Separation Examined.
pp. 1–111539 passagespart 3 of 14
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But what colour have these men for this vile aspersion, I never heard but only this, their Ordination. The sum of all they say, amounts to this, The Ministers of England stand by a Romish ordination; Ergo, They are no true Gospel, but Antichristian Ministers, this is that, which makes the heavy stir in England.
But what colour have these men for this vile aspersion, I never heard but onely this, their Ordination. The summe of all they say, amounts to this, The Ministers of England stand by a Romish ordination; Ergo, They are no true Gospel, but Antichristian Ministers, this is that, which makes the heavy stir in England.
For answer to this, I may say as the father of the blind man, He is of age, and can speak for himself; so the Presbyterial Ministers are of ability sufficient to speak, and have spoken enough in answer to this cavil, to satisfy sober minds; but what will satisfy unreasonable men? I am not very willing to insist upon this, because I can speak but little, which hath not been spoken before (for the substance) but yet this being an ingredient unto the formal cause of a Minister (which I have mentioned before, and promised to prove, that for the substance of the Ordinance our Ministers have it) I must speak a few words in answer to their cavils against it.
For answer to this, I may say as the father of the blinde man, He is of age, and can speake for himself; so the Presbyterial Ministers are of ability sufficient to speake, and have spoken enough in answer to this cavill, to satisfie sober mindes; but what will satisfie unreasonable men? I am not very willing to insist upon this, because I can speak but little, which hath not beene spoken before (for the substance) but yet this being an ingredient unto the formall cause of a Minister (which I have mentioned before, and promised to prove, that for the substance of the Ordinance our Ministers have it) I must speake a few words in answer to their cavils against it.
The Ordination of these Ministers, say they, came from the Romish Synagogue, they also were ordained by Bishops, Ergo, They are no true Ministers, hence we separate from them.
I answer,
First, had I thought there had been such a stir in England about this, I should have laboured to have understood the minds of our Elders in New England about it; all the time I was there, I never heard the question moved, whether they did look on that Ordination they had here, as true (for substance) or not. But this I dare boldly affirm for them;
First, had I thought there had beene such a stirre in England about this, I should have laboured to have understood the minds of our Elders in New England about it; all the time I was there, I never heard the question moved, whether they did look on that Ordination they had here, as true (for substance) or not. But this I dare boldly affirme for them;
1 That they do look upon abundance of our Presbyterial Ministers, as true Ministers of Christ.
1 That they doe looke upon abundance of our Presbyteriall Ministers, as true Ministers of Christ.
2 I know that they will disapprove of the practice of some, who have separated from the Ministers, whom they have before chosen, and the godly Congregations, upon this notion, as I ⟨p. 16⟩know some have done, 1especially from that famous Congregation of Dedham, of which I dare say, that for a Parochial Congregation, there is not the like number of real and visible Saints in any Congregation in England; I am sure there was not before this Separation was made; and for the Ministers I speak not of them, they are men well known. I wish I had nothing more to trouble me, then to live under that Ministry in that Congregation, I hope whereas now I am a sad man, I should be as cheerful as any man in England. Mr. Burroughs said, he could communicate in that Congregation, then it seems he did not question whether there were any true Ministers.
2 I know that they will disapprove of the practice of some, who have separated from the Ministers, whom they have before chosen, and the godly Congregations, upon this notion, as I ⟨p. 16⟩know some have done, 1especially from that famous Congregation of Dedham, of which I dare say, that for a Parochial Congregation, there is not the like number of reall and visible Saints in any Congregation in England; I am sure there was not before this Separation was made; and for the Ministers I speake not of them, they are men well knowne. I wish I had nothing more to trouble me, then to live under that Ministry in that Congregation, I hope whereas now I am a sad man, I should be as chearfull as any man in England. Mr. Burroughs said, he could communicate in that Congregation, then it seemes hee did not question whether there were any true Ministers.
- 1I do honour the grace of divers of those Christians who separated, but Satan got into an Angel of light, and deceived
Object. But if you say, Our New England Ministers do renounce their Ordination which they had here, for they are ordained again.
Object. But if you say, Our New England Ministers doe renounce their Ordination which they had here, for they are ordained againe.
Answ. 1Its true, they are ordained again, but I never heard it was upon that ground, for let a Minister be ordained there in one Church, if there be cause of his removal, and so be elected in another Church, they ordain him again.
Answ. 1Its true, they are ordained againe, but I never heard it was upon that ground, for let a Minister be ordained there in one Church, if there be cause of his removall, and so be elected in another Church, they ordaine him againe.
