pp. 1264–12658 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The Prophet Isaiah in his fifth chapter, crieth out, saying. Woe be unto you which call evil good, and good evil, darkness, light, and light, darkness, sower, sweet, and sweet sower. And followeth in the same place, in the said Prophets, Woe, saith he, to you that be wise and Sapient in your own eyes, and prudent in your own estimation. No man can deny but that the Cardinal of Scotland and his adherents to be under this most heavy and grievous curse, when as they do so generally confound the Christian religion and their wicked Monkery, that they do entitle them both by one name of holiness, I trust I will make it appear more manifest then the day, that they do it by a sacrilegious audacity or boldness, unto such as setting a part all preposterous affection, will embrace the truth, when as she doth manifestly show her self.
The Prophet Esay in hys fift chapter, cryeth out, saying. Wo be vnto you which call euill good, and good euill, darkenesse, lyght, and lyght, darkenesse, sower, sweete, and sweete sower. And followeth in the same place, in the sayd Prophetes, Wo, sayth he, to you that be wise and Sapient in your owne eyes, and prudent in your owne estimation. No man can denye but that the Cardinall of Scotland and hys adherentes to be vnder this most heauy and grieuous curse, when as they doe so generally confound the Christian religion and their wicked Monkery, that they do entitle them both by one name of holinesse, I trust I will make it appeare more manifest then the day, that they do it by a sacrilegious audacitie or boldnesse, vnto such as settyng a parte all preposterous affection, wyll embrace the truth, when as she doth manifestlye shewe her selfe.
But before I enter into the matter, I will all men to understand, that I do not touch that kind of Monkery, which Saint Augustine and other so often make mention of: As in which the Monks being gathered together utterly, contemning and despising the vanities of this world, did lead a most chaste and godly life, living in prayer, reading, and disputations, not puffed up with pride, nor contentious with frowardness, neither full of envy, no man possessed any thing of his own, no man was chargeable or burdenous unto others, they wrought with their hands to get that which might sustain the body, the spirit and mind not let and hindered from God. Whatsoever did superabound more then was necessary for their sustentation, as by the restraint of their delicious and delicate fare, much did redound of the labours of their hands, it was with such diligence distributed unto the poor and needy, as it was not with greater diligence gotten by them which did give the same.
But before I enter into the matter, I will all men to vnderstand, that I do not touche that kynd of Monkery, whiche Saint Augustine and other so often make mention of: As in which the Monkes beyng gathered together vtterly, contemnyng and despising the vanities of this world, dyd lead a most chaste and godly lyfe, liuyng in prayer, readyng, and disputations, not puffed vp wyth pryde, nor contentious with frowardnesse, neyther full of enuie, no man possessed any thing of hys owne, no man was chargeable or burdenous vnto others, they wrought with theyr handes to gette that which might sustayne the body, the spirit and mynd not let and hindered from God. Whatsoeuer did superabound more then was necessarye for their sustentation, as by the restraint of their delicious and delicate fare, much did redound of the labours of their hands, it was with such diligence distributed vnto ye poore and nedy, as it was not with greater diligence gotten by them which did geue the same.
For they by no means went about to have abundance lying by them, but sought all means possible that nothing should remain by them more then sufficient, besides this, no man was forced to any extremity, which he could not bear or suffer, no man had any thing laid upon him, which he refused, neither was he condemned of the rest, which confessed himself unable to imitate or follow: they had always in their mind how commendable a thing love and charity was, they remembered that all things are clean unto them which are clean. Therefore they did not refuse or reject any kinds of meat as polluted or defiled: but all their whole industry and labour was applied to subdue lust and concupiscence, and to retain love amongst brethren. Many of them did drink no wine, yet notwithstanding they thought not themselves defiled therewithal. For unto such as were sick and diseased, who could not recover the health of their body without the same, they did most gently permit it. And where as many foolishly refused the same, they brotherly admonished them to take heed that they became not rather the weaker▪ then the holier, thorough their vain superstition.
