pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 23 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
LAT. He is too precious a thing for us to offer; he offereth himself.
WEST. Here in another place of Chrysostom to the people of Antioch, and also to the Philippians, he saith, "There should be a memory and sacrifice for the dead."
WEST. Here in another place of Chrysostom to the people of Antioch, and also to the Phillippians, he saith, "There should be a memory and sacrifice for the dead."
LAT. I do say, that the holy communion beareth the name of a sacrifice, because it is a sacrifice memorative.
WEST. What say you to the sacrifice of the dead?
LAT. I say that it needeth not, and it availeth not.
WEST. Augustine in his Enchiridion, saith, "We must not deny that the souls of the dead are relieved by the devotion of their friends who are living, when the sacrifice of the Mediator is offered for them." Where he proveth the verity of Christ's body, and praying for the dead. And it is said, that the same Augustine said mass for his mother.
WEST. Augustine in his Enchiridon, saith, "We must not deny that the souls of the dead are relieved by the devotion of their friends who are living, when the sacrifice of the Mediator is offered for them." Where he proveth the verity of Christ's body, and praying for the dead. And it is said, that the same Augustine said mass for his mother.
LAT. But that mass was not like your's, which thing doth manifestly appear in his writings, which are against it in every place. And Augustine is a reasonable man, he requireth to be believed no further than he bringeth scripture for his proof, and agreeth with God's word.
WEST. In the same place he proveth a propitiatory sacrifice, and that upon an altar, and no oyster-board.
LAT. It is the Lord's table, and no oyster-board. It may be called an altar, and so the doctors call it in many places: but there is no propitiatory sacrifice, but only Christ. The doctors might be deceived in some points, though not in all things; I believe them when they say well.
COLE. Is it not a shame for an old man to lye? You say, you are of the old fathers' faith where they say well, and yet you are not.
LAT. I am of their faith when they say well; I refer myself to my lord of Canterbury's book wholly herein.
SMITH. Then you are not of Chrysostom's faith, nor of St. Augustine's faith.
LAT. I have said, when they say well, and bring scripture, I am of their faith; and further Augustine requireth not to be believed.
WEST. Origen, Hom. xiii, upon Leviticus.
LAT. I have but one word to say; The sacramental bread is called a propitiation, because it is a sacrament of the propitiation. What is your vocation?
WEST. My vocation is at this time to dispute; otherwise I am a priest, and my vocation is to offer.
LAT. Where have you that authority given you to offer.
WEST. [Hoc facite] "Do this," for [facite] in that place is taken for [offerte] that is, "offer ye."
LAT. Is [facere] nothing but [sacrificare] "to sacrifice?" Why, then no man must receive the sacrament, but priests only: for there may none other offer but priests. ERGO, Th••• may none receive but priests.
WEST. Your argument is to be denied.
LAT. Did Christ then offer himself at his supper?
PIE. Yes, he offered himself for the whole world.
PYE. Yes, he offered himself for the whole world.
LAT. Then if this word [facite] "do ye," signify [sacrificate] "sacrifice ye," it followeth, as I said, that none but priests only ought to receive the sacrament, to whom it is only lawful to sacrifice: and where find you that, I pray you?
WEST. Forty years ago, whither could you have gone to have found your doctrine?
LAT. The more cause we have to thank God, that hath now sent the light into the world▪
WEST. The light▪ Nay, light and lewd preachers; for you could not tell what you might have. Ye altered and changed so often your communions and altars, and all for this one end, to spoil and rob the church.
LAT. These things pertain nothing to me, I must not answer other men's deeds, but only for mine own.
