pp. 2119–212156 passagespart 1 of 2
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
SO it pleased the Queens most excellent majesty, having heard of diversity of opinions in certain matters of religion amongst sundry of her loving subjects, and being very desirous to have the same reduced to some godly and Christian concord, by the advise of the Lords and others of the privy Counsel, as well for the satisfaction of persons doubtful, as also for the knowledge of the very truth in certain matters of difference, to have a convenient chosen number of the best learned of either part, and to confer together their opinions and reasons, and thereby to come to some good and charitable agreement. And hereupon by her Majesties commandment, certain of her privy Counsel declared this purpose to the Archbishop of York (being also one of the same privy Counsel) and required him that he would impart the same to some of the Bishops, and to make choice of viij.ix. or x. of them, and that there should be the like number named of the other part. And further also declared to him (as then was supposed) what the matter should be. And as for the time, it was thought meet to be as soon as possible might be agreed upon. And then after certain days past, it was signified by the said Archbishop, that there was appointed by such of the Bishops, to whom he had imparted this matter eight persons, that is to say, 4. Bishops and 4. Doctors. The names of whom here follow under written, &c.
SO it pleased the Queenes most excellent maiestie, hauyng heard of diuersitie of opinions in certaine matters of religion amongst sundry of her louyng subiects, and beyng very desirous to haue the same reduced to some godly and Christian concord, by the aduise of the Lordes and others of the priuy Counsaile, as well for the satisfaction of persons doubtfull, as also for the knowledge of the very truth in certaine matters of difference, to haue a conuenient chosen number of the best learned of eyther part, and to conferre together their opinions and reasons, and thereby to come to some good and charitable agreement. And hereuppon by her Maiesties commaundement, certaine of her priuy Counsaile declared this purpose to the Archbishoppe of Yorke (beyng also one of the same priuy Counsaile) and required hym that he would imparte the same to some of the Bishops, and to make choise of viij.ix. or x. of them, and that there should be the like number named of the other part. And further also declared to hym (as then was supposed) what the matter should be. And as for the tyme, it was thought meet to be as soone as possible might be agreed vpon. And then after certaine dayes past, it was signified by the sayd Archbishoppe, that there was appointed by such of the Bishops, to whome hee had imparted this matter eight persons, that is to say, 4. Bishops and 4. Doctours. The names of whom here follow vnder written, &c.
*The Papists. The B. of Winchest. The B. of Lich. The B. of Chest. The B. of Carlisle. The B. of Linc. D. Cole. D. Harpsfield. D. Langdale. D. Chedsey.
*The Papistes. The B. of Winchest. The B. of Lich. The B. of Chest. The B. of Carlile. The B. of Linc. D. Cole. D. Harpsfield. D. Langdale. D. Chedsey.
*The Protestants. D. Scory B. of Chich. D. Cox. M. Whitehead. M Grindall. M▪ Horne. M Doct. Sands. M. Gest. M. Aelmer. M. Ivell.
*The Protestants. D. Scory B. of Chich. D. Coxe. M. Whitehed. M Grindall. M▪ Horne. M Doct. Sands. M. Gest. M. Aelmer. M. Iuell.
Who were content at the Queens Majesties commandment, to show their opinions, and as the said Archbishop termed it, render account of their faith in those matters which were mentioned and that especially in writing, although he said, they thought the same so determined, as there was no cause to dispute upon them. The matter which they should talk upon, was comprehended in these three propositions, here under specified.
Who were content at the Queenes Maiesties commaundement, to shewe their opinions, and as the sayde Archbishop termed it, render accompte of their fayth in those matters which were mentioned and that especially in writyng, although he sayd, they thought the same so determined, as there was no cause to dispute vppon them. The matter which they should talke vpon, was comprehended in these three propositions, here vnder specified.
1. It is against the word of God, and the custom of the ancient Church, to use a tongue unknown to the people, in common prayer, and the administration of the Sacraments.
1. It is agaynst the worde of God, and the custome of the auncient Church, to vse a tongue vnknowen to the people, in common prayer, and the administration of the Sacraments.
2. Every Church hath authority to appoint, take away, and change ceremonies and Ecclesiastical rites, so the same be to edification.
2. Euery Church hath authoritie to appointe, take away, and change ceremonies and Ecclesiasticall rites, so the same be to edification.
