pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 16 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
GLIN. That church ever hath worshipped the flesh of Christ in the eucharist. BUT the church hath never been idolatrous. ERGO, It hath always judged the flesh of Christ to be in the eucharist,
RID. And I also worship Christ in the sacrament, but not because he is included in the sacrament, like as I worship Christ also in the scriptures, not because he is really included in them. Notwithstanding▪ I say, that the body of Christ is present in the sacrament, but yet sacramentally and spiritually, according to his grace giving life, and in that respect really, that is, according to his benediction giving life. FURTHERMORE, I acknowledge, gladly, the true body of Christ to be in the Lord's supper, in such sort as the church of Christ (which is the spouse of Christ, and is taught of the Holy Ghost, and guided by God's word) doth acknowledge the same. But the true church of Christ doth acknowledge a presence of Christ's body in the Lord's supper to be communicated to the godly, by grace, and spiritually, as I have often showed, and by a sacramental signification, but not by the corporal presence of the body of his flesh.
RID. And I also worship Christ in the sacrament, but not because he is included in the sacrament, like as I worship Christ also in the scriptures, not because he is really included in them. Notwithstanding▪ I say, that the body of Christ is present in the sacrament, but yet sacramentally and spiritually, according to his grace giving life, and in that respect really, that is, according to his benediction giving life. FURTHERMORE, I acknowledge, gladly, the true body of Christ to be in the Lord's supper, in such sort as the church of Christ (which is the spouse of Christ, and is taught of the Holy Ghost, and guided by God's word) doth acknowledge the same. But the true church of Christ doth acknowledge a presence of Christ's body in the Lord's supper to be communicated to the godly, by grace, and spiritually, as I have often shewed, and by a sacramental signification, but not by the corporal presence of the body of his flesh.
GLIN. Austin saith, "Some there were who thought us, instead of bread and of the cup, to worship Ceres and Bacchus." FROM whence I gather, that there was an adoration of the sacrament among the fathers; and Erasmus in an epistle to the brethren of Low-Germany, saith, that the worshipping of the sacrament was before Austin and Cyprian.
GLIN. Austin saith, "Some there were who thought us, instead of bread and of the cup, to worship Ceres and Bacchus." FROM wh•nce I gather, that there was an adoration of the sacrament among the fathers; and Erasmus in an epistle to the brethren of Low-Germany, saith, that the worshipping of the sacrament was before Austin and Cypr••n.
RID. We do handle the signs reverently: but we worship the sacrament as a sacrament, not as a thing signified by the sacrament.
GLIN. What is the symbol of sacrament?
RID. Bread.
GLIN. Ergo, We worship bread.
RID. There is a deceit in this word [adoramus.] We worship the symbols, when reverently we handle them. We worship Christ wheresoever we perceive his benefits. But we understand his benefit to be the greatest in the sacrament.
GLIN. So I may fall down before the bench here, and worship Christ: and if any man ask me what I do, I may answer, I worship Christ.
RID. We adore and worship Christ in the eucharist. And if you mean the external sacrament; I say, that also is to be worshipped as a sacrament.
GLIN. So was the faith of the primitive church.
RID. Would to God we would all follow the faith of that church.
GLIN. Think you that Christ hath now his church?
RID. I do so.
GLIN. But all the church adoreth Christ, verily and really in the sacrament.
RID. You know yourself that the eastern church would not acknowledge transubstantiation, as appeareth in the council of Florence.
•OLE. That is false. For in the same they did acknowledge transubstantiation, although they would not entreat of the matter, for that they ha• not in their commission so to do.
•OLE. That is false. For in the same they did acknowledge transubstantiation, although they would not intreat of the matter, for that they ha• not in their commission so to do.
RID. Nay, they would determine nothing of the matter, when the article was propounded unto them.
RID. Nay, they would determine nothing of the matter, when the article was prop•unded unto them.
••LE. I• was not because they did not acknowledge the […], but because they had no commission •o to do.
••LE. I• was not because they did not acknowledge the 〈…〉, but because they had no commission •o to do.
CU•TOR Reverend […] ▪ I will prove and declare, that the body of Christ is truly and really in the […] whereas the holy fathers, both of […] church, have written both many things and no less manifest of the same matter, yet […] only Chrysostom. THAT which is in the cup, is the same that flowed from the side of Christ. BUT true and pure blood did flow from the side of Christ ERGO, His true and pure blood is in the cup.
CU•TOR Reverend 〈…〉 ▪ I will prove and declare, that the body of Christ is truly and really in the 〈…〉 whereas the holy fathers, both of 〈…〉 church, have written both many things and no less manifest of the same matter, yet 〈…〉 only Chrysostom. THAT which is in the cup, is the same that flowed from the side of Christ. BUT true and pure blood did flow from the side of Christ ERGO, His true and pure blood is in the cup.
RID. It is his true blood which is in the chalice, I grant, and the same which sprang from the side of Christ. But how? It is blood indeed, in which it sprang from his side. For here is the blood, but by way of a sacrament.
AGAIN. I say, like as the bread of the sacrament and of thanksgiving is called the body of Christ given for us; so the cup of the Lord is called the blood which sprang from the side of Christ. But as the sacramental bread is called the body, because it is the sacrament of his body: even so likewise the cup is called the blood which flowed out of Christ's side, because it is the sacrament of that blood which flowed out of his side, instituted by the Lord himself for ou• singular advantage; namely, for our spiritual nourishment: like as baptism is ordained in water to spiritual regeneration.
CUR. The sacrament of the blood is not blood.
RID. The sacrament of the blood is the blood, and that is attributed to the sacrament, which is spoken of the thing of the sacrament.
[HI•E Weston repeateth Curtop's argument in English.]
WEST. That which is in the chalice, is the same which flowed out of Christ's side. BUT there came out very blood. ERGO, There is blood in the chalice.
RID. The blood of Christ is in the chalice indeed, but not in the real presence, but by grace, and in a sacrament.
WEST. That is very well. Then we have blood in the chalice.
RID. It is true, but by grace, and in a sacrament.
[HERE the people hissed at him.]
RID. O my masters! I take this for no judgment: I will stand to God's judgment.
WAT. Good sir, I have determined to have respect of the time, and to ••stain from all those things which may hinder the progress of our disputation; and therefore first I ask this question; when Christ said in the sixth of John, "He that eateth my flesh," &c. doth he signify in those words •he eating of his true and natural flesh, or else of the bread and symbol?
RID. I understand that place of the very flesh of Christ to be eaten, but spiritually: and further I say, that the sacrament also pertaineth unto the spiritual eating. For without the spirit to eat the sacrament is to •at •t unprofitably. For whoso eateth not spiritually, he eateth his own condemnation.
WAT. I ask then, whether the eucharist be a sacrament?
RID. The eucharist, taken for a sign or symbol, is a sacrament.
WAT. Is it instituted of God?
RID. It is instituted of God.
WAT. Where?
RID In the supper.
WAT. With what words is it […] a sacrament?
WAT. With what words is it 〈…〉 a sacrament?