pp. 147–15019 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
22 Then the men of Israel said unto Gideon: Reign thou over us, both thou and thy son and thy sons son, because thou hast delivered us out of the hand of Midian. 23 And Gideon answered them: I will not reign over you, neither shall my child reign over you, the Lord shall reign over you.
22 Then the men of Israel sayd vnto Gideon: Reigne thou ouer vs, both thou and thy sonne and thy sonnes sonne, bycause thou hast deliuered vs out of the hand of Madian. 23 And Gideon aunswered them: I will not raygne ouer you, neither shall my chyld reigne ouer you, the Lord shal raigne ouer you.
The people •eceavinge a benefit at Gideons hand, would have made him king, that they might not be counted ingrate. But seeing gratitude is a virtue, it ought to have no unjust thing joined with it: which these men observed not. For they appointed not their kingdom by the law of god. In Deut. the .27. chap. it is written, that he should be a king whom god had chosen.1 Neither pertained it unto the people, to appoint a king whom they would. Wherefore that which they do now, is not freely to give any thing that is their own, but to give ye which is an other mans. The right to appoint a king, belonged to god, and not unto men: which thing also Gideon wisely saw, neither was Christ ignorant thereof, when they which were filled with bread, came unto him to create him a king,2 he weighed the manner of his vocation, and for that his kingdom was not of this world, and understood that they usurped an other mans right, and were not moved thereunto: By just causes, he put of from himself such a burden. The same things happened in a manner unto the bishops of Rome. Which at the beginning were holy: for very many of them were notable by constancy of faith, & martyrdom. Farthermore their church was kindled with ferventness of charity, & towards the poor most liberal, so that it sent alms even into the east part, to the Islands and metal places, where the holy confessors of Christ lived in exile. All which things got that chair much favour and grace with the faithful.3 Wherefore the supreme power and kingdom in the church was in a manner offered, some times unto those bishops: which they like Gideon refused with a great spirit & singular modesty. Of which thing also what Gregorius the b. of Rome judged, I will briefly declare. In his .4. book of Epistles. in the .32.34.36.38. & .39. Epistles he of that matter writeth at large, both unto Mauritius the emperor, and also to Constantia Augusta, likewise to the Patriarchs, Alexandrinus, and Antiochenus, yea and to John the Patriarch of Constantinople, and lastly to Anianus Deacon of the same church.
The people •eceauinge a benefite at Gideons hand, would haue made him king, that they might not be coūted ingrate. But seing gratitude is a vertue, it ought to haue no vniust thing ioyned with it: whiche these men obserued not. For they appoynted not theyr kyngdome by the lawe of god. In Deut. the .27. chap. it is written, that he should be a king whom god had chosen.1 Neyther perteined it vnto the people, to appoint a kinge whome they would. Wherfore that which they doo now, is not frely to geue any thing that is theyr owne, but to geue ye which is an other mans. The right to appointe a king, belonged to god, and not vnto men: which thyng also Gideon wysely saw, neyther was Christ ignorant therof, when they which were filled with bread, came vnto him to create him a king,2 he wayghed the maner of his vocation, and for that his kingdome was not of this worlde, and vnderstoode that they vsurped an other mans right, and were not moued therunto: By iust causes, he put of from himself such a burthē. The same things happened in a maner vnto ye bishops of Rome. Which at the beginning were holy: for very many of thē wer notable by constancy of faith, & martirdom. Farthermore their church was kindled with feruentnes of charity, & towards the poore most liberal, so that it sent almes euen into the east part, to the Ilands and metalle places, where the holy confessours of Christ liued in exile. All which thinges got that chaire much fauor and grace with the faithful.3 Wherefore the supreame power and kingdome in the church was in a manner offred, some times vnto those bishops: which they like Gideon refused with a great spirite & singuler modesty. Of which thing also what Gregorius the b. of Rome iudged, I will briefly declare. In his .4. boke of Epistles. in the .32.34.36.38. & .39. Epistles he of that matter writeth at large, both vnto Mauritius the emperor, and also to Constantia Augusta, likewise to the Patriarkes, Alexandrinus, and Antiochenus, yea and to Iohn the Patriarche of Constantinople, and lastlye to Anianus Deacon of the same church.
In the time (saith he) of Pelagius my predecessor, Joannes Constantinopolitanus when he had assembled a synod, by an other pretence, claimed unto him self the title of the universal supreme Patriarch, which thing Pelagius toke in evil part, and therefore made the acts of that Synod frustrate. Farther, he commanded his Deacon which was his deputy, whom he had with the Emperor, that he should not communicate with John, being so arrogant and proud. Gregory ⟨image 154⟩succeeded Pelagius and decreed the same things, & writing unto the emperor, saith, Peter the chief among the Apostles, never called himself universal Apostle, and nevertheless John bishop of Constantinople now goeth about to call him self the universal Patriarch: & straightway he crieth out: O times, O manners. And this reason he addeth to these things, if the universal head be so ordained of men, by the ruin or corruption of such a head, the church also shall perish together. Of this place Nestorius was once bishop, who believed most wickedly of the son of god. Macedonius had the same dignity, who believed not that the holy ghost was god. If those Patriarchs had then been universal Bishops in the church, the whole church had fallen also with them.