WEST. Well, Mr. Latimer, this is our intent, to wish you well, and to exhort you to come to yourself, and remember, that without Noah's ark there is no health. Remember what they have been, that were the beginners of your doctrine: none but a few flying apostates, running out of Germany for fear of the faggot. Remember what they have been who have set forth the same in this realm: a sort of fling brains and light heads, who were never constant in one thing, as it was to be seen in the turning of the table, where like a sort of apes they could not tell which way to turn their tails, looking one day west, and another day east; one that way, and another this way. They will be like (they say) to the apostles, they will have no churches; a hovel is good enough for them. They come to the communion with no reverence. They get them a tankard, and one saith, I drink, and I am thankful; the more joy of thee, saith another. And in them was it true that Hilary saith, "We make every year and every month a faith." A runagate Scot did take away the adoration or worshipping of Christ in the sacrament, by whose procurement that heresy was put into the last communion-book; so much prevailed that one man's authority at that time. You never agreed with the Tygurines, or Germans, or with the church, or with yourself. Your stubbornness cometh of a vain glory, which is to no purpose: for it will do you no good when a faggot is in your beard. And we see all, by your own confession▪ how little cause you have to be stubborn, for your learning is in feoffers hold. The queen's grace is merciful, if you will turn.
LAT. You shall have no hope in me to turn. I pray for the queen daily, even from the bottom of my heart, that she may turn from this religion.
WEST. Here you all see the weakness of heresy against the truth: he denieth all truth, and all the old fathers.
HERE too our readers may see whether this boasting prolocutor obtained a glorious victory or not, over his insulted opponents, and how slender his pretensions for a triumph on that account. But no wonder he should claim the victory, disputing as he did, not without his tippling-cup at his elbow; nor without frequent smiles from those who applauded the strength of his arguments; especially at that time, in the course of Dr. Ridley's disputation, when Weston, holding the cup, or beer-pot, in his hand, said to the opponent, "Urge this, urge this; for this makes for us;" which words occasioned much laughter among the auditors.
THUS we have given a full account of those disputations, that were maintained against three worthy confessors and martyrs of the Lord, wherein may be seen the disorderly usage of the university men, their unmannerly deportment in the divinity school, the tumult of a rude multitude, the passion, fierceness, and interruption of the grave doctors, the full ground of the reasonings, the censure of the partial judges, the foul language, and indecent railing of the prolocutor, with his vain blast of triumph at the conclusion of each debate, by which he showed himself both actor, moderator, and judge. We need not wonder then that this victorious conqueror, having the law in his own hands, should say of himself, Vic•• veritas, though he said not one true word, nor ever made a true conclusion, almost throughout the several disputations.
THUS we have given a full account of those disputations, that were maintained against three worthy confessors and martyrs of the Lord, wherein may be seen the disorderly usage of the university men, their unmannerly deportment in the divinity school, the tumult of a rude multitude, the passion, fierceness, and interruption of the grave doctors, the full ground of the reasonings, the censure of the partial judges, the foul language, and indecent railing of the prolocutor, with his vain blast of triumph at the conclusion of each debate, by which he shewed himself both actor, moderator, and judge. We need not wonder then that this victorious conqueror, having the law in his own hands, should say of himself, Vic•• veritas, though he said not one true word, nor ever made a true conclusion, almost throughout the several disputations.
THE day after these were closed, being the 19th of April, it happened that Mr. Harpsfield was called upon, to dispute for his form, to be made a doctor of divinity; on which occasion Dr. Cranmer was again brought forth, and permitted, among the rest, to deliver an argument or two in defence of his cause, as the sequel will show.
THE day after these were closed, being the 19th of April, it happened that Mr. Harpsfield was called upon, to dispute for his form, to be made a doctor of divinity; on which occasion Dr. Cranmer was again brought forth, and permitted, among the rest, to deliver an argument or two in defence of his cause, as the sequel will shew.