3. It cannot be proved by the word of God, that there is in the Mass offered up a sacrifice propitiatory for the quick and the dead.
3. It cannot be prooued by the worde of God, that there is in the Masse offered vp a sacrifice propitiatorie for the quicke and the dead.
It was hereupon fully resolved by the Queens majesty, with the advise aforesaid, that according to their desire, it should be in writing on both parts, for avoiding of much alteration in words, and that the said Bishops should, because they were in authority of degree superiors, first declare their minds and opinions to the matter, with their reasons in writing. And the other number being also viij. men of good degree in schools, and some having been in dignity in the church of England, if they had any thing to say to the contrary, should the same day declare their opinions in like manner, and so each of them should deliver their writings to the other, to be considered what were to be improved therein, and the same to declare again in writing at some other convenient day, and the like order to be kept in all the rest of the matters. All this was fully agreed upon with the Archb. of York, and so also signified to both parties.
It was hereupon fully resolued by the Queenes maiestie, with the aduise aforesayd, that according to their desire, it should be in writing on both partes, for auoyding of much alteration in wordes, and that the sayd Bishops should, because they were in authoritie of degree superiours, first declare their myndes and opinions to the matter, with their reasons in writyng. And the other number beyng also viij. men of good degree in schooles, and some hauyng bene in dignitie in the church of England, if they had any thing to say to ye contrary, should the same day declare their opinions in lyke manner, and so eche of them should deliuer their writings to the other, to bee considered what were to bee improoued therein, and the same to declare agayne in writyng at some other conuenient day, and the like order to bee kept in all the rest of the matters. All this was fully agreed vpon with the Archb. of Yorke, and so also signified to both parties.
And immediately hereupon, divers of the Nobility and states of the realm understanding that such a meting and conference should be, and that in certain matters whereupon the Court of Parliament consequently following, some laws might be grounded. They made earnest means to her Majesty, that the parties of this conference, might put and read their assertions in the English tongue, and that in the presence of them of the Nobility and others of her Parliament house, for the better satisfaction and enabling of their own judgements, to treat and conclude of such laws as might depend hereupon.
And immediately hereupon, diuers of the Nobilitie and states of the realme vnderstanding that such a meting and conference shoulde bee, and that in certaine matters whereupon the Courte of Parliament consequently followyng, some lawes might be grounded. They made ernest meanes to her Maiestie, that the parties of this conference, might put and read their assertions in the English tongue, and that in the presence of them of the Nobilitie and others of her Parliament house, for the better satisfaction and enabling of their owne iudgements, to treat and conclude of such lawes as might depend hereupon.
This also being thought very reasonable, was signified to both parties and so •ully agreed upon, and the day appointed for the first meeting, to be the Friday in the forenoon, being the last of March, at Westminster church. At which foresaid day and place, both for good order & for honour of the conference by the Queens majesties commandment, the Lords and others of the privy counsel were present, and a great part of the nobility also: And notwithstanding this former order appointed, and consented unto by both parts, yet the Bishop of Winchester & his Colleagues alleging they had mistaken that their assertions and reasons should be written, and so only recited out of the book, said their book was not ready the•• written, but they were ready to argue and dispute, and therefore they would for that time repeat in speech that which they had to say to the first probation.
This also beyng thought very reasonable, was signified to both parties and so •ully agreed vpon, and the daye appoynted for the first meetyng, to bee the Friday in the forenoone, beyng the last of March, at Westminster church. At which foresayd day and place, both for good order & for honour of the conference by the Queenes maiesties commandement, the Lordes and others of the priuy counsaile were present, and a great parte of the nobilitie also: And notwithstanding this former order appoynted, and consented vnto by both partes, yet the Bishop of Winchester & his Colleagues alledging they had mistaken yt their assertions and reasons should be written, and so onely recited out of the booke, sayd their booke was not ready the•• written, but they were ready to argue and dispute, and therefore they would for that tyme repeate in speache that which they had to say to the first probation.
