pp. 40–435 passages
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
As for that which ye say, that when Scandal may be taken at the doing of the thing commanded, then the thing commanded becometh inexpedient, and so ought not to be obeyed; that ye be not more deceived with this error, we pray you mark, that a thing commanded, by our Superiors, in Church or Policy, m•y be two ways inexpedient, to wit, either in respect of some particular Persons, who th•ough weakness, or malice, do stumble at it, or else in respect of the body in general, because it is contrary to Order, Decency and Edification. If the thing commanded be inexpedient, the former way, we may indeed, in such a case, for eschewing the Scandal of the weak, forbear the practice of the thing commanded, Hic, & nunc, in some particular places, and times: providing always we do this without offence of our Superiors, and without the scandal of others, but we cannot totally forbear practice, for we are to look more to the utility, which the body of the Church may receive, by the thing commanded, and by our obedience to our Superiors, then to some particular persons. 47. But if the thing commanded be in our private judgement inexpedient, the other way, we ought not for that, to deny Obedience to the laws of the Church; for when the inexpediency of a thing is questionable, and probable arguments may be brought, pro and contra, concerning the expediency of it, we have sufficient warrant to practise it, if the Church enact it as expedient. Otherwayes your way is so dangerous, that there shall never be peace, nor unity in the Church, for men ordinarily are divided in judgement, concerning the expediency of things. Suppose a Synod consisting of one hundred Pastors, threescore shall think this particular Ceremony expedient, for the good of the Church, and in respect of plurality of voices▪ make an act to be concluded for the establishing of it, shall the remnant forty, who are of the contrary judgement, deny obedience to the acts of the Synod?
As for that which yee say, that when Scandall may be taken at the doing of the thing commanded, then the thing commanded becommeth inexpedient, and so ought not to be obeyed; that yee be not more deceived with this errour, we pray you marke, that a thing commanded, by our Superiours, in Church or Policie, m•y be two wayes inexpedient, to wit, either in respect of some particular Persons, who th•ough weaknesse, or mali•e, doe stumble at it, or else in respect of the body in generall, because it is contrary to Order, Decencie and Edification. If the thing commanded be inexpedient, the former way, we may indeed, in such a case, for eschewing the Scandall of the weake, forbeare the practice of the thing commanded, Hic, & nunc, in some particular places, and times: provyding alwayes we doe this without offence of our Superiours, and without the scandall of others, but we cannot totally forbeare practice, for we are to looke more to the utilitie, which the body of the Church may receive, by the thing commanded, and by our obedience to our Superiours, then to some particular persons. 47. But if the thing commanded be in our private judgement inexpedient, the other way, we ought not for that, to deny Obedience to the lawes of the Church; for when the inexpediencie of a thing is questionable, and probable arguments may be brought, pro and contra, concerning the expediencie of it, wee have sufficient warrant to practise it, if the Church inact it as expedient. Otherwayes your way is so dangerous, that there shall never be peace, nor unitie in the Church, for men ordinarily are divided in judgement, concerneing the expediencie of things. Suppose a Synode consisting of one hundred Pastours, threescore shall think this particular Ceremonie expedient, for the good of the Church, and in respect of pluralitie of voyces▪ make an act to be concluded for the establishing of it, shall the remnant fourty, who are of the contrary judgement, deny obedience to the acts of the Synode?
Answer. 1. This distinction of inexpedient in the matter of indifferent Ceremonies is Popish and vain, for if the Ceremony be indifferent, and may be wanted in the worship of God (as these Ceremonies be) if one soul, for whom Christ died, shall be murdered thereby, it is hoc ipso, to be judged inexpedient and scandalous in it self, and so cannot fall under the object of a Church Canon, as 1 Cor. 8. 13. If meat make my brother to stumble (he saith not the whole Church) I will not eat. Ergo, he cannot command others to eat. 1 Cor. 10. 28. But if any man, [Greek or Hebrew], say to you, this is offered in sacrifice to Idols, eat not, [Greek or Hebrew], for his sake that showed it. Ergo, if it seem expedient, and so be scandalous to one, let alone to a whole Church, we are totally to forbear it, and Paul would, while the world standeth, 1 Cor. 8. 13. forbear it. 2. You will not have us to forbear a thing indifferent, that actively (for the passive scandal, I hope, you regard not as a scandal) doth scandalize, but with a provision that we do it without offence of Superiors, and without the scandal of others. But I ask, Doctors, what you mean by Offence of Superiors, if you mean without displeasing and inciting our Superiors to anger. 1. You ignorantly confound displeasing and Scandalizing, When a Pastor rebuketh Superiors, as Jeremiah, Elijah, and John Baptist, in the good old world did, they did displease Superiors, but not scandalize them; yea, they did edify their Superiors, while as they did offend them. It is wicked Divinity, to mean, that we are not to eschew the murdering of a weak brother for whom Christ died providing we offend not, that is, displease not our Superiors. Will you to please men displease the God of heaven, and commit spiritual homicide? This is worse then Popery.
