pp. 1259–126578 passagespart 2 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
It is no marvel though these mad dogs do so bark against me, whom they think to have counselled the kings Majesty (I would to God I had also throughly persuaded him) that he should take away from these unjust sacrilegious possessors, the riches wherewithal they are fatted and engreased like Swine. For this is the nature of dogs, that if any man go about to take away the bone out of their mouth, by and by to snatch at him and tear him with their teeth. It is out of all controversy unto such which have any wit at all, that such were very childish, that is to say, ignorant of all learning and judgement, which did so fat and feed with their possessions these belly beasts. For who would not judge it more then childish,1 to bestow the kings victuals or meat upon the bellies of the Prophets of Baal and Jezebel? But all they which at this present do endue such filthy sinks (I will not call them deus of thieves) with such revenues they do follow the steps of Jezebel, for what other thing do they, when as daily they are bleating and bowing before their Images, burning of incense, and fall flat down before their altars, but that which in times past the prophets of Baal did when as they transported the worship of God unto an Idol? Wherefore, if Daniel and Elijah were spotted with heresy when they would have destroyed the Priests of Baal, I grant that I also must be an heretic. But forsomuch as then he did nothing but which was commanded him of the Lord, that was able to kill the Prophet which had allured the people to follow strange gods, he could not truly and justly be accused of heresy: so neither can my adversaries spot me therewithal, except peradventure they will condemn in me, that where as Elijah dealt more rigorously with the Prophets of Baal, for he cast them into the broke Kidron. I required or desired no more, but that the riches which was wickedly bestowed upon them, and their possessions might be taken from them.
It is no maruell though these mad dogges do so barke agaynst me, whom they thinke to haue councelled ye kings Maiesty (I would to God I had also throughly perswaded hym) that he should take away from these vniust sacrilegious possessours, the riches wherewithall they are fatted and engreased lyke Swyne. For this is the nature of dogs, that if any man go about to take away the boane out of their mouth, by and by to snatche at hym and teare hym with theyr teeth. It is out of all controuersie vnto such which haue any wit at all, that such were very childish, that is to say, ignoraunt of all learnyng and iudgement, which did so fat and feede with their possessiōs these belly beastes. For who would not iudge it more then childish,1 to bestow the kyngs vitayles or meate vpon the bellies of the Prophets of Baal and Iesabell? But all they which at this present do endue such filthy sinkes (I wyll not call them deus of thieues) with such reuenues they do follow the steps of Iesabell, for what other thing do they, when as daily they are bleating and bowyng before theyr Images, burnyng of incense, and fall flat downe before their altars, but yt which in tymes past ye prophets of Baal dyd when as they transported the worship of God vnto an Idoll? Wherefore, if Daniel and Helias were spotted with heresie when they would haue destroyed the Priests of Baall, I graunt that I also must be an hereticke. But forsomuch as then he did nothyng but which was cō maunded hym of the Lord, that was able to kyll the Prophet which had allured the people to follow strange gods, he could not truly and iustly be accused of heresie: so neyther can my aduersaries spot me therewithall, except peraduenture they will condemne in me, that where as Elias delt more rigorously with the Prophetes of Baall, for he cast them into the broke Kidron. I required or desired no more, but that the riches which was wickedly bestowed vpon them, and theyr possessions might be taken frō them.
He willed and desired, and oftentimes with his whole heart prayed that the church of Scotland might come and be brought to the same point and state,1 and to like ruin as the church of England was already come unto.
He willed and desired, and oftentimes with his whole heart prayed that the church of Scotland might come and be brought to the same poynt and state,1 and to lyke ruine as the church of England was already come vnto.
If the church of Israel decayed, when as in the time of Zorobabell, N•emias, and other holy men, it was released and set at liberty out of Babylon: I grant also, that it was a ruin unto the Englishmen to have departed and gone away out of Babylon, the mother of all whoredom:1 upon whose rotten and filthy paps and breasts, they have a long time depended and hanged, being made drunk with the wine of her whoredom and unshamefastnesse. They had rather cause to give me thanks, which with so sincere and good a heart, wished unto them so happy a fall. But these unthankful persons thought it not enough with slander and reproach to tear me asunder, but that now also as blind rage and madness hath taken away all sincerity and uprightness of mind and judgement to lye in wait, and lay snares for my life.
If the church of Israel decayed, when as in the tyme of Zorobabell, N•emias, and other holy men, it was released and set at libertie out of Babilon: I graunt also, that it was a ruine vnto the Englishmen to haue departed and gone away out of Babylon, the mother of all whoredome:1 vpon whose rotten and filthy paps and brests, they haue a long tyme depended and hanged, beyng made drunke with the wyne of her whoredome and vnshamefastnesse. They had rather cause to geue me thankes, which wyth so sincere and good a heart, wished vnto them so happy a fall. But these vnthankfull persones thought it not enough wt slaunder and reproch to teare me asunder, but that now also as blynd rage and madnesse hath taken away all sinceritie and vprightnesse of mynde and iudgement to lye in wayte, and lay snares for my lyfe.