In the time (sayth he) of Pelagius my predecessor, Ioannes Constantinopolitanus when he had assembled a sinode, by an other pretence, claymed vnto him self the title of the vniuersal supreame Patriarch, which thyng Pelagius toke in euil part, and therfore made the acts of that Sinode frustrate. Farther, he commaunded his Deacon which was his deputye, whome he had with the Emperoure, that he should not communicate with Iohn, being so arrogant and proud. Gregorye ⟨image 154⟩succeded Pelagius and decreed the same things, & writing vnto the emperor, sayth, Peter the chiefe amonge the Apostles, neuer called himselfe vniuersall Apostle, and neuerthelesse Iohn byshop of Constantinople now goeth about to cal him selfe the vniuersall Patriarch: & straightway he crieth out: O times, O maners. And this reason he addeth to these things, if the vniuersal head be so ordeyned of men, by the ruine or corruption of such a head, the church also shall perishe together. Of this place Nestorius was once bishop, who beleued most wickedly of the sonne of god. Macedonius had the same dignitye, who beleued not that the holy ghost was god. If those Patriarches had then beene vniuersall Bishops in the church, the whole church had fallen also with them.
Let none of the papists cry that it is no strong argument: because it is none of ours, but Gregory's their father: let them cry out against him, who afterward addeth: That he which maketh himself universal bishop, taketh away from other bishops their office, for where any man is universal bishop, he leaveth no office of a bishop unto others. This also is the collection of Gregory, and not found out by us. And undoubtedly if a man at this day look rightly and more nighly up on the thing, he shall see that the bishops of the west do govern their churches only by the order given them by the bishop of Rome.1 Gregory afterward addeth that John preferreth himself above the Emperor: which thing Gregory counted for an absurdity. But our men now a days think it necessary that Cesar should be subject to him: yea they have often times resisted emperors, many times wearied them, and sometimes moved them out of their place. And yet Gregory their father detesteth and inveigheth against it, as a thing unjust and not to be suffered. And writing unto Augusta he is yet more vehement, saying that the same belongeth unto Antichrist. Wherefore let not our men marvel, if we sometime call the bishop of Rome Antichrist, forasmuch as their Gregory, calleth him by the most goodly title, which will be universal bishop.
Let none of the papistes cry that it is no strong argument: bicause it is none of ours, but Gregories their father: let them cry out against him, who afterward addeth: That he which maketh himselfe vniuersall bishop, taketh away from other bishops their office, for where anye man is vniuersall byshop, he leaueth no office of a bishop vnto others. This also is the collectiō of Gregory, and not foūd out by vs. And vndoubtedly if a man at this day loke rightly and more nighly vp on the thing, he shal see that the bishops of the west doe gouerne theyr churches onely by the ordre geuen them by the bishop of Rome.1 Gregory afterwarde addeth that Iohn preferreth himselfe aboue the Emperor: which thing Gregory coū ted for an absurdity. But oure men now a dayes thinke it necessarye that Cesar should be subiect to him: yea they haue oftē times resisted emperors, many times wearied them, and sometimes moued them out of theyr place. And yet Gregory theyr father detesteth and inueigheth agaynst it, as a thinge vniust and not to be suffred. And writing vnto Augusta he is yet more vehemēt, saying that the same belongeth vnto Antechrist. Wherfore let not our mē meruayle, if we sometime cal the bishop of Rome Antechrist, for asmuch as their Gregory, calleth him by ye most goodly title, which wilbe vniuersal bishop.
1The Synod of Calcedonia, as the same Gregory saith, gave unto the seat of Rome this prerogative, namely unto Leo the first of that name. Howbeit no man used it, because our elders being men most holy, saw it was not meet for any mortal man. Only Christ is the universal head of the church For he is the small grain of mustard seed, which hath increased into abroad and large tree, that it overspreadeth the whole world: and he is that little leaven, wherewith three pecks of meal were leavened. And the stone hewed out without hands, which is become so great a mount that it hath filled all things. Wherefore Christ him self, for as much as he is able to be with us, is to all us the universal head, to whom every one of us cleaveth as members. Moreover Gregory admonisheth Alexandrinus and Antiochenus, that they should receive no Epistles, which had written in them a tittle of so great pride. And he saith, that to receive such a title, is to fall from the faith. Now let our men go, and obtrude this yoke, which by the testimony of their Gregory we can not receive, except we should go back from faith: Namely in attributing that to a man, which we must believe is proper and peculiar unto Christ. Neither doubteth he to affirm, that this John transgressed the decrees of Christ, the rules of the Apostles, and Cannons of the fathers. All these things saith he, hath he violated in the usurpation of this one title. And he addeth, what wilt thou answer unto Christ in the last day of judgement, thou that hast arrogantly taken upon thee his office, and wilt have all his members subject unto thee? He commanded, that we should not call any a father unto us upon earth. But thou commandest men to call thee universal father. In what estimation therefore hast thou the words of the Lord?
