[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostatical Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Wittenberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.[figure: royal blazon or coat of arms] ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE POSITIONS OF Dr. AEGIDIUS HUNNIUS, Concerning the Hypostaticall Union, by Dr. DAVID PARRY, In Witteberg, An. 1592. a.d. Disputed the 23. of May: IN WHICH The Orthodox Doctrine of the Person of JESUS CHRIST is asserted, according to the rule of holy Scripture, and the consent of pious Antiquity.
pp. 770–844447 passagespart 10 of 12
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
This is no new matter, which the Remonstrants handle in this Article: for, of old the Semipelagians in Marseilles, and Syracusa held the same, in these words, Our Lord Jesus Christ dyed for all mankind, 1and no man at all is exempted from the redemption of his blood, although his mind hath been quite averse all his life from him; because the mystery of mercy belongs to all men: by which therefore many are not renewed, because they are fore-known, that they account it needless to be renewed: Therefore, so far as concerns God, life eternal is prepared for all; but, as for mans liberty of will, it is received by them, who, of their own accord, shall believe God, and shall receive the help of grace, by the merit of their faith.
THis is no new matter, which the Remonstrants handle in this Article: for, of old the Semipelagians in Marsiles, and Syracusa held the same, in these words, Our Lord Jesus Christ dyed for all mankind, 1and no man at all is exempted from the redemption of his bloud, although his mind hath been quite averse all his life from him; because the mysterie of mercy belongs to all men: by which therefore many are not renewed, because they are fore-knowne, that they account it needlesse to be renewed: Therefore, so far as concernes God, life eternall is prepared for all; but, as for mans liberty of will, it is received by them, who, of their owne accord, shall beleeve God, and shall receive the help of grace, by the merit of their faith.
By this Article, although in show they amplified Gods grace, and mans redemption; yet, in effect, they minced both: giving to God an indifferent grace, to Christ the merit of redemption, but to free-will the efficacy of both. And while they would overthrow the doctrine of Predestination, which Austin did maintain out of the Apostle, they did, indeed, shake the whole Gospel, in ascribing the cause of faith and perseverance; and consequently, of mans salvation, to God and Christ indifferently, but to mans wit and free-will determinately: which, what it is, they that are taught by God do understand: For, where is that of the Apostle? Who hath separated thee? What hast thou, which thou hast not received? But, 1if thou hast received, why dost thou brag, as if thou hadst not received it? Cursed is he that maketh flesh his arm.
By this Article, although in shew they amplified Gods grace, and mans redemption; yet, in effect, they minced both: giving to God an indifferent grace, to Christ the merit of redemption, but to free-will the efficacie of both. And while they would overthrow the doctrine of Predestination, which Austin did maintaine out of the Apostle, they did, indeed, shake the whole Gospel, in ascribing the cause of faith and perseverance; and consequently, of mans salvation, to God and Christ indifferently, but to mans wit and free-will determinately: which, what it is, they that are taught by God doe understand: For, where is that of the Apostle? Who hath separated thee? What hast thou, which thou hast not received? But, 1if thou hast received, why dost thou brag, as if thou hadst not received it? Cursed is he that maketh flesh his arme.
So they in this Article, concerning a general obtaining of reconciliation of all men with God by Christs death, make show of enlarging the grace of Christs death; indeed, they do the very same that the former did. And while they think to overthrow the Apostolical Predestination, which discriminates those that shall be saved, from them that shall not be saved; they go about to bring in their own eventual predestination, of those that spontaneously believe and persevere, or who determine themselves to faith and perseverance, after faith and perseverance; which, indeed, is rather to be called Postdestination, then Predestination. And while they endeavour to make mens will the mistress of resistible grace, and expose to mans will reconciliation by Christs death, they evacuate the faith of grace, and weaken that comfort which we have by Christs death.
So they in this Article, concerning a generall obtaining of reconciliation of all men with God by Christs death, make shew of enlarging the grace of Christs death; indeed, they doe the very same that the former did. And while they think to overthrow the Apostolicall Predestination, which discriminates those that shall be saved, from them that shall not be saved; they go about to bring in their own eventuall predestination, of those that spontaneously beleeve and persevere, or who determine themselves to faith and perseverance, after faith and perseverance; which, indeed, is rather to be called Postdestination, then Predestination. And while they endeavour to make mens will the mistresse of resistible grace, and expose to mans will reconciliation by Christs death, they evacuate the faith of grace, and weaken that comfort which we have by Christs death.
Now they think, as the former did, that Predestination is hence everted, thus: If God gave his Son to the world, and would have him dye not only for some, but equally for all men; and Christ, according to his Fathers will, did dye for all men alike: God therefore hath not by his predestination elected some only to life eternal, and rejected others: neither can Christ be said to dye only for some, or for the elect alone. But eternal Predestination is not hence prejudiced: for, notwithstanding it, God would have his Son dye, whom he gave to the world; and Christ did dye, according to his Fathers counsel: otherwise indeed, or in another sense, for all men alike, whether they be elected and faithful, or reprobate and infidels; but otherwise, or in another sense, for the elect only and faithful.
Now they think, as the former did, that Predestination is hence everted, thus: If God gave his Son to the world, and would have him dye not onely for some, but equally for all men; and Christ, according to his Fathers will, did dye for all men alike: God therefore hath not by his predestination elected some only to life eternall, and rejected others: neither can Christ be said to dye onely for some, or for the elect alone. But eternall Predestination is not hence prejudiced: for, notwithstanding it, God would have his Son dye, whom he gave to the world; and Christ did dye, according to his Fathers counsell: otherwise indeed, or in another sense, for all men alike, whether they be elected and faithfull, or reprobate and infidels; but otherwise, or in another sense, for the elect onely and faithfull.
That this may be the better understood and demonstrated, the Article is to be examined more accurately; and it hath four parts: 1. A proposition, that Christ ⟨p. 826⟩dyed for all and singular, which is ambiguous. 2. A Gloss, that he hath obtained for all reconciliation and remission of sins, which is equivocal, and false. 3. A Condition, that none but the faithful enjoy really this reconciliation, which is true: it limiteth the Proposition, and overthrows the Gloss. 4. A Proof, by the two alleged places of Scripture, which directly do not concern the Proposition: for, in neither of the alleged places is there any mention made of Christs death for all and singular; so that I wonder how the Authors could not call to mind fitter places: yea, the later member of the first compels them to limit the Proposition, and refels their Gloss; therefore some true passages are mixed with ambiguities and falsehoods. I say, 'tis true, That no man really enjoys the remission of sins, but the faithful man: For, he that believeth not, the wrath of God abides on him, not remission or reconciliation; except that under these words, really enjoy, there seems to lye hid the buskin of the two-fold fruition of remission of sins, or reconciliation: The one real by faith, proper only to the faithful, which only is true: The other not real, without faith, common to all, even to Infidels, which is fictitious and nothing. Hence is gathered, that Christ properly dyed for all, and only the faithful, for none of the unfaithful; and so he dyed not absolutely for all and singular: for, to dye for one, is properly by death to free one from death, or, to dye in the stead of another, that he may live; as is plain, 2 Sam. 18.33. Would to God I had dyed for thee; that is, in thy stead, that thou mightst live. And of Christ, Rom. 5.6, 8. He dyed for us, when we were wicked, and sinners; that is, in our stead, that we, being delivered from sin and death, may live to righteousness, or, may have life eternal. So 1 Cor. 5.15. 1 John 3.16. and 4.9. John 15.13. &c.
