Now as touching the first part, 1where he saith that my expositions be an occasion to bring the people to boldness of sin, I ask him why? his answer is because I give them boldness that there is no Purgatory, nor yet hell, thereto Rastell by his leave (maketh a fitten) I dare not say he 2maketh a lye for that he would call railing for I never denied hell, but affirm in many places of my book & even in the first side of mine answer against him I affirm hell, and perpetual damnation, but when ye come to the proof of his words, then you shall see how wisely the man concludeth, for he thinketh that ab inferiori ad suū superius confuse distribue, men shall think it a good consequent as if I should say that we lack fire in prison, then would he conclude that there lacked fire in all Middlesex. Or if I would say their were no wit in Rastels head ⟨p. 69⟩then would he conclude that there were no wit in no mans head, but he hath so long studied Philosophy, that he hath clean forgotten his principals of Sophistry, notwithstanding we will forgive him this fault for the man is somewhat aged and therefore I think it is long since he read them, and that they are now out of his memory: nevertheless he will say that his argument is not solved for although I deny not hell, yet I deny Purgatory, and so I give the people an occasion to sin, because they fear not Purgatory, whereunto I have so sufficiently answered in Rastels vij. argument that I wonder that he is not a shamed to bring the same again but he trusteth that my books shall never be read, and his may go surely abroad, and therefore he may say what he will only he careth not what he saith so he hold not his peace.
Now as touchyng the first part, 1where he saith that my expositions be an occasion to bryng the people to boldnes of sinne, I aske hym why? his aunswere is because I geue thē boldnes that there is no Purgatory, nor yet hell, thereto Rastell by his leaue (maketh a fitten) I dare not say hee 2maketh a lye for that hee would call rayling for I neuer denyed hell, but affirme in many places of my booke & euē in the first side of myne aunswere agaynst him I affirme hell, and perpetuall damnation, but when ye come to the proofe of his wordes, then you shall sée how wisely the mā cōcludeth, for he thinketh that ab inferiori ad suū superius confuse distribue, men shall thinke it a good consequent as if I should say that we lacke fire in prisō, then would he cōclude that there lacked fire in all Middlesex. Or if I wold say their were no wit in Rastels head ⟨p. 69⟩then would hee conclude that there were no witte in no mās head, but he hath so long studyed Philosophy, that hee hath cleane forgotten his principals of Sophistry, notwithstandyng we wil forgeue him this faute for the man is somewhat aged and therfore I thinke it is lōg since he read them, and that they are now out of his memory: neuerthelesse he will say that hys argument is not soluted for although I denye not hell, yet I denye Purgatory, and so I geue the people an occasiō to sinne, because they feare not Purgatory, whereunto I haue so sufficiently aunswered in Rastels vij. argument that I wonder that hee is not a shamed to bryng the same agayne but he trusteth that my bookes shall neuer be read, and his may go surely abroad, and therefore he may say what he will onely hee careth not what he saith so he hold not his peace.
- 1Firth.
- 2Frith is a good scholar & sone hath learned his lesson, he will say no more they lye, for that is bitter.Frith is a good scholer & sone hath lerned his lesson, he will say no more they lye, for that is bitter.