1The Sinode of Calcedonia, as the same Gregory sayth, gaue vnto the seat of Rome this prerogatiue, namely vnto Leo the first of that name. Howbeit no mā vsed it, because our elders being men most holy, saw it was not meete for anye mortal man. Onely Christ is the vniuersal hed of the church For he is the smal grayn of musterdsede, whiche hath incresed into abrode and large tre, that it ouerspreadeth the whole world: and he is that little leauen, wherwith thre peckes of meale wer leauened. And the stone hewed out without handes, whiche is become so great a moūt that it hath filled al thinges. Wherfore Christ him self, for as much as he is able to be with vs, is to al vs the vniuersal hed, to whom euery one of vs cleaueth as membres. Moreouer Gregory admonisheth Alexandrinus and Antiochenus, that they shoulde receaue no Epistles, whiche had written in them a tittle of so great pride. And he sayth, that to receaue such a title, is to fall from the fayth. Now let our men go, and obtrude this yoke, whiche by the testimony of theyr Gregory we can not receaue, except we should go back from faith: Namely in attributing that to a manne, which we must beleue is propre and peculiar vnto Christe. Neither doubteth he to affirme, that this Iohn transgressed the decrees of Christ, the rules of the Apostles, and Cannons of the fathers. All these things sayth he, hath he violated in the vsurpation of this one title. And he addeth, what wilt thou aunswere vnto Christ in the last day of iudgement, thou that hast arrogantly takē vpon thee his office, and wilt haue al his members subiect vnto thee? He commaunded, that we shoulde not call anye a father vnto vs vpon erth. But thou commandest men to cal thee vniuersal father. In what estimation therfore hast thou the wordes of the Lord?
1Howbeit in collecting of these places of Gregory, I think there are some things which are diligently to be taken heed of, namely two: of the which the one is, that he saith that Peter was the chief member of the universal church: & Paul, Andrew ⟨p. 148⟩and John, were heads of singular churches. This I therefore admonish you, for because the Apostles were not bishops of singular churches, for they wandered abroad thorough out the whole world, they founded churches & wan sundry nations unto the Lord, and all they were members,2 and that principal men bres of the universal church. Wherefore this sentence of Gregory is not to be admitted. The other thing, which I judge is to be observed, is that Gregory doth testify that this his John did first usurp unto himself the title of universality,3 which assuredly I cannot be persuaded of. Forasmuch as Theodoretus in his book de haerecibus, when he writeth of Nestorius, oftentimes saith, that he was made universal patriarch. Yea and Justinianus in suis novellis, attributeth that title to diverse Patriarchs. And (to speak as the thing is) I suppose, that Gregory this pretty little saint would have had the thing or matter of an universal bishop, although he reprehended the name and title. For as the history of those times teacheth, and his epistles testify, he abstained not from governing of other churches He showed indeed that the name should be avoided, namely least the patriarch of Constantinople by that title should either prefer himself, or be equal unto the bishop of Rome.
1Howbeit in collecting of these places of Gregory, I thinke there ar some thinges which ar diligently to be takē hede of, namely two: of the which the one is, that he sayth yt Peter was the chief membre of the vniuersal church: & Paule, Andrew ⟨p. 148⟩and Iohn, were heades of singular churches. This I therefore admonish you, forbycause the Apostles wer not byshops of singuler churches, for they wandred abrode thorough out the whole worlde, they founded churches & wan sondry nacions vnto the Lord, and al they were members,
But before these times, Cyprian withstood the church of Rome,1 who sought then to claim unto it self some tyranny, and he judged that appellations should not be brought unto the seat of Rome, but would have Ecclesiastical causes judged in every singular province: namely, that they which in any place were condemned by the judgement of bishops, should not be restored by the aid of the seat of Rome: when as yet he chiefly reverenced the church of Rome, & acknowledged it as the Matrix in these our regions. And assuredly to have it in great estimation, is a far other thing, then to grant unto it tyranny or dominion above all other. For to the first we may after a sort agree, but to the other we must not assent, unless we will fall from the faith. Afterward in Augustine's time, when he was present at the Synod of Africa, 2there was great and long alteration about this thing, and at length the bishop of Rome could never prove (which thing yet he chiefly endeavoured to do) that this power was given him in the council of Nice, that men from all parts of the world might appeal unto him. Wherefore if it were either for lack of knowledge or of some rashness, or by the people, or by flatterers given to any bishop of Rome, it should by the example of Gideon, Leo, and Gregory have been refused.
But before these times, Ciprian wythstoode the churche of Rome,1 whoe sought then to clayme vnto it self some tiranny, and he iudged that appellatiōs should not be brought vnto the seat of Rome, but would haue Ecclesiastical causes iudged in euery singuler prouince: namely, that they which in any place wer condemned by the iudgement of byshops, should not be restored by the ayd of the seate of Rome: when as yet he chiefly reuerenced the church of Rome, & acknowleged it as ye Matrix in these our regiōs. And assuredly to haue it in great estimacion, is a farre other thing, then to graunt vnto it tiranny or dominion aboue al other. For to the first we may after a sort agre, but to the other we must not assente, vnlesse we will fall from the fayth. Afterwarde in Augustines time, when he was present at the Sinode of Africa, 2there was great and longe alteration about this thinge, and at length the bishop of Rome coulde neuer proue (whiche thing yet he chiefly endeuored to do) that this power was geuen him in the councell of Nice, that menne from all partes of the worlde mighte appeale vnto him. Wherefore if it were eyther for lacke of knowlege or of some rashnes, or by the people, or by flaterers geuen to any byshop of Rome, it should by the example of Gideon, Leo, and Gregory haue bene refused.
