Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 14 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
8 For Classes, 1the Congregational men say Consociation of Churches is not only lawful, but in some cases necessary. So Mr. Hooker. ⟨p. 106⟩Mr. Cotton speaks fully to this, Keys p. 54, 55. weighty matters such as, Election and ordination of Elders, excommunication of an Elder, or any person of public note, the translation of an Elder from one Church to another, it is an holy Ordinance to proceed with common consultation and consent. I suppose thus much might have been obtained of the Classical-brethren, that though in cases of weight, as excommunication, they would not have such an Ordinance carried on by one Minister, but have the thing seriously examined first, and debated in a Classis, yet when the thing had been concluded upon, they would leave the execution of the sentence to the officer, or officers of the Church, where the case lieth. If so much might be obtained, I should be very far from opposing a Classis, I would not willingly live without one.
8 For Classes, 1the Congregationall men say Consociation of Churches is not onely lawfull, but in some cases necessary. So Mr. Hooker. ⟨p. 106⟩Mr. Cotton speakes fully to this, Keyes p. 54, 55. weighty matters such as, Election and ordination of Elders, excommunication of an Elder, or any person of publike note, the translation of an Elder from one Church to another, it is an holy Ordinance to proceed with common consultation and consent. I suppose thus much might have beene obtained of the Classical-brethren, that though in cases of weight, as excommunication, they would not have such an Ordinance carried on by one Minister, but have the thing seriously examined first, and debated in a Classis, yet when the thing had beene concluded upon, they would leave the execution of the sentence to the officer, or officers of the Church, where the case lyeth. If so much might be obtained, I should be very farre from opposing a Classis, I would not willingly live without one.
- 1Pref. surv. ch. dis.
I know of no other material point of difference, as for the first subject of the power of the Keys, that is but a notion, though its true, much practise depends upon it, yet I find not that our Divines here would have the fraternity to be the first subject, by their owning of Mr. Cotton his book of the Keys; for Mr. Cotton makes a Church organized to be the first subject, and not the Fraternity, as is apparent in divers places of that book.
I know of no other material point of difference, as for the first subject of the power of the Keyes, that is but a notion, though its true, much practise depends upon it, yet I finde not that our Divines here would have the fraternity to be the first subject, by their owning of Mr. Cotton his booke of the Keyes; for Mr. Cotton makes a Church organized to bee the first subject, and not the Fraternity, as is apparent in divers places of that booke.
The sum is, I wonder at our differences, well might that worthy Divine say in his letter to me from New England, Its the wonderment of this side of the world, that you that are godly, and may agree, yet will not! surely the cause lieth more in the Will, then any thing else. Give me leave therefore I pray, to make my humble request to our Reverend Divines, the Congregational-men, that they would please to close in with the Classical brethren, and not suffer these groundless differences to trouble the Churches any longer. If you ask, Why do you make your request to us, are we the cause why they are not bealed? I cannot think the cause lies only in the Ministers; nay I have heard long since there had been an agreement among the Ministers, had not some others that live by divisions, broken it; but whether all Ministers are of the same mind I know not: nay, I have observed the spirits of some Congregational-Ministers carried with more eagerness against the Classical-brethren, then è converso, and I am sure, if there be any blame among the Ministers, it is charged most upon the Congregational-men, whether justly or no, it concerns ⟨p. 107⟩you to clear your selves: Besides, at this time the Civill power most smiles upon you, and now it is a good time to show you seek the peace and flourishing of all Churches, by joining with your fellow-brethren, and not to be content though your Interest be safe, unless the whole may have comfort as well as your selves; for you cannot but judge that there are more true visible Churches, then those which are called Independent Churches, and that there be others that are true Ministers, besides the Independent Ministers; why then should not the comfort of these Churches and Ministers be sought? which cannot be, unless your selves be pleased to declare against these errors and schisms of the times, and fall in with these Ministers to carry on the work of Christ together. Let me, I beseech you, present to your view a few things to be considered.