This variation from the former order, and specially from that which themselves had by the said Archbishop in writing before required, adding thereto the reason of the Apostle, that to contend with words, is profitable to nothing, but to subversion of the hearer, seemed to the Queens majesties counsel somewhat strange, and yet was it permitted without any great reprehension, because they excused themselves with mistaking the order, and agreed that they would not fail but put it in writing and according to the former order, deliver it to the other part, and so the said Bishop of Winchester and his Colleagues, appointed Doctor Cole Dean of Pauls, to be the utterer of their minds, woo partly by speech only, and partly by reading of authorities written, and at certain times being informed of his Colleagues, what to say made a declaration of their meanings and their reasons to their first proposition, which being ended, they were asked by the privy Counsel if any of them had any more to be said, and they said no. So as the other par•e was licensed to show their minds, which they did according to the first order, exhibiting all that which they meant to be propounded, in a book written, which after a prayer and invocation made most humbly to almighty God for the enduing of them with his holy spirit, and a protestation also to stand to the doctrine of the Catholic Church builded upon the Scriptures, and the doctrine of the Prophets and the Apostles, was distinctly red by one Robert Horne Bachelor in Divinity, late Dean of Duresme, and after Bishop of Winchester. The Copy of which their Protestation here followeth, according as it was by him penned and exhibited, with their preface also before the same, as is here expressed.
This variation from the former order, and specially from that which themselues had by the sayde Archbishop in writyng before required, adding thereto the reason of the Apostle, that to contend with wordes, is profitable to nothyng, but to subuersion of the hearer, seemed to the Queenes maiesties counsaile somewhat strange, and yet was it permitted without any great reprehension, because they excused themselues with mistakyng the order, and agreed that they would not faile but put it in writing and accordyng to the former order, deliuer it to the other part, and so the sayd Bishop of Winchester and hys Colleagues, appoynted Doctour Cole Deane of Paules, to be the vtterer of their myndes, woo partly by speech onely, and partly by readyng of authorities written, and at certaine tymes beyng enformed of his Colleagues, what to say made a declaration of their meanynges and their reasons to their first proposition, which being ended, they were asked by the priuy Counsaile if any of them had any more to be sayd, and they sayd no. So as the other pare was licenced to shewe their myndes, which they dyd accordyng to the first order, exhibityng all that whiche they ment to be propounded, in a booke written, which after a prayer and inuocation made most humbly to almightye God for the enduyng of them with his holy spirite, and a protestation also to stand to the doctrine of the Catholike Church builded vpon the Scriptures, and the doctrine of the Prophets and the Apostles, was distinctly red by one Robert Horne Bacheler in Diuinitie, late Deane of Duresme, and after Bishoppe of Winchester. The Copye of which their Protestation here followeth, accordyng as it was by him penned and exhibited, with their preface also before the same, as is here expressed.
Forasmuch as it is thought good unto the Queens most excellent Majesty (unto whom in the Lord all obedience is due) that we should declare our judgement in writing upon certain propositions: we, as becometh us to do herein, most gladly obey.
FOrasmuch as it is thought good vnto the Queenes most excellent Maiesty (vnto whom in the Lord all obedience is due) that we should declare our iudgement in writyng vpon certaine propositions: we, as becommeth vs to doe herein, most gladly obey.
Seeing that Christ is our only master, whom the father hath commanded us to hear: and seeing also his word is the truth, from the which it is not lawful for us to depart not one hair breadth, and against the which (as the Apostle saith) we can do nothing, we do in all things submit our selves unto this truth, and do protest that we will affirm nothing against the same.
See•ng that Christ is our onely maister, whome the father hath commaunded vs to heare: and seyng also hys worde is the truth, from the which it is not lawfull for vs to depart not one haire bredth, and against the which (as the Apostle saith) we can do nothing, we doe in all thinges submitte our selues vnto this truth, and doe protest that we will affirme nothyng agaynst the same.
And forasmuch as we have for our mother the true and catholic Church of Christ, which is grounded upon the doctrine of the Apostles and Prophets, and is of Christ the head in all things governed, we do reverence her judgement, we obey her authority as becometh children: and we do devoutly profess and in all points follow the faith which is contained in the three Creeds, that is to say, of the Apostles, of the Council of Nice, ⟨p. 2120⟩and of Athanasius.
And forasmuch as we haue for our mother the true and catholike Church of Christ, which is grounded vpon the doctrine of the Apostles and Prophetes, and is of Christ the head in all things gouerned, we do reuerence her iudgement, we obey her authoritie as becommeth children: and we do deuoutly professe and in all points follow the faith which is conteined in the three Creedes, that is to say, of the Apostles, of the Councell of Nice, ⟨p. 2120⟩and of Athanasius.
