Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 2 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
As the Anointing of the baptized, As Cyprian, It is necessary that the baptized person be anointed, &c. yea, and puts much in it, as one may see, who reads those Epistles.
Tertullian also makes mention of this.
Hence Fabianus ordered, that this oil should be prepared every year, and reprehended those, who kept it two or three years together, in secunda Epist. and Episc. orient. Hence also care was taken afterwards, that none but Bishops should make this, the Presbyters must not dare to do it. Sylvester in Concil. Rom.
Hence Fabianus ordered, that this oyle should be prepared every yeare, and reprehended those, who kept it two or three yeares together, in secunda Epist. and Episc. orient. Hence also care was taken afterwards, that none but Bishops should make this, the Presbyters must not dare to doe it. Sylvester in Concil. Rom.
Also in the Lords Supper, the mixing of water with the wine, which how ever some say, it was because of the hot Countries, ⟨p. 10⟩yet Alexander, who they say was the first that mixed water with wine, 1doth not give that reason, but because water and blood came out of Christs side. In Justin Martyrs time, it seems this was their manner also, but this was not the Institution.
Also in the Lords Supper, the mixing of water with the wine, which how ever some say, it was because of the hot Countries, ⟨p. 10⟩yet Alexander, who they say was the first that mixed water with wine, 1doth not give that reason, but because water and blood came out of Christs side. In Justin Martyrs time, it seemes this was their manner also, but this was not the Institution.
- 1Epist. ad omnes Ortho. Apol. 2.
Also we find several Church-officers among them, as appears by Gaius Bishop of Rome, who ordered, that all the orders in the Church must ascend, from the door-keeper to the Bishop. Ostiarius, Lector, Exorcista, Acolythus, Subdiaconus, Diaconus, Presbyter, Episcopus. The ordination of these Officers, with their Ceremonies are after set down in the fourth Council of Carthage.
Also we find severall Church-officers among them, as appears by Gaius Bishop of Rome, who ordered, that all the orders in the Church must ascend, from the door-keeper to the Bishop. Ostiarius, Lector, Exorcista, Acolythus, Subdiaconus, Diaconus, Presbyter, Episcopus. The ordination of these Officers, with their Ceremonies are after set downe in the fourth Councel of Carthage.
If the Decretals of Gaius be of any Authority, all these were in primitive Churches, before Constantine came to the Empire.
More things I might add, but I forbear.
More things I might adde, but I forbeare.
And though there were many glorious Martyrs, yet all their Church-members were not such, many did yield to the heathenish Idolatry, when persecution began, yea, and there were foul sins among them Churches, as Adultery, Whoredom (yea, even among those, who had been Confessors, as Cyprian affirms, ingemiscimus saith he, to see it) drunkenness, swearing, and what not, as any one may well gather, who is but a little versed in Antiquity, 1and by reading over the Canons made in their Councils, we may learn what they were troubled with.
And though there were many glorious Martyrs, yet all their Church-members were not such, many did yeeld to the heathenish Idolatry, when persecution began, yea, and there were foul sins among them Churches, as Adultery, Whoredome (yea, even among those, who had beene Confessors, as Cyprian affirmes, ingemiscimus saith he, to see it) drunkennesse, swearing, and what not, as any one may well gather, who is but a little versed in Antiquity, 1and by reading over the Canons made in their Councels, we may learne what they were troubled with.
- 1De unita Eccles.