For they by no meanes went about to haue aboundaunce lyeng by them, but sought all meanes possible that nothyng should remayne by them more then sufficient, besides this, no man was forced to any extremitie, which he could not beare or suffer, no man had any thyng layd vpon hym, which he refused, neyther was he condemned of the rest, which confessed hymselfe vnable to imitate or follow: they had alwayes in their mynde how commendable a thyng loue and charitie was, they remembered that all things are cleane vnto them which are cleane. Therefore they did not refuse or reiect any kynds of meate as polluted or defiled: but all their whole industry and labor was applied to subdue lust and concupiscence, and to retayne loue amongst brethren. Many of them did drinke no wine, yet notwithstandyng they thought not themselues defiled therewithall. For vnto such as were sicke and diseased, who could not recouer the health of their body without the same, they did most gently permit it. And where as many foolishly refused the same, they brotherly admonished them to take heede that they became not rather the weaker▪ then the hollier, thorough theyr vayne superstition.
Hitherto I have repeated that which Saint Augustine writeth of the Monks in his time whereby I would as it were paint out in a table, what manner of Monkery there was in the old time, that all men might understand how great difference there is between that and the monkery in these our latter days. For he would have all extreme compulsion to be taken away in such things as by the word of God are left to us at liberty.1 But now a days there is nothing more severely and cruelly exacted. For they say it is a remediless offence if any do but never so little swerve from their prescript order in colour or kind of garment, or in any kind of meat or in any other frivolous or vain ceremony.
Hetherto I haue repeated that which Saint Augustine writeth of the Monkes in his tyme wherby I would as it were paint out in a table, what maner of Monkery there was in the old tyme, that all men might vnderstand how great difference there is betweene that and the monkery in these our latter dayes. For he would haue all extreme compulsion to be taken away in such things as by the worde of God are left to vs at libertye.1 But nowe a dayes there is nothing more seuerely and cruelly exacted. For they say it is a remedilesse offence if any do but neuer so little swarue from their prescript order in coulor or kind of garment, or in any kynd of meat or in any other friuolous or vayne ceremony.
Saint Augustine doth straightly affirm that it is not lawful for Monks to live idle upon other mens labour, he plainly denieth that in his time there was any such example of any well ordered Monastery: but our Monks do constitute the principal part of holiness in idleness, which they call a contemplative life, wherefore the state of Monkery of the old time, and of these our days, is in all points so divers,1 that scarce can any thing be more unlike, I will not say utterly contrary: for our Monks not content with that godliness to the study and desire, whereof Christ commandeth all his continually to be intentive, they imagine a new kind of godliness, I know not what, by the meditation whereof they are more perfect, then all other. But it is a most pestilent error (which all godly men ought to abhor) to feign any other rule of perfection, then that common rule delivered unto the whole universal Church, which we suppose to be sufficiently approved in the refutation of the article before passed. Now I also pass over with silence the great blasphemy, whereby they compare their monastical confession unto Baptism. I also hold my peace that they do dissipate and divide the Communion of the Church, when as they do separate themselves from the lawful society and fellowship of the faithful, and claim unto themselves a peculiar ministry and private administration of the Sacraments, but as Saint Augustine witnesseth, it was so far of, that the Monks in times past, had any several church or administration of the Sacraments with others, and were a part and portion of the common people. Albeit that they dwelt asunder.
