pp. 306–3771,048 passagespart 8 of 27
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
IT is likewise doubted, after what order the sacrificing priest shall be, whether after the order of Aaron, or else after the order of Melch•sedek. ⟨p. 329⟩For as far as I know, the holy scripture doth allow no more.
WEST. Let this be sufficient.
RID. If we lack time at this present, there is time enough hereafter.
WEST. These are but evasions, or starting holes; you consume the time in vain.
RID. I cannot start far from you, I am captive and bound.
SMITH. That which you have spoken may suffice at this present.
RID. Let me alone, I pray you, for I have not much to say behind.
WEST. Proceed.
RID. Moreover, there is ambiguity in this word [really,] whether it be taken as the logicians term it "transcendenter," that is, most generally, and so it may signify any manner of thing which belongeth •o the body of Christ, by any means; after which sort we also grant Christ's body to be really in the sacrament of the Lord's supper, (as in disputation, if occasion be given, shall be declared) or whether it be taken to signify the very same thing, having body, life, and soul, which was assumed and taken of the word of God, into the unity of person. In which sense, seeing the body of Christ is really in heaven, because of the true manner of his body, it may not be said to be here on the earth. There is yet a further doubtfulness in these words, [under the forms of bread and wine,] whether the forms be there taken to signify only the accidental and outward shows of bread and wine; or therewithal the substantial natures thereof, which are to be seen by their qualities, and perceived by the exterior senses. NOW the error and falseness of the proposition, after the sense of the Roman church and schoolmen, may hereby appear, in that they affirm the bread to be transubstantiated and changed to the flesh assumed of the word of God, and that (as they say) by virtue of the word, which they have devised by a certain number of word•, and cannot be found in any of the evangelists, or in St. Paul, and so they gather that Christ's body is really contained in the sacrament of the altar. Which position is grounded upon the foundation of the transubstantiation; which foundation is monstrous, against reason, and destroyeth the analogy or proportion of the sacraments: and therefore this proposition also, which is built upon this rotten foundation, is false, erroneous, and to be counted as a detestable heresy of the sacramentaries.
RID. Moreover, there is ambiguity in this word [really,] whether it be taken as the logicians term it "transcendenter," that is, most generally, and so it may signify any manner of thing which belongeth •o the body of Christ, by any means; after which sort we also grant Christ's body to be really in the sacrament of the Lord's supper, (as in disputation, if occasion be given, shall be declared) or whether it be taken to signify the very same thing, having body, life, and soul, which was assumed and taken of the word of God, into the unity of person. In which sense, seeing the body of Christ is really in heaven, because of the true manner of his body, it may not be said to be here on the earth. There is yet a further doubtfulness in these words, [under the forms of bread and wine,] whether the forms be there taken to signify only the accidental and outward shews of bread and wine; or therewithal the substantial natures thereof, which are to be seen by their qualities, and perceived by the exterior senses. NOW the error and falseness of the proposition, after the sense of the Roman church and schoolmen, may hereby appear, in that they affirm the bread to be transubstantiated and changed to the flesh assumed of the word of God, and that (as they say) by virtue of the word, which they have devised by a certain number of word, and cannot be found in any of the evangelists, or in St. Paul, and so they gather that Christ's body is really contained in the sacrament of the altar. Which position is grounded upon the foundation of the transubstantiation; which foundation is monstrous, against reason, and destroyeth the analogy or proportion of the sacraments: and therefore this proposition also, which is built upon this rotten foundation, is false, erroneous, and to be counted as a detestable heresy of the sacramentaries.
WEST. We lose time.
RID. You shall have time enough.
WEST. To reasoning. You shall have some other day for this matter.
RID. I have no more to say concerning my explication. If you will give me leave and let me alone, I will but speak a word or two for my confirmation.
WEST. Say on.
THERE ought no doctrine to be established in the church of God, which dissenteth from the word of God, from the rule of faith, and draweth with it many absurdities that cannot be avoided.
BUT this doctrine of the first proposition is such.
THEREFORE, it ought not to be established and maintained in the church of God.
THE major, or first part of my argument, i• plain; and the minor, or second part, is proved thus:
THE doctrine maintaineth a real, corporal, and carnal presence of Christ's flesh assumed and taken of the word, in the sacrament of the Lord's supper, and that not by virtue and grace only, but also by the whole essence and substance of the body and flesh of Christ.
BUT such a presence disagreeth from God's word, from the rule of faith, and cannot but draw with it many absurdities.
