Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 11 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
The fourth Proposal; We would have power in admission of Members, and in Excommunication.
The fourth Proposall; We would have power in admission of Members, and in Excommunication.
Ans. For admission of Members:
1 When you bring proof out of the Word, what power Church-Members have exercised in admission of Members, I hope you shall find none shall debar you from having that power.
1 When you bring proofe out of the Word, what power Church-Members have exercised in admission of Members, I hope you shall finde none shall debarre you from having that power.
2 When there are Members to be admitted, who never were Church-Members, you shall find it granted, but that is not our case here; if you would have power in admission to Sacraments, you have that liberty given you, to bring in Testimony for, or against; and if you bring in sufficient proofs against persons, you shall find they shall not be admitted; thus must you do in any Church what-ever. If any good Christian shall come, and give in testimony for another, the Minister will gladly receive it.
2 When there are Members to be admitted, who never were Church-Members, you shall finde it granted, but that is not our case here; if you would have power in admission to Sacraments, you have that liberty given you, to bring in Testimonie for, or against; and if you bring in sufficient proofes against persons, you shall finde they shall not be admitted; thus must you doe in any Church what-ever. If any good Christian shall come, and give in testimony for another, the Minister will gladly receive it.
For Excommunication, the Presbyterial Ministers will not Excommunicate without the peoples consent; you shall have liberty [first asking leave of the Minister, who is the Ruler, and Mouth of the Congregation] to propound any question soberly, and gravely, which you would have cleared, before you manifest your consent, if there be any thing dark to you, that so you may clearly obey them [for I hope you do not look to be equal with Officers in this Act] and I hope this is more then ever you saw practised in old times. Now that the Ministers will not Act against the people [I suppose they mean the Body of the People, for if they mean, unless all the people consent, I would not consent to the Presbyterial Ministers in this, that some few particular persons, guilty it may be themselves in some degree, shall obstruct the sentence, when the sounder and major part of the Church consents] hear their own words.
For Excommunication, the Presbyteriall Ministers will not Excommunicate without the peoples consent; you shall have liberty [first asking leave of the Minister, who is the Ruler, and Mouth of the Congregation] to propound any question soberly, and gravely, which you would have cleared, before you manifest your consent, if there be any thing darke to you, that so you may clearly obey them [for I hope you doe not looke to be equall with Officers in this Act] and I hope this is more then ever you saw practised in old times. Now that the Ministers will not Act against the people [I suppose they meane the Body of the People, for if they meane, unlesse all the people consent, I would not consent to the Presbyteriall Ministers in this, that some few particular persons, guilty it may be themselves in some degree, shall obstruct the sentence, when the sounder and major part of the Church consents] heare their owne words.
1 That these were Prophets in no Office.
2 1That the gift of Prophesying there mentioned was ordinary, and perpetual; of the Presbyterial Divines you have two men [there may be more for ought I know] to grapple with, that have strongly debated this question, and have answered all that is brought. Of the Congregational Divines I find two men of no small worth, who though in some extraordinary ⟨p. 85⟩case in places where Ministers are not to be had, if there be any able Christian fit to speak, they would grant such a liberty in a regular way; but for the places you bring to prove that it is an Ordinance of Christ for private members to prophesy, 2they oppose this: Mr. Cotton saith, That place 1 Cor. 314.31. doth not speak of ordinary private members, but of men furnished with extraordinary gifts, he proves it afterward. Mr. Norton saith, Prophecy, concerning which Paul speaks, 1 Cor. 14. is not to be understood of any ordinary and perpetual gift whatever, much less of an ordinary and perpetual gift of private brethren, and that he proves.
