The Positions of Hunnius concerning the union.
pp. 771–790191 passagespart 2 of 5
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 771–790191 passagespart 2 of 5
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
It belongs notwithstanding to the integrity of the Word incarnate, or of Christ, as be is Christ;1 whose person, after the Incarnation, is compounded, as the Ecclesiastic Writers do witness.
It belongs notwithstanding to the integrity of the Word incarnate, or of Christ, as be is Christ;1 whose person, after the Incarnation, is compounded, as the Ecclesiastick Writers doe witnesse.
1In the ninth Position there lies some deceit: for he saith, that the flesh belongs to the integrity of the Word incarnate, that afterward he may conclude the ubiquity of the flesh; when as the entire Word, being incarnate, is every-where. But he cunningly saith, that it belongs to the integrity of the Word incarnate, but not to the integrity of the person of the Word incarnate; lest he should seem to conclude a quaternity, or make the Word one person, and the Word incarnate another. To the same purpose is it, when he calls the person of the Word incarnate, or of Christ, [Greek or Hebrew], compounded. Now, the orthodox Writers, though they reject not simply these speeches (for they themselves speak so, without any fear of cavilling) yet ⟨p. 775⟩they warn us to understand them aright, to wit, in that sense as they were used by Ecclesiastic Writers; to whose testimony our adversaries appeal, lest we should conclude, that the hypostasis of the Word, before its Incarnation, was imperfect; or, that it is from some other hypostasis of the Word incarnate: For so, of necessity, a quaternity must follow. We must then stick to that which our adversary confesseth rightly, Thes. 8. that the Word is in it self altogether perfect and entire. We must also hold what he acknowledgeth, Thes. 12. that there is not one Son begot of the Father from eternity, and another conceived and begot of Mary in time; but that there is one and the same: For, these being granted, it is plain, that the Word, and the Word incarnate are not two different persons, but one and the same numerical hypostasis; and that they differ not essentially, but only in some respect: as Peter, when he is clothed, and when he is naked, is one and the same person, differing from it self not subjectively, but accidentally.
1In the ninth Position there lies some deceit: for he saith, that the flesh belongs to the integrity of the Word incarnate, that afterward hee may conclude the ubiquitie of the flesh; when as the entire Word, being incarnate, is every-where. But he cunningly saith, that it belongs to the integrity of the Word incarnate, but not to the integritie of the person of the Word incarnate; lest hee should seem to conclude a quaternitie, or make the Word one person, and the Word incarnate another. To the same purpose is it, when he calls the person of the Word incarnate, or of Christ, 〈non-Latin alphabet〉, compounded. Now, the orthodox Writers, though they reject not simply these speeches (for they themselves speak so, without any feare of cavilling) yet ⟨p. 775⟩they warne us to understand them aright, to wit, in that sense as they were used by Ecclesiastick Writers; to whose testimony our adversaries appeale, lest wee should conclude, that the hypostasis of the Word, before its Incarnation, was imperfect; or, that it is from some other hypostasis of the Word incarnate: For so, of necessity, a quaternity must follow. We must then stick to that which our adversary confesseth rightly, Thes. 8. that the Word is in it selfe altogether perfect and entire. We must also hold what he acknowledgeth, Thes. 12. that there is not one Son begot of the Father from eternity, and another conceived and begot of Mary in time; but that there is one and the same: For, these being granted, it is plaine, that the Word, and the Word incarnate are not two different persons, but one and the same numericall hypostasis; and that they differ not essentially, but onely in some respect: as Peter, when he is clothed, and when he is naked, is one and the same person, differing from it selfe not subjectively, but accidentally.
Hence further it follows manifestly, that nothing can be properly said to belong to the integrity of the Word incarnate, which doth not also belong to the integrity of the person of the Word; but to say this, were to deny the perfection of the Word, and to make a composition in God.
Hence further it followes manifestly, that nothing can be properly said to belong to the integrity of the Word incarnate, which doth not also belong to the integrity of the person of the Word; but to say this, were to deny the perfection of the Word, and to make a composition in God.
