Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 13 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Mr. Norton, 1another Congregational man, acute and holy, hath written upon this subject excellently: If the Separatists do understand the Latin tongue, they shall find their practises overthrown and condemned, Rejicimus Separatistas non distinguentes inter ecclesiam, & impuritates ecclesiae, Grave crimen schismatis. I wish we had a few of these Mr. Nortons in England, though he be a man who stands much for the peoples liberty, yet he so ordereth their liberty, that our Ministers would be glad if they had their Churches governed, as is the Church whereof himself, together with Mr. Na. Rogers, are officers; these are Congregational men. 2I will not rehearse what I find in Camero, because he wrote before these times, and will be reckoned for a Presbyterian; four grounds he gives for separation, none of which I am sure our Separatists can allege, 1. Grievous and intolerable persecution. 2. When the Church is Heretical. 3. When Idolatry is set up. 4. When the Church is the seat of Antichrist. I shall conclude with a speech of his, Ut nihil aequè arguit ingenium spiritus Christi, ac studium conservandae societatis & unionis, in quo charitas elucet; sic etiam nullum est evidentius argumentum pravitatis ingenii humani (unde & inter carnis opera contentienes nominantur) quàm tumultuandi & rixandi studium.
Mr. Norton, 1another Congregational man, acute and holy, hath written upon this subject excellently: If the Separatists doe understand the Latine tongue, they shall finde their practises overthrowne and condemned, Rejicimus Separatistas non distinguentes inter ecclesiam, & impuritates ecclesiae, Grave crimen schismatis. I wish we had a few of these Mr. Nortons in England, though he be a man who stands much for the peoples liberty, yet he so ordereth their liberty, that our Ministers would be glad if they had their Churches governed, as is the Church whereof himselfe, together with Mr. Na. Rogers, are officers; these are Congregationall men. 2I will not rehearse what I finde in Camero, because he wrote before these times, and will be reckoned for a Presbyterian; foure grounds he gives for separation, none of which I am sure our Separatists can alleadge, 1. Grievous and intolerable persecution. 2. When the Church is Heretical. 3. When Idolatry is set up. 4. When the Church is the seat of Antichrist. I shall conclude with a speech of his, Ʋt nihil aequè arguit ingenium spiritus Christi, ac studium conservandae societatis & unionis, in quo charitas elucet; sic etiam nullum est evidentius argumentum pravitatis ingenii humani (unde & inter carnis opera contentienes nominantur) quàm tumultuandi & rixandi studium.
Object. But you have spoken against godly men all this while.
Ans. Not against their godliness one word, their schism & errors only I have opposed. But I know not what new Divinity we have got up in these days, that if they be godly men that drink in ⟨p. 99⟩errors, or practise inordinately; Oh, take heed how you speak, they are godly men; there may be an unwise speaking, when men shall only fling out against persons, but confute nothing; but certainly godly men deserve reproof as well as others; I hope the being of a godly man doth not make that to be no sin in him, which is sin in another; but here is the subtlety of Satan, and it was all the game he had to play in those times, I must now, saith he, get into an Angel of light, and I must work among these godly professors, 1if I can get some of those away, I shall get other hollow ones to cleave to them, and make a party: If I now make not a division among them, but that they join all with one shoulder to set up Christs Kingdom, and thrust down mine, it will go hard with my kingdom; now therefore, find fault with the Ordination of Ministers, it was Popish, so separate from them; plead conscience, that is a tender piece; strive for exact purity (though it be beyond the rule as to visible Church-fellowship,) and thus he hath found out his ways to damp all the work of Reformation.
Ans. Not against their godlinesse one word, their schisme & errors only I have opposed. But I know not what new Divinity we have got up in these dayes, that if they be godly men that drinke in ⟨p. 99⟩errours, or practise inordinately; Oh, take heed how you speake, they are godly men; there may be an unwise speaking, when men shall onely fling out against persons, but confute nothing; but certainly godly men deserve reproofe as well as others; I hope the being of a godly man doth not make that to be no sinne in him, which is sinne in another; but here is the subtilty of Satan, and it was all the game he had to play in those times, I must now, saith he, get into an Angel of light, and I must worke among these godly professors, 1if I can get some of those away, I shall get other hollow ones to cleave to them, and make a party: If I now make not a division among them, but that they joyne all with one shoulder to set up Christs Kingdome, and thrust down mine, it will go hard with my kingdome; now therefore, finde fault with the Ordination of Ministers, it was Popish, so separate from them; plead conscience, that is a tender peece; strive for exact purity (though it be beyond the rule as to visible Church-fellowship,) and thus he hath found out his wayes to damp all the worke of Reformation.