That this may be the better understood and demonstrated, the Article is to be examined more accurately; and it hath foure parts: 1. A proposition, that Christ
The Proposition is ambiguous, because imperfect: Our Saviour Jesus Christ dyed for all and singular. If you add, For believers, the Proposition will be clear and true. If, For men, it will remain ambiguous: for, it may be understood, either of the greatness of the merit of Christs death, sufficient to all men for reconciliation; or, of the efficacy thereof, in reconciling all men. In the former sense, the Proposition is true: for, Christs death, in respect of its greatness and power, is a most sufficient remedy, to expiate the sins of all and of every one; neither is any thing wanting for a real reconciliation to all, and every one that receives it by faith. In this sense Christ may be said to dye for all and every one: as (for example) the Physician, when the whole City is infected, preparing a sufficient antidote for all the sick, may be said to prepare it for all; and in this sense, these sayings in Scripture,1 where Christ is said to dye for all, To have tasted death for all, To be a propitiation for the sins of all the world, are commonly not unfitly understood, although they may be taken more strictly.
The Proposition is ambiguous, because imperfect: Our Saviour Jesus Christ dyed for all and singular. If you adde, For beleevers, the Proposition will be cleere and true. If, For men, it will remaine ambiguous: for, it may be understood, either of the greatnesse of the merit of Christs death, sufficient to all men for reconciliation; or, of the efficacie thereof, in reconciling all men. In the former sense, the Proposition is true: for, Christs death, in respect of its greatnesse and power, is a most sufficient remedy, to expiate the sins of all and of every one; neither is any thing wanting for a reall reconciliation to all, and every one that receives it by faith. In this sense Christ may be said to dye for all and every one: as (for example) the Physician, when the whole Citie is infected, preparing a sufficient antidote for all the sick, may be said to prepare it for all; and in this sense, these sayings in Scripture,1 where Christ is said to dye for all, To have tasted death for all, To be a propitiation for the sins of all the world, are commonly not unfitly understood, although they may be taken more strictly.
In the later sense, concerning the fruit or efficacy of that most sufficient remedy, which is a real reconciliation with God, and a restitution from death to life, the Proposition is false: for, to say, that Christ dyed so for all and singular, that he hath reconciled to God all and singular promiscuously, faithful and faithless, who either know not Christ, or oppose him, is to contradict the Gospel; which, with great consent, challengeth the efficacy of Christs death for all believers only: For proving of which, that one saying of our Saviour Christ alleged in the Article, John 3.16. That all, &c. is sufficient: for, he faith not, that all and singular men may have life eternal; but, That all who believe in him may not perish, but may have life eternal, according as the real fruition of the remission of sins is limited in the Article. Whence, in the fore-alleged sayings, 1 Tim. 2.6. Hebr. 2.9. 1 John 2.2. &c. when they are understood of the efficacy of Christs death, the universal All is necessarily to be restrained to the universality of believers, and of the elect; of which universality, Prosper writes finely:1 In the elect (saith he) and in them that are separated out of the generality of all men, there is accounted a special kind of universality, that, out of all the world, all the world may seem to be delivered: and, out of all mankind, all men may seem to be assumed.
In the later sense, concerning the fruit or efficacie of that most sufficient remedie, which is a reall reconciliation with God, and a restitution from death to life, the Proposition is false: for, to say, that Christ dyed so for all and singular, that he hath reconci•ed to God all and singular promiscuously, faithfull and faithlesse, who either know not Christ, or oppose him, is to contradict the Gospel; which, with great consent, challengeth the efficacie of Christs death for all beleevers only: For proving of which, that one saying of our Saviour Christ alledged in the Article, John 3.16. That all, &c. is sufficient: for, he faith not, that all and singular men may have life eternall; but, That all who beleeve in him may not perish, but may have life eternall, according as the reall fruition of the remission of sins is limited in the Article. Whence, in the fore-alledged sayings,
With these two truths the Remonstrants are evidently held: 1. That Christ, in respect of the sufficiency of his price and merit, dyed for all and singular, and would ⟨p. 827⟩dye, and according to his Fathers counsel should dye. 2. In respect of the fruit and efficacy of his death; that is, of a real reconciliation and restitution with God, that he did not dye for all and singular, but for all and only the believers he would and should dye, as his Father had decreed. The first truth they are not sound anywhere in the conference plainly to prove, nor openly to deny; nor can they deny it, unless they will make his merit insufficient. The later truth they grant, in respect of the event: that all men are not really renewed in Christ, nor restored into the state of grace; but they deny it in respect of our Saviours intention, or the counsel of his Father, then which, what can be more absurd and false? For, whom God, by the death of his son, doth not indeed restore in time, them he never intended or decreed from eternity really to restore: For, surely,1 our God hath done whatsoever he pleased. What then he hath not done, nor doth in time, neither did he will it from eternity: And whom Christ, by his death, hath not really restored, them he did not will to restore, nor by his Fathers counsel should he. But, by their own confession, Christ did not really restore all men into the state of grace; therefore they must needs confess, that Christ hath not really willed their restitution, nor should he, according to his Fathers counsel: Otherwise they must say, that Christ did not something, which every way he was willing to do, and so let them deny his omnipotency; or, what by his Fathers counsel he should have done, so let them deny his obedience. If they object, that Christ would have gathered the sons of Jerusalem, but that he did not; let them also say, that God by all means would have gathered them; not only by outward calling, and invitation to repentance, by his Prophets, his own, and his Apostles preaching; but also by the drawing of his inward grace and power: and that for all that he prevailed not. Now let them see how they do not accuse Gods omnipotent Son of impotency, and attach themselves of blasphemy.
With these two truths the Remonstrants are evidently held: 1. That Christ, in respect of the sufficiencie of his price and merit, dyed for all and singular, and would ⟨p. 827⟩
Being then, nill they, will they, forced by both these truths, they must needs give their ingenuous consent with the orthodoxall Church, or not: If they acknowledge a consent, how do they not condemn themselves of perfidiousness, for tearing the united Churches with vain verbal digladiations, and disturb the quietness of the Common-wealth? If they deny a consent in the former, how do they not blaspheme the death of the Son of God, as an insufficient ransom? If in the later, how do they not entangle themselves in a contradiction? For, if they deny, that Christ, in respect of the efficacy and fruit of his death, did not dye for all and singular, but only for the believers; they must needs affirm to the contrary, that Christ, in respect of the fruit and efficacy of his death, dyed for all and every man, and not for the believers alone; that is, that he hath reconciled all, and every one to God, and not the believers alone: or, which is all one, that he hath made all and every particular man enjoy really remission of sins; but they plainly deny this affirmation, in the limitation of their Article, when they say, That no man doth really enjoy remission of sins, except the faithful man. And more plainly in the conference, That all men are not really renewed by Christ, and restored into the state of grace. 1They are held fast then by this contradiction, That all are really restored and reconciled; and, That all are not really reconciled.
Being then, nill they, will they, forced by both these truths, they must needs give their ingenuous consent with the orthodoxall Church, or not: If they acknowledge a consent, how do they not condemne themselves of perfidiousnesse, for tearing the united Churches with vain verball digladiations, and disturb the quietnesse of the Common-wealth? If they deny a consent in the former, how doe they not blaspheme the death of the Son of God, as an insufficient ransome? If in the later, how do they not entangle themselves in a contradiction? For, if they deny, that Christ, in respect of the efficacie and fruit of his death, did not dye for all and singular, but onely for the beleevers; they must needs affirme to the contrary, that Christ, in respect of the fruit and efficacie of his death, dyed for all and every man, and not for the beleevers alone; that is, that he hath reconciled all, and every one to God, and not the beleevers alone: or, which is all one, that he hath made all and every particular man enjoy really remission of sins; but they plainly deny this affirmation, in the limitation of their Article, when they say, That no man doth really enjoy remission of sins, except the faithfull man. And more plainly in the conserence, That all men are not really renewed by Christ, and restored into the state of grace.
