pp. 367–374110 passagespart 3 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
HARPS. He doth there speak of a symbol, which is the outward form of the sacrament. He meaneth, that doth tarry in its own nature.
WEST. Theodoret also, in his second dialogue of those kinds of bread and wine, saith, "They go not out of their own nature, but they tarry in their own substance."
HARPS. They are understood to be of the same substance, into which they are turned.
WEST. But what say you to this? "They remain in their former substance."
HARPS. Symbola manent, that is, "The outward signs do tarry"
WEST. But what is meant here by this word, [a symbol?]
HARPS. The outward form or shape only of the nature.
WEST. Then you cannot call them a substance.
HARPS. Yes, sir, every thing hath a certain substance in its kind.
WEST. That is true, but accidents are not substances in their kind.
HARPS. They are something in their kind.
WEST. Chrysostom to Caesarius the monk, saith, "Like as before it is consecrated, it is bread; so after it is consecrated, it is delivered from the name of bread, and is endued with the name of the Lord's body, whereas the nature doth remain."
HARPS. Where read you this pla•• I pray you?
WEST. Here in Peter Martyr I find it; I have his book in my hand.
HARPS. The author shall be of more credit, before I make so much of him as to frame an answer unto it.
WEST. Indeed I know not well where he findeth it. But Gelasius saith, That the nature of bread and wine do tarry.
HARPS. What is that Gelasius?
WEST. A bishop of Rome.
HARPS. Then he allowed the mass.
WEST. Yes, and oftentimes said it; and purgatory he also allowed, and prayer for the dead, relics, and invocation to the saints.
WEST. Yes, and oftentimes said it; and purgatory he also allowed, and prayer for the dead, relicks, and invocation to the saints.
HARPS. Then he meant nothing against transubstantiation.
WEST. It doth appear so indeed. But Origen faith, "That the material bread doth tarry, and is conveyed into the privy, and is eaten of worms."
HARPS. Tush, tush, this place appertaineth unto holy bread.
HARPS. Tush, tush, this place appeartaineth unto holy bread.
WEST. What, doth it appertain unto holy bread?
HARPS. Yes, unto holy bread.
WEST. By what means can you show how this miraculous work bringeth Christ into the sacrament?
WEST. By what means can you shew how this miraculous work bringeth Christ into the sacrament?
HARPS. By the scriptures I prove it, which say, "This is my body."
WEST. It doth rejoice us all not a little, that you have so well maintained the sound doctrine of the sacrament of the altar, wherein you have faithfully cleaved to the catholic church▪ as a• only stay of our religion: by which means you have proved yourself meet to be authorised further towards the practising of the scripture.
AND here, I do openly witness, that I do thoroughly consent with you, and have, for disputation's sake only, brought these arguments against you, which you have right learnedly satisfied: and now all things being done, after our form and manner, we will end this disputation, saying, In oppositum est sacra theologia, In oppositum est, &c,
THUS have ye heard, in these disputations about the holy supper of the Lord, the reasons and arguments of the doctors, the answers and resolutions of the bishops, and the vanity of the prolocutor, triumphing before the victory, with, "The truth hath overcome;" who rather should have exclaimed, "Power hath overcome;" as it happeneth always, where the greater part overcometh the better. For else, if power had not helped the prolocutor more than truth, there had been a small victory. But so it is, where judgments be partial, there all things turn to victory, though it be ever so mean and simple, as in this disputation doth well appear. For, on the side of the opponent, scarce any argument was rightly framed in true mood and figure; neither could the respondents be permitted to speak for themselves; and when they answered any thing, it was condemned as soon as they began to speak. Besides, such disturbance, tumults, and confusion (more like a conspiration, than a fair debate, without form and order) were in the school, during the whole time, that the respondents could not utter their minds; neither would the opponents be satisfied with any reasons, which they constantly opposed with evasive delusions. Concerning the disturbance that prevailed, it will plainly appear, from what Bishop Ridley has reported in the following narrative.