THEREFORE, the second part is true.
THE first part of this argument is manifest, and the second may yet farther be confirmed thus.
WEST. You consume time, which might be better bestowed on other matters. Opponent, I pray you, to your arguments.
SMITH. I will here reason with you upon transubstantiation, which you say is contrary to the rule and analogy of faith. The contrary whereof I prove by the scriptures and the doctors. But before I enter argumentation with you, I demand first, whether in the sixth chapter of John, there be any mention made of the sacrament, or of the real presence of Christ in the sacrament?
RID. It is against reason that I should be hindered to prosecute that which I have to speak in this assembly, being not so long, but that it may be comprehended in few words.
WEST. Let him read on.
RID. First of all this presence is contrary to many places of holy scripture.
SECONDLY, It varieth from the articles of the faith.
THIRDLY, It destroyeth and taketh away the institution of the Lord's supper.
FOURTHLY, It maketh precious things common to profane and ungodly persons; for it casteth that which is holy unto dogs, and pearls unto swine.
FIFTHLY, It forceth men to maintain many monstrous miracles without necessity and authority of God's word.
SIXTHLY, It giveth occasion to the heretics, who erred concerning the two natures of Christ, to defend their heresies thereby.
SEVENTHLY, It falsifieth the sayings of the godly fathers; it falsifieth also the catholic faith of the church, which the apostles taught, the martyrs confirmed, and the faithful (as one of the fathers saith) do retain and keep until this day. Wherefore the second part of my argument is true.
THIS carnal presence is contrary to the word of God, as appeareth, John xvi. "I tell you the truth. It is profitable to you that I go away, for if I go not away, the comforter shall not come unto you." Acts iii. "Whom the heavens must receive until the time of restoring all things which God hath spoken." Matt. ix. "The children of the bridegroom cannot mourn so long as the bridegroom is with them: but now is the time of mourning." John xvi. "But I will see you again, and your hearts shall rejoice." John xiv. "I will come again and take you to myself." Matt. xxiv. "If they shall say unto you, Behold here is Christ, or there is Christ, believe them not: for wheresoever the dead carcass is, thither the eagles will resort."
THIS carnal presence is contrary to the word of God, as appeareth, John xvi. "I tell you the truth. It is profitable to you that I go away, for if I go not away, the comforter shall not come unto you." Acts iii. "Whom the heavens must receive until the time of restoring all things which God hath spoken." Matt. ix. "The children of the bridegroom cannot mourn so long as the bridegroom is with them: but now is the time of mourning." John xvi. "But I will see you again, and your hearts shall rejoice." John xiv. "I will come again and take you to myself." Matt. xxiv. "If they shall say unto you, Behold here is Christ, or there is Christ, believe them not: for wheresoever the dead carcase is, thither the eagles will resort."
IT varieth from the articles of the faith; he ascended into heaven, and sitteth at the right hand of God the Father, from whence (and not from any other place, saith St. Augustine) he shall come to judge both the quick and the dead.
IT destroyeth and taketh away the institution of the Lord's supper, which was commanded only to be used and continued until the Lord himself should come. If therefore he be really present in the body of his flesh, then must the supper cease: for a remembrance is not of a thing present, but a thing past and absent. And there is a difference between remembrance and presence, and (as one of the fathers saith) a figure is in vain where the figured is present.
IT maketh precious things common to profane and ungodly persons, and constraineth men to confess many absurdities. For it affirmeth, that whoremongers and murd•••rs▪ yea, and (as some of them hold opinion) the wicked and faithless, mi•e, rats, and dogs, also may receive the very real and corporal ⟨p. 331⟩body of the Lord, wherein the fullness of the Spirit of light and grace dwelleth; contrary to the manifest words of Christ in six places and sentences of the sixth chapter of St. John.
IT maketh precious things common to profane and ungodly persons, and constraineth men to confess many absurdities. For it affirmeth, that whoremongers and murd•••rs▪ yea, and (as some of them hold opinion) the wicked and faithless, mi•e, rats, and dogs, also may receive the very real and corporal ⟨p. 331⟩body of the Lord, wherein the fulness of the Spirit of light and grace dwelleth; contrary to the manifest words of Christ in six places and sentences of the sixth chapter of St. John.
IT confirmeth also and maintaineth that beastly kind of cruelty of the anthropophagi, that is, the devourers of man's flesh: for it is a more cruel thing to devour a quick man, than to slay him.