The Positions of Hunnius concerning the union.
pp. 771–790191 passagespart 3 of 5
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
pp. 771–790191 passagespart 3 of 5
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The similitude of the union of the soul and body is more apt to declare this mystery,1 which Athanasius used in his Creed; and Cyrillus, after him, in his Synodical Epistle, saying, The Word, in the assumed nature, hath made such an habitation for it self, as the soul is believed to have in its proper body.
The similitude of the union of the soule and body is more apt to declare this mysterie,1 which Athanasius used in his Creed; and Cyrillus, after him, in his Synodicall Epistle, saying, The Word, in the assumed nature, hath made such an habitation for it selfe, as the soule is beleeved to have in its proper body.
Of this Simile thus writeth Justin; 1Some (saith he) having conceived in their mind of this union, as of the union of soul and body, have so delivered it; and it's a convenient example, though not in all points, yet in some. Also the example of man is in some respect to be admitted, and in some respect to be avoided. And 'tis so indeed: For they agree thus, That, as the reasonable soul and body are united into one person; and, as in one hypostasis subsist two natures, distinct in their essences and properties, and concurring in these operations that are proper to men; and one of them working what is proper to it, but not without the communion of the other: Even so, saith Hierome, it is known, that one and the same Christ is God and man, and that he did work according to both forms;2 to wit, of the humanity and divinity, and that by this he exercised two operations: For, both forms or natures did operate; the one communicating with the other in that which was proper to it: The Word operating what is proper to the Word, and the flesh putting in execution what belongs to the flesh, &c. But in many things the Simile will not hold: For, in man there is an union of two finite natures; but in Christ, of a finite nature, and an infinite. In man, both natures are shut up within the same bounds; but in Christ, the divinity is not confined to the narrow limits of the flesh. In man, the union is the composition of matter and form; but in Christ, the flesh is not the matter of the divinity, nor this the form of the flesh. In man, there results a third thing out of the composition, which is neither of the other two; but in Christ, the Word or person is the same before the union, but naked and simple; after the union, clothed with flesh, and in a manner compounded. In man, the union is dissolved by death; but Christ will never lay aside the nature which he once assumed. Lastly, to this ⟨p. 779⟩purpose serves that which Thomas observes:3 In man (saith he) there is a two fold unity made up; to wit, of the nature, and of the person: of the nature, when as the soul is formally united to the body, perfecting it; that of two, there may be made up one nature, as of the act and potentiality, of the matter and form: and in this regard the similitude consisteth not; because the divine nature cannot be the form of the body. 2.
Of this Similie thus writeth Justin; 1Some (saith he) having conceived in their mind of this union, as of the union of soule and body, have so delivered it; and it's a convenient example, though not in all points, yet in some. Also the example of man is in some respect to be admitted, and in some respect to be avoided. And 'tis so indeed: For they agree thus, That, as the reasonable soule and body are united into one person; and, as in one hypostasis subsist two natures, distinct in their essences and properties, and concurring in these operations that are proper to men; and one of them working what is proper to it, but not without the communion of the other: Even so, saith Hierome, it is knowne, that one and the same Christ is God and man, and that he did work according to both formes;2 to wit, of the humanity and divinity, and that by this he exercised two operations: For, both formes or natures did operate; the one communicating with the other in that which was proper to it: The Word operating what is proper to the Word, and the flesh putting in execution what belongs to the flesh, &c. But in many things the Similie will not hold: For, in man there is an union of two finite natures; but in Christ, of a finite nature, and an infinite. In man, both natures are shut up within the same bounds; but in Christ, the divinitie is not confined to the narrow limits of the flesh. In man, the union is the composition of matter and forme; but in Christ, the flesh is not the matter of the divinitie, nor this the forme of the flesh. In man, there results a third thing out of the composition, which is neither of the other two; but in Christ, the Word or person is the same before the union, but naked and simple; after the union, clothed with flesh, and in a manner compounded. In man, the union is dissolved by death; but Christ will never lay aside the nature which he once assumed. Lastly, to this ⟨p. 779⟩purpose serves that which Thomas observes:3 In man (saith he) there is a two fold unitie made up; to wit, of the nature, and of the person: of the nature, when as the soule is formally united to the body, perfecting it; that of two, there may be made up one nature, as of the act and potentiality, of the matter and forme: and in this regard the similitude consisteth not; because the divine nature cannot be the forme of the body. 2.