And seeing that we never departed, neither from the doctrine of God which is contained in the holy Canonical Scriptures, nor yet from the faith of the true and catholic church of Christ, but have preached truly the word of God, and have sincerely ministered the sacraments according to the institution of Christ, unto the which our doctrine and faith, the most part also of our adversaries did subscribe not many years past, (although now as unnatural they are revolted from the same) we desire that they render account of their backsliding, and show some cause wherefore they do not only resist that doctrine which they have before professed, but also persecute the same by all means they can. We do not doubt but through the equity of the Queens most excellent majesty, we shall in these disputations be entreated more gently then in years late past, when we were handled most unjustly, & scantly after the common manner of men. As for the judgement of the whole controversy, we refer unto the most holy scriptures, and the catholic church of Christ (whose judgement unto us ought to be most sacred): notwithstanding by the catholic church we understand not the Romish church, whereunto our adversaries attribute such reverence, but that which S. Augustine & other fathers affirm, ought to be sought in the holy scriptures, and which is governed and led by the spirit of Christ.
And seyng that we neuer departed, neither frō the doctrine of God which is contained in the holy Canonicall Scriptures, nor yet from the fayth of the true and catholike church of Christ, but haue preached truely the worde of God, and haue sincerely ministred the sacraments accordyng to the institution of Christ, vnto the which our doctrine and fayth, the most part also of our aduersaries did subscribe not many yeares past, (although now as vnnaturall they are reuolted from the same) wee desire that they render accompt of their backsliding, and shewe some cause wherefore they do not only resist that doctrine which they haue before professed, but also persecute the same by all meanes they can. We do not doubt but through the equitie of the Queenes most excellent maiesty, we shall in these disputations be entreated more gently then in yeres late past, when we were handled most vniustly, & scantly after the common maner of men. As for the iudgement of the whole controuersie, we referre vnto the most holy scriptures, and the catholike church of Christ (whose iudgement vnto vs ought to be most sacred): notwithstanding by the catholike church we vnsterstand not the Romish church, whereunto our aduersaries attribute suche reuerence, but that which S. Augustine & other fathers affirme, ought to be sought in the holy scriptures, and which is gouerned and led by the spirite of Christ.
1It is against the word of God and the custom of the Primitive Church to use a tong unknown to the people in common prayers & administration of the sacraments.
1It is against the worde of God and the custome of the Primitiue Church to vse a tong vnknowen to the people in common praiers & administration of the sacraments.
By these words (the word of God) we mean only the written word of God, or canonical scriptures.
By these words (the word of God) we meane only the written word of God, or canonicall scriptures.
And by the custom of the primitive church, we mean the order most generally used in the church for the space of 500. years after Christ, in which times lived the most notable fathers, as Justine, Ireneus, Tertullian, Cyprian, Basil, Chrysostom, Hierome, Ambrose, Austine, &c.
And by the custome of the primitiue church, we meane the order most generally vsed in the church for the space of 500. yeres after Christ, in which times liued the most notable fathers, as Iustine, Ireneus, Tertullian, Cyprian, Basill, Chrysostome, Hierome, Ambrose, Austine, &c.
1This assertion above written hath two parts. First, that the use of the tongue not understanded of the people in common prayers of the Church, or in the administration of the Sacraments, is against Gods word.
1This assertion aboue written hath two partes. Fyrst, that the vse of the tongue not vnderstanded of the people in common prayers of the Church, or in the administration of the Sacramentes, is agaynst Gods worde.
The second, that the same is against the use of the primitive Church.
The second, that the same is agaynst the vse of the primatiue Church.