HARPS. I Am not ignorant what a weighty matter it is to entreat of the whole order and trade of the scriptures: and most hard it is too, in the great con••ntion of religion, to show the ready way whereby the scriptures may best be understood; for the often reading of them doth not bring the true understanding of them. What other thing is there then? Verily this is the ready way, not to follow our own heads and senses, but to give over our judgment unto the holy catholic church, who hath of old years the truth, and always delivered the same to her posterity: but if the often reading of scriptures, and ever so painful comparing of places, should bring the true understanding, then divers heretics might prevail even against whole general councils. The Jews did greatly brag of their knowledge of the law, and of the Saviour that they waited for. But what availed it them? Notwithstanding, I know right well, that divers places of the scripture do much warn us of the often reading of the same, and what fruit doth thereby follow; as, "Search the scriptures, for they do bear witness of me," &c. "The law of the Lord is pure, able to turn souls." And that saying of St. Paul, "All scripture inspired from above, doth make that a man may be instructed to all good works." Howbeit, doth the law of the Jews convert their souls? Are they by reading instructed to every good work? The letter of the Old Testament is the same that we have. THE heretics also have ever had the same scriptures, which we have that be catholics. But they are served as Tantalus that the poets speak of, who, in the plenty of things to eat and drink, is said to be oppressed with hunger and thirst. The swifter that men […] seek the scriptures without the catholic church, the deeper they fall, and find hell for their labour St. Cyprian, never swerving from the catholic church, saith, "He that doth not acknowledge the church to be his mother, shall not have God to his Father." Therefore it is true divinity to be wise with the church, where Christ saith, "Unless ye eat my flesh, and drink my blood, ye have no life in you." IF he had […] of only eating bread and drinking wine, no••ing had been more pleasant to the Capernaites, neither would they have forsaken him. The […] nothing to the• that do so take it. […] Capernaites did imagine ⟨p. 368⟩Christ to be given in such sort as he lived. But Christ spake high things;
HARPS. I Am not ignorant what a weighty matter it is to intreat of the whole order and trade of the scriptures: and most hard it is too, in the great conntion of religion, to shew the ready way whereby the scriptures may best be understood; for the often reading of them doth not bring the true understanding of them. What other thing is there then? Verily this is the ready way, not to follow our own heads and senses, but to give over our judgment unto the holy catholic church, who hath of old years the truth, and always delivered the same to her posterity: but if the often reading of scriptures, and ever so painful comparing of places, should bring the true understanding, then divers heretics might prevail even against whole general councils. The Jews did greatly brag of their knowledge of the law, and of the Saviour that they waited for. But what availed it them? Notwithstanding, I know right well, that divers places of the scripture do much warn us of the often reading of the same, and what fruit doth thereby follow; as, "Search the scriptures, for they do bear witness of me," &c. "The law of the Lord is pure, able to turn souls." And that saying of St. Paul, "All scripture inspired from above, doth make that a man may be instructed to all good works." Howbeit, doth the law of the Jews convert their souls? Are they by reading instructed to every good work? The letter of the Old Testament is the same that we have. THE heretics also have ever had the same scriptures, which we have that be catholics. But they are served as Tantalus that the poets speak of, who, in the plenty of things to eat and drink, is said to be oppressed with hunger and thirst. The swifter that men seek the scriptures without the catholic church, the deeper they fall, and find hell for their labour St. Cyprian, never swerving from the catholic church, saith, "He that doth not acknowledge the church to be his mother, shall not have God to his Father." Therefore it is true divinity to be wise with the church, where Christ saith, "Unless ye eat my flesh, and drink my blood, ye have no life in you." IF he had of only eating bread and drinking wine, noing had been more pleasant to the Capernaites, neither would they have forsaken him. The nothing to the that do so take it. Capernaites did imagine
not that they should have him as flesh in the market▪ but to consider his presence with the Spirit, under the forms whereby it is given. As there is an alteration of bodies by courses and times of ages, so there is no less variety in eating of bodies. THESE things which I have recited briefly, Mr. Harpsfield did set out with many more words; and hereupon Dr. Weston disputed against him.
WEST. Christ's real body is not in the sacrament. ERGO, You are deceived.
HARPS. I deny the antecedent.
WEST. John xvi. "I speak the truth unto you: it behoveth me that I go away from you. For unless I do depart, the comforter cannot come," &c. I will make this argument. (1) Christ is so gone away, as he did send the Holy Ghost. (2) BUT the Holy Ghost did verily come into the world. (3) ERGO, Christ is verily gone.
HARPS. He is verily gone, and yet remaineth here.