Of the person, as when of these is made up one man, consisting of a body and a soul; and in this is the similitude: for one Christ subsisteth in the divine and humane nature.
Of the person, as when of these is made up one man, consisting of a body and a soule; and in this is the similitude: for one Christ subsisteth in the divine and humane nature.
Therefore, as the soul, in respect of its substance, is not without the body; for it is all united to its body: so the whole Word incarnate can neither be, nor be found, nor ought to be enquired for, out of its own flesh.
Therefore, as the soule, in respect of its substance, is not without the body; for it is all united to its body: so the whole Word incarnate can neither be, nor be found, nor ought to be enquired for, out of its owne flesh.
By a manifest fallacy, from that which is said respectively, or secundum quid, to that which is spoken simply, of a similitude, he concludes a falsehood: For, this is Hunnius his collection, The Simile drawn from man, is more fit then from other things: Ergo, it agrees in every thing; and, consequently, the reason is alike of the soul and of the deity: that, as the soul is confined to the bounds of the body; so the deity doth no where subsist without the flesh. Who may not here sensibly perceive the imposture? He makes a comparison between the soul and the Word, as if there were a parity between them; whereas there is an extreme imparity: for the soul, being a finite spirit, cannot be without the body, in which it is, so long as it is tied to the body, though it be all in all, and all in every part: But the Deity of the Word is not a finite spirit, but immense, and most pure, by its most simple immensity, all in the finite flesh, and all, and the same together without the finite flesh, and subsisting without all things: For who will say, that the Deity of the Word was only there; suppose in the mothers womb, in the Temple, in the Justice-Hall, on the Cross, in the Sepulchre, &c. where his flesh was said to be circumscribed, and to be absent in other places, where his flesh was not? Who will say, that he did not fill heaven and earth, that he was not at Rome, at Athens, and every-where without Judea, at the same time when his body, that was most united then to him, did remain within the limits of Judea alone? Surely, he who affirms the contrary, either feigns a Deity enclosed and circumscribed in the narrow bounds of the body; or else a body diffused every-where with the Deity; that is (to use few words) he makes either a finite Deity, or an infinite body. This then is one of these false hypotheses, by which this Sophister under-props the ubiquity of the flesh. He adds also sophistically, that the Word neither is, nor can be sought or found, without its flesh: which words neither have the same meaning, nor the same truth. For Orthodox men confess, that the Word is not to be sought out of the flesh; because in the flesh only, as in his temple, he will be sought and worshipped by faith and prayers. And from hence they gather against the Ubiquitaries, that the flesh of the Word doth not lurk within a sacramental crust;
By a manifest fallacie, from that which is said respectively, or secundum quid, to that which is spoken simply, of a similitude, hee concludes a falshood: For, this is Hunnius his collection, The Similie drawne from man, is more fit then from other things: Ergo, it agrees in every thing; and, consequently, the reason is alike of the soule and of the deity: that, as the soule is confined to the bounds of the body; so the deity doth no where subsist without the flesh. Who may not here sensibly perceive the imposture? He makes a comparison between the soule and the Word, as if there were a parity between them; whereas there is an extreme imparity: for the soule, being a finite spirit, cannot be without the bodie, in which it is, so long as it is tied to the bodie, though it be all in all, and all in every part: But the Deitie of the Word is not a finite spirit, but immense, and most pure, by its most simple immensity, all in the finite flesh, and all, and the same together without the finite flesh, and subsisting without all things: For who will say, that the Deitie of the Word was onely there; suppose in the mothers womb, in the Temple, in the Justice-Hall, on the Crosse, in the Sepulchre, &c. where his flesh was said to be circumscribed, and to be absent in other places, where his flesh was not? Who will say, that he did not fill heaven and earth, that he was not at Rome, at Athens, and every-where without Judea, at the same time when his bodie, that was most united then to him, did remaine within the limits of Judea alone? Surely, he who affirmes the contrary, either feignes a Deity enclosed and circumscribed in the narrow bounds of the bodie; or else a bodie diffused every-where with the Deity; that is (to use few words) hee makes either a finite Deity, or an infinite bodie. This then is one of these false hypotheses, by which this Sophister under-props the ubiquity of the flesh. He addes also sophistically, that the Word neither is, nor can be sought or found, without its flesh: which words neither have the same meaning, nor the same truth. For Orthodoxe men confesse, that the Word is not to be sought out of the flesh; because in the flesh onely, as in his temple, he will be sought and worshipped by faith and prayers. And from hence they gather against the Ubiquitaries, that the flesh of the Word doth not lurk within a sacramentall crust;
because they neither worship it, nor ought they to worship it: yet they deny not therefore, that the Word is not elsewhere by that essential immensity, which he hath in common with the Father and the holy Ghost: For so the Word, being enclosed within finite flesh, should be terminated or bounded; or else the flesh should have an immensity every-where, with the immensity of the Word; both which is false. Nor do the Orthodox Fathers otherwise speak or think. Athanasius, 1The Word is in the flesh, and over and above all things. Ibid. He subsisteth over and above all things. Ibid. At the same moment, when he was in an humane body, he was over and above all things. So Hieron ad Marcel. He who was infinite, was also in the Son of man total. August.2 The Son of God was total in the body, and total every-where.
