An answer to M. Mores fourth book.An aunswere to M. Mores fourth booke.
pp. 319–339203 passagespart 4 of 6
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
M. Though the Turk offer pleasures unto the receivers, and death unto 1the refusers of his sect (as the Pope doth) yet he suffereth none to break their promises of chastity dedicate to ⟨p. 328⟩God (though haply they use no such vows, and as the Pope will not except it be for money) but Luther teacheth to break holy vows.
M. Though the Turke offer pleasures vnto the receauers, and death vnto 1the refusers of his secte (as the Pope doth) yet he suffereth none to breake their promises of chastitie dedicate to ⟨p. 328⟩God (though haply they vse no such vowes, and as the Pope wil not except it be for money) but Luther teacheth to breake holy vowes.
Tyndall. Luther teacheth that unlaw 1full vows grounded on a false faith unto the dishonouring of God are to 2be broken and no other. And again, constrained service pleaseth not God. And thirdly, your Pope giveth licence and his blessing to break all lawful vows, but with the most unlawful of all will ye not dispense.
Tyndall. Luther teacheth that vnlaw 1full vowes grounded on a false fayth vnto the dishonouring of God are to 2be broken and no other. And agayne, constrayned seruice pleaseth not God. And thirdly, your Pope geueth licēce and his blessing to breake all lawfull vowes, but with the most vnlawfull of all will ye not dispence.
1Tyndall.
2Unlawful vows are not to be observed.Vnlawfull vowes are not to be obserued.
Then he bringeth forth the ensample of the heathen, to confirm the Popes chastity. And no wrong, for the same false imagination that the heathen had in theirs, hath the Pope in his. Understand therefore, if thou vow any indifferent thing, to please God in his 1own person, he receiveth not thine Idolatry: for his pleasure & honour is, that thou shouldest be as he hath made thee, and shouldest receive all such things of his hand and use them so far forth as they were needful, and give him thanks, and be bound to him: and not that thou shouldest be as thou haddest made thy self, & that he should receive such things of thee to be bound to thee, to thank thee & reward thee. And again, thou must give me a reason of thy vow out of the word of God. Moreover when thou 2vowest lawfully, thou mayest not do it precisely, but alway except, if thine own or thy neighbours necessity required the contrary. As if thou haddest vowed never to eat flesh, or drink wine, or strong drink, to tame thy flesh, and thou afterward fellest in disease so that thy body in that behalf were to tame, or that there could no other sustenance be gotten. Than thou must interpret such cases except, though thou madest no mention of them at the making of thy vow. Some man would say, other shift might be made: What then? If other drink as 3hot as wine and of the same operation, and other meat of the same power and virtue as flesh is, must be had, why shouldest thou forswear wine or flesh, seeing it is now no longer for the taming of thy body. And so forth of all other, as I have above declared.
Then he bringeth forth the ensample of the heathen, to confirme the Popes chastitie. And no wrong, for the same false imagination that the heathē had in theirs, hath the Pope in hys. Ʋnderstand therfore, if thou vow any indifferent thing, to please God in his 1owne person, he receaueth not thyne Idolatrie: for hys pleasure & honour is, that thou shouldest be as he hath made thee, and shouldest receaue all such thinges of his hand and vse them so farforth as they were needfull, and geue him thankes, and be bounde to hym: and not that thou shouldest be as thou haddest made thy selfe, & that he should receaue such thinges of thee to be bounde to thee, to thanke thee & rewarde thee. And agayne, thou must geue me a reason of thy vow out of the worde of God. Moreouer when thou
And when he bringeth in the Apostles, martyrs, confessors, and xv. hundred years, it is clean contrary. For they had no such false imagination of chastity or of any other work: but they used it to serve their neighbour and to 1avoid trouble in time of persecution, and to be eased of that burden that was to heavy for their weak shoulders, and not to compel God to thank them for that liberty for which they be bound to thank him.
And when he bringeth in the Apostles, martyrs, confessours, and xv. hundred yeares, it is cleane contrary. For they had no such false imagination of chastity or of any other worke: but they vsed it to serue their neighbour and to 1auoyde trouble in time of persecution, and to be eased of that burthen that was to heauy for their weake shoulders, and not to cōpell God to thāke them for that libertie for which they be bound to thanke hym.
1All our abstinence & chastising of our selves, is to our own profit.All our abstinence & chastising of our selues, is to our owne profite.
IN the tenth he inveigheth and raileth against that which neither he nor any 1fleshly minded Papist can understand; as they have no power to consent unto the laws of God, which herein appeareth, that they compel their brethren which be as good as they, to do and believe what they lust, & not what God commandeth. He affirmeth that Martin saith, how that we do no sin our selves with our own will, but that 2God sinneth in us, and useth us as a dead instrument, and forceth us thereunto and damneth us, not for our own deeds but for his, and for his own pleasure, as he compelleth unto sin for his pleasure or rather he for his pleasure sinneth in us. I say, that a man sinneth voluntarily, but the power of the will and of the deed is of God, and every will and deed are good in the nature of the deed, and the evilness is a lack that there is, as the eye, though it be blind is good in nature, in that it is such a member created for such a good use: but it is called evil for lack of sight. And so are our deeds evil because we 3lack knowledge and love to refer them unto the glory of God. Which lack cometh of the devil that blindeth us with lusts and occasions that we can not see the goodness and righteousness of the law of God & the means how to fulfil it. For could we see it, and the way to do it, we should love it naturally as a child doth a fair apple. For a child when as a man showeth him a fair apple, and will not give it him weepeth, so should we naturally mourn when the members would not come forward to fulfil the law according to the desire of our hearts. For Paul saith. ij. Cor. iiij. If our 4Gospel be hid, it is hid unto them that perish, among which the God of this world hath blinded the wits of the unbelievers, that the light of the glorious gospel of Christ should not shine 5to them. And Christ saith that the birds eat up the seed sown upon the way, and interpreteth by the seed the word, and by the fowls, the devil. So that the devil blindeth us with ⟨p. 329⟩falsehood and lies which is our worldly
And on the other side, that an other man loveth the laws of God and useth the power that he hath of god well, and referreth his will and his deeds unto the honour of God, cometh of the mercy of God which hath opened his wits, and showed him light to see the goodness and righteousness of the law of God, and the way that is in Christ to fulfil it, whereby he loveth it naturally and trusteth to do it. Why doth God open one mans eyes & not an others? Paul Rom. ix. forbiddeth to ask why. For it is to deep for mans 1capacity. God we see is honoured thereby, and his mercy set out, and the more seen in the vessels of mercy. But the popish can suffer God to have no secret hid to himself. They have searched to come to the bottom of his bottomless wisdom, and because they can not attain to that secrete and be to proud to let it alone, and to grant themselves ignorant with the Apostle that knew no other then Gods glory 2in the elect, they go and set up freewill with the heathen philosophers, and say that a mans freewill is the cause why God chooseth one and not an other, contrary unto all the scripture. Paul saith it cometh not of the will nor of the deed, but of the mercy of God. And they say that every man hath at the least way power in his freewill, to deserve that power should be given him of god to keep the law. But the scripture testifieth that Christ hath deserved for y• elect, even them when they hated God, that their eyes should be opened to see the goodness of the law of God, and the way to fulfil it, and forgiveness of all that is passed, whereby they be drawn to love it and to hate sin.
