pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 20 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
THUS I have taken the more pains to write, because I refused to dispute, in consideration of my debility thereunto: that all men may know, how that I have so done not without great pains, hav•ng not any man to help me, as I have never before been debarred to have. O sir, you may chance ⟨p. 359⟩to live till you come to this age and weakness that I am of. I have spoken in my time before two kings more than once, two or three hours together, without interruption; but now that I may speak the truth, (by your leave) I could not be suffered to declare my mind before you, no, not by the space of a quarter of an hour, without revilings, checks, rebukes, taunts, such as I have not felt the like, in such an audience, all my life long. Surely it cannot but be an heinous offence that I have given. But what was it? Forsooth, I had spoken of the four marrow-bones of the mass. The which kind of speaking I never read to be a sin against the Holy Ghost.
I could not be allowed to show what I meant by my metaphor: but, sir, now by your favour I will tell you what I mean.
I could not be allowed to shew what I meant by my metaphor: but, sir, now by your favour I will tell you what I mean.
THE first is the popish consecration, which hath been called a God's body-making.
THE second is transubstantiation.
THE third is massal oblation.
THE fourth, adoration.
THESE chief and principal portions parts, and points, incident to the mass, and most esteemed in the same, I call the marrow-bones of the mass; which indeed you, by force, might, and violence intrude, in sound of words, in some of the scripture, with racking and cramping, injuring and wronging the same: but else, indeed, plain out of the scripture, as I am thoroughly persuaded, altho' in disputation I now could do nothing to persuade the same to others, being both unapt to study, and also to make a show of my former study in such readiness as should be requisite to the same.
THESE chief and principal portions parts, and points, incident to the mass, and most esteemed in the same, I call the marrow-bones of the mass; which indeed you, by force, might, and violence intrude, in sound of words, in some of the scripture, with racking and cramping, injuring and wronging the same: but else, indeed, plain out of the scripture, as I am thoroughly persuaded, altho' in disputation I now could do nothing to persuade the same to others, being both unapt to study, and also to make a shew of my former study in such readiness as should be requisite to the same.
I have heard much talk of Dr. Weston in my time: but I never knew your person to my knowledge, till I came before you as the queen's majesty's commissioner. I pray God send you so right judgment, as I perceive you have great wit, great learning, with many other qualities. God give you gra•e ever well to use them, and ever to have in remembrance, that he that dwelleth on high, locketh on the low things on the earth; and that there is no council against the Lord; and also that this world hath been, and yet is a tottering world. And again, that though we must obey the princes, yet that hath this limitation, namely, in the Lord. For whosoever obey them against the Lord, they be the most pernicious to them, and the greatest adversaries that they have: for they so procure God's vengeance upon them, if God be the only ruler of things.
THERE are some so corrupt in mind, the truth being taken from them, that they think gain to be godliness; great learned men, and yet men of no learning, but of railing, and raging, about questions, and strife of words. I call them men of no learning, because they know not Christ, how much else soever they know. And on this sort we are wont to call great learned clerks, being ignorant of Christ, unlearned men; for it is nothing but plain ignorance, to know any thing without Christ: whereas whoso knoweth Christ, the same hath knowledge enough, although in other knowledge he be to seek. The apostle Paul confesseth of himself to the Corinthians, that he did know nothing but Jesus Christ crucified. Many men babble many things of Christ, who yet know not Christ; but, pretending Christ, do craftily colour and darken his glory. Depart from such men, saith the apostle Paul to Timothy.
IT is not out of the way to remember what St. Augustine saith. The place where, I do not now remember, except it be against the epistles of Petilian; "Whosoever (saith he) teacheth any thing necessarily to be believed, which is not contained m the Old and New Testament, the same is accursed." Oh! beware of this curse, if you be wise. I am much deceived if Basilius have not such like words; "Whatsoever (saith he) is besides the holy scripture, if the same be taught as necessarily to be believed, that is sin." Oh, therefore, take heed of this sin!