I shall say no more but this, though some of these Separatists are godly men, yet if godly men stand thus as now we do, I believe God will not spare us, though we be godly men, but he will ere long bring such plagues upon the professing party in England, as shall make their hearts ache. For my part, I look on England thus, there have been choice servants of God in England, who laboured under the Hierarchical oppression, many strong cries have they made for the removal of that burden, and that they might enjoy him in his own Ordinances, without the mixtures of mens inventions; God hath given us in the answer of those prayers, as to the removing of what offended: and now saith God, look you to it, ye Professors, I give the power (which never your Fathers saw) into the hands of the Puritanical *party, let me now see how you will improve it for the advancement of my Church and glory; but verily if we improve it no better then now we do, we must look that God will not intrust us with this power long (he doth not use to stay long before he visits his Churches) but quickly deprive us of this liberty, and Lord if thou doest, thou shalt be just.
I shall say no more but this, though some of these Separatists are godly men, yet if godly men stand thus as now we do, I beleeve God will not spare us, though we be godly men, but he will ere long bring such plagues upon the professing party in England, as shall make their hearts ake. For my part, I look on England thus, there have been choice servants of God in England, who laboured under the Hierarchicall oppression, many strong cryes have they made for the removall of that burden, and that they might enjoy him in his owne Ordinances, without the mixtures of mens inventions; God hath given us in the answer of those prayers, as to the removing of what offended: and now saith God, looke you to it, yee Professors, I give the power (which never your Fathers saw) into the hands of the Puritanicall *party, let me now see how you will improve it for the advancement of my Church and glory; but verily if we improve it no better then now we do, we must look that God will not intrust us with this power long (he doth not use to stay long before he visits his Churches) but quickly deprive us of this liberty, and Lord if thou doest, thou shalt be just.
- *The old scoff.
Having done with the Separatists, I shall now take a short view of the agreements and differences that are with, and between the Classical and Congregational Divines, and then ⟨p. 100⟩shall make bold to present an humble request to the Congregational Divines.
1. Do the Classical-brethren stand for all the Ordinances of Christ, as Praying, Preaching, Sacraments, Discipline, &c? so do the Congregational-brethren.
1. Do the Classical-brethren stand for all the Ordinances of Christ, as Praying, Preaching, Sacraments, Discipline, &c? so doe the Congregational-brethren.
2. Do the Classical-brethren stand for Christs officers, Pastors, sach errs, Ruling-elders, Deacons, allowing such, and only such? o do the Congregational-brethren. They agree in worship and in officers.
2. Do the Classical-brethren stand for Christs officers, Pastors, sach ers, Ruling-elders, Deacons, allowing such, and onely such? o doe the Congregational-brethren. They agree in worship and in officers.
3. Do the Classical-brethren hold to the old doctrines of Faith, Repentance, holding up the preaching of the Law in its method, to prepare before faith, to guide after faith? so do the Congregational-brethren, such as we look upon as sound, and esteem worth the regarding.
3. Do the Classical-brethren hold to the old doctrines of Faith, Repentanee, holding up the preaching of the Law in its method, to prepare before faith, to guide after faith? so do the Congregational-brethren, such as we looke upon as sound, and esteem worth the regarding.
4. Do the Classical-brethren hold the government of the Church to be Presbyterial? so do the Congregational-men, such as are the most acute. Besides what Mr. Norton (none of the lowest rank) hath asserted in his book which I quoted before, I have heard him say, That if the Congregational-government did make the government of the Church democratical, he would give up the cause.
4. Do the Classical-brethren hold the government of the Church to be Presbyterial? so do the Congregational-men, such as are the most acute. Besides what Mr. Norton (none of the lowest ranke) hath asserted in his book which I quoted before, I have heard him say, That if the Congregational-government did make the government of the Church democratical, he would give up the cause.