And on the other side, that an other man loueth the lawes of God and vseth ye power that he hath of god well, and referreth hys will and his deedes vnto the honour of God, commeth of the mercy of God which hath opened his wittes, and shewed him light to see the goodnes and righteousnes of the lawe of God, and the way that is in Christ to fulfill it, wherby he loueth it naturally and trusteth to do it. Why doth God open one mans eyes & not an others? Paule Rom. ix. forbiddeth to aske why. For it is to deepe for mās 1
I ask the popish one question whether the will can prevent a mans wit 1and make the wit see the righteousness of the law, and the way to fulfil it in Christ? If I must first see the reason why ere I can love, how shall I with my will do that good thing that I know not of? how shall I thank God for the mercy that is laid up for me in Christ, ere I believe it. For I must believe the mercy ere I can love the work. Now faith cometh not of our freewill, but is the grace of God given us by grace ere there be any will in our hearts to do the law of 2God. And why God giveth it not every man I can give no reckoning of his judgements. But well I wot, I never deserved it, nor prepared my self unto it, but ran an other way clean contrary in my blindness, and sought not that way, but he sought me, and found me out, and showed it me, and therewith drew me to him. And I bow the knees of mine hart unto god night and day, that he will show it all other men. And I suffer all that I can to be a servant to open their eyes.
I aske the popishe one question whether the will can preuent a mans witte 1and make the witte see the righteousnesse of the lawe, and the way to fulfill it in Christ? If I must first see the reason why yer I can loue, how shall I with my will do that good thing that I know not of? how shall I thanke God for the mercy that is layde vp for me in Christ, yer I beleue it. For I must beleue the mercy yer I can loue the worke. Now fayth commeth not of our frewill, but is the grace of God geuen vs by grace yer there be any will in our hartes to do the lawe of 2God. And why God geueth it not euery man I can geue no reckoning of his iudgementes. But well I wot, I neuer deserued it, nor prepared my self vnto it, but ranne an other way cleane contrary in my blyndnesse, and sought not that way, but he sought me, and found me out, and shewed it me, and therwith drew me to him. And I bow the knees of mine hart vnto god night and day, that he will shew it all other men. And I suffer all that I can to be a seruaunt to open their eyes.
For well I wot they can not see of themselves before God have prevented them with his grace. For Paul saith Phil. i. he that began a good work in 1you shall continue or bring it unto a full end, so that God must begin to work in us. And Phil. ij. God it is 2that worketh both the willing and also bringing to pass. And it must needs 3be, for God must open mine eyes, and show me somewhat and make me see the goodness of it, to draw me to him, ere I can love, consent, or have any actual will to come.
For well I wot they can not see of themselues before God haue preuēted them wyth hys grace. For Paule saith Phil. i. he that began a good worke in 1you shall continue or bring it vnto a full ende, so that God must beginue to worke in vs. And Phil. ij. God it is 2that worketh both the willing and also bringing to passe. And it must needes 3be, for God must open mine eyes, and shew me somewhat and make me see the goodnesse of it, to draw me to hym, yer I can loue, consent, or haue any actuall will to come.
And when I am willing, he must assist me and help to tame my flesh, and to overcome the occasions of the world, and the power of the fends. God therefore hath a special care for his 1elect, in so much that he will shorten the wicked days for their sakes, in which no man, if they should continue might endure. And Paul suffereth all for the elect. ij. Timothy. ij. And Gods sure foundation standeth saith Paul, God knoweth his. So that refuse the truth who shall, God will keep a nun ber of his mercy, and call them out of blindness; to testify the truth unto the rest, that their damnation may be with out excuse.
And when I am willing, he must assiste me and helpe to tame my fleshe, and to ouercome the occasions of the worlde, and the power of the fendes. God therfore hath a special care for his 1elect, in so much that he will shorten ye wicked dayes for their sakes, in which no man, if they should continue might endure. And Paule suffereth all for the electe. ij. Timothy. ij. And Gods sure foundation standeth sayth Paule, God knoweth hys. So that refuse the truth who shall, God will keepe a nū ber of his mercy, and call them out of blindnesse; to testifie the truth vnto the rest, that their damnation may be with out excuse.
The Turk, the Jew and the Popish build upon freewill & ascribe their justifying unto their works. The Turk when he hath sinned, runneth to the purifyings or ceremonies of Mahomet, and the Jew to the ceremonies of Moses, and the Pope unto his own ceremonies, to fetch forgiveness of their sins. And the Christen goeth 1thorough repentance toward the law, unto the faith that is in Christs blood.
The Turke, the Iew and the Popish build vpon frewill & ascribe theyr iustifying vnto their woorkes. The Turke when he hath synned, runneth to the purifyinges or ceremonies of Mahomet, and the Iew to the ceremonies of Moses, and the Pope vnto his owne ceremonies, to fet forgeuenesse of their sinnes. And the Christen goeth 1thorough repentaunce towarde the law, vnto the fayth that is in Christes bloud.
1The Christians seek help of Christ.The Christians seeke helpe of Christ.
And the Pope saith that the ceremonies of Moses justified not, compelled with the words of Paul. And how then should his justify? Moses Sacraments were but signs of promises ⟨p. 330⟩of faith, by which faith the believers are justified, and even so be Christs also. And now because the Jews have put out the significations of their Sacraments and put their trust in the works of them, therefore they be Idolaters, and so is the Pope for like purpose. The Pope saith that Christ dyed 1not for us, but for the Sacraments, to give them power to justify. O Antichrist.
And the Pope saith that the ceremonies of Moyses iustified not, compelled with the woordes of Paule. And how then should his iustifie? Moyses Sacramentes were but signes of promises ⟨p. 330⟩of fayth, by which fayth the beleuers are iustified, and euen so be Christes also. And now because the Iewes haue put out the significations of their Sacraments and put their trust in the workes of them, therfore they be Idolaters, and so is the Pope for like purpose. The Pope sayth that Christ dyed 1not for vs, but for the Sacramentes, to geue them power to iustifie. O Antichrist.
His xj. chapter is as true as his story 1of Utopia & all his other Poetry. He meaneth Doctor Ferman person of Honey lane. Whom after they had handled after their secret manner and disputed with secretly and had made him swear that he should not utter how he was dealt with, as they have made many other, then they contrived a manner of disputations had with him, with such oppositions, aunswearynges and arguments as should serve only to set forth their purpose. As M. More throughout all his book maketh, quoth 2he, to dispute and move questions after such a manner as he can soil them or make them appear soiled, and maketh him grant where he listeth and at the last to be concluded and lad whether M. More will have him. Wherefore I will not rehearse all the arguments, for it were to long, and is also not to be believed that he so made them or so disputed with them, but that they added and pulled away & feigned as they list as their guise is. But I will declare in light that which M. More ruffleth up in darkness, that ye may see their falsehood.
