Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 10 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
2 But suppose i the so, yet why must that Mat. 18. be meant only of the Fraternity? Tell the Church, i. e. the Fraternity, if he will not hear the Church, i. e. the Fraternity, where are the Officers, are they no body? one in New England would needs know of me, why they should tell the Ministers of it, when as it is, Tell the Church, not the Ministers? this indeed would confirm it, and here we should have brave order.
2 But suppose i the so, yet why must that Mat. 18. be meant only of the Fraternity? Tell the Church, i. e. the Fraternity, if hee will not heare the Church, i. e. the Fraternity, where are the Officers, are they no body? one in New England would needs know of me, why they should tell the Ministers of it, when as it is, Tell the Church, not the Ministers? this indeed would confirme it, and here we should have brave order.
Mr. 1Cawdry upon that Text seems to have a good Argument, since that the Kingdom of Heaven is there meant the Church, the keys are given to Peter as distinguished from the Church; It is not a reasonable construction (saith he) of the Text to say, I give to thee the keys of the Kingdom of Heaven, that is, of the Church, and to mean, I give to the Church the keys of the Church; whence he concludes, they were given to Peter, and so to the Officers for the Church, as the keys are given to the Steward for the family. This Argument is worth the Answering.
Mr. 1Cawdry upon that Text seemes to have a good Argument, since that the Kingdome of Heaven is there meant the Church, the keyes are given to Peter as distinguished from the Church; It is not a reasonable construction (saith he) of the Text to say, I give to thee the keyes of the Kingdome of Heaven, that is, of the Church, and to mean, I give to the Church the keyes of the Church; whence he concludes, they were given to Peter, and so to the Officers for the Church, as the keyes are given to the Steward for the family. This Argument is worth the Answering.
- 1Vind. vin. p. 6.
Object. The strongest Objection to me is this, the first subject takes up the whole adjunct, for there is a reciprocation; therefore the Presbytery cannot be the first subject, for the keys are not reciprocated with them; instance is given in Election, Admission of Members, Discipline, which cannot be performed without the Fraternity.
Object. The strongest Objection to mee is this, the first subject takes up the whole adjunct, for there is a reciprocation; therefore the Presbytery cannot be the first subject, for the keyes are not reciprocated with them; instance is given in Election, Admission of Members, Discipline, which cannot be performed without the Fraternity.
Answ. If reciprocation be so required, &c. then this will as well deny the people to be first subject, for reciprocation cannot be with them; for Preaching, Administration of Sacraments, Government &c. to be sure the people cannot do; there will be more said for the Presbytery; they actually choose, they actually admit, they actually govern and exercise discipline, they have both the Power and the Act: but for the people they cannot do any Act which belongs to the Officer, nor have so much as the power of it: we may see by this, where the power will chiefly reside: to say, the Fraternity, though they have not official power, yet they have power to choose an Officer, and so consequently, they are the first subject, this is very unsatisfactory, to have the Adjunct reciprocated at the second hand, it being denied before that they have the Adjunct; the reciprocation between homo & animal risibile is not at second hand
Answ. If reciprocation be so required, &c. then this will as well deny the people to bee first subject, for reciprocation cannot bee with them; for Preaching, Administration of Sacraments, Government &c. to be sure the people cannot doe; there will be more said for the Presbytery; they actually choose, they actually admit, they actually govern and exercise discipline, they have both the Power and the Act: but for the people they cannot doe any Act which belongs to the Officer, nor have so much as the power of it: we may see by this, where the power will cheifly reside: to say, the Fraternity, though they have not officiall power, yet they have power to chuse an Officer, and so consequently, they are the first subject, this is very unsatisfactory, to have the Adjunct reciprocated at the second hand, it being denyed before that they have the Adjunct; the reciprocation betweene homo & animal risibile is not at second hand
2 This doth not at all shake me, but I stand on my ground still, conceiving, that the Church or ganized is the first subject of the power of the Keys, not that I make the people equal sharers in the power of the keys with the Officers, but what I mean I shall express afterwards.