We must not trust unto the inconstancy of the common people,1 which is always moveable now they will have Gideon to reign, a little afterward you shall see that they were most ungrate against him: for (as the history declareth) they slew his children. Gideon refuseth not the principality, as though he would not labour in the public wealth:2 but because he understood that it was no lawful vocation: which the Popes also ought to regard. He had before his eyes the law in Deut. now alleged. The Pope ought also to look upon the words of Christ: Kings of the nations (saith the Lord) bear rule over their subjects: but ye shall not do so: and being demanded, who should be greatest, he answered, that he which was lowest, and which more served others. This is to govern the church, not to command, but to serve. Peter himself also taught ministers not to bear dominion over their flock.3 And Paul hath written that Christ is set the head of the church, & not men: although in it they are above other to be much made of, & to be honoured, which more then other profit the faithful, and are more largely endowed with good gracious gifts: and as Christ required of Peter, do more deeply love him: and which are more abundantly endowed with those qualities, which Paul to Timothy and Titus requireth in bishops. If we highlier honour such men in the church above other, not as lords, not as universal bishops, not as heads of the church, but as excellent ministers thereof, the authority and obedience of the word of god should thereby be nothing diminished.
We must not trust vnto the inconstancy of the common people,1 which is alwayes moueable now they wyll haue Gideon to raigne, a litle afterwarde you shal see that they were most vngrate againste him: for (as the historye declareth) they slew his children. Gideon refuseth not the principality, as though he would not labour in the publike wealth:2 but bicause he vnderstode that it was no lawful vocatiō: which the Popes also ought to regard. He had before his eyes ye law in Deut. now alledged. The Pope ought also to loke vpon the words of Christ: Kinges of the nations (sayth the Lord) bear rule ouer theyr subiectes: but ye shal not do so: and being demaunded, who should be greatest, he aunsweared, that he which was lowest, and which more serued others. This is to gouern the church, not to commaund, but to serue. Peter himselfe also taught ministers not to beare dominion ouer their flocke.
1But they do not so. They have fixed the excellency and dignity of the ministers of the church, unto chairs, places, and cities, howsoever he be in greater price & honour, which sitteth in those chairs or places, and what manner of man so eve• he be in life and manners. And so is there no regard had to the graces and gifts of God, but only to the place and seat. This undoubtedly was the fountain, offspring, and beginning of all evils and superstitions. Our elders thought it good, that in cities which were more famous, where merchandises were traded, and were assemblies of men, where Proconsuls or Presidents governed, there also the bishops should be of greater authority and jurisdiction. Whereby custom obtained, that those Churches and chairs were had in greater honour.
1But they do not so. They haue fixed the exellency and dignity of the ministers of the church, vnto chayres, places, and cities, howsoeuer he be in greater price & honor, which sytteth in those chayres or places, and what manner of man so eue• he be in lyfe and manners. And so is there no regarde had to the graces and giftes of God, but onely to the place and seate. This vndoubtedly was the fountayne, ofpring, and beginning of al euils and superstitions. Our elders thought it good, that in cities which were more famous, where marchandises were traded, and were assemblies of men, where Proconsuls or Presidentes gouerned, there also the bishops should be of greater authority and iurisdiction. Whereby custome obteined, that those Churches and chayres were had in greater honor.
But (as it cometh to pass) ambition crept in, and in those places bishops were ordained, not alway such as were more worthy, but such as were better favoured of Princes. And oftentimes the better learned and more holy were given over to small and abject bishoprics. When Augustine was Bishop of Hippoverhegium, one called Aurelius governed the most honourable church of Carthago. And who knoweth not that Augustine in doctrine, manners, and authority, far excelled Aurelius? The same thing happened unto Gregorius Nazianzenus, who was bishop in an abject place, namely in Sassimis, when as many other, not to be compared with him, obtained the chief chairs. After this way & manner the bishop of Rome began to be preferred above other, namely because of the most ample dignity of the city:1 which cause nevertheless he understanding that it was no firm groundsel of the honour which he had obtained, he hath feigned other causes of his excellency. And first he pretendeth that he had this privilege by the council of Nice: which yet he could not prove before the fathers of Africa, because in that Synod the charge only of suburb churches was committed unto him. Not a charge to bear dominion, but to give counsel to admonish, and if there were any things of more weight, to refer the same to the council. As to the bishop of Alexandria the suburb churches of Egypt, and to the bishop of Antioch of the suburb churches of the east parties. And it was not given the bishop of Rome, to be the universal pastor. Neither is it possible that a weak and mortal man should feed the flock of Christ in all countries.
