pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 19 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
WAT. But the Lamb of God lieth on the table.
RID. It is a figurative speech, for in our mind we understand him which is in heaven.
WAT. But he lieth there, as the Greek word imports.
RID. He lieth there, that is, he is there present, not corporally, but he lieth there in his operation.
WAT. He lieth, but his operation lieth not.
RID. You think very grossly of the sitting or lying of the celestial Lamb on the table of the Lord. For we may not imagine any such sitting or lying upon the table, as the reason of man would judge: but all things are here to be understood spiritually. For that heavenly Lamb is (as I confess) on the table, but by a spiritual presence, by grace, and not after any corporal substance of his flesh taken out of the virgin Mary. AND indeed the same canon doth plainly teach, that the bread which is set on the table is material bread; and therefore it (the canon I mean) commandeth that we should not creep on the ground in our thoughts, to those things which are set before us: as who should say, what other things are they (as much as pertaineth to their true substance) than bread and wine? but rather, saith the canon, lifting up our minds into heaven, let us consider with faith the Lamb of God which taketh away the sins of the world, sitting or lying upon the table. For a lifted up faith, saith he, seeth him which sitteth on the right hand of God the Father, after the true manner of a body set by grace on the Lord's table, and taking away the sins of the world. For I think you mean not so, as though the Lamb did lie there prostrate with his members spread upon the table.
SMITH. I bring another place out of the council of Nice: "None of the apostles said, this is a figure of the body of Christ▪ none of the reverend elders ••id, the unbloody sacrifice of the altar to be a figure. ERGO, […] deceived.
SMITH. I bring another place out of the council of Nice: "None of the apostles said, this is a figure of the body of Christ▪ none of the reverend elders ••id, the un•loody sacrifice of the altar to be a figure. ERGO, 〈…〉 deceived.
RID. This […] of Nice. For I have read over t•is […] many times.
RID. This 〈…〉 of Nice. For I have read over t•is 〈…〉 many times.
THEN came in another whom Mr. Ridley knew not, and said, "The universal church both of the Greeks and Latins, of the east and of the west, have agreed in the council of Florence, uniformly, in the doctrine of the sacrament, that in the sacrament of the altar there is the true and real body.
RID. I deny the Greek and the east church to have agreed either in the council at Florence, or at any time else, with the Romish church, in the doctrine of transubstantiation of bread into the body of Christ. Fo• there was nothing in the council of Florence, wherein the Greeks would agree with the Romanists; however I confess, it was left for every church to use, as they were wont, leavened or unleavened bread. HERE cried out Dr. Cole, and said, they agreed together concerning transubstantiation of bread into ⟨p. 356⟩the body of Christ Dr. Ridley said that could not be. THEN started up another, unknown to Dr. Ridley, but thought to be one of the scribes, who affirmed with him, that indeed there was nothing decreed concerning transubstantiation; the council left that as a matter not meet nor worthy to disturb the peace and concord of the church. To whom Dr. Ridley answered again, that he said the truth.
PIE. What say you to that council, where it is said, that the priest doth offer an unbloody sacrifice of the body of Christ?
PYE. What say you to that council, where it is said, that the priest doth offer an unbloody sacrifice of the body of Christ?
RID. I say, it is well said, if it be rightly understood.
PIE. But he offered an unbloody sacrifice.
PYE. But he offered an unbloody sacrifice.
RID. It was called unbloody, and is offered after a certain manner, and in a mystery, and as a representation of that bloody sacrifice, and he doth not lye, which saith Christ to be offered.
WEST. I with one argument will throw down to the ground your opinion, out of Chrysostom, Hom. xxiv. in 1 Cor. And I will teach, not only a figure and a sign, or grace only, but the very same body, which was here conversant on the earth, to be in the eucharist. (1) WE worship the self-same body in the eucharist, which the wise men did worship in the manger. (2) BUT that was his natural and real body, not spiritual. (3) ERGO, The real body of Christ is in the eucharist. AGAIN, the same Chrysostom saith, "We have not here the Lord in a manger, but on the altar. Here a woman holdeth him not in her hands, but a priest."
RID. We worship, I confess, the same true Lord and Saviour of the world, which the wise men worshipped in the manger; howbeit we do it in a mystery, and in the sacrament of the Lord's supper, and that in spiritual liberty, as saith St. Austin, l. 3. De Doctrina Christiana; not in carnal servitude; that is, we do not worship servilely the signs for the things; for that should be, as he also saith, a part of a servile infirmity. But we behold with the eyes of faith him present after grace, and spiritually set upon the table; and we worship him which sitteth above, and is worshipped of the angels. For Christ is always assistant to his mysteries, as the said Augustine saith. And the Divine Majesty, as Cyprian saith, doth never absent himself from the divine mysteries; but this assistance and presence of Christ, as in baptism it is wholly spiritual, and by grace, and not by any corporal substance of the flesh, even so it is here in the Lord's supper, being rightly and according to the word of God duly ministered.