But here they will retreat to the gloss of their Proposition, That Christ dyed for all and singular so, that he hath impetrated by his death to all men, reconciliation and remission of sins: As if this were the third sense, in which Christ may be said to dye for all, besides the respect of the sufficiency and efficacy of his death: and so the former distinction is made void; because he hath impetrated for all men reconciliation by his death. But I desire, that they would tell us, what the meaning of this high-strained phrase is, by which they have eluded above ten times the answers of their brethren at the conference. The Scripture speaks no-where thus, That Christ impetrated for all men reconciliation; but speaks openly,1 That God in Christ did reconcile to himself all things in heaven and in earth: That he reconciled the world to himself: That Christ reconciled all things by his blood; signifying, that Christ really did restore into the state of grace the world, synecdochically; that is, all believers in the ⟨p. 828⟩world:2 as in these words, I came not to condemn the world, but to save it. That the world may know that I am sent by thee: where the world cannot be understood, but of the world of the Elect. Again, all things; that is, all that are justified by faith, as is plain, Rom. 5.11.
But here they will retreat to the glosse of their Proposition, That Christ dyed for all and singular so, that he hath impetrated by his death to all men, reconciliation and remission of sins: As if this were the third sense, in which Christ may be said to dye for all, besides the respect of the sufficiencie and efficacie of his death: and so the former distinction is made void; because he hath impetrated for all men reconciliation by his death. But I desire, that they would tell us, what the meaning of this high-strained phrase is, by which they have eluded above ten times the answers of their brethren at the conference. The Scripture speaks no-where thus, That Christ impetrated for all men reconciliation; but speaks openly,1 That God in Christ did reconcile to himselfe all things in heaven and in earth: That hee reconciled the world to himselfe: That Christ reconciled all things by his bloud; signifying, that Christ really did restore into the state of grace the world, synecdochically; that is, all beleevers in the
If in this sense they will, that Christ impetrated reconciliation for all, for, that he really reconciled all; why do not they speak plainly? and why do they not express to which all he impetrated this? If to all believers, what need they wrangle? If to all men promiscuously, let them tell how he impetrated: whether by the greatness of his merit, or also by its efficacy? If by the greatness of his merit, again why do they wrangle? If by efficacy also, let them speak, whether absolutely and without faith, or under condition of faith? If absolutely to all, even without faith, how do they not again entangle themselves in a contradiction, by their limited condition, That no man really doth enjoy reconciliation, except the faithful man? If under condition of faith, how are they not tied with another knot of contradiction? for, if he hath obtained to all under condition of faith; therefore, the condition of faith failing, he hath not obtained: but many are destitute of this condition of faith; that is, many are Infidels: therefore to these many he hath not obtained. But, again, are not these contradictory sayings, He hath impetrated for all, He hath not impetrated for many? Which way soever then they turn their cothurne, they will be found either disturbers of peace by their Logomachy, or else entangled in a contradiction.
If in this sense they will, that Christ impetrated reconciliation for all, for, that he really reconciled all; why doe not they speake plainly? and why doe they not expresse to which all he impetrated this? If to all beleevers, what need they wrangle? If to all men promiscuously, let them tell how he impetrated: whether by the greatnesse of his merit, or also by its efficacy? If by the greatnesse of his merit, againe why do they wrangle? If by efficacy also, let them speake, whether absolutely and without faith, or under condition of faith? If absolutely to all, even without faith, how doe they not againe intangle themselves in a contradiction, by their limited condition, That no man really doth enjoy reconciliation, except the faithfull man? If under condition of faith, how are they not tied with another knot of contradiction? for, if he hath obtained to all under condition of faith; therefore, the condition of faith failing, he hath not obtained: but many are destitute of this condition of faith; that is, many are Infidels: therefore to these many he hath not obtained. But, againe, are not these contradictory sayings, He hath impetrated for all, He hath not impetrated for many? Which way soever then they turne their cothurne, they will be found either disturbers of peace by their Logomachie, or else intangled in a contradiction.
But this their cothurne or buskin must be somewhat more exactly discussed, that it may appear, how fit it is for both feet; that is, that it may appear out of the signification of the words, how it hides the true and false meaning. Reconciliation is a restitution or rendering of disagreeing parties into favour: actively it is attributed to God and Christ; passively to us. The word impetrate is equivocal, signifying divers things; sometimes to entreat, sometime to prepare, procure, merit, acquire, obtain, confer, &c. therefore this phrase, Christ obtained reconciliation for all, must needs be very equivocal: but, to play with equivocations is not for Divines, but for Sophisters, who would deceive. Yet, this phrase cannot have above three meanings; Either that Christ by his death obtained reconciliation for all, by a certain Metalepsis, by meriting or pro-meriting matter sufficient enough of reconciliation to all men: as for example, The Physician (of whom before) preparing a most sufficient cure for all sick people, or obtaining it else-where, may be said to have prepared or obtained health for all: Or, that he hath properly obtained reconciliation for all, conferring the same upon all; that is, hath really reconciled all: and that, either absolutely without condition; as for example, Joab, 1by the intercession of the woman of Tekoa, did absolutely obtain reconciliation from David for the parricide Absalom; that, without any condition, he should be brought into the Kings sight, and that the father should kiss his son: As also Esther is said to have obtained for the Jews security, absolutely without condition: Or under condition of faith to be required in all, that if all believe in the Son, they may indeed be reconciled; if they believe not, they may be debarred from reconciliation: as for example, Impunity was obtained from Solomon to seditious Adomiah upon condition of his innocency,2 If he be a worthy man, a hair shall not fall from his head, but if evil be found in him, he shall die.
But this their cothurne or buskin must be somewhat more exactly discussed, that it may appeare, how fit it is for both feete; that is, that it may appeare out of the signification of the words, how it hides the true and false meaning. Reconciliation is a restitution or rendring of disagreeing parties into favour: actively it is attributed to God and Christ; passively to us. The word impetrate is equivocall, signifying divers things; sometimes to intreat, sometime to prepare, procure, merit, acquire, obtaine, conferre, &c. therefore this phrase, Christ obtained reconciliation for all, must needs be very equivocall: but, to play with equivocations is not for Divines, but for Sophisters, who would deceive. Yet, this phrase cannot have above three meanings; Either that Christ by his death obtained reconciliation for all, by a certaine Metalepsis, by meriting or pro-meriting matter sufficient enough of reconciliation to all men: as for example, The Physician (of whom before) preparing a most sufficient cure for all sick people, or obtaining it else-where, may be said to have prepared or obtained health for all: Or, that he hath properly obtained reconciliation for all, conferring the same upon all; that is, hath really reconciled all: and that, either absolutely without condition; as for example, Joab,
I will speak more briefly; Christ hath procured reconciliation for all men, either in respect of the amplitude of his merit, being most sufficient for the reconciliation of all; or over and above, in respect of the efficacy of reconciling all men; and that either absolutely, whether they believe or not; or conditionally, if all believe. Neither can there be a fourth sense given of this phrase; which, when the Remonstrants allege in their Conference, That Christ hath procured reconciliation for all; that is, hath caused, that God should open again the gate of his grace to sinful man, although no man shall enter into that communion of his grace, but by faith; either this is a new buskin, or an equivocal Scheme or Livery-cloak, by a limitation taking ⟨p. 829⟩that away, which before it had set down: (for, how hath he really obtained reconciliation, who hath caused the Prince to open the gate of his Castle to seditious people, through which, notwithstanding, no man must pass, but by paying of a thousand Crowns, then which, the condition of faith is far better?) or, if it is to be called the obtaining of reconciliation, it belongs to the third conditional way of impetration. There remains then only three ways of obtained reconciliation, with one of which they must say, that Christ obtained reconciliation for all.