But (as it commeth to passe) ambicion crepte in, and in those places byshoppes were ordeyned, not alwaye suche as were more worthye, but such as were better fauored of Princes. And oftentimes the better learned and more holy were geuen ouer to small and abiecte bishoprikes. When Augustine was Bishop of Hippouerhegium, one called Aurelius gouerned the most honorable church of Carthago. And who knoweth not that Augustine in doctrine, maners, and authoritye, farre excelled Aurelius? The same thinge happened vnto Gregorius Nazianzenus, who was byshop in an abiect place, namelye in Sassimis, when as many other, not to be compared with him, obtayned the chief chayres. After this way & maner the bishop of Rome began to be preferred aboue other, namelye bycause of the moste ample dignitye of the citye:1 whyche cause neuerthelesse he vnderstanding that it was no firme groundsele of the honor which he had obteyned, he hath fained other causes of his excellency. And first he pretendeth that he had this priueledge by ye councel of Nice: which yet he could not proue before ye fathers of Africa, bicause in that Sinode the charge onelye of suburbe churches was committed vnto hym. Not a charge to beare dominion, but to geue counsel to admonish, and if there wer any things of more waight, to referre the same to the counsell. As to the bishop of Alexandria the suburbe churches of Egipt, and to the byshop of Antioch of the suburbe churches of the east parties. And it was not geuen the bishop of Rome, to be the vniuersall pastor. Neyther is it possible that a weake and mortall man should feede the flocke of Christe in all countries.
Farthermore the bishop of Rome boasted, that he was set to be the head of the church:1 which cannot be meet for any man. For from the head are derived moving and sense by the sinews, into all members, as Paul very well teacheth to the Ephesians and Colossians. But no man can perform that, as of himself, by closures & joints to quicken the members of the church with the sprite of god. It longeth only to christ,2 to distribute unto his members spiritual motions, illustration of the mind, and eternal life. Indeed kings and magistrates may be called heads of the people, because they govern civilly, and from them we may look for good laws and civil movings: but in the church men entreat not of civil life, but of spiritual and eternal life, which we cannot look for, but at gods hand, neither can any mortal men quicken the members of the church. Kings & magistrates when they are godly, in my judgement ought to have the chief place in the church: and to them it pertaineth, if religion be il administered, to correct the defaults. For therefore they bear the sword to maintain Gods honour. But they cannot be heads of the church. Paul to the Romans and to the Corinthians, where he maketh rehearsal of the members of the church, putteth some to be eyes, some noses, ears, hands, and feet: but he adorneth none with the dignity of the head, who yet to the Ephesians saith this of Christ, that god had given him to be the head of the body of the church.3 Let the papists show written in any other places of the holy scriptures, that Christ gave an other head unto the church, & they shall have the victory. But I know assuredly they cannot. For if that could have been done the church should be a two headed monster. But it is a sport to hear what John, sometimes B. of Rochester in defending the Pope answered ⟨p. 149⟩to this. To grant two heads of the Church (saith he) is not absurd: for the Apostle writeth, the man is the head of the woman, & nevertheless every wife hath beside her husband which is the head, an other head also. Wherefore he concluded that we may thus affirm of the church, namely that it hath both Christ and the Pope to be head. But this man faileth by a false Sillogismus of equivocation. For speaking now of a head, as it is attributed unto the Church, he falleth to a natural head.
In matrimony the husband is the head of the wife, not the natural head,1 but as touching economical life. But the natural head of the woman, is the beginning of her natural life. And undoubtedly if we look upon the natural head in the church, we shall find that it is not one head: but look how many men there be in it, so many heads shall there be: for there is none without an head in it. And when we speak of the head of the Church, we must keep our selves in the Metaphor: and as it should be absurd and monstrous, for one man to have two natural heads, so shall it be judged as portentous, for the Church to have two Metaphorical, that is spiritual heads. We must always, when we entreat of any thing, persist in the same order and kind: which thing if we do not observe, we shall easily be deceived by equivocation.
In matrimony the husband is the head of the wife, not the natural hed,1 but as touching aeconomical life. But the natural head of the woman, is the beginning of her natural life. And vndoubtedly if we looke vpon the natural head in the church, we shal finde that it is not one head: but looke howe manye men there be in it, so many heades shal there be: for there is none without an heade in it. And when we speake of the head of the Churche, we must keepe our selues in the Metaphore: and as it should be absurde and monstrous, for one man to haue two natural heades, so shal it be iudged as portentous, for the Churche to haue two Metaphorical, that is spiritual heads. We must alwaies, whē we entreate of any thing, persist in the same order and kinde: which thing if wee doo not obserue, we shal easily be deceaued by equiuocation.
But let us return to the Pope,1 who least he should seem to be destitute of testimonies of the holy scriptures, taketh two places out of them. Whereof the one is: Upon this rock I will build my Church, and will give the keys. &c. But that place pertaineth to all those which confess the verity of faith: for Peter, when the Lord demanded what the Apostles believed of him, answered in the name of them all, that he was the son of the living God. Wherefore, that which Christ speaketh unto him, pertaineth to all them, which together with him believe and profess the same self thing. For the keys are given unto the Church. And in John, the Lord after his resurrection gave them unto all them: at the last also, when he should ascend up into heaven, he sent them all alike to preach throughout the world. And as touching the foundation, the Church hath no other foundation but Christ. For Paul unto the Corinth. said: No man can lay any other foundation, then that which is already laid,2 which is Christ Jesus. And if at any time the Apostles be called foundations of the church, that is to be understand, because they in the first time of the Church cleaved unto the foundation, as the first and greater stones, not because the Church leaned unto them as to the principal foundation.