because they neither worship it, nor ought they to worship it: yet they deny not therefore, that the Word is not elsewhere by that essentiall immensitie, which hee hath in common with the Father and the holy Ghost: For so the Word, being enclosed within finite flesh, should be terminated or bounded; or else the flesh should have an immensity every-where, with the immensity of the Word; both which is false. Nor doe the Orthodox Fathers otherwise speake or thinke. Athanasius, 1The Word is in the flesh, and over and above all things. Ibid. He subsisteth over and above all things. Ibid. At the same moment, when he was in an humane body, hee was over and above all things. So Hieron ad Marcel. He who was infinite, was also in the Son of man totall. August.2 The Son of God was totall in the body, and totall every-where.
They are deceived then, and they reduce this admirable union to the narrowness of one only place, who dream, that the Word in the flesh is in one, and only in that place, where the humane nature of Christ visibly dwells; but besides this place, that it subsisteth over and above it, in other places innumerable.
They are deceived then, and they reduce this admirable union to the narrownesse of one onely place, who dreame, that the Word in the flesh is in one, and onely in that place, where the humane nature of Christ visibly dwells; but besides this place, that it subsisteth over and above it, in other places innumerable.
He condemneth for an error, not ours, but the doctrine both of holy Writ, and of godly Antiquity: for, the Scriptures unanimously witness, that the humane nature of Christ was visibly confined still to one place, and not to two or more at once invisibly; the incomprehensible [Word] in the mean time showing its presence, both in its flesh, and else-where, where the flesh is not, and the union still remaining entire. The Fathers also write clearly, that the Word was so in the flesh, that it was not shut up within those narrow confines, but that it subsisted out of it, and over and above all things else. It is a fallacy, if not a falsehood, when he saith, that now this admirable union, is not to be confined to the narrow enclosure of one only place: for, though the flesh be shut up in one place, it will not follow, that therefore the union is to be reduced to these narrow straits; because, to be reduced to a narrow place, and to be in a place, is the property of the flesh, not of the union; but the properties of the natures neither make the union, nor effect it: otherwise, by the same reason one might cavil, that the union is corporeal, visible, dead; because, the flesh is corporeal, visible, and dead: or, that it is eternal, immense, and God; because, the Word is eternal, immense, and God. But, although the flesh is not diffused every-where with the [Word,] nor the Word circumscribed by the narrowness of the flesh; notwithstanding the flesh is nowhere not united to the Word, and subsisting by the Word; and the Word is nowhere not united to the flesh, and subsisting in the flesh: wheresoever then the flesh is, there is the union; and wheresoever the Word is, there is the union; not by reason of the diffusion of the flesh, but by reason of that most simple immensity of the Word; by which he is so in the flesh, that he is not therefore contained in the flesh, but every-where together without it he filleth all things; and so he is without the flesh, that notwithstanding he subsisteth every where in it, and that not by any one part of himself, but total; neither another person, but the same; for, we must not imagine, that there is one part of the Word in the flesh, and another without it; but he wholly subsisteth in the flesh, and wholly without the flesh; because he is immense and impartible.