2 This doth not at all shake me, but I stand on my ground still, conceiving, that the Church or ganized is the first subject of the power of the Keyes, not that I make the people equall sharers in the power of the keyes with the Officers, but what I mean I shall expresse afterwards.
3 Yet am I not satisfied (nor could ever be) that whatever belongs to the Church must needs be included in the power of the keys; Election, I look at it only as Potest as circa claves, but not to be a power of them.
3 Yet am I not satisfied (nor could ever be) that whatever belongs to the Church must needs be included in the power of the keyes; Election, I look at it only as Potest as circa claves, but not to be a power of them.
The Text tells us the use of them, what thou bindest, what thou loosest, to bind and to loose is the use of them: but what is this to the election of an Officer? when as he may refuse their Call, or the Call ⟨p. 77⟩of any Church? how do they loose him or bind him? Electio noncogit.
The Text tells us the use of them, what thou bindest, what thou loosest, to bind and to loose is the use of them: but what is this to the election of an Officer? when as hee may refuse their Call, or the Call ⟨p. 77⟩of any Church? how doe they loose him or bind him? Electio noncogit.
For the other two things, Admission, and Discipline: Those Divines, who say, that Baptism makes men Members of the Church, if they can prove this strongly, they will carry away the former, scil. that the people have nothing to do in Admission of members, for baptism makes members; now to this I cannot yet fully agree, there might be much said for the contrary. I conceive the New England Divines have spoken well to this besides the opinion of M. Cartwright, 1and Ames, who join with them.
For the other two things, Admission, and Discipline: Those Divines, who say, that Baptisme makes men Members of the Church, if they can prove this strongly, they will carry away the former, scil. that the people have nothing to do in Admission of members, for baptisme makes members; now to this I cannot yet fully agree, there might be much said for the contrary. I conceive the New England Divines have spoken well to this besides the opinion of M. Cartwright, 1and Ames, who joyn with them.
- 1Ans to 32. Qu. p. 12.
So, those Divines who affirm the Presbytery may excommunicate, renitente plebe, if they can prove it strongly, they will carry away the latter, and then indeed its clear, the people have no interest in the power of the keys; but this neither can be admitted, and the stream of Divines oppose this.
So, those Divines who affirme the Presbytery may excommunicate, renitente plebe, if they can prove it strongly, they will carry away the latter, and then indeed its cleare, the people have no interest in the power of the keyes; but this neither can be admitted, and the streame of Divines oppose this.
But though I yield the Ministry cannot orderly do these things without the people, yet I deny the people do these things in the same way and order, that the Ministry doth them: And therefore Quaere, Whether it be proper to say, the people hath any power of the keys?
But though I yeeld the Ministry cannot orderly doe these things without the people, yet I deny the people do these things in the same way and order, that the Ministry doth them: And therefore Quaere, Whether it be proper to say, the people hath any power of the keyes?
For Admissions, this will be more troublesome, because we find no examples of the Churches where the people did show their power in Admissions: for that act of Paul, Act 9.26, 27. Whether it be sufficient to prove it, I leave it to consideration; they did not admit, why? they were afraid of him, the text saith, being a persecutor, then no wonder the Apostles, as well as the people, were afraid of him; the 27 verse saith, Barnabas carried Paul to the Apostles, not to the people, which would imply, the Apostles carried the stroke in Admissions.
For Admissions, this will be more troublesome, because we finde no examples of the Churches where the people did shew their power in Admissions: for that act of Paul, Act 9.26, 27. Whether it be sufficient to prove it, I leave it to consideration; they did not admit, why? they were afraid of him, the text saith, being a persecutor, then no wonder the Apostles, as well as the people, were afraid of him; the 27 verse saith, Barnabas carried Paul to the Apostles, not to the people, which would imply, the Apostles carryed the stroke in Admissions.