- 1See Answ. to 32. q. 70
Thirdly, I can say this, our New England Ministers have often desired, and frequently admitted to preach in their Congregations, that went from hence, but were not ordained there.
But our Ministers of New England are here judged nothing worth, but are as contemptible as any, in the mouths of our Separatists, yet they are men of worth.
Secondly, I answer to what you say, It came through, and from the Romish Synagogue. If your argument have any force, you must cast it thus:
Those Ministers which stand by a Romish Institution, are no true Ministers of Christ. But the Ministers of England stand by a Romish Institution; Ergo, the Ministers of England are no true Ministers of Christ.
The major you will grant, and if we can prove the minor, our Ministers shall utterly renounce their Ordination, I dare undertake for them; but the minor is very false, they stand by no Romish Institution: for Ordination is none of their inventions, but instituted by the Lord Jesus himself, long before Antichrist was. But your Argument runs thus:
The major you will grant, and if we can prove the minor, our Ministers shall utterly renounce their Ordination, I dare undertake for them; but the minor is very false, they stand by no Romish Institution: for Ordination is none of their inventions, but instituted by the Lord Jesus himselfe, long before Antichrist was. But your Argument runs thus:
Those Ministers which stand by an Institution of Christ descending ⟨p. 9⟩to them from the Apostles through the Church of Rome, they are no true Ministers of Christ.
But the Ministers of England stand by an Institution of Christ, descending to them from the Apostles through the Church of Rome, Ergo, They are no true Ministers.
This is the true meaning of your Argument, but the major is very false: shall the passing through Rome null the Institutions of Christ? did not the Scriptures, Sacraments, and what ever Ordinances we now have, descend to us from the Apostles through Rome? Shall we therefore cast them away? That Argument runs as strong against our Baptism, and any other Ordinance, with which though the Church of Rome mingled their inventions, did they therefore null the Ordinance? the vessels that were once dedicated to God by his own Institution, though they were put into the house of Nebuchadnezzars gods, and those that were fit, very like used by Belshazzar to drink wine in, when he praised the gods &c. they were not so much as new cast again, but carried to Jerusalem.1
This is the true meaning of your Argument, but the major is very false: shall the passing through Rome null the Institutions of Christ? did not the Scriptures, Sacraments, and what ever Ordinances we now have, descend to us from the Apostles through Rome? Shall we therefore cast them away? That Argument runnes as strong against our Baptisme, and any other Ordinance, with which though the Church of Rome mingled their inventions, did they therefore null the Ordinance? the vessels that were once dedicated to God by his owne Institution, though they were put into the house of Nebuchadnezzars gods, and those that were fit, very like used by Belshazzar to drinke wine in, when he praised the gods &c. they were not so much as new cast againe, but carried to Jerusalem.1
- 1Ezra 1.7. ad fin.
I pray what do you think of the judgement of Mr. Johnson? a man great, I am sure, among the brethren of the Separation (though the Separatists in our days make a tush at the judgement of any man, yea, although he were of the Separation; but yet consider the reasons which swayed him, and then judge.) The case was this, One that was a Minister in the Church of England, was after chosen Teacher to a separate Congregation, without any new Imposing of hands, this he undertakes to justify thus:
I pray what doe you thinke of the judgement of Mr. Johnson? a man great, I am sure, among the brethren of the Separation (though the Separatists in our dayes make a tush at the judgement of any man, yea, although he were of the Separation; but yet consider the reasons which swayed him, and then judge.) The case was this, One that was a Minister in the Church of England, was after chosen Teacher to a separate Congregation, without any new Imposing of hands, this he undertakes to justifie thus:
1 Imposition of hands is of God, and not an invention of man: It was not a postor threshold first brought by Antichrist into the Temple of God, but had therein afore Antichrist sate there.
3. Imposition of hands is in the Church of Rome still given to the office of the Ministry, and in the name of the Lord, as they do also still administer Baptism.
3. Imposition of hands is in the Church of Rome still given to the office of the Ministry, and in the name of the Lord, as they doe also still administer Baptisme.
4. We found not either precept, example, or ground in the Scripture binding us to the repetition of it.
5. The Priests and Levites in Israel becoming unclean, when afterward they were cleansed, retained still their places of being Priests, and Levites; and the children of the Priests and Levites succeeding after them, •id administer without a new anointing, or new imposition of hands &c. ⟨p. 18⟩Thus then, as Mr. Johnson and Mr. Ainsworth opposed Rebaptization, because Baptism is an Ordinance of God, which was had in the Church of Rome, before she fell into Apostasy, and hath been there continued ever since the Apostles times (how ever commingled with many inventions of their own:) so Mr. Johnson defended the Ordination of that Minister, which he had in England, because Imposition of hands was in the Church of Rome from the Apostles times, before her Apostasy, and is there continued to this day, though mixed with many pollutions of their own.