The summe is, I wonder at our differnces, well might that worthy Divine say in his letter to me from New England, Its the wonderment of this side of the world, that you that are godly, and may agree, yet will not! surely the cause lyeth more in the Will, then any thing else. Give me leave therefore I pray, to make my humble request to our Reverend Divines, the Congregational-men, that they would please to close in with the Classical brethren, and not suffer these groundlesse differences to trouble the Churches any longer. If you aske, Why doe you make your request to us, are we the cause why they are not bealed? I cannot thinke the cause lyes onely in the Ministers; nay I have heard long since there had been an agreement among the Ministers, had not some others that live by divisions, broken it; but whether all Ministers are of the same minde I know not: nay, I have observed the spirits of some Congregational-Ministers carried with more eagernesse against the Classical-brethren, then è converso, and I am sure, if there be any blame among the Ministers, it is charged most upon the Congregational-men, whether justly or no, it concernes
First, the Classical men have bid very fair for peace and agreement with you; hear their words, 1We do here manifest our willingness to accommodate with you according to the word in a way of union; and (such of us as are Ministers) to preach up and to practise a mutual forbearance and toleration in all things, that may consist with the fundamentals of Religion [what need then any other Toleration?] with the power of godliness, and with that peace, which Christ hath established in his Church; but to make ruptures in the body of Christ, and to divide Church from Church, &c. there is no warrant for this out of the word. The page before this, they offer as much as this, and speak so Christianly and ingenuously, that it must needs move any Christian heart that loves the peace and prosperity of the Churches, to meet them half way, and not suffer any differences more to appear.
First, the Classical men have bid very faire for peace and agreement with you; heare their words, 1We doe here manifest our willingnesse te accommodate with you according to the word in a way of union; and (such of us as are Ministers) to preach up and to practise a mutuall forbearance and toleration in all things, that may consist with the sundamentals of Religion [what need then any other Toleration?] with the power of godlinesse, and with that peace, which Christ hath established in his Church; but to make ruptures in the body of Christ, and to divide Church from Church, &c. there is no warrant for this out of the word. The page before this, they offer as much as this, and speake so Christianly and ingenuously, that it must needs move any Christian heart that loves the peace and prosperity of the Churches, to meet them halfe way, and not suffer any differences more to appeare.
- 1Lond. in Vind. p. 120. 121.
As for that exception they make, the ruptures of Churches, I think it to be a very just exception; that golden rule hath place here, ut tibi, sic aliis, would any of us be content to have other Ministers take from us the best of our people that have chosen us before, and owned us for their officers? say what you please, you are men, and I know it would be a strong temptation, when as for want of these, also their hands are weakened in the carrying on of Reformation in their Churches.
As for that exception they make, the ruptures of Churches, I thinke it to be a very just exception; that golden rule hath place here, ut tibi, sic aliis, would any of us be content to have other Ministers take from us the best of our people that have chosen us before, and owned us for their officers? say what you please, you are men, and I know it would be a strong temptation, when as for want of these, also their hands are weakned in the carrying on of Reformation in their Churches.
If you take away the best (who are the joy of a Minister) take away the worst also. If you live near a place where there is no Minister, and take in such Christians to you as the place affords, ⟨p. 108⟩and return them when the place is furnished: or if there be a Minister, and but few Christians, so that he cannot give the Lords Supper with comfort, if he and his people will join with you they may, none oppose this; but when a godly Minister hath visible Saints sufficient in his Parish, to have these taken from him, is such a thing which I would not have offered to me, therefore I would not offer the same to another. I know where the pinch lies, on the Ministers part, Our maintenance ariseth from the members, &c. but for this the State hath provided an answer (and certainly it is a great mercy) reform you in the place where you live, take none but Scripture-visible-Saints to the Sacraments, catechize, and do what you can to reform the rest, the State hath provided for your maintenance, none shall keep it from you, as well as the word gives it you, Gal. 6. Let him that is taught in the word communicate to him that teacheth in all good things. Christ sent Paul not to baptize, but to preach the Gospel, 1 Cor. 1.17. preaching is the spending work, and the chief, of this all the Parish are partakers, I am ready to dispense the Seals to all visible Saints, therefore I know no scruple why I should not receive from all, since all receive from me.