I will speake more briefly; Christ hath procured reconciliation for all men, either in respect of the amplitude of his merit, being most sufficient for the reconciliation of all; or over and above, in respect of the efficacy of reconciling all men; and that either absolutely, whether they beleeve or not; or conditionally, if all beleeve. Neither can there be a fourth sense given of this phrase; which, when the Remonstrants alledge in their Conference, That Christ hath procured reconciliation for all; that is, hath caused, that God should open againe the gate of his grace to sinfull man, although no man shall enter into that communion of his grace, but by faith; either this is a new buskin, or an equivocall Scheme or Livery-cloak, by a limitation taking ⟨p. 829⟩that away, which before it had set downe: (for, how hath he really obtained reconciliation, who hath caused the Prince to open the gate of his Castle to seditious people, through which, notwithstanding, no man must passe, but by paying of a thousand Crownes, then which, the condition of faith is farre better?) or, if it is to be called the obtaining of reconciliation, it belongs to the third conditionall way of impetration. There remaines then onely three wayes of obtained reconciliation, with one of which they must say, that Christ obtained reconciliation for all.
If the first way, they agree with the orthodox Church: what then do they trouble the Church and State? If the second way, they contradict themselves; affirming, that Christ did obtain for all absolute reconciliation; that is, that he did restore all men really into the state of grace; as, Joab did absolutely reconcile Absalom to his Father; that is, restored him to his Fathers favour. But, contrarily, they plainly deny, in limiting of the Article in their Conference, That all are really repaired in Christ, and restored to the state of grace; which contradiction is no less apparent, then if they should say, That Joab made Absalom absolutely obtain his Fathers favour, and not absolutely; or, he restored him really into his Fathers favour, and did not absolutely restore him. If the third way, they are again dashed upon the rock of contradiction: for, if Christ by his intention obtained reconciliation for all men, upon condition of faith to be required in all men; then he obtained it to none without the condition of faith, or to none that want faith; or, Infidels, in whom it ought not to be: nor is it put casually, either by God, who doth not give faith to all men, but to whom he pleaseth; nor by free-will, which is dead in sin, till God quicken it. Now, there have been always faithless men, and yet are many; is not here then a manifest conflict? He hath procured for all, and he hath not procured for all. Which way soever then they use this buskin, either they mean the same thing with their equivocations, which orthodoxall men do; and so by their verbosity, they disturb the Church and State: or else, they are entangled with manifest contradictions: or, lastly, (how strange soever they seem to make the matter) they are forced to betake themselves unto the tents of the Massilian Semi-pelagians, maintaining an universal reconciliation, even of those that live and die without the faith and knowledge of Christ: which Heresy was lately renewed in Germany, by Huberus.
If the first way, they agree with the orthodox Church: what then doe they trouble the Church and State? If the second way, they contradict themselves; affirming, that Christ did obtaine for all absolute reconciliation; that is, that he did restore all men really into the state of grace; as, Joab did absolutely reconcile Absalom to his Father; that is, restored him to his Fathers favour. But, contrarily, they plainly deny, in limiting of the Article in their Conference, That all are really repaired in Christ, and restored to the state of grace; which contradiction is no lesse apparent, then if they should say, That Joab made Absalom absolutely obtaine his Fathers favour, and not absolutely; or, he restored him really into his Fathers favour, and did not absolutely restore him. If the third way, they are againe dashed upon the rock of contradiction: for, if Christ by his intention obtained reconciliation for all men, upon condition of faith to be required in all men; then he obtained it to none without the condition of faith, or to none that want faith; or, Infidels, in whom it ought not to be: nor is it put casually, either by God, who doth not give faith to all men, but to whom he pleaseth; nor by free-will, which is dead in sin, till God quicken it. Now, there have beene alwayes faithlesse men, and yet are many; is not here then a manifest conflict? He hath procured for all, and he hath not procured for all. Which way soever then they use this buskin, either they meane the same thing with their equivocations, which orthodoxall men do; and so by their verbosity, they disturbe the Church and State: or else, they are entangled with manifest contradictions: or, lastly, (how strange soever they seeme to make the matter) they are forced to betake themselves unto the tents of the Massilian Semi-pelagians, maintaining an universall reconciliation, even of those that live and die without the faith and knowledge of Christ: which Heresie was lately renewed in Germany, by Huberus.
And hither, truly, do almost all their Arguments, borrowed from the Huberians,1 aim. Hence they call Christ the reconciler, not only of the faithful, but also of the whole world; that is, of Infidels too. From this Hypothesis, are their Classical absurdities, which they cast upon the orthodox Protestants; That otherwise, the unbelievers, if Christ did not obtain for them reconciliation, should have nothing to believe: or, if they did believe, they should believe a lye; which are most false: for, though Christ died not for all, in respect of the efficacy of his death; yet, he died for all, in respect of the sufficiency of his merit. This all Infidels have, which they may believe in the Gospel, that Christ suffered sufficiently for the sins of all the world, and paid a full ransom, and reconciled all to God that believe in him; and therefore, shall be partakers of this merit and reconciliation, if of faithless they will become believers: Now, in affirming and believing this, they do no ways believe a lye. But Infidels should believe a lye, if they should conclude, or were taught, that while they remain in infidelity, reconciliation is obtained for them in Christ. For, this is a lye, and not truth, that Christ hath obtained reconciliation for all, even for Infidels as they are, and remain such.
And hither, truly, do almost all their Arguments, borrowed from the Huberians,1 aime. Hence they call Christ the reconciler, not onely of the faithfull, but also of the whole world; that is, of Infidels too. From this Hypothesis, are their Classicall absurdities, which they cast upon the orthodox Protestants; That otherwise, the unbeleevers, if Christ did not obtaine for them reconciliation, should have nothing to beleeve: or, if they did beleeve, they should beleeve a lye; which are most false: for, though Christ died not for all, in respect of the efficacy of his death; yet, he died for all, in respect of the sufficiency of his merit. This all Infidels have, which they may beleeve in the Gospell, that Christ suffered sufficiently for the sins of all the world, and paid a full ransome, and reconciled all to God that beleeve in him; and therefore, shall be partakers of this merit and reconciliation, if of faithlesse they will become beleevers: Now, in affirming and beleeving this, they do no wayes beleeve a lye. But Infidels should beleeve a lye, if they should conclude, or were taught, that while they remaine in infidelity, reconciliation is obtained for them in Christ. For, this is a lye, and not truth, that Christ hath obtained reconciliation for all, even for Infidels as they are, and remaine such.
They suppose also, that many for whom Christ died, are damned; but the Apostle cries out against this as false, Who shall condemn? it is Christ that is dead: for,1 this Apostolical consolation were in vain, if this universal were not supposed; to wit, That no man is condemned, for whom Christ died. For, to this godly minds may firmly subsume; Christ died for me, and conclude; I shall not then be condemned. This is the Christians comfort, from Christs death. But they destroy this, putting a particular instead of an universal; Some for whom Christ died shall not be condemned: for, what consequence can arise of pure particulars? or what comfort? ⟨p. 830⟩And, in vain do they allege the words of the Catechism to cover their buskin and Massilianisme, saying, If one will have obtaining to be altogether the same that restoring to the state of grace, 2what will be done to the Catechism, which, Answ. 37. useth the same word? But, 1. this is false, that the Catechism useth the same words; for, it doth not say, That he might obtain the grace of God, justice, and life eternal; but that he might acquire it. Then, if it should use the same word obtained, this would help nothing the cothurne: for, it doth not say, for all; but, that to us; to wit, believers; of whom the question is, What believest thou when thou sayest, he suffered? Grace &c. he might acquire: But the Catechism evidently tieth them with a contradiction. For, it speaks of the real acquisition of grace, or restitution into the state of grace,3 with which Christ is said, to have purchased the Church of God with his own blood; that is, to have restored her into the state of grace. If then, he purchased, be all one with he obtained; it follows, that to obtain, is all one with, to restore into the state of grace; which they deny: and, to obtain reconciliation for all, is the same that, to restore into the state of grace; by denying of which in the Conference, they tie themselves again with the knot of contradiction.4
They suppose also, that many for whom Christ died, are damned; but the Apostle cries out against this as false, Who shall condemne? it is Christ that is dead: for,
Nor can they free themselves of this knot, by objecting that in the same Answer, Christ is said to have sustained the wrath of God against the sins of all mankind: for, these words will not suffer themselves to be thus glossed upon and wrested, That Christ by his death hath reconciled all mankind, or hath impetrated reconciliation and remission of sins to all mankind: for, to whom he purchased this, or, as they speak, hath impetrated, the subsequent words teach, that by his passion, &c. But they declare and amplify the cause and matter of his passion to have been this; to wit, The sense and enduring of Gods wrath, kindled against the sins, not of some men, but of all mankind; from whence is made an universality of sin, and of Gods wrath suffered by Christ against sin: but no ways an universality of reconciliation obtained or restored to all; for, the impetration or restitution of reconciliation declares the end and fruit of the passion; but these words speak not of the end and fruit, but of the efficiency and matter of the passion. The knot then remains, and in vain do they seek a pretext for their buskin in the Catechism.
