pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 3 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
CRAN. Nay, I disagree with the papistical church.
OGLE. This you do through the ignorance of logic.
CRAN. Nay, this you say through the ignorance of the doctors.
WESTON. I will go plainly to work by scriptures. What took he?
CRAN. Bread.
WEST. What gave he?
CRAN. Bread.
WEST. What brake he?
CRAN. Bread.
WEST. What did he eat?
CRAN. Bread.
WEST. He gave bread, therefore he gave not his body. He gave not his body, therefore it is not his body verily, and in deed, and in truth.
CRAN. I deny the argument.
COLE. This argument holdeth, a disparatis. It is bread: Ergo, It is not the body. And it is such an argument or reason, as cannot be dissolved.
CRAN. The like argument may be made: He is a rock: Ergo, He is not Christ.
COLE. It is not alike.
WEST. He gave not his body indeed: Ergo, It was not his body indeed.
CRAN. He gave his death, his passion, and the sacrament of his passion. And in very deed, setting the figure aside, formally it is not his body.
CRAN. He gave his death, his passion, and the sacrament of his passion. And in very deed, settting the figure aside, formally it is not his body.
WEST. Why, then, the scripture is false.
CRAN. Nay, the scripture is most true.
WEST. This saith Chrysostom, Homil. 61, ad pop. Antioch. "Needful it is, dear friends, to tell you what the miracle of the mysteries is, and wherefore it is given, and what profit there is of the thing. We are one body, and members of his flesh and of his bones. We that be in the mystery, let us follow the thing which was spoken. Wherefore that we may become this thing, not only by love, but also that we may become one with that flesh indeed, that is brought to pass by this food, which he gave unto us, minding to show his great good will that he hath towards us: and therefore he mixed himself with us, and united his own body with us, that we should be made all as one thing together, as a body joined and annexed to the head, for this is a token of most ardent and perfect love. And the same thing Job also insinuating, said of his servants, of whom he was desired above measure, insomuch that they, showing their great desire towards him, said, Who shall give unto us to be filled with his flesh. Therefore also Christ did the same, who, to induce us into a greater love towards him, and to declare his desire towards us, did not only give himself to be seen of them, but also to be handled, and eaten. Parents many times give their children to others to be fed; but I do not so, saith Christ, but feed you with my own flesh, and set myself before you. I am become your brother; I took flesh and blood for you. Again, my flesh and blood, by the which I am made your kinsman, I deliver unto you. OUT of which words of St. Chrysostom I make▪ said Weston, this argument. (1) THE same flesh whereby Christ is made our brother and kinsman, is given of Christ to us to be eaten. (2) CHRIST is made our brother and kinsman, by his true, natural, and organical flesh. ⟨p. 317⟩(3) THEREFORE, this true, natural, and organical flesh is given to us to be eaten.
WEST. This saith Chrysostom, Homil. 61, ad pop. Antioch. "Needful it is, dear friends, to tell you what the miracle of the mysteries is, and wherefore it is given, and what profit there is of the thing. We are one body, and members of his flesh and of his bones. We that be in the mystery, let us follow the thing which was spoken. Wherefore that we may become this thing, not only by love, but also that we may become one with that flesh indeed, that is brought to pass by this food, which he gave unto us, minding to shew his great good will that he hath towards us: and therefore he mixed himself with us, and united his own body with us, that we should be made all as one thing together, as a body joined and annexed to the head, for this is a token of most ardent and perfect love. And the same thing Job also insinuating, said of his servants, of whom he was desired above measure, insomuch that they, shewing their great desire towards him, said, Who shall give unto us to be filled with his flesh. Therefore also Christ did the same, who, to induce us into a greater love towards him, and to declare his desire towards us, did not only give himself to be seen of them, but also to be handled, and eaten. Parents many times give their children to others to be fed; but I do not so, saith Christ, but feed you with my own flesh, and set myself before you. I am become your brother; I took flesh and blood for you. Again, my flesh and blood, by the which I am made your kinsman, I deliver unto you. OUT of which words of St. Chrysostom I make said Weston, this argument. (1) THE same flesh whereby Christ is made our brother and kinsman, is given of Christ to us to be eaten. (2) CHRIST is made our brother and kinsman, by his true, natural, and organical flesh.