He hath openly holden, said, and affirmed, preached, and taught, that the laws of the Church, that is to say, the sacred Canons approved and allowed by the holy Catholic and Apostolic church to be of •o force, strength, or effect, alleging therefore, and affirming that they are made and invented, contrary to the law of God.
He hath openly holden, sayd, and affirmed, preached, and taught, that the lawes of the Church, that is to say, the sacred Canons approoued and allowed by the holy Catholike and Apostolike church to be of •o force, strength, or effect, alledging therfore, and affirmyng that they are made and inuented, contrary to the law of God.
God forbid that I should say, that those things which are approved and allowed by the holy Catholic Church, should be of no effect or value. For well I know that the holy Apostolic church hath never allowed, ordained,1 or taught any thing which she hath not learned of the Lord, the apostles are witnesses thereof, Peter and Paul, whereof the one of them dareth not freely utter or speak of any of those things, which Christ hath not wrought by himself for the obedience of the Gentiles.
God forbid that I should say, that those things which are approoued and allowed by the holy Catholike Church, should be of no effect or valew. For well I know that the holy Apostolicke church hath neuer allowed, ordained,1 or taught any thyng which she hath not learned of the Lord, the apostles are witnesses thereof, Peter and Paul, wherof the one of thē dareth not freely vtter or speake of any of those things, which Christ hath not wrought by hymselfe for the obedience of the Gentiles.
The other exhorteth that if any man speak, he should speak the praises of God, but I condemn those laws, which the bishops of Rome have made according to their own will and mind, and say that they are spiritual,1 pertaining unto the soul, and necessary unto everlasting life.
The other exhorteth that if any man speake, he should speake the praises of God, but I condemne those lawes, which the bishops of Rome haue made accordyng to their owne will and mynde, and say that they are spirituall,1 pertainyng vnto the soule, and necessarie vnto euerlastyng lyfe.
For so much as the writings of the Apostles do evidently declare, that there was no authority known amongest them to make or ordain any ordinances or laws.
For so much as the writyngs of the Apostles doe euidently declare, that there was no authoritie knowen amongest them to make or ordayne any ordinaunces or lawes.
Furthermore the Scriptures do manifestly show the same, how oftentimes even by the Lords own mouth,1 this foresaid authority is taken from the Ministers of the Church: so that no excuse for them remaineth, but that they be plain rebels against the word of GOD, how many so ever do presume or take upon them to appoint or set any new laws upon the people of GOD, which thing is more manifest and evident, then the light it self in many places of the Scripture. For in the 23. chapter of Joshua, it is written you shall observe, and do all that is written in the law of Moses, neither shall you swerve from that, either to the right hand, either to the left hand. But that which is written in the twelfth chapter of Deuteronomium, ought to move them somewhat the more.
Furthermore the Scriptures do manifestly shewe the same, how oftentimes euen by the Lordes owne mouth,1 this foresayd authoritie is taken from the Ministers of the Church: so that no excuse for them remayneth, but that they be playne rebelles agaynst the worde of GOD, how many so euer doe presume or take vppon them to appoint or set any new lawes vpon the people of GOD, whiche thyng is more manifest and euident, then the lyght it selfe in many places of the Scripture. For in the 23. chapter of Iosue, it is written you shall obserue, and doe all that is written in the lawe of Moyses, neyther shall you swarue from that, eyther to the ryght hande, eyther to the lefte hand. But that which is written in the twelfth chapter of Deuteronomium, ought to mooue them somewhat the more.
Whatsoever I command saith the Lord, that you shall observe and do: thereunto you shall add nothing, neither shall you take any thing from it. The like he had said before in the fourth chapter of the same book. And again Moses in the xxx. chapter of the same book doth witness, that he did put forth life, and blessing unto Israel, ⟨p. 1264⟩when as he gave them that law which he had received of the Lord.1 How can they then excuse themselves of perjury, which ordain new laws to live by? But let us proceed further, and see what authority the Priests of Levies stock had to make laws. I do not deny but that God in the xvij. chapter of Deuteronomy, ordained under a great penalty, that the authority of the Priests should not be contemned, but had in reverence. But in the ij. of Malachi. He also declareth under what condition they are to be heard, where as he saith: he hath made a covenant with Levi, that the law of truth should be in his mouth, and by and by after he added: the lips of the Priest shall keep and maintain wisdom, and the law they shall require at his mouth, which is the messenger of the Lord of hosts. Therefore it is fit and necessary that if a Priest will be heard, that he do show himself the messenger of God, that is to say, faithfully to report and declare the commandments which he hath received of the Lord. For where as Malachi speaketh of hearing of them, he putteth this specially that they do answer according to the law of the Lord. Therefore like as the Levitical Priests did break their covenant made with GOD, if they do teach any other law then that which they had received of him: So likewise these men must either acknowledge themselves to be covenant breakers, or else they may not bind the consciences of men with no new law.