Answer. 1. This distinction of inexpedient in the matter of indifferent Ceremonies is Popish and vaine, for if the Ceremonie be indifferent, and may be wanted in the worship of God (as these Ceremonies be) if one soule, for whom Christ died, shall be murthered thereby, it is hoc ipso, to be judged inexpedient and scandalous in it selfe, and so cannot fall under the object of a Church Canon, as 1 Cor. 8. 13. If meat make my brother to stumb'le (he saith not the whole Church) I will not eat. Ergo, he cannot command others to eat.
But if you mean, that we are to forbear the thing commanded for eschewing the scandal of the weak, providing we do it without the offence of Superiors, that is without the active scandalizing of Superiors, then 1. your distinction is vain, for if we scandalize culpably our superiors by our forbearance, though it be inexpedient to all private persons, we are not to forbear, because in no case can we break the sixth Commandment, and scandalize our Superiors. 2. You shall be forced to give• case, wherein we are necessitated by Gods ⟨p. 42⟩providence, and that by way of contradiction, whether we forbear, or forbear not, to murder either the souls of some weak ones, or the souls of Superiors, by our forbearance of the practice of things judged expedient by Superiors, you make us to murder the souls of Superiors by the non-forbearance, or you will have us to murder the souls of weak brethren, if we practise. This is a wronging of Providence, and a Manichean tenet, that we can be under such a necessity of sinning. Yea, there must be two centra•y revealed wills in God, commanding, by forbearing the Ceremonies, not to murder Superiors, and commanding by not forbearing, not to murder weak brethren; and so God commandeth both to forbear, and also not to forbear. If you say, the weak may be informed, and then it is a passive scandal only, and practising is lawful at the commandment of Superiors. I answer, 1. Then your distinction hath no use here. 2. I answer. Let the Superiors, who have more knowledge, be informed, that to abstain from a practice, that may murder any one redeemed by Christ, is Christs commandment (Thou shalt do no murder) then it is but a passive scandal, and not an active, or culpably given scandal. Ergo, we are to forbear the thing commanded for eschewing of the scandall▪ (hic & nunc) of the weak, even though with the offence, that is the passive scandal of Superiors and others, which is contradictory to the Doctors. 3. If we may forbear obedience to Gods positive Commandements, hic & nunc, for eschewing of Scandal, far more may we, hic & nunc, not crosse, not kneel, hic & nunc, when crossing and kneeling murdereth one for whom Christ died, even though it offend our Superiors. Ergo, this provision of the Doctors is vain;
But if you meane, that wee are to forbeare the thing commanded for eschewing the scandall of the weake, providing we doe it without the offence of Superiours, that is without the active scandalizing of Superiours, then 1. your distinction is vaine, for if we scandalize culpably our superiours by our forbearance, though it be inexpedient to all private persons, we are not to forbeare, because in no case can we breake the sixt Commandement, and scandalize our Superiours. 2. You shall be forced to give case, wherein we are necessitated by Gods
and Superiors are unjustly offended, if our non-murdering of weak brethren offend them, nor are we to care for the Doctors provision here. 4. No utility can truly redound to the whole Church by practising of an indifferent thing which culpably occasioneth the murdering of a weak brother, Except our Doctors mean, that sin may edify the whole Church. 5. They say, if the things in our private judgement be inexpedient the second way, that is to the Church, the Church cannot Command them, except the Church command against ⟨p. 43⟩her conscience. 6. If matters in their expediency be questionable and probable on both sides, the Churches determination should end the controversy (saith the Doctors) this is the Doctrine of the Jesuits, aSuarez. bThomas Sanches, and cGregor de valent. as I show before dwhen a thing is probable, and I be resolved in conscience against neither of the sides, and fear the one side be murdering him, for whom Christ died, which is against Gods commandment, and know that humane authority commandeth the contrary and am persuaded it is indifferent, and a positive commandment of men, if the Churches determination be here to sway my conscience; to practise, is to me blind obedience, for humane authority as it is such, giveth no light. Ergo, it cannot remove my doubting, and beget faith; and also the conscience is so much the bolder to venture on a sin, against God, for fear of eschewing a sin against men, which is questionable, and in a matter indifferent, this is also the stout conscience of Bonaventura 2 sent. dist. 39. plus est standum praecepto Praelati quam conscientiae. 7. Our Doctors say, our way is against the peace of the Church: But I answer, their way is Popish, and against the truth of God, in commanding our consciences to rest upon the wicked will of men. And their instance of a Synod of a hundred Pastors may be brought aswell to prove the Synod of Trent is to be obeyed, as for the present purpose,
and Superiours are unjustly offended, if our nonmurthering of weake brethren offend them, nor are we to care for the Doctors provision here. 4. No utilitie can truly redound to the whole Church by practising of an indifferent thing which culpably occasioneth the murthering of a weake brother, Except our Doctors meane, that sinne may edifie the whole Church. 5. They say, if the things in our private judgement be inexpedient the second way, that is to the Church, the Church cannot Command them, except the Church command against