5. The Priests and Levites in Israel becoming unclean, when afterward they were cleansed, retained still their places of being Priests, and Levites; and the children of the Priests and Levites succeeding after them, •id administer without a new anointing, or new imposition of hands &c. ⟨p. 18⟩Thus then, as Mr. Johnson and Mr. Ainsworth opposed Rebaptization, because Baptisme is an Ordinance of God, which was had in the Church of Rome, before she fell into Apostasie, and hath been there continued ever since the Apostles times (how ever comingled with many inventions of their owne:) so Mr. Johnson defended the Ordination of that Minister, which he had in England, because Imposition of hands was in the Church of Rome from the Apostles times, before her Apostasie, and is there continued to this day, though mixed with many pollutions of their owne.
I pray only note this, that whereas I say, they stand by their Ordination, I do not mean that only, but also they have the election of the people, of which I spake before, and that the Separatists cannot deny, which yet they make the greatest matter in a Ministers call.
I pray onely note this, that whereas I say, they stand by their Ordination, I doe not meane that onely, but also they have the election of the people, of which I spake before, and that the Separatists cannot deny, which yet they make the greatest matter in a Ministers call.
Thirdly, I answer, If this argument be of any force, it would rather prevail against the first Reformers, as in other Nations, so against our first Reformers in England, who came newly out of Popery; but what is this to us, who have been above ninety years out of that bondage, and have cast off their Government, Worship, and Doctrine (so far as Antichristian) for a long time; but if our first Reformers were able enough to maintain their call, then much more our Ministers.
Thirdly, I answer, If this argument be of any force, it would rather prevaile against the first Reformers, as in other Nations, so against our first Reformers in England, who came newly out of Popery; but what is this to us, who have beene above ninety yeares out of that bondage, and have cast off their Government, Worship, and Doctrine (so farre as Antichristian) for a long time; but if our first Reformers were able enough to maintaine their call, then much more our Ministers.
Fourthly, but if you will throw away all that comes through Rome, let us see what course you will take, when you have denied all the Ordinances, that have been administered for these ninety years in England [for if no Ministry, then certainly no Authoritative preaching, no Sacraments] and thus you have renounced your Baptism, which you had by these Ministers; what method will you take in your Reformation? how will you come to be re-baptized? you will tell me, You will covenant together, and then elect and ordain a Minister, and he shall baptize: Of this more afterward.
Fourthly, but if you will throw away all that comes through Rome, let us see what course you will take, when you have denied all the Ordinances, that have beene administred for these ninety yeares in England [for if no Ministry, then certainly no Authoritative preaching, no Sacraments] and thus you have renounced yuor Baptisme, which you had by these Ministers; what method will you take in your Reformation? how will you come to be re-baptized? you will tell me, You will covenant together, and then elect and ordaine a Minister, and he shall baptize: Of this more afterward.
But let me examine what you say at present; You will covenant together (supposing your selves to be Saints first) say you so? are you Saints by calling? how came you to be so? what did God call you immediately? No, you must say many (if not all) of you, who have any truth of grace, by the preaching of the word; what, by those Ministers from whom you separate, as no Ministers, because of their Ordination? hath the Lord so far ⟨p. 19⟩owned his despised members, as to make them the instruments to bring you to be visible Saints, fit to embody or covenant, &c? and are these now no Ministers? are you the effect of their Ministerial labours, and they no Ministers? Surely in this one thing you have overthrown your selves; but then you say, you will ordain him, this I will consider in its own place; Then he shall baptize: but since he did renounce his own baptism also, who shall baptize him first? you must have a Minister to do that, to be sure he cannot do it himself, nor none of you, for you are private persons; to administer the Lords Supper before you be baptised, is contrary to Scripture rules.
But let me examine what you say at present; You will covenant together (supposing your selves to be Saints first) say you so? are you Saints by calling? how came you to be so? what did God call you immediately? No, you must say many (if not all) of you, who have any truth of grace, by the preaching of the word; what, by those Ministers from whom you separate, as no Ministers, because of their Ordination? hath the Lord so farre ⟨p. 19⟩owned his despised members, as to make them the instruments to bring you to be visible Saints, fit to imbody or covenant, &c? and are these now no Ministers? are you the effect of their Ministeriall labours, and they no Ministers? Surely in this one thing you have overthrowne your selves; but then you say, you will ordaine him, this I will consider in its owne place; Then he shall baptize: but since he did renounce his owne baptisme also, who shall baptize him first? you must have a Minister to do that, to be sure he cannot doe it himselfe, nor none of you, for you are private persons; to administer the Lords Supper before you be baptised, is contrary to Scripture rules.
