not forsake the beginning of their being in Christ, fall away from faith, lose grace, is to be more exactly considered out of Scripture, before they can teach it with confidence; that is, they doubt whether it be true. But, if before they speak the truth, they cannot doubt of this: For, if they, who by true faith are inserted into Christ, have sufficient strength to obtaine the victory over sin, Satan, &c. and Christ in all tentations is present with them, and reacheth out his hand, that they cannot be seduced or taken out of Christs hand, by any cunning or strength of Satan; how, I pray, can it be doubted, but that such, by reason of the helps given to them by Christ, and by reason of his assistance, and of his confirming and aiding of them in all tentations; but chiefly of defection, can never forsake the beginning of their being in Christ, can never fall away from faith, and can never be robbed of their grace? In questioning then that which before they asserted, and that, indeed, most truly, doe not they fight against themselves?
They except, that their assertion is not categorical, but conditional, that Christ, by his Spirit, is present with them, that he stretcheth out his hand to them, and confirms them that are inserted into him by true faith, if so be they are ready for the fight, and beg his help, nor be wanting in performance of their duty, &c. But that this condition is not placed or performed by many, and that therefore no conflict follows. But, I pray, what kind of God do they feign here, (whom secretly they exclude?) What kind of Christ? What kind of Spirit? To wit, such an one, who, indeed, furnisheth those who by true faith are engrafted into Christ, with the means of resistible grace; but doth not fit them for the combat in their tentations, suffers them so to snort, that they seek not for his help, that they are wanting in the performance of their duty; but Gods promises and asseverations do teach far otherwise: for, albeit the condition of the combat, of prayers and vigilancie, which they require, be altogether necessary for perseverance; yet, that this is not so much proposed by the faithful (which is all these men would have) as effected by the Spirit of God in the faithful, is clear by these and such like testimonies:1 The Lord thy God shall circumcise thine heart, and the heart of thy seed, that thou mayest love the Lord thy God with all thine heart. I will put my fear in their hearts, that they shall not depart from me. Which words Austin citing, for the good of perseverance, thus explains, So great shall my fear be, which I will put in their hearts, that they shall adhere to me continually. I will put my Spirit in the midst of you, and I will make, that you shall walk in my precepts, and keep my judgements, and do them. This shall be my covenant with them, saith the Lord: My Spirit, which is in thee, and my words, which I have put in thee, shall not depart from thy mouth. I will pour upon the house of David, and upon the inhabitants of Jerusalem, 2the spirit of grace and supplication, and they shall look on me whom they have pierced &c. God will strengthen you even to the end. He that hath begun in you a good work, will perfect it, until the day of the Lord Jesus, who, by the power of God, are kept by faith to salvation, &c.
They except, that their assertion is not categoricall, but conditionall, that Christ, by his Spirit, is present with them, that hee stretcheth out his hand to them, and confirmes them that are inserted into him by true faith, if so be they are ready for the fight, and beg his help, nor be wanting in performance of their duty, &c. But that this condition is not placed or performed by many, and that therefore no conflict followes. But, I pray, what kind of God doe they feigne here, (whom secretly they exclude?) What kind of Christ? What kind of Spirit? To wit, such an one, who, indeed, furnisheth those who by true faith are engraffed into Christ, with the meanes of resistible grace; but doth not fit them for the combate in their tentations, suffers them so to snort, that they seek not for his help, that they are wanting in the performance of their dutie; but Gods promises and asseverations doe teach far otherwise: for, albeit the condition of the combate, of prayers and vigilancie, which they require, be altogether necessary for perseverance; yet, that this is not so much proposed by the faithfull (which is all these men would have) as effected by the Spirit of God in the faithfull, is cleere by these and such like testimonies:
Either these are vain promises, which God forbid, or the assumption is false, that the condition is not proposed or performed by many, who are not engrafted into Christ by true faith.
Either these are vaine promises, which God forbid, or the assumption is false, that the condition is not proposed or performed by many, who are not engraffed into Christ by true faith.
Cavilling to the contrary will not avail, That these promises are not absolute, but to be understood with a condition, to be performed by the faithful: that being strictly understood, they exclude the least offences of the Saints: that a condition is commanded, not promised, &c. which are vain shifts: For, the promises speak plainly concerning the very condition of faith, prayers, perseverance in the faithful to be wrought by the holy Ghost. Nor will it follow, that the working of perseverance is not promised, because it is commanded, and required of the faithful: For, it is commanded also, that they fear God, that they walk in the commandments of God, &c. and yet God promiseth, I will put my fear, &c. I will make them to walk in my precepts. Now, this is commanded, not because they can, but because they should do what is required; and,1 For this cause (saith Austin) God commands some things, which we cannot do, that we may know what to beg of him. Hearing then the command, they ask for that which is commanded, saying with Austin, Give me what thou commandest, and command what thou wilt. 2Which ⟨p. 840⟩words of mine (saith he) Pelagius at Rome could not endure, when they were rehearsed by a certain brother, a fellow Bishop of mine, in his presence, and in an angry way contradicting him, he had almost fallen foul with him that did repeat them: The orthodox men at this day are in the like condition with them; and yet these promises do not exclude the failings of the Saints, whether their sins be great or small, but they lift up those that are fallen from their fall: for these promises are sometimes also directed to just men that fall;3 If the righteous fall, he shall not be bruised, because the Lord supporteth him. If his sons shall forsake my Law▪ &c. I will visit with the rod their transgressions, but my mercy I will not take from him.