But let vs returne to the Pope,1 who least he shoulde seme to be destitute of testimonies of the holy scriptures, taketh two places out of them. Whereof the one is: Vpon this rocke I wil builde my Churche, and wyll gyue the keyes. &c. But that place pertaineth to al those which confesse the verity of faith: for Peter, when the Lord demaunded what the Apostles beleued of him, aunswered in the name of them al, that he was the sonne of the liuing God. Wherefore, that which Christ speaketh vnto him, pertaineth to all them, whych together wyth him beleue and professe the same selfe thing. For the keyes are geuen vnto the Church. And in Iohn, the Lord after his resurrection gaue them vnto all them: at the last also, when he should ascend vp into heauen, he sent them all alike to preache throughout the world. And as touching the foūdation, the Church hath no other foundation but Christ. For Paul vnto the Corinth. sayde: No man can lay any other foundation, then that which is already layde,2
The other place which they bring out of the scriptures, is,1 because Christ saith unto Peter, feed my Lambs. But they are exceedingly deceived: for it was not the office of Peter only, but also of the other Apostles, to feed the flock of the Lord. But it was so said peculiarly unto Peter, because he had denied the Lord thrice, and therefore he might have seemed to have fallen from the fellowship of the Apostles, unless he had of Christ been restored by certain words. And that not only he, but also other ought to feed the sheep of Christ, his own words testify, which be writeth in his Epistle, where he admonisheth other Ministers to feed the flock of the Lord. But grant, that the Lord gave unto Peter any principal thing: what hath the bishop of Rome common with him? Let him declare his spirit, and as Peter hath laboured for the Church, let him also labour: which thing if he perform, then will we acknowledge him, not as an universal bishop, but as a good Minister of Christ.2 He saith that he hath the chair that Peter had. What seat I pray you speaketh he of? The holy ghost is not bound to seats. But grant that it were so, Antioch had Peter sitting in it before Rome had. For that church he planted, and long while governed. But they say that he was slain at Rome. But the Jews crucified Christ himself at Jerusalem, which is a thing of greater weight. Wherefore if we should follow this argument, the bishop of Jerusalem should be preferred above all other. Yea, and Peter, as it is written to the Galatians, was not the Apostle of the Gentiles, ⟨image 156⟩but of circumcision, as it was agreed between Paul, James, John, and Barnabas. Neither do we ever read that Peter prescribed the other Apostles any thing, or that they depended of him. Yea Paul most manifestly testifieth, that he received nothing of Peter. Farther, it is certain that Peter was slain under Nero, & John lived even to the time of Trajan. And they say that Cletus, Linus, and Clemens succeeded Peter at Rome. What then, shall we think that John the Apostle was subject unto Clemens? And of necessity he should be so, if the Bishop of Rome be the universal head or general bishop. But who will say that this may be suffered? Moreover,3 lies may be confuted with lies. Our adversaries bring the Epistle of Clemens, which is a feigned Epistle, as a thing certain.
We will gratify them in this thing,1 and we will now grant that to be true, which is false. Let them mark his superscription, which is written after this manner: Clemens to James the brother of the Lord, by the providence of God the bishop of bishops, & governor of the Church which is at Jerusalem, and of all the Churches every where. What will they say here? The bishop of Rome ascribeth his title unto the Bishop of Jerusalem, and attributeth this universal charge of all Churches unto him, and not to himself. This argument maketh very much against those, which have unto the Churches obtruded this Epistle for true, & ratified it. But that can nothing hurt us, which is taken out of that epistle, against our doctrine. For we know that it is a feigned thing, as that which was never alleged by any of the fathers. And in it the same Clemens affirmeth, that he him self wrote the little book called Itenarium Perri: which book (as it is said in the Decrees) is counted among the Apocrypha books. But of this thing I have spoken sufficient, & these things have I rehearsed, only that we might understand, how much Gideon is to be preferred before the Antichrists of Rome.
We wyl gratefy thē in this thing,1 and we wyll now graunt that to be true, which is false. Let them marke his superscription, which is written after thys maner: Clemens to Iames the brother of the Lord, by the prouidence of God ye bishop of bishops, & gouernour of the Church which is at Ierusalem, and of al the Churches euery where. What wyl they say here? The bishop of Rome ascribeth his title vnto the Byshop of Ierusalem, and attributeth this vniuersall charge of all Churches vnto him, and not to himselfe. This argument maketh verye muche agaynste those, which haue vnto the Churches obtruded this Epistle for true, & ratefied it. But that can nothing hurt vs, which is takē out of that epistle, against our doctrine. For we know that it is a fayned thing, as that which was neuer alledged by any of the fathers. And in it the same Clemens affirmeth, that he hym selfe wrote the litle booke called Itenarium Perri: which booke (as it is said in the Decrees) is counted among the Apocripha bookes. But of this thing I haue spoken sufficient, & these thinges haue I rehearsed, onely that we might vnderstand, howe much Gideon is to be preferred before the Antechristes of Rome.