As for the Ministers, they also were ordained by Bishops (though they were not such lordly ones as ours were) with Presbyters joining with them, this no man can deny that knows any thing of those times; whence then I am bold to affirm, that if there were true Ministers, and true visible Churches in those times, even while they were under persecuting heathenish Emperors, then there are true Ministers, and true visible Churches now in England, and if there be none now, neither were there any in those times; but I think no man is so impudent to deny that there were true Ministers and Churches in those times. I plead now for many Presbyterial Ministers, and their Congregations. So I have done with my second Argument, which if I should draw into form, it runs thus:
As for the Ministers, they also were ordained by Bishops (though they were not such lordly ones as ours were) with Presbyters joyning with them, this no man can deny that knows any thing of those times; whence then I am bold to affirme, that if there were true Ministers, and true visible Churches in those times, even while they were under persecuting heathenish Emperours, then there are true Ministers, and true visible Churches now in England, and if there be none now, neither were there any in those times; but I thinke no man is so impudent to deny that there were true Ministers and Churches in those times. I plead now for many Presbyteriall Ministers, and their Congregations. So I have done with my second Argument, which if I should draw into forme, it runnes thus:
If there were true Ministers, and true visible Churches in the ⟨p. 11⟩first three hundred years after Christ, then there are true Ministers, and visible Churches now in England.
If there were true Ministers, and true visible Churches in the ⟨p. 11⟩first three hundred yeares after Christ, then there are true Ministers, and visible Churches now in England.
But the Antecedent is true, ergo the consequent is true.
Some we have that dote, they tell us, they expect men to be sent from God, and endued with extraordinary gifts, as were the Apostles, &c, and these are the men, who shall set up Churches, and reform us. Good Lord, whither will our vile hearts carry us, if thou dost leave them?
Some we have that dote, they tell us, they expect men to be sent from God, and endued with extraordinary gifts, as were the Apostles, &c, and these are the men, who shall set up Churches, and reforme us. Good Lord, whither will our vile hearts carry us, if thou dost leave them?
These persons are not worth the answering, but yet let me say a little to them, and so pass on to the chief thing I intend.
These persons are not worth the answering, but yet let me say a little to them, and so passe on to the chiefe thing I intend.
For the gift of Tongues, I need not speak, what is necessary God hath given to most, and many excel in that gift.
For the gift of Tongues, I need not speake, what is necessary God hath given to most, and many excell in that gift.
For Miracles.
I They were given but for that time, to help on the work of the Ministry (as sauce doth meat) but now if God doth that by the Ministry of his Servants without Miracles, which he did then by the Ministry accompanied with Miracles (viz. Convert, Edify, Formalize, &c.) this doth but more confirm our Ministry, and prove that God owns these despised Ministers. The plain word preached, hath made as good Christians, as preaching, and Miracles.
I They were given but for that time, to help on the worke of the Ministry (as sauce doth meat) but now if God doth that by the Ministry of his Servants without Miracles, which he did then by the Ministry accompanied with Miracles (viz. Convert, Edifie, Formalize, &c.) this doth but more confirme our Ministry, and prove that God ownes these despised Ministers. The plaine word preached, hath made as good Christians, as preaching, and Miracles.
2 If any Body hath need of the gift of Miracles, then Master Eliot in New England hath, who now preaches to the Indians, and others with him; but God carrieth on his work amongst the Indians without miracles.
2 If any Body hath need of the gift of Miracles, then Master Eliot in New England hath, who now preaches to the Indians, and others with him; but God carrieth on his worke amongst the Indians without miracles.
3 Do not you your selves believe the Scriptures to be the Word of God? if so, what need have you of such kind of persons so gifted? The greatest Miracle which I desire to confirm me in the truth of the Scriptures, is to find the power of Christ his Death, and Resurrection in my heart, without which I care not for miracles. But enough for these.
3 Doe not you your selves beleeve the Scriptures to be the Word of God? if so, what need have you of such kinde of persons so gifted? The greatest Miracle which I desire to confirme me in the truth of the Scriptures, is to finde the power of Christ his Death, and Resurrection in my heart, without which I care not for miracles. But enough for these.
There are others, who having been Members of an Independent Church, where divisions have fallen out, and so have broke in pieces, they have said, that Ministers are not fitted with a spirit of Government, to keep Churches in order, and therefore these are not times as yet for such Reformation, I answer;
There are others, who having been Members of an Independent Church, where divisions have fallen out, and so have broke in peeces, they have said, that Ministers are not fitted with a spirit of Government, to keep Churches in order, and therefore these are not times as yet for such Reformation, I answer;
1 The more shame for your Church-Members, who are of such proud, and turbulent spirits, that godly and able Ministers are not able enough to govern them; those who come into Church ⟨p. 12⟩Communion with the awe of God upon their hearts, we can govern them; some such spirits we find among the Independents, but if we could see more it would be better.