1That the flesh then doth belong to the integrity of the person of the Word, is to be so understood, as the person is called compounded by Writers, to wit, not properly, but improperly: For, on the first Thesis we showed, That the person of the Word incarnate is compounded, made up, constituted, consisteth of two natures; not as an heap of corn is made up of many grains, a mixed body of elements: Or, as a living creature, is compounded of a body and soul, which are peculiar ways of composition. Neither can they be attributed to the person of Christ, unless many absurdities do follow hence, as Thomas shows at length. But the term Composition is here taken in a large signification,2 for the position of divers things together in one, which way soever it be; for, so the hypostatical union may be called a composition: to wit, that by it the person of the Son of God, before subsisting of one nature, now subsisteth of two, remaining in the interim perfect and simple in it self: But not as if the person of the Word incarnate were made up of two natures, or of a person and a nature, neither of which that person is; as man is made up of a reasonable soul and body, but neither of these is man. After the same manner the flesh may be said to belong to the integrity of the person of the Word incarnate, not as a part integrating and completing an incomplete person; but, as a nature assumed into the hypostasis of the Word, in which the same Word inhabiteth whole and entire corporally, as it were in his Temple, and exhibits himself, as it were clothed with a garment or veil, to be seen and felt, he being in himself invisible and unpalpable: For so we see the Scripture speaks of that inhabitation of the Word in the flesh assumed, John 2.21. Phil. 2.8. Hebr. 10.20. and so do the Orthodox Fathers: among the rest, Austin; 3The Word (saith he) was made flesh, that is, man; yet not converted, nor changed into that which was made: but clothed with flesh, that he might be seen of fleshly men, in a fleshly manner. Neither doth our Adversary speak otherwise, when he saith, Thes. 18. that the whole Word was clothed and covered with flesh.
1But let us not imagine, that the flesh accidentally only, and by way of an external habit, is super-added and joined to the Word, as a garment extrinsically adheres to a man; or accidentally and changeably; which, as Lombard witnesseth, was the opinion of some: for the flesh is so assumed into the most intimate and inward hypostasis of the Word, that the union thereof with the Word is truly hypostatical; that is, it hath the same subsistence with the Word.
1But let us not imagine, that the flesh accidentally only, and by way of an externall habit, is super-added and joyned to the Word, as a garment extrinsecally adheres to a man; or accidentally and changeably; which, as Lombard witnesseth, was the opinion of some: for the flesh is so assumed into the most intimate and inward hypostasis of the Word, that the union thereof with the Word is truly hypostaticall; that is, it hath the same subsistence with the Word.
These things being observed, there will be no danger of fallacies; for it will be easy, out of the distinction and true explication of the phrase, to destroy whatsoever the Adversary can hereafter allege from thence, for the omnipresence of the flesh: For, the entire and whole person of the Word incarnate is God, and immense, and omnipresent; eternal also, and begotten of the Father, and illocall, &c. Although the flesh assumed into that person be not, or is not made God, nor immense, ⟨p. 776⟩nor omnipresent, and much less eternal, begot of the Father, illocall, &c. For it will not follow, saith Austin, that whatsoever is in God, must be every-where as God.
These things being observed, there will be no danger of fallacies; for it will be easie, out of the distinction and true explication of the phrase, to destroy whatsoever the Adversary can hereafter alledge from thence, for the omnipresence of the flesh: For, the entire and whole person of the Word incarnate is God, and immense, and omnipresent; eternall also, and begotten of the Father, and illocall, &c. Although the flesh assumed into that person be not, or is not made God, nor immense, ⟨p. 776⟩nor omnipresent, and much lesse eternall, begot of the Father, illocall, &c. For it will not follow, saith Austin, that whatsoever is in God, must be every-where as God.
The person then of our Saviour consisteth not of one nature only, but of two coupled together immutably, and without confusion; so likewise indivisibly, and without separation: and so they meet together in one hypostasis, according to the Canon of the Council of Chalcedon.
The person then of our Saviour consisteth not of one nature onely, but of two coupled together immutably, and without confusion; so likewise indivisibly, and without separation: and so they meet together in one hypostasis, according to the Canon of the Councell of Chalcedon.