2 1That the gift of Prophesying there mentioned was ordinary, and perpetuall; of the Presbyteriall Divines you have two men [there may be more for ought I know] to grapple with, that have strongly debated this question, and have answered all that is brought. Of the Congregationall Divines I finde two men of no small worth, who though in some extraordinary ⟨p. 85⟩case in places where Ministers are not to be had, if there be any able Christian fit to speake, they would grant such a liberty in a regular way; but for the places you bring to prove that it is an Ordinance of Christ for private members to prophesie,
I intend not to launch forth Into this Controversy, for others have answered all those arguments that are brought; but let me say this, When I considered these places, 1 Cor. 12.28. God hath set some in the Church, first Apostles, secondarily Prophets, thirdly Teachers. The 29. verse, Are all Apostles? are all Prophets? are all Teachers? In the same order he reckons them. So Ephes. 4.11. He gave some Apostles, some Prophets, &c. So Act. 13. 1. There was in the Church at Antioch certain Prophets and Teachers, as Barnabas, &c. Prophets have ever their place next Apostles, and are ranked before Teachers; these texts are to me strong proofs, that these Prophets were no such private men as ours, nor their gifts ordinary; those that would be such must needs take place of their officers, you are before them, for these Prophets are always placed before ordinary officers. That 1 Cor. 13.2. and 14. v. 22.30. these places well considered will prove it was no ordinary gift.
I intend not to lanch forth Into this Controversie, for others have answered all those arguments that are brought; but let me say this, When I considered these places, 1 Cor. 12.28. God hath set some in the Church, first Apostles, secondarily Prophets, thirdly Teachers. The 29. verse, Are all Apostles? are all Prophets? are all Teachers? In the same order he reckons them. So Ephes. 4.11. He gave some Apostles, some Prophets, &c. So Act. 13. 1. There was in the Church at Antioch certaine Prophets and Teachers, as Barnabas, &c. Prophets have ever their place next Apostles, and are ranked before Teachers; these texts are to me strong proofes, that these Prophets were no such private men as ours, nor their gifts ordinary; those that would be such must needs take place of their officers, you are before them, for these Prophets are alwayes placed before ordinary officers. That 1 Cor. 13.2
But I would leave that way of arguing? and would argue against it from what I have observed about it.
1. It is needless, what need is there of it? I have observed that the ordinary time when these Prophets go to work, is after the Ministers have done preaching: what need is there of these men now to go to Prophesying? why do they not go home and meditate upon the Sermons they have heard, and call them over in their families? but (for sooth) now the brethren must go to Prophesy.
1. It is needlesse, what need is there of it? I have observed that the ordinary time when these Prophets goe to worke, is after the Ministers have done preaching: what need is there of these men now to goe to Prophesying? why doe they not goe home and meditate upon the Sermons they have heard, and call them over in their families? but (for sooth) now the brethren must goe to Prophesie.
2. It is not only needless, but it is dangerous, Satan hath a design in it.
2. It is not onely needlesse, but it is dangerous, Satan hath a designe in it.
First, to undermine the power of the word preached, these persons who have heard two Sermons before, run now to Prophesying, ⟨p. 86⟩where is the word the people heard before? 1this fine thing hath put out that.
- 1Tortul. hath an observation of the heretics then, Nec suis praesidibus reverentiam noverunt & hoc est quod. schismata apud hereticos fere non sunt; quia cum sint, non apparent schismata. Praescrip. adv Hae••t. This is very true of these kind of people, so far as I have observed among most of them.Tortul. hath an observation of the hereticks then, Nec suis praesidibus reverentiam noverunt & hoc est quod. schismata apud hereticos fere non sunt; quia cum sint, non apparent schismata. Praescrip. adv Hae••t. This is very true of these kinde of people, so far as I have observed among most of them.
Secondly, his design is to blast the Ministers, for I have observed, Ministers, nor their preaching is in any request with this generation, and the people are more taken with their prophesying, being a pretty new conceit, then they are with their officers preaching; be it never so solid.
Secondly, his designe is to blast the Ministers, for I have observed, Ministers, nor their preaching is in any request with this generation, and the people are more taken with their prophesying, being a pretty new conceit, then they are with their officers preaching; be it never so solid.