He condemneth for an errour, not ours, but the doctrine both of holy Writ, and of godly Antiquity: for, the Scriptures unanimously witnesse, that the humane nature of Christ was visibly confined still to one place, and not to two or more at once invisibly; the incomprehensible [Word] in the meane time shewing its presence, both in its flesh, and else-where, where the flesh is not, and the union still remaining entire. The Fathers also write cleerely, that the Word was so in the flesh, that it was not shut up within those narrow confines, but that it subsisted out of it, and over and above all things else. It is a fallacy, if not a falshood, when he saith, that now this admirable union, is not to be confined to the narrow inclosure of one onely place: for, though the flesh be shut up in one place, it will not follow, that therefore the union is to be reduced to these narrow straits; because, to be reduced to a narrow place, and to be in a place, is the property of the flesh, not of the union; but the properties of the natures neither make the union, nor effect it: otherwise, by the same reason one might cavill, that the union is corporeall, visible, dead; because, the flesh is corporeall, visible, and dead: or, that it is eternall, immense, and God; because, the Word is eternall, immense, and God. But, although the flesh is not diffused every-where with the [Word,] nor the Word circumscribed by the narrownesse of the flesh; notwithstanding the flesh is nowhere not united to the Word, and subsisting by the Word; and the Word is nowhere not united to the flesh, and subsisting in the flesh: wheresoever then the flesh is, there is the union; and wheresoever the Word is, there is the union; not by reason of the diffusion of the flesh, but by reason of that most simple immensity of the Word; by which he is so in the flesh, that he is not therefore contained in the flesh, but every-where together without it he filleth all things; and so he is without the flesh, that notwithstanding he subsisteth every where in it, and that not by any one part of himselfe, but totall; neither another person, but the same; for, we must not imagine, that there is one part of the Word in the flesh, and another without it; but he wholly subsisteth in the flesh, and wholly without the flesh; because he is immense and impartible.
Neither is there one Word in heaven, and another on earth, but the same is every-where in the flesh, or incarnate, because most simple; although in the mean while, the flesh, both by the verity of its essence, and in one place where it wills, it remaineth.
Neither is there one Word in heaven, and another on earth, but the same is every-where in the flesh, or incarnate, because most simple; although in the meane while, the flesh, both by the verity of its essence, and in one place where it wills, it remaineth.
We do not therefore dream, that the [Word] in the flesh is only in one place, in other infinite places without the flesh, and therefore, without the union: for, it is every-where in its own flesh, supporting and moving by a secret and indissoluble union; but no where, and at no time deserting it, or distant from it: but properly it is not either in one, or in infinite places, seeing these things are in place only, that have dimensions. But God the Word is of that immensity, that he hath neither a corporal, nor an intellectual place, but metaphorically only, being said to be there where his operation is known,1 as Damascene witnesseth. In brief, the [Word] is every-where, and so remaineth united to its flesh, even existing without it; for, it can never be absent from the flesh, being immense, and every-where wholly the same, without extension or multiplication, though in the mean while, the essence of the flesh is only in one place.
We do not therefore dreame, that the [Word] in the flesh is only in one place, in other infinite places without the flesh, and therefore, without the union: for, it is every-where in its owne flesh, supporting and moving by a secret and indissoluble union; but no where, and at no time deserting it, or distant from it: but properly it is not either in one, or in infinite places, seeing these things are in place onely, that have dimensions. But God the Word is of that immensity, that he hath neither a corporall, nor an intellectuall place, but metaphorically onely, being said to be there where his operation is knowne,1 as Damascene witnesseth. In briefe, the [Word] is every-where, and so remaineth united to its flesh, even existing without it; for, it can never be absent from the flesh, being immense, and every-where wholly the same, without extension or multiplication, though in the meane while, the essence of the flesh is onely in one place.
But, if this Ubiquitary Doctor understandeth not, or approveth not of these things, let him proceed in his dream, of his dimensive and extensive [Word;] which is not total every-where, but some-where it existeth in some part of it, or else is wholly some-where absent: but, we believe with Athanasius, that this is of high admiration, that the Word contained by none, containeth notwithstanding all things; and being present in the body, is not else-where absent, but subsisteth over and above all things, and yet is most present in the natures of all things, but more chiefly in his own flesh. These my steries are to be adored, but not to be squared by the dull edge of humane reason.
But, if this Ubiquitary Doctor understandeth not, or approveth not of these things, let him proceed in his dreame, of his dimensive and extensive [Word;] which is not totall every-where, but some-where it existeth in some part of it, or else is wholly some-where absent: but, we beleeve with Athanasius, that this is of high admiration, that the Word contained by none, containeth notwithstanding all things; and being present in the body, is not else-where absent, but subsisteth over and above all things, and yet is most present in the natures of all things, but more chiefly in his owne flesh. These my steries are to be adored, but not to be squared by the dull edge of humane reason.