Whatsoeuer I commaund sayth the Lorde, that you shall obserue and doe: thereunto you shall adde nothing, neyther shall you take any thyng from it. The lyke he had sayd before in the fourth chapter of the same booke. And agayne Moyses in the xxx. chapiter of the same booke doth witnesse, that he dyd put foorth lyfe, and blessing vnto Israell, ⟨p. 1264⟩when as he gaue them that lawe which he had receiued of the Lord.1 How can they then excuse themselues of periury, which ordaine new lawes to liue by? But let vs proceede further, and see what authoritie the Priestes of Leuies stocke had to make lawes. I doe not denye but that God in the xvij. chapter of Deuteronomie, ordayned vnder a great penaltie, that the authoritie of the Priestes should not be contemned, but had in reuerence. But in the ij. of Malachie. He also declareth vnder what condition they are to be heard, where as he sayth: he hath made a couenaunt with Leuy, that the law of truth should be in hys mouth, and by and by after he added: the lips of the Priest shall keepe and maintayne wisedome, and the law they shall require at hys mouth, which is the messenger of the Lord of hostes. Therefore it is fitte and necessary that if a Priest will be heard, that he doe shew himselfe the messenger of God, that is to say, faythfully to report and declare the commaundements which he hath receiued of the Lorde. For where as Malachie speaketh of hearyng of them, he putteth this specially that they doe aunswere accordyng to the lawe of the Lorde. Therefore lyke as the Leuiticall Priestes did breake theyr couenaunt made with GOD, if they do teache any other lawe then that which they had receyued of hym: So likewyse these men muste eyther acknowledge themselues to be couenant breakers, or els they may not bynde the consciences of men with no new lawe.
Furthermore, what power the Prophets had universally, it is very lively described in Ezekiel in his xxxiij. chapter.
Furthermore, what power the Prophetes had vniuersally, it is very liuely described in Ezechiel in his xxxiij. chapter.
Thou son of man saith the Lord, I have made thee a guide unto the house of Israel, thou shalt hear the word out of mine own mouth,1 and declare it unto them from me. He then which is commanded to hear of the mouth of the Lord, is he not forbidden to rehearse or speak any thing of himself? For what other thing is it to speak from the Lord, but so to speak, that he may boldly affirm and say, that it is not his word, but the word of the Lord, which he speaketh.
Thou sonne of man sayth the Lord, I haue made thee a guide vnto the house of Israel, thou shalt heare the word out of myne owne mouth,1 and declare it vnto them from me. He then which is commaunded to heare of the mouth of the Lord, is he not forbidden to rehearse or speake any thing of hymselfe? For what other thyng is it to speake from the Lord, but so to speake, that he may boldly affirme and say, that it is not his word, but the word of the Lorde, which he speaketh.
Further, God by his Prophet Jeremiah calleth it chaff, what so ever doth not proceed from himself. Wherefore, none of the Prophets have opened their mouths at any time to speak, but being premonished before by the word of GOD. Whereupon it happeneth, that these words are so often pronounced by them, The word of the Lord, The charge or burden of the Lord, The vision of the Lord, Thus saith the Lord, The mouth of the Lord hath spoken it.
Further, God by his Prophet Ieremy calleth it chaffe, what so euer doth not proceede from hymselfe. Wherefore, none of the Prophetes haue opened theyr mouthes at any tyme to speake, but beyng premonished before by the worde of GOD. Whereupon it happeneth, that these wordes are so often pronounced by them, The worde of the Lord, The charge or burden of the Lord, The vision of the Lord, Thus sayth the Lord, The mouth of the Lord hath spoken it.
Now that we may also confirm that which is before spoken, by the examples of the Apostles, that they have taught nothing but that which they have learned of the Lord, the law which Christ prescribed unto them, when as he endowed them with the dignity and honour of the Apostleship, is somewhat more profoundly to be repeated. In the last chapter of Matthew, he commandeth them to go forth and teach, not such things as they themselves did rashly invent or devise, but those things which he had commanded them.
Now that we may also confirme that which is before spoken, by the examples of the Apostles, that they haue taught nothyng but that whiche they haue learned of the Lorde, the law which Christ prescribed vnto them, when as he endowed them with the dignitie and honour of the Apostleship, is somewhat more profoundly to be repeated. In the last chapiter of Mathew, he commandeth them to go foorth and teach, not such thyngs as they themselues did rashly inuent or deuise, but those things which he had commaunded them.