A near friend of mine (yet living) a Divine well known travelling into Germany, coming home in Holland he went to hear Mr. Ainsworth, who preached a very strong Sermon (the person was able to judge) while Mr. Ainsworth was preaching, my friend observed the carriage of his members, it was, he thought, not becoming the Ordinance (I will not write all he told me, left I should be thought to write out of malice) very dull and dead that was the fairest; when Mr. Ainsworth had done, they now were to prophesy; my friend said he observed, that those, who sate so dully and unreverently, while their Pastor was preaching very excellently, now their turn came to prophesy, rose up, and were so perk and lively, that he could but note their carriage. The word preached by officers, though never so able, doth little good, where this trade is driven.
A neare friend of mine (yet living) a Divine well knowne travelling into Germany, coming home in Holland he went to heare Mr. Ainsworth, who preached a very strong Sermon (the person was able to judge) while Mr. Ainsworth was preaching, my friend observed the carriage of his members, it was, he thought, not becoming the Ordinance (I will not write all he told me, left I should be thought to write out of malice) very dull and dead that was the fairest; when Mr. Ainsworth had done, they now were to prophesie; my friend said he observed, that those, who sate so dully and unreverently, while their Pastor was preaching very excellently, now their turne came to prophesie, rose up, and were so perke and lively, that he could but note their carriage. The word preached by officers, though never so able, doth little good, where this trade is driven.
3. I have observed, order with peace and unity, is seldom or never kept, where these persons flourish: one thinks his parts are as good as his brothers; this man he carps, and finds fault with his brothers doctrine; then come differences in, and heart-burnings; this man would be thought to be the chief, and most called upon to exercise, another likes not that, jangling, discord, breaches, I have known to be the fruit of this good work.
3. I have observed, order with peace and unity, is seldome or never kept, where these persons flourish: one thinkes his parts are as good as his brothers; this man he carps, and findes fault with his brothers doctrine; then come differences in, and heart-burnings; this man would be thought to be the chiefe, and most called upon to exercise, another likes not that, jangling, discord, breaches, I have knowne to be the fruit of this good work.
4. I have rarely known any of these persons that were humble men: the bones of pride, and self-conceitedness have stuck out shamefully in the chief of those, whom I have known; what others are, whom I have not known, I cannot tell, but the most gracious, savoury, humble persons that I have known, though as able as those who are so forward, yet they cannot be brought to this practice, but content themselves in improving what talents they have otherwise.
4. I have rarely knowne any of these persons that were humble men: the bones of pride, and selfe-conceitednesse have stucke out shamefully in the chiefe of those, whom I have knowne; what others are, whom I have not knowne, I cannot tell, but the most gracious, savoury, humble persons that I have knowne, though as able as those who are so forward, yet they cannot be brought to this practice, but content themselves in improving what talents they have otherwise.
5. I do not find private men to be so able, as these suppose themselves to be; some particular persons, Christians of good ⟨p. 87⟩experience, and ripe understandings, and some that are scholars may be able to speak to some points very well; but most what our Prophets deliver, either vile errors, as I have known, or else wrong the Scriptures very grossly many times: 1One of late was handling that Text of Cornelius, Act. 10. that he was a devout man, prayed, gave alms, &c. he cast this gloss upon it, that Cornelius was but as our devout Papists, that use also to pray, and give alms; this is strange that Cornelius was no other then such a one, doth the Scripture set such commendations upon such a person? I doubt the man did not well know what it was to be devout in Scripture account; the next words, fearing God, might have helped him to understand what manner of one he was. Being at London within less then a year, I heard there was a meeting of Christians, and the brethren were to prophesy, and it seems it was their manner to speak ex tempore after the first had spoken; I suppose they would imitate that text, 1 Cor. 14.30. If any thing be revealed to another that sitteth by, &c. I had no great stomach to go, yet I thought I would go hear, supposing that these persons who cry up prophesying, had something more excellent then other Ministers, especially being such adversaries to Black-coats: The text was 1 Thes. 5. Quench not the Spirit; the next words, Despise not prophesying, were brought in be sure, and charged home, that people should observe that, as one way of quenching the Spirit, I believe they spake ex tempore: Learning, and Ordination they were cried down; the glorious new lights brought in by the illiterate men were cried up; but such a mess I had, that should our poor Country Black-coats prophesy no better, we should teach our people to despise prophesying.