The person of our Saviour consisteth of two natures, not by the composition of one third of integral parts, or essential either, as of matter and form, as this Doctor doth tacitly imply; but only by that way which was declared in the first and ninth Thesis: 1for otherwise, there would be a quaternity. The words of the Canon of the Council of Chalcedon sound thus, The Son of God was manifested in two natures, without confusion, without conversion, without division, without separation; the difference of the natures, being no ways abolished by the union, but rather the propriety of each nature, meeting in one person or hypostasis, is preserved. That fiction then of our Adversary, which followeth in the 36. Thesis, is repugnant to this Canon; to wit, That the humanity, in respect of the union, hath most eminently transcended all locality in the illocall Word, and hath obtained an illocall way of subsisting: For so, the properties of both natures should not be preserved, but confused; for, the flesh should lose its locality in the illocall Word: and, consequently, its circumscription, dimensions, quantity and substance: Neither can it be in any case both local and illocall; for it is impossible, that one and the same nature can be susceptible of contrary properties or affections together,2 as, with Theodoret, Damascene teacheth every-where.
The person of our Saviour consisteth of two natures, not by the composition of one third of integrall parts, or essentiall either, as of matter and forme, as this Doctor doth tacitely imply; but onely by that way which was declared in the first and ninth Thesis: 1for otherwise, there would be a quaternity. The words of the Canon of the Councell of Chalcedon sound thus, The Son of God was manifested in two natures, without confusion, without conversion, without division, without separation; the difference of the natures, being no waies abolished by the union, but rather the propriety of each nature, meeting in one person or hypostasis, is preserved. That fiction then of our Adversary, which followeth in the 36. Thesis, is repugnant to this Canon; to wit, That the humanity, in respect of the union, hath most eminently transcended all localitie in the illocall Word, and hath obtained an illocall way of subsisting: For so, the properties of both natures should not be preserved, but confused; for, the flesh should lose its localitie in the illocall Word: and, consequently, its circumscription, dimensions, quantity and substance: Neither can it be in any case both locall and illocall; for it is impossible, that one and the same nature can be susceptible of contrary properties or affections together,
Hence there is but one Lord Jesus Christ, 1 Cor. 8. and in the two natures and nativities, which are more then generically different, there is but one only Son, in his eternal generation without a mother, in his temporal nativity without a Father, Hebr. 7.
Hence there is but one Lord Jesus Christ, 1 Cor. 8. and in the two natures and nativities, which are more then generically different, there is but one onely Son, in his eternall generation without a mother, in his temporall nativity without a Father, Hebr. 7.
Neither did the Father from eternity beget one Son, and Mary his mother another, by a temporal birth and conception; but that only one Son of God and man.
Neither did the Father from eternity beget one Son, and Mary his mother another, by a temporall birth and conception; but that onely one Son of God and man.
As the Father begot not one Son from eternity, and Mary another in time, but the very same; so there is not a different, but the person of the Word, before and after the Incarnation, is the same in essence and number: For, the second person of the Trinity, was neither changed by the Incarnation, nor was it multiplied or perfected; therefore the younger Divines were well warned to take heed, and rightly to understand the Adversaries phrase,1 when he saith, that the flesh belongs to the integrity of the Word incarnate; and that the person of the Word incarnate was composed: For, it is very improper to say, That the person of the Word, is a part of the person of the Word incarnate; because the person is not made a part of the person, either of its own, or of another's: For, if of its own, then the whole should be a part of it self; if of another's, there would not be the same Son, begot of his Father, and borne of his mother: and necessarily there will follow a multiplication and quaternity of the persons; therefore Austin saith well, Christ is one person of a double substance (saith he,2) because he is God and man; and yet, neither God nor man can be called a part of this person: otherwise God, the Son of God, before he took the form of a servant, was not whole; and he increased, when man was added to his divinity.
As the Father begot not one Son from eternity, and Mary another in time, but the very same; so there is not a different, but the person of the Word, before and after the Incarnation, is the same in essence and number: For, the second person of the Trinitie, was neither changed by the Incarnation, nor was it multiplied or perfected; therefore the younger Divines were well warned to take heed, and rightly to understand the Adversaries phrase,1 when he saith, that the flesh belongs to the integrity of the Word incarnate; and that the person of the Word incarnate was composed: For, it is very improper to say, That the person of the Word, is a part of the person of the Word incarnate; because the person is not made a part of the person, either of its owne, or of anothers: For, if of its owne, then the whole should be a part of it selfe; if of anothers, there would not be the same Son, begot of his Father, and borne of his mother: and necessarily there will follow a multiplication and quaternity of the persons; therefore Austin saith well, Christ is one person of a double substance (saith he,
As Gabriel said, What shall be borne of thee, shall be called holy▪ and the Son of God. Hence Elisabeth, being full of the holy Ghost, calls her the mother of her Lord.