There was a report when I was in New England, that a Carpenter re-baptised Mr. Williams, 1and then he did re-baptize the rest: I do not stand to defend the thing whether it be true or no, but it was like enough to be true, and suitable to the other opinions and practises of that wild generation. Where are we now?
There was a report when I was in New England, that a Carpenter re-baptised Mr. Williams, 1and then he did re-baptize the rest: I do not stand to defend the thing whether it be true or no, but it was like enough to be true, and sutable to the other opinions and practises of that wilde generation. Where are we now?
- 1In Just. Mar. time none received the Supper, but such as were first baptised, Apol. 2. Jus Divi. Append. p. 269.In Iust. Mar. time none received the Supper, but such as were first baptised, Apol. 2. Ius Divi. Apend. p. 269.
Fifthly, that is very observable, which the London Ministers have added in the defence of their Ordination, That in this Church of England, the corruptions which the Church of Rome would have introduced about Ordination of Ministers and other Ecclesiastical affairs, were withstood and opposed by the Kings of England: Nor do we read of any Ministers that were ordained by any Agents sent from Rome, but only some idle ceremonies of Confirmation, or them that were ordained by the Pall and the Ring brought thence into England. Thus far the London Ministers: In the margin they have set down the Authors that prove it.
Fifthly, that is very observable, which the London Ministers have added in the defence of their Ordination, That in this Church of England, the corruptions which the Church of Rome would have introduced about Ordination of Ministers and other Ecclesiasticall affaires, were withstood and opposed by the Kings of England: Nor doe we read of any Ministers that were ordained by any Agents sent from Rome, but onely some idle ceremonies of Confirmation, or them that were ordained by the Pall and the Ring brought thence into England. Thus far the London Ministers: In the margent they have set downe the Authours that prove it.
Sixthly, There might be another answer given by some, who are good Historians, [which I confess I am not, wanting both time and such books] so far as I can go, I will. That the Churches in England were at first rightly gathered and constituted, it is not to be doubted, 1the instruments of gathering being Apostles or Apostolical men, as is evident by Mr. Fox; neither is it to be doubted, but they did ordain officers in the Churches, for we read of Ministers and Bishops. The land falling to the possession of the Saxons about the year 568. 2the Story saith by them, all the Clergy and the Christian Ministers of the Britons were then utterly driven out, in so much that the Arch-bishops of London and York went into Wales: thus ⟨p. 12⟩long then it seems the Ministers of England had no ordination from Rome; 3this appears also by Austin, who came into England in the year five hundred ninety eight, he about the year six hundred, 4assembled the Bishops and Doctors of Britain (so that still here were Ministers, but where their abode was, the story sets not down, but supposed to be towards Wales,) and charged them to preach the Gospel to the English-men, and also that they should among themselves reform certain rites in their Church (so that still here were Ministers and Churches) specially for keeping of Easter-tide, baptizing after the manner of Rome, &c. to which the Scots and Britons would not agree (this shows they did not depend upon Rome.) Afterward there was another Synod gathered, where seven Bishops of Britain were present; and though we find a great battle fought presently after, where the Britons were overcome, yet the Story doth not mention that the Ministers were all slain there. Now the thing I aim at is this, that since there were so many Ministers and Bishops in England, who had their ordination by succession from those Apostolical men, and not from Rome, and we find so many, when Austin came, why may we not suppose that these might again preach the Gospel to the English-men, though at first they were opposite, when they had smarted for their folly? and why may we not suppose they might return into England again, especially into those parts near Wales? also those who were driven out, as the Story saith they were, suppose into some other parts, might not they return into England?
also must we take the words of the Story, (All the Clergy and Christian Ministers were driven out) strictly so, as none at all were left, though latent, &c? those, who are good Historians, may help here, and it would be some answer to that objection of our ordination coming from Rome, though unto me, the objection is very feeble, if this answer cannot be made out.
also must we take the words of the Story, (All the Clergy and Christian Ministers were driven out) strictly so, as none at all were left, though latent, &c? those, who are good Historians, may helpe here, and it would be some answer to that objection of our ordination coming from Rome, though unto me, the objection is very feeble, if this answer cannot be made out.