If you take away the best (who are the joy of a Minister) take away the worst also. If you live neare a place where there is no Minister, and take in such Christians to you as the place affords, ⟨p. 108⟩and returne them when the place is furnished: or if there be a Minister, and but few Christians, so that he cannot give the Lords Supper with comfort, if he and his people will joyne with you they may, none oppose this; but when a godly Minister hath visible Saints sufficient in his Parish, to have these taken from him, is such a thing which I would not have offered to me, therefore I would not offer the same to another. I know where the pinch lyes, on the Ministers part, Our maintenance ariseth from the members, &c. but for this the State hath provided an answer (and certainly it is a great mercy) reforme you in the place where you live, take none but Scriputre-visible-Saints to the Sacraments, catechize, and doe what you can to reforme the rest, the State hath provided for your maintenance, none shall keepe it from you, as well as the word gives it you,
O but your members will not be content with this. I know not but your members may find God in a godly reformed Classical Church, we see the differences are very small; but suppose the worst, let then your members remove into the Parishes where you live, and this is no offence to any; if they say, It will something hinder their estate: Mr. Burroughs will tell them then they love their bodies better then their souls, 1if they look upon things very much concerning their soul, and will not buy them with some abatement of their profit: could this have been once enjoyed, New England sufferers had not been there now; Though Parishes are not Churches, yet Ministers care must be bounded some where. I presume you are willing to close, so that you may not sin.
O but your members will not be content with this. I know not but your members may finde God in a godly reformed Classicall Church, we see the differences are very small; but suppose the worst, let then your members remove into the Parishes where you live, and this is no offence to any; if they say, It will something hinder their estate: Mr. Burroughs wil tel them then they love their bodies better then their soules, 1if they looke upon things very much concerning their soul, and will not buy them with some abatement of their profit: could this have beene once enjoyed, New England sufferers had not been there now; Though Parishes are not Churches, yet Ministers care must be bounded some where. I presume you are willing to close, so that you may not sin.
- 1Expos. Hos. c. 2. v. 1.2. p. 225.
I beseech you first, what sin is it to let a godly Classical man enjoy his own members?
I beseech you first, what sinne is it to let a godly Classicall man enjoy his owne members?
Secondly, What sin is it to admit a visible Saint, and member of a Classical Church to communion with you?
Secondly, What sinne is it to admit a visible Saint, and member of a Classical Church to communion with you?
Thirdly, what sin is it to declare against the errors and schisms of the times? you see it is the thoughts of the New England Divines, that through our too much connivance at these, this inundation of errors is like to destroy all. If these ⟨p. 109⟩three be but yielded, I believe you may live and enjoy your liberty of conscience, and no man will trouble you.
Thirdly, what sinne is it to declare against the errours and schismes of the times? you see it is the thoughts of the New England Divines, that through our too much connivence at these, this inundation of errours is like to destroy all. If these ⟨p. 109⟩three be but yeelded, I beleeve you may live and enjoy your liberty of conscience, and no man will trouble you.
2. A second consideration is this, you see those who call for agreement, they are no babes, they are men, holy, learned, excellently gifted, and the arguments they give for their Classical form of government are not slight, but such as deserve strong heads to answer; it may be my shallowness, but truly I cannot yet see some things they plead for to be clearly answered, as their arguments for the Catholic-Church-visible; their arguments for their Presbyterial Church, from the Church of Jerusalem, Corinth, &c. yet I have read the answers with a kind of prejudice against the Classical way, being before engaged in the Congregational-way, and usually then men are apt to make a little serve the turn: But I cannot yet be satisfied, and that such a Church as is in this small village where I live, should have equal power with the Church of Corinth, and be exempted from all other power, though (which God forbid) we should walk scandalously, is a piece of Divinity that I cannot yet believe. There seems to be something in that which learned Mr. Hudson hinteth from 1 Cor. 14.34. Let your women keep silence in the Churches. Here are Churches in Corinth, he doth not say, Let women, but Let your women (that indeed which is a rule for the Churches of Corinth, is a rule for all Churches) those Congregations are called Churches, yet one combined Church of Corinth.
2. A second consideration is this, you see those who call for agreement, they are no babes, they are men, holy, learned, excellently gifted, and the arguments they give for their Classical forme of government are not slight, but such as deserve strong heads to answer; it may be my shallownesse, but truly I cannot yet see some things they plead for to be clearly answered, as their arguments for the Catholick-Church-visible; their arguments for their Presbyterial Church, from the Church of Jerusalem, Corinth, &c. yet I have read the answers with a kinde of prejudice against the Classical way, being before engaged in the Congregational-way, and usually then men are apt to make a little serve the turne: But I cannot yet be satisfied, and that such a Church as is in this small village where I live, should have equall power with the Church of Corinth, and be exempted from all other power, though (which God forbid) we should walke scandalously, is a peece of Divinity that I cannot yet beleeve. There seemes to be something in that which learned Mr. Hudson hinteth from 1 Cor. 14.34. Let your women keepe silence in the Churches. Here are Churches in Corinth, he doth not say, Let women, but Let your women (that indeed which is a rule for the Churches of Corinth, is a rule for all Churches) those Congregations are called Churches, yet one combined Church of Corinth.