Further to search into this, let us suppose the Ministry of the Church of Corinth preach, an Infidel hear them, the man is so far convinced of the vanity of his Heathenism, and danger of his sinful lusts he wallowed in, and so far convinced of the necessity of that Doctrine which he hears, that he renounces his Idols, reforms his conversation, &c. now he comes to the Ministers to signify what is done, and what he desires, to be received into the Church, and be baptized, being willing to give up himself to that doctrine: the Ministry [instrumentally] hath wrought this; now what power hath the people here to hinder this man? is it at their choice whether they will admit him or no? when the Officers see what effect the preaching hath had, here being a Disciple made, shall they be hindered from baptizing him? what power ⟨p. 78⟩have the people here? what shall they go first and examine him? I know not where examination was ever given to the people; must he make his profession of faith before all the Church, as Victorinus that brave Rhetorician? 1we find it was not their course to do so with all those whom they admitted, for many did only to the Presbyters: This power indeed the brethren have, that if any know this man to live in a known way of wickedness, that cannot possibly stand with any hopes of faith, to come and give in witness against such a person to the Officers: I suppose this will be yielded, and the Officers would not now baptize him. But what power more they have, I know not; they see his conversation, and can testify of that, but it were strange that it should be left to the peoples choice, whether they will admit a man or not, when the word hath had so much power, and they cannot bring in sufficient objections to the contrary. Put case the major part of the members of the Church had drunk in some errors [that a major part may do so, hath been proved in our time] and they will not give their consent to the admission of the man, if they find him not of their opinion [commonly those who have drunk in error, use to look untowardly upon those who are contrary] now the Ministers have no power to admit this man, nor baptize him, though they see he hath right to it. But I leave that.
Further to search into this, let us suppose the Ministry of the Church of Corinth preach, an Infidell heare them, the man is so far convinced of the vanity of his Heathenism, and danger of his sinful lusts he wallowed in, and so far convinced of the necessity of that Doctrine which he heares, that he renounces his Idols, reforms his conversation, &c. now he comes to the Ministers to signifie what is done, and what he desires, to be received into the Church, and be baptized, being willing to give up himselfe to that doctrine: the Ministry [instrumentally] hath wrought this; now what power hath the people here to hinder this man? is it at their choyce whether they will admit him or no? when the Officers see what effect the preaching hath had, here being a Disciple made, shal they be hindred from baptizing him? what power
For Discipline, I conceive renitente plebe, the Eldership should not excommunicate: it is in vain to do so indeed, if the people will hold communion: but yet this doth not argue that the people do here act, as doth the Eldership; For the Eldership doth it Authoritativè, the people by a popular consenting with the Officers, that the person be excommunicate: the people do act here obedientially to their Officers, therefore a vast difference is between them. I remember a passage of Mr. Hookers in the Assembly of Divines; When a case is brought to the Elders, the Elders having searched all things to the bottom, now the Elders bring the case to the Fraternity, and lay it down clear before them, this is the case, and this ought to be done, now (said he) the people are bound to obey us, as well as when we preach. And it is clear, for as in preaching they discover the mind of God, so in this sentence they declare the same concerning this act. 12 Cor. 10.6. We have in readiness to revenge all disobedience, when your obedience is fulfilled. Mr. Cotton saith, the Apostles revenge of disobedience by way of reproof in preaching, doth not follow the peoples obedience, but proceedeth, whether the people obey or not; it was therefore their revenge by way of censure in Discipline, ⟨p. 79⟩which they had in readiness, when the obedience of the Church is fulfilled in discerning and approving the equity of the Censure, which the Apostle, or Elders have declared to them from the word.