As for the Churches of England, being rightly at first gathered, 1as above mentioned; Mr. Cotton yields it, so as he saith, That all the work now is, not to make them Churches, which were none before, but to reduce, and restore them to their primitive Institution, &c.
As for the Churches of England, being rightly at first gathered, 1as above mentioned; Mr. Cotton yeelds it, so as he saith, That all the work now is, not to make them Churches, which were none before, but to reduce, and restore them to their primitive Institution, &c.
- 1Way of Ch. in N. E. Ch. 7. p. 111.
To that part of the Objection, They were ordained by Bishops; I pray what do you think of Master Bradford, and the rest of ⟨p. 13⟩those holy Ministers and Martyrs that were ordained by the Bishops in those days, Cranmer, Ridley, Hooper, &c? was he an Anti-christian Minister, and all those Ministers, who were then ordained, though now they were scarce got out of the Popish Ceremonies? &c. the holy Martyrs then did never offer to separate from Mr. Bradford, and the rest, nor call them Antichristian Ministers. I pray how many such Bradfords have you among you? Not all the Separatists in England can afford such a one; Christ calls him his faithful Minister, but you say Mr. Bradford is none; cursed be that doctrine. Now if those Ministers were true Ministers, though they had an Episcopal Ordination, then so are ours, notwithstanding their Ordination by Bishops. It is vain to say those Bishops were godly men, so were ot ours: for it is a bold assertion to say, that none of the Bishops since have been godly men, no doubt there are divers in Heaven. And besides, it is absurd to think, that the truth and efficacy of an Ordinance depends upon the truth of Grace in him who doth administer it; as for Ceremonies, if you search, they were not clear then, no more then our Bishops were.
To that part of the Objection, They were ordained by Bishops; I pray what doe you thinke of Master Bradford, and the rest of ⟨p. 13⟩those holy Ministers and Martyrs that were ordained by the Bishops in those dayes, Cranmer, Ridley, Hooper, &c? was he an Anti-christian Minister, and all those Ministers, who were then ordained, though now they were scarce got out of the Popish Ceremonies? &c. the holy Martyrs then did never offer to separate from Mr. Bradford, and the rest, nor call them Antichristian Ministers. I pray how many such Bradfords have you among you? Not all the Separatists in England can afford such a one; Christ cals him his faithfull Minister, but you say Mr. Bradford is none; cursed be that doctrine. Now if those Ministers were true Ministers, though they had an Episcopall Ordination, then so are ours, notwithstanding their Ordination by Bishops. It is vaine to say those Bishops were godly men, so were ot ours: for it is a bold assertion to say, that none of the Bishops since have been godly men, no doubt there are divers in Heaven. And besides, it is absurd to thinke, that the truth and efficacy of an Ordinance depends upon the truth of Grace in him who doth administer it; as for Ceremonies, if you search, they were not cleare then, no more then our Bishops were.
It is a silly shift to say, They walked according to their light; I hope there was the same rule to judge of the truth of Ministers then, that is now; it was not their light which made them true Ministers, but the rule. But the truth of their Ministry was never questioned, till our Separatists rose up, who are not comparable to them in parts, or holiness.
It is a silly shift to say, They walked according to their light; I hope there was the same rule to judge of the truth of Ministers then, that is now; it was not their light which made them true Ministers, but the rule. But the truth of their Ministry was never questioned, till our Separatists rose up, who are not comparable to them in parts, or holinesse.
2 I pray, what do you make of those Ministers who were ordained in the Primitive Churches? 1they were ordained in Cyprian's time by Bishops, and Presbyters; and by Hieroms time the Bishops had engrossed that power into their own hands, as appears by that speech of his, Excepting Ordination, 2what doth a Bishop that a Presbyter doth not? so that by this time it should seem that the Presbyters were turned out, and the Bishops only Ordained. It is possible this might be but in some Churches, for the fourth council of Carthage ordered, That no Bishop should Ordain without the council of his Clergy, Can. 22. Can. 3. Now, what were these no Ministers? Anti-christ was not yet got into his Seat, for the years of his reign had been expired before this time. It is strange, that those should be no true Ministers, who lived so near the Apostles times, and under ⟨p. 22⟩persecution also, as in Cyprian's time; neither was Cyprian surely the first Bishop that did Ordain, for there were Bishops before him; yea, besides this Ordination by Bishops, we find the Papists contending strongly for strange Rites, which they use in Ordination, and they say they were also used in those Primitive times: for the anointing of the hands of the Presbyter that is ordained, this they would prove from Cyprian, or at least the Author of The Card. work of Ch. who should seem to be as old as Cyprian; also from Eusebius Hist. Eccles. l. 10. c. 4. which place would seem to favour it; and others there are, whom they quote. See Greg. De Val. to 4. d. 9. q. 5. Also for the shaving of the heads of their Ministers, this we find indeed in August. time, Ep. 26. & Ep. 147. And this Calvin himself doth not deny to have been used then, and gives the reason why it was used; which Greg. de Val. scornes, and gives other reasons, To. 4. D. 9. q. 5. p. 3. If the Decret. Epistles of Anicetus be of any Authority, we shall find it in his days, long before Augustin; and I wonder that Greg. Val. doth not quote him. I am apt to think, being they were so prone to Ceremonies in other Ordinances, that something was added to this also; 3and I marvel that in the fourth Council of Carthage, where they set down their rites in Ordinations of other officers, and some very ridiculous, that the ordination of Presbyters should be the most pure; but still with Bishops as well as Presbyters, which is the thing now in hand.