Nor can they free themselves of this knot, by objecting that in the same Answer, Christ is said to have sustained the wrath of God against the sins of all mankinde: for, these words will not suffer themselves to be thus glossed upon and wrested, That Christ by his death hath reconciled all mankinde, or hath impetrated reconciliation and remission of sins to all mankinde: for, to whom he purchased this, or, as they speake, hath impetrated, the subsequent words teach, that by his passion, &c. But they declare and amplifie the cause and matter of his passion to have beene this; to wit, The sense and induring of Gods wrath, kindled against the sins, not of some men, but of all mankinde; from whence is made an universality of sin, and of Gods wrath suffered by Christ against sin: but no wayes an universality of reconciliation obtained or restored to all; for, the impetration or restitution of reconciliation declares the end and fruit of the passion; but these words speake not of the end and fruit, but of the efficiency and matter of the passion. The knot then remaines, and in vaine do they seeke a pretext for their buskin in the Catechisme.
Lastly,1 I find in the Conference one cunning trick, devised to elude the contradiction; where they write, That the passion and death of Christ doth in order precede both faith and infidelity; and therefore, the Remonstrants think it an absurdity, that Christ died for the faithful and Infidels, as Infidels; and that they assented he did die for all men, of whom afterward some became Infidels, some believers: for they discerned between the state of a sinner before his infidelity, and in it; and so they think they have sufficiently salved this contradiction; Christ died for all and singular; and, Christ died not for Infidels, whereof there be many: but indeed, they loose not the knot with these subtleties, and new tragical phrases; but they lay open the hidden ulcer of their minds, and the mystery of the new prophesies: Therefore let us examine the particulars.
Lastly,1 I finde in the Conference one cunning trick, devised to elude the contradiction; where they write, That the passion and death of Christ doth in order precede both faith and infidelity; and therefore, the Remonstrants thinke it an absurdity, that Christ died for the faithfull and Infidels, as Infidels; and that they assented he did die for all men, of whom afterward some became Infidels, some beleevers: for they discerned betweene the state of a sinner before his infidelity, and in it; and so they thinke they have sufficiently salved this contradiction; Christ died for all and singular; and, Christ died not for Infidels, whereof there be many: but indeed, they loose not the knot with these subtleties, and new tragicall phrases; but they lay open the hidden ulcer of their mindes, and the mystery of the new prophesies: Therefore let us examine the particulars.
1. Though we grant that Christs death and passion do in order precede faith, yet 'tis false that it goeth before infidelity in order; for, infidelity in order goeth before mans sin and his enmity against God, as in order the cause precedes the effect: but sin and mans enmity against God in order precede the passion and death of Christ, as the Apostle witnesseth, For Christ, when as yet we were without strength, in his own time he died for the wicked: 1also, When as yet we were sinners and enemies, we were reconciled by the death of his Son; therefore, infidelity in order precedes the passion and death of Christ.
1. Though we grant that Christs death and passion do in order precede faith, yet 'tis false that it goeth before infidelity in order; for, infidelity in order goeth before mans sin and his enmity against God, as in order the cause precedes the effect: but sin and mans enmity against God in order precede the passion and death of Christ, as the Apostle witnesseth, For Christ, when as yet we were without strength, in his owne time he died for the wicked: 1also, When as yet we were sinners and enemies, we were reconciled by the death of his Son; therefore, infidelity in order precedes the passion and death of Christ.
Again, there is no consequence: Christs death in order precedes faith and infidelity; therefore, it is absurd to say, that Christ died for the faithful, and unfaithful, as they were such: for, they delude us under the fallacy of non causa; for, whatsoever becomes of the order of faith, and infidelity to Christs death, it is most true that Christ died for believers and unbelievers as they were such, removing the hidden equivocations.
Againe, there is no consequence: Christs death in order precedes faith and infidelity; therefore, it is absurd to say, that Christ died for the faithfull, and unfaithfull, as they were such: for, they delude us under the fallacy of non causa; for, whatsoever becomes of the order of faith, and infidelity to Christs death, it is most true that Christ died for beleevers and unbeleevers as they were such, removing the hidden equivocations.
Of unbelievers, we have showed out of the Apostle testimony: for, if it be most true, that Christ died for sinners and enemies, as they were such; to wit, antecedently; ⟨p. 831⟩that is, who in order were sinners and enemies before Christs death; then it is most true, that Christ died for Infidels as they were such; to wit, antecedently; that is, who in order before Christs death were Infidels, after ceased to be wicked, unbelievers, enemies, by reason of their faith: The same is also most true of believers, and that whether Christs death be absolutely considered in it self, or in relation to Christs intention, and the Fathers counsel.
Of unbeleevers, we have shewed out of the Apostle testimonie: for, if it be most true, that Christ died for sinners and enemies, as they were such; to wit, antecedently; ⟨p. 831⟩that is, who in order were sinners and enemies before Christs death; then it is most true, that Christ died for Infidels as they were such; to wit, antecedently; that is, who in order before Christs death were Infidels, after ceased to be wicked, unbeleevers, enemies, by reason of their faith: The same is also most true of beleevers, and that whether Christs death be absolutely considered in it selfe, or in relation to Christs intention, and the Fathers counsell.
If we absolutely consider Christs death, as in order it goeth before faith, we conclude, that it is absurd to say, that Christ died for the faithful as such antecedently; that is, whose faith in order went before Christs death; for so belief must go before the thing believed, which is absurd; whereas, in such relatives, belief is posterior to the thing believed, as knowledge to the thing known; the sensitive act, to the sensible object, according to Aristotle. But, it is no absurdity if we say,1 that Christ died for the faithful as such consequently; that is, whose faith, looking on Christs death, and applying it to themselves, might attain the fruit and efficacy thereof; for, in this sense our Saviour Christ plainly saith,2 that he prayeth and sanctifieth himself for those that should believe in him: that he layeth down his life for his friends, and sheep; to wit consequently, who in order after the belief of Christs death, should be believers, friends, and sheep.
If we absolutely consider Christs death, as in order it goeth before faith, we conclude, that it is absurd to say, that Christ died for the faithfull as such antecedently; that is, whose faith in order went before Christs death; for so beliefe must goe before the thing beleeved, which is absurd; whereas, in such relatives, beliefe is posterior to the thing beleeved, as knowledge to the thing knowne; the sensitive act, to the sensible object, according to Aristotle. But, it is no absurdity if we say,1 that Christ died for the faithfull as such consequently; that is, whose faith, looking on Christs death, and applying it to themselves, might attaine the fruit and efficacy thereof; for, in this sense our Saviour Christ plainly saith,2 that he prayeth and sanctifieth himselfe for those that should beleeve in him: that he layeth downe his life for his friends, and sheepe; to wit consequently, who in order after the beliefe of Christs death, should be beleevers, friends, and sheepe.
