pp. 694–7851,484 passagespart 13 of 38
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Newman. Christ will not be in an unclean person that hath the devil.
Thornton. Why, will you not believe that Christ was in hell? and you will grant that the devil is there; and so might he be in Judas, if it pleased him.
Newman. Christ would not suffer Mary Magdalen to touch him, who sought him at his grave, and did love him entirely; much less will he suffer an ungodly man to receive him into his unclean body.
Newman. Christ would not suffer Mary Magdalen to touch him, who sought him at his grave, and did love him intirely; much less will he suffer an ungodly man to receive him into his unclean body.
Thorn. Yes, seeing God may do all things, he may do what he list, and still be where he […]. And doth not the Psalm say, He is in hell, and in all places? Why should we then doubt of his •• ing there?
Thorn. Yes, seeing God may do all things, he may do what he list, and still be where he 〈…〉. And doth not the Psalm say, He is in hell, and in all places? Why should we then doubt of his •• ing there?
New. Though his Godhead be in all place•, yet that is not sufficient to prove that his humanity is in all places.
Thorn. No, do you not believe that God is omnipotent, and may do all things?
New. I do believe that God is almighty, and may do all that he will do.
Thorn. Nay, but if he be omnipotent, he […] do all things, and there is nothing impossible for him to do.
Thorn. Nay, but if he be omnipotent, he 〈…〉 do all things, and there is nothing impossible for him to do.
New. I know God is almighty, and can do all that he will: but he cannot make his Son a […] ▪ he cannot deny himself, nor can he restore virginity once violated and defiled.
New. I know God is almighty, and can do all that he will: but he cannot make his Son a 〈…〉 ▪ he cannot deny himself, nor can he restore virginity once violated and defiled.
Thorn. What is that to your purpose? God doth not defile virginity; we speak but of things that God doth.
New. Why, will you have the humanity […] Christ in all places as the Deity is?
New. Why, will you have the humanity 〈…〉 Christ in all places as the Deity is?
Thorn. Yea, he is in all places as the Deity is, if it please him.
New I promise you that seemeth to me a very great heresy, for heaven and earth are not able to contain the divine power of God, for it is in all places, as here and in every place; and yet you say, that wheresoever the Deity is, there is also the ⟨p. 737⟩humanity; and so you will make him no body, but a fantastical body, and not a body indeed.
Thorn. Nay, we do not say he is in all places as the Deity is, but if it please him he may be in all places with the Deity.
New. I promise you, that seemeth to me as great an heresy as ever I heard in my life, and I dare not grant it, lest I should deny Christ to be a very man, and that were against all the scriptures.
Thorn. Tush, what shall we stand reasoning with him? I dare say he doth not believe that Christ came out of his mother, not opening the matrice. Do you believe that Christ rose from death, and came from death, and came through the stone?
New. I do believe that Christ rose from death; but I do not believe he came through the stone, neither doth the scripture so say.
Thorn. Lo, how say you? he doth no• believe that Christ came through the stone; and if he doth not believe this, how shall he believe the other? If he could believe this, it were easy for him to believe the other.
New. The scripture doth not say he went through the stone, but it saith, the angel of God came down, and rolled away the stone, and for fear of him the keepers became even as dead men.
Thorn. Ah fool, fool, that was because the woman should not see that he was risen again from death.
New. Well, the scripture maketh as much for me, as it doth for you, and more too.
Thorn. Well, let us stand not any longer about this. Back again to the real presence. How say you, is the body of Christ really in the sacrament, or no?
New. I have answered you already.
Thorn. Well, do you not believe that it is there really?
New. No, I believe it not.
Thorn. Well, will you stand to it?
New. I must needs stand to it, till I be persuaded by a further truth.
Thorn. Nay, you will not be persuaded, but stand to your own opinion.
New. Nay, I stand not to mine own opinion, God I take to witness, but only to the scriptures of God, and that can all those that stand here witness with me, and nothing but the scriptures: and I take God to witness that I do nothing of presumption, but that that I do is only my conscience; and if there be a further truth than I see▪ except it appear a truth to me, I cannot receive it as a truth. And seeing faith is the gift of God, and cometh not of man; for it is not you that can give me faith, nor any man else: therefore I hope you will bear the more with me, seeing it must be wrought by God, and when it shall please him to open a further truth to me, I shall receive it with all my heart, and embrace it.
THORNTON had many other questions which I did not bear away; but as I do understand, these are the chief: as for taunts, foolish and unlearned, he lacked none. Praise God for his gifts, and God increase in us strength.
IF the body of Christ were really and bodily in the sacrament, then whosoever received the sacrament, received also the body.
THE wicked receiving the sacrament, receive not the body of Christ.
ERGO, The body of Christ is not really in the sacrament.
THEY which eat the flesh, and drink the blood of Christ, dwell in him, and he in them.
The wicked dwell not in Christ, nor he in them.
ERGO, The wicked eat not the flesh, nor drink the blood of Christ.
THEY that have Christ dwelling in them, bring forth much fruit, John xv. "He that dwelleth in me, and I in him, bringeth forth much fruit."