3 A Bishop, if you consider him merely as a Bishop, was but a Minister, and set apart to do the work of a Minister, the same, which all other Ministers may do; Bishops did Pray, Preach, Baptize, administer the Lords Supper, Ordain, Suspend, Excommunicate, and these things other Ministers do, and may do; that he did lift up himself above other Ministers, that was his error, that he would take upon him the sole power of Ordination, and Excommunication, this was his error; but as the addition of an human invention did not null the Ordinances, (as suppose only grown persons had been baptized, and that by dipping, and after dipping they had been signed with the sign of the Cross, would this have nulled the Ordinance in the Anabaptists esteem?) no more this usurpation of the power of administering these Ordinances did null a Bishop, so as he was no Minister; the Ordinances were, and are Christs institutions. Indeed you may call him, an Over-grown Presbyter, ⟨p. 23⟩but a Presbyter. 1Diotrophes loving of pre-eminence did justly deserve reproof, and John did no doubt deal with him, but yet for present did not deny him to be a Minister, though a corrupt one; for the sole power of Ordination, they tell us, It is the order of the Church of England, as of the Council of Carthage, that when a Presbyter is Ordained, all the Presbyters that are present shall lay hands. As for the sole power of Excommunication, though it was an error gross enough, yet by the 17. Canon, Concil. Sardic. 2it should seem the Bishops by that time had got that power to excommunicate alone; which Canon provides a remedy for a person wrongfully excommunicated by his Bishop, to got relief by Appeals; now if that corruption had got in so early, long before Anti-christ had got to his Seat, no wonder though it was found among our Bishops, yet I hope they were true Ministers whom they Ordained. As a Bishop was a Lord Bishop, his Lordship was but a mere civill addition annexed to the Bishopric by Regal favour, his Lordship was no ingredient into Ordination.
3 A Bishop, if you consider him meerly as a Bishop, was but a Minister, and set apart to doe the worke of a Minister, the same, which all other Ministers may doe; Bishops did Pray, Preach, Baptize, administer the Lords Supper, Ordaine, Suspend, Excommunicate, and these things other Ministers doe, and may doe; that he did lift up himselfe above other Ministers, that was his errour, that he would take upon him the sole power of Ordination, and Excommunication, this was his errour; but as the addition of an human invention did not null the Ordinances, (as suppose only growne persons had been baptized, and that by dipping, and after dipping they had been signed with the signe of the Crosse, would this have nulled the Ordinance in the Anabaptists esteeme?) no more this usurpation of the power of administring these Ordinances did null a Bishop, so as he was no Minister; the Ordinances were, and are Christs institutions. Indeed you may call him, an Over-growne Presbyter,
4 The Laws of this Realm do account nothing Divine in a Bishop, but his being a Presbyter, 1and therefore the Parliament in their Ordinance for Ordination, tells us, that they did ordain as Presbyters, not as Bishops, much less as Lord Bishops; yea, I have heard a reverend Minister (now Pastor of a Congregational Church in Essex) say, that when the Bishop ordained him, he told him, I do ordain you as I am a Presbyter.
4 The Lawes of this Realme doe account nothing Divine in a Bishop, but his being a Presbyter, 1and therefore the Parliament in their Ordinance for Ordination, tels us, that they did ordaine as Presbyters, not as Bishops, much lesse as Lord Bishops; yea, I have heard a reverend Minister (now Pastor of a Congregationall Church in Essex) say, that when the Bishop ordained him, he told him, I doe ordaine you as I am a Presbyter.
- 1Lond. vind. 125. Dr. Seam. answ. to Diat. p. 85.