The first part is most manifestly proved by the 14. chapter of the Epistle to the Corinthians,1 almost through out the whole chapter. In the which chapter Saint Paul entreateth of this matter, ex professo purposely. And although some do cavil that Saint Paul speaketh not in that chapter of praying, but of Preaching, yet is it most evident to any indifferent reader of understanding, and appeareth also by the exposition of the best writers, that he plainly there speaketh not only of Preaching and Prophesying, but also of prayer and thanksgiving, and generally of all other public actions, which require any speech in the Church or congregation. For of praying he saith: I will pray with my spirit, and I will pray with my mind, I will singe with my spirit, and I will singe with my mind. And of thanksgiving (which is a kind of prayer:) Thou givest thanks well, but the other is not edified. And how shall he which occupieth the room of the unlearned say, Amen to thy giving of thanks when he understandeth not what thou sayest? And in the end, descending from particulars to a general proposition, concludeth that all things ought to be done to edification. Thus much is clear by the very words of Saint Paul: and the ancient Doctors, Ambrose, Augustine, Hierom, and other do so understand this chapter, as it shall appear by their testimonies which shall follow afterward.
The first parte is most manifestly prooued by the 14. chapiter of the Epistle to the Corinthians,1 almost thorow out the whole chapter. In the whiche chapter Saynt Paule intreateth of this matter, ex professo purposely. And although some do cauel that Saint Paule speaketh not in that chapter of praying, but of Preaching, yet is it most euident to any indifferent reader of vnderstanding, and appeareth also by the exposition of the beste writers, that hee plainely there speaketh not onely of Preaching and Prophesying, but also of prayer and thankesgeuing, and generally of all other publicke actions, whiche require any speache in the Church or congregation. For of praying he sayth: I will pray with my spyrite, and I will pray with my minde, I will singe with my spyrite, and I will singe with my minde. And of thankesgeuing (which is a kinde of prayer:) Thou geuest thankes well, but the other is not edyfied. And how shall he which occupyeth the roume of the vnlearned say, Amen to thy geuing of thanks when he vnderstandeth not what thou sayest? And in the ende, descending from particulers to a generall proposition, cō cludeth that all thinges oughte to be done to edyfication. Thus much is cleare by the very words of Saint Paule: and the auncyent Doctors, Ambrose, Augustine, Hierom, and other do so vnderstand this chapter, as it shal appeare by their testimonyes which shall follow afterwarde.
¶Upon this Chapter of Saint Paul we gather these reasons following.
¶Upon this Chapter of Saint Paule we gather these reasons following.
But the use of an unknown tongue, in public prayer or administration of Sacraments doth not edify the congregation.
But the vse of an vnknowē tongue, in publicke prayer or administration of Sacramentes doth not edifye the congregation.
Therefore the use of an unknown tongue in public prayer or administration of Sacraments is not to be had in the Church.
Therefore the vse of an vnknowen tongue in publicke prayer or administration of Sacramentes is not to be had in the Church.
1The second part is also proved by Saint Pauls plain words. First by this similitude. If the trumpet give an uncertain sound who shall be prepared to battle? Even so likewise when ye speak with tongues, except ye speak words that have signification, how shall it be understanded what is spoken? for ye shall but speak in the air, that is to say, in vain, and consequently without edifying.
1The seconde parte is also prooued by Saynte Paules playne wordes. Fyrst by this similitude. If the trumpet geue an vncertayne sounde who shall be prepared to battaile? Euen so likewise when ye speake with tongues, except ye speake wordes that haue signification, how shall it be vnderstanded what is spoken? for ye shal but speake in the ayre, that is to say, in vayne, and consequently without edifieng.
And afterward in the same chapter he saith: how can he that occupieth the place of the unlearned say, Amen, at thy giving of thanks, seeing he understandeth not what thou sayest? for thou verily givest thanks well, but the other is not edified.
And afterward in the same chapter he sayth: how can he that occupieth the place of the vnlearned say, Amen, at thy geuing of thankes, seeyng he vnderstandeth not what thou sayest? for thou verily geuest thanks well, but the other is not edified.
These be Pauls words, plainly proving, that a tong not understanded, doth not edify. And therefore both the parts of the reason thus proved by S. Paul, the conclusion followeth necessarily.
These be Pauls words, plainly proouing, that a tong not vnderstanded, doth not edifie. And therefore both the parts of the reason thus prooued by S. Paul, the conclusion followeth necessarily.
Secondly, nothing is to be spoken in the congregation in an unknown tongue,1 except it be interpreted to the people, that it may be understand. For saith Paul, if there be no interpreter to him that speaketh in an unknown tong, taceat in ecclesia, let him hold his peace in the church. And therefore the common prayers & administration of sacraments, neither done in a known tong, neither interpreted, are against this commandment of Paul, and not to be used.