But relatively to our Saviours intention, and his Fathers counsel, if we speak of Christs death, as in this Question we ought to speak, and understand the phrase, to die for another, is the most proper signification, as was said above: it is most true that Christ died, and that he would and should die, only for the faithful as they are such; that is, for such as should make his death by faith their own: not for Infidels as they are such; that is, for such as by infidelity should neglect and contemn his death. On the contrary, it is absurd to say, that Christ in that most proper sense did not die, nor would, nor should die only for the faithful; but also, that he died, and that he should, and would have died for Infidels, as they are such: For, that this is not only repugnant to holy Writ, and to the event (by which we ought to judge what our Saviours will, and his Fathers counsel was) but that it implies also a manifest contradiction, the Remonstrants own conscience will tell them.
But relatively to our Saviours intention, and his Fathers counsell, if we speake of Christs death, as in this Question we ought to speake, and understand the phrase, to die for another, is the most proper signification, as was said above: it is most true that Christ died, and that he would and should die, onely for the faithfull as they are such; that is, for such as should make his death by faith their owne: not for Infidels as they are such; that is, for such as by infidelity should neglect and contemne his death. On the contrary, it is absurd to say, that Christ in that most proper sense did not die, nor would, nor should die onely for the faithfull; but also, that he died, and that he should, and would have died for Infidels, as they are such: For, that this is not onely repugnant to holy Writ, and to the event (by which we ought to judge what our Saviours will, and his Fathers counsell was) but that it implies also a manifest contradiction, the Remonstrants owne conscience will tell them.
3. In that they assent, that Christ died for all men, it is well, if they mean of the greatness of the price of Christs death, which was most sufficient for all men; but if they mean the fruit and efficacy impetrated or purchased for all men, although both in life and death they be strangers to Christ, they do not assent to Scripture, and to the event, but to the Massilian Semi-pelagianism.
3. In that they assent, that Christ died for all men, it is well, if they meane of the greatnesse of the price of Christs death, which was most sufficient for all men; but if they meane the fruit and efficacy impetrated or purchased for all men, although both in life and death they be strangers to Christ, they do not assent to Scripture, and to the event, but to the Massilian Semi-pelagianisme.
4. It is true, that of all men, some in order after Christs death become faithful: but 'tis false, that in order after Christs death some become unfaithful; for, Christ being to die in order found all men in impiety, sin, and enmity, Rom. 5. v. 6.8, 9. therefore he found all in infidelity.
4. It is true, that of all men, some in order after Christs death become faithfull: but 'tis false, that in order after Christs death some become unfaithfull; for, Christ being to die in order found all men in impiety, sin, and enmity, Rom. 5. v. 6.8, 9. therefore he found all in infidelity.
5. In that they know how to discriminate, between the state of a sinner in his infidelity, and before it; they doubtless had not this knowledge in Scripture, which knoweth not the state of sin or of sinners before infidelity, or without it,1 but testifieth, that all men are borne the sons of wrath, of infidelity, and of disobedience. This then is that corrupt lurking sort of mystery of the new Prophecy, and the first lye upon which the five Articles, and divers other, both manifest and occult, are built; to wit, that man is borne without infidelity, and that there is no infidelity, till man be grown up, and rejects the Gospel: and from hence, that original sin, if any such be, is a punishment, not a fault; and hence is it, that the natural man hath free-will to good and evil; otherwise, wrongfully is faith demanded of him, who hath not the faculty of believing: hence are predestination and election of fore-seen faith: hence an universal impetration of reconciliation by Christs death: hence is resistible grace or indifferent: hence is the apostasy of the Saints, uncertain perseverance, doubtful faith, & other hid matters which time will reveal.
5. In that they know how to discriminate, betweene the state of a sinner in his infidelity, and before it; they doubtlesse had not this knowledge in Scripture, which knoweth not the state of sin or of sinners before infidelity, or without it,1 but testifieth, that all men are borne the sons of wrath, of infidelity, and of disobedience. This then is that corrupt lurking sort of mystery of the new Prophesie, and the first lye upon which the five Articles, and divers other, both manifest and occult, are built; to wit, that man is borne without infidelity, and that there is no infidelity, till man be growne up, and rejects the Gospell: and from hence, that originall sin, if any such be, is a punishment, not a fault; and hence is it, that the naturall man hath free-will to good and evill; otherwise, wrongfully is faith demanded of him, who hath not the faculty of beleeving: hence are predestination and election of fore-seene faith: hence an universall impetration of reconciliation by Christs death: hence is resistible grace or indifferent: hence is the apostacy of the Saints, uncertain perseverance, doubtful faith, & other hid matters which time wil reveale.
Out of all this, two things we have to observe: One is, that by this cunning shift, of the order of faith to Christs death, the contradiction is not unfolded or avoided, by which they are forced to entangle themselves in this Article: That Christ died ⟨p. 832⟩absolutely for all and singular, and obtained reconciliation for all; and yet that he died not for Infidels, whereof there be many; nor obtained reconciliation for them, which is an evident argument of an evil cause: For, when the Adversary is driven to admit of contradictions, he is gone. The other, because this Article troubles the Church with contradictions and equivocations, and overthrows it self, that it is not to be suffered in the Church.
Out of all this, two things we have to observe: One is, that by this cunning shift, of the order of faith to Christs death, the contradiction is not unfolded or avoided, by which they are forced to entangle themselves in this Article: That Christ died ⟨p. 832⟩absolutely for all and singular, and obtained reconciliation for all; and yet that he died not for Infidels, whereof there be many; nor obtained reconciliation for them, which is an evident argument of an evill cause: For, when the Adversary is driven to admit of contradictions, he is gone. The other, because this Article troubles the Church with contradictions and equivocations, and overthrowes it selfe, that it is not to be suffered in the Church.
Man hath not saving faith from himself, nor by force of his free-will; seeing that in the state of defection and sin, he cannot of himself either think or do any good, which is good indeed, such as saving faith is; but, it is necessary that he be borne over again by God in Christ through his holy Spirit, and that he be renewed in his mind, will, affections, and all his faculties; that he might think, understand, will, and perform that which is good, according to that of Christ, John 15.5. Without me ye can do nothing.
Man hath not saving faith from himselfe, nor by force of his free-will; seeing that in the state of defection and sin, he cannot of himself either thinke or do any good, which is good indeed, such as saving faith is; but, it is necessary that he be borne over againe by God in Christ through his holy Spirit, and that he be renewed in his minde, will, affections, and all his faculties; that he might think, understand, will, and performe that which is good, according to that of Christ, John 15.5. Without me yee can do nothing.
This grace of God is the beginning, progress, and perfection of all goodness, and that so far, that the regenerate man himself, without this first, or adventitious exciting, consequent, and co-operating grace, can neither will, think, or do any good, nor resist any evil tentation; so that all the good works which we can imagine, are to be ascribed to the grace of God in Christ. As for the true manner how that grace worketh, that is not irresistible; for, it is said of many, They resisted the holy Ghost, Act. 7. and else-where in many other places.
This grace of God is the beginning, progresse, and perfection of all goodnesse, and that so far, that the regenerate man himselfe, without this first, or adventitious exciting, consequent, and co-operating grace, can neither will, thinke, or do any good, nor resist any evill tentation; so that all the good workes which we can imagine, are to be ascribed to the grace of God in Christ. As for the true manner how that grace worketh, that is not irresistible; for, it is said of many, They resisted the holy Ghost, Act. 7. and else-where in many other places.
Although these two Articles in some sort differ; for the third is, concerning the operating cause of faith and conversion in an unregenerate man: the fourth in the former part is, concerning the operating cause of the progress, increment, and perfection of all good in the regenerate man; the other part is, concerning the manner by which that cause produceth both faith and conversion in the unregenerate, and the progress, increment, and perfection in the regenerate; notwithstanding, they do altogether cohere; and therefore, in the Conference, were conjoined by the parties that conferred; yea, and the fifth, which is concerning the perseverance of the Saints,1 is knit to the fourth, because the way of operating grace hath relation as well to that perfection which is obtained by perseverance, as to its beginning and progress.
