pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 22 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
WEST. We are commanded to drink blood in the new law. ERGO, It is very blood.
LAT. We drink blood, so as appertaineth to us to drink to our comfort, in sacramental wine. We drink blood sacramentally: he gave us his blood to drink spiritually; he went about to show, that as certainly as we drink wine, so certainly we drink his blood spiritually.
LAT. We drink blood, so as appertaineth to us to drink to our comfort, in sacramental wine. We drink blood sacramentally: he gave us his blood to drink spiritually; he went about to shew, that as certainly as we drink wine, so certainly we drink his blood spiritually.
WEST. Do not you seem to be a papist, which do bring in new words, not found in the scripture? Where find you that, "sacramentally," in God's book?
LAT. It is necessarily gathered from scripture.
WEST. The Old Testament doth forbid the tasting of blood, but the New doth command it.
LAT. It is true, not as touching the thing, but as touching the manner thereof.
WEST. Hear, ye people, this is the argument: THAT which was forbidden in the Old Testament, is commanded in the New. To drink blood was forbidden in the Old Testament, and commanded in the New.
[This argument, because the major thereof is not universal, is not formal, and may well be retorted against Weston thus.
No natural or moral thing, forbidden materially in the Old Testament, is commanded in the New.
To drink man's natural blood is forbidden materially in the Old Testament.
ERGO, To drink man's natural blood materially is not commanded in the New.]
LAT. It is commanded spiritually to be drunk; I grant it is blood drunk in the New Testament, but we receive it spiritually.
PIE. It was not forbidden spiritually in the old law.
PYE. It was not forbidden spiritually in the old law.
LAT. The substance of blood is drunk, but not in one manner.
PIE. It doth not require the same manner of drinking.
PYE. It doth not require the same manner of drinking.
LAT. It is the same thing, not the same manner. I have no more to say.
WEST. [Here Weston cited the place of Chrysostom, of Judas's treason:] "O the madness of Judas! He made bargain with the Jews for thirty pence to sell Christ, and Christ offered him his blood which he sold."
LAT. I grant he offered to Judas his blood which he sold, but in a sacrament.
WEST. Because you can defend your doctors no better, you shall see what worshipful men ye hang upon, and one that hath been of your mind shall dispute with you. Mr. Cartwright, I pray you, dispute.
CART. Reverend father, because it is given me in commandment to dispute with you, I will do it gladly. But first understand, before we go any further, that I was in the same error that you are in: but I am sorry for it, and do confess myself to have erred: I acknowledge mine offence, and I wish and desire God that you may also repent with me.
LAT. Will you give me leave to tell what hath caused Mr. Doctor here to recant? It is merely "The pain of the law," which hath brought you back, and converted you, and many more; which hindereth many from confessing God. And this is a great argument; there are few here can dissolve it.
CART. That is not my case, but I will make you this short argument, by which I was converted from mine errors. (1) IF the true body of Christ be not really in the sacrament, all the whole church hath erred from the apostle's time. (2) BUT Christ would not suffer his church to err. (3) ERGO, It is the true body of Christ.
LAT. The Popish church hath erred, and doth err. I think for the space of six or seven hundred years, there was no mention made of any eating but spiritually: for, before these five hundred years, the church did ever confess a spiritual eating. But the Romish church begat the error of transubstantiation. My lord of Canterbury's book handleth that very well, and by him I could answer you if I had him.
CART. Linus and all the rest do confess the body of Christ to be in the sacrament: and St. Augustine also upon the 99th Psalm, upon this place, "Worship his footstool," &c. granteth that it is to be worshipped.
LAT. We do worship Christ in the heavens, and we do worship him in the sacrament: but the massing worship is not to be used.
SMITH. Do you think that Cyril was of the ancient church?
LAT. I do think so.
SMITH. He saith, That Christ dwelleth in us corporally: these are Cyril's words of the mystical benediction.
LAT. That [corporally] hath another understanding, than you do grossly take it. CYRIL saith, that Christ dwelleth corporally in us, but he saith not that Christ dwelleth corporally in the bread. Which dwelling of Christ in us, is as our dwelling is also in Christ, not local or corporal, but spiritual and heavenly. Corporally therefore is to be taken in the same sense, as St. Paul saith the fullness of divinity to dwell in Christ corporally, that is, not lightly nor accidentally, but perfectly and substantially, with all his virtue and power, &c. And so dwelleth Christ corporally in us also.
LAT. That [corporally] hath another understanding, than you do grossly take it. CYRIL saith, that Christ dwelleth corporally in us, but he saith not that Christ dwelleth corporally in the bread. Which dwelling of Christ in us, is as our dwelling is also in Christ, not local or corporal, but spiritual and heavenly. Corporally therefore is to be taken in the same sense, as St. Paul saith the fulness of divinity to dwell in Christ corporally, that is, not lightly nor accidentally, but perfectly and substantially, with all his virtue and power, &c. And so dwelleth Christ corporally in us also.
[HERE Smith repeated these words of Cyril, "By the communicating of the body of Christ, Christ dwelleth in us corporally.]
LAT. The solution of this is in my lord of Canterbury's book.
SMITH. Cyril was no papist, and yet these are his words, "Christ dwelleth in us corporally?" But you say, he dwelleth in us spiritually.
LAT. I say both, that he dwelleth in us corporally and spiritually, according to his meaning: spiritually by faith, and corporally by taking our flesh upon him. For I remember, I have read this in my lord of Canterbury's book.
WEST. Because your learning is let out to farm, and shut up in my lord of Canterbury's book, I will recite unto you a place of St. Ambrose, concerning the preparation for the mass, where he saith, "We see the chief priest coming unto us, and offering blood," &c. LIKEWISE both Augustine in the 38th Psal. and Chrysostom concerning the incomprehensible nature of God, vol. 3. say, "Not only men," &c.
LAT. I am not ashamed to acknowledge mine ignorance, and these testimonies are more than I can bear away.
WEST. Then you must leave some behind you for lack of carriage.
LAT. But as to Chrysostom, he hath many figurative speeches, and emphatical phrases in many places; as in that which you have now recited: but he saith not, For the quick and the dead; he taketh the celebration for the sacrifice.
WEST. You shall hear Chrysostom again, upon the 9th chapter of the Acts, "What say you? The host in the hands of the priest," &c. He doth not call it a cup of wine.
LAT. You have mine answer there in a paper; and yet he calleth it not a propitiatory sacrifice.
WEST. You shall hear it to be so: and I bring another place of Chrysostom out of the same treatise, "It was not rashly instituted by the apostles," &c.