Secondly, nothing is to be spoken in the congregation in an vnknown tongue,1 except it be interpreted to the people, that it may be vnderstand. For saith Paul, if there be no interpreter to him yt speaketh in an vnknown tong, taceat in ecclesia, let him hold his peace in the church. And therfore the commō praiers & administratiō of sacramēts, neither done in a known tong, neither interpreted, are against this commandement of Paul, and not to be vsed.
The minister in prayer or administration of sacraments using language not understanded of the hearers,1 is to them barbarous, an alien, which of Saint Paul is accounted a great absurdity.
The minister in praier or administration of sacramēts vsing language not vnderstanded of the hearers,1 is to thē barbarous, an alien, which of Saint Paul is accompted a great absurditie.
It is not to be counted a Christian common prayer,1 where the people present declare not their assent unto it by saying Amen, wherein is employed all other words of assent.
It is not to bee counted a Christian common prayer,1 where the people present declare not their assent vnto it by saying Amen, wherein is employed all other words of assent.
But S. Paul affirmeth that the people cannot declare their assent in saying Amen,1 except they understand what is said, as afore.
But S. Paul affirmeth that the people cannot declare their assent in saying Amen,1 except they vnderstand what is said, as afore.
Therefore it is no Christian common prayer where the people understandeth not what is said.
Therfore it is no Christian common prayer where the people vnderstandeth not what is sayd.
Paul would not suffer in this time a strange tongue to be heard in the common prayer in the church, notwithstanding that such a kind of speech was then a miracle, & a singular gift of the holy ghost, whereby infidels might be persuaded and brought to the faith: much less is it to be suffered now amongst christian and faithful men, especially being no miracle, nor especial gift of the holy ghost.
Paule would not suffer in this tyme a strange tongue to be heard in the common prayer in the church, notwithstanding that such a kind of speach was then a miracle, & a singular gift of the holy ghost, whereby infidels might bee perswaded and brought to the faith: much lesse is it to bee suffred now amongst christian and faithful men, especially being no miracle, nor especiall gift of the holy ghost.
Some will peradventure answer, that to use any kind of tong in common prayer or administration of sacraments is a thing indifferent.1
Some will peraduenture answer, that to vse any kind of tong in common prayer or administration of sacramēts is a thing indifferent.1
But S. Paul is to the contrary. For he commandeth all things to be done to edification, he commandeth to keep silence if there be no interpreter,1 and in the end of the chapter he concludeth thus. If any man be spiritual or a prophet, let him know that the things which I write, are the commandments of the Lord. And so shortly to conclude, the use of a strange tongue in prayer and ministration is against the word and commandment of God.
But S. Paul is to the contrary. For he commaundeth all things to be done to edification, he cōmandeth to keepe silence if there be no interpreter,1 and in the end of the chapter he concludeth thus. If any man be spirituall or a prophet, let him know that the things which I write, are the commaundementes of the Lorde. And so shortly to conclude, the vse of a strange tongue in prayer and ministration is agaynst the word and commandement of God.
To these reasons, grounded upon S. Pauls words, which are the most firm foundation of this assertion, divers other reasons may be joined, gathered out of the scriptures and otherwise.
To these reasons, grounded vpon S. Pauls wordes, which are the most firme foundation of this assertion, diuers other reasones may bee ioyned, gathered out of the scriptures and otherwise.
In the old testament all things pertaining to the public prayer, benedictions, thanksgivings, or sacrifices,1 were always in their vulgar and natural tong. In the 2. book of Paralipom. chap. 29. it is written that Hezekiah commanded the Levites to praise God with the Psalms of David, and Asaph the Prophet, which doubtless were written in Hebrew their vulgar tongue. If they did so in the shadows of the law, much more ought we to do the like, who (as Christ saith) must pray in spiritu & veritate.
In the old testament all things pertainyng to ye publike prayer, benedictions, thankesgeuings, or sacrifices,1 were alwayes in their vulgar and naturall tong. In the 2. booke of Paralipom. chap. 29. it is written that Ezechias commanded the Leuites to praise God with ye Psalms of Dauid, and Asaph the Prophet, which doubtlesse were written in Hebrew their vulgar tongue. If they did so in the shadowes of the law, much more ought we to doe the like, who (as Christ saith) must pray in spiritu & veritate.