There are other points besides which I mention not, but certainly the controversy is not so clear as the controversy against Papists, Socinians, &c. therefore I should think that we had need close the more with these men.
There are other points besides which I mention not, but certainly the controversie is not so clear as the controversie against Papists, Socinians, &c. therefore I should thinke that we had need close the more with these men.
A third consideration is this; unto me it is something, I know not how it takes with others, the strange things that God in his Providence hath suffered to fall out in Congregational Churches, I mean for Divisions especially, and errors; that charge cannot be denied of many Congregational Members what errors they have drunk in; and for Divisions, they are not secret things, but such as the whole Nation knows, insomuch that I have heard a serious Congregational Minister, and an able man say, when he hath heard what cracks, and rendings there have been in Congregational Churches, he thought seriously whether it were the way of God or no; how ⟨p. 110⟩many Congregational Churches may be reckoned where these have been, and if Ministers do not let their Members take their own course, even what they will, and drink in what errors they will, it is hard to keep a Church from rending, 1England gives strong proof of this. It is a very unhappy Story that Mr. Edwards relates of the Church at Arnheim, if it be true, I find it quoted by the London Ministers: where that Act was done in New England, that Mr. Cawdrey mentions in his Epistle to the dissenting Brethren, I cannot imagine; but that is also strange, if true; I suppose he relates as it was related to him, I know indeed where there is a sad example of this kind there also. This use I make of these things, that we had need take another review of Congregational principles, in respect of that power which is given to the Fraternity, and in the mean time to be very tender towards the Classical Brethren, and study agreement with them.
A third consideration is this; unto me it is something, I know not how it takes with others, the strange things that God in his Providence hath suffered to fall out in Congregationall Churches, I meane for Divisions especially, and errours; that charge cannot bee denied of many Congregationall Members what errours they have drunke in; and for Divisions, they are not secret things, but such as the whole Nation knows, insomuch that I have heard a serious Congregationall Minister, and an able man say, when he hath heard what crackes, and rendings there have been in Congregationall Churches, he thought seriously whether it were the way of God or no; how ⟨p. 110⟩many Congregationall Churches may be reckoned where these have been, and if Ministers doe not let their Members take their owne course, even what they will, and drinke in what errours they will, it is hard to keep a Church from rending,
The fourth, The Classical men are opposed in reforming their Churches, as well as the Congregational men; now for these to be opposed, not only by the profane part, whom they keep off from the Lords Supper, but to be opposed also by the Congregational men, that they prove a grief to them, this is a hard chapter; certainly we had need more close with them, and help to comfort them, rather then grieve them in their work, they are scorned by the profane party, let not us scorn them.
The fourth, The Classicall men are opposed in reforming their Churches, as well as the Congregationall men; now for these to be opposed, not only by the prophane part, whom they keep off from the Lords Snpper, but to be opposed also by the Congregationall men, that they prove a griefe to them, this is a hard chapter; certainly we had need more close with them, and help to comfort them, rather then grieve them in their worke, they are scorned by the profane party, let not us scorne them.
5 These Nurseries of errors [I mean the Separatists, who cast off Orthodox Officers] are as bad enemies to the Congregational Churches, as they are to the Classical; nay worser, your Members will quickly drink in their poison, yea, and go away from you to them, 1as experience hath testified; therefore it concerns you to join with the Classical men against them; but by one passage I meet with in the London Vindication, it seems some Congregational men do not think so, for they in their complaint to you thus speak; Are there not some of you that choose rather to join with Anabaptists, and Episcopal men then with us? and that will give letters dimissory to your Members, to depart from you to the Churches of the Anabaptists? and at the same time deny them to such as desire them, for to join with Churches of our Communion? we charge not these things upon you all, but upon some, whose names we forbear to mention; this is very strange, but this confirms what I said before, that the cause of our dis-union is not altogether in the Classical men.
5 These Nurseries of errours [I meane the Separatists, who cast off Orthodox Officers] are as bad enemies to the Congregationall Churches, as they are to the Classicall; nay worser, your Members will quickly drinke in their poyson, yea, and goe away from you to them, 1as experience hath testified; therefore it concernes you to joyne with the Classicall men against them; but by one passage I meet with in the London Vindication, it seems some Congregationall men doe not thinke so, for they in their complaint to you thus speake; Are there not some of you that chuse rather to joyne with Anabaptists, and Episcopall men then with us? and that will give letters dimissory to your Members, to depart from you to the Churches of the Anabaptists? and at the same time deny them to such as desire them, for to joyne with Churches of our Communion? we charge not these things upon you all, but upon some, whose names we forbeare to mention; this is very strange, but this confirmes what I said before, that the cause of our dis-union is not altogether in the Classicall men.