1 The more shame for your Church-Members, who are of such proud, and turbulent spirits, that godly and able Ministers are not able enough to governe them; those who come into Church ⟨p. 12⟩Communion with the awe of God upon their hearts, we can governe them; some such spirits we finde among the Independents, but if we could see more it would be better.
2 I wonder not at your Divisions, when I see what Principles some godly Congregational men have gone by, for the ordering of their Church Government.
2 I wonder not at your Divisions, when I see what Principles some godly Congregationall men have gone by, for the ordering of their Church Government.
3 Your Argument is as strong against the Apostles, for there were Heresies, and Schisms in their days.
3 Your Argument is as strong against the Apostles, for there were Heresies, and Schismes in their dayes.
But I leave these, and return to that, from whence I have made a digression; Having then proved there are true Ministers, and Churches in England, let us examine the grounds, why these men separate from these Ministers, and Churches; I conceive their grounds may be referred to one of these heads: Either to The Ministers, Either to Or Worship, Either to Or the Congregation, Either to Or the place of meeting;
If there be any thing else that cannot so well be reduced to one of these, yet I am sure I shall meet with it, before I have done.
For the Ministers, they are indeed made the Dung of England, who are more scorned then they, especially the Presbyterial men, be they never so holy, or learned? Whether there be just cause in respect of men, I leave it to God to judge; I am sure when Ministers were in honour, we found the Word had good effect, but since they came to be thus scorned, little good hath been done. I deny not but God may have a just quarrel against us, and give me leave (without offence) to propound the Reasons why.
For the Ministers, they are indeed made the Dung of England, who are more scorned then they, especially the Presbyteriall men, be they never so holy, or learned? Whether there be just cause in respect of men, I leave it to God to judge; I am sure when Ministers were in honour, we found the Word had good effect, but since they came to be thus scorned, little good hath been done. I deny not but God may have a just quarrell against us, and give me leave (without offence) to propound the Reasons why.
1 The first I had rather conceal, because I should seem to spy out a mote in my Fathers, and Brethren's eyes, when I have a beam in my own; but therefore I rather propound it, as I heard it from a Reverend and judicious Divine, a man of a gracious and moderate spirit, Mr. Nathaniel Rogers in New England. I was talking with him there, when the news came of the Covenant that England, and Scotland entered into; the thing pleased him, and all our Churches exceedingly: This only, (said he) I have not heard of, That there hath been a general Humiliation amongst the Ministers, for their yielding so much to the superstitious inventions of that Hierarchy.
1 The first I had rather conceale, because I should seem to spy out a mote in my Fathers, and Brethrens eyes, when I have a beame in my owne; but therefore I rather propound it, as I heard it from a Reverend and judicious Divine, a man of a gracious and moderate spirit, Mr. Nathaniel Rogers in New England. I was talking with him there, when the newes came of the Covenant that England, and Scotland entred into; the thing pleased him, and all our Churches exceedingly: This only, (said he) I have not heard of, That there hath been a generall Humiliation amongst the Ministers, for their yeelding so much to the superstitious inventions of that Hierarchy.
2 I conceive God may justly have a quarrel against us (the ⟨p. 13⟩younger sort of Ministers) for our woeful conformity to the Fashions of the times; what long hair now do we see most young Ministers wear, and if any new fond fashion comes up, who follows it sooner then they? Who take more liberty here then Independent Ministers, the younger sort?
2 I conceive God may justly have a quarrell against us (the ⟨p. 13⟩younger sort of Ministers) for our wofull conformity to the Fashions of the times; what long haire now doe we see most young Ministers weare, and if any new fond fashion comes up, who follows it sooner then they? Who take more liberty here then Independent Ministers, the younger sort?