But because, by the Apostles definition, the whole personal union is and consisteth in that ⟨p. 781⟩corporal inhabitation and immanency of all fullness of the deity in the flesh, by an unavoidable consequence we infer, that where it dwells not in the flesh, but is imagined to be without it, there it cannot be said to be united to it.
But because, by the Apostles definition, the whole personall union is and consisteth in that ⟨p. 781⟩corporall inhabitation and immanency of all fulnesse of the deity in the flesh, by an unavoidable consequence we inferre, that where it dwels not in the flesh, but is imagined to be without it, there it cannot be said to be united to it.
He proves the Word to be no-where without the flesh, but first out of Pauls definition of union, as he saith; then, by a contraposition out of the definition, he thus seems to gather: What is immanent in the flesh, is not without it; the Word is immanent or dwells in the flesh, because the union is the inhabitation, or immanency of the Word in the flesh; therefore the Word is not without the flesh. Answ. If he did contend, that the Word was no-where so without the flesh, but that it is also in the flesh, we would yield to him in all this: But, when he simply denieth the Word to have any existence out of the flesh, that he may diffuse the flesh every-where with it; we answer to the Major proposition, with a distinction; That cannot be without the flesh, which is so inherent in it, as that it is shut up within the dimensions of it: But we deny the Word to be so inherent in the flesh, or that it is such an immanency by which the Apostle shows rather the union, then defines it to be the corporal inhabitation of all fullness of the deity in the flesh; and the Adversary himself shortly after denieth it.
He proves the Word to be no-where without the flesh, but first out of Pauls definition of union, as he saith; then, by a contraposition out of the definition, he thus seemes to gather: What is immanent in the flesh, is not without it; the Word is immanent or dwels in the flesh, because the union is the inhabitation, or immanency of the Word in the flesh; therefore the Word is not without the flesh. Answ. If he did contend, that the Word was no-where so without the flesh, but that it is also in the flesh, we would yeeld to him in all this: But, when he simply denyeth the Word to have any existence out of the flesh, that he may diffuse the flesh every-where with it; we answer to the Major proposition, with a distinction; That cannot be without the flesh, which is so inherent in it, as that it is shut up within the dimensions of it: But we deny the Word to be so inherent in the flesh, or that it is such an immanency by which the Apostle shews rather the union, then defines it to be the corporall inhabitation of all fulnesse of the deity in the flesh; and the Adversary himselfe shortly after denyeth it.
For, the Word doth not so inhabit, as to be circumscribed by the limits of the flesh; nor is he so immanent, that he is no where without it; as the soul existing in the body, is no where out of the body: but that he is never separated or absent from it. The inhabitation then is not the enclosing of the Word within the flesh, but a secret conjunction with the flesh into one hypostasis.
For, the Word doth not so inhabit, as to be circumscribed by the limits of the flesh; nor is he so immanent, that he is no where without it; as the soule existing in the body, is no where out of the body: but that he is never separated or absent from it. The inhabitation then is not the enclosing of the Word within the flesh, but a secret conjunction with the flesh into one hypostasis.
In that he calls the union an immanency, he hath not this out of the Apostle, but out of Damascene, who calls it [Greek or Hebrew]. (which word some translate a permeation; others, an immeation, others, an immanency, or inhabitation) no ways understanding the Eutychian mixture of the natures, or the circumscription of the Word in the flesh, or the diffusion of the flesh with the Word; but a mutual, intimate, and indissoluble union of both natures into one hypostasis, the natures and properties remaining entire: which is so well known out of Damascene, that it needs not be insisted on.
In that he calls the union an immanency, he hath not this out of the Apostle, but out of Damascen, who calls it 〈non-Latin alphabet〉. (which word some translate a permeation; others, an immeation, others, an immanency, or inhabitation) no wayes understanding the Eutychian mixture of the natures, or the circumscription of the Word in the flesh, or the diffusion of the flesh with the Word; but a mutuall, intimate, and indissoluble union of both natures into one hypostasis, the natures and properties remaining entire: which is so well knowne out of Damascen, that it needs not be insisted on.
By a contraposition out of the definition he thus gathers, Where the Word is united to the flesh, there it dwells in the flesh, and so remains in it, as that it is no where without it: therefore where it dwells not in the flesh, but is fancied to be without it, there it cannot be said to be united with it; which, because it is absurd (for so there will follow a Nestorian separation) it is also absurd, that the Word should be any-where without the flesh.
