Bland. I am glad that you are so much against all men, to say that Christs body is alive in the Sacrament: it may fortune to bring you to the truth in time to come. Me think it is evil to keep Christs body alive in the Pyx, or else must ye grant that he is alive in receiving, & dead in the Pyx. And ye say truth that it is *not the natural receiving of Christs blood that maketh a man drunken:2 for it is the nature of wine that doth that, which ye deny not.
And a more truth ye confess then ye did think, when ye said: If a man be drunken, it is by the qualities and quantities, without the substance of blood: for in deed blood hath no such qualities with it: which is evident that there is no natural blood. If a man be drunken with wine consecrated, it must be a miracle, as I think you will have it, that the said accidences should be without their natural substance, and work all the operations of both substance and accidences: and so it followeth that a man may be drunken by miracle. The body that ye receive, ye say, is alive, because it is annexed to the Godhead, and the flesh that ye receive is lively, because it hath the spirit of God joined to it.
This division is of your new inventions to divide the body and the flesh, the one alive by the Godhead, the other lively by Gods spirit, and both one Sacrament: ye make of it a thing so fantastical, that ye imagine a body without flesh, and flesh without a body, as ye do qualities & quantities without substance, and a living body without qualities and quantities.
Bland. I am glad that you are so muche agaynst all men, to saye that Christes body is aliue in the Sacramente: it may fortune to bring you to the truth in time to come. Me thinke it is euill to keepe Christes body aliue in the Pixe, or els must ye graunt that he is aliue in receiuing, & dead in the Pixe. And ye say truth that it is *not the naturall receiuing of Christes bloud that maketh a man drunken:2 for it is the nature of wine that doth that, which ye denye not.
And a more truth ye confesse then ye dyd thinke, when ye sayd: If a man be drunken, it is by the qualities and quantities, without the substaunce of bloud: for in deede bloud hath no such qualities with it: which is euident that there is no naturall bloud. If a man be drunken with wine consecrated, it must be a myracle, as I thinke you will haue it, that the sayde accidences should be without theyr naturall substaunce, and worke all the operations of both substaunce and accidences: and so it foloweth that a man may be drunken by myracle. The body that ye receiue, ye say, is aliue, because it is annexed to the Godhead, and the flesh that ye receiue is liuelye, because it hath the spirite of God ioyned to it.
This diuision is of your new inuentions to diuide the bodie and the flesh, the one aliue by the Godhead, the other liuely by Gods spirite, and both one Sacrament: ye make of it a thing so fantasticall, that ye imagine a body without flesh, and flesh without a body, as ye do qualities & quantities without substaunce, and a liuing body without qualities and quantities.
- *Christs blood hath not th• quality to make a man […] Receiving of that in the […] can make a man drunk. Ergo that in the […] not be the blood of Christ.Christes bloud hath not th• qualitye to make a man 〈…〉 Receauing of that in the 〈…〉 can make a man dronke. Ergo that in the 〈…〉 not be the bloud of Christ.
- 2Argument.