3 There hath been a too great Idolizing of Learning, and abusing it in Sermons, by reciting of the Fathers, or School-men, some men fondly making, it may be, a quarter of their Sermons to be Latin, or Greek sentences out of them, and then turning them into English, to make people admire them, and conclude them to be great Scholars; not but that it is lawful to quote a Father, or a School-man: but I speak of that excess, and pride also, that went along with it, that they thought themselves so exalted above the people, and looked on them, as the Pharisees, Joh. 7.49. Hence God doth now let Ministers and Learning be trampled upon. But this was not the fault of those godly men, who now are despised, as much as the worst.
3 There hath been a too great Idolizing of Learning, and abusing it in Sermons, by reciting of the Fathers, or School-men, some men fondly making, it may be, a quarter of their Sermons to be Latine, or Greek sentences out of them, and then turning them into English, to make people admire them, and conclude them to be great Schollars; not but that it is lawfull to quote a Father, or a Schoole-man: but I speake of that excesse, and pride also, that went along with it, that they thought themselves so exalted above the people, and looked on them, as the Pharisees, Joh. 7.49. Hence God doth now let Ministers and Learning be trampled upon. But this was not the fault of those godly men, who now are despised, as much as the worst.
4 There is in some young Ministers a too base esteem of private Christians, that are not learned; I have heard my self those, who have spoken very contemptibly of them, scorning they should have any hand in Church affairs; now it is true, there are abundance of private Christians very weak, but some there are, solid, understanding men; and though we do not admit these to be Governors in the Church (unless chosen to the Office of a Ruling Elder, to join with us) yet Ministers shall find sometimes, that they have no cause to repent, in giving an ear to what they say.
4 There is in some young Ministers a too base esteeme of private Christians, that are not learned; I have heard my selfe those, who have spoken very contemptibly of them, scorning they should have any hand in Church affaires; now it is true, there are abundance of private Christians very weake, but some there are, solid, understanding men; and though we doe not admit these to be Governours in the Church (unlesse chosen to the Office of a Ruling Elder, to joyne with us) yet Ministers shall finde sometimes, that they have no cause to repent, in giving an eare to what they say.
These things I have observed, and wish (especially for the three latter) that God hath not brought us down for them. I might have added, some young Ministers study more quint-essential Notions, curious Fancies, and please people much with fine speculations about Christ, and Free Grace, but have left the old way of Preaching, which did the good. This Chemical Divinity hath pleased mens ears, but not awed, nor humbled mens hearts; it makes frothy, but not solid Christians.
These things I have observed, and wish (especially for the three latter) that God hath not brought us downe for them. I might have added, some young Ministers study more quint-essentiall Notions, curious Phansies, and please people much with fine speculations about Christ, and Free Grace, but have left the old way of Preaching, which did the good. This Chymicall Divinity hath pleased mens eares, but not awed, nor humbled mens hearts; it makes frothy, but not solid Christians.
But these are not to be imputed to all the Presbyterians, who are thus scorned.
But now to the Ministers.
The general apprehension that these men have of the Ministers, is that they are Anti-christian Ministers, and what is more common in their mouths then to call them so? This is a heavy charge, if it could be proved: but this term Anti-christian is both a simple term, a complex Proposition, a Syllogism, i. e. they think it sufficient proof to charge them with it, though hundreds of these know no more then a Babe, wherein the formality of Anti-christianism doth consist, but every thing that displeases them, that is Antichristian; Infant Baptism is Anti-christian, the Ordination of Ministers is Anti-christian, singing of Psalms is Anti-christian, it is proof sufficient, they have said it; now this seems to me very strange, that those men, who Instrumentally, 1. Convert men to Christ. 2. Build up men in Christ. 3. Oppose Anti-christ to the utmost. 4. Who have cast off Anti-christ. 5. If they were under Anti-christs power, should soon find his favour to be Fire and Faggot, yet these men to be called Anti-christians, I say with the Text, The Lord rebuke thee, O Satan: But if you will take Anti-christ in a large sense, why may not those be as truly called Anti-christians, who do throw down, what Ordinances Christ hath set up; as, The Ordinance of the Ministry, giving his promise to be with it to the end of the world; the Baptizing of the infants of believing Parents; singing of Psalms, any form of external Church-Government; all these are thrown down by most of you, and many walk above Ordinances. I say, may not these be called as truly Anti-christians in a large sense, who thus throw down, what Christ hath set up, as well as those, who set up such Ordinances, as Christ never did set up? (which is one sign of Anti-christianism.)
