pp. 694–7851,484 passagespart 16 of 38
Modern spelling is a reading aid: the words are the author’s, only the spelling is modernized. Original shows the page as printed, with the transcription marks.
Smith. Then could you not persecute it as you do: but as you say the church of God at Corinth was manifest both to God and St. Paul; even so is this church of God in England, which you persecute, both known to God, and also even to the very wicked, although they know not, nor will know their truth nor conversation; yea, and your sinful number have professed their verity, and maintained the same a long season.
Bonner. Well, thou sayest that the church of God was only at Corinth, when St. Paul writ unto them, and so will I put in writing, shall I?
Smith. I do greatly marvel, my lord, that you are not ashamed to lay snares for your brethren on this manner. This is now the third snare you have laid for me. First, to make me confess that the church of England is not the church of Christ. Secondly, to say it is not known. Thirdly, to say the church of God is not universal, but particular. And this is not the office of a bishop. For if an innocent had come in your way, you would have done your best, I see to entangle him. WELL, friend, said Dr. Harpsfield, you are no innocent, as it appeareth.
Smith. By the grace of God I am that I am; and this grace in me, I hope is not in vain. WELL, said Bonner, laughing, tell me, how sayest thou of the church?
Smith. I told you whereon the true church is built, and I affirm in England to be the true congregation of God, and also in omne•• terra•, "Their sound is gone forth into all lands," and this is the afflicted and persecuted church, which ye cease not to imprison, slay, and kill. And in Corinth was not all the congregation of God, but a number of those holy and elect people of God. For neither Paul nor Peter were present at Corinth when they wrote, and yet were they of the church of God, as many thousands more which also communicate in that Holy Spirit.
Bonner. What call you catholic, and what call you church?
Sm•th. Catholic is universal, and church •s a congregation knit together in unity. THEN after much like talk, it was laid to my charge, that my fellow and I spake one thing. For which I praised God, and was sent again to the garden. Where, after a while, as I and brother Harwood had been together, came one of my lord's chaplains, that much desired to commune with […] demanding first if I were a prisoner.
Sm•th. Catholic is uni•ersal, and church •s a congregation knit together in unity. THEN after much like talk, it was laid to my charge, that my fellow and I spake one thing. For which I praised God, and was sent again to the garden. Where, after a while, as I and brother Harwood had been together, came one of my lord's chaplains, that much desired to commune with 〈…〉 demanding first if I were a prisoner.
Smith. I am in this flesh a prisoner, and subject to my master and your's▪ but I hope yet the Lord's free man through Christ Jesus.
Doctor. I do much desire to talk to you lovingly, because you are a man that I much lament, with many other sweet words. To which I answered, Sub melle latet venenum. And after much ado about his god, I compelled him to say, that it must needs enter into the belly, and so fall into the draught.
Doctor. What derogation was it to Christ, when the Jews spit in his face?
Smith. If the Jews, being his enemies, did spit in his face, and we being his friends throw him into the draught, which of us have deserved the greatest damnation? Then by your argument, he that doth injury to Christ, shall have a most plenteous salvation. THEN the doctor started away, and would have his humanity incomprehensible, making a comparison between the soul of man and the body of Christ, bringing in to serve his turn, which way Christ came in among his disciples, the doors being shut?
Smith. Although it be said, that when he came the doors were shut, yet have I as much to prove, that the doors opened at his coming, as you have to prove he came through the door. For that Almighty God who brought the disciples out of prison, which yet when search was made was found shut, was able to •et Christ •n at the door, although it were shut: and yet it maketh not for your purpose; for they saw him, […] him, and felt him, and that you cannot say you do, neither is he in more places than one at the same time.
Smith. Although it be said, that when he came the doors were shut, yet have I as much to prove, that the doors opened at his coming, as you have to prove he came through the door. For that Almighty God who brought the disciples out of prison, which yet when search was made was found shut, was able to •et Christ •n at the door, although it were shut: and yet it maketh not for your purpose; for they saw him, 〈…〉 him, and felt him, and that you cannot say you do, neither is he in more places than one at the same time.
AT which answer when he had made many scoffings, he went from me, and we were carried into my lord's hall, where we were baited by my lord's ba•d of servants almost all the day, until our keepe• seeing their rudeness, shut us all up in a handsome chamber, while my lord wen• into his synagogue to condemn Mr. D•nley and John Newman.