For my part, I am but among the weakest of Gods Ministers, but yet I think it were no hard matter to prove the government of the Church to be Aristocratical: I enter not now into the debating of the question, but this hath much stuck with me.
For my part, I am but among the weakest of Gods Ministers, but yet I thinke it were no hard matter to prove the government of the Church to be Aristocratical: I enter not now into the debating of the question, but this hath much stucke with me.
First, there is government in the Church, I mean an external polity, besides an internal government of the Spirit, what ever our fantastical Spiritualists have dreamed of; the Scripture is too plain against these.
First, there is government in the Church, I meane an externall politie, besides an internall government of the Spirit, what ever our phantastical Spiritualists have dreamed of; the Scripture is too plain against these.
Secondly, then there are governors and governed; this must needs be yielded, else government cannot be; for governors there are, none that are sound in their wits can deny, if they own the Scriptures.
Secondly, then there are governours and governed; this must needs be yeelded, else government cannot be; for governours there are, none that are sound in their wits can deny, if they owne the Scriptures.
Thirdly, the affairs then of the Church must be so carried, that these Relates may be kept distinct: for that government which destroys these, by making the Correlate, i. the body governed, to be governor (and so there are none governed) cannot possibly be, a government standing so much with the light of nature. There is no government, if all rule.
Thirdly, the affaires then of the Church must be so carried, that these Relates may be kept distinct: for that government which destroys these, by making the Correlate, i. the body governed, to be governour (and so there are none governed) cannot possibly be, a government standing so much with the light of nature. There is no government, if all rule.
Obj. But how can the government of the Church be Aristocratical, when as you carry things by the suffrage of the people?
Obj. But how can the government of the Church be Aristocraticall, when as you carry things by the suffrage of the people?
Answ. I should desire also to propound these questions.
First, would you not, if now Churches were constituting, give the people this liberty, that if any could bring in good testimony against a man, who was to be received into the Church, that they should do it, and if the thing be proved, will not you refuse to admit such a one?
First, would you not, if now Churches were constituting, give the people this liberty, that if any could bring in good testimony against a man, who was to bee received into the Church, that they should do it, and if the thing be proved, will not you refuse to admit such a one?
Secondly, if it now come to casting out of a member, will not you give liberty to any of the brethren, who shall (first asking you leave to speak) in a sober, grave way, propound some question to the clearing of the case in hand, before the people join with you in cutting off a member, I say, would not you give this liberty?
Secondly, if it now come to casting out of a member, will not you give liberty to any of the brethren, who shall (first asking you leave to speak) in a sober, grave way, propound some question to the clearing of the case in hand, before the people joyn with you in cutting off a member, I say, would not you give this liberty?
Thirdly, will you excommunicate renitente ecclesiâ? your books say otherwise, and you know what both our Ancient and Modern Divines have affirmed in this point, and therefore I quote none.
Thirdly, will you excommunicate renitente ecclesiâ? your books say otherwise, and you know what both our Ancient and Moderne Divines have affirmed in this point, and therefore I quote none.
I do not mention election to be given to the people, for that hath nothing of government in it, and this you give fully; but if you grant me the three former heads, then which way you will prove the government to be Aristocratical, the same way I shall. I have spoken to this before, and therefore conclude with Chamies, and others, the government is Aristocratical.
I do not mention election to be given to the people, for that hath nothing of government in it, and this you give fully; but if you grant me the three former heads, then which way you will prove the government to be Aristocraticall, the same way I shall. I have spoken to this before, and therefore conclude with Chamies, and others, the government is Aristocraticall.
Obj. But how can this be, if the people will not consent, how are they governed?
Answ. Put case Jonathan had been indeed a great malefactor, and Saul would have had him legally and justly put to death, but the people would not consent to their King, but rescue Jonathan, shall we hence conclude, ergo the government of Israel is not Monarchical? the case is the same here.
Answ. Put case Jonathan had been indeed a great malefactor, and Saul would have had him legally and justly put to death, but the people would not consent to their King, but rescue Jonathan, shall we hence conclude, ergo the government of Israel is not Monarchicall? the case is the same here.
Now I am upon this head, I shall desire to make a little digression, before I proceed to any more heads. Mr. Edwards in a Sermon at Colchester laid down this Thesis.