HIs xj. chapter is as true as his story 1of Ʋtopia & all his other Poetrie. He meaneth Doctour Ferman person of Hony lane. Whō after they had hādled after their secret maner and disputed with secretly and had made him sweare that he should not vtter how he was dealt with, as they haue made many other, then they contriued a maner of disputatiōs had with him, with such oppositions, aunswearynges and argumentes as should serue onely to set forth their purpose. As M. More thoroughout all his booke maketh, quoth 2he, to dispute and moue questions after such a maner as he can soyle them or make them appeare soyled, and maketh him graunt where he lysteth and at the last to be concluded and lad whether M. More will haue him. Wherfore I wil not rehearse all the arguments, for it were to long, and is also not to be beleued that he so made them or so disputed with them, but that they added and pulled away & fayned as they liste as their guise is. But I will declare in light that which M. More ruffeleth vp in darkenesse, that ye may see their falshead.
First if ye were not false hypocrites, 1why had ye not disputed openly with him, that the world might have heard and borne record, that that which ye now say of him were true? what cause is there that the lay people might not as well have heard his words of his own mouth, as read them of your writing, except ye were juggling spirits that walk in darkness?
First if ye were not false hypocrites, 1why had ye not disputed openly with him, that the world might haue heard and borne recorde, that that whiche ye now say of him were true? what cause is there that the lay people might not as well haue heard his wordes of hys own mouth, as read them of your writyng, except ye were iugglyng spirites that walke in darknesse?
When M. More saith, the Church teacheth that men should not trust in their works, it is false if he mean the Popes Church. For they teach a man to trust in dumb ceremonies & Sacraments, in penance and all manner works that come them to profit, which yet help not unto repentance nor to faith nor to love a mans neighbour.
When M. More sayth, the Church teacheth that men should not trust in theyr workes, it is false if he meane ye Popes Church. For they teach a man to trust in domme ceremonies & Sacramētes, in penaūce and all maner workes that come them to profite, whiche yet helpe not vnto repentaunce nor to fayth nor to loue a mans neighbour.
M. More declareth the meaning of no sentence, he describeth the proper signification of no word, nor the difference of the significations of any term, but runneth forth confusedly in unknown words and general terms. And where one word hath many significations he maketh a man some time believe that many things are but one thing, and some time he leadeth from one signification unto an other & mocketh a mans wits. As he juggleth 1with this term Church, making us in the beginning understand all that believe, and in the conclusion the Priests only. He telleth not the office of the law, he describeth not his penance nor the virtue thereof or use, he declareth no Sacrament, nor what they mean nor the use nor wherein the fruit of confession standeth, nor whence the power of the absolution cometh, nor wherein it resteth, nor what justifying meaneth, nor the order nor showeth any diversity of faiths, as though all faiths were one faith and one thing.
M. More declareth the meanyng of no sentence, hee describeth the proper signification of no word, nor the difference of the significatiōs of any terme, but runneth foorth confusedly in vnknowen wordes and generall termes. And where one word hath many significations he maketh a man some tyme beleue that many thynges are but one thyng, and some tyme he leadeth from one signification vnto an other & mocketh a mans wittes. As he iuggleth 1with this terme Church, makyng vs in the begynnyng vnderstand all that beleue, and in the conclusion the Priestes onely. He telleth not the office of the law, he describeth not his penaūce nor the vertue therof or vse, he declareth no Sacrament, nor what they meane nor the vse nor wherin the frute of cō fession standeth, nor whence the power of the absolution commeth, nor wherin it resteth, nor what iustifying meaneth, nor the order nor sheweth any diuersitie of faythes, as though all faiths were one fayth and one thyng.
1M. More […] a juggle• with terms.M. More 〈…〉 a iuggle• with termes.
Mark therefore, the way toward justifying or forgiveness of sin, is the 1law. God causeth the law to be preached unto us & writeth it in our harts and maketh us by good reasons feel that the law is good and ought to be kept and that they which keep it not are worthy to be damned. And on the other side I feel that there is no power in me, to keep the law whereupon it would shortly follow that I should despair, if I were not shortly ho•pe. But 2God which hath begun to cure me and hath laid that corrosive unto my sores, goeth forth in his cure, and setteth his son Jesus before me and all his passions and death, and saith to me: this is my dear son, and he hath prayed for thee & hath suffered all this for thee, and for his sake I will forgive thee all that thou hast done against this good law, and I will heal thy flesh & teach thee to keep this law, if y• wilt learn. And I will bear with thee & take all a worth that thou doest, till thou canst do better. And in the mean season, not withstanding thy weakness, I will yet love thee no less then I do the angels in heaven, so thou wilt be diligent to learn. And I will assist thee and keep thee and defend thee and be thy shield and care for thee.
Marke therfore, the way toward iustifying or forgeuenesse of sinne, is the 1law. God causeth the law to be preached vnto vs & writeth it in our harts and maketh vs by good reasons feele that the law is good and ought to bee kept and that they which keepe it not are worthy to be damned. And on the other side I fele that there is no power in me, to kepe the law wherupon it would shortly folow that I should dispaire, if I were not shortly ho•pe. But 2God which hath begon to cure me and hath layde that corosy vnto my sores, goeth forth in his cure, and setteth hys sonne Iesus before me and all his passions and death, and sayth to me: this is my deare sonne, and he hath prayed for thee & hath suffred all this for thee, and for his sake I will forgeue thee all that thou hast done agaynst this good lawe, and I will heale thy flesh & teach thee to kepe this law, if y wilt learne. And I will beare with thee & take all a worth that thou doest, till thou caust do better. And in the meane season, not withstandyng thy weakenesse, I will yet loue thee no lesse then I do the aungels in heauen, so thou wilt be diligent to learne. And I will assiste thee and keepe thee and defend thee and be thy shielde and care for thee.
And the hart here beginneth to mollify and wax soft & to receive health and believeth the mercy of God and in believing is saved from the fear of everlasting death, and made sure of everlasting ⟨p. 331⟩life, and then being overcome 1with this kindness, beginneth to love again and to submit her self unto the law of God to learn them and to walk in them.
And the hart here beginneth to mollifie and waxe soft & to receaue health and beleueth the mercy of God and in beleuyng is saued frō the feare of euerlastyng death, and made sure of euerlastyng ⟨p. 331⟩life, and then beyng ouercome 1with this kindnesse, begynneth to loue agayne and to submitte her selfe vnto the law of God to learne them and to walke in them.
1The great mercy and kindness of God moveth man to repentance.The great mercy and kindenes of God moueth mā to repētaūce.
Note now the order, first God giveth me light to see the goodness and righteousness of the law, & mine own sin and unrighteousness. Out of which knowledge springeth repentance. 1Now repentance teacheth me not that the law is good, and I evil, but a light that the spirit of God hath given me, out of which light repentance springeth.
