pp. 367–374110 passagespart 2 of 3
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
WEST. But I say▪ Christ's body was passible and not passible at one instant.
SEATON. You may ask as well other questions, how he is in heaven? whether he sit or stand? and whether he be there as he lived here?
CRAN. You yourself, by putting a natural presence, do force me to the question▪ "How he is here?" Therefore next I do ask this question, "Whether good and evil men do eat the body in the sacrament?"
HARPS. Yes, they do so, even as the sun doth shine upon kings palaces, and on dung-heaps.
CRAN. Then do I inquire, "[…] long Christ tarrieth in the eater?"
CRAN. Then do I inquire, "〈…〉 long Christ tarrieth in the eater?"
HARPS. These are curious questions, not proper to be asked.
CRAN. I have taken them out of your schools and schoolmen, which you yourselves do most use: and there also do I learn to ask, "How far he goeth into the body?"
HARPS. We know that the body of Christ is received to nourish the whole man, both body and soul.
CRAN. How long doth he abide in the body?
SEATON. St. Augustine saith, our flesh goeth into his flesh. But after he is once received into the stomach, it maketh no matter for us to know how far he doth pierce, or whether he is conveyed.
[H•a• Mr. Tresham and one Mr. London answered, that Christ being given there under such form and quantity as pleased him▪ it was not to be inquired of his tarrying, or of his descending into the body]
HARPS. You were wont to lay to our charge, that we added to the scripture▪ saving always, that we should fetch the truth out of the scripture, and now you yourself bring questions out of the schoolmen, which you have disallowed in us.
CRAN. I say, that I am constrained to ask these questions, because of this carnal presence which you imagine: and yet I know right well, that these questions are answered out of the scriptures. As to my last question, "How long he abideth in the body?" &c. the scripture answereth plainly, that Christ doth so long dwell in his people, as they are his members. Whereupon I make this argument. (1) THEY which eat the flesh of Christ, do dwell in him, and he in them. (2) BUT the wicked do not remain in him, nor he in them. (3) ERGO, The wicked do not eat his flesh, nor drink his blood.
HARPS. I will answer unto you as St. Augustine saith, not that howsoever a man do eat, he eateth the body; but he that eateth after a certain manner.
CRAN. I cannot tell what manner ye appoint, but I am sure that evil men do not eat the flesh and drink the blood of Christ, as Christ speaketh in the sixth of John.
HARPS. In the sixth of John, some things are to be referred to the godly, and some to the ungodly.
CRAN. Whatsoever he doth treat of there concerning eating, doth pertain unto good men.
HARPS. If you do mean only of the word [eating▪] it is true; if concerning the thing▪ it is not so; and if your meaning be of that which is contained under the word [eating,] it may be so taken, I grant.
CRAN. Now to the argument: "He that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me▪ and I in him." Doth not this prove sufficiently, that evil men do not eat what the good do?
TRESH. You must add, He that eateth worthily.
CRAN. I speak of the same manner of eating that Christ speaketh of.
WEST. Augustine, to the brethren in the wilderness, says, "There is a certain manner of eating." Augustine speaketh of two manners of eating; ⟨p. 372⟩the one of them that eat worthily, the other that eat unworthily.
HARPS. All things in the sixth of John are not to be referred to the sacrament; but to the receiving of Christ by faith. The fathers do agree, that there is no reference made to the supper of the Lord, before they come unto, "The bread which I give, is my flesh," &c.
CRAN. Nay, but manna is treated of both before and after.
HARPS. I will apply another answer. This argument hath a kind of poison in it, which must be thus bitten away; that manna and this sacrament are not both one. Manna hath not its efficacy of itself, but of God.
CRAN. But they that did take manna worthily, had fruit thereby: and so by your assertion, he that doth eat of the flesh of Christ worthily, hath his fruit by that. Therefore the like doth follow of them both, and so there should be no difference between manna and this sacrament, by your reason.
HARPS. When it is said, that they which did eat manna are dead, it is to be understood, that they did want the virtue of manna.
CRAN. They then which do eat either of them worthily, do live.
HARPS. They do live which do eat manna worthily, not by manna, but by the power of God given by it. The other which do eat this sacrament, do live by the same.
CRAN. Christ did not treat of the cause, but the effect which followed: he doth not speak of the cause whereof the effect proceedeth.