That there was no such tyrannical government in any Church (unless it were in the Church of Rome) as is in the Independent Churches; he proved it thus, They carry all things by the suffrage of the people, and if all do not consent, they will censure them; how he will prove this? a special example, in the Church of Boston in New England, when ⟨p. 102⟩they excommunicated Mrs. Hutchison; because her own son did not join in the casting out of his own mother, he was likewise censured; an unnatural thing, said he, and so carried it, that both his own friends, and other Ministers, who were strangers, thought he was also excommunicated, as they told me when I spake with them.
That there was no such tyrannicall government in any Church (unlesse it were in the Church of Rome) as is in the Independent Churches; he proved it thus, They carry all things by the suffrage of the people, and if all doe not consent, they will censure them; how he will prove this? a speciall example, in the Church of Boston in New England, when ⟨p. 102⟩they excommunicated Mrs. Hutchison; because her owne sonne did not joyne in the casting out of his owne mother, he was likewise censured; an unnaturall thing, said he, and so carried it, that both his owne friends, and other Ministers, who were strangers, thought he was also excommunicated, as they told me when I spake with them.
The story doth something concern the head I am upon, and therefore I make bold to insert it here. I was a little troubled at the passage, knowing well how things were carried, being present at that time, and so took occasion some few weeks after, to give a bare narrative how the thing was carried with so much meekness, I am sure as none could accuse me. The sum is this, When all ways according to the word had been tried with Mrs. Hutchison to recall her, but none would prevail, the question was put to the Church to manifest consent for her excommunication; her son and son-in-law (one more then Mr. Edwards mentioned) stood up to put some stop in the way (had they sate still, as any body would have expected, though they had suspended their votes, I know not who would have spoken one word to them) Mr. Cotton rose up, and gave them a grave admonition, that though their natural affection might now work, for which he did not blame them, yet he would not have them prefer their mother before Christ, nor hinder their mother from that Ordinance, which might be a means to save her soul; with these words they both sate down: they never had any other censure (if this be a censure) and the Church proceeded in her excommunication. Now I appeal unto all, to judge where was the tyranny in this act? yet though I carried this with all mildness, this was the only cause why Mr. Edwards raked up all he could against me, and put it into print, even such things as never were in my thoughts. But here you may see, they stand not upon the suffrage of all the people.
The story doth something concerne the head I am upon, and therefore I make bold to insert it here. I was a little troubled at the passage, knowing well how things were carried, being present at that time, and so tooke occasion some few weeks after, to give a bare narrative how the thing was carried with so much meeknesse, I am sure as none could accuse me. The summe is this, When all wayes according to the word had beene tryed with Mrs. Hutchison to recall her, but none would prevaile, the question was put to the Church to manifest consent for her excommunication; her sonne and sonne-in-law (one more then Mr. Edwards mentioned) stood up to put some stop in the way (had they sate still, as any body would have expected, though they had suspended their votes, I know not who would have spoken one word to them) Mr. Cotton rose up, and gave them a grave admonition, that though their naturall affection might now worke, for which hee did not blame them, yet he would not have them preferre their mother before Christ, nor hinder their mother from that Ordinance, which might bee a meanes to save her soule; with these words they both sate downe: they never had any other censure (if this be a censure) and the Church proceeded in her excommunication. Now I appeale unto all, to judge where was the tyranny in this act? yet though I carried this with all mildnesse, this was the onely cause why Mr. Edwards raked up all he could against me, and put it into print, even such things as never were in my thoughts. But here you may see, they stand not upon the suffrage of all the people.
Fifthly, do the Classical-men call for Synods? so do the Congregational-men, Mr. Cotton, Keys c. 6. Mr. Norton, Respon. ad Apollon. p. 112. &c.
Fifthly, doe the Classical-men call for Synods? so do the Congregational-men, Mr. Cotton, Keyes c. 6. Mr. Norton, Respon. ad Apollon. p. 112. &c.
And certainly they are men of strange spirits, who deny Synods to be useful, and no Ordinance of God: I doubt he did not well consider what his pen let drop, and left it to posterity, That he never saw any good that came by any Synod, but rather ⟨p. 103⟩the contrary. A great Clerk indeed he was, but surely the man was in some passion; I am sure I have known the contrary, much good come by Synods; but some of our Independents snutch up this sentence of his, as if it were Apostolical. This is the difference, say the Congregational-men, the Synod bindes directivè, non juridicè, the Classical will have both.