Furthermore, Paul in the second to the Colossians, denieth that he hath any dominion or rule over the faith of the Corinthians, albeit he was ordained by the Lord to be their Apostle. If you require and desire a further reason of the moderation of Saint Paul, read the tenth chapter of his Epistle to the Romans, where as he teacheth, That faith cometh by hearing, it cometh not by the dreams of the Bishop of Rome, or by any other Bishop, but only by the word of God, neither ought any man to think it strange, that neither Christ restrained his Apostles by the law, that they should not teach any thing but that which they had learned of the mouth of the Lord. He set the same law upon himself because it should not be lawful for any man to refuse it.
Furthermore, Paule in the second to the Collossians, denieth that he hath any dominion or rule ouer the fayth of the Corinthians, albeit he was ordayned by the Lorde to be their Apostle. If you require and desire a further reason of the moderation of Saint Paule, read the tenth chapter of his Epistle to the Romaines, where as he teacheth, That fayth commeth by hearyng, it commeth not by the dreames of the Bishop of Rome, or by any other Bishop, but onely by the worde of God, neyther ought any man to thinke it straunge, that neyther Christ restrayned hys Apostles by the lawe, that they should not teache any thyng but that which they had learned of the mouthe of the Lord. He set the same law vppon himselfe because it should not be lawfull for any man to refuse it.
My doctrine saith Christ is not mine, but his which sent me, my fathers: he which hath been the only and eternal counsellor of the father, which also is ordained by the Father, the Lord and Master over all, for so much yet as he doth the office and part of a Minister, he doth by his example prescribe unto all Ministers, what rule and order they ought to follow in teaching, wherefore the power of the Church is not such, that it may at his own will and discretion, teach new doctrines, either as they term it, frame new Articles of faith, either establish new laws: but is subject unto the word of the Lord, and as it were included in the same. But now let us behold what defence they do bring for their constitutions. The Apostles say they, and the Elders of the Primitive Church established a decree, besides the commandment of Christ, whereby they did command all people to abstain from all things offered unto Idols, suffocation, and blood.1 If that were lawful for them so to do, why is it not lawful for their successor, as often as necessity shall require to imitate and follow them in doing the like.
My doctrine sayth Christ is not myne, but hys which sent me, my fathers: he which hath bene the onely and eternall counseller of the father, which also is ordayned by the Father, the Lord and Maister ouer all, for so much yet as he doth the office and part of a Minister, he doth by hys example prescribe vnto all Ministers, what rule and order they ought to followe in teachyng, wherfore the power of the Church is not such, that it may at hys owne wyll and discretion, teach new doctrines, eyther as they terme it, frame new Articles of fayth, either establish new laws: but is subiect vnto the worde of the Lorde, and as it were included in the same. But now let vs beholde what defence they do bryng for their constitutions. The Apostles say they, and the Elders of the Primitiue Church established a decree, besides the commandement of Christ, wherby they did commaunde all people to abstayne from all things offered vnto Idols, suffocation, and bloud.1 If that were lawfull for them so to doe, why is it not lawfull for their successour, as often as necessitie shall require to imitate and follow them in doyng the lyke.
But I deny that the Apostles in that behalf, did make any new decree or ordinance, for so much as Peter in the same council pronounceth God to be tempted, if any yoke be laid upon the necks of the Disciples: Even he himself doth subvert and overthrow his own sentence,1 if they consent to lay any yoke upon them. But a yoke is laid upon them if the Apostles by their own authority do decree to prohibit the Gentiles not to touch any thing offered unto Idols or strangled, but you will say, they do write that they should abstain from those things. I grant that they do so write. But what doth S. James declare? That the Gentiles which are converted unto God are not to be troubled and vexed in such extern decrees and outward elements as these be. And the Apostle sufficiently declareth that he goeth about nothing less than to restrain the liberty of the Gentiles, but only to admonish and warn them how they should moderate and rule themselves amongest their brethren, lest they should abuse their liberty to the offence of the others.
But I deny that the Apostles in that behalfe, did make any new decree or ordinaunce, for so much as Peter in the same counsell pronounceth God to be tempted, if any yoke be layd vpon the neckes of the Disciples: Euen he hymselfe doth subuert and ouerthrowe hys owne sentence,1 if they consent to lay any yoke vppon them. But a yoke is layd vpon them if the Apostles by their owne authoritie do decree to prohibite the Gentils not to touch any thyng offered vnto Idoles or strangled, but you will say, they do write that they should abstayne from those thinges. I graunt that they do so write. But what doth S. Iames declare? That the Gentils which are conuerted vnto God are not to be troubled and vexed in such externe decrees and outward elementes as these be. And the Apostle sufficiently declareth that he goeth about nothyng lesse thē to restraine the libertie of the Gentiles, but onely to admonish and warne them how they should moderate and rule themselues amongest their brethren, lest they should abuse their libertie to the offence of the others.