5. I doe not finde private men to be so able, as these suppose themselves to be; some particular persons, Christians of good ⟨p. 87⟩
These things I have observed in this new invented Ordinance: the sum is, when you bring us the men that are qualified for such a work (such as that worthy and honourable man Mr. Winthrop, who was a solid man, a good scholar, and natural Philosopher, fitted to speak excellently, and did sometimes, before Mr. Cotton went over to New England, when the officers desired him, but I never heard whether he did, after Mr. Cotton came) and can prove those texts to be meant of ordinary gifts, and the Prophets to be persons out of office, then we shall give you leave to Prophesy, but not after other Sermons preached by your officers.
These things I have observed in this new invented Ordinance: the summe is, when you bring us the men that are qualified for such a worke (such as that worthy and honourable man Mr. Winthrop, who was a solid man, a good schollar, and naturall Philosopher, fitted to speake excellently, and did sometimes, before Mr. Cotton went over to New England, when the officers desired him, but I never heard whether he did, after Mr. Cotton came) and can prove those texts to be meant of ordinary gifts, and the Prophets to be persons out of office, then we shall give you leave to Prophesie, but not after other Sermons preached by your officers.
Answ. 1Mr. Burroughs saith, The Devil uses to take sanctuary in conscience, hoping there men will be tender; but enquiry is to be made, whether he be indeed got in there, or in some other room of the soul. What that worthy man hath spoken to this point, I refer the Reader to Chap. 6. of his Irenicum.
Answ. 1Mr. Burroughs saith, The Devill uses to take sanctuary in conscience, hoping there men will be tender; but enquiry is to be made, whether he be indeed got in there, or in some other roome of the soule. What that worthy man hath spoken to this point, I refer the Reader to Chap. 6. of his Irenicum.
- 1Iren. p. 30.
Because conscience is so often pleaded, and made the Asylum for every opinionist, let us search when a man may be judged by Christian rules to be swayed by conscience.
First, I would look that such a man be one, that according to the best observation that can be made of him, hath a renewed conscience: I must find him to be uniform, else I weigh not what he saith about his conscience. There will be infirmities, but then they are but infirmities, and those truly lamented.
First, I would looke that such a man be one, that according to the best observation that can be made of him, hath a renewed conscience: I must finde him to be uniforme, else I weigh not what he saith about his conscience. There will be infirmities, but then they are but infirmities, and those truly lamented.
Though a man have a renewed conscience, 1yet I will not say that a true renewed conscience is the cause why he maintains such an opinion, he may not be rightly conscientious in that.
Though a man have a renewed conscience, 1yet I will not say that a true renewed conscience is the cause why he maintaines such an opinion, he may not be rightly conscientious in that.
- 1Posito abstracto & concreto non statim ponitur modus agendi.
Secondly, such a one is ready to give an account of his conscience if you call him to it, if he will not give me a reason what moves his conscience, I regard him no more: Conscience is but a Deputy, it cannot make Laws, but they are made before.
Secondly, such a one is ready to give an account of his conscience if you call him to it, if he will not give me a reason what moves his conscience, I regard him no more: Conscience is but a Deputy, it cannot make Lawes, but they are made before.
Thirdly, such a man hath used all means, the best means he can, to find out Gods mind, prayer, reading, conferring with the ablest Saints, and such as have most skill to guide; yea, prayer and fasting, any way to find out the truth his conscience is troubled about: If he hath not used the best, and all means, I weigh not his plea of conscience.