For Discipline, I conceive renitente plebe, the Eldership should not excommunicate: it is in vaine to doe so indeed, if the people will hold communion: but yet this doth not argue that the people doe here act, as doth the Eldership; For the Eldership doth it Authoritativè, the people by a popular consenting with the Officers, that the person bee excommunicate: the people doe act here obedientially to their Officers, therefore a vaste difference is betweene them. I remember a passage of Mr. Hookers in the Assembly of Divines; When a case is brought to the Elders, the Elders having searched all things to the bottome, now the Elders bring the case to the Fraternity, and lay it down clear before them, this is the case, and this ought to be done, now (said he) the people are bound to obey us, as well as when wee preach. And it is cleare, for as in preaching they discover the minde of God, so in this sentence they declare the same concerning this act.
That phrase, discerning and approving of the equity, needs a little more clearing; but I leave them: However this Reverend Divine seems to refer that obedience unto the will of Christ, by the words going before his exposition, yet that hinders not, but it may in some sense be applied to their officers [who also obey Christ] for that phrase is not strange to have people obey their officers, Heb. 13.17. O bey your Rulers, there may be some thing in it, not only obey your Teachers, but Rulers; when they rule, as when they preach, Mr. Norton expressing, 1as I conceive, how the brethren act with the Eldership [for so I remember it was in his Tables which I had, & had some thoughts to have Printed them, but in that great fire, when Colchester was besieged (having lent them to a friend) they were burnt, as I hear) Parts judicii in rebus jurisdictionis, quales sunt fratrum examinatio, dijudicatio & sententiatio Causae per modum obedientiae, Presbyterio debitae, 2 Cor. 10.16. & cap. 2.9.
That phrase, discerning and approving of the equity, needs a little more clearing; but I leave them: However this Reverend Divine seems to refer that obedience unto the wil of Christ, by the words going before his exposition, yet that hinders not, but it may in some sence be applyed to their officers [who also obey Christ] for that phrase is not strange to have people obey their officers, Heb. 13.17. O bey your Rulers, there may be some thing in it, not only obey your Teachers, but Rulers; when they rule, as when they preach, Mr. Norton expressing, 1as I conceive, how the brethren act with the Eldership [for so I remember it was in his Tables which I had, & had some thoughts to have Printed them, but in that great fire, when Colchester was besiedged (having lent them to a friend) they were burnt, as I heare) Partes judicii in rebus jurisdictionis, quales sunt fratrum examinatio, dijudicatio & sententiatio Causae per modum obedientiae, Presbyterio debitae, 2 Cor. 10.16. & cap. 2.9.
Mr. Gillespie, also besides his own opinion giveth reasons, 1and allegeth divers Divines, who interpret this place of Church censures: & these words, when your obedience is fulfilled, gives him one ground for his interpretation: for as Estius and Novarinus explain the Apostles reason, it is in vain to excommunicate all such as are worthy of excommunication, when there is a general renitency in the Church: but still we observe the people act obedientially to their officers, that they did not at that time, was their fault.
Mr. Gillespie, also besides his own opinion giveth reasons, 1and alledgeth divers Divines, who interpret this place of Church censures: & these words, when your obedience is fulfilled, gives him one ground for his interpretation: for as Estius and Novarinus explain the Apostles reason, it is in vain to excommunicate all such as are worthy of excommunication, when there is a generall renitency in the Church: but still we observe the people act obedientially to their officers, that they did not at that time, was their fault.
- 1Aar. rod, p. 289, &c.
Besides, if excommunication be the highest act of Rule, and therefore cannot be performed where Rulers are not, as saith Mr. Cotton: and if a homogeneall body can express no spiritual Jurisdiction, but only withdraw, as saith Master Burroughs, then the people having Rulers, are not now made Rulers, nor have the power of jurisdiction; there is indeed jurisdiction exercised among them by reason of their Rulers, to whom they consent and obey.
Besides, if excommunication be the highest act of Rule, and therefore cannot be performed where Rulers are not, as saith Mr. Cotton: and if a homogeneall body can expresse no spirituall Jurisdiction, but onely withdraw, as saith Master Burroughs, then the people having Rulers, are not now made Rulers, nor have the power of jurisdiction; there is indeed jurisdiction exercised among them by reason of their Rulers, to whom they consent and obey.
