pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 17 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
RID. By the words and deeds which Christ said and did, and commanded us to do the same.
WAT. It is a thing commonly received of all, that the sacraments of the new law give grace to them that worthily receive.
RID. True it is, that grace is given by the sacrament, but as by an instrument. The inward virtue and Christ give the grace through the sacrament.
WAT. What is a sacrament?
RID. I remember there may be many definitions of a sacrament in Augustine: but I will take that which seemeth most fit to this purpose. A sacrament is a visible sign of invisible grace.
WAT. Ergo, Grace is given to the receivers.
RID. The union or conjunction with Christ through the Holy Ghost is grace, and by the sacrament we are made members of the mystical body of Christ, for by the sacrament part of the body is grafted in the head.
RID. The uni•n or conjunction with Christ through the Holy Ghost is grace, and by the sacrament we are made members of the mystical body of Christ, for by the sacrament part of the body is grafted in the head.
WAT. But there is a difference between the mystical body, and natural body.
RID. There is (I grant you) a difference, but the head of them both is one.
WAT. The eucharist is a sacrament of the New Testament. ERGO, It hath a promise of grace. BUT no promise of grace is made of bread and wine. ERGO, Bread and wine are not the sacraments of the New Testament.
RID. I grant that grace pertaineth to the eucharist, according to this saying, "The bread which we break, is it not the communication or partaking of the body of Christ?" And like as he that eateth, and he that drinketh unworthily of the sacrament of the body and blood of the Lord, eateth and drinketh his own damnation▪ even so he that eateth and drinketh worthily, eateth life, and drinketh life. I grant also, that there is no pro••se made to bread and wine. But in •smuch as they are sanctified, and made the sacraments of the body and blood of the Lord▪ they […] a promise of grace annexed unto them▪ […], of spiritual partaking of the body of Christ to be communicated and given, not to the bread and wine, but to ⟨p. 351⟩them who worthily receive the sacrament.
RID. I grant that grace pertaineth to the eucharist, according to this saying, "The bread which we break, is it not the communication or partaking of the body of Christ?" And like as he that eateth, and he that drinketh unworthily of the sacrament of the body and blood of the Lord, eateth and drinketh his own damnat••n▪ even so he that eateth and drinketh worthily, eateth life, and drinketh life. I grant also, that there is no pro••se made to bread and wine. But in •smuch as they are sanctified, and made the sacraments of the body and blood of the Lord▪ they 〈…〉 a promise of grace annex•d unto them▪ 〈…〉, of spiritual partaking of the body of Christ to be communicated and given, not to the bread and wine, but to ⟨p. 351⟩them who worthily receive the sacrament.
WAT. If the substance of bread and wine do remain, then the union betwixt Christ and us is promised to them that take bread and wine. BUT that union is not promised to bread and wine, but to the receivers of the flesh and blood. John 6. "He that eateth my flesh," &c. ERGO, The substance of bread and wine remaineth not.
RID. The promise undoubtedly is made to the flesh and blood, but the same is to be received in the sacrament through faith.
WAT. Every sacrament hath a promise of grace annexed unto it. ERGO, The bread and wine are not sacraments.
RID. True it is, every sacrament hath grace annexed unto it instrumentally. But there are divers understandings of this word [ •abet] "hath." For the sacrament hath not grace included in it; but to those that receive it well, it is turned to grace. After that manner the water in baptism hath grace promised, and by that the Holy Spirit is given; not that grace is included in water, but that grace cometh by water.
WAT. This promise is made to the flesh and blood of Christ, and not to the bread and wine. ERGO, The sacrament is not bread and wine, but the body and blood of Christ.
RID. There is no promise made to him that taketh common bread and common wine, but to him that receiveth in the sanctified bread▪ and bread of the communion, there is a large promise of grace made; neither is the promise given to the symbol•, but to the thing of the sacrament. But the thing of the sacrament is the flesh and blood.
WAT. Every sacrament of the New Testament giveth grace, promised of God to those that worthily receive it.
WAT. Every sacrament of the New Testament giveth grac•, promised of God to those that worthily receive it.
RID. This sacrament hath a promise of grace made to those who receive it worthily, because grace is given by it, as by an instrument, not that Christ hath transfused grace into bread and wine.
WAT. But this promise which is made, is only to those that worthily receive the flesh and blood; not the bread and wine.
RID. That proposition of your's hath a double understanding. There is no promise made to them that receive common bread, as it were; but to those that worthily receive the sanctified bread, there is a promise of grace made, as Origen doth testify.
WAT. Where is that promise made?
RID. "The bread which we brake, is it not a communication of the body of Christ?" And, "We being many are one bread, one body of Christ."
WAT. What doth he mean by bread in that place?
RID. The bread of the Lord's table; the communion of the body of Christ.
WAT. Hear what Chrysostom saith upon that passage: "The bread which we break, is it not the communication of Christ's body? Wherefore did he not say, participation? Because he would signify some great matter, and that he would declare a great convenience and conjunction betwixt the same. For we do not communicate by participation only, and receiving, but also by co-uniting. For, like as that body is co united to Christ, so also we by the same bread are united to him."
RID. Let Chrysostom have his manner of speaking, and his sentence. If it be true, I reject it not. But let it not be prejudicial to me to name it true bread.
WAT. "All (saith Chrysostom) which sit together at one board, do communicate together of one true body. What do I call (saith he) this communicating? We are all the self same body. What doth bread signify? The body of Christ. What ate they that receive it? The body of Christ. For ⟨p. 352⟩many are but one body." Chrysostom doth interpret this place against you: "All we be one bread, and one mystical body, which do participate together one bread of Christ."
RID. All we be one mystical body, which do communicate of one Christ in bread, after the efficacy of regeneration or quickening.
WAT. Of what manner of bread speaketh he?
RID. Of the bread of the Lord's table.
WAT. Is that bread one?
RID. It is one, of the church being one, because one bread is set forth upon the table: and so of one bread all together do participate, which communicate at the table of the Lord.
WAT. See how absurdly you speak. Do you say, all which be from the beginning to the end of the world?
RID. All, I say, which at one table together have communicated in the mysteries might well so do. But the heavenly and celestial bread is likewise one also, whereof the sacramental bread is a mystery: the which being one, all we together do participate.
WAT. A perverse answer. Which all? Mean you all christian men?
RID. I do distribute this word [All]: for all were wont together to communicate of the one bread divided into parts. All, I say, which were one congregation, and which all did communicate together at one table.
WAT. What? Do you then exclude then from the body of Christ all them who did not communicate, being present?
FECK. But Cyprian saith, "Bread which no multitude doth consume." Which cannot be understood but only of the body of Christ.
RID. Also Cyprian in this place did speak of the true body of Christ, and not of material bread.