AT which answer when he had made many scoffings, he went from me, and we were carried into my lord's hall, where we were b•ited by my lord's ba•d of servants almost all the day, until our keepe• seeing their rudeness, shut us all up in a handsome chamber, while my lord wen• into his synagogue to condemn Mr. D•nley and John Newman.
THEN they brought my lord mayor up into the chamber […] my […] intended to sup• to hear the matter, and I was the first that was ca••ed, where my lord mayor being set with the bishop and one of the sheriffs, wine was flowing on every side, whilst I stood before them like a mute; which made me remember how Pilate and Herod were made friends, but no man was sorry for Joseph's hurt. But after my lord had well drank, my articles were sent for and read, and he demanded whether I did say as was written?
THEN they brought my lord mayor up into the chamber 〈…〉 my 〈…〉 intended to sup• to hear the matter, and I was the first that was ca••ed, where my lord mayor being set with the bishop and one of the sheriffs, wine was flowing on every side, whilst I stood before them like a mute; which made me remember how Pilate and Herod were made friends, but no man was sorry for Joseph's hurt. But after my lord had well drank, my articles were sent for and read, and he demanded whether I did say as was written?
Smith. That I have said, I have said, and what I have said I do mean.
Bonner. Well, my lord mayor, your lordship hath heard in some measure, what a stout heretic this is, and nevertheless forasmuch as they report me to seek blood, and call me bloody Bonner, whereas, God knoweth, I never sought any man's blood in all my life, I have kept him from the consistory this day, whither I could have brought him justly; I desire him to turn, and I will with all speed dispatch him out of his trouble; and this I profess before your lordship and all this audience.
Smith. Why, my lord, do you put on this fair visor before my lord mayor, to make him believe that you seek not my blood, to cloak your murders, through my stoutness, as you call it? Have you not had my brother Tomkins before you, whose hand when you burned most cruelly, you burned also his body, and not only him, but a great many of the members of Christ, men that feared God, and lived virtuously, and also the queen's majesty's most true subjects, as their goods and bodies have made manifest? And seeing in these saints you have showed so little mercy, shall it seem to my lord and •his audience that you show me more favour? No, no, my lord. But if you mean as you say, why then do you examine me of what I am not bound to answer you?
Smith. Why, my lord, do you put on this fair vizor before my lord mayor, to make him believe that you seek not my blood, to cloak your murders, through my stoutness, as you call it? Have you not had my brother Tomkins before you, whose hand when you burned most cruelly, you burned also his body, and not only him, but a great many of the members of Christ, men that feared God, and lived virtuously, and also the queen's majesty's most true subjects, as their goods and bodies have made manifest? And seeing in these saints you have shewed so little mercy, shall it seem to my lord and •his audience that you shew me more favour? No, no, my lord. But if you mean as you say, why then do you examine me of what I am not bound to answer you?
Bonner. Well, what sayest thou by the sacrament of the altar? Is it not the very body of Christ, flesh, blood, and bone, as it was born of the virgin?
Smith. I have answered that it is none of God's order nor a sacrament, but of man's own vain invention, and showed him the Lord's institution. ⟨p. 748⟩But when he was so earnest before the audience, declaring that we knew nothing, bringing out his Hoc est corpus meum to lay in my dish; I proved before the audience that it was a dead god, declaring the distinction appointed between two creatures of bread and wine, and that a body without blood hath no life. At which Harpsfield found himself much offended, and took the tale out of my lord's mouth, saying,
Smith. I have answered that it is none of God's order nor a sacrament, but of man's own vain invention, and shewed him the Lord's institution. ⟨p. 748⟩But when he was so earnest before the audience, declaring that we knew nothing, bringing out his Hoc est corpus meum to lay in my dish; I proved before the audience that it was a dead god, declaring the distinction appointed between two creatures of bread and wine, and that a body without blood hath no life. At which Harpsfield found himself much offended, and took the tale out of my lord's mouth, saying,
Harps. I will prove by the scriptures, that you blaspheme God in so saying: for it is given in two parts, because there are two things showed. •hat is to say, his body and his passion, as saith St. Paul: and therefore the bread is his body, and the wine the representation of his death and blood-shedding.