HARPS. I do say, the effects are divers, life, and death, which do follow the worthy and unworthy eating thereof.
CRAN. Since you will needs have an addition to it, we must use both in manna and in the sacrament, indifferently, either worthily or unworthily. Christ spake absolutely of manna and of the supper; so that, after that absolute speaking of the supper, wicked men can in no wise eat the flesh of Christ, and drink his blood. FURTHER, Augustine upon John, Tract. xxvi. upon these words, "He that eateth," &c. saith, "There is no such virtue in common meats, as in the Lord's body. For whoso eateth other meats, hath still hunger, and needeth to be satisfied daily, but he that doth eat the flesh of Christ, and drinketh his blood, doth live forever." But you know, wicked men do not so. ERGO. Wicked men do not receive.
HARPS. St. Augustine meaneth. That he who eateth Christ's flesh, &c. after a certain manner, should live forever. Wicked men do eat, but not after that manner.
CRAN. Only they which participate Christ are of the mystical body. BUT evil men are not of the mystical body. ERGO, They do not participate Christ.
WEST. Your wonderful gentle behaviour and modesty, good Dr. Cranmer, is worthy much commendation: and that I may not deprive you of your right and just deserving, I give you most hearty thanks in my own name, and in the name of all my brethren, At which saying all the doctors gently put off their caps, Then Dr. Weston did oppose the respondent on this wise.
WEST. Tertullian doth call the sacrament the sign and figure of the Lord. ST. AUGUSTINE to Dardanus▪ saith, "The Lord did not stick to say, This is my body, when he gave a sign of his body." BESIDES this, he giveth rules how to understand the scriptures, saying. If the scriptures seem to command some heinous thing, then it is figurative, as by example. "To eat the flesh, and drink the blood, is a tropical speech."
HARPS. Tertullian did write in that place against Marcion an heretic, who denied Christ to have a true body, and said, he had only a fantastical body. He went about to show, that we had Christ both in heaven and on earth; and though we have the true body in the sacrament, yet he would not go about so to confound him, as to say, that Christ was truly in the sacrament: for that heretic would have thereat rather marvelled, than believed it. Therefore he showed him, that it was the figure of Christ: and a figure cannot be but of a thing that is, or hath been extant. TO the text of Augustine, the church hath never taught the contrary. There is an outward thing in the sacrament, which sometimes hath sundry names. For it may be called a figure in this declaration, That body which is in the sacrament, is a figure of Christ dwelling in heaven. TO the third, That which is wrought by Augustine, for example, about the understanding of the scriptures, is thus to be understood, as tending to a general manner of eating; so, To eat the flesh, and drink the blood, may be a figurative speech to exclude Anthropophagiam, that is, "The eating of man's flesh." The which is, when we eat man's flesh, cut in morsels, as we eat common meat; so as we neither have, nor eat Christ in the sacrament.
HARPS. Tertullian did write in that place against Marcion an heretic, who denied Christ to have a true body, and said, he had only a fantastical body. He went about to shew, that we had Christ both in heaven and on earth; and though we have the true body in the sacrament, yet he would not go about so to confound him, as to say, that Christ was truly in the sacrament: for that heretic would have thereat rather marvelled, than believed it. Therefore he shewed him, that it was the figure of Christ: and a figure cannot be but of a thing that is, or hath been extant. TO the text of Augustine, the church hath never taught the contrary. There is an outward thing in the sacrament, which sometimes hath sundry names. For it may be called a figure in this declaration, That body which is in the sacrament, is a figure of Christ dwelling in heaven. TO the third, That which is wrought by Augustine, for example, about the understanding of the scriptures, is thus to be understood, as tending to a general manner of eating; so, To eat the flesh, and drink the blood, may be a figurative speech to exclude Anthropophagiam, that is, "The eating of man's flesh." The which is, when we eat man's flesh, cut in morsels, as we eat common meat; so as we neither have, nor eat Christ in the sacrament.
WEST. I understand your short and learned answer, which doth sufficiently satisfy me. But now to the second question, which is of transubstantiation. THE scripture calleth it bread. ERGO, It is bread.
HARPS. In the name of bread all is signified which we do eat.
WEST. Theodoret, an ancient writer, in his first dialogue, says, "That Christ changed not the nature, but called it his body."