WEST. That which the woman did hold in her womb, the same holdeth the priest.
RID. I grant the priest holdeth the same thing, but after another manner. She did hold the […] body; the priest holdeth the mystery of the body.
RID. I grant the priest holdeth the same thing, but after another manner. She did hold the 〈…〉 body; the priest holdeth the mystery of the body.
HERE Weston again repeated his argument out of Chrysostom in English.
RID. I say that the author meant it spiritually.
[HERE the prolocutor, Dr. Weston, put an end to the disputation with these words: You see the stubborn, the boasting, the crafty, the unconstant mind of this man. Here you, see this day, that the strength of the truth is without foil. Therefore, I beseech you all most earnestly to blow the note of triumph: having said this, he began, and they followed, exclaiming, "Truth hath the victory, Truth hath the victory."]
[HERE the prolocut•r, Dr. Weston, put an end to the disputation with these words: You see the stubborn, the boasting, the crafty, the unconstant mind of this man. Here you, see this day, that the strength of the truth is without foil. Therefore, I beseech you all most earnestly to blow the note of triumph: having said this, he began, and they followed, exclaiming, "Truth hath the victory, Truth hath the victory."]
BISHOP Latimer was brought out to dispute upon Wednesday, April 18. This disputation began at eight o'clock, and was conducted in much ⟨p. 357⟩the same manner as those preceding, except that most part of it was in English: for the bishop alleged, that he was out of use with the Latin, and unfit for that place.
BISHOP Latimer was brought out to dispute upon Wednesday, April 18. This disputation began at eight o'clock, and was conducted in much ⟨p. 357⟩the same manner as those preceding, except that most part of it was in English: for the bishop alledged, that he was out of use with the Latin, and unfit for that place.
MR. SMITH of Oriel college, Dr. Cartwright, Mr. Harpsfield, and others, replied to him, with many cruel insinuations and bitter taunts. The old bishop escaped no hissings, and scornful laughings, which those who had went before had patiently endured. Being very faint, he desired that he might not long tarry; nor durst he drink for fear of vomiting. The disputation ended before eleven of the clock. Dr. Latimer was not suffered to read what he had, as he observed, painfully written: but it was exhibited up, and the prolocutor, after having read part thereof, proceeded unto the disputation.☞
MEN and brethren, we are come together this day (by the help of God) to vanquish the strength of the arguments, and dispersed opinions of adversaries, against the truth of the real presence of the Lord's body in the sacrament. And therefore, you father, if you have any thing to answer, I do admonish that you answer in short and few words.
LAT. I pray you, good master prolocutor, do not exact that of me, which is not in me; I have not these twenty years much used the Latin tongue.
WEST. Take your ease, father.
LAT. I thank you sir, I am well; let me here protest my faith; for I am not able to dispute; and afterwards do your pleasure with me.
THE conclusions whereunto I must answer, are these:
1. THE first is, That in the sacrament of the altar by the virtue of God's word pronounced by the priest, there is really present the natural body of Christ, conceived of the virgin Mary, under the kinds of the appearance of bread and wine; in like manner his blood.
2. THE second is, That after consecration there remaineth no substance of bread and wine, nor any other substance, but the substance of God and Man.
3. THE third is, That in the mass there is the lively sacrifice of the church, which is propitiable, as well for the sins of the quick, as of the dead.
CONCERNING the first conclusions, I think it is set forth with certain new found terms that are obscure, and do not sound according to the speech of scripture. But however I understand it, this I do answer plainly, (though not without peril) that to the right celebration of the Lord's supper, there is no other presence of Christ required, than a spiritual presence: and this presence is sufficient for a christian man, as a presence by which we abide in Christ, and Christ abideth in us, to the obtaining of eternal life, if we persevere. And this same presence may be called most fitly a real presence, that is, a presence not feigned, but a true and faithful presence. Which thing I here rehearse, ⟨p. 358⟩lest some sycophant, or scorner, should suppose me, with the anabaptists, to make nothing else of the sacrament, but a naked and bare sign. As for that which is feigned of many concerning their corporal presence, I for my part take it for a papistical invention; therefore I think it ought utterly to be rejected.
CONCERNING the second conclusion, I dare be bold to say, that it hath no ground in God's word, but is a thing invented and found out by man, and therefore to be taken as false; and I had almost said, as the mother and nurse of the other errors. It were good for my lords and masters of the transubstantiation, to take heed lest they conspire with the Nestorians, for I do not see how they can avoid it.