And certainly they are men of strange spirits, who deny Synods to be usefull, and no Ordinance of God: I doubt he did not well consider what his pen let drop, and left it to posterity, That he never saw any good that came by any Synod, but rather ⟨p. 103⟩the contrary. A great Clerke indeed he was, but surely the man was in some passion; I am sure I have knowne the contrary, much good come by Synods; but some of our Independents snutch up this sentence of his, as if it were Apostolical. This is the difference, say the Congregational-men, the Synod bindes directivè, non juridicè, the Classical will have both.
When I observe what both sides speak of Synods, methinks this can be no such matter of difference.
The Classical Brethren say, 1All the determinations even of National Synods are to be obeyed no further, then they agree with the word of God; and that a Synod est judex judicandus; That Congregations are to examine with the judgment of discretion, what is sent to them from Synods.
The Classical Brethren say, 1All the determinations even of Nationall Synods are to be obeyed no further, then they agree with the word of God; and that a Synod est judex judicandus; That Congregations are to examine with the judgment of discretion, what is sent to them from Synods.
- 1Lond. Vind. p. 23
Mr. Rutherford saith, 1The Acts of the Assembly oblige all the absents, not present in all their members, not because of the Authority of the Church, but because of the matter, which is necessary and agreeable to Gods word.
- 1Peac. plea. p. 322.
That people may not examine decrees of their Synods according to Gods word: That people may not reason or speak in their Synods, 1we acknowledge no such Synods. This latter needs a little fencing, otherwise we should have confusion enough; our Churches in New England chose out of every Church, two of the ablest of the private brethren, and sent them as their messengers, these indeed had liberty to speak and propound doubts in the Synod, but it was not left free for any body to speak, that would.
That people may not examine decrees of their Synods according to Gods word: That people may not reason or speake in their Synods, 1we acknowledge no such Synods. This latter needs a little fencing, otherwise we should have confusion enough; our Churches in New England chose out of every Church, two of the ablest of the private brethren, and sent them as their messengers, these indeed had liberty to speake and propound doubts in the Synod, but it was not left free for any body to speake, that would.
- 1Ib. p. 246.
Mr. Gillespie states a question; Suppose a scandalous person would come to the Sacrament, 1the Minister knowing him to be so, adviseth the Eldership to join with him, and do their duty in keeping this person away, it may be they refuse; Appeal is made to higher Assemblies, Classis, Synod, &c. they it may be will judge him fit for the Sacrament, this is their sentence, must this Minister now obey the sentence of the Classis or Synod? His determination is, That the Minister being clear in his conscience, and the matter of scandal sufficiently proved, he must not do an unlawful act in obedience to men, but follow the rule, 1 Tim. 5.22. Keep thy self pure, his conscience illuminated by Gods word is a rule to him of his own personal acting, or not acting.
Mr. Gillespie states a question; Suppose a scandalous person would come to the Sacrament, 1the Minister knowing him to be so, adviseth the Eldership to joyne with him, and do their duty in keeping this person away, it may be they refuse; Appeale is made to higher Assemblies, Classis, Synod, &c. they it may be will judge him fit for the Sacrament, this is their sentence, must this Minister now obey the sentence of the Classis or Synod? His determination is, That the Minister being cleare in his conscience, and the matter of scandal sufficiently proved, he must not doe an unlawfull act in obedience to men, but follow the rule, 1 Tim. 5.22. Keep thy selfe pure, his conscience illuminated by Gods word is a rule to him of his owne personal acting, or not acting.
- 1Aar. rod. 477, 478.
Come to the Congregational-men, Mr. Cotton saith, 1We dare not ⟨p. 104⟩say that the power of a Synod reaches no further then the giving counsel, they bind burdens, they bind not only materially, but formally, from the Authority of the Synod, See more, p. 53, 54.
Come to the Congregational-men, Mr. Cotton saith, 1We dare not ⟨p. 104⟩say that the power of a Synod reaches no further then the giving connsell, they bind burthens, they bind not onely materially, but formally, from the Authority of the Synod, See more, p. 53, 54.