By a contraposition out of the definition he thus gathers, Where the Word is united to the flesh, there it dwels in the flesh, and so remaines in it, as that it is no where without it: therefore where it dwels not in the flesh, but is fancied to be without it, there it cannot be said to be united with it; which, because it is absurd (for so there will follow a Nestorian separation) it is also absurd, that the Word should be any-where without the flesh.
But first, we have said before,1 that Ubiety is improperly attributed to the Word and union; then it is false, which in the converting proposition he assumes of such an immanency, as that the Word is no-where without the flesh; for this is to beg the matter in question. Besides, in the Proposition converted, he admits of that fallacy which is called (Ignoratio elenchi, or) the ignorance of the reprehending Argument, feigning these two to be repugnant; to wit, The Word inhabiteth in the flesh, and, the Word is without the flesh, which indeed are not repugnant, by reason of the most simple immensity of the Word, as is showed. The Argument of our Adversary directly concluding, is this, Where the Word is united to the flesh, there it is not out of the flesh, because the union is the inhabitation; but the Word is every-where united to the flesh; therefore it is no-where without the flesh. But the Minor Proposition hath this ignoration of the Elenchus, and trusts to a false definition: for, we will not yield him, that the union is such an inhabitation as he fancies; wherefore we deny the Major: for, wheresoever the Word is, he inhabits all in the flesh, and all without the narrowness of the flesh, filling heaven and earth with the immensity of his essence,
But first, we have said before,1 that Ubiety is improperly attributed to the Word and union; then it is false, which in the converting proposition he assumes of such an immanency, as that the Word is no-where without the flesh; for this is to beg the matter in question. Besides, in the Proposition converted, he admits of that fallacy which is called (Ignoratio elenchi, or) the ignorance of the reprehending Argument, feigning these two to be repugnant; to wit, The Word inhabiteth in the flesh, and, the Word is without the flesh, which indeed are not repugnant, by reason of the most simple immensity of the Word, as is shewed. The Argument of our Adversary directly concluding, is this, Where the Word is united to the flesh, there it is not out of the flesh, because the union is the inhabitation; but the Word is every-where united to the flesh; therefore it is no-where without the flesh. But the Minor Proposition hath this ignoration of the Elenchus, and trusts to a false definition: for, we will not yeeld him, that the union is such an inhabitation as he fancies; wherefore we deny the Major: for, wheresoever the Word is, he inhabits all in the flesh, and all without the narrownesse of the flesh, filling heaven and earth with the immensity of his essence,
Especially, because, according to this opinion, we must determine that the whole Word, (seeing he cannot be divided into parts) in his whole personality, and in the whole plenitude of the deity, is in innumerable places without his humanity; which were truly to draw in sunder ⟨p. 782⟩through many places, that most intrinsical, and altogether indistant union.
Especially, because, according to this opinion, we must determine that the whole Word, (seeing he cannot be divided into parts) in his whole personality, and in the whole plenitude of the deity, is in innumerable places without his humanity; which were truly to draw in sunder ⟨p. 782⟩through many places, that most intrinsecall, and altogether indistant union.
You sing over again the same song: To place the whole Word in his whole personality, and in the whole fullness of the deity in innumerable places without his own flesh, is to distract in sunder the indistant union of the natures; but to do this is a wicked thing; therefore so must that. We again deny the Major, for the union remains indistant, even when the whole Word without the narrowness of the flesh fills all other things; because, by his most simple immensity, neither all, nor half of him (seeing he is individed) departs, or is absent from his flesh; neither is he pulled away or separated by any distance of place, but he subsists so all within it, that he is also all-present every-where without it: whereas, not another, but the same and entire Word is within the flesh which is without it. And this argument of pulling asunder the natures, is very silly; for it flows from a false imagination, that the Word existing without the flesh, remains not united to the flesh; which is both most false, and impossible: for, if it were any-where absent from its flesh, it were not immense; and, if in any part only it remained in the flesh, it should be divided. Therefore, to feign any distance between the natures, is truly to feign a Word having dimensions; which our Adversary, by clearing of himself, sufficiently showeth.