5 The Ministers of England are ready to acknowledge those defects, and corruptions which did cleave to their entering into the Ministry by the Bishops; hear their own words, 1We do not deny, but that the way of Ministers entering into the Ministry by the Bishops, had many defects in it, for which they ought to be humbled; but we add, that notwithstanding all the accidental corruptions, yet it is not substantially, and essentially corrupted. They acknowledge then the error, and desire to be humbled for it: what more would you have, God will accept of this I doubt not, and why not you? How to mend Dr. Seamans Divinity I know not, where you have also the error acknowledged implicitly (for it is in answer to this Objection) then giving his judgement in the case: When sin cleaves to the manner of Calling, 2through the general error or corruption of all sorts of people who are concerned in it, &c. it is not otherwise to be invalidated here below, then by doctrinal Censure, and Repentance, ⟨p. 16⟩and not by iteration. Repentance through Christs Blood doth take away corruption out of Gods fight, and will it not (when they are so ingenuous) out of your sight?
5 The Ministers of England are ready to acknowledge those defects, and corruptions which did cleave to their entring into the Ministry by the Bishops; heare their owne words, 1We doe not deny, but that the way of Ministers entring into the Ministry by the Bishops, had many defects in it, for which they ought to be humbled; but we adde, that notwithstanding all the accidentall corruptions, yet it is not substantially, and essentially corrupted. They acknowledge then the errour, and desire to be humbled for it: what more would you have, God will accept of this I doubt not, and why not you? How to mend Dr. Seamans Divinity I know not, where you have also the errour acknowledged implicitely (for it is in answer to this Objection) then giving his judgement in the case: When sinne cleaves to the manner of Calling, 2through the generall errour or corruption of all sorts of people who are concerned in it, &c. it is nototherwise to be invalidated here below, then by doctrinall Censure, and Repentance,
6 There is a maxim taken up among the Independents, 1(yea and others) and it goeth for as good Divinity as any the Gospel hath, viz. That errors in Non-fundamentals must be borne withal in Churches, we must labour indeed to convince people of such, but if they will not be so convinced, we must not proceed any further to cast them out. I have heard the New England Ministers sharply censured, because they have excommunicated for some errors, (i.e. denying of some Ordinances) which are supposed to fall within the compass of Non-fundamentals; This maxim is cried up among the Separatists. For the Thesis it self (considering into what a narrow compass Fundamentals are pent up) I think it to be Apocryphal Divinity, and just it is with God to let in errors in Fundamentals, when such Church, and Truth-destructive Principles are drunk in by godly Christians; yet let us bring this rule, and lay it to the case in hand: I hope they do not make rules for themselves, if it be a true Christian Rule, it is for all Christians; Here then we have men qualified by God with Ministerial, and (abundance of them) personal gifts, they have the election or consent of the people, they are separated to the work of the Ministry by persons, who were Ministers, but did erroneously assume too much to themselves, now grant that here is an error, yet I hope it is not in a fundamental point. Some great Divines call Ordination but an Adjunct, and your selves less, you think it a Toy: so then if you must not be separated from a Church for errors in Non-fundamentals, then neither ought you to separate from a true Church for an error, which is not fundamental. Certainly if that rule hath place any where, then here: you will by this rule keep Anabaptists, Anti-Sabbatarians, Antinomians, (truly such) Anti-Psalmists, Arminians, &c. within your Churches, and not cast them out; but (forsooth) a little error (in comparison of them) and that acknowledged, in the Ministers, that is ground sufficient to cast off them, and call them Antichristians, &c. yet there are no conscientious men but these; the Separatists Gospel will afford Rules for them, but not for other Christians.
6 There is a maxime taken up among the Independents, 1(yea and others) and it goeth for as good Divinity as any the Gospel hath, viz. That errours in Non-fundamentals must be borne withall in Churches, we must labour indeed to convince people of such, but if they will not be so convinced, we must not proceed any further to cast them out. I have heard the New England Ministers sharply censured, because they have excommunicated for some errours, (i.e. denying of some Ordinances) which are supposed to fall within the compasse of Non-fundamentals; This maxime is cryed up among the Separatists. For the Thesis it selfe (considering into what a narrow compasse Fundamentals are pent up) I thinke it to be Apocryphall Divinity, and just it is with God to let in errours in Fundamentals, when such Church, and Truthdestructive Principles are drunke in by godly Christians; yet let us bring this rule, and lay it to the case in hand: I hope they doe not make rules for themselves, if it be a true Christian Rule, it is for all Christians; Here then we have men qualified by God with Ministeriall, and (abundance of them) personal gifts, they have the election or consent of the people, they are separated to the worke of the Ministry by persons, who were Ministers, but did erroneously assume too much to themselves, now grant that here is an errour, yet I hope it is not in a fundamentall point. Some great Divines call Ordination but an Adjunct, and your selves lesse, you thinke it a Toy: so then if you must not be separated from a Church for errours in Nonfundamentals, then neither ought you to separate from a true Church for an errour, which is not fundamentall. Certainly if that rule hath place any where, then here: you will by this rule keepe Anabaptists, Anti-Sabbatarians, Antinomians, (truly such) Anti-Psalmists, Arminians, &c. within your Churches, and not cast them out; but (forsooth) a little errour (in comparison of them) and that acknowledged, in the Ministers, that is ground sufficient to cast off them, and call them Antichristians, &c. yet there are no conscientious men but these; the Separatists Gospel will afford Rules for them, but not for other Christians.