They allege furthermore, that which is written in the 23. of Matthew, the Scribes and Pharisees have si•ten in the chair of Moses, therefore all things what so ever they command you to observe and keep,1 the same observe and do, but do you not as they do. I answer, the Lord in this place doth inveigh against the manners of the Pharisees simply instructing his hearers, which before he had taught, that albeit they could perceive or see nothing in their life which they should follow, yet for all that they should not refuse to do those things which they did teach by the word, I say by the word, and not of their own head.
They alledge furthermore, that which is written in the 23. of Mathew, the Scribes and Phariseis haue si•ten in the chayre of Moyses, therefore all thyngs what so euer they commaund you to obserue and keepe,1 the same obserue and do, but do you not as they doe. I aunswer, the Lord in this place doth inuey agaynst the manners of the Pharisies simply instructing his hearers, which before he had taught, that albeit they could perceiue or see nothyng in their lyfe which they should follow, yet for all that they should not refuse to doe those thyngs which they dyd teach by the worde, I say by the worde, and not of theyr owne head.
Divers and many ways he hath said, holden, and also affirmed, and openly taught that there is no religion to be observed or kept, but simply to be abolished and destroyed: as it is now in England, and despising all religion, affirming, that it is but abusing of the people, he hath taught that their habits and vestures are deformed, and very monstrous, having in them no manner of utility or holiness, inducing and alluring as much as in him lay, all the adherents of his opinion, that all religion in the kingdom of Scotland should be subverted and utterly taken away, to the great offence of the Catholic Church, and the diminishing and detrimen of the Christian Religion.
Diuers and many wayes he hath sayd, holden, and also affirmed, and openly taught that there is no religion to be obserued or kept, but simply to be abolished and destroyed: as it is now in England, and despising all religion, affirmyng, that it is but abusing of the people, he hath taught that their habites and vestures are deformed, and very monstrous, hauyng in them no maner of vtilitie or holynesse, inducyng and alluryng as much as in him laye, all the adherentes of hys opinion, that all religion in the kyngdome of Scotland should be subuerted and vtterly taken away, to the great offence of the Catholicke Church, and the diminishing and detrimen of the Christian Religion.
The Prophet Isaiah in his fifth chapter, crieth out, saying. Woe be unto you which call evil good, and good evil, darkness, light, and light, darkness, sower, sweet, and sweet sower. And followeth in the same place, in the said Prophets, Woe, saith he, to you that be wise and Sapient in your own eyes, and prudent in your own estimation. No man can deny but that the Cardinal of Scotland and his adherents to be under this most heavy and grievous curse, when as they do so generally confound the Christian religion and their wicked Monkery, that they do entitle them both by one name of holiness, I trust I will make it appear more manifest then the day, that they do it by a sacrilegious audacity or boldness, unto such as setting a part all preposterous affection, will embrace the truth, when as she doth manifestly show her self.
The Prophet Esay in hys fift chapter, cryeth out, saying. Wo be vnto you which call euill good, and good euill, darkenesse, lyght, and lyght, darkenesse, sower, sweete, and sweete sower. And followeth in the same place, in the sayd Prophetes, Wo, sayth he, to you that be wise and Sapient in your owne eyes, and prudent in your owne estimation. No man can denye but that the Cardinall of Scotland and hys adherentes to be vnder this most heauy and grieuous curse, when as they doe so generally confound the Christian religion and their wicked Monkery, that they do entitle them both by one name of holinesse, I trust I will make it appeare more manifest then the day, that they do it by a sacrilegious audacitie or boldnesse, vnto such as settyng a parte all preposterous affection, wyll embrace the truth, when as she doth manifestlye shewe her selfe.
But before I enter into the matter, I will all men to understand, that I do not touch that kind of Monkery, which Saint Augustine and other so often make mention of: As in which the Monks being gathered together utterly, contemning and despising the vanities of this world, did lead a most chaste and godly life, living in prayer, reading, and disputations, not puffed up with pride, nor contentious with frowardness, neither full of envy, no man possessed any thing of his own, no man was chargeable or burdenous unto others, they wrought with their hands to get that which might sustain the body, the spirit and mind not let and hindered from God. Whatsoever did superabound more then was necessary for their sustentation, as by the restraint of their delicious and delicate fare, much did redound of the labours of their hands, it was with such diligence distributed unto the poor and needy, as it was not with greater diligence gotten by them which did give the same.