You sing over againe the same song: To place the whole Word in his whole personality, and in the whole fulnesse of the deity in innumerable places without his owne flesh, is to distract in sunder the indistant union of the natures; but to do this is a wicked thing; therefore so must that. We againe deny the Major, for the union remaines indistant, even when the whole Word without the narrownesse of the flesh fills all other things; because, by his most simple immensity, neither all, nor halfe of him (seeing he is individed) departs, or is absent from his flesh; neither is he pulled away or separated by any distance of place, but he subsists so all within it, that he is also all-present every-where without it: whereas, not another, but the same and entire Word is within the flesh which is without it. And this argument of pulling asunder the natures, is very silly; for it flowes from a false imagination, that the Word existing without the flesh, remaines not united to the flesh; which is both most false, and impossible: for, if it were any-where absent from its flesh, it were not immense; and, if in any part onely it remained in the flesh, it should be divided. Therefore, to feigne any distance betweene the natures, is truly to feigne a Word having dimensions; which our Adversary, by cleering of himselfe, sufficiently sheweth.
Some orthodox men untie this knot, by distinguishing the personality and deity of the Word; confessing that to be no-where out of his flesh, seeing there is one personality of both: but this they make all to exist within and without the flesh, in that the essence of the Word is simply infinite. But, lest our Adversaries should cavil, that so we do not make the personality equally infinite with the essence of the Word; therefore we will wave this distinction. We know that the personality and divinity of the Word differ not subjectively, but only in some respect: when as then both are equally immense and most simple; by the same reason it must necessarily follow, that both subsist wholly in their flesh, and wholly without the flesh, and, with the Father and holy Ghost, fill heaven and earth.
Some orthodox men untie this knot, by distinguishing the personality and deity of the Word; confessing that to be no-where out of his flesh, seeing there is one personality of both: but this they make all to exist within and without the flesh, in that the essence of the Word is simply infinite. But, lest our Adversaries should cavill, that so we do not make the personality equally infinite with the essence of the Word; therefore we will wave this distinction. We know that the personality and divinity of the Word differ not subjectively, but onely in some respect: when as then both are equally immense and most simple; by the same reason it must necessarily follow, that both subsist wholly in their flesh, and wholly without the flesh, and, with the Father and holy Ghost, fill heaven and earth.
In the mean time, out of our doctrine, there doth not follow such a shutting up of the Word into the nature assumed, as makes the person of the Word lose his infinity, or become finite; but from bence rather is inferred this perpetual immanency, inhabitation, and incarnation we speak of, which elevates the finite humanity, into the infinite personality of the Son of God, and consequently, it makes that the Word is never absent from its flesh, never distant from it,1 and never subsisteth without it; but that without distance, as (Damascene saith) it is united with it, and remaineth with it above all locality of this created world, ineffably, and still present.
In the meane time, out of our doctrine, there doth not follow such a shutting up of the Word into the nature assumed, as makes the person of the Word lose his infinity, or become finite; but from bence rather is inferred this perpetuall immanency, inhabitation, and incarnation we speake of, which elevates the finite humanity, into the infinite personality of the Son of God, and consequently, it makes that the Word is never absent from its flesh, never distant from it,1 and never subsisteth without it; but that without distance, as (Damascen saith) it is united with it, and remaineth with it above all locality of this created world, ineffably, and still present.
Here he perceives, that out of his immanency or inhabitation, necessarily follows the inclusion and finity of the Word; therefore he denies the sequel: but in vain, for thus he is convinced; What is so immanent in the finite flesh, that it existeth no-where without it; that must necessarily be shut up within the dimensions of the flesh, and be finite, as the flesh is finite: But the Word is thus immanent in the flesh; it is therefore shut up within the finite dimensions of the flesh; which is absurd. The Major is most true: our Adversaries Minor is absurd, there follows then an absurd conclusion: He saith, that the perpetual immanency follows out of his doctrine rather; but, this is to beg the matter in question, to infer an immanency out of an immanency. He saith,1 that the immanency elevateth the finite humanity, into the infinite personality of the Son of God. If he understood this Teratology of the union of the flesh with the infinite hypostasis of the flesh, retaining the properties thereof, no orthodox man would reject it; but the stile of truth is plain, whereas that of a lye is intricate: such as this is. For, he doth not mean this of the union, as he saith, but of an ubiquitary diffusion of the flesh with the Word, which orthodox Divines simply deny; for, the flesh can no more cast off her finity and dimensions, then she can her very nature, no not in the union it self. Now, if remaining ⟨p. 