Government is proper to the Presbytery, saith acute Mr. Norton, 1and shows under seven particulars how the Presbyters govern in Church affairs, and so in this exercise of Discipline: if so, then the people are governed in this act; how then doth a people governed, act in reference to Rulers governing, but by way of obedience? So that to me there appears a vast difference between the power ⟨p. 80⟩of Discipline, as it is in the hands of the Presbytery, and as in the hands of the people, though the Ministers cannot excommunicate without the people.
Government is proper to the Presbytery, saith acute Mr. Norton, 1and shewes under seven particulars how the Presbyters governe in Church affairs, and so in this exercise of Discipline: if so, then the people are governed in this act; how then doth a people governed, act in reference to Rulers governing, but by way of obedience? So that to mee there appeares a vaste difference betweene the power ⟨p. 80⟩of Discipline, as it is in the hands of the Presbytery, and as in the hands of the people, though the Ministers cannot excommunicate without the people.
- 1Resp: ad Apol. p: 65 67:
I speak a few words to this point here, because I would spare the labour in another place.
I speake a few words to this point here, because I would spare the labour in another place.
As for the Analogy drawn from the civill power, the people are the first subject of civill power; Ergo the Fraternity is the first subject of Church power; For the Antecedent I leave that, but the consequence I should deny, there is a great disproportion.
As for the Analogy drawne from the civill power, the people are the first subject of civill power; Ergo the Fraternity is the first subject of Church power; For the Antecedent I leave that, but the consequence I should deny, there is a great disproportion.
First, The People are not the effect of their Magistrates, or follow after them (as the people of Israel were not of Saul) but the Fraternity, quâ sic, is the effect of the Ministry: The Apostles converted, and after them the Ministers converted; Converting is but to make the people such, for whom the power of the keys is given:
First, The People are not the effect of their Magistrates, or follow after them (as the people of Israel were not of Saul) but the Fraternity, quâ sic, is the effect of the Ministry: The Apostles converted, and after them the Ministers converted; Converting is but to make the people such, for whom the power of the keyes is given:
Secondly, There is some thing in this; In Corporations, if the people have elected a man to be an Alderman, or Mayor, if he refuse it, there is a Fine set upon him; some have been fined 20 li. some more according as the Corporations are: but if the body of the people will choose an Officer, and he will refuse it, what then? I know no kind of Church act that reaches him: this shows there is something more in civill then Church power,
Secondly, There is some thing in this; In Corporations, if the people have elected a man to be an Alderman, or Mayor, if he refuse it, there is a Fine set upon him; some have been fined 20 li. some more according as the Corporations are: but if the body of the people will choose an Officer, and he will refuse it, what then? I know no kind of Church act that reaches him: this shewes there is something more in civill then Church power,
Thirdly, The people do give to their Magistrates a power to make Laws, &c. for their good; but the Church gives no power into the hands of her Ministers, but they have all their power immediately from Christ.
Thirdly, The people do give to their Magistrates a power to make Lawes, &c. for their good; but the Church gives no power into the hands of her Ministers, but they have all their power immediately from Christ.
Fourthly, Hence the people may limit their people, or enlarge it: But the people cannot limit, nor enlarge the power the Ministers have.
Fourthly, Hence the people may limit their people, or inlarge it: But the people cannot limit, nor inlarge the power the Ministers have.
Fifthly, We see the Magistrates Act in the name of the people [in the name of the Commonwealth of England] but Ministers do not act in the name of the Church, but Christ; as saith Mr. Burroughs and Mr. Norton before quoted.
Fiftly, We see the Magistrates Act in the name of the people [in the name of the Commonwealth of England] but Ministers doe not act in the name of the Church, but Christ; as saith Mr. Burroughs and Mr. Norton before quoted.
More might be produced, but I content my self with these; and though that maxim be received, Salus populi, Suprema lex, yet it hinders not but the people may save themselves, though they be not the first subject of the keys. Mr. Richardson, whom Dr. Ames and Mr. 1Hooker, honoured much, and follow much, placeth the power of binding, and loosing in the Governors, not in the people.