Note now the order, first God geueth me light to see the goodnesse and righteousnesse of the law, & myne own sinne and vnrighteousnesse. Out of whiche knowledge spryngeth repentaunce. 1Now repentaunce teacheth me not that the law is good, and I euill, but a light that the spirite of God hath geuen me, out of whiche light repentaunce springeth.
1The right order of our justification.The right order of our iustificatiō.
Then the same spirit worketh in mine hart trust and confidence to believe the mercy of God and his truth, that he will do as he hath promised. Which belief saveth me. And immediately out of that trust springeth love toward the law of God again. And what soever a man worketh of any other love than this it pleaseth not God, nor is that love godly.
Then the same spirite woorketh in myne hart trust and confidence to beleue the mercy of God and his truth, that he will do as hee hath promised. Whiche beleffe saueth me. And immediatly out of that trust spryngeth loue toward the law of God agayne. And what soeuer a man worketh of any other loue thē this it pleaseth not God, nor is that loue godly.
Now love doth not receive this mercy but faith only, out of which faith love springeth, by which love I power out again upon my neighbour that goodness which I have received of God by faith. Hereof ye see that I can not be justified without repentance and yet repentance justifieth me not. And hereof ye see that I can not have a faith to be justified and saved, except love spring thereof immediately, and yet love justifieth me not before God. For my natural love to God again doth not make me first see & feel the kindness of God in Christ, but faith thorough preaching. For we love not God first, to compel him to love again: but he loved us first & gave his son for us, that we might see love and love 1again, saith S. John in his first Epistle. Which love of God to us ward we receive by Christ thorough faith saith Paul.
Now loue doth not receaue this mercy but fayth onely, out of whiche fayth loue springeth, by which loue I power out agayn vpon my neighbour that goodnesse which I haue receaued of God by fayth. Hereof ye see that I cā not be iustified without repentaūce and yet repentaunce iustifieth me not. And hereof ye see that I can not haue a fayth to be iustified and saued, except loue spryng therof immediatly, and yet loue iustifieth me not before God. For my naturall loue to God agayne doth not make me first see & feele the kyndnesse of God in Christ, but fayth thorough preachyng. For we loue not God first, to cōpell him to loue agayn: but he loued vs first & gaue his sonne for vs, that we might see loue and loue 1agayne, sayth S. Iohn in his first Epistle. Which loue of God to vs ward we receaue by Christ thorough fayth sayth Paule.
And this example have I set out for 1them in divers places, but their blind Popish eyes have no power to see it, covetousness hath so blinded them. And when we say faith only justifieth us, that is to say, receiveth the mercy wherewith God justifieth us and forgiveth us, we mean not faith which hath no repentance and faith which hath no love unto the laws of God again and unto good works, as wicked hypocrites falsely belie us.
And this example haue I set out for 1them in diuers places, but their blynd Popish eyes haue no power to see it, couetousnesse hath so blynded them. And when we say faith onely iustifieth vs, that is to say, receaueth the mercy wherewith God iustifieth vs and forgeueth vs, we meane not fayth whiche hath no repentaunce and fayth whiche hath no loue vnto the lawes of God agayne and vnto good workes, as wicked hypocrites falsly belye vs.
1Faith only apprehendeth our justification.Faith only apprehendeth our iustification.
For how then should we suffer as we do all misery, to call the blind and ignorant unto repentance & good works which now do but consent unto all evil, and study mischief all day long, for all their preaching their justifying of good works. Let M. More improve this with his sophistry and set forth his own doctrine that we may see the reason of it and walk in light.
For how thē should we suffer as we do all misery, to cal the blind and ignoraūt vnto repentaunce & good workes which now do but consent vnto all euill, and study mischief all day long, for all their preachyng their iustifying of good woorkes. Let M. More improue this with his sophistrie and set foorth his owne doctrine that we may see the reason of it and walke in light.
Hereof ye see what faith it is that 1justifieth us. The faith in Christs blood of a repenting hart toward the law doth justify us only and not all manner faiths. Ye must understand therefore, that ye may see to come out of Mores blind maze, how that there be many faiths and that all faiths be not one faith, though they be all called with on general name. There is a story 2faith without feeling in the hart, where with I may believe the whole story of the Bible & yet not set mine hart earnestly thereto, taking it for the food of my soul, to learn to believe and trust God, to love him dread him and fear him by the doctrine and examples there of, but to seem learned & to know the story, to dispute and make merchandise, after as we have examples enough. And the faith wherewith a man doth miracles, is an other gift then the faith of a repenting hart to be saved through Christs blood, and the one no kin to the other though M. More would have them so appear. Neither is the devils faith & the Popes faith (wherewith they believe that there is a God & that Christ is & all the story of the Bible and may yet stand with all wickedness and full consent to evil) kin unto the faith of them that hate evil and repent of their misdeeds and knowledge their sins and be fled with full hope and trust of mercy unto the blood of Christ.
Hereof ye see what fayth it is that 1iustifieth vs. The fayth in Christes bloud of a repentyng hart toward the law doth iustifie vs onely and not all maner faythes. Ye must vnderstād therfore, that ye may see to come out of Mores blynd maze, how that there be many faythes and that all faythes be not one faith, though they be al called with on generall name. There is a story 2faith without feelyng in the hart, wher with I may beleue the whole story of the Bible & yet not set myne hart earnestly thereto, takyng it for the fode of my soule, to learne to beleue and trust God, to loue him dread him and feare him by the doctrine and examples ther of, but to seme learned & to know the story, to dispute and make marchaundise, after as we haue exāples ynough. And the fayth wherewith a man doth miracles, is an other gift then the faith of a repētyng hart to be saued through Christes bloud, and the one no kynne to the other though M. More would haue them so appeare. Neither is the deuils fayth & the Popes fayth (wherwith they beleue that there is a God & that Christ is & all the story of the Bible and may yet stond with all wickednesse and full cōsent to euil) kynne vnto the fayth of them that hate euill and repent of their misdeedes and knowledge their sinnes and be fled with full hope and trust of mercy vnto the bloud of Christ.
And when he saith, if faith certify our hearts that we be in the favour of God and our sins forgiven, & become 1good ere we do good works, as the tree must be first good ere it bring forth good fruit, by Christs doctrine, then we make good works but a shadow wherewith a man is never the better. Nay Sir we make good works, fruits whereby 2our neighbour is the better, and whereby God is honoured, and our flesh tamed. And we make of them sure tokens whereby we know that our faith is no feigned imagination and dead opinion, made with captiving our wits after the Popes traditions, but a lively thing wrought by the holy Ghost.