783⟩finite, she is elevated into an infinity; that is, is made infinite; then sure it must be both at once finite and infinite, quantitative and without quantity, flesh and no flesh: and, what is this, but to fancy an Utopian Chimera? Again, he saith, by means of this immanency, the Word is never absent, no-where distant from his flesh: but indeed, this is effected, not by the immanency which he feigns, but by his most simple immensity; for, by this it is that the Word is all the same in his flesh, and every-where without all. He saith, that by the means of this immanency, the Word never subsisteth without the flesh, but inseparably is united to it. But, again, he ascribes a false effect, to an untrue cause, and admits ignorationem elenchi; for, the inhabitation of the Word in the flesh, (which he, by an ambiguous term, will rather call an immanency) is not his inclusion, or confining within the flesh; that is, within the dimensions of the flesh:
Here he perceives, that out of his immanency or inhabitation, necessarily followes the inclusion and finity of the Word; therefore he denies the sequell: but in vaine, for thus he is convinced; What is so immanent in the finite flesh, that it existeth no-where without it; that must necessarily be shut up within the dimensions of the flesh, and be finite, as the flesh is finite: But the Word is thus immanent in the flesh; it is therefore shut up within the finite dimensions of the flesh; which is absurd. The Major is most true: our Adversaries Minor is absurd, there followes then an absurd conclusion: He saith, that the perpetuall immanency followes out of his doctrine rather; but, this is to beg the matter in question, to inferre an immanency out of an immanency. He saith,
neither do these two, To be without the flesh, and, To remain inseparably united to the flesh, destroy one another, as was showed but now. Yet, if both be not true together concerning the Word; neither can he be immense, nor can he be God. Lastly, in that, he saith, the flesh united to the Word, or the Word to the flesh, remaineth so above all locality of this created world, it is either a vain Teratology, or a false opinion, that the flesh is made illocall by the union, because the Word is illocall; of which hereafter we will speak upon the 36. These.
neither do these two, To be without the flesh, and, To remaine inseparably united to the flesh, destroy one another, as was shewed but now. Yet, if both be not true together concerning the Word; neither can he be immense, nor can he be God. Lastly, in that, he saith, the flesh united to the Word, or the Word to the flesh, remaineth so above all locality of this created world, it is either a vaine Teratologie, or a false opinion, that the flesh is made illocall by the union, because the Word is illocall; of which hereafter we will speake upon the 36. These.
But, it no ways follows, if the Word, after the Incarnation, be not without the nature which was personally assumed; that therefore, we must believe him to be no-where without that place, in which Christs humane nature, by the condition of its essence, remains.
But, it no wayes follows, if the Word, after the Incarnation, be not without the nature which was personally assumed; that therefore, we must beleeve him to be no-where without that place, in which Christs humane nature, by the condition of its essence, remaines.
Here he avoids another rock, that, granting the immanency which he feigns, the Word will never be without the place of the nature assumed, therefore he must needs be finite: he denies the sequel of this, but in vain; for he is convinced thus: What is not without a finite nature existing in a certain place, neither is it without that place, in which the finite nature existeth; but the Word is no where without his finite nature assumed, existing in a certain place, where-ever it be; ergo, it is no where without that place, and consequently, the Word is made finite. The Minor is our Adversaries, the reason of the Major is manifest and firm: That, albeit the place be one thing, and the nature existing in that place be another thing; notwithstanding the nature assumed, by the condition of its essence (as our Adversary rightly confesseth) is not without a place, nor remains out of a place, and the place is equal to it: whatsoever then is not without the nature assumed, as the thing contained or placed, neither is that without the place containing; because, the thing containing, and the thing contained; the place, and the thing placed, are equal.
Here he avoids another rock, that, granting the immanency which he feignes, the Word will never be without the place of the nature assumed, therefore he must needs be finite: he denies the sequell of this, but in vaine; for he is convinced thus: What is not without a finite nature existing in a certaine place, neither is it without that place, in which the finite nature existeth; but the Word is no where without his finite nature assumed, existing in a certaine place, where-ever it be; ergo, it is no where without that place, and consequently, the Word is made finite. The Minor is our Adversaries, the reason of the Major is manifest and firme: That, albeit the place be one thing, and the nature existing in that place be another thing; notwithstanding the nature assumed, by the condition of its essence (as our Adversary rightly confesseth) is not without a place, nor remaines out of a place, and the place is equall to it: whatsoever then is not without the nature assumed, as the thing contained or placed, neither is that without the place containing; because, the thing containing, and the thing contained; the place, and the thing placed, are equall.