More might be produced, but I content my selfe with these; and though that maxime be received, Salus populi, Suprema lex, yet it hinders not but the people may save themselves, though they be not the first subject of the keyes. Mr. Richardson, whom Dr. Ames and Mr. 1Hooker, honoured much, and follow much, placeth the power of binding, and loosing in the Governours, not in the people.
- 1Manuscr: Tables.
This discourse I have run into by answering to the first Proposal, ⟨p. 81⟩which being the main, I have bestowed more lines about it; the rest I shall run over quickly. Come we now to the second.
This discourse I have runne into by answering to the first Proposall, ⟨p. 81⟩which being the maine, I have bestowed more lines about it; the rest I shall run over quickly. Come we now to the second.
The second Proposal may be this; 1We would have an explicit Covenant in every particular Church, this we judge to be the form of a Church, and we cannot join with a Church without it.
The second Proposall may be this; 1Wee would have an explicite Covenant in every particular Church, this we judge to be the forme of a Church, and we cannot joyne with a Church without it.
- 1The second Proposal. No Congregational Divine dares put the form of a Church in the explicitness of the Covenant, but these do. Survey, pare first, p. 47, 48.The second Proposall. No Congregational Divine dares put the forme of a Church in the explicitenesse of the Covenant, but these doe. Survey, pare first, p. 47, 48.
A. Many people have taken up this by the end, a Covenant is the form of a Church, understanding it of an explicit Covenant, but they know not what a Form is; if they did, they would be more wary then they are. But let us hear what Congregational men say, from whom you take up this word.
A. Many people have taken up this by the end, a Covenant is the forme of a Church, understanding it of an explicite Covenant, but they know not what a Forme is; if they did, they would be more wary then they are. But let us heare what Congregationall men say, from whom you take up this word.
1 Mr. Hooker saith, an implicit Covenant preserves the true nature of the true Church, &c. and an implicit Covenant is, when in their practise they do that, whereby they make themselves engaged to walk in such a society, according to such rules of government, which are exercised amongst them, and so submit themselves thereunto, but do not make any verbal profession thereof. Thus the people in the Parishes in England, when there is a Minister put upon them by the Patron, or Bishop, they constantly hold them to the fellowship of the people in such a place, attend all the Ordinances there used, and the Dispensations of the Minister so imposed upon them, &c. by such actions, they declare that by their practises, which others hold forth by public profession; thus far Mr. Hooker, so Mr. Norton, Resp. ad Apollon. p. 22.28. so the Confession of Church Disc. by the Synod of New England.
1 Mr. Hooker saith, an implicite Covenant preserves the true nature of the true Church, &c. and an implicite Covenant is, when in their practise they doe that, whereby they make themselves ingaged to walke in such a society, according to such rules of government, which are exercised amongst them, and so submit themselves thereunto, but doe not make any verball profession thereof. Thus the people in the Parishes in England, when there is a Minister put upon them by the Patron, or Bishop, they constantly hold them to the fellowship of the people in such a place, attend all the Ordinances there used, and the Dispensations of the Minister so imposed upon them, &c. by such actions, they declare that by their practises, which others hold forth by publick profession; thus farre Mr. Hooker, so Mr. Norton, Resp. ad Apollon. p. 22.28. so the Confession of Church Disc. by the Synod of New England.
2 You have a National Covenant, a solemn one, I think it is strong enough if you observe it well: there is that which answers the Covenants you find made in Scripture.
2 You have a Nationall Covenant, a solemne one, I thinke it is strong enough if you observe it well: there is that which answers the Covenants you finde made in Scripture.
To say, by that we are made a National Church; this were very silly, yet I think there may be so much said for a National Church that will not readily be answered. But suppose the Churches in New England [which God forbid] should decline, &c. If the General Court should make such a Covenant to pass through all the Churches in the Colony, would it make a National Church? they would conceive their Churches still to be Congregational.
