Answer 1. This is a wide step, to make all things in Scripture, either matters of faith, or matters indifferent. That there were eight persons in Noah's Ark, and that Sampson s•ew a thousand with the jaw bone of an ass, are not matters of faith, as matters of faith are contradistinguished, from things indifferent, many are saved, who neither know nor believe many things of this historical verity in Scripture, yet are they not matters indifferent. But the Doctors are reconcilers with the Belgic Arminians, who deny all the things controverted betwixt Papists and us, and betwixt us and Arminians, and Anabaptists, at least the most part of them to be fundamental▪ and that either side may be believed, and holden, without hazard of salvation, and therefore we are to lean to the Churches determination in these without farther inquiry. 2 They mean, that in matters controverted, and in all things indifferent; as whether in this, or that fact, we do murder him for whom Christ died; We are to give our faith and conscience over to the Church without further trial. 3. What if we be▪ not persuaded of the indifferency of the things commanded but doubt whether they be commanded or forbidden in the Word, as is now the present case of Ceremonies to us, for we cannot be persuaded of their indifferency, and the Doctors saith they are not matters of faith. Ergo, by their own doctrine their distinction is defective. 4. Scripture is also perfect in resolving us, what is scandal and murdering of our brother, as what is Idolatry and Blasphemy, and therefore we are not to hang our faith here upon the Churches Canons without farther trial, as you say. 5. That the Scripture is perfect in matters of faith, but imperfect in matters of Policy, that is in matters wherein we may kill him for whom Christ died, is no better then the Papists distinction, who teach us that the Scripture is perfect in the articles of faith, not in traditions, so Scotus asaith. True Theology according to Divine revelation is only of things in Scripture, or which may be deduced out of Scripture. And Suarez bsaith, Things that belong to accidentarie rites are left to the Churches determination, but the Scripture implicitly containeth all articles of fear ⟨p. 45⟩faith. And so saith cBannes, and dDuvallius. 6.
Answer 1. This is a wide step, to make all things in Scripture, either matters of faith, or matters indifferent. That there were eight persons in Noahs Arke, and that Sampson s•ew a thousand with the jaw bone of an asse, are not matters of faith, as matters of faith are contradistinguished, from things indifferent, many are saved, who neither know nor believe many things of this historicall veritie in Scripture, yet are they not matters indifferent. But the Doctors are reconcilers with the Belgik Arminians, who deny all the things contraverted betwixt Papists and us, and betwixt us and Arminians, and Anabaptists, at least the most part of them to be fundamentall▪ and that either side may be believed, and holden, without hazard of salvation, and therefore we are to leane to the Churches determination in these without farther inquirie. 2 They mean, that in matters contraverted, and in all things indifferent; as whether in this, or that fact, we doe murther him for whom Christ died; Wee are to give our faith and conscience over to the Church without further tryall. 3. What if wee be▪ not perswaded of the indifferencie of the things commanded but doubt whether they bee commanded or forbidden in the Word, as is now the present case of Ceremonies to us, for we cannot be perswaded of their indifferencie, and the Doctors saith they are not matters of faith. Ergo, by their own doctrine their distinction is defective. 4. Scripture is also perfect in resolving us, what is scandall and murthering of our brother, as what is Idolatrie and Blasphemie, and therefore we are not to hang our faith here upon the Churches Canons without farther tryall, as you say. 5. That the Scripture is perfect in matters of faith, but imperfect in matters of Policie, that is in matters wherein we may kill him for whom Christ died, is no better then the Papists distinction, who teach us that the Scripture is perfect in the articles of faith, not in traditions, so Scotus asaith. True Theologie according to Divine revelation is onely of things in Scripture, or which may be deduced out of Scripture. And Suarez bsaith, Things that belong to accidentarie rites are left to the Churches determination, but the Scripture implicitly containeth all articles of feare ⟨p. 45⟩faith. And so saith cBannes, and d
- aScotus prol. in sent. q. 3. ad art. 3.
- bSuarez 10. •e leg. cap. 1. & de trip. vi••. Theology, Tract. 1. disp. •. q. •.Suarez 10. •e leg. cap. 1. & de trip. vi••. Theologie, Tract. 1. disp. •. q. •.
- cBanne•, tom. in q 1. ••• 10. dub 2.
- dDuvallius, 2 tract. de legib q 5. art. 1. •d ar• 2.