And when he sayth, if fayth certifie our hartes that we bee in the fauonr of God and our sinnes forgeuen, & become 1good yer we do good workes, as the tree must be first good yer it bring forth good fruite, by Christes doctrine, thē we make good workes but a shadowe wherewith a man is neuer the better. Nay Sir we make good woorkes, fruites whereby 2our neighbour is the better, and whereby God is honoured, and our fleshe tamed. And we make of them sure tokēs wherby we know that our fayth is no fayned imagination and dead opinion, made with captiuing our wits after the Popes traditions, but a lyuely thyng wrought by the holy Ghost.
1Works.Workes.
2Out of a lively and justifying faith springeth good works.Out of a liuely and iustifiyng faith springeth good workes.
And when he disputeth, if they that have faith, have love unto the law, and purpose to fulfil it, then faith alone justifieth not, how will he prove that argument? 1he juggleth with this word alone: and would make the people believe that we said, how a bare faith that is without all other company, of repentance, love, and other virtues, yea & without Gods spirit to, did justify us, so that we should not care to do good. But the Scripture so taketh not alone, nor we so mean, as M. More knoweth well enough. When an horse 2beareth a saddle and a man therein, we may well say, that that horse only & alone beareth the saddle, and is not helped of the man in bearing thereof. But he would make men understand that we meant, the horse bare the saddle empty and no man therein: let him mark this to see his ignorance, which would God were not coupled with malice. Every man that hath wit, hath a will 3to, and then by M. Mores argument, wit only giveth not the light of understanding. Now the conclusion is false and the contrary true. For yt wit without help of the will giveth the light of the understanding, neither doth the will work at all, until the wit have determined this or that to be good or bad. Now what is faith save a spiritual light of understanding, and an inward knowledge or feeling of mercy. Out of which knowledge love doth spring. But love brought me not that knowledge, for I knew it ere I loved. So that love in the process of nature to dispute from the cause to the 4effect helpeth not at all to the feeling that God is merciful to me no more than the loving hart and kind behaviour of an obedient wife to her husband maketh her see his love & kindness to her, for many such have unkind husbands. But by his kind deeds to her, doth she see his love. Even so my love and deeds make me not see Gods love to me in the process of nature: but his kind deeds to me, in that he gave his son for me, maketh me see his love, & to love again.
And when he disputeth, if they that haue faith, haue loue vnto the lawe, and purpose to fulfill it, then faith alone iustifieth not, how will he proue that argument? 1
Our love and good works make not God first love us, and change him from hate to love, as the Turk, Jew, and vain popish mean, but his love and deeds make us love, & change us from hate to love. For he 1loved us when we were evil, and his enemies, as testifieth Paul in divers 2places, and chose us, to make us good and to show us love, and to draw us 3to him, that we should love again.
Our loue and good workes make not God first loue vs, and chaunge hym from hate to loue, as the Turke, Iewe, and vaine popishe meane, but his loue and deedes make vs loue, & chaunge vs from hate to loue. For he 1loued vs when we were euill, and his enemies, as testifieth Paule in diuers 2places, and chose vs, to make vs good and to shew vs loue, and to draw vs 3to him, that we should loue agayne.
The father loveth his child, when it hath no power to do good, & when it must be suffered to run after the own lusts without law, and never loveth it better then then, to make it better, and to show it love, to love again. If ye could see what is written in the first epistle of John, though all the other scripture were laid a part, he should see all this.
The father loueth his childe, when it hath no power to do good, & when it must be suffered to runne after the owne lustes without lawe, and neuer loueth it better then then, to make it better, and to shew it loue, to loue agayne. If ye coulde see what is writtē in the first epistle of Iohn, though all the other scripture were layde a parte, he should see all this.
And ye must understand, that we sometime dispute forward, from the cause to the effect, and sometime backward from the effect to the cause, and must beware that we be not therewith beguiled, we say summer is come and therefore all is green, and dispute forward. For somme• is the cause of the 1greenness. We say the trees be green, & therefore summer is come, and dispute backward from the effect to the cause. For the green trees make not summer but maketh somme• known. So we dispute backward, the man doth good 2deeds and profitable unto his neighbour, he must therefore love God: he loveth God, he must therefore have a true faith and see mercy.
And ye must vnderstand, that we sometyme dispute forwarde, from the cause to the effect, and sometyme backward from the effect to the cause, and must beware that we be not therwyth beguiled, we say sommer is come and therefore all is grene, and dispute forwarde. For somme• is the cause of the 1grenesse. We say the trees be grene, & therfore sommer is come, and dispute backward from the effect to the cause. For the grene trees make not sommer but maketh somme• knowen. So we dispute backward, the man doth good 2deedes and profitable vnto his neyghbour, he must therefore loue God: he loueth God, he must therefore haue a true fayth and see mercy.
1☜
2He that loveth God loveth his neighbour.He that loueth God loueth hys neighbour.
And yet my works make not my love, nor my love my faith, nor my faith Gods mercy: But contrary, gods 1mercy maketh my faith, and my faith my love, and my love my works. And if the Pope could see mercy and work of love to his neighbour, and not sell his works to God for heaven after M. Mores doctrine, we needed not so subtle disputing of faith.
And yet my woorkes make not my loue, nor my loue my faith, nor my faith Gods mercy: But cōtrary, gods 1mercy maketh my fayth, and my fayth my loue, and my loue my works. And if the Pope could see mercy and worke of loue to his neighbour, and not sell his woorkes to God for heauen after M. Mores doctrine, we needed not so suttle disputing of faith.
1Note here the mercy & goodness of God.Note here the mercy & goodnes of God.
And when M. More allegeth Paul to the Corinthians, to prove that faith may be without love, he proveth nothing, but juggleth only. He saith, it 1is evident by the words of Paul, that a man may have a faith to do miracles without love, & may give all his good in alms without love, and give his body to burn for the name of Christ, & all without charity. Well I will not stick with him: he may so do without charity & without faith thereto. Then a man may have faith without faith. Yea verily because there be many differences of faith, as I have said, and not all faiths one faith, as master More juggleth. We read in the works of S. Cyprian, that 2there were martyrs that suffered martyrdom for the name of Christ all the 3year long, and were tormented and healed again, and then brought forth a fresh. Which martyrs believed as ye ⟨p. 333⟩do, that the pain of their martyrdom should be a deserving & merit enough not only to deserve heaven for themselves, but to make satisfaction for the sins of other men thereto, and gave pardons of their merits, after the ensample of the Popes doctrine, and forgave the sins of other men, which had openly denied Christ, and wrote unto Cyprian, that he should receive those men that had denied Christ into the congregation again, at the satisfaction of their merits. For which pride Cyprian wrote to them and called 4them the devils martyrs and not Gods. Those martyrs had a faith without faith. For had they believed that all mercy is given for Christs bloudshedding, they would have sent other men thither, and would have suffered their own martyrdom for love of their neighbours only, to serve them and to testify the truth of God in our saviour Jesus, unto the world, to save at the least way some, that is to wit, the elect, for whose sake Paul suffereth all thing, and not to win heaven. If I work for a worldly purpose, I 5get no reward in heaven: even so if I work for heaven or an higher place in heaven, I get there no reward. But I must do my work for yt love of my neighbour, because he is my brother, and the price of Christs blood, and because Christ hath deserved it, and desireth it of me, and then my reward is great in heaven.