1Here is put forth an other question, whether the rule and government of God be therefore excluded, because the Magistrate of a public wealth, or of Aristocratia, or of a kingdom, is given unto a man. The cause of the doubt is, because when it was said unto Gideon: Thou shalt reign over us: he answered, I will not reign over you, but the Lord shall reign over you. It is not hard to dissolve this question proposed: forasmuch as the administration, wherewith God governeth public wealths, hindereth not the Magistrate, which is his Vicar & Minister. And assuredly God reigned together with David and Josiah: and the Israelites at that time had a certain Magistrate, and one of their own, with whom also God himself also governed. Wherefore the words of Gideon do not teach this, that God cannot reign there, where as is a lawful king. But this thing only he regarded, that the present state of things, which was instituted by God,2 ought not to be altered without him. There was a public wealth then in Israel, they had Senators, and in all places there were Judges appointed: wherefore the form of the public wealth could not by men be changed, without great offence. If so be thou wilt demand, when it is to be thought that God doth govern & rule in other Magistrates? I answer: Then, when this is only provided for, that Citizens may live virtuously. And forasmuch as piety is of all virtues the most excellent, the Lord doth then reign, when allthings are referred unto it. Farther, as touching civil actions, when to every man is rendered his own, & Magistrates govern not for their own commodity, but for the public utility.
1Here is put forth an other question, whether the rule and gouernmēt of God be therfore excluded, bicause the Magistrate of a publike wealth, or of Aristocratia, or of a kingdome, is geuen vnto a man. The cause of the doubt is, bicause when it was sayd vnto Gideon: Thou shalt raygne ouer vs: he answered, I wyl not raygne ouer you, but the Lord shal raign ouer you. It is not hard to dissolue this question proposed: forasmuch as the administration, wherwith God gouerneth publike wealthes, hindreth not the Magistrate, which is his Vicar & Minister. And assuredly God raigned together with Dauid and Iosias: and the Israelites at that tyme had a certaine Magistrate, and one of their own, with whom also God himselfe also gouerned. Wherfore the wordes of Gideon do not teach this, that God cannot raigne there, where as is a lawfull king. But this thyng onelye he regarded, that the present state of thinges, whiche was instituted by God,
When the thing is otherwise, shall we say that God reigneth or no, as when Nero, Domitianus, Commodus, Heliogabalus, and such wicked men were governors?1 Did God then cease from governing of the world? I think we must make a distinction of these things, which are done in those kingdoms, of the good things I say from the evil: forasmuch as there is no Empire so vitiate and corrupt, but that it still retaineth in it many good things. Let us look upon the government of Nero, & we shall see there in a manner, an infinite number of wicked and mischievous acts, where yet many parts also of Justice flourished. ⟨p. 150⟩Provinces were governed by Praetors, and Presidents, which execute laws, not altogether unjustly. It was lawful for Paul to appeal unto Rome, neither could the Hebrews by the laws be permitted to judge him as they lusted themselves. And the same Paul, when he had showed that he was a Citizen of Rome, escaped both from bonds and from stripes. Wherefore seeing in a government most corrupt, very many good and profitable things flourished, the same could come from none other but from God. It is therefore manifest that god at that time forsook not the care and administration of things.
When the thing is otherwyse, shall wee saye that God raygneth or no, as when Nero, Domitianus, Commodus, Heliogabalus, and suche wycked men wer gouernours?1 Did God then cease from gouerning of the worlde? I thynke we must make a distinction of these thinges, which are done in those kingdomes, of the good thinges I say from the euil: forasmuch as there is no Empire so vitiate and corrupt, but that it stil retaineth in it many good thinges. Let vs looke vpon the gouernment of Nero, & we shal se ther in a maner, an infinite number of wicked and mischeuous actes, where yet many partes also of Iustice floorished. ⟨p. 150⟩Prouinces were gouerned by Pretors, and Presidentes, which execute lawes, not altogether vniustly. It was lawful for Paul to appeale vnto Rome, neyther could the Hebrues by the lawes be permitted to iudge him as they lusted themselues. And the same Paul, when he had shewed that he was a Citizen of Rome, escaped both from bondes and from stripes. Wherefore seing in a gouernment most corrupt, very many good and profitable thinges floorished, the same coulde come frō none other but from God. It is therfore manifest that god at that time forsooke not the care and administration of thinges.
But if thou go forward and ask,1 whether the vices and corruptions of Empires are to be referred unto God: I will answer, that the true cause of sin is in man, but the will of God doth neither allow those vices, nor command them in his laws: yea, he prohibiteth and detesteth them. But he useth them to punish the wickedness of the people: for, for the since of the people, he maketh an hypocrite to reign, and in his fury he giveth kings. For such things are evil and since, and have in them a consideration of punishments: & as they are punishments, they pertain unto the justice of God.
But if thou go forward and aske,1 whether the vices and corruptions of Empires are to be referred vnto God: I wyll answer, that the true cause of synne is in man, but the wil of God doth neither allow those vices, nor cōmaunde them in his lawes: yea, he prohibiteth and detesteth them. But he vseth them to punish the wickednes of the people: for, for the synnes of the people, he maketh an hipocrite to raygne, and in his fury he geueth kinges. For such thinges are euyl and synnes, and haue in them a consideration of punishments: & as they are punishmentes, they pertayne vnto the iustice of God.