To say, by that we are made a Nationall Church; this were very silly, yet I thinke there may be so much said for a Nationall Church that will not readily be answered. But suppose the Churches in New England [which God forbid] should decline, &c. If the Generall Court should make such a Covenant to passe through all the Churches in the Colony, would it make a Nationall Church? they would conceive their Churches still to be Congregationall.
3 I make no doubt but you should have found (if you had but a little patience) that when the Ministers had come to set up Discipline, they would have brought their people under ⟨p. 82⟩some stricter tie, to subject to Church Discipline, I have heard some speak of it; they would have found it too lax, that implicit consent to make people put in execution that, Matth. 118.15, 16, &c. as some have found before them; and it was not without some cause that Apollonius sets down that, as one thing that is required of a Church-Member, and whom they will admit to the Lords Supper, That he shall promise to subject himself to Discipline; he tells us, thus it was concluded upon in several Synods, he mentions fix Synods. I have found the experience of this so already, that I should think my self in a poor case to exercise Discipline without it; the people feel some stricter tie upon their spirits, and I thank God I have known good effects by it.
3 I make no doubt but you should have found (if you had but a little patience) that when the Ministers had come to set up Discipline, they would have brought their people under ⟨p. 82⟩some stricter tye, to subject to Church Discipline, I have heard some speake of it; they would have found it too laxe, that implicite consent to make people put in execution that, Matth. 118.15, 16, &c. as some have found before them; and it was not without some cause that Apollonius sets downe that, as one thing that is required of a Church-Member, and whom they will admit to the Lords Supper, That he shall promise to subject himselfe to Discipline; he tells us, thus it was concluded upon in severall Synods, he mentions fix Synods. I have found the experience of this so already, that I should thinke my selfe in a poore case to exercise Discipline without it; the people feele some stricter tye upon their spirits, and I thanke God I have knowne good effects by it.
4 If you will needs go closer do, you may enter into a close Covenant, as did those worthy Christians in Wethersfield, in that old Prophets days, who sets down their Covenant in his seven Treatises; but they did not separate as you do. Excel those Christians if you can.
4 If you will needs goe closer doe, you may enter into a close Covenant, as did those worthy Christians in Wetherfield, in that old Prophets dayes, who sets downe their Covenant in his seven Treatises; but they did not separate as you doe. Excell those Christians if you can.
A. This were a thing to be wished indeed, and that I believe which the Ministers would be glad, if they could attain it; I gave you instances before out of their Books, and it is that which they would put forth their power to effect, so far as the state of the Kingdom is capable of, if once they were invested with power to exercise Discipline; and indeed as the condition of England stands, there is need of a Civill Power to back them; the case is not now, as in the Primitive times.
A. This were a thing to be wished indeed, and that I beleeve which the Ministers would be glad, if they could attaine it; I gave you instances before out of their Bookes, and it is that which they would put forth their power to effect, so farre as the state of the Kingdome is capable of, if once they were invested with power to exercise Discipline; and indeed as the condition of England stands, there is need of a Civill Power to back them; the case is not now, as in the Primitive times.
2 You must put a difference between Churches new erecting, and these in England, which have been Churches so long; when I raise a house new from the ground, I may then do as I please, but if I be mending of an old house, I must do as well as I can, repair by degrees.
2 You must put a difference between Churches new erecting, and these in England, which have been Churches so long; when I raise a house new from the ground, I may then doe as I please, but if I be mending of an old house, I must doe as well as I can, repaire by degrees.
3 What would you have done with all the rest, Excommunicate them? that's a piece of work indeed; and besides, there is a great deal of work to do before we come to that, it may be many will not be found contumacious; nay you see, they do separate them from the Lords Supper, and divers begin to look something more narrowly to baptism.