And all they which believe that their sins be forgiven them, and they received as the scripture testifieth, unto the inheritance of heaven for Christs merits, the same love Christ and their brethren for his sake, and do all thing for their sakes only, not once thinking of heaven when they work, but on their brethren's need. When they suffer themselves above might, then they comfort their soul with the remembrance of heaven, that this wretchedness shall have an end, and we shall have a thousand fold pleasures and rewards in heaven, not for the merits 1of our deservings, but given us freely for Christs. And he that hath that love, hath the right faith, and he that hath that faith hath the right love. For I can not love my neighbour for Christs sake, except I first believe that I have received such mercy of Christ. Nor can I believe that I have received such mercy of Christ, but that I must love my neighbour for his sake, seeing that he so instantly desireth me.
And all they which beleue that their sinnes be forgeuen them, and they receaued as the scripture testifieth, vnto the enheritaunce of heauē for Christes merites, the same loue Christ and their brethren for his sake, and do all thyng for their sakes onely, not once thinking of heauen when they worke, but on their brethrens neede. When they suffer themselues aboue might, then they comfort their soule with the remē braunce of heauen, that this wretchednes shall haue an ende, and we shall haue a thousand folde pleasures and rewardes in heauen, not for the merites 1of our deseruings, but geuen vs freely for Christes. And he that hath yt loue, hath the right faith, and he that hath yt faith hath the right loue. For I cā not loue my neighbour for Christes sake, except I first beleue that I haue receaued such mercy of Christ. Nor can I beleue that I haue receaued such mercy of Christ, but that I must loue my neighbour for his sake, seing that he so instantly desireth me.
1Our doings can deserve nothing, but Christ hath deserved for us.Our doynges can deserue nothyng, but Christe hath deserued for vs.
And when he allegeth S. James, 1it is answered him in the Mammon, and S. Augustine answereth him. And S. James expoundeth himself. For he saith in the first chapter, God which begat us of his own will with the word of truth, which word of truth, is his promises of mercy and forgiveness in our Saviour Jesus, by which he begat us, gave us life and made us a new creature through a fast faith. And James goeth and rebuketh the opinion 2and false faith of them that think it enough to be saved by, if they believe that there is but one god, & that Christ was borne of a virgin, and a thousand things which a man may believe, and yet not believe in Christ, to be saved from sin through him. And that James speaketh of another faith then at the beginning appeareth by his ensample. The devils have faith saith he: yea but the devils have no faith that can repent of evil or to believe in Christ to be saved through him, or that can love God and work his will of love. Now Paul speaketh of a faith that is in Christs blood to be saved thereby, which worketh immediately thorough love of the benefit received. And James at the beginning speaketh of a faith that bideth trying, saying, the trying of your faith worketh or ca•seth patience. But the faith of the devils will bide no trying, for they will not work Gods will because they love him not. And in like manner is it of the 3faith of them that repent not, or that think themselves without sin. For except a man feel out of what danger Christ hath delivered him, he can not love the work. And therefore James saith right, that no such faith that will not work can justify a man.
And when he alleageth S. Iames, 1it is aunswered him in the Mammon, and S. Augustine answereth hym. And S. Iames expoundeth himselfe. For he saith in the first chapter, God which begatte vs of his owne will wyth the worde of truth, which worde of truth, is his promises of mercy and forgeuenesse in our Sauiour Iesus, by which he begat vs, gaue vs life and made vs a new creature thorow a fast faith. And Iames goeth and rebuketh the opinion 2
And when Paul saith faith only justifieth: And James, that a man is justified by works and not by faith only, there is great difference between Pauls only and James only. For Pauls only is to be understand, that faith justifieth in the heart and before God, without help of works, yea & ere I can work. For I must receive life through faith to work wi•h, ere I can work. But James only is this wise to be understand, that faith doth not so justify, that nothing justifieth 1save faith. For deeds do justify also. But faith justifieth in the hart and before God, and the deeds before the world only, and maketh the other ⟨p. 334⟩seen, as ye may see by the scripture.
And when Paule saith faith onely iustifieth: And Iames, that a man is iustified by woorkes and not by fayth onely, there is great differēce betwene Paules onely and Iames onely. For Paules onely is to be vnderstand, that faith iustifieth in the harte and before God, without helpe of workes, yea & yer I can worke. For I must receaue life thorow faith to worke wi•h, yer I can worke. But Iames onely is thys wise to be vnderstand, that faith doth not so iustifie, that nothyng iustifieth 1saue fayth. For deedes do iustifie also. But faith iustifieth in the hart and before God, and the deedes before the worlde onely, and maketh the other ⟨p. 334⟩seene, as ye may see by the scripture.
For Paul saith Rom iiij. it Abraham 1have works, he hath whereof to rejoice, but not before god. For if Abraham had received those promises of deserving, then had it ben Abraham's praise & not gods, as thou mayst see in the text: neither had God showed Abraham mercy and grace, but had only given him his duty and deserving. But in that Abraham received all the mercy that was showed him, freely through faith, out of the deservings of the seed that was promised him, as thou mayst see by Genesis & by the Gospel of John, 2where Christ testifieth that Abraham saw his day and rejoiced, and of that joy no doubt wrought, it is gods praise, and the glory of his mercy. And the same mayst thou see by James, when he saith Abraham offered his son, & so was the Scripture fulfilled, that Abraham believed, & it was reckoned him for righteousness and he was thereby made Gods friend.
For Paul sayth Rom iiij. it Abrahā 1haue woorkes, he hath whereof to reioyce, but not before god. For if Abrahā had receaued those promises of deseruing, then had it ben Abrahās prayse & not gods, as thou mayst see in the text: neither had God shewed Abrahā mercy and grace, but had onely geuen hym his dutie and deseruyng. But in that Abraham receaued all the mercy that was shewed hym, frely through fayth, out of the deseruynges of the seed that was promised him, as thou mayst see by Genesis & by the Gospell of Iohn, 2where Christ testifieth that Abraham saw his day and reioyced, and of that ioy no doubt wrought, it is gods prayse, and the glory of his mercy. And the same mayst thou see by Iames, when he sayth Abraham offered his sonne, & so was the Scripture fulfilled, that Abraham beleued, & it was rekened him for righteousnesse and he was thereby made Gods frend.
How was it fulfilled? before God? Nay, it was fulfilled before God many years before, and he was Gods friend many years before, even from the first appointment that was made between God and him. Abraham received 1promises of all mercy & believed and trusted God and went & wrought out of that faith. But it was fulfilled before us which can not see the hart, as James saith, I will show thee my faith out of my works, and as the angel said to Abraham, now I know that thou dreadest God. Not but that he knew it before, but for us spake he that, which can see nought in Abraham more then in other men, save by his works.
