pp. 45–464 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
But we with good warrant •oe aver, that the precept which forbiddeth the resisting of the civill power, and in general the denying ⟨p. 46⟩of obedience to the lawful commandments of our Superiors, is of greater obligation then the precept of not scandalizing. Their first reason I put in form to them thus. That is of greater obligation which commandeth acts edificative to all, then that which commandeth acts edificative to some only, for the good of all is to be preferred to the good of some particular persons, and we are to have a greater care of the salvation of all, then of some. But the precept of obedience to Superiors is universal, and commandeth the act of edifying all to wit, obedience to Superiors, and an act to eschew the scandal of all to wit, disobedience. But the precept of eschewing the scandal of some, doth but edify some only, and not all Ergo &c.
But we with good warrant •oe averre, that the precept which fobiddeth the resisting of the civill power, and in generall the denying ⟨p. 46⟩of obedience to the lawfull commandements of our Superiors, is of greater obligation then the precept of not scandalizing. Their first reason I put in forme to them thus. That is of greater obligation which commandeth acts edificative to all, then that which commandeth acts edificative to some only, for the good of all is to be preferred to the good of some particular persons, and we are to have a greater care of the salvation of all, then of some. But the precept of obedience to Superiours is universall, and commandeth the act of edifying all to wit, obedience to Superiours, and an act to eschew the scandall of all to wit, disobedience. But the precept of eschewing the scandall of some, doth but edifie some only, and not all Ergo &c.
Ans. 1. It is soon proved by your learning, for the precept of Gods law to eschew scandal, to you is no precept, and so of no obligation, when Superiors command to scandalize, so you may prove that snow is whiter then the raven, when as the raven is not white at all.
Ans. 1. It is soon proved by your learning, for the precept of Gods law to eschew scandall, to you is no precept, and so of no obligation, when Superiours command to scandalize, so you may prove that snow is whiter then the raven, when as the raven is not white at all.
I answer. 2. That precept is of greater obligation that commandeth acts edificative to all, then that which commandeth acts edificative to some. It is true, 1. if it be a lawful command of God, but the assumption applied to your purpose is most false, the command to obey Prelates, when they command things indifferent, the obedience whereof doth culpably occasion the murdering of him, for whom Christ died, is not a commandment edificative to all, yea, it is a Commandment of acts destructive to the souls of all. This Argument would have some colour, if it were not a vain begging of the question, for they lay down as, confessed, that the practise of Ceremonies, from whence many souls are ruined, is obedience, and obedience to the fifth Commandment. This is to be proven, and constantly denied by us, because disobedience to the sixth Commandment, and murdering of our brother, cannot be obedience to the fifth Commandment.
I answer. 2. That precept is of greater obligation that commandeth acts edificative to all, then that which commandeth acts edificative to some. It is true, 1. if it be a lawfull command of God, but the •ssumption applyed to your purpose is most false, the command to obey Prelates, when they command things indifferent, the obedience whereof doth culpably occasion the murthering of him, for whom Christ died, is not a commandement edificative to all, yea, it is a Commandement of acts destructive to the soules of all. This Argument would have some colour, if it were not a vaine begging of the question, for they lay downe as, confessed, that the practise of Ceremonies, from whence many soules are ruined, is obedience, and obedience to the fift Commandement. This is to be proven, and constantly denyed by us, because disobedience to the sixth Commandement, and murthering of our brother, cannot be obedience to the fift Commandement.