- 1Pag. 119.
6 I pray consider what a fine Game the Devil hath played by this opposition between us, hath he not turned our Reformation into a deformation? Hath he not caused the building of the Temple to cease? Do not all things that concern the Reformation of the Church stand at a stay? What do we now? indeed those who are for Congregational Government, have the opportunity to gather Churches [as they call it] but what becomes of the whole? It was told me when I was in Spain, [which was the winter before Naseby Fight] that divers that were in religious Orders that lived there, were got into England; Certainly Jesuits, or Devils have been here to hold the Congregational, and Classical Brethren at such a distance, that while they have been contending about Government, we are in danger of loosing Ordinances, Truths, Government, and be swallowed up with a deluge of Errors, Schisms, and Heresies; Divide & impera, that hath been Satan's project.
6 I pray consider what a fine Game the Devill hath played by this opposition between us, hath he not turned our Reformation into a deformation? Hath he not caused the building of the Temple to cease? Doe not all things that concerne the Reformation of the Church stand at a stay? What doe we now? indeed those who are for Congregationall Government, have the opportunity to gather Churches [as they call it] but what becomes of the whole? It was told me when I was in Spaine, [which was the winter before Naseby Fight] that divers that were in religious Orders that lived there, were got into England; Certainly Jesuits, or Devils have been here to hold the Congregationall, and Classicall Brethren at such a distance, that while they have been contending about Government, we are in danger of loosing Ordinances, Truths, Government, and be swallowed up with a deluge of Errors, Schismes, and Heresies; Divide & impera, that hath been Satans project.
7 I beseech you consider, whether we lye not open to Gods stroke: is there not matter of provocation given him, by reason of these Divisions (that his work stands at a stay) Errors, Schisms, Heresies, and decay of godliness that follows upon these, that he should take away the Liberties he hath given us, and make us feel a heavy yoke again? Surely these things will not be long borne. Mr. Caryll hath a sad speech, 1God hath begun to do so many marvels amongst us, that I verily believe the work he is about, will end in a marvel too; and we in the close shall be made either a wonder of Mercy, or a wonder of Judgement to all the Nations round about.
7 I beseech you consider, whether we lye not open to Gods stroke: is there not matter of provocation given him, by reason of these Divisions (that his worke stands at a stay) Errours, Schismes, Heresies, and decay of godlinesse that follows upon these, that he should take away the Liberties he hath given us, and make us feele a heavie yoke againe? Surely these things will not be long borne. Mr. Caryll hath a sad speech, 1God hath begun to doe so many marvells amongst us, that I verily beleeve the worke he is about, will end in a marvell too; and we in the close shall be made either a wonder of Mercy, or a wonder of Judgement to all the Nations round about.
- 1Expos. on Job, c. 5. ver. 9.
We are made indeed a wonder in regard of the strange Opinions, Heresies, Divisions, they wonder at us in New England; but till God sets up his Kingdom in our hearts, 1consisting in righteousness, peace, and joys of the Holy Ghost, and sets up his Kingdom in the Nation, riding in triumph in his Ordinances, converting of souls, and battering down the profaneness of our hearts, scattering our Errors and Schisms, we shall not be a wonder of mercy to other Nations; but if God shall be pleased to let our hearts feel his inward Kingdom, and our eyes see his external visible Kingdom after that manner exalted, then Lord, some of us care not how soon we fall asleep.
We are made indeed a wonder in regard of the strange Opinions, Heresies, Divisions, they wonder at us in New England; but till God sets up his Kingdome in our hearts, 1consisting in righteousnesse, peace, and joyes of the Holy Ghost, and sets up his Kingdome in the Nation, riding in triumph in his Ordinances, converting of soules, and battering down the prophanenesse of our hearts, scattering our Errors and Schismes, we shall not be a wonder of mercy to other Nations; but if God shall be pleased to let our hearts feele his inward Kingdome, and our eyes see his externall visible Kingdome after that manner exalted, then Lord, some of us care not how soone we fall asleep.
FINIS.