How was it fulfilled? before God? Nay, it was fulfilled before God many yeares before, and he was Gods frend many yeares before, euen from the first appointement that was made betwene God and hym. Abraham receaued 1promises of all mercy & beleued and trusted God and went & wrought out of that fayth. But it was fulfilled before vs which can not see the hart, as Iames saith, I wil shew thee my faith out of my workes, and as the aungell said to Abrahā, now I know that thou dreadest God. Not but that he knew it before, but for vs spake he that, whiche can see nought in Abraham more then in other men, saue by his workes.
1Abraham believed gods promises & therefore was justified.Abrahā beleued gods promises & therefore was iustified.
And what works meant James? verily the works of mercy. As if a brother or a sister lack raiment or sustenance and ye be not moved to compassion nor feel their diseases, what faith have ye then? No faith (be sure) 1that feeleth the mercy that is in Christ. For they that feel that, be merciful again & thankful. But look on the works of our spirituality which will not only be justified with works before the world, but also before God. They have had all Christendom to rule this viij. hundred years, and as they only be anointed in the head, so have they only been King and Emperor and have had all power in their hands and have been the doers only and the leaders of those shadows that have had the name of Princes, and have led them whether they would & have breathed into their brains what they listed. And they have wrought the world out of peace and unity and every man out of his welfare and are become alone well at ease, only free, only at liberty, only have all thing & only do nought therefore, only lay on other mens backs & bear nought them selves. And the good works of them that wrought out of faith and gave their goods & lands to find the poor, them devour they also alone. And what works preach they? Only that are to 2them profitable & whereby they reign in mens consciences as God: to offer, to give to be prayed for & to be delivered out of Purgatory and to redeem your sin of them, and to worship ceremonies and to be shriven and so forth.
And what workes ment Iames? verely the workes of mercy. As if a brother or a sister lacke rayment or sustenaunce and ye be not moued to compassion nor feele their diseases, what fayth haue ye then? No fayth (be sure) 1that feeleth the mercy that is in Christ. For they that feele that, be mercyfull agayne & thankefull. But looke on the workes of our spiritualitie which will not onely be iustified with workes before the worlde, but also before God. They haue had all Christēdome to rule this viij. hundred yeares, and as they onely be annointed in the head, so haue they onely bene Kyng and Emperour and haue had all power in their hands and haue bene the doers onely and the leders of those shadowes that haue had the name of Princes, and haue led them whether they would & haue brethed into their braynes what they lysted. And they haue wrought the world out of peace and vnitie and euery man out of his wellfare and are become alone well at ease, onely free, onely at libertie, onely haue all thyng & onely do nought therefore, onely laye on other mēs backes & beare nought thē selues. And the good woorkes of them that wrought out of fayth and gaue theyr goods & landes to finde the poore, thē deuoure they also alone. And what workes preach they? Onely that are to
vowest lawfully, thou maist not do it precisely, but alway except, if thyne owne or thy neighbours necessitie required the contrary. As if thou haddest vowed neuer to eate fleshe, or drinke wine, or stronge drinke, to tame thy fleshe, and thou afterwarde fellest in disease so that thy body in that behalfe were to tame, or that there coulde no other sustinaunce be gotten. Thā thou must interprete suche cases excepte, though thou madest no mention of them at the making of thy vow. Some man woulde say, other shifte might be made: What then? If other drinke as
hoate as wine and of the same operation, and other meate of the same power and vertue as fleshe is, must be had, why shouldest thou forsweare wine or fleshe, seing it is now no longer for the taming of thy body. And so forth of all other, as I haue aboue declared.
1Vows.Vowes.
2All vows are to be made with great advisement.All vowes are to be made wyth great aduisement.
3We m•st use Gods creatures for our nec•e.We m•st vse Gods creatures for our nec•e.
wisdom, and therewith stoppeth out the true light of Gods wisdom, which blindness is the evilness of all our deeds.
IN the tenth he inueyeth and rayleth against that which neither he nor any 1fleshly mynded Papiste can vnderstand; as they haue no power to cōsent vnto the lawes of God, which herein appeareth, that they compell their brethren which be as good as they, to do and beleue what they lust, & not what God commaundeth. He affirmeth that Martin sayth, how that we do no sinne our selues with our owne will, but that 2God sinneth in vs, and vseth vs as a dead instrument, and forceth vs therunto and dāneth vs, not for our owne deedes but for his, and for his owne pleasure, as he compelleth vnto sinne for his pleasure or rather he for hys pleasure sinneth in vs. I say, that a man sinneth voluntarily, but the power of the will and of the deede is of God, and euery will and deede are good in the nature of the deede, and the euilnesse is a lacke that there is, as the eye, though it be blinde is good in nature, in that it is such a member created for such a good vse: but it is called euill for lacke of sight. And so are our deedes euill because we 3lacke knowledge and loue to referre them vnto the glory of God. Which lacke commeth of the deuill that blyndeth vs with lustes and occasions that we can not see the goodnesse and righteousnes of the law of God & the meanes how to fulfill it. For could we see it, and the way to do it, we should loue it naturally as a childe doth a fayre apple. For a childe whē as a mā sheweth him a fayre apple, and will not geue it hym weepeth, so should we naturally mourne when the members woulde not come forwarde to fulfill the lawe according to the desire of our hartes. For Paule sayth. ij. Cor. iiij. If our 4Gospell be hid, it is hid vnto thē that perishe, among which the God of this world hath blynded the wittes of the vnbeleuers, that the light of the glorious gospell of Christ should not shine 5to them. And Christ sayth that the birdes eate vp the seede sowen vppon the way, and interpreteth by the seede the worde, and by the foules, the deuill. So that the deuill blindeth vs wyth ⟨p. 329⟩falshead and lyes which is our worldly 6wisdome, and therewith stoppeth out the true light of Gods wisdome, which blindenes is the euilnesse of all our deedes.
1Freewi•t.
2More blasphemeth God.
3Our deeds are evil, because we lack know ledge to refer them unto the glory of God.Our dedes are euill, because we lacke know ledge to referre them vnto the glory of God.
5The devil is the blinder & kepee of us from y• understanding of gods will.The deuill is the blinder & kepee of vs frō y• vnderstanding of gods wyll.
6The devil is the blinde• and keeper of us from the understanding of Gods will.The deuill is the blinde• and keper of vs from the vnderstandyng of Gods wil.
capacitie. God we see is honoured therby, and his mercy set out, and the more seene in the vessels of mercy. But the popishe can suffer God to haue no secret hid to himselfe. They haue searched to come to the botome of hys botomlesse wisdome, and because they cā not attayne to that secrete and be to proude to let it alone, and to graunt themselues ignoraūt with the Apostle that knew no other then Gods glory
in the elect, they go and set vp freewill with the heathen philosophers, and say that a mans freewill is the cause why God chuseth one and not an other, cō trary vnto all the scripture. Paul saith it commeth not of the will nor of the deede, but of the mercy of God. And they say that euery man hath at ye least way power in his freewill, to deserue that power shoulde be geuen hym of god to kepe the law. But the scripture testifieth that Christ hath deserued for y• elect, euen thē whē they hated God, that their eyes should be opened to see the goodnes of the lawe of God, and the way to fulfill it, and forgeuenes of all that is passed, wherby they be drawen to loue it and to hate sinne.