By reason of this identity of the person or hypostasis, the Word was said to be made flesh, John 1. The branch of David, Jehovah, Jerem. 23. The Son of man, Son of the living God, Matth. 16. The second man, the Lord from heaven, 1 Cor. 15. And the second Adam made a quickening Spirit, Ibid.
By reason of this identity of the person or hypostasis, the Word was said to be made flesh, John 1. The branch of David, Jehovah, Jerem. 23. The Son of man, Son of the living God, Matth. 16. The second man, the Lord from heaven, 1 Cor. 15. And the second Adam made a quickning Spirit, Ibid.
Now, there is one Christ, not by conversion of the Deity into flesh, but by assumption of the humanity into God.
Wherefore, lest the phrase of the Evangelist, The Word was made flesh, might seem to sound of any change of the Word into flesh, the holy Ghost explains it by words equivalent, saying, That God is manifested in the flesh, that Jesus Christ came in the flesh, that the Son of God was made partaker of flesh and blood, and took the seed of Abraham; and that in Christ dwells all fullness of the Godhead bodily, 1 Tim. 3. 1 John. 4. Heb. 2. Col. 2.
Wherefore, lest the phrase of the Evangelist, The Word was made flesh, might seem to sound of any change of the Word into flesh, the holy Ghost explaines it by words equivalent, saying, That God is manifested in the flesh, that Jesus Christ came in the flesh, that the Son of God was made partaker of flesh and bloud, and took the seed of Abraham; and that in Christ dwells all fulnesse of the Godhead bodily, 1 Tim. 3. 1 John. 4. Heb. 2. Col. 2.
All this is right, if the phrase of Athanasius (The assumption of the humanity into God) be not wrested against the meaning of Athanasius: 1as if he had signified either a changing of the humanity into God, or an equalling of it with God, or a transfusion of the properties of the Godhead into it, by which it is made God: For, whatsoever is created (saith the same Athanasius) cannot be God; therefore let the assumption of the humanity into God,2 be understood of its hypostatical union with God, or the Word, the properties of both being preserved, according to the declaration of the Synod of Chalcedon, &c. And of Austin, in his book de fide ad Petrum, God then received into his person the form of a servant, that is, the nature of a servant, &c.
All this is right, if the phrase of Athanasius (The assumption of the humanity into God) be not wrested against the meaning of Athanasius: 1as if hee had signified either a changing of the humanity into God, or an equalling of it with God, or a transfusion of the properties of the Godhead into it, by which it is made God: For, whatsoever is created (saith the same Athanasius) cannot be God; therefore let the assumption of the humanity into God,2 be understood of its hypostaticall union with God, or the Word, the properties of both being preserved, according to the declaration of the Synod of Chalcedon, &c. And of Austin, in his book de fide ad Petrum, God then received into his person the forme of a servant, that is, the nature of a servant, &c.
But the Word was not so made flesh, as that any part thereof was associated with the flesh, which was assumed: For the Word, being of a spiritual nature, is not cut or divided into parts.
But the Word was not so made flesh, as that any part thereof was associated with the flesh, which was assumed: For the Word, being of a spirituall nature, is not cut or divided into parts.
But the whole Word, in the whole fullness of its Deity, is united to the flesh: All of it (as the Orthodox Fathers tell us) was clothed with flesh, and covered with it,1 wholly incarnate, inhumanated, and incorporated.
But the whole Word, in the whole fulnesse of its Deity, is united to the flesh: All of it (as the Orthodox Fathers tell us) was clothed with flesh, and covered with it,1 wholly incarnate, inhumanated, and incorporated.
And this is also right: For neither can there be, nor can we imagine how there should be, any union of parts between the flesh and the Word, which is indivisible: The whole Word then assumed the whole flesh, and with the whole flesh the whole Word was personally united.