The generall apprehension that these men have of the Ministers, is that they are Anti-christian Ministers, and what is more common in their mouthes then to call them so? This is a heavie charge, if it could be proved: but this terme Anti-christian is both a simple terme, a complexe Proposition, a Syllogisme, i. e. they think it sufficient proofe to charge them with it, though hundreds of these know no more then a Babe, wherein the formality of Anti-christianisme doth consist, but every thing that displeases them, that is Antichristian; Infant Baptism is Anti-christian, the Ordination of Ministers is Anti-christian, singing of Psalms is Anti-christian, it is proofe sufficient, they have said it; now this seemes to me very strange, that those men, who Instrumentally, 1. Convert men to Christ. 2. Build up men in Christ. 3. Oppose Anti-christ to the utmost. 4. Who have cast off Anti-christ. 5. If they were under Anti-christs power, should soon finde his favour to be Fire and Faggot, yet these men to be called Anti-christians, I say with the Text, The Lord rebuke thee, O Satan: But if you will take Anti-christ in a large sence, why may not those be as truly called Anti-christians, who doe throw downe, what Ordinances Christ hath set up; as, The Ordinance of the Ministry, giving his promise to be with it to the end of the world; the Baptizing of the infants of beleeving Parents; singing of Psahnes, any forme of externall Church-Government; all these are throwne downe by most of you, and many walke above Ordinances. I say, may not these be called as truly Anti-christians in a large sence, who thus throw downe, what Christ hath set up, as well as those, who set up such Ordinances, as Christ never did set up? (which is one signe of Anti-christianisme.)
But if you would know what is properly Anti-christianism, 1I pray take it from a far more able man then my self, one well known, and that deserves honour, Mr. Burroughs; he well observed the madness of people, that cry out against any thing, that displeases them, that it is Anti-christianism, then sets down thus, wherein it consists.
But if you would know what is properly Anti-christianisme, 1I pray take it from a farre more able man then my selfe, one well knowne, and that deserves honour, Mr. Burroughs; he well observed the madnesse of people, that cry out against any thing, that displeases them, that it is Anti-christianisme, then sets downe thus, wherein it consists.
- 1Exposi. on Hos. first Book, p. 162.
1 Whosoever shall obtrude any Doctrine upon the Church, to be believed by their own Authority.
1 Whosoever shall obtrude any Doctrine upon the Church, to be beleeved by their owne Authority.
2 The intrusion of such Offices, and Officers in the Church, as merely belong to the spiritual man.
2 The intrusion of such Offices, and Officers in the Church, as meerly belong to the spirituall man.
3 The imposing of any Ordinance, or new Institution upon the Church.
4 The imposing of Laws so to bind Conscience, as the Laws of Christ do.
4 The imposing of Lawes so to binde Conscience, as the Lawes of Christ doe.
This, saith he, is to set up another head. I need not add the owning of the Pope as a visible Monarchical head over the Church, who doth all that, which Mr. Burroughs hath mentioned; but this then I desire, that any, who thus call the Ministers Antichristian, would charge them, and make it good, that they are guilty of any of these things, or else be ashamed for ever after to call faithful Ministers of Christ, Antichristians.
This, saith he, is to set up another head. I need not adde the owning of the Pope as a visible Monarchical head over the Church, who doth all that, which Mr. Burroughs hath mentioned; but this then I desire, that any, who thus call the Ministers Antichristian, would charge them, and make it good, that they are guilty of any of these things, or else be ashamed for ever after to call faithfull Ministers of Christ, Antichristians.