- 1Keys p. 25
Neither do I see, that our reverend Divines in their preface to that book do oppose Mr. Cotton; for say they [in laying down Mr. Cottons judgement] Christ hath not furnished them only with ability to give Counsel, but with a Ministerial power and Authority, to determine, declare, and enjoin such things, as may tend to reducing such Congregations to right order and peace. But is there Authority? it may be my shallowness; but for the present I do not call to mind any power invested with Authority, but if they enjoin a thing to be done, and it be refused, that Authority will reach further. Authoritas cogit, as is the kind of the Authority, Civill or Ecclesiastical.
Neither doe I see, that our reverend Divines in their preface to that book do oppose Mr. Cotton; for say they [in laying down Mr. Cottons judgement] Christ hath not furnished them only with ability to give Counsell, but with a Ministeriall power and Authority, to determine, declare, and injoyn such things, as may tend to reducing such Congregations to right order and peace. But is there Authority? it may be my shallownesse; but for the present I doe not call to mind any power invested with Authority, but if they injoyne a thing to bee done, and it be refused, that Authority will reach further. Authoritas cogit, as is the kind of the Authority, Civill or Ecclesiasticall.
Blessed Burroughs [in answering to that which some would have, 1scil, that a Synod may formally excommunicate, because by excommunication, they (i.e. Heretical Churches) are put out of the Kingdom of Christ, into the Kingdom of Satan, and this will terrify] saith, consider whether this be not done before, and that with an authority of Christ, by those former six things (mentioned in the page before) for Heretical Congregations, or persons are judged, and declared in a solemn Ordinance, by the Officers of Christ gathered together in his name, to be such as have no right to any Church Ordinance, to have no Communion with any of the Churches of Christ; now if this judgement be right, are not such persons or Congregations put out of the Kingdom of Christ, and put under the power of Satan, consequently?
Blessed Burroughs [in answering to that which some would have, 1scil, that a Synod may formally excommunicate, because by excommunication, they (i.e. Hereticall Churches) are put out of the Kingdome of Christ, into the Kingdome of Satan, and this will terrifie] saith, consider whether this be not done before, and that with an authority of Christ, by those former six things (mentioned in the page before) for Hereticall Congregations, or persons are judged, and declared in a solemn Ordinance, by the Officers of Christ gathered together in his name, to be such as have no right to any Church Ordinance, to have no Communion with any of the Churches of Christ; now if this judgement be right, are not such persons or Congregations put out of the Kingdome of Christ, and put under the power of Satan, consequently?
- 1Iren. p. 44.
Certainly, this cannot be a ground of such difference, shall Non and Ex make such a stir, when Non is as bad as Ex? I should judge my self, I am sure, to be in as bad a case by the one, as the other, though for my part this notion of Catholic-visible-Church, hath made me ready to yield to Synods juridical power; I could I say yield it, and yet not differ from these reverend Divines, if they follow home their non-communion close.
Certainly, this cannot be a ground of such difference, shall Non and Ex make such a stir, when Non is as bad as Ex? I should judge my self, I am sure, to be in as bad a case by the one, as the other, though for my part this notion of Catholike-visible-Church, hath made me ready to yeeld to Synods juridicall power; I could I say yeeld it, and yet not differ from these reverend Divines, if they follow home their non-communion close.
Now if you say, what doth this help against Heretical Congregations, though you have proceeded to Non-communion, they regard it not, but still go on in their Heresies, and leaven others? to that they will say, what do they care for your excommunication, if all the Heretics in England were excommunicated, they would not care, but go on still. Indeed our New England Divines will teach us a way how to help it, viz. if a Synod hath declared against an Heretical Congregation, ⟨p. 105⟩being pertinacious, and so hath proceeded to non-communion, they will call in the Civil power to help, and so they have a way to help by their non-communion, and this must be the help of them though they be excommunicated.
Now if you say, what doth this helpe against Hereticall Congregations, though you have proceeded to Non-communion, they regard it not, but still go on in their Heresies, and leaven others? to that they wil say, what do they care for your excommunication, if all the Hereticks in England were excommunicated, they would not care, but go on still. Indeed our New England Divines will teach us a way how to helpe it, viz. if a Synod hath declared against an Hereticall Congregation, ⟨p. 105⟩being pertinacious, and so hath proceeded to non-communion, they will call in the Civil power to help, and so they have a way to help by their non-communion, and this must be the help of them though they be excommunicated.