In what sense the Word is said to be clothed, and covered with flesh, &c. we have already explained in the ninth Thesis, to wit, not by way of an external habit accidentally, but by way of an intrinsical union substantially. Hence then it appears, that the Word was not changed into flesh, by taking of man; no more then our limbs, being clothed, are changed, as Austin speaketh.1 Neither is it a speech proper enough, when they say, that the flesh appertains to the integrity of the person of the Word incarnate; that is, that it is an integral part of it, as three feet belong to the integrity of the three-footed stool: but rather, that the flesh belongs to the person of the Word incarnate, as being the nature assumed by the Word into the unity of the person, in which it might manifest it self to the world: as Austin saith, The Word was made flesh, that is, clothed with flesh, that to fleshly men he might appear in a fleshly way.
In what sense the Word is said to be clothed, and covered with flesh, &c. wee have already explained in the ninth Thesis, to wit, not by way of an externall habit accidentally, but by way of an intrinsecall union substantially. Hence then it appeares, that the Word was not changed into flesh, by taking of man; no more then our limbs, being clothed, are changed, as Austin speaketh.1 Neither is it a speech proper enough, when they say, that the flesh appertaines to the integritie of the person of the Word incarnate; that is, that it is an integrall part of it, as three feet belong to the integrity of the three-footed stoole: but rather, that the flesh belongs to the person of the Word incarnate, as being the nature assumed by the Word into the unitie of the person, in which it might manifest it selfe to the world: as Austin saith, The Word was made flesh, that is, clothed with flesh, that to fleshly men he might appeare in a fleshly way.
Yet no man will deny or doubt, that the Incarnation of the Word, which is indivisible, was totally made; if that be understood, without including the immensity of the Word, within the dimensions of the flesh: as also without an ubiquitary diffusion of the finite flesh with the infinite Word.
Which union, because total, is foolishly compared with examples of partial unions; to wit, of the Sun, touching some part of his Orb: Of the stone, enclosed within some part of the ring: Of Antwerp, situated near a part of the sea.
Which union, because totall, is foolishly compared with examples of partiall unions; to wit, of the Sun, touching some part of his Orbe: Of the stone, enclosed within some part of the ring: Of Antwerp, situated neer a part of the sea.
We must confess, that this hidden & admirable union of the unmeasurable nature of God, with the measured nature of man, cannot fully be expressed by any similitude. ⟨p. 778⟩And, although both ancient and modern Divines make use of divers Similes; yet, we may truly say of them all, with Damascene, In all similitudes, there are many dissimilitudes. And, it is impossible to find examples, that may express the Deity and Incarnation in every thing. Justin, Cyril, Athanasius made use of these Similes that are taken from the Sun, a Ring, the Ocean. Basil useth the similitude of an hot iron: Athanasius of a burned stick, or burning iron: Cyril of a burning coal: Damascene of a fiery sword: Justin and Athanasius of the body and light of the Sun: But none of all these similitudes will exactly agree with the thing it self. This man toucheth our Divines, for using examples of partial unions; but with little sincerity: for, sometimes they make use of such Similes, not to declare exactly the thing it self, from which, we confess, the examples of finite things are far distant; but only to show the sophistry of Ubiquitaries: For example; When Jacobus Andreas, at Maulbrun, did foolishly demonstrate the Ubiquity thus, Gods right hand is every-where; the humanity of Christ sits at Gods right hand: Ergo, the humanity is every-where. Our men, by a Syllogism, altogether like this (if you look up on the form) made it appear, that this was a naughty argument, and consisted of four terms: The Ocean encompasseth the whole world; Antwerp is seated near the Ocean: Ergo, Antwerp encompasseth the whole world. By this way they did not compare matter with matter, but one fault with another; for both Syllogisms were alike faulty: therefore the showing of this error was not foolish. Neither doth Doctor Hunnius demonstrate better the illocalitie of the flesh in the Word below, in his 36. Thesis. It is thus in brief, The Word is illocall, the flesh was assumed into the Word: Ergo, the flesh is illocall. Why then do we not send this Disputer to the four terms of Antwerp, and the Ocean? For, as these are different terms, To be the Ocean, and to be seated near the Ocean; so these are different, To be the Word, and to be in the Word: as in the Vulcanian demonstration these were different speeches, To be Gods right hand, and, To sit at Gods right hand.
We must confess, that this hidden & admirable union of the unmeasurable nature of God, with the measured nature of man, cannot fully be expressed by any similitude. ⟨p. 778⟩