But before I enter into the matter, I will all men to vnderstand, that I do not touche that kynd of Monkery, whiche Saint Augustine and other so often make mention of: As in which the Monkes beyng gathered together vtterly, contemnyng and despising the vanities of this world, dyd lead a most chaste and godly lyfe, liuyng in prayer, readyng, and disputations, not puffed vp wyth pryde, nor contentious with frowardnesse, neyther full of enuie, no man possessed any thing of hys owne, no man was chargeable or burdenous vnto others, they wrought with theyr handes to gette that which might sustayne the body, the spirit and mynd not let and hindered from God. Whatsoeuer did superabound more then was necessarye for their sustentation, as by the restraint of their delicious and delicate fare, much did redound of the labours of their hands, it was with such diligence distributed vnto ye poore and nedy, as it was not with greater diligence gotten by them which did geue the same.
For they by no means went about to have abundance lying by them, but sought all means possible that nothing should remain by them more then sufficient, besides this, no man was forced to any extremity, which he could not bear or suffer, no man had any thing laid upon him, which he refused, neither was he condemned of the rest, which confessed himself unable to imitate or follow: they had always in their mind how commendable a thing love and charity was, they remembered that all things are clean unto them which are clean. Therefore they did not refuse or reject any kinds of meat as polluted or defiled: but all their whole industry and labour was applied to subdue lust and concupiscence, and to retain love amongst brethren. Many of them did drink no wine, yet notwithstanding they thought not themselves defiled therewithal. For unto such as were sick and diseased, who could not recover the health of their body without the same, they did most gently permit it. And where as many foolishly refused the same, they brotherly admonished them to take heed that they became not rather the weaker▪ then the holier, thorough their vain superstition.
For they by no meanes went about to haue aboundaunce lyeng by them, but sought all meanes possible that nothyng should remayne by them more then sufficient, besides this, no man was forced to any extremitie, which he could not beare or suffer, no man had any thyng layd vpon hym, which he refused, neyther was he condemned of the rest, which confessed hymselfe vnable to imitate or follow: they had alwayes in their mynde how commendable a thyng loue and charitie was, they remembered that all things are cleane vnto them which are cleane. Therefore they did not refuse or reiect any kynds of meate as polluted or defiled: but all their whole industry and labor was applied to subdue lust and concupiscence, and to retayne loue amongst brethren. Many of them did drinke no wine, yet notwithstandyng they thought not themselues defiled therewithall. For vnto such as were sicke and diseased, who could not recouer the health of their body without the same, they did most gently permit it. And where as many foolishly refused the same, they brotherly admonished them to take heede that they became not rather the weaker▪ then the hollier, thorough theyr vayne superstition.
Hitherto I have repeated that which Saint Augustine writeth of the Monks in his time whereby I would as it were paint out in a table, what manner of Monkery there was in the old time, that all men might understand how great difference there is between that and the monkery in these our latter days. For he would have all extreme compulsion to be taken away in such things as by the word of God are left to us at liberty.1 But now a days there is nothing more severely and cruelly exacted. For they say it is a remediless offence if any do but never so little swerve from their prescript order in colour or kind of garment, or in any kind of meat or in any other frivolous or vain ceremony.
Hetherto I haue repeated that which Saint Augustine writeth of the Monkes in his tyme wherby I would as it were paint out in a table, what maner of Monkery there was in the old tyme, that all men might vnderstand how great difference there is betweene that and the monkery in these our latter dayes. For he would haue all extreme compulsion to be taken away in such things as by the worde of God are left to vs at libertye.1 But nowe a dayes there is nothing more seuerely and cruelly exacted. For they say it is a remedilesse offence if any do but neuer so little swarue from their prescript order in coulor or kind of garment, or in any kynd of meat or in any other friuolous or vayne ceremony.
Saint Augustine doth straightly affirm that it is not lawful for Monks to live idle upon other mens labour, he plainly denieth that in his time there was any such example of any well ordered Monastery: but our Monks do constitute the principal part of holiness in idleness, which they call a contemplative life, wherefore the state of Monkery of the old time, and of these our days, is in all points so divers,1 that scarce can any thing be more unlike, I will not say utterly contrary: for our Monks not content with that godliness to the study and desire, whereof Christ commandeth all his continually to be intentive, they imagine a new kind of godliness, I know not what, by the meditation whereof they are more perfect, then all other. But it is a most pestilent error (which all godly men ought to abhor) to feign any other rule of perfection, then that common rule delivered unto the whole universal Church, which we suppose to be sufficiently approved in the refutation of the article before passed. Now I also pass over with silence the great blasphemy, whereby they compare their monastical confession unto Baptism. I also hold my peace that they do dissipate and divide the Communion of the Church, when as they do separate themselves from the lawful society and fellowship of the faithful, and claim unto themselves a peculiar ministry and private administration of the Sacraments, but as Saint Augustine witnesseth, it was so far of, that the Monks in times past, had any several church or administration of the Sacraments with others, and were a part and portion of the common people. Albeit that they dwelt asunder.