3 What would you have done with all the rest, Excommunicate them? that's a peece of work indeed; and besides, there is a great deale of worke to doe before we come to that, it may be many will not be found contumacious; nay you see, they doe separate them from the Lords Supper, and divers begin to looke something more narrowly to baptisme.
4 How many corrupt Members do you find in the Church ⟨p. 83⟩of Corinth and Galatia? for the latter, what a change was there made in their affections towards Paul? 1who close did they cleave to those Judaizing Zealots? who turned them away almost to another Gospel, insomuch that though Paul wished those Seducers were cut off, Gal. 5.12. i. e. by Excommunication, yet he did not peremptorily command it, renitente Ecclesiâ. The Church of Corinth had drunk in vile errors, the women it should seem (disorderly) would speak in the Church; and for Members, 2 Cor. 12.20, 21. you may conceive by the sins there mentioned, what they were many of them, Ch. 13.2. 2Paul indeed saith, he will not spare them. This place Master Gillespie thinks gives light to, Ch. 10. & 6. When your obedience is fulfilled; our Ministers debar such from the Supper.
4 How many corrupt Members doe you finde in the Church ⟨p. 83⟩of Corinth and Galatia? for the latter, what a change was there made in their affections towards Paul? 1who close did they cleave to those Judaizing Zelots? who turned them away almost to another Gospel, insomuch that though Paul wished those Seducers were cut off, Gal. 5.12. i. e. by Excommunication, yet he did not peremptorily command it, renitente Ecclesiâ. The Church of Corinth had drunke in vile errours, the women it should seeme (disorderly) would speake in the Church; and for Members, 2 Cor. 12.20, 21. you may conceive by the sins there mentioned, what they were many of them, Ch. 13.2. 2
5 If you did not thus separate from them, they might do more towards the reforming of their Congregations, but you weaken their hands, as I shall touch hereafter.
5 If you did not thus separate from them, they might doe more towards the reforming of their Congregations, but you weaken their hands, as I shall touch hereafter.
6 But what do you mean by visible Saints, what is required, or how would you judge of one? what, would you have them real Saints? I suppose you do not think so, cross to the texts, the Floor, the Drag-net, &c. what would you have such, as by the exactest scrutiny that can be made, we may judge to be Saints really? I desire your Texts for this. Did the Apostles do thus when they baptised any? surely they must either judge by an Apostolical Spirit, but we see they were mistaken if they did so; or else they must stay a good while and try men, winter them, 1and summer them (as we say) before they did judge of their Saint-ship; but this they did not do, they baptised them quickly; such Members as the Apostles admitted, we may, or else give us texts to the contrary. I have touched this in another Tract, desiring, that those who are for such strictness in Members, would give us their grounds; remember Doctor Ames, Falsum est internas virtutes a nobis requiri, ut aliquis sit in Ecclesiâ quoad visibilem ejus statum.
6 But what doe you meane by visible Saints, what is required, or how would you judge of one? what, would you have them reall Saints? I suppose you doe not thinke so, crosse to the texts, the Floore, the Drag-net, &c. what would you have such, as by the exactest scrutiny that can be made, we may judge to be Saints really? I defire your Texts for this. Did the Apostles doe thus when they baptised any? surely they must either judge by an Apostolicall Spirit, but we see they were mistaken if they did so; or else they must stay a good while and try men, winter them, 1and summer them (as we say) before they did judge of their Saint-ship; but this they did not doe, they baptised them quickly; such Members as the Apostles admitted, we may, or else give us texts to the contrary. I have touched this in another Tract, desiring, that those who are for such strictnesse in Members, would give us their grounds; remember Doctor Ames, Falsum est internas virtutes a nobis requiri, ut aliquis sit in Ecclesiâ quoad visibilem ejus statum.
- 1The Churches after took more time, but they did not come to that exact scrutiny, &c. Bell. ever. to. 2. l. 2. c. 1. s. 5.The Churches after took more time, but they did not come to that exact scrutiny, &c. Bell. ener. to. 2. l. 2. c. 1. s. 5.