THE third conclusion (as I understand it) seemeth subtly to sow sedition against the offering which Christ himself offered for us in his own proper person, according to these words of St. Paul, Heb. i. where he saith, "That Christ his own self hath made purgation of our sins." And afterwards, "That he might (said he) be a merciful and faithful bishop, concerning those things which are to be done with God, for the taking away of our sins." So that the expiation or taking away of our sins may be thought to depend on this, that Christ was an offering bishop, than that he was offered, were it not that he was offered of himself: and therefore it is needless that he should be offered of any other. I will speak nothing of the wonderful presumption of man, to dare to attempt this thing without a manifest vocation, especially in that it tendeth to the overthrowing and making fruitless (if not wholly, yet partly) of the cross of Christ; for truly it is no base or mean thing to offer Christ. And therefore well may a man say to my lords and masters the offerers, By what authority do ye this? and who gave you this authority? Where? When? A man cannot (saith the baptist) take any thing, except it be given him from above: much less then may any man presume to usurp any honour, before he be thereto called. Again, If any man sin, (saith St. John) we have, not a master, or offerer, at home, who can sacrifice for us at mass, but we have (saith he) an advocate Jesus Christ, who once offered up himself long ago: of which offering the efficacy and effect is for ever, so that it is needless to have such offerers.
THE third conclusion (as I understand it) seemeth subtily to sow sedition against the offering which Christ himself offered for us in his own proper person, according to these words of St. Paul, Heb. i. where he saith, "That Christ his own self hath made purgation of our sins." And afterwards, "That he might (said he) be a merciful and faithful bishop, concerning those things which are to be done with God, for the taking away of our sins." So that the expiation or taking away of our sins may be thought to depend on this, that Christ was an offering bishop, than that he was offered, were it not that he was offered of himself: and therefore it is needless that he should be offered of any other. I will speak nothing of the wonderful presumption of man, to dare to attempt this thing without a manifest vocation, especially in that it tendeth to the overthrowing and making fruitless (if not wholly, yet partly) of the cross of Christ; for truly it is no base or mean thing to offer Christ. And therefore well may a man say to my lords and masters the offerers, By what authority do ye this? and who gave you this authority? Where? When? A man cannot (saith the baptist) take any thing, except it be given him from above: much less then may any man presume to usurp any honour, before he be thereto called. Again, If any man sin, (saith St. John) we have, not a master, or offerer, at home, who can sacrifice for us at mass, but we have (saith he) an advocate Jesus Christ, who once offered up himself long ago: of which offering the efficacy and effect is for ever, so that it is needless to have such offerers.
WHAT meaneth Paul, when he saith, "They that serve at the altar, are partakers of the altar?" and so addeth; "So the Lord hath ordained, that they that preach the gospel, shall live by the gospel." Whereas he should have said, The Lord hath ordained, that they that sacrifice at mass, should live of their sacrificing, that there might be a living assigned to our sacrificers now, as was before Christ's coming to the Jewish priests. For now they have nothing to allege for their living, as they that be preachers have. So that it appeareth, that the sacrificing priesthood is changed by God's ordinance into a preaching priesthood, and the sacrificing priesthood should cease utterly, saving inasmuch as all christian men are sacrificing priests.
WHAT meaneth Paul, when he saith, "They that serve at the altar, are partakers of the altar?" and so addeth; "So the Lord hath ordained, that they that preach the gospel, shall live by the gospel." Whereas he should have said, The Lord hath ordained, that they that sacrifice at mass, should live of their sacrificing, that there might be a living assigned to our sacrificers now, as was before Christ's coming to the Jewish priests. For now they have nothing to alledge for their living, as they that be preachers have. So that it appeareth, that the sacrificing priesthood is changed by God's ordinance into a preaching priesthood, and the sacrificing priesthood should cease utterly, saving inasmuch as all christian men are sacrificing priests.
THE supper of the Lord was instituted to provoke us to thanksgiving, for the offering which the Lord himself did offer for us, much rather than that our offerers should do there as they do. "Feed (saith Peter) as much as ye may the flock of Christ:" nay, rather let us sacrifice as much as we may for the flock of Christ. If the matter be as men now make it, I can never wonder enough, that Peter would or could forget this office of sacrificing, which at this day is in such a price and estimation, that to feed is almost nothing with many. If thou cease from feeding the flock, how shalt thou be taken? Truly catholic enough. But if thou cease from sacrificing and massing, how will that be taken? At the least, I warrant thee, thou shalt be called an heretic.
AND whence, I pray you, come these papistical judgments? Except perchance they think a man feedeth the flock in sacrificing for them: and then what needeth there any learned pastors? For no man is so foolish, but soon he may learn to sacrifice and mass it.
AND whence, I pray you, come these papistical judgments? Except perchance they think a man feedeth the flock in sacrificing for them: and then what needeth there any learned pastors? For no man is so foolish, but soon he may l•arn to sacrifice and mass it.