Cavilling to the contrary will not availe, That these promises are not absolute, but to be understood with a condition, to be performed by the faithfull: that being strictly understood, they exclude the least offences of the Saints: that a condition is commanded, not promised, &c. which are vaine shifts: For, the promises speak plainly concerning the very condition of faith, prayers, perseverance in the faithfull to be wrought by the holy Ghost. Nor will it follow, that the working of perseverance is not promised, because it is commanded, and required of the faithfull: For, it is commanded also, that they feare God, that they walke in the commandements of God, &c. and yet God promiseth, I will put my feare, &c. I will make them to walk in my precepts. Now, this is commanded, not because they can, but because they should do what is required; and,
If then this Article in the three former members is true and certain, as it is most true and certain, it cannot by the condition inserted be excused from this manifest conflict, and contradiction of the adversative addition, thus: All engrafted into Christ by true faith, and therefore partakers of his quickening Spirit, are so confirmed by Christ, that by no deceit of Satan, or by any force can they be seduced, or taken out of Christs hand: this is true and certain: and, All engrafted into Christ by true faith are so confirmed, that they cannot be seduced nor taken from Christ: this is not true and certain, but doubtful and uncertain, and more exactly to be weighed according to Scripture. This conflict again is a manifest argument of an evil cause, and a bad conscience; neither do they elude the conflict, but tie the knot, while they say, That they question not the doctrinal point of perseverance, 1but desire only to be further instructed: But they dispute so through all their Conference of the perseverance of the Saints, and they desire to be instructed, that among their divers tergiversations, they may prove the very same to be plainly false and impious, which in the former members of the Article they did assever to be true and certain.
If then this Article in the three former members is true and certaine, as it is most true and certaine, it cannot by the condition inserted be excused from this manifest conflict, and contradiction of the adversative addition, thus: All ingraffed into Christ by true faith, and therefore partakers of his quickning Spirit, are so confirmed by Christ, that by no deceit of Satan, or by any force can they be seduced, or taken out of Christs hand: this is true and certaine: and, All ingraffed into Christ by true faith are so confirmed, that they cannot be seduced nor taken from Christ: this is not true and certaine, but doubtfull and uncertaine, and more exactly to be weighed according to Scripture. This conflict againe is a manifest argument of an evill cause, and a bad conscience; neither doe they elude the conflict, but tye the knot, while they say, That they question not the doctrinall point of perseverance, 1but desire onely to be further instructed: But they dispute so through all their Conference of the perseverance of the Saints, and they desire to be instructed, that among their divers tergiversations, they may prove the very same to be plainly false and impious, which in the former members of the Article they did assever to be true and certaine.
Furthermore, in the same Conference every-where, whether it be to avoid this conflict, or to draw envy upon orthodox men, sophistically changing the subject of the Article, they write, that our orthodox Divines teach, That they who once believed, can never again fall, 1nor shall fall; but are persuaded, that, let them sin as often as they will, they can never lose their faith, nor fall from grace, but inevitably shall persevere, and shall be saved: And it is but only this opinion of perseverance (as they say,) or manner of it, which they call in question,2 or dislike: For the refuting then, and overthrowing of which, the engines of seven Arguments are properly directed to overthrow the orthodox doctrine:3 1. Because of it self it is repugnant to true piety and good works;4 or, because the preaching of it is scandalous,5 and the belief of it licentious. 2. Because it takes away the means of exhortations,6 promises,7 and threatenings, &c. 3. Because it makes the warnings and caveats which the holy Ghost gives us against Satan's treacheries ineffectual.8 4. Because examples testify, that many who have believed, have totally and finally fallen from the faith. 5. Because many faithful men are recorded to have fallen grievously, and that they have committed the works of the flesh, and heinous wickedness, with which filthy deeds faith could not consist. 6. Because, this being granted, all baptised Infants, that are borne of faithful Parents▪ should be saved. 7. Because many faithful men do so defile themselves with wickedness, that they are to be excommunicated, and are excommunicated by the Ministers of the Church.
Furthermore, in the same Conference every-where, whether it be to avoid this conflict, or to draw envy upon orthodox men, sophistically changing the subject of the Article, they write, that our orthodox Divines teach, That they who once beleeved, can never againe fall,
But truly, if this be all, and only this, which they question and oppose, they show themselves to be vain wranglers; I will not say, rash disturbers of the Church and State, who make such stir about an opinion, which the orthodox, no less then themselves, would have, not only to be examined according to Scripture; but also, as a scandalous doctrine, and manifestly false, they oppose it, reprove it, and judge it fitting to be thrust out of the Church: or surely, they fasten a notable calumny upon orthodox men, fathering an opinion upon them, which they do no ways acknowledge to be theirs. And therefore these seven engines of Arguments beat upon that false opinion only, and no ways hurt the orthodoxall Tenet, as is showed in the Conference. Now the Calumnies appear thus:1
But truly, if this be all, and onely this, which they question and oppose, they shew themselves to be vaine wranglers; I will not say, rash disturbers of the Church and State, who make such stirre about an opinion, which the orthodox, no lesse then themselves, would have, not onely to be examined according to Scripture; but also, as a scandalous doctrine, and manifestly false, they oppose it, reprove it, and judge it fitting to be thrust out of the Church: or surely, they fasten a notable calumny upon orthodox men, fathering an opinion upon them, which they do no wayes acknowledge to be theirs. And therefore these seven engines of Arguments beate upon that false opinion onely, and no wayes hurt the orthodoxall Tenet, as is shewed in the Conference. Now the Calumnies appeare thus:1
The first is in the Subject, who once believe: For the Orthodox do not affirm, that all such persevere, whereas, hypocrites also, and temporary believers, not perseverers are said equivocally to believe: but of these only they speak, who by true faith are inserted into Christ,1 and are partakers of his quickening spirit.