Saint Augustine doth straightly affirme that it is not lawfull for Monkes to lyue idle vpon other mens labor, he plainly denieth that in his tyme there was any such example of any well ordered Monastery: but our Monkes do constitute the principall part of holynesse in idlenesse, which they call a contemplatiue lyfe, wherfore the state of Monkery of the olde tyme, and of these our dayes, is in all points so diuers,1 that scarse can any thing be more vnlike, I will not say vtterly contrary: for our Monkes not content with that godlinesse to the studye and desire, whereof Christ commaundeth all his continually to be intentiue, they imagine a new kynd of godlinesse, I know not what, by the meditation whereof they are more perfect, then all other. But it is a most pestilent errour (which all godlye men ought to abhorre) to fayne any other rule of perfection, then that common rule deliuered vnto the whole vniuersall Churche, which we suppose to be sufficiently approoued in the refutation of the article before passed. Now I also passe ouer with silence the great blasphemy, whereby they compare their monasticall confession vnto Baptisme. I also hold my peace that they do dissipate and deuide the Communion of the Church, when as they doe seperate themselues from the lawfull societie and fellowship of the faythfull, and clayme vnto themselues a peculiar ministery and priuate administration of the Sacraments, but as Saint Augustine witnesseth, it was so far of, that the Monkes in tymes past, had any seueral church or administration of the Sacramentes with others, and were a part and portion of the common people. Albeit that they dwelt asunder.
But if that a man may touch the manner of these our Monks, what shall I call the cloisters in these our dais, otherwise then brothel houses, swine sties, and dens of discord. Besides that, I will pass over their fairs and markets, which in these latter days they do make of their relics of Martyrs, to build up Sodom again. Wherefore I conclude, that this their kind of life which they claim unto themselves, is utterly wicked and naught, the which is not established or grounded upon any certain calling of God, neither allowed by him, wherefore I may be bold to say, that it is unlawful, because their con science hath nothing whereby to sustain it self before god, and whatsoever is not of faith, is sin.
But if that a man may touch the manner of these our Monks, what shall I call the cloysters in these our dais, otherwise then brothell houses, swine sties, and dennes of discord. Besides that, I will passe ouer their faires and markets, which in these latter dayes they do make of their reliques of Martyrs, to build vp Sodome agayne. Wherfore I conclude, that this their kynde of lyfe whiche they clayme vnto themselues, is vtterly wicked and naughte, the which is not established or grounded vppon any certayne callyng of God, neyther allowed by him, wherefore I may be bold to say, that it is vnlawfull, because their cō science hath nothing wherby to sustaine it selfe before god, and whatsoeuer is not of fayth, is sinne.
And furthermore, so long as they do entangle & bind themselves with so many and so perverse, and wicked kind of worshipping, as the Monkery now a days doth contain in it, I may well say that they are not consecrated unto God, but unto the devil. For why? was it lawful for the Prophets, to say, that Israelites did offer their children unto wicked spirits, and not unto God only, for this cause that they did corrupt and violate the true worshipping of God with profane ceremonies. Is it not lawful then to speak the like of our Monks which together with their cowls have put on a thousand snares of most wicked superstitions? Let every man now weigh and consider with himself, if I have done wickedly to wish such religions as is this our Monkery, to be utterly extinguished and rooted out. Moreover, all christian princes should rightly and truly do their office, if as in times past Josiah pulled down and overthrew the high places which his elders the kings of Judah had builded, so they would abolish and drive away these kind of Monks.
And furthermore, so long as they do entangle & bynde themselues with so many and so peruerse, and wicked kynd of worshippyng, as the Monkery now a days doth contayne in it, I may well say that they are not consecrated vnto God, but vnto the diuell. For why? was it lawfull for the Prophets, to say, that Israelites did offer theyr children vnto wicked spirites, and not vnto God onely, for this cause that they did corrupt and violate the true worshippyng of God with prophane ceremonies. Is it not lawfull then to speake the lyke of our Monkes which together with their cowles haue put on a thousand snares of most wicked superstitions? Let euery man now waigh and consider with himselfe, if I haue done wickedly to wishe such religions as is this our Monkery, to be vtterly extinguished and rooted out. Moreouer, all christian princes should rightly and truely do their office, if as in tymes past Iosias pulled downe and ouerthrew the high places which hys elders the kings of Iuda had builded, so they woulde abolishe and dryue away these kynde of Monkes.