Saint Augustine doth straightly affirme that it is not lawfull for Monkes to lyue idle vpon other mens labor, he plainly denieth that in his tyme there was any such example of any well ordered Monastery: but our Monkes do constitute the principall part of holynesse in idlenesse, which they call a contemplatiue lyfe, wherfore the state of Monkery of the olde tyme, and of these our dayes, is in all points so diuers,1 that scarse can any thing be more vnlike, I will not say vtterly contrary: for our Monkes not content with that godlinesse to the studye and desire, whereof Christ commaundeth all his continually to be intentiue, they imagine a new kynd of godlinesse, I know not what, by the meditation whereof they are more perfect, then all other. But it is a most pestilent errour (which all godlye men ought to abhorre) to fayne any other rule of perfection, then that common rule deliuered vnto the whole vniuersall Churche, which we suppose to be sufficiently approoued in the refutation of the article before passed. Now I also passe ouer with silence the great blasphemy, whereby they compare their monasticall confession vnto Baptisme. I also hold my peace that they do dissipate and deuide the Communion of the Church, when as they doe seperate themselues from the lawfull societie and fellowship of the faythfull, and clayme vnto themselues a peculiar ministery and priuate administration of the Sacraments, but as Saint Augustine witnesseth, it was so far of, that the Monkes in tymes past, had any seueral church or administration of the Sacramentes with others, and were a part and portion of the common people. Albeit that they dwelt asunder.
But if that a man may touch the manner of these our Monks, what shall I call the cloisters in these our dais, otherwise then brothel houses, swine sties, and dens of discord. Besides that, I will pass over their fairs and markets, which in these latter days they do make of their relics of Martyrs, to build up Sodom again. Wherefore I conclude, that this their kind of life which they claim unto themselves, is utterly wicked and naught, the which is not established or grounded upon any certain calling of God, neither allowed by him, wherefore I may be bold to say, that it is unlawful, because their con science hath nothing whereby to sustain it self before god, and whatsoever is not of faith, is sin.
But if that a man may touch the manner of these our Monks, what shall I call the cloysters in these our dais, otherwise then brothell houses, swine sties, and dennes of discord. Besides that, I will passe ouer their faires and markets, which in these latter dayes they do make of their reliques of Martyrs, to build vp Sodome agayne. Wherfore I conclude, that this their kynde of lyfe whiche they clayme vnto themselues, is vtterly wicked and naughte, the which is not established or grounded vppon any certayne callyng of God, neyther allowed by him, wherefore I may be bold to say, that it is vnlawfull, because their cō science hath nothing wherby to sustaine it selfe before god, and whatsoeuer is not of fayth, is sinne.
And furthermore, so long as they do entangle & bind themselves with so many and so perverse, and wicked kind of worshipping, as the Monkery now a days doth contain in it, I may well say that they are not consecrated unto God, but unto the devil. For why? was it lawful for the Prophets, to say, that Israelites did offer their children unto wicked spirits, and not unto God only, for this cause that they did corrupt and violate the true worshipping of God with profane ceremonies. Is it not lawful then to speak the like of our Monks which together with their cowls have put on a thousand snares of most wicked superstitions? Let every man now weigh and consider with himself, if I have done wickedly to wish such religions as is this our Monkery, to be utterly extinguished and rooted out. Moreover, all christian princes should rightly and truly do their office, if as in times past Josiah pulled down and overthrew the high places which his elders the kings of Judah had builded, so they would abolish and drive away these kind of Monks.
And furthermore, so long as they do entangle & bynde themselues with so many and so peruerse, and wicked kynd of worshippyng, as the Monkery now a days doth contayne in it, I may well say that they are not consecrated vnto God, but vnto the diuell. For why? was it lawfull for the Prophets, to say, that Israelites did offer theyr children vnto wicked spirites, and not vnto God onely, for this cause that they did corrupt and violate the true worshippyng of God with prophane ceremonies. Is it not lawfull then to speake the lyke of our Monkes which together with their cowles haue put on a thousand snares of most wicked superstitions? Let euery man now waigh and consider with himselfe, if I haue done wickedly to wishe such religions as is this our Monkery, to be vtterly extinguished and rooted out. Moreouer, all christian princes should rightly and truely do their office, if as in tymes past Iosias pulled downe and ouerthrew the high places which hys elders the kings of Iuda had builded, so they woulde abolishe and dryue away these kynde of Monkes.