Harps. I will prove by the s•riptures, that you blaspheme God in so saying: for it is given in two parts, because there are two things shewed. •hat is to say, his body and his passion, as saith St. Paul: and therefore the bread is his body, and the wine the representation of his death and blood-shedding.
Smith. You falsify the word, and rack it to serve your purpose. For the wine was not only the showing his passion, but the bread also. For our Saviour saith, "So often as ye do th•s, do it in remembrance of me." And St. Paul saith, "So oft as you eat of this bread, and drink of this cup, you shall show forth the Lord's death till he come." And her• is as much reverence given to the one as to the other. Wherefore if the bread be his body, the cup must be his blood, and as well you make his body in the cup, as his blood in the bread.
Smith. You falsify the word, and rack it to serve your purpose. For the wine was not only the shewing his passion, but the bread also. For our Saviour saith, "So often as ye do th•s, do it in remembrance of me." And St. Paul saith, "So oft as you eat of this bread, and drink of this cup, you shall sh•w forth the Lord's death till he come." And her• is as much reverence given to the one as to the other. Wherefore if the bread be his body, the cup must be his blood, and as well you make his body in the cup, as his blood in the bread.
THEN my lord rose up, and went to the table, where the lord mayor desired me to save my soul. To whom I answered, I hoped it was saved through Christ Jesus; desiring him to have pity on his own soul, and remember whose sword he carried.
ON which I was carried into the garden, and there abode till the rest of my friends were examined, and then were we sent away to Newgate with many foul farewells, my lord bishop giving the keeper charge to lay me in limbo.
ON which I was carried into the garden, and there abode till the rest of my friends were examined, and then were we sent away to Newgate with many foul farewels, my lord bishop giving the keeper charge to lay me in limbo.
UPON Saturday, at eight o'clock, I was brought to his chamber again, and there examined by him as followeth.
Bonner. Thou Robert Smith, &c. sayest that there is no catholic church here on earth.
Smith. You have heard me both speak the contrary, and you have writing as a witness of the same.
Bonner. Yes, but I must ask this question: how sayest thou?
Smith. Must you of necessity begin with a lie? It maketh manifest that you determine to the end with the same. But there shall no liars enter […] the kingdom of God. Nevertheless, if you will […] answered, ask mine articles that were written yesterday, and they shall tell you that I have confessed a church of God, as well in earth as in heaven, and yet all one church, and one man's members, eve• Christ Jesus.
Smith. Must you of necessity begin with a lie? It maketh manifest that you determine to the end with the same. But there shall no liars enter 〈…〉 the kingdom of God. Nevertheless, if you will 〈…〉 answered, ask mine articles that were written yesterday, and they shall tell you that I have confessed a church of God, as well in earth as in heaven, and yet all one church, and one man's members, eve• Christ Jesus.
Bonner. Well, what savest thou to auricular confession? Is it not necessary to be used in Christ's church? and wilt thou not be confessed by the priest?
Smith. It is not needful to be used in Christ's church, as I answered yesterday. But if it be needful for your church, it is to pick men's pockets; and such pick pocket matters is all the whole rabble of your ceremonies: for all that you maintain is […] money-••tters.
Smith. It is not needful to be used in Christ's church, as I answered yesterday. But if it be needful for your church, it is to pick men's pockets; and such pick pocket matters is all the whole rabble of your ceremonies: for all that you maintain is 〈…〉 money-••tters.
Bonner. Why, how art thou able to prove th•• confession is a pick pocket matter? Art thou […] ashamed to say so?
Bonner. Why, how art thou able to prove th•• confession is a pick pocket matter? Art thou 〈…〉 ashamed to say so?
Smith. I speak by experience: for I have bo•• heard and seen the fruits of the same. For first […] hath been, we see, a betrayer of king's secrets, and the secrets of other men's consciences; who being delivered, and glad to be discharged from their sins▪ have given great sums of money to priests to absolve them, and sing masses for their soul's health.
Smith. I speak by experience: for I have bo•• heard and seen the fruits of the same. For first 〈…〉 hath been, we see, a betrayer of king's secrets, and the secrets of other men's consciences; who bein• delivered, and glad to be discharged from their sins▪ have given great sums of money to priests to absolve them, and sing masses for their soul's health.