Thirdly, such a man hath used all means, the best means he can, to find out Gods mind, prayer, reading, conferring with the ablest Saints, and such as have most skill to guide; yea, prayer and fasting, any way to finde out the truth his conscience is troubled about: If he hath not used the best, and all means, I weigh not his plea of conscience.
Fourthly, if after searching he cannot yet come to see what the stream of holy and learned men do hold and practise, but must differ from them, it will be a trouble and grief to his spirit, that he should differ from them, fearing lest God should hide it from him, seeing others how holy and able they are, and therefore thinking they may know more of Gods mind, then he doth.
Fourthly, if after searching he cannot yet come to see what the streame of holy and learned men doe hold and practise, but must differ from them, it will be a trouble and griefe to his spirit, that he should differ from them, fearing lest God should hide it from him, seeing others how holy and able they are, and therefore thinking they may know more of Gods minde, then he doth.
Fifthly, such a man will walk very humbly and respectively towards those men, from whom he differs, being he knows ⟨p. 89⟩so holy and able, let us hear Mr. Burroughs speak: 1But you will say, every man pleads conscience; how shall we know whether it be the stoutness of his heart, or the tenderness of his conscience? Thus, if this man behaveth himself humbly, and the rather humbly in all other things, because he cannot see what his Brother doth in such and such particulars, and so is in danger to be an offence to his Brother, and therefore his soul is humbled, this is a good witness that it is mere conscience, and not stoutness that makes him differ: But now, if his behaviour be high, and proud, when he differeth from his brother, he doth not take it to be an affliction to him, that he cannot see what his brother doth, but censureth him, and thinks that it is either through his weakness, or through his wilfulness that he will not see, and so carries himself high, and proudly before his brother, this witnesseth to his face that it is stubbornness, and singularity. Nay, then Mr. Burroughs, you have scarce left ten conscientious Separatists in England, the former part of this I have not seen in any, the latter I have seen enough.
Fifthly, such a man will walke very humbly and respectively towards those men, from whom he differs, being he knowes ⟨p. 89⟩so holy and able, let us heare Mr. Burroughs speake: 1But you will say, every man pleads conscience; how shall we know whether it be the stoutnesse of his heart, or the tendernesse of his conscience? Thus, if this man behaveth himselfe humbly, and the rather humbly in all other things, because he cannot see what his Brother doth in such and such particulars, and so is in danger to be an offence to his Brother, and therefore his soule is humbled, this is a good witnesse that it is meere conscience, and not stoutnesse that makes him differ: But now, if his behaviour be high, and proud, when he differeth from his brother, he doth not take it to be an affliction to him, that he cannot see what his brother doth, but censureth him, and thinkes that it is either through his weaknesse, or through his wilfulnesse that he will not see, and so carries himselfe high, and proudly before his brother, this witnesseth to his face that it is stubbornnesse, and singularity. Nay, then Mr. Burroughs, you have scarce left ten conscientious Separatists in England, the former part of this I have not seen in any, the latter I have seen enough.
6 A man truly conscientious, &c. in those points where he doth agree with other learned and holy men, will there cleave close to them, in opposing also all other points which he judgeth to be false; he will not be a sly enemy, or scoffer of such, and a conniver at, and a favourer of other Sects and Opinions, which his heart tells him are not sound, or at least he doubts much of them.
6 A man truly conscientious, &c. in those points where he doth agree with other learned and holy men, will there cleave close to them, in opposing also all other points which he judgeth to be false; he will not be a slye enemy, or scoffer of such, and a conniver at, and a favourer of other Sects and Opinions, which his heart tells him are not sound, or at least he doubts much of them.
Now the grounds of all these several heads in the trial of him, who differs purely out of conscience, are these:
Now the grounds of all these severall heads in the triall of him, who differs purely out of conscience, are these:
1. Because such a conscience in the very formal notion of it carrieth this, viz. this mans heart is awed, and carried away with the Majesty, and Authority of God and his Truth; it argueth much grace, if one takes it in the true notion, then I am sure such a heart will do all these things.