THERE are some that speak many false things more probable, and more like to the truth, than the truth itself. Therefore Paul giveth a watch-word▪ "Let no man (saith he) deceive you with probability and persuasions of words." But what mean you, saith one, by this talk so far from the ⟨p. 360⟩matter? Well, I hope, good masters, you will suffer an old man a little to play the child, and to speak one thing twice. O Lord God! you have changed the most holy communion into a private action; and you deny to the laity the Lord's cup, contrary to Christ's commandment: and you do blemish the annunciation of the Lord's death till he come: for you have changed the common prayer, called the divine service, with the administration of the sacraments, from the vulgar and known language, into a strange tongue, contrary to the will of the Lord revealed in his word. God open the door of your heart, to see the things you should see herein. I would fain obey my sovereign as any in this realm: but in these things I can never do it with an upright conscience. God be merciful unto us. Amen.
WEST. Then you refuse to dispute? Will you here then subscribe?
LAT. No, good master, I pray be good to an old man. You may, if it please God, be once old, as I am: you may come to this age, and to this debility.
WEST. You said upon Saturday last, that you could not find the mass, nor the marrow-bones thereof, in your book: but we will find a mass in that book.
LAT. No, good Mr. Doctor, you cannot.
WEST. What find you then there?
LAT. A communion.
WEST. Which communion, the first or the last?
LAT. I find no great diversity in them; they are one supper of the Lord: but I like the last very well.
WEST. The first you do not approve of?
LAT. I do not well remember wherein they differ.
WEST. Then cake bread, and loaf bread, are all one? You call it the supper of the Lord; but you are deceived in that; for they had done the supper before, and therefore the scripture saith, "After they had supped." St. Paul findeth fault with the Corinthians, that some of them were drunken at this supper; and you know, no man can be drunken at your communion.
WEST. Then cak• bread, and loaf bread, are all one? You call it the supper of the Lord; but you are deceived in that; for they had done the supper before, and therefore the scripture saith, "After they had supped." St. Paul findeth fault with the Corinthians, that some of them were drunken at this supper; and you know, no man can be drunken at your communion.
LAT. The first was called [Coena Judaica] "The Jewish Supper," when they did eat the paschal lamb together; the other was called [Coena Dominica] "The Lord's Supper."
WEST. That is false; for Chrysostom denieth that. St. Ambrose on the x. chap. of the 1 Cor. saith, "The mystery of the sacrament, given as they were at supper, is not the supper of the Lord." Also Gregory Nazianzene saith the same. And the first supper was called Agapee: can you tell what that is?
LAT. I understand not Greek: yet I think it meaneth charity.
WEST. Mr. Opponent begin.
SMITH. Because I perceive that this charge is laid upon my neck to dispute with you; to the end that the same may go forward after a right manner and order, I will propose three questions, so as they are put forth unto me. And first I ask this question of you, although the same indeed ought not to be called in question: but such is the condition of the church, that it is always vexed of the wicked. I ask, I say, whether Christ's body be really in the sacrament?
LAT. I trust I have obtained of Mr. Prolocutor, that no man shall exact that thing of me which is not in me. And I am sorry that this worshipful audience should be deceived of their expectation for my sake. I have given up my mind in writing to Mr. Prolocutor.
SMITH. Whatsoever you have given up, it shall be registered among the acts.
LAT. Disputation requireth a good memory; my memory is gone, and marvellously weakened, and never the better, I think, for the prison.
WEST. How long have you been in prison?
LAT. Three quarters of this year.
WEST. And I was in prison six years.
LAT. The more pity, sir.
WEST. How long have you been of this opinion?
LAT. It is not long, sir, that I have been of this opinion.
WEST. The time hath been when you said mass full devoutly.
LAT. Yes, I crave God's mercy heartily for it.
WEST. Where learned you this new fangleness.
LAT. I have long sought for the truth in this matter of the sacrament, and have hot been of this mind more than seven years: and my lord of Canterbury's book hath especially confirmed my judgement herein. If I could remember all therein contained, I would not fear to answer any man in this matter.