It is plainly manifest by lawful proves, that the said John Borthwike had and presently hath, divers books suspected of heresy, condemned as well by the papal, as also Regal and ordinary authority, and prohibited by the law, that is to say, specially the new Testament commonly printed in English, Oecolampadius, Melancton, and divers treatises of Erasmus, and other condemned heretics, also a Book entitled, unio dissidentium, the which containeth most manifest and great errors, and heretical assumptions, and hath red and studied the same as well openly as privately, and hath presented and communicated them unto others, and also hath instructed and taught many Christians in the same, to the end and purpose, to divert and turn them away from the true christian and catholic faith.
It is plainly manifest by lawfull prooues, that the said Iohn Borthwike had and presently hath, diuers bookes suspected of heresie, condemned as wel by the papall, as also Regall and ordinary authoritie, and prohibited by the lawe, that is to say, specially the newe Testament commonly printed in Englishe, Oecolampadius, Melancton, and diuers treatises of Erasmus, and other condemned heretickes, also a Booke intituled, vnio dissidentium, the which conteyneth most manifest and great erroures, and hereticall assumptions, and hath red and studied the same as well openly as priuately, and hath presented and communicated them vnto others, and also hath instructed and taught many Christians in the same, to the ende and purpose, to diuert and turne them away from the true christian and catholike fayth.
O good God, who can suffer so great a blasphemy? with what a filthy cankered stomach do these Romish swine note the new testament of heresy? who would not judge it a most venomous tongue, which dare pronounce or utter such contumelious words against the holy Gospel of our Saviour Christ? Truly as the Jews which put Christ to death, of all other murderers, even so these men (how so ever they do pronounce me an Archheretic) do fill up the measure of all other heretics: I will not say blasphemies, how then shall these serpents and stock of Vipers escape and fly the judgement of everlasting fire? I do not greatly stand or stay that they do suspect Oecolampadius, Melanchthon, or Erasmus, neither am I so mad to plead their cause who as they are men of singular learning and eloquence, so do their writings manifestly declare, how falsely and wickedly these Sycophants impute this crime & slander of heresy unto them.
O good God, who can suffer so great a blasphemye? with what a filthy cankered stomacke doe these Romishe swine note the new testament of heresie? who would not iudge it a most venemous tongue, which dare pronounce or vtter such contumelious wordes agaynst the holy Gospell of our Sauiour Christ? Truely as the Iewes which put Christ to death, of all other murderers, euen so these men (how so euer they doe pronounce me an Archheretike) do fill vp the measure of all other heretikes: I wyll not say blasphemies, how then shall these serpentes and stocke of Uipers escape and flye the iudgement of euerlastyng fire? I do not greatly stand or stay that they doe suspect Oecolampadius, Melancthon, or Erasmus, neither am I so mad to plead their cause who as they are men of singuler learnyng and eloquence, so doe their writings manifestly declare, how falsly and wickedly these Sicophants impute this crime & slaunder of heresie vnto them.
It is manifest that the said John Borthwike was so obstinate in all the foresaid error and heresies, and so maintained and taught them with such an indurate heart and mind, that he would not by no means be persuaded from them by his friends and divers other persons, which did dearly love and favour him, but chose rather obstinately to persevere in his said errors.
It is manifest that the sayd Iohn Borthwike was so obstinate in all the foresayde errour and heresies, and so maintained and taught them with such an indurate heart and mynd, that he would not by no meanes be persuaded from them by his friends and diuers other persons, which did dearly loue and fauour hym, but chose rather obstinatly to perseuere in his sayd errours.
I am willingly contented to be reduced to the Catholic faith, but if that Satan raise up any storms or tempest against that, those I do some thing resist, wherefore they most shamefully lye which do otherwise jest or talk of me, for I know not by what reason they call them my friends which so greatly laboured to convert me, neither will more esteem them, then the Midianites, which in times past called the children of Israel to do sacrifice unto their Idols. And furthermore, I desire the most high and mighty God, that he will never suffer me to swerve or turn away from this so holy, godly, and christian obstinacy and stubbornness. The man is blest that hath set his whole hope and confidence upon the Lord, and hath not regarded or looked upon the proud, or those which follow after lies.
I am willingly contented to be reduced to the Catholike faith, but if that Sathan rayse vp any stormes or tempest agaynst that, those I do some thyng resist, wherefore they most shamefully lye which doe otherwyse iest or talke of me, for I know not by what reason they call them my friendes which so greatly laboured to conuert me, neither will more esteeme them, then the Madianites, whiche in tymes past called the children of Israell to doe sacrifice vnto their Idols. And furthermore, I desire the most highe and mighty God, that he will neuer suffer me to swarue or turne away from this so holy, godly, and christian obstinacie and stubburnnesse. The man is blest that hath set his whole hope and confidence vpon the Lorde, and hath not regarded or looked vpon the proud, or those which follow after lies.