This Mr. Norton intimates, 1Ecclesiae appellant Magistratum in causis Ecclesiae non ad doctrinam declarandam, vel disciplinam exequendam, sed ad doctrinam a Cencilio declaratam, vel disciplinam ab ecclesiâ applicatam sanction Civili confirmandam. The duty which Mr. Cotton showeth to lye upon the Civill Magistrate infers as much. As also Mr. Burroughs. And thus it was in New England; when the Synod (at which the Civill Power was present, as to hear, so to keep civill order) had confuted and condemned the Errors and Heresies, and so was broke up, then a General Court was called, which soon suppressed those Heresies, and brought the Churches to peace again.
This Mr. Norton intimates, 1Ecclesiae appellant Magistratum in causis Ecclesiae non ad doctrinam declarandam, vel disciplinam exequendam, sed ad doctrinam a Cencilio declaratam, vel disciplinam ab ecclesiâ applicatam sanctione Civili confirmandam. The dury which Mr. Cotton sheweth to lye upon the Civill Magistrate inferres as much. As also Mr. Burroughs. And thus it was in New England; when the Synod (at which the Civill Power was present, as to hear, so to keep civill order) had consuted and condemned the Errors and Heresies, and so was broke up, then a Generall Court was called, which soon suppressed those Heresies, and brought the Churches to peace again.
- 1Resp, ad Apol. 148 Keys 50 Iren. c. 4. Mr. Marshal relates, that Zuinglius in a public dispute did so stop the mouths of the Anabaptist; that they appearing to the Magistrates unreasonably obstinate, were banish d the City, Defen. ag. Tomb. 58.Resp, ad Apol. 148 Keyes 50 Iren. c. 4. Mr. Marshal relates, that Zuinglius in a publick dispute did so stop the mouthes of the Anabaptist; that they appearing to the Magistrates unreasonably obstinate, were banish d the City, Defen. ag. Tomb. 58.
If the Civill power would do as much here, we should soon see our Churches in better order. What Civill Magistrates have done in this ease before, I need not mention, books are full. Its true, the Churches were, when there was no Civill Power to defend them, but oppose them; but we can find how many Heresies and Schisms they were then troubled with; shall the Church be in no better case under a Christian Civill Power, Nursing-Fathers, then at that time?
If the Civill power would do as much here, we should soon see our Churches in better order. What Civill Magistrates have done in this ease before, I need not mention, books are full. Its true, the Churches were, when there was no Civill Power to defend them, but oppose them; but we can finde how many Heresies and Schismes they were then troubled with; shall the Church be in no better case under a Christian Civill Power, Nursing-Fathers, then at that time?
6 Do the Classical godly men look upon their Congregations, having visible Saints among them, to be true visible Churches? so do the Congregational men judge them also. I gave instance before.
6 Doe the Classicall godly men looke upon their Congregations, having visible Saints among them, to be true visible Churches? so doe the Congregationall men judge them also. I gave instance before.
7 Would then the Classical brethren, have their members (being such as have right to the Ordinance) to partake with Congregational Churches in the Lords Supper to show their communion? certainly so they ought; but why Congregational men do refuse godly men, members of Classical Churches, not admitting them to the Lords Supper, when they have desired it, is very strange to me; I wish our reverend Brethren would give us solid grounds for this practice, for it gives offence, and that justly. aMr. Hooker, and bMr. Burroughs have both said they should be admitted: Shall a Church be acknowledged to be a true Church, where Doctrine and Worship is pure also, this person a member of it, a visible Saint (it may be a real Saint) and shall he be denied communion?
7 Would then the Classical brethren, have their members (being such as have right to the Ordinance) to partake with Congregational Churches in the Lords Supper to shew their communion? certainly so they ought; but why Congegationall men doe refuse godly men, members of Classicall Churches, not admitting them to the Lords Supper, when they have desired it, is very strange to me; I wish our reverend Brethren would give us solid grounds for this practice, for it gives offence, and that justly. aMr. Hooker, and bMr. Burroughs have both said they should be admitted: Shal a Church be acknowledged to be a true Church, where Doctrine and Worship is pure also, this person a member of it, a visible Saint (it may be a real Saint) and shall he be denyed communion?
- aPreface to survey ch. dis.
- bIren. p. 266.