1We may not be curious to search gods secretes.
2A Papistical opinion.A Papisticall opiniō.
Witte, reason, & iudgement goeth before will.
2Faith is the gift of God & cometh not by free will.Faith is the gift of God & commeth not by free wil.
Doct. Ferman.
2Master doctor Fermon was a virtuous godly and learned manMaster doctour Fermon was a vertuous godly and learned mā
•
1The order of justifying.The order of iustifying.
2A lively description of our […] fication.A lyuely descriptio• of our 〈…〉 fication.
1what faith justifieth.what faith iustifieth.
2There are diversities of faith, and but one faith that justifieth us.There are diuersities of faith, and but one faith that iustifieth vs.
he iuggleth wyth this worde alone: and would make the people beleue that we said, how a bare faith that is without all other company, of repē taunce, loue, and other vertues, yea & without Gods spirite to, did iustifie vs, so that we shoulde not care to do good. But the Scripture so taketh not alone, nor we so meane, as M. More knoweth well inough. When an horse
beareth a saddell and a man therin, we may wel say, that yt horse onely & alone beareth the saddell, and is not holpe of the man in bearing thereof. But he would make men vnderstand that we ment, the horse bare the saddell emptie and no man therin: let him marke this to see his ignoraunce, which woulde God were not coupled with malice. Euery man that hath wit, hath a will
to, and then by M. Mores argument, witte onely geueth not the light of vnderstanding. Now the conclusion is false and the contrary true. For yt wit without helpe of the will geueth the light of the vnderstanding, neyther doth the will woorke at all, vntill the wit haue determined this or that to be good or bad. Now what is faith saue a spirituall light of vnderstanding, and an inwarde knowledge or feelyng of mercy. Out of which knowledge loue doth spring. But loue brought me not that knowledge, for I knew it yer I loued. So that loue in the processe of nature to dispute from the cause to the
effect helpeth not at all to the feeling that God is mercifull to me no more than the louing hart and kinde behauiour of an obedient wife to her husband maketh her see his loue & kyndnesse to her, for many such haue vnkinde husbandes. But by hys kynde deedes to her, doth she see hys loue. Euen so my loue and deedes make me not see Gods loue to me in the processe of nature: but his kinde deedes to me, in that he gaue his sonne for me, maketh me see his loue, & to loue againe.
1Faith alone justifieth.Fayth alone iustifieth.
2A similitude.
3More is maliciously blind.More is maliciously blynde.
4An ap• and proper example of love.An ap• and proper exsample of loue.
And when M. More alleageth Paule to the Corinthians, to proue that faith may be without loue, he proueth nothing, but iuggleth onely. He saith, it 1is euident by the wordes of Paule, that a mā may haue a faith to do miracles without loue, & may geue all his good in almes without loue, and geue his body to burne for the name of Christ, & al without charitie. Wel I will not sticke with hym: he may so do without charitie & without fayth therto. Then a mā may haue faith without faith. Ye verely because there be many differēces of faith, as I haue sayd, and not all faithes one fayth, as maister More iuggleth. We read in the woorkes of S. Ciprian, that 2there were martyrs that suffered martyrdome for the name of Christ all the 3yeare long, and were tormented and healed agayne, and then brought forth a freshe. Which martyrs beleued as ye ⟨p. 333⟩do, that the payne of their martyrdom should be a deseruing & merite inough not onely to deserue heauen for themselues, but to make satisfaction for the sinnes of other men thereto, and gaue pardons of their merites, after the ensample of the Popes doctrine, and forgaue the sinnes of other men, which had openly denyed Christ, and wrote vnto Ciprian, that he shoulde receaue those men that had denyed Christ into the congregation agayne, at the satisfaction of their merites. For whiche pride Ciprian wrote to them and called 4them the deuilles martyrs and not Gods. Those martyrs had a fayth without fayth. For had they beleued that all mercy is geuen for Christes bloudshedding, they would haue sent other mē thether, and would haue suffered their owne martyrdome for loue of their neighbours onely, to serue thē and to testifie the truth of God in our sauiour Iesu, vnto the worlde, to saue at the least way some, that is to wete, the elect, for whose sake Paule suffereth all thing, and not to winne heauē. If I worke for a worldly purpose, I 5get no rewarde in heauen: euen so if I worke for heauen or an hyer place in heauen, I get there no rewarde. But I must do my woorke for yt loue of my neighbour, because he is my brother, and the price of Christes bloude, and because Christ hath deserued it, and desireth it of me, and then my rewarde is great in heauen.
1Faith may be had with out love, but it is a barren & naked faithFaith may be had wt out loue, but it is a barreine & naked faith
2Cyprian.Ciprian.
3Martyrs that suffered all a year long.Martyrs that suffered all a yeare long.
4The devils Martyrs.The deuils Martyrs.
5We must do good works of love, and not for reward.We must doe good workes of loue, and not for reward.
and false fayth of them that thinke it inough to be saued by, if they beleue that there is but one god, & that Christ was borne of a virgine, and a thousand things which a man may beleue, and yet not beleue in Christ, to be saued from sinne thorow him. And that Iames speaketh of another faith then at the beginning appeareth by his ensample. The deuils haue faith saith he: yea but the deuilles haue no faith that can repent of euil or to beleue in Christ to be saued thorow him, or that cā loue God and worke his wil of loue. Now Paule speaketh of a fayth that is in Christes bloude to be saued thereby, which worketh immediatly thorough loue of the benefite receaued. And Iames at the beginning speaketh of a fayth that bydeth trying, saying, the trying of your faith worketh or ca•seth pacience. But the faith of the deuilles will bide no trying, for they will not woorke Gods will because they loue him not. And in like maner is it of the
fayth of them that repent not, or that thinke themselues without sinne. For except a mā feele out of what daunger Christ hath deliuered hym, he can not loue the worke. And therfore Iames sayth right, that no such fayth that will not woorke can iustifie a man.
1James. […].Iames. 〈…〉.
2James •eproveth sel•••••tes and not a true and lively saith.Iames •eproueth sel•••••tes and not a true and liuely sayth.
3Faith that will not work when opportunity serveth can not justify.Fayth that will not woorke when oportunitie serueth cā not iustifie.
them profitable & wherbey they raigne in mens cōsciences as God: to offer, to geue to be prayed for & to be deliuered out of Purgatory and to redeme your sinne of them, and to worshyp ceremonies and to be shryuen and so forth.
1He that seeth his neighbour in necessity & hath no compassion on him, hath no faith.Hee that seeth hys neighbour in necessitie & hath no compassion on him, hath no fayth.
2The Papists preach works that are profitable to them selves.The Papistes preach workes that are profitable to them selues.