But when Princes are so corrupt, what is to be done? We must obey,1 but usque ad aras, that is, so far as religion suffereth. May private men take upon them to alter a corrupt Prince? They may do it in admonishing, in giving coū sell and reproving, but not by force of weapons. Yea, Citizens may fight for the defence of the public wealth, as long as it lasteth. Wherefore Pompeius, Cicero, and Cato, are not lightly to be condemned, for that they resisted Cesar, going about to stir up insurrection, although at that time the public wealth was very corrupt. But when he had once obtained the Empire, he ought not by private men to be deprived with weapons. Wherefore Augustus said unto Strabo, who spake evil of Cato, being then dead, that he was a good Citizen, which contended that the present state of things should not be changed. In the public wealth of the Hebrews, which flourished in the time of Gideon, God governed in very deed. It was (as I have said) Aristocratia, where Elders were chosen by common voices, to do justice: in which office, unless they rightly behaved themselves, they were both punished, and put out of their room: but if there happened any hard war, God himself raised up Judges, but they were not chosen by the people, neither did the children succeed the Parents in that office. After this manner did God govern the Hebrews. The words of Gideon sufficiently declare, that the Judges exercised not the office of an ordinary Magistrate. It was in the Lord to raise up for the time whom he would,2 therefore the Lord said unto Samuel: They have not rejected thee, but me, that I should not reign over them. Hereby we gather, that when any thing is offered us, we must always weigh, whither the same be good of his own nature, and whither it be lawfully given, and may lawfully be used. Which if it be not, let us put away from us, whatsoever is offered, as Christ rejected Satan, when he promised him all the kingdoms of the world, neither received he the kingdom offered him by the people. This the Pope considereth not, who for his unlawful Supremacy or tyranny, continually warreth, and there is nothing which he attempteth not: so far is he of to refuse these things. &c.
But when Princes are so corrupt, what is to be done? We must obey,1 but vsque ad aras, that is, so farre as religion suffreth. Maye priuate men take vpon them to alter a corrupt Prince? They may do it in admonishing, in geuing coū sel and reprouing, but not by force of weapons. Yea, Citizens may fight for the defence of the publike wealth, as long as it lasteth. Wherfore Pompeius, Cicero, and Cato, are not lightly to be condemned, for that they resisted Cesar, going about to styrre vp insurrection, althoughe at that time the publike wealth was very corrupt. But when he had once obtained the Empire, he ought not by priuate men to be depriued with weapons. Wherfore Augustus said vnto Strabo, who spake euil of Cato, being then dead, that he was a good Citizen, which contended that the present state of thinges should not be chaunged. In the publyke wealth of the Hebrues, which floorished in the time of Gideon, God gouerned in very deede. It was (as I haue said) Aristocratia, where Elders were chosen by common voices, to do iustice: in which office, vnles they rightly behaued themselues, they were both punished, and put out of their roume: but if there happened any hard warre, God himselfe raysed vp Iudges, but they were not chosen by the people, neither did the children succede the Parentes in that office. After this maner did God gouerne the Hebrues. The wordes of Gideon sufficientlye declare, that the Iudges exercised not the office of an ordinarye Magistrate. It was in the Lord to rayse vp for the time whom he would,
The other place which they bring out of the scriptures, is,1 bicause Christ saith vnto Peter, feede my Lambes. But they are excedingly deceaued: for it was not the office of Peter onely, but also of the other Apostles, to feede the flocke of the Lord. But it was so sayd peculiarly vnto Peter, bicause he had denyed the Lord thrise, and therefore he might haue seemed to haue fallen from the fellowship of the Apostles, vnles he had of Christ bene restored by certaine woordes. And that not onely he, but also other ought to feede the shepe of Christ, his own woordes testify, which be writeth in his Epistle, wher he admonisheth other Ministers to feede the flocke of the Lorde. But graunt, that the Lorde gaue vnto Peter anye principal thing: what hath the bishop of Rome common with him? Let hym declare his spirite, and as Peter hath labored for the Church, let hym also labour: which thing if he performe, then wil we acknowledge him, not as an vniuersal bishop, but as a good Minister of Christ.2 He sayth that hee hath the chaire that Peter had. What seate I pray you speaketh he of? The holy ghost is not bounde to seates. But graunt that it were so, Antioche had Peter sitting in it before Rome had. For that church he planted, and long whyle gouerned. But they say that he was slayne at Rome. But the Iewes crucified Christ himselfe at Ierusalem, which is a thing of greater waight. Wherfore if we should follow this argument, the bishop of Ierusalem should be preferred aboue all other. Yea, and Peter, as it is written to the Galathians, was not the Apostle of the Gentiles, ⟨image 156⟩but of circumcision, as it was agreed betwene Paul, Iames, Iohn, and Barnabas. Neither do we euer reade that Peter prescribed the other Apostles any thyng, or that they depended of him. Yea Paul most manifestly testifieth, that he receaued nothing of Peter. Farther, it is certaine yt Peter was slain vnder Nero, & Iohn liued euen to the time of Traiane. And they say that Cletus, Linus, and Clemens succeded Peter at Rome. What then, shal we thinke that Iohn the Apostle was subiect vnto Clemens? And of necessity he should be so, if the Byshop of Rome be the vniuersal head or general bishop. But who wil say that this may be suffred? Moreouer,3 lyes may be confuted with lyes. Our aduersaries bring the Epistle of Clemens, which is a fained Epistle, as a thing certaine.