The first is in the Subject, who once beleeve: For the Orthodox do not affirme, that all such persevere, whereas, hypocrites also, and temporary beleevers, not perseverers are said equivocally to beleeve: but of these onely they speake, who by true faith are inserted into Christ,1 and are partakers of his quickning spirit.
The other Calumny is in the first Attribute, That they can never, nor ever shall fall; for, both Scripture and experience testify, and the Orthodox think and teach, that the Saints, or such as are engrafted into Christ, being they are men, and subject to humane infirmities, may not only fall, but have oftentimes fallen through the infirmities of their flesh, into small and great sins. The third is in the other Attribute, Let faithful men sin never so much, yet they may and ought to be persuaded of their perseverance; and this is that absurd doctrine of the Saints perseverance. But this is as foolish and plain a piece of Sophistry or fallacy of the accident, as if they had said, Because sound men may and ought to run and labour; so sick men, who are in a Fever, or in a fit of the Gout, may and should run and labour: but as sickly dispositions accidentally hinder the vital actions of the body, so the infirmities of the flesh accidentally hinder the spiritual operations of faith and of the Spirit.
The other Calumny is in the first Attribute, That they can never, nor ever shall fall; for, both Scripture and experience testifie, and the Orthodox think and teach, that the Saints, or such as are ingraffed into Christ, being they are men, and subject to humane infirmities, may not onely fall, but have oftentimes fallen through the infirmities of their flesh, into small and great sins. The third is in the other Attribute, Let faithfull men sin never so much, yet they may and ought to be perswaded of their perseverance; and this is that absurd doctrine of the Saints perseverance. But this is as foolish and plaine a piece of Sophistry or fallacy of the accident, as if they had said, Because sound men may and ought to run and labour; so sick men, who are in a Fever, or in a fit of the Gout, may and should run and labour: but as sickly dispositions accidentally hinder the vitall actions of the body, so the infirmities of the flesh accidentally hinder the spirituall operations of faith and of the Spirit.
The fourth Calumny is in the third Attribute, The faithful can never lose their faith, nor fall from grace. This sounds to them as an absolute impossibility; but the Orthodox use a limitation thus; The faithful cannot fall, if you look upon Gods gracious promises: for, the holy Ghost is a faithful keeper, and the counsel of God, concerning the salvation of such as are predestinated is unchangeable; and that out of the mouth of our Saviour, Mat. 24.24. John 10.28. But if we look upon the treacheries and strength of Satan, and the infirmities of the faithful, when they are left to themselves, then they are too part, and that every moment to be supplanted by Satan and their own flesh:1 and they openly profess, that in that respect they may fall away and perish.
The fourth Calumnie is in the third Attribute, The faithfull can never lose their faith, nor fall from grace. This sounds to them as an absolute impossibility; but the Orthodox use a limitation thus; The faithfull cannot fall, if you looke upon Gods gracious promises: for, the holy Ghost is a faithfull keeper, and the counsell of God, concerning the salvation of such as are predestinated is unchangeable; and that out of the mouth of our Saviour, Mat. 24.24. John 10.28. But if we looke upon the treacheries and strength of Satan, and the infirmities of the faithfull, when they are left to themselves, then they are too part, and that every moment to be supplanted by Satan and their owne flesh:1 and they openly professe, that in that respect they may fall away and perish.
The fifth is in the same Attribute; To lose faith, to fall from grace: which these men understand absolutely; but the Orthodox understand a limitation; That they cannot lose faith, nor fall from grace altogether or totally; to wit so, as to become of faithful men Infidels, and enemies to God, as they that sin before regeneration: which is false, both by testimony of Scripture and experience.
The fifth is in the same Attribute; To lose faith, to fall from grace: which these men understand absolutely; but the Orthodox understand a limitation; That they cannot lose faith, nor fall from grace altogether or totally; to wit so, as to become of faithfull men Infidels, and enemies to God, as they that sin before regeneration: which is false, both by testimonie of Scripture and experience.
The sixth is in the fourth Attribute, But shall persevere inevitably. They think that we mean any sort of men, even such as are carnally secure, as if they should persevere, nill they will they: which is far from the mind and candour of orthodox Divines. And so, having unfolded their buskins, and removed the calumnies, that the orthodoxall doctrine, concerning the perseverance of the Saints in faith, is true and sound, is showed by ten Arguments, taken out of the Scripture in the Conference.
The sixth is in the fourth Attribute, But shall persevere inevitably. They think that we meane any sort of men, even such as are carnally secure, as if they should persevere, nill they will they: which is farre from the minde and candor of orthodox Divines. And so, having unfolded their buskins, and removed the calumnies, that the orthodoxall doctrine, concerning the perseverance of the Saints in faith, is true and sound, is shewed by ten Arguments, taken out of the Scripture in the Conference.