1. Because such a conscience in the very formall notion of it carrieth this, viz. this mans heart is awed, and carried away with the Majesty, and Authority of God and his Truth; it argueth much grace, if one takes it in the true notion, then I am sure such a heart will doe all these things.
2 Such a man is awed with all truths, 1and therefore the command of unity, to be all of one mind, to speak the same things; these have such a power on his spirit, as it puts him upon all these.
2 Such a man is awed with all truths, 1and therefore the command of unity, to be all of one minde, to speake the same things; these have such a power on his spirit, as it puts him upon all these.
3 Such a man considers that to be an offence to other godly Christians, from whom he differs, is a thing that he had need take heed of; also a fear of weakening the work of God in the place where he lives.
3 Such a man considers that to be an offence to other godly Christians, from whom he differs, is a thing that he had need take heed of; also a feare of weakning the worke of God in the place where he lives.
4 Such a one knows the vileness of his own heart, and is prying into his own weaknesses, others he can see more holy and ⟨p. 90⟩able then himself, and hence he fears himself, and conceives such men, being so holy and near to God, I fear he may reveal that to them, which he conceals from me.
4 Such a one knowes the vilenesse of his owne heart, and is prying into his own weaknesses, others he can see more holy and ⟨p. 90⟩able then himselfe, and hence he feares himselfe, and conceives such men, being so holy and neare to God, I feare he may reveale that to them, which he conceals from me.
Now then, if you can bring us men who express all these, and walk truly by these rules, you shall not need to go to the State, to get an Act for Toleration of tender consciences, for I doubt not but Churches will be very tender of such; God seldom leaves these to drink in any vile error, if for a time they be mis-lead, he will discover his mind to them ere long, I am assured. But alas, how far are our people from these things? I do not rehearse them over again, but either let these be disproved to be no rules to judge by, or if they be, there are not ten (as I said) of such scarce to be found in England, who separate from the Ministry, and Churches, and have betaken themselves to their private houses; yea, if we go to our Congregational Churches, and examine these, who plead for Liberty of Conscience, we shall hardly find these Rules observed. The sum is, you see, if indeed you be right conscientious men, and lead by a pure Conscience in the points wherein you differ, you shall have that liberty that Christ would have allowed you, and none will Domineer over your Consciences.
Now then, if you can bring us men who expresse all these, and walke truly by these rules, you shall not need to goe to the State, to get an Act for Toleration of tender consciences, for I doubt not but Churches will be very tender of such; God seldome leaves these to drink in any vile errour, if for a time they be mis-lead, he will discover his minde to them ere long, I am assured. But alas, how farre are our people from these things? I doe not rehearse them over againe, but either let these be disproved to be no rules to judge by, or if they be, there are not ten (as I said) of such scarce to be found in England, who separate from the Ministry, and Churches, and have betaken themselves to their private houses; yea, if we goe to our Congregationall Churches, and examine these, who plead for Liberty of Conscience, we shall hardly finde these Rules observed. The summe is, you see, if indeed you be right conscientious men, and lead by a pure Conscience in the points wherein you differ, you shall have that liberty that Christ would have allowed you, and none will Domineere over your Consciences.
I know of nothing more can be alleged, but I think I have taken in all that is brought against the Ministry, and Churches. It may be, some would be apt to cast in this, That the Ministers are no friends to the State, ergo, &c.
I know of nothing more can be alledged, but I thinke I have taken in all that is brought against the Ministry, and Churches. It may be, some would be apt to cast in this, That the Ministers are no friends to the State, ergo, &c.
I shall not stay to give any answer to this more then thus:
1 The Separatists were, before this Government was erected, to be sure the leaven of all was laid, if not all actually separated.
1 The Separatists were, before this Government was erected, to be sure the leaven of all was layed, if not all actually separated.