CRAN. I grant the consequence and the consequent.
WEST. THEREFORE we eat it with our mouth.
CRAN. I deny it, we eat it through faith.
WEST. HE gave us the same flesh to eat, whereby he became our brother and kinsman. BUT he became our brother and kinsman, by his true, natural, and organical flesh THEREFORE, he gave his true, natural, and organical flesh to be eaten.
CRAN. I grant he took and gave the same true, natural, and original flesh wherein he suffered, and yet he feedeth us spiritually, and that flesh is received spiritually.
WEST. He gave us the same flesh which he took of the virgin. BUT he took not the true flesh of the virgin spiritually, or in a figure. THEREFORE, he gave his true natural flesh, not spiritually.
CRAN. Christ gave to us his own natural flesh, the same wherein he suffered, but feedeth us spiritually.
WEST. Chrysostom is against you, who saith, "Let it come into thy remembrance with what honour thou art honoured, at what table thou fittest at: for with the same thing we are nourished, which the angels do behold and tremble at: neither are they able to behold it without great fear, for the brightness which cometh thereof: and we are brought and compact into one heap or mass with him, being together one body of Christ, and one flesh with him. Who shall speak the powers of the Lord, and shall declare forth all his praises? What pastor hath ever nourished his sheep with his own members? Many mothers have put forth their infants after their birth to other nurses: which he would not do, but feedeth us with his own body, and conjoineth and uniteth us to himself." Whereupon I gather this argument. LIKE as mothers nurse their children with milk, so Christ nourisheth us with his body. BUT mothers do not nourish their infants spiritually with their milk: THEREFORE, Christ doth not nourish those that be his spiritually with his blood.
CRAN. He gave us the wine for his blood.
WEST. If he gave the wine for his blood, as you say, then he gave less than mothers do give. BUT Chrysostom affirmeth, that he gave more than mothers give. THEREFORE he gave not the wine for his blood.
CRAN. You prevent mine answer. He gave wine, yet the blood is considered therein. As for example: when he giveth baptism, we consider not the water, but the Holy Ghost, and remission of sins. We receive with the mouth of the sacrament; but the thing and the matter of the sacrament we receive by faith.
WEST. When Christ said, Eat ye, whether meant he by the mouth or by faith?
CRAN. He meant that we should receive the body by faith, the bread by the mouth.
WEST. Nay, the body by the mouth.
CRAN. That I deny.
WEST. I prove it out of Chrysostom, writing upon the 50th psalm. "SHE that is a mother, shameth sometime to play the nurse. But Christ our nurse doth not so play with us. Therefore instead of meat he feedeth us with his own flesh, and instead of drink he feedeth ⟨p. 318⟩us with his own blood." Likewise upon the xxvi. chap. of Matthew, the •3d Homily, he saith, "For it shall not be enough for him to become man, and in the mean time to be whipped; but he doth bring us into one mass or lump with himself (as I may so call it), and maketh us his body, not by faith alone, but also in very deed."
CRAN. I grant we make one nature with Christ. But that to be done with the mouth I deny.
WEST. Chrysostom, 2 Cor. chap. xiii. Hom. 29. hath these words, "No little honour is given to our mouth, receiving the body of the Lord."
CRAN. This I say, that Christ entereth into us both by our ears and our eyes. With our mouth we receive the body of Christ, and tear it with our teeth, that is to say, the sacrament of the body of Christ. Wherefore I say and affirm, that the virtue of the sacrament is much: and therefore Chrysostom many times speaketh of sacraments no otherwise, than of Christ himself, as I could prove if I might have liberty to speak, by many places of Chrysostom, where he speaketh of the sacrament of the body of Christ.