1. Because God in his word hath promised to the faithful in Christ,1 a total and final perseverance, Jer. 32.40. Psal. 125.1. John 10.28. &c. Therefore he performs it, because he cannot lye. This is Austin's first Argument for the good of perseverance.2 2. Because the Apostles witness, that God doth, and will faithfully perform his promises, concerning their preservation in the faith. 1 Cor. 1.8. & 10.13. Phil. 1.6. 1 Thes. 5.23. &c. 3. Because, out of the Apostles doctrine,3Rom. 8.30. the perseverance of those that are called according to Gods Decree, is the proper effect of predestination; so that Bellarmine himself, a great Patron of indifferent or resistible grace, doth plainly confess, That perseverance is the most proper effect of predestination, so that without perseverance, predestination cannot be fulfilled. 4. Because Christ prayed,4 and doth pray for the perseverance not of Peter alone, but of all who were to believe by the Apostles preaching; but the Father always hears the Son, Luke 22.32. Joh. 17.20. John 11.42. &c. 5. Because they that are engrafted into Christ by true faith,5
Against these points, all that with much verbosity are handled by the Novelists in the Conference, from page 414. to page 459. come to this one point of the condition required in the faithful, which exception we have already showed both to be weak, and also to be overthrown by the promises themselves; now all are reduced to this one solid and unanswerable demonstration, from the position of sufficient causes, to the position of the effect, thus:
Against these points, all that with much verbosity are handled by the Novelists in the Conference, from page 414. to page 459. come to this one point of the condition required in the faithfull, which exception wee have already shewed both to be weake, and also to be overthrowne by the promises themselves; now all are reduced to this one solid and unanswerable demonstration, from the position of sufficient causes, to the position of the effect, thus:
To whom God hath promised to give certainly perseverance in faith, and who are kept by the power of God in faith to the end, and for whose perseverance Christ hath prayed, and doth pray; and who pray themselves incessantly for the same; and whose perseverance is grounded in Gods eternal predestination: their perseverance in true faith unto the end is not doubtful, but sure, according to the Scripture: All engrafted into Christ by true faith are such, to whom God hath promised to give perseverance, Jer. 32.40. Psal. 25.1. &c. and who by the power of God are preserved by faith unto salvation, 1 Pet. 1.5. and for whose perseverance Christ did and doth pray, John 17.20. Rom. 8.34. and who daily in the Lords Prayer call upon God for the same: whose perseverance at length is founded in Gods eternal predestination, Mat. 24.24. Rom. 8.30. Ephes. 1.11, 14. 1 Thes. 2.13, 14. &c. Therefore the perseverance of all those who are inserted by true faith into Christ, is not doubtful, but certain, according to Scripture.
To whom God hath promised to give certainly perseverance in faith, and who are kept by the power of God in faith to the end, and for whose perseverance Christ hath prayed, and doth pray; and who pray themselves incessantly for the same; and whose perseverance is grounded in Gods eternall predestination: their perseverance in true faith unto the end is not doubtfull, but sure, according to the Scripture: All ingraffed into Christ by true faith are such, to whom God hath promised to give perseverance, Jer. 32.40.
No less firm a demonstration doth the proximate cause yield which begets true faith, always remaining in the Elect, out of two sayings in Scripture joined together, 1 Pet. 1.23. You are renewed not of mortal seed, but of immortal, by the word of God which abideth foe ever: And, 1 John 3.9. He that is borne of God sinneth not, because the seed of God remaineth in him: nor can he sin, because he is borne of God. Hence we reason thus:
No lesse firme a demonstration doth the proximate cause yeeld which begets true faith, alwayes remaining in the Elect, out of two sayings in Scripture joyned together, 1 Pet. 1.23. You are renewed not of mortall seed, but of immortall, by the word of God which abideth foe ever: And, 1 John 3.9. He that is borne of God sinneth not, because the seed of God remaineth in him: nor can he sin, because he is borne of God. Hence we reason thus:
They who are borne of the immortal seed of Gods word, and in whom this immortal seed (notwithstanding their infirmities) doth remain, in them also faith abides; nor doth it finally fail, and consequently perseverance, which is faith it self not failing, but remaining and persevering: the reason of this, is the individual knitting of the cause and the effect, because the immortal seed of Gods word remaineth not (in whom it doth remain) but by faith: All that are engrafted into Christ by true faith, are borne again of the immortal seed of Gods word, as Peter the Apostle witnesseth; and in them abideth this immortal seed (not withstanding their infirmities) witness John the Apostle: In all then that are by true faith engrafted into Christ, faith remains, neither doth it ever utterly fail, and consequently perseverance, &c.
They who are borne of the immortall seed of Gods word, and in whom this immortall seed (notwithstanding their infirmities) doth remaine, in them also faith abides; nor doth it finally faile, and consequently perseverance, which is faith it selfe not failing, but remaining and persevering: the reason of this, is the individuall knitting of the cause and the effect, because the immortall seed of Gods word remaineth not (in whom it doth remaine) but by faith: All that are ingraffed into Christ by true faith, are borne againe of the immortall seed of Gods word, as Peter the Apostle witnesseth; and in them abideth this immortall seed (not withstanding their infirmities) witnesse John the Apostle: In all then that are by true faith ingraffed into Christ, faith remaines, neither doth it ever utterly faile, and consequently perseverance, &c.