ALthough these two Articles in some sort differ; for the third is, concerning the operating cause of faith and conversion in an unregenerate man: the fourth in the former part is, concerning the operating cause of the progresse, increment, and perfection of all good in the regenerate man; the other part is, concerning the manner by which that cause produceth both faith and conversion in the unregenerate, and the progresse, increment, and perfection in the regenerate; notwithstanding, they do altogether cohere; and therefore, in the Conference, were conjoyned by the parties that conferred; yea, and the fifth, which is concerning the perseverance of the Saints,1 is knit to the fourth, because the way of operating grace hath relation as well to that perfection which is obtained by perseverance, as to its beginning and progresse.
The third needs not much examination: if we follow the natural sense of the words, in both parts it is consentaneous to holy Writ. 1. That the procreating cause of saving faith in man, is not man himself, or his free-will; because, in the state of sin, man is not fit to think or do any good thing of himself, according to Scripture, Ephes. 2.9. 2 Cor. 3.5. &c. 2. That man necessarily must be by God in Christ, through the grace of the holy Ghost, regenerated or illuminated in his mind, renewed in his will, affections, &c. to understand, think, will, and perfect that which is good, according to the place alleged, John 15.6.
The third needs not much examination: if we follow the naturall sense of the words, in both parts it is consentaneous to holy Writ. 1. That the procreating cause of saving faith in man, is not man himselfe, or his free-will; because, in the state of sin, man is not fit to think or doe any good thing of himselfe, according to Scripture, Ephes. 2.9. 2 Cor. 3.5. &c. 2. That man necessarily must be by God in Christ, through the grace of the holy Ghost, regenerated or illuminated in his minde, renewed in his will, affections, &c. to understand, think, will, and perfect that which is good, according to the place alledged, John 15.6.
The fourth also in the former part, if you look upon the words, is true, and gives glory to God, because it ascribes the beginning, progress, and perfection of all goodness in the regenerate man, to God, or to grace, according to these sayings, Jam. 1.7. Ephes. 2.9. Phil. 1.6. &c. Neither would the orthodox men in the Conference, reprehend any of these, if they be understood according to the meaning of holy Scripture. But there is poison in the tail. The closure, concerning the way of the operation of that grace, takes away what before was granted. They deny this way of operation to be irresistible; in the Conference they call it resistible: These words, in their very sound are horrid and barbarous, and not without a Solecism: ⟨p. 833⟩they are barbarous, because not known to Latin Writers, for ought I know, nor to the holy Scriptures; unheard also in the Schools of orthodox Protestants, and perhaps of the Jesuits too. I have not read all the Jesuits, but Bellarmine, the chiefest of them, an exact Disputer of general and special assistance, or indifferent, and not indifferent motion and grace, in his Books of Grace & Free-will, hath it no where, as I remember. It seems, that Arminius his party hath devised this high buskin of irresistible grace, to the great benefit of their cause, to make the truth the more envied: As if, forsooth, the orthodoxall party did teach, that grace were irresistible, that is, coactive, or coaction.
The fourth also in the former part, if you looke upon the words, is true, and gives glory to God, because it ascribes the beginning, progresse, and perfection of all goodnesse in the regenerate man, to God, or to grace, according to these sayings, Jam. 1.7. Ephes. 2.9. Phil. 1.6. &c. Neither would the orthodox men in the Conference, reprehend any of these, if they be understood according to the meaning of holy Scripture. But there is poyson in the taile. The closure, concerning the way of the operation of that grace, takes away what before was granted. They deny this way of operation to be irresistible; in the Conference they call it resistible: These words, in their very sound are horrid and barbarous, and not without a Solecisme:
Even in sense and signification the terms are barbarous: for, that is irresistible, which cannot be resisted; resistible, which may be resisted. By what Author will they prove this to be spoken passively? Why may not rather actively irresistible signify that which cannot resist; resistible, which can resist? Many verbals, indeed, in bilis, drawn from actives, signify passively: as, amabilis, placabilis, &c. but not a few also descending from neutrals, are not of the passive, but of the neuter signification: as, rationabilis, risibilis, &c. for him who can reason and laugh, &c. So the word Stabilis, which (doubtless) the word Resistibilis doth follow, from resisto; that is, gradum sisto, to stand, or else, to resist. As then stabilis, so instabilis, repugnabilis, are not passives, as if they signified to be stood, to be unstood, to be resisted; but neutrals, which signify to stand long, not to stand, and able to resist: So he is called resistible, not who can be resisted, but who can resist: So contrarily, resistible will be very resisting: as, Echo resonabilis in Sabinus, is an Echo much resounding; which meaning, when the clause wanted in both Articles, this was not according to the Remonstrants mind: therefore they should have first consulted with Grammarians about the use of such a barbarous word, before they had troubled the Church with it.
Even in sense and signification the termes are barbarous: for, that is irresistible, which cannot be resisted; resistible, which may be resisted. By what Authour will they prove this to be spoken passively? Why may not rather actively irresistible signifie that which cannot resist; resistible, which can resist? Many verbals, indeed, in bilis, drawn from actives, signifie passively: as, amabilis, placabilis, &c. but not a few also descending from neutralls, are not of the passive, but of the neuter signification: as, rationabilis, risibilis, &c. for him who can reason and laugh, &c. So the word Stabilis, which (doubtlesse) the word Resistibilis doth follow, from resisto; that is, gradum sisto, to stand, or else, to resist. As then stabilis, so instabilis, repugnabilis, are not passives, as if they signified to be stood, to be unstood, to be resisted; but neutralls, which signifie to stand long, not to stand, and able to resist: So hee is called resistible, not who can be resisted, but who can resist: So contrarily, resistible will be very resisting: as, Echo resonabilis in Sabinus, is an Echo much resounding; which meaning, when the clause wanted in both Articles, this was not according to the Remonstrants mind: therfore they should have first consulted with Grammarians about the use of such a barbarous word, before they had troubled the Church with it.
But let this barbarous word be Latin, and of the passive signification; let, I say, the operation of resistible and irresistible grace be that which may be resisted by mans will, or may not, or which may be hindered or not hindered by free-will: the question is, what must be determined of this? Whether this grace, which produceth all these things, ascribed to it in both Articles, be resistible, or irresistible?
But let this barbarous word be Latine, and of the passive signification; let, I say, the operation of resistible and irresistible grace be that which may be resisted by mans will, or may not, or which may be hindred or not hindred by free-will: the question is, what must be determined of this? Whether this grace, which produceth all these things, ascribed to it in both Articles, be resistible, or irresistible?
The Remonstrants affirm the former, but deny the later. Our orthodox men, in the Conference, acknowledge not this barbarous and ambiguous term; but as for the matter it self, the former they deny, the later they affirm: If, 1(say they) by this word Resist, be understood to hinder altogether, and to master Gods working, we confess, that in mans conversion, such a working of grace is placed by us, which in this sense is irresistible; that is, which cannot be hindered nor mastered by mans resisting will: the reason is, because the grace of God in Christ doth overcome, hinder, and take away this opposition. And this their opinion they prove strongly by ten Arguments out of Scripture. On the contrary, the Remonstrants endeavour to show by nine Reasons, that their grace is resistible, the most of them being equivocal,2 because of the ambiguity of the word Grace, 3upon which chiefly depends the whole company of their sayings and arguments. To unfold therefore this ambiguity, and the better to perceive the state of the question, we must use the distinction of a three-fold state of mans will.
