The Arguments of a certain famous Disputer, for the oral manducation.The Arguments of a certaine famous Disputer, for the orall manducation.
pp. 815–8164 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The Arguments of a certain famous Disputer, for the oral manducation.
The Arguments of a certaine famous Disputer, for the orall manducation.
To whatsoever organ the eating of one thing in the Lords Supper doth agree, to that same it is needful, that the eating of another thing should agree: but to the mouth of the body, the eating of one thing; that is, of the bread in the Supper, doth agree: and therefore of another thing; that is, of Christs body. Answ. The Major is true of foods that are naturally conjoined, or contain each other: as meat, or flesh-pies; but the bread and Christs body are not thus conjoined: and therefore of these the Major is false. But he proves the Major: Whosoever includes, under the same word of eating, bread and wine, the body and blood of Christ, he also affirms, that both are received by the same instrument; but Christ includes bread and wine, his body and blood, within the same word of eating: Therefore Christ affirms also, that both are received by the same instrument of eating. Answ. 1. The Disputer doth not conclude the Major that is denied, which he should conclude by an universal Syllogism in Barbara: therefore his proof is idle. Answ. 2. The Major is a petition of the thing in question, and is denied. The falsehood also is plain out of