What need many words; If the perseverance of the Saints be doubtful, then is it not given certainly by God to all them that ask it daily, praying with all their heart, Hallowed by thy Name, thy Kingdom come, thy will be done on earth, as it is in heaven: Lead us not into tentation, 1but deliver us from evil, &c. In which Petitions, Cyprian and Austin learnedly and religiously teach, that perseverance is begged of God: then 2. this promise of God, besides others, will be vain, Hear, O house of Jacob, who have been carried by me from the womb, even to your old age I am with you, and till you be hairy I will carry you: 2I have made, I will bear, I will also carry, and will deliver. 3. In vain will the Apostles most hearty persuasion, confidence and promise be, I am persuaded that he who hath begun a good work in you will perfect it, 3until the day of Jesus Christ. For I am persuaded, that neither life nor death, &c. can separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus. God will confirm you to the end unblamable, until the day of our Lord Jesus Christ. 4. In vain will be the prayer and confidence of the Saints, praying with David, O God, forsake me not in mine old age, and when my head groweth grey. Thou hast showed me many and great afflictions, but thou hast returned and quickened me. 5. Justifying faith will be in vain, or the assurance of the remission of sins for the time present: for, he that doubteth of Gods promise for the time to come, feigns that he believes the promise of the time present;4 for, these are conjoined, I did bear you, I will bear you till your old age. I, I am he who blot out thine iniquities, &c. and will not remember thy sins any more. 6. In vain, finally, is the faith of eternal life and salvation: because, he that doubts of his perseverance in faith, without which life eternal is not obtained, how can he be confident of life eternal? for, he that doubts if he shall live till the morrow, how can he be assured he shall live eternally? so, instead of faith, a fallacious opinion shall take place; in mens ⟨p. 843⟩consciences, hesitation, doubting, fear, anxiety, undermining and overthrowing all Christian comfort and confidence, will domineer. These are the fruits which the denial of perseverance will bring forth; all which are false, impious, blasphemous;
Now, the cavil about the condition annexed to the promises, doth nothing hinder our Arguments, as was showed. Neither is the perseverance of the Saints prejudiced by that calumny of scandalous preaching, and licentious belief of perseverance. For, otherwise the Apostles preaching of this doctrine had been scandalous, and the Churches believing thereof at that time had been licentious.1 I (saith Austin) will not exaggerate this matter with my words, but will rather leave it to them to consider, that they may see what this is which they have persuaded themselves, to wit, that the preaching of perseverance doth rather wrong the hearers by desperation, then help them by exhortation: for, this were as much as if you would say, that then man despairs of his own salvation, when he hath learned to put his trust, not in himself, but in God. Neither doth the Paralogisme non causae, concerning the neglect or nullifying of the means, and fore-warnings, &c. hinder us; for, by these same means the holy Ghost doth work and support the certainty of perseverance in the hearts of the Saints, nor are we moved with the examples of hypocrites and Apostates in their fourth Engine, of whom also the five marginals of the Article speak. For, these men had nothing common with the true faithful, but the bare name only of faith, of all which it is therefore said,2 They went out from us, because they were not of us; for, if they had been of us, they had remained with us, but that is might be known they were not of us, therefore they went out. See Austine, De bono perseverantiae, c. 8. The great and grievous falls of Moses, Aaron, David, Solomon, Peter, Judas, and of others, trouble not us; for, if they did any thing prejudice perseverance, it was in the totality, not in the finality thereof: for, it may be easily proved, that all those, whom the enemies of perseverance do object, either were not true believers, but hypocrites; or repented in the end. But neither can their total perseverance be overthrown from hence, except withal Gods promises be overthrown too, which is impossible should be overthrown by the exception of a pretended condition.
Now, the cavill about the condition annexed to the promises, doth nothing hinder our Arguments, as was shewed. Neither is the perseverance of the Saints prejudiced by that calumny of scandalous preaching, and licentious beliefe of perseverance. For, otherwise the Apostles preaching of this doctrine had beene scandalous, and the Churches beleeving thereof at that time had beene licentious.
and the spirit against the flesh. This also we are content should be called resistible; yet not simply, but in some respect: For this resistibilitie or resistance is not (as the former) between grace & the will, but between sensualitie, or that remainder of the flesh in the Saints, & between grace▪ as the Apostle witnesseth, That which I would,
I doe not; but what I would not, that I doe: For, I do not the good, which I would; but the evill, which I would not, that do I. And so, that the flesh at last is overcome by the spirit, sensuality by the regenerate will, & concupiscence by grace.
For, when (say they) God reveales his will, wee acknowledge the irresistible vertue of the holy Spirit in our mind; because our mind cannot avoid ipsum scire, or the knowledge it selfe, and in our soule, when he knocketh: because, nill we, will we, we are forced to feel it. Concerning the resistibilitie of the second degree, we will not trouble our selves: for, they denie not the illumination of them to be irresistible also. But for the motion to assent, and some measure of joy, they may, for us, think what they please. If they say it is resistible, because the motion doth not so effectually work upon the will, this is nothing to the question. But, for a finall resistance, both Scripture and example prove, They receive the word with joy;
but have no root, who beleeve for a while, and in time of tentation faile. After that, many of his disciples departed from him. Some have made shipwrack of their faith. Some depart from the faith, denying the Lord that bought them; they forsake the holy doctrine delivered to them.