The Remonstrants affirme the former, but deny the later. Our orthodox men, in the Conference, acknowledge not this barbarous and ambiguous terme; but as for the matter it selfe, the former they denie, the later they affirme: If, 1(say they) by this word Resist, be understood to hinder altogether, and to master Gods working, wee confesse, that in mans conversion, such a working of grace is placed by us, which in this sense is irresistible; that is, which cannot be hindred nor mastered by mans resisting will: the reason is, because the grace of God in Christ doth overcome, hinder, and take away this opposition. And this their opinion they prove strongly by ten Arguments out of Scripture. On the contarie, the Remonstrants endeavour to shew by nine Reasons, that their grace is resistible, the most of them being equivocall,2 because of the ambiguitie of the word Grace, 3
For we must consider what mans will can do, or doth, before its conversion; what in conversion it self, and what after it. So there is a three-fold grace: the first is, calling grace, or, that of vocation external, answering the first state of the will: the other is operating grace, or, that of inward motion, answering the second state: the third is co-operating, or, of internal motion too, fit for the third state.
For we must consider what mans will can doe, or doth, before its conversion; what in conversion it selfe, and what after it. So there is a three-fold grace: the first is, calling grace, or, that of vocation externall, answering the first state of the will: the other is operating grace, or, that of inward motion, answering the second state: the third is co-operating, or, of internall motion too, fit for the third state.
⟨p. 826⟩
dyed for all and singular, which is ambiguous. 2. A Glosse, that hee hath obtained for all reconciliation and remission of sins, which is equivocall, and false. 3. A Condition, that none but the faithfull enjoy really this reconciliation, which is true: it limiteth the Proposition, and overthrowes the Glosse. 4. A Proofe, by the two alledged places of Scripture, which directly doe not concerne the Proposition: for, in neither of the alledged places is there any mention made of Christs death for all and singular; so that I wonder how the Authours could not call to mind fitter places: yea, the later member of the first compells them to limit the Proposition, and refells their Glosse; therefore some true passages are mixed with ambiguities and falshoods. I say, 'tis true, That no man really enjoyes the remission of sins, but the faithfull man: For, he that beleeveth not, the wrath of God abides on him, not remission or reconciliation; except that under these words, really enjoy, there seemes to lye hid the buskin of the two-fold fruition of remission of sins, or reconciliation: The one reall by faith, proper onely to the faithfull, which onely is true: The other not reall, without faith, common to all, even to Infidels, which is fictitious and nothing. Hence is gathered, that Christ properly dyed for all, and onely the faithfull, for none of the unfaithfull; and so he dyed not absolutely for all and singular: for, to dye for one, is properly by death to free one from death, or, to dye in the stead of another, that he may live; as is plaine, 2 Sam. 18.33. Would to God I had dyed for thee; that is, in thy stead, that thou mightst live. And of Christ, Rom. 5.6, 8. He dyed for us, when we were wicked, and sinners; that is, in our stead, that we, being delivered from sin and death, may live to righteousnesse, or, may have life eternall. So 1 Cor. 5.15. 1 John 3.16. and 4.9. John 15.13. &c.
. &c. when they are understood of the efficacie of Christs death, the universall All is necessarily to be restrained to the universalitie of beleevers, and of the elect; of which universality, Prosper writes finely:
In the elect (saith he) and in them that are separated out of the generality of all men, there is accounted a speciall kind of universality, that, out of all the world, all the world may seem to be delivered: and, out of all mankind, all men may seem to be assumed.
1Lib. 1. de vocat. Gent. c. 3.
dye, and according to his Fathers counsell should dye. 2. In respect of the fruit and efficacie of his death; that is, of a reall reconciliation and restitution with God, that he did not dye for all and singular, but for all and only the beleevers he would and should dye, as his Father had decreed. The first truth they are not sound anywhere in the conference plainly to prove, nor openly to deny; nor can they deny it, unlesse they will make his merit insufficient. The later truth they grant, in respect of the event: that all men are not really renewed in Christ, nor restored into the state of grace; but they deny it in respect of our Saviours intention, or the counsell of his Father, then which, what can be more absurd and false? For, whom God, by the death of his son, doth not indeed restore in time, them he never intended or decreed from eternitie really to restore: For, surely,
our God hath done whatsoever hee pleased. What then hee hath not done, nor doth in time, neither did he will it from eternitie: And whom Christ, by his death, hath not really restored, them he did not will to restore, nor by his Fathers counsell should he. But, by their own confession, Christ did not really restore all men into the state of grace; therefore they must needs confesse, that Christ hath not really willed their restitution, nor should hee, according to his Fathers counsell: Otherwise they must say, that Christ did not something, which every way he was willing to doe, and so let them deny his omnipotencie; or, what by his Fathers counsell hee should have done, so let them deny his obedience. If they object, that Christ would have gathered the sons of Jerusalem, but that he did not; let them also say, that God by all meanes would have gathered them; not onely by outward calling, and invitation to repentance, by his Prophets, his owne, and his Apostles preaching; but also by the drawing of his inward grace and power: and that for all that he prevailed not. Now let them see how they doe not accuse Gods omnipotent Son of impotencie, and attach themselves of blasphemy.
as in these words, I came not to condemne the world, but to save it. That the world may know that I am sent by thee: where the world cannot be understood, but of the world of the Elect. Againe, all things; that is, all that are justified by faith, as is plaine, Rom. 5.11.
by the intercession of the woman of Tekoa, did absolutely obtaine reconciliation from David for the paricide Absalom; that, without any condition, he should be brought into the Kings sight, and that the father should kisse his son: As also Esther is said to have obtained for the Jews security, absolutely without condition: Or under condition of faith to be required in all, that if all beleeve in the Son, they may indeed be reconciled; if they beleeve not, they may be debarred from reconciliation: as for example, Impunity was obtained from Salomon to seditious Adomiah upon condition of his innocency,
this Apostolicall consolation were in vaine, if this universall were not supposed; to wit, That no man is condemned, for whom Christ died. For, to this godly minds may firmely subsume; Christ died for me, and conclude; I shall not then be condemned. This is the Christians comfort, from Christs death. But they destroy this, putting a particular instead of an universall; Some for whom Christ died shall not be condemned: for, what consequence can arise of pure praticulars? or what comfort?
⟨p. 830⟩
And, in vaine do they alledge the words of the Catechisme to cover their buskin and Massilianisme, saying, If one will have obtaining to be altogether the same that restoring to the state of grace,
what will be done to the Catechisme, which, Answ. 37. useth the same word? But, 1. this is false, that the Catechisme useth the same words; for, it doth not say, That he might obtaine the grace of God, justice, and life eternall; but that he might acquire it. Then, if it should use the same word obtained, this would helpe nothing the cothurne: for, it doth not say, for all; but, that to us; to wit, beleevers; of whom the question is, What beleevest thou when thou sayest, he suffered? Grace &c. he might acquire: But the Catechisme evidently tieth them with a contradiction. For, it speakes of the reall acquisition of grace, or restitution into the state of grace,
with which Christ is said, to have purchased the Church of God with his owne bloud; that is, to have restored her into the state of grace. If then, he purchased, be all one with he obtained; it follows, that to obtaine, is all one with, to restore into the state of grace; which they deny: and, to obtaine reconciliation for all, is the same that, to restore into the state of grace; by denying of which in the Conference, they tye themselves againe with the knot of contradiction.
they are barbarous, because not knowne to Latine Writers, for ought I know, nor to the holy Scriptures; unheard also in the Schooles of orthodox Protestants, and perhaps of the Jesuites too. I have not read all the Jesuites, but Bellarmine, the chiefest of them, an exact Disputer of generall and speciall assistance, or indifferent, and not indifferent motion and grace, in his Books of Grace & Free-will, hath it no where, as I remember. It seems, that Arminius his party hath devised this high buskin of irresistible grace, to the great benefit of their cause, to make the truth the more envied: As if, forsooth, the orthodoxall party did teach, that grace were irresistible, that is, coactive, or coaction.
upon which chiefly depends the whole companie of their sayings and arguments. To unfold therefore this ambiguitie, and the better to perceive the state of the question, we must use the distinction of a three-fold state of mans will.