AND for example, I began to bring in a pageant▪ that by report was played at St. Thomas of Acres▪ and where I was when a child, waiting […] a gentleman of Norfolk, which being bound in conscience▪ through the persuasion of the priest, gave away a great quantity of his goods, and forgave unto one Mr. Gresham a large sum of money, and to another as much. The priest for his part had a good share and the house had an annuity to keep him: which ⟨p. 749⟩thing when his brother heard, he came to London, and after a declaration made to the council, how by the subtlety of the priest he had robbed his wife and children, recovered a great part again, to the value of two or three hundred pounds of Mr. Gresham and his other friend; but what he gave to the house could not be recovered. This story I began to tell; but when my lord saw it favoured not to his purpose, he began to revile me, and said, By the mass, if the queen's majesty were of my mind, thou shouldst not come to talk before any man, but shouldst be put in a sack, with a dog in the same, and be thrown into a river.
AND for example, I began to bring in a pageant▪ that by report was played at St. Thomas of Acres▪ and where I was when a child, waiting 〈…〉 a gentleman of Norfolk, which being bound in ••nscience▪ through the persuasion of the priest, gave away a great quantity of his goods, and forgave unto one Mr. Gresham a large sum of money, and to another as much. The priest for his part had a good share and the house had an annuity to keep him: which ⟨p. 749⟩thing when his brother heard, he came to London, and after a declaration made to the council, how by the subtilty of the priest he had robbed his wife and children, recovered a great part again, to the value of two or three hundred pounds of Mr. Gresham and his other friend; but what he gave to the house could not be recovered. This story I began to tell; but when my lord saw it favoured not to his purpose, he began to revile me, and said, By the mass, if the queen's majesty were of my mind, thou shouldst not come to talk before any man, but shouldst be put in a sack, with a dog in the same, and be thrown into a river.
Smith. I know you speak by practice, as much as by speculation, for both you and your predecessors have sought all possible means to kill Christ secretly; witness Mr. Hun, whom your predecessor caused to be thrust in at the nose with hot burning needles, and then to be hanged, and gave it out that the said Hun hanged himself: and also a good brother of your's, a bishop of your profession, having in his prison an innocent man, whom, because he could not overcome by scripture, he caused to be privately strangled, and his flesh to be ••rn and plucked away with a pair of pincers; and bringing him before the people, said, the rats had eaten him. Thus according to your oath is all your dealing, and hath been: and as you, taking upon you the office, do not without oaths open your mouth▪ no more do you without murder maintain your traditions.
Smith. I know you speak by practice, as much as by speculation, for both you and your predecessors have sought all possible means to kill Christ secretly; witness Mr. Hunne, whom your predecessor caused to be thrust in at the nose with hot burning needles, and then to be hanged, and gave it out that the said Hunne hanged himself: and also a good brother of your's, a bishop of your profession, having in his prison an innocent man, whom, because he could not overcome by scripture, he caused to be privately strangled, and his flesh to be ••rn and plucked away with a pair of pincers; and bringing him before the people, said, the rats had eaten him. Thus according to your oath is all your dealing, and hath been: and as you, taking upon you the office, do not without oaths open your mouth▪ no more do you without murder maintain your traditions.
Bonner. Ah, you are a generation of liars; there is not one true word that cometh out of your mouths.
Smith. Yes, my lord, I have said that Jesus Christ is dead for my sins, and risen for my justification, and this is no lie.
THEN Bonner made his man to put in my tale of the gentleman in Norfolk, and would have m• recite it again: which when I would not do, he made his man put in such sums as he […]. At the end of this sir John Mordant came in, and sat down to hear my examination. Then said my lord, How sayest thou, Smith, to the seven sacraments▪ Believest thou not that they be of God's order, that is to say, the sacrament of, &c.
THEN Bonner made his man to put in my tale of the gentleman in Norfolk, and would have m• recite it again: which when I would not do, he made his man put in such sums as he 〈…〉. At the end of this sir John Mordaunt came in, and sat down to hear my examination. Then said my lord, How sayest thou, Smith, to the seven sacraments▪ Believest thou not that they be of God's order, that is to say, the sacrament of, &c.
Smith. I believe that in God's church are but two sacraments, that is to say, the sacrament of regeneration, and the sacrament of the Lord's supper: and as for the sacrament of the altar, and all your sacraments, they may well serve your church, but God's church hath nothing to do with them, neither have I any thing to do to answer them, nor you to examine me of them.
Bonner. Why, is God's order changed in baptism? In what point do we dissent from the word of God?