As you trouble the Ministers here, so I doubt they will ⟨p. 25⟩trouble you in the Ordinations of your Ministers; that is, to make it clear to them, that private men have power to Ordain: I have seen it my self, when two private men have imposed their hands upon him, who was to be their Pastor. Another I know, whom a Carpenter and a Taylor Ordained, with imposition of hands; I doubt the Ministers will put you hard to it, to prove that this is according to the Rule, (yea, when other Ministers [but of other Churches] were present, these have imposed hands.) If we consult with the Gospel, we shall find it rather to favour a Bishop (though no Lordly one) by the example of Timothy and Titus, (from whom our Bishops proved their Superiority, and sole power of Ordination) to Ordain, then private men, and that in the presence of divers other Ministers. I am sure this will be hard to prove from Scripture, I shall speak a few words to this point afterward. Suppose any of the Bishops had been of that opinion, that none but persons grown, and making confession of their Faith ought to be Baptized, and they would Baptize only by dipping, would not the Anabaptists have judged this to be true Baptism? would they null this Baptism, because he was a Bishop, since he was a Minister, set apart to that work? &c. as Austin baptized many thus, after he had been in England a while, who yet was an Arch-Bishop, was that no true Baptism? I do not think that the Anabaptists (if they have any brains in their heads) will deny that Baptism were null; if that were good, so is Ordination for the substance of it. If there have been no true Ministers, nor Ordinances, nor Churches, but where there hath been no humane mixtures, nor wicked persons, then there hath been but few Ministers, Ordinances, or Churches, since there was a Church upon earth, and if there ought to be separation from such Ministers and Churches, then we should have found Separatists enough; how hardly was Superstition kept out in the Church of the Jews before the Captivity, say, how many years? 1Afterward, when Christ came, were they clear? what think you then of corrupt Caiaphas the High Priest, his corrupt entering into, and his continuance in the place for one year?
As you trouble the Ministers here, so I doubt they will ⟨p. 25⟩trouble you in the Ordinations of your Ministers; that is, to make it cleare to them, that private men have power to Ordaine: I have seene it my selfe, when two private men have imposed their hands upon him, who was to be their Pastor. Another I know, whom a Carpenter and a Taylor Ordained, with imposition of hands; I doubt the Ministers will put you hard to it, to prove that this is according to the Rule, (yea, when other Ministers [but of other Churches] were present, these have imposed hands.) If we consult with the Gospel, we shall finde it rather to favour a Bishop (though no Lordly one) by the example of Timothy and Titus, (from whom our Bishops proved their Superiority, and sole power of Ordination) to Ordaine, then private men, and that in the presence of divers other Ministers. I am sure this will be hard to prove from Scripture, I shall speake a few words to this point afterward. Suppose any of the Bishops had been of that opinion, that none but persons growne, and making confession of their Faith ought to be Baptized, and they would Baptize only by dipping, would not the Anabaptists have judged this to be true Baptisme? would they null this Baptisme, because he was a Bishop, since he was a Minister, set apart to that worke? &c. as Austin baptized many thus, after he had been in England a while, who yet was an Arch-Bishop, was that no true Baptisme? I doe not thinke that the Anabaptists (if they have any braines in their heads) will deny that Baptisme were nul; if that were good, so is Ordination for the substance of it. If there have been no true Ministers, nor Ordinances, nor Churches, but where there hath been no humane mixtures, nor wicked persons, then there hath been but few Ministers, Ordinances, or Churches, since there was a Church upon earth, and if there ought to be separation from such Ministers and Churches, then we should have found Separatists enough; how hardly was Superstition kept out in the Church of the Jewes before the Captivity, say, how many yeares?