differs not from Rhetorical persuasion, or a moral enticing to faith; such an one as is impossible for man to be quickened, who is dead in sin. What are alleged to the contrary, are nothing to the purpose. 5. Because grace, working faith and conversion, by its efficacy, overcomes all the strength of men, or other creatures: and therefore cannot be mastered by mans corrupted will, Ephes. 1.18, 19. Col. 2.12, 13. 2 Thes. 1.11. 2 Pet. 1.3. The Major of which reason is not weak, as they say: for that power,
1. Because, as God doth irresistibly illuminate those, whom he doth effectually intend to convert; so likewise he doth irresistibly bestow on them, not onely the power, but the act also of beleeving, Phil. 1.29. and 2.13. therefore, by his effectuall moving, he doth not onely take away resistance, but resistibilitie also from them. Whereas they object, To you it is given to suffer for Christ: 1this belongs not to the operating, but to the co-operating grace. Of which wrestling we said already:2 therefore 'tis nothing to the purpose. 2. Because God, by converting us, gives us a new heart, and a new spirit: he removes the heart of stone, and gives flesh,3 and makes us walk in his waies. But it is absurd, to imagine a new heart, a new spirit, and the act of walking in Gods lawes, with resistance or resistibilitie, Jer. 31.18. Deut. 29.4. Ezek. 36.26. against which no solid thing is alledged, though much is said. 3. Because the quickning, regeneration, conversion, new creation of the naturall man,4 dead in sin, with resistibilitie, is no lesse an absurditie,5 then to feign or imagine such a resistance in mans first creation, or daily generation, or last resuscitation, John 3.3. and 5.25. Ephes. 2.5. &c. which reason will never be refuted with verbositie.6 4. Because grace, working conversion with resistibilitie,7 differs not from Rhetoricall perswasion, or a morall enticing to faith; such an one as is impossible for man to be quickned, who is dead in sin. What are alledged to the contrarie, are nothing to the purpose. 5. Because grace, working faith and conversion, by its efficacie, overcomes all the strength of men, or other creatures: and therefore cannot be mastered by mans corrupted will, Ephes. 1.18, 19. Col. 2.12, 13. 2 Thes. 1.11. 2 Pet. 1.3. The Major of which reason is not weak, as they say: for that power,8 which is insuperable by mans depraved will, is also irresistible to the same. 6. Because, if the grace of regeneration were resistible,9 it were common to many unregenerate men; but the Scripture makes it peculiar to Gods sons only, Rom. 8.14, 30. 1 Cor. 1.23, 24. Joh. 14.17. and 6.36, 45. 1 John. 4.17. which reason doth not conclude only for irresistance,10 as is pretended, but also for irresistibilitie. 7. Because the Fathers drawing, without which none can come to Christ,11Joh. 6.44. supposeth an irresistibilitie of grace;
1Col. p. 218.
2Col. p. 229.
3Col. p. 218. & p. 281.
4Col. p. 219.
5Col. d pag. 295. ad 309.
6Col. p. 220.
7Col. p. 309.
8Col. p. 312.
9Col. p. 220.
10Col. p. 317.
11Col p. 221.
and God himself, I separated my self; which lye is approved by the Remonstrants blasphemously. 11. To these add another reason out of Joh. 15.5. Without me you can do nothing. For, if converting grace be resistible, he that doth not resist grace, may refute Christ, and say, Behold without thee I have not resisted grace. Neither can he say, It's by thee that I have not resisted: But whereas, by supposition, the same grace is placed in the resistent, he ought also to say, It is by thee that he hath resisted; which is blasphemy. 12. Let Austins reason be added,
hearts, to incline them which way he will (and he doth with the very wills of men what he pleaseth;
otherwise, no man would come, being drawn:1 and yet for all this, we are not drawn against our will by the Father (which is objected) no more then against our will we are illuminated. 8. Because the gift of faith and repentance is said to be given by Gods Spirit, not onely,2 because it is offered to the will irresistibly, but because it is put into the heart, or infused irresistibly,3Joh. 6.63. Eph. 2.8. Phil. 1.19. 2 Tim. 2.25. Rom. 5.5. The contrarie cavills are altogether Atheologicall, or inconsistent with Divinitie. 9. Because the resistibilitie of grace, if there ought to be a conversion, supposeth in the unregenerate will,4 a power of 〈…〉 resisting; but this the Scripture generally denieth. The Remonstrants will at length consider, whether this reason concludeth not against them. 10. Because, if we yeeld a resistibilitie of grace, the work chiefly necessary for our salvation; to wit, faith and repentance, should be placed in mans arbitrement, as in the proximate cause. And the reason of this difference, why of two unregenerate, the one in hearing the Gospel beleeveth, the other beleeveth not, should proceed from man: because one would resist grace, the other would not; against that place, Who separated thee? 5What hast thou that thou hast not received? Which is spoken, not only in respect of Infidels (as they think) but likewise in respect of grace: For, if in two Infidels we put grace equally resistible, surely, he that resisteth not grace, but receives it, and beleeves, he may answer not only to him that resisteth and beleeveth not, but even to grace,6 and God himself, I separated my self; which lye is approved by the Remonstrants blasphemously. 11. To these adde another reason out of Joh. 15.5. Without me you can do nothing. For, if converting grace be resistible, he that doth not resist grace, may refute Christ, and say, Behold without thee I have not resisted grace. Neither can he say, It's by thee that I have not resisted: But whereas, by supposition, the same grace is placed in the resistent, he ought also to say, It is by thee that he hath resisted; which is blasphemy. 12. Let Austins reason be added,7 He that hath a most omnipotent power over mens ⟨p. 836⟩hearts, to encline them which way he will (and he doth with the very wills of men what he pleaseth;
. concerning Saul, to whom, when God would give the kingdome, and the Israelites had power either to resist him, or to submit themselves to him, God touched their hearts, that they neither could, nor would resist: and this he did, by working on their wills. The other is out of
. and 12. of David, whom, when God decreed to settle him in the kingdome with better successe, the Spirit of the Lord came upon Abisai, a prince among thirty, that he said, We are thine, O David, and will be with thee, thou son of Jesse. Can he (saith Austin) resist the will of God, and not rather doe his will, who in his heart did worke by his Spirit, which came upon him, that he should will, say, and do this? And by them Almighty God, who was with him brought them to make him king. What? did he bind him with any corporeall bands? He wrought within, he held the heart, he moved the heart, and drew them by their wills, which wills he wrought in them.
1De grat. Christ. cap. 24.
⟨p. 837⟩
Who now againe doth not see, that the meat is to be ascribed specifically and proximately to the takers, but to the father indifferently and remotely? Such is the resistibilitie of grace, which these men teach.
The Lord thy God shall circumcise thine heart, and the heart of thy seed, that thou maist love the Lord thy God with all thine heart. I will put my feare in their hearts, that they shall not depart from mee. Which words Austin citing, for the good of perseverance, thus explaines, So great shall my feare be, which I will put in their hearts, that they shall adhere to me continually. I will put my Spirit in the midst of you, and I will make, that you shall walke in my precepts, and keep my judgements, and doe them. This shall be my covenant with them, saith the Lord: My Spirit, which is in thee, and my words, which I have put in thee, shall not depart from thy mouth. I will poure upon the house of David, and upon the inhabitants of Jerusalem,
the spirit of grace and supplication, and they shall look on mee whom they have pierced &c. God will strengthen you even to the end. He that hath begun in you a good worke, will perfect it, untill the day of the Lord Jesus, who, by the power of God, are kept by faith to salvation, &c.
For this cause (saith Austin) God commands some things, which we cannot doe, that we may know what to beg of him. Hearing then the command, they aske for that which is commanded, saying with Austin, Give me what thou commandest, and command what thou wilt.
words of mine (saith he) Pelagius at Rome could not endure, when they were rehearsed by a certaine brother, a fellow Bishop of mine, in his presence, and in an angry way contradicting him, he had almost fallen foule with him that did repeat them: The orthodox men at this day are in the like condition with them; and yet these promises do not exclude the faillings of the Saints, whether their sinnes be great or small, but they lift up those that are fallen from their fall: for these promises are sometimes also directed to just men that fall;
If the righteous fall, he shall not be bruised, because the Lord supporteth him. If his sons shall forsake my Law▪ &c. I will visit with the rod their transgressions, but my mercy I will not take from him.
nor shall fall; but are perswaded, that, let them sin as often as they will, they can never lose their faith, nor fall from grace, but inevitably shall persevere, and shall be saved: And it is but only this opinion of perseverance (as they say,) or manner of it, which they cal in question,
4. Because examples testifie, that many who have beleeved, have totally and finally fallen from the faith. 5. Because many faithfull men are recorded to have fallen grievously, and that they have committed the workes of the flesh, and hainous wickednesse, with which filthy deeds faith could not consist. 6. Because, this being granted, all baptised Infants, that are borne of faithfull Parents▪ should be saved. 7. Because many faithfull men do so defile themselves with wickednesse, that they are to be excommunicated, and are excommunicated by the Ministers of the Church.
1Coll. p. 403, 404.353.354, 355.372.
2Coll. p. 353.
3pag. 356.
4pag. 359.
5pag. 360.
6pag. 361.
7pag. 362.
8pag. 363.
pray incessantly for their own perseverance; but whatsoever they ask of God by faith, they obtain it. And this was Austin's second Argument, for the good of perseverance. 6. Because they that are engrafted by faith into Christ truly,
1 Pet. 1.5. 7. Because they that are by true faith engrafted into Christ, have their salvation sealed in their hearts by the earnest of the holy Ghost, and consequently, their faith and perseverance are sealed too,
2 Cor. 1.21. Ephes. 1.13. &c. 8. Because true believers are like a tree that doth not wither, the wise man that built upon the rock, the seed cast into the good ground, &c. according to Scripture.
9. Because true believers are distinguished from temporary back-sliders by reason the faith of those is rooted in their hearts, but the faith of these hath no root. 10. Because the Scripture expressly confirms,
1. Because God in his word hath promised to the faithfull in Christ,1 a totall and finall perseverance, Jer. 32.40. Psal. 125.1. John 10.28. &c. Therefore he performes it, because he cannot lye. This is Austines first Argument for the good of perseverance.2 2. Because the Apostles witnesse, that God doth, and will faithfully performe his promises, concerning their preservation in the faith. 1 Cor. 1.8. & 10.13. Phil. 1.6. 1 Thes. 5.23. &c. 3. Because, out of the Apostles doctrine,3Rom. 8.30. the perseverance of those that are called according to Gods Decree, is the proper effect of predestination; so that Bellarmine himself, a great Patron of indifferent or resistible grace, doth plainly confesse, That perseverance is the most proper effect of predestination, so that without perseverance, predestination cannot be fulfilled. 4. Because Christ prayed,4 and doth pray for the perseverance not of Peter alone, but of all who were to beleeve by the Apostles preaching; but the Father alwayes heares the Son, Luke 22.32. Joh. 17.20. John 11.42. &c. 5. Because they that are ingraffed into Christ by true faith,5 pray incessantly for their owne perseverance; but whatsoever they aske of God by faith, they obtaine it. And this was Austines second Argument, for the good of perseverance. 6. Because they that are ingraffed by faith into Christ truly,6 are by the power of God faithfully preserved in faith persevering to the end,71 Pet. 1.5. 7. Because they that are by true faith ingraffed into Christ, have their salvation sealed in their hearts by the earnest of the holy Ghost, and consequently, their faith and perseverance are sealed too,82 Cor. 1.21. Ephes. 1.13. &c. 8. Because true beleevers are like a tree that doth not wither, the wise man that built upon the rock, the seed cast into the good ground, &c. according to Scripture.9 9. Because true beleevers are distinguished from temporary back-sliders by reason the faith of those is rooted in their hearts, but the faith of these hath no roote. 10. Because the Scripture expresly confirmes,10 that the true beleevers can or shall never utterly fall away. Rom. 6.2, 8, 9, 10, 11. 1 Joh 3.9. 1 Joh. 5.4.
1Coll. p. 147.
2De bono persev. c. 2. Coll. p. 343.
3Coll. p. 344. Lib. 3. De justif. c. 12.
4Coll. p. 344.
5Coll. p. 344.
6Coll. p. 345.
7Coll. p. 345.
8Coll. p. 346.
9Coll. p. 346.
10Coll. p. 347.
Psal. 25.1
. &c. and who by the power of God are preserved by faith unto salvation,
. &c. Therefore the perseverance of all those who are inserted by true faith into Christ, is not doubtfull, but certaine, according to Scripture.
What need many words; If the perseverance of the Saints be doubtfull, then is it not given certainly by God to all them that aske it daylie, praying with all their heart, Hallowed by thy Name, thy Kingdome come, thy will be done on earth, as it is in heaven: Leade us not into tentation, 1but deliver us from evill, &c. In which Petitions, Cyprian and Austine learnedly and religiously teach, that perseverance is begged of God: then 2. this promise of God, besides others, will be vaine, Heare, O house of Jacob, who have beene carried by me from the wombe, even to your old age I am with you, and till you be hairy I will carry you: 2I have made, I will beare, I will also carry, and will deliver. 3. In vaine will the Apostles most hearty perswasion, confidence and promise be, I am perswaded that he who hath begun a good worke in you will perfect it, 3untill the day of Jesus Christ. For I am perswaded, that neither life nor death, &c. can separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus. God will confirme you to the end unblamable, untill the day of our Lord Jesus Christ. 4. In vaine will be the prayer and confidence of the Saints, praying with David, O God, forsake me not in mine old age, and when my head groweth gray. Thou hast shewed me many and great afflictions, but thou hast returned and quickned me. 5. Justifying faith will be in vain, or the assurance of the remission of sins for the time present: for, he that doubteth of Gods promise for the time to come, feignes that he beleeves the promise of the time present;4 for, these are conjoyned, I did beare you, I will beare you till your old age. I, I am he who blot out thine iniquities, &c. and will not remember thy sins any more. 6. In vaine, finally, is the faith of eternall life and salvation: because, he that doubts of his perseverance in faith, without which life eternall is not obtained, how can he be confident of life eternall? for, he that doubts if he shall live till the morrow, how can he be assured he shall live eternally? so, instead of faith, a fallacious opinion shall take place; in mens ⟨p. 843⟩consciences, hesitation, doubting, feare, anxiety, undermining and overthrowing all Christian comfort and confidence, will domineere. These are the fruits which the deniall of perseverance will bring forth; all which are false, impious, blasphemous;
I (saith Austine) will not exaggerate this matter with my words, but will rather leave it to them to consider, that they may see what this is which they have perswaded themselves, to wit, that the preaching of perseverance doth rather wrong the hearers by desperation, then helpe them by exhortation: for, this were as much as if you would say, that then man despaires of his owne salvation, when he hath learned to put his trust, not in himselfe, but in God. Neither doth the Paralogisme non causae, concerning the neglect or nullifying of the meanes, and fore-warnings, &c. hinder us; for, by these same meanes the holy Ghost doth worke and support the certainty of perseverance in the hearts of the Saints, nor are we moved with the examples of hypocrites and Apostates in their fourth Engine, of whom also the five marginals of the Article speake. For, these men had nothing common with the true faithfull, but the bare name onely of faith, of all which it is therefore said,
They went out from us, because they were not of us; for, if they had beene of us, they had remained with us, but that is might be knowne they were not of us, therefore they went out. See Austine, De bono perseverantiae, c. 8. The great and grievous falls of Moses, Aaron, David, Salomon, Peter, Judas, and of others, trouble not us; for, if they did any thing prejudice perseverance, it was in the totality, not in the finality thereof: for, it may be easily proved, that all those, whom the enemies of perseverance do object, either were not true beleevers, but hypocrites; or repented in the end. But neither can their totall perseverance be overthrowne from hence, except withall Gods promises be